Document aZozBnmzv3By9mMrjyJQL85y
October JO, 1956
Dr# K. B* Sayers Office of industrial Hygiene and Sanitation U S* Public Health Service Washington, D* C*
Dear Dr, Sayers1
From time to time I have reported to you caaes of complaints or of alleged injuries from tiie handling and us of leaded gasoil ns* The pitrno3 of this letter is to mate a report on a series of caaes of poisoning which occurred In connection with the cleaning of a blending tank at the Savannah refinery of the Standard Oil Company of Kentucky* Wo have made a rather detailed study of this situation, and 1 ill pro* vide you a 1th the details of our study when all of the work lias been completed* For your present information, however, it seoras desirable to acquaint you with the circuias tancos
On August 18th, seven men were sent in to clean a tank which had been used for loaded gasoline and in which leaded gasoline had been blended* The tank had been 3 tea mod for ninoty-six hours, cooled for forty-eight hours and then aired out by forced circulation of air for thirty-sis: hours in addition* The regulations which we have issued wore not followed in carrying out the cleaning activities* These activities required four to sis hours during which time the men made no complaints of subjective symptoms# One man showed evidences of illness after twenty-four hours and the others became ill in from forty-eight to slxty-two hours* The symptoms developed slowly, reaching their peak eight to ten days;later, at which time three of the raen succumbed to an acute central nervous system Intoxication, the other four slowly recovering until they are non apparently entirely well
Because of the peculiarity of the initial symptoms, these cases were not reported to us for 3one days, but ay associate,Dr* Eitsmillor, arrived on the scene at the height of the acute illness and shortly before the death of one of the men* Necropsies were performed on the three fatal cases and excretory studies were mode on all of the men* The materials from the tank were obtained for analysis in order to determine,
Dr* Sayers (eonfc)
-2-
If possible, the precis cau3 of the acuteness of the Intoxication* It is apparent from the Incomplete analyses that these men were heavily exposed to lead compounds of an organic type, while the clinical course of their illness was such as definitely to justify that diagnosis.
Cases of this type have been reported
to you before by U3 and we have been aware for som*e time
of the hazards associated with the cleaning of these
tanks. However these are the first fatal cases although
not the first severe ones which r;e have 3eon. Without
going Into details as to the background of this last
occurrence, v;e have come to the conclusion that the
handling of this hazard is not adequate in the hands
of the distributing companies, and that we ourselves
will have to take a hand In the supervision of this
operation. Accordingly, with the assistance of technical
representatives of the Ethyl Gasoline Corporation, we
have undertaken to make a thorough investigation of the
entire problem. We are making a complete survey of
conditions In the field with reference to the number of
tank3 involved, their location, their previous use and
their entire history. We expect to obtain representative
samples of material from the sides of the tanks and from
the sludge at the bottom In order to assure ourselves
in relation to the histories of use of these tanks an to
what are the factors which give rise to decomposition of
tetraethyl lead in the gasoline, and what quantities of
lead are involved. We are not certain that the hazard
is of any moment in connection with tanks which have been
used for storage alone. However
are making no assumpfcoms
and we expect to spend the next several months in determining
the facts. On the "basis of such facts we will be In position
to make recommendations as to what should bo done throughout
the field in caring for this problem. I nay say at this
point that if general refinery regulations are enforced
and If the regulations which we have made with reference
to loaded gasoline storage tanks are followed, there should
be no cases of poisoning. However, we do not feel at present
that we can count on the application of regulations now in
existence, and we shall attempt to set up a mechanism which
will bring thi3 about. Incidentally we are beginning the
latter process by putting a metal warning sign on all tanks
which have been used for blending gasoline containing lead.
Y/e expect to study all tanks which are cleaned for some time
to come not only through the analysis of materials from the
tanks, but also by the determination of the dust concentra
tions which occur in the atmosphere in such tanks at the
time of cleaning.
If you have any suggestions to offer or If you wish any further Information at this time, do
K 0009217
'Dr. Sayers
3
not hesitate to write to no. For my part 1 shall keep you in touch tilth the information which develops out of oar 3tudy, and I shall confer with you on the methods which we will ultimately employ in the solution of this disturbing problem. The worst difficulty, of course. Is associated with the Infrequency and irregularity of the cleaning operations* There is also the problem, of which you are well aware, of the wide variation in safety methods in the refineries. Some of them operate on very rigid rules, while many of them have very little in the nay of safety organizations and practices*
Vi!thin a few days X shall bo sending you some further information cm cases of complaint, and particularly on a case which recently came to a hearing in the Federal Court in Wilson, IJorth Carolina.
Kith kindest personal regards.
Cordially yours.
PJuCsla cc Dr. Edgar
Hobrt1,rriW' 'Ko Ko o V M.D.
HZ 0003218