Document bBjENdovKE788LDevEYOEaY03
27
PCDDs are in progress. The carcinogenic potentials of PCDFs have not beenstudied.
2,3,7,8-TCDD is teratogenic in mice and hamsters. The threshold teratogenic dose in mice was estimated to be 0.1 meg per day (Smith et al, 1976). 2,3,7,8-TCDD has been shown to be fetotoxic in a wide variety of species, including primates. HCDD was teratogenic in rats at a dose of
I
100 meg'/kg per day (IARC 1977) There is as yet no data on the fetotoxic potentials of PCDFs in animals.
The toxic effects of 2,3,7,8-TCDD in man are summarized in Table 7. The toxic effects most consistently observed in occupational studies are chloracne, liver dysfunction, neuropsychiatric disturbances, and abnormalities in porphyrin metabolism. Table 8 summarizes the findings of the morbidity studies of workers exposed to 2,3,7,8-TCDD to date. The few follow-up studies which have been done show resolution of gross liver dysfunction and porphyrin abnormalities following removal from exposure. (Pazderova-Vijlupkova et al, 1981; Suskind, 1984).
Several of the occupational exposures occurred as the result of uncontrolled exothermic reactions during the production of trichlorophenol. A similar process accident at Seveso, Italy in 1976 resulted in widespread community exposure to 2,3,7,8-TCDD. Health effects included chloracne, primarily in children, and peripheral neuropathy in a small percent of those exposed (Pocchiari et al, 1979).
The epidemiologic studies on the carcinogenecity of TCDD are summarized in Table 9- While individual occupational mortality studies reveal no excess of cancer, the pooled data suggest an excess of soft tissue sarcoma (Honchar and Halperin, 1981).
28
Table 7. Toxic Effects of 2,3,7,8-Tetrachlorodlbanzo-p-dioxin in Man.a
E f f e c t s ____ _______ _______________________________ _________ _ ________ DERMATOLOGICAL
Chloracne Porphyria cutanea tarda Hyperpigmentation and
hirsutism
INTERNAL Liver damage^ Elevated serum hepatic enzyme levels Disorders of fat metabolism Disorders of carbohydrate metabolism
I
Cardiovascular disorders Urinary tract disorders Respiratory disorders Pancreatic disorders
NEUROLOGICAL Polyneuropathies (perpheral neuritis) Lower extremity weakness Sensory impairments (sight, hearing, smell, taste)
PSYCHIATRIC Neurasthenic or depressive syndromes____ ____ ______
^Source: Huff, Moore, Saracci, and Tomatis, 1980 ^Mild fibrosis, fatty changes, hemofuscin deposition and parenchymal-cell
degeneration were observed in a few cases.
TABLE 8. REPORTED OCCU?ATIONAL EXPOSURES IN CHLORINATED PHENOLS RESULTING IN HUMAN ILLNESSa
Type of
Year,Place,and
exposure and
chemical(s)_______ no. of cases
Effects on the
Effects on
Neurological
liver and
the skin__________effects__________ serum lipids_______Other effects________ References
1936 Michigan
Production
Tetrachlorophenol
21
2- (2-chlorophenyl)
phenol
Chloracne, hyperkeratosis
Fatigue, weight loss
Butler, 193
1936 Mississippi Wood treat Tetrachlorophenol ment
300-600
Chloracne,facial erythema, vsicula tion, ulceration, hyperkeratosis, hyperpigmentation
Fatigue, colored urine, urinary problems, venous thrombosis
Anonymous, 1936: Sting I960
1969 West Virginia Trichlorophenol 2,4,5-T
Explosion 117
Production 111
Cvl
1969 Germany Trichlorophenol Tetrachlorophenol Pentachlorophenol
Production, Industrial Laboratory
17
Chloracne, facial erythema, hyper pigmentation, melanosis
Nervousness, Hepatomegaly, ab- Fatigue, weight >
irritability, normal liver
loss, weakness,
insomnia,
function, toxic decreased libido,
personality
hepatitis, elevat- impotence, intol
change,de-*-
ed triglycerides erance to cold,
pression,
and cholesterol increased sus
headache,
ceptibility to
vertigo, pain
infection (es
and weakness
pecially respir
lower extrem-
atory)
eties, paresis,
peripheral neuro
pathy, abnormal
nerve biopsy
(loss of myelin)
Chloracne, hyperpigment ation, scarring
Lower extremity Abnormal liver pain and weak- function, ness, paresis cirrhosis without atrophy, paresthesia, polyneuritiB
Fatigue, severe bronchitis, de creased libido, impotence, bursi tis, myocardial damage
Ashe and Suskind, 19 1950; Suski 1953; Suski 1977
Baader and Bauer, 195!
1952 Germany Trichlorophenol
Production 31
Chloracne, hyperpigmen tation
1953 Germany Trichlorophenol
Explosion 55
Chloracne
1956 France Trichlorophenol 1966 France Trichlorophenol
1956 New Jersey Trichlorophenol
Product ion 17
Explosion 21
Production 29
1963 Holland Trichlorophenol 2,4,5-T
Explosion 106
Chloracne
Chloracne, hyperpigmentation, hy pertrichosis, acquired porphy ria cutanea tarda Chloracne, facial erythema
Lower extremity Toxic hepatitis, pain and weak- abnormal liver ness,paresthesia, biopsy memory and con centration defi cits, sleep disturbances,' hy persomnolence, abnormal psycho logical tests (apathy, dulled emotional response)
Fatigue, chronic bronchitis, per sistent blepharoconjunctivitis, myocardial dam age, intolerance to alcohol
Suskind, 19
Sensory impair- Toxic hepatitis ment of smell,taste, hearing; tendency to orthostatic collapse, limited paresis, peripheral neuropathy, reading difficulties
Fatigue, drowsiness, bronchit is, laryn gitis, blepharoconj unctivitis, hemorrhagic pleu ritis, myocardial damage, Increased susceptibility to infection
Coldman, ]
Peripheral neuropathy
Toxic hepatitis, elevated tryglycerides and choles terol
Dugois et 1956; Dugo et al, 196
Clinical exam ination normal
No information
Abnormal liver
Right upper
function, abnor quadrant pain
mal liver biopsies
(parenchymal cell
degeneration,
fluorescence)
Liver function normal
Fatigue
Bleiberg e 1966
Vos et al,
1964 USSR Trichlorophenol 2,4,5-T
Production 128
Chloracne
1968 England Trichlorophenol
Explosion 79
Cloracne, facial erythema
1965-1968 Czechoslovakia Trichlorophenol Pentachlorophenol 2,4,5,-T
Production 80
Chloracne, hyperpigmenta- v tion, hyper trichosis , scarring, ac quired porphyria cutanea tarda
1969 New Jersey Trichlorophenol 2,4,5-T 2,4-D
1978 England Trichlorophenol no longer in production
Production 73
Followup of plant studied by Bleiberg (above)
Followup of 41 workers in 1968 explosion (above) 41
Chloracne in 48, hypertrichosis in 16, hyperpig mentation in 30, no overt por phyria cutanea tarda
Chloracne
Headache, loss of memory, somnolence, sleeplessness, Increased sweating
Fatigue, joint pain, stomach pain
Telegina and Bikbulatova,
1970
Abnormal liver function
Transient glyco suria, mild con junctivitis
May, 1973; Jensen and Walker, 196' Jensen et al 1972
Lower extremity Hepatomegaly, ab
weakness and
normal liver func
pnin,somnolence, tion, abnormal
headache, insom liver biopsies
nia, emotional (mild steatosis,
and psychiatric periportal fibro
disorders, peri sis, fluorescence)
pheral neuro Elevated triglyc
pathy (confirmed erides, phospho
by abnormal EMC) lipids, and
cholesterol
Fatigue, weight loss, abnormal blucose tolerance, no evidence of myocardial or renal damage or of increased eye inflammation or respiratory in fection
Jiraskek et 1964 ; Pazdei Vejlupkova t al, 1980; PazderovaVejlupkova e 1981
Lower extremity No significant weakness, corre abnormalities lation between chloracne and hypomania scale on MMPI
Eye irritation, mild uroporphyrinuria in one worker
Poland et a 1971 (see Bleiberg et 1964)
Elevated CGT, elevated tri glycerides , elevated urinary D-glucaric
acid
May, 1982
1949 West Virginia Trichlorophenol 2,3,5-T .
1949 West Virginia Trichlorophenol 2,4,5-T
226 Followup of plant studied by Ashe and Suskind (above)
204 Followup of plant studied by Ashe and Suskind and Moses et al (above)
Chloracne 70-residual 47-by his tory
Abnormal sensory findings in those with chloracne
Chloracne in 107 Actinic Elastosis
^ 1976 Seveso Trichlorophenol
No. not given ICMESA workers follow-up five years after explosion
a Source: Moses et al, 1984
Elevated GGT In those with chloracne
Decreased libido, Moses et al sexual dysfunction 1984
History of GI ulcer Lower pulmonary function in exposed smokers
Suskind and Hertzberg, 1984
Elevated Aik. Phos.
Elevated urinary porphyrins
Ghezzi et al, 1984