Document a1M5njJnyNRXwaXQqoNRpaYoa
rkg'lVEW YORK TIMES, SATU1
FEBRUARY 21, 1981
By PAUL L. MONTGOMERY
,
SpecUl to The New York Time*
,
BINGHAMTON, N.Y., Feb. 19 --
Every morning for the last two weeks,
squads of workers equipped with goggles
. and respirators, and wearing disposable
: vinyl gloves and white coveralls, have ' been passed through the police barri-
. cades at the State Office Building here to
; attack the poisonous soot that has infilV trated each floor of the iS-story building.
The contamination by soot laden with
'V polychlorinated biphenyls -- PCB's -- ' .. was the result of a fire in a basement
.
transformer before dawn on Feb. 5.
Every item in the. building, from lottery
tickets on sale in the lobby to the law
books in the Court of Claims, received a
dusting of the chemical, identified as a
' cause of cancer.
.
The building, the tallest in downtown
. Binghamton, was not occupied at the
David Seiffert, coordinator of the cleanup
for the state's Office of General Services.
"As best we can tell, no one has managed
to contaminate an office building be
fore." " . . '
l1-- v
Use of PCB's in new equipment was
banned by Congress in 1976, but thou
sands of transformers that were built be
fore that date and that used the chemical
as a coolant are still in use.
PCB's are stable compounds -- also
used in waxes and inks -- that only can be
broken down to their benign components
by incineration for two seconds at 2,000
degrees Fahrenheit. This chemical
stability explains the remarkable persist
ence of PCB's, which find their way into
ground water and eventually the food
chain. In humans, the chemical accumu
lates in fatty tissue and is neither elimi
nated nor broken down.
...
Fire Vaporized Coolant
seal on the Pyranol chamber and vapor ized the liquid. The vapor became at tached to soot particles, which was spread throughout building through the air-conditioning ducts. He estimated that 100 gallons of Pyranol was lost that way; the remaining 80 gallons spilled and were cleaned up in the basement after the fire.
After the Federal ban on PCB's, manu facturers argued that it would be imprac tical to replace the proscribed coolant in older transformers with less pernicious substances. Mr. Seiffert said that, in' light of the'accident? here, that view might Change, particularly for equipment that is near air-circulating devices:
Round-the-CIock Effort
Mr. Seiffert said tests on the air in the building after the fire showed it to be "quite clean," with two or three micro grams of PCB's per cubic meter. He said
time of the fire and has been closed since, In transformers, the relatively non that Federal law allowed as much as 500
its bustling departments and 750 employ flammable oil is circulated in sealed micrograms per cubic meter, but that a
ees scattered in temporary offices chambers to cool the copper parts. The substitute standard proposed by the Na throughout the city, which is in the cen transformer in the modern State Office tional Institute for Occupational Safety
tral portion of the state.
Building, completed in 1972, contained and Health was 1, microgram per cubic
The cleanup is expected to take at least 180 gallons of the liquid under General meter. '
.
-
several months, and cost at least $500,000. Electric's trade name, Pyranol; the liq "The real problem is that no one knows
Officials confronted with the hare acci uid is 65 percent PCB's.
what the standard should be," the engi
dent are still feeling their way.
According to Mr. Seiffert, an engineer, neer said. "The State Department of
"It's an experimental situation," said the. fire apparently burst the pressure Health is testing air in other office build-
PCB-ARCH-EXT0375966
I ." .
4A_____Thurs., Fe
',1981
ST. LOUIS POST-DlSPATCL
gfti
.; J;.?i ;/::
**f?
,, ' ' '*
PLtrm S88888 88888888
838888888 88 8 88 38833888888.8,8:1
mtWWV 83 9 3 888 8 88 88 8 8
8 8 SSB888888888 ' !
3 a as a a 33 a as 8 as ( '
, in'.n?S1 8888889*888*8* : ;:
>.'
M8888B888***** *>
r .; "*
*'
^rFjRW gggs8B8SSS88!f* *4
88888888*88888
Waaif 8.*8t8:f 388
-1-!
Mj3 S8889S88*S88#;|g^^^
a s s a ai ***
%s
SSSS,*8!!",`'"!P^sl5
^P*^inf?Pi?:fl
f f*?g| ;..****
{J
ill; life
* |>.- " ':V--;. ..!8
:.. ^ W -
^ i' ;,I I i ^
.......
i, s"'f"FiT51
.TbeNewYortTtoes/BUlMUler i
Squad of workmen in goggles and respirators cleaning up poisonous soot in the 18-story State Office Building, above, in Binghamton, N.Y. The cleanup is expected to take several months.
ings in Binghamton to see what an aver cleanup will proceed with regard for their
age acceptable level would be. Then we'll safety.
:
' ' "
have to clean the building until we meet the standard."
Workers Are Assured '
The main task in the cleanup is re State: workers have also been told that
moval of the layer of soot and dust, which the building .will not be .reopened until
is about 10 percent PCB's. Thirty-two minimum PCB standards: axe met, even
workers from the New England Pollution if it means cleaning the building several
Control Company of East Norwalk, times. The state offers a free blood test to
Conn., which is under contract to the anyone who suspects they might have
state, are working in 12-hour shifts, seven been exposed, and cleanup workers re
days a week vacuuming and scrubbing. ceive periodic examinations. .
So far, they have completed the first Nevertheless, there is nervousness:.
cleaning of the 17th, 16th and 15th floor "My friends half-joke with' me that I
and started on the 14th today.
should be decontaminated," said a secre
Much material -- drapes, carpets, tary who worked in the State Transporta
upholstery, blank forms, desk calendars tion Department.
.
-- has been discarded because it would The suspicion extends to the workers:
not be worth the trouble to clean. Impor-. doing the cleanup. Vincent J. Brigahte,-
tant documents have been bagged and director of operations for New England
put in a secure area of the basement.
Pollution Control, who has spent his ca
All of,the discarded material, as well as reer commuting to oil spills, tank-truck
material used in the cleaning, is sealed in accidents and other environmental disas
steel drums for burial at especially ters, says his men meet hostility at their
licensed landfill sites in Niagara Falls motel and in restaurants.
and Williamsburg, Ohio.
He says he was getting onto the eleva-1
Workers in the city and Broome County tor in City Hall the other day when two i.
office buildings, which share the monu young women already inside recognized i
mental downtown plaza with the state him. They stepped out, refusing to ride j
building, have been uneasy since the fire. with him.
Officials have met several times with "It's fear of the unknown," said Mr;
them to give assurances that their build Brigante. "1 guess I.can't really blame
ings are not contaminated, and that the them."
-
. .:
Monsanto Co. Lends
Analyst To Reagan
Po8trDl8patch Washington Bureau
WASHINGTON -- Among the many
new-' Reagan administration aides who
surfaced in the many briefings on the
new^ economic plan was A. Nicholas
Filippello of St. Louis, on loan from the
Monsanto Co.
. Filippello, whose, regular job is
director of economic analysis at
Monsanto, showed up Wednesday to
help pass out documents at a White
House breakfast news briefing by
Murray L. Weiden aum, also of St.
Louis,, chairman of the president's
Council of Economic,Advisers. '
"'Weidenbaum, , aV Washington.
University economist,* said he had
brought Filippello alongsto Washington
. for about two months as a special
consultant on macro-economic matters,
which involve the economy as a whole
as distinguished from individual
industries or firms.
'
*,
"Essentially, he is pinch-hitting until
I recruit the two other members of the
council," Weidenbaum told the Post
Dispatch. "Monsanto will be picking up
his c.salary. He will, .not deal with,
budgetary or regulatory matters , for
obvious
reasons.
tt :.
-`
'.
.
3t'-
. ,1 ; i- '
' '
; V.;
'
'-#*?}
.
' ^ .
- v .
.,.
v; '.. - _- . >
'
.
,
: '
y-:/..
-
'
. :
--
' ' " .
; - ;;
. :>.y.
/S-a ' ' ;;*&'. .
,
.V-V '
'V. ' ' \7
.- / ...
'. ' 'y ' -' `
. ' _. "'rvX
* '-j.,
!. * ` : v .
- vv - :.r.
' :pM
; ' *V .'O'; ..
PCB-ARCH-EXT0375967