Document Zb4BbJx3VZaqZeaQqbgO85QO
l l i U H J t i l i c <J
rmCM t,
*
thAH C--lO C M tO H -^M O N C l
W. J> HcCarville - A3NB - .4-3257
U *JC C T
utrcmtHcc
April 24, 1979
Q&A - AGENT ORANGE W. G. KRUMMRICH PLANT
Mr. D. R. Bishop Mr. H. M. Keating - G4WA/ Dr. George Roush - A2SA Mr. M. C. Throdahl - DID
T O Mr. W. B. Papageorge - G4WA
Attached is a preparedness Q&A on Agent Orange for internal use at W. G. Krummrich Plant. Questions from outside should he referred to Dan Bishop or myself.
/hmv ( Attachment
V. J . mcCarville
Confidential-Subject to Protective Order
/\pL-L-L --t, x 'j t y Q&A re "Agent Orange" at WGK (Internal use only)
Q: When did Monsanto make "Agent Orange" at WGK?
A: "Agent Orange", which was a mixture of the n-butyl ester of 2,4-D and the n-butyl ester of 2,4,5-T, was supplied to the. U.S. Government during the period 1965 through 1968.
most
Q: What is the material in "Agent Orange" that is'ftoxic to humans?
A: An impurity in the 2,4,5-T known as 2,3,7-, 8-tetrachlorodibenzo p-dioxin (2,3,7,8-TCDD).
Q: How much 2,3,7,8 TCDD was in Monsanto1s 2,4,5-T?
A: We don't know for sure. There are more than 20 different tetrachloro dioxins possible, all of which analyze about the same, using the techniques we had available 10 years ago, but* only the 2,3,7,8 isomer has'been shown to.be highly toxic in animal studies.'
Q: What are,,the long-term effects of exposure to 2,3,7,8-TCDD?
1t
*
A: There are no long-term health effects known in humans, but
because of some recent studies in monkeys and earlier studies
in mice and rats, the government has started a study to
examine human exposures.
_
\*
-
Q: What is Monsanto doing to study workers exposed to 2,4,5-T?
A: Although we have had experience with 2,4,5-T and presumably with 2,3,7,8-TCDD at Nitro dating back-to.1949, we have seen no long-term effects on health other than chloracne. - Last summer'wagreed to take part in an independent study of Nitro employees carried out on behalf of the World Health Organization. Nitro was chosen because exposure levels believed to be many times what would be expected in the normal production and
handling of 2,4,5-T were experienced in 1949 during a process -accident. Since even in the routine operations the exposure levels at the Nitro location were believed to be considerably highe: * than WGK, we believe it is necessary to complete this study as soon as possible. When we finish t*his study later in 1979, we will know whether there is any need to1expand the study to WGK.
Confidential-Subject to
Protective Order
V * ^ r-2, Q&A - Agent Orange - WGK
Q: Why did Monsanto agree to the Nitro study last summer? A: Since the Nitro experience is the oldest recorded incident
involving 2,3,7,8 TCDD and since it involved the largest exposed population (228) until the Seveso, Italy, episode in 1976, and also because we had not observed any long-term effects, the WHO believed that a detailed follow-up after 30 years might provide valuable information. At the time we agreed to the Nitro study, the "Agent Orange" question had not even been raised.
Q: From the studies with monkeys, mice and rats what would you say is the possible effect on my health of iny four years of exposure to contaminated 2,4,5-T?
"A: The only known human effect is chloracne. The purpose of the study at Nitro is to uncover any other long-term effects.
Qz What has been the effect so far on the exposed population at Seveso \
'll
- Italy?
As The initial irritating effect caused some cases of chloracneWe are not aware of any other known effects.
i Confidential-Subject to Protective Order