Document ZJZ9znLvX0ba60Eqgx0kL0vQ7

FILE NAME Mundet Cork MCK DATE 1957 DOC MCK112 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION WC Claim of Brockenshire eceseereerte ~ OO s ora, WORKERS ' COMPENSATION APPEALS BEARD STATE OF CALIFORNIA Spor L LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE ) APPLICANT VS COMPAN ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SJFELY , ET AL 807863 CASE NE 63 D.A. 250-245 CERTIFICATION | EVIDENCE DEFENDANT 8 I DO HEREBY CERTIFY that the attached are full true and correct copies of the documents in the file in the: entitled cause oo . This certification is for evidence only and is not to be used for filing with the County Clerk under Labor Code Section 5806 Attest my hand and the Seal of the Worker's Compensation Appeals of Board the State of California September Dated At Rae Los Angeles Ca. 25 1978 __  * . wv i . oa t INGUSTRIAL fy 03 INGUSTRIAL + G eee O eeN e )PF INGUSTRIAL 03 ANGELES JUN 20 9 23 67 t 807864 PACIFICINDEMNITY INDEMNITY INDEMNITY INDEMNITY PACIFIC INDEMNITY GROUP CRET VIDRESS PAGPIG INDEMNITY CRET COMPANY COMPANY I TIZAS PACIFIC INDEMNITY COMPANY NORTHWESTERN NORTHWESTERN NORTHWESTERN PAGIPIG INDEMNITY COMPANY 9800 WILSMINE BOULEVARD L " OS ANGELES CALIFORNIA BOCHA GP GEPARTIME GANLY S June 19 1967 . Workmen's Compensation Appeals Board . R 4107 State Building ; 107 S. Broadway Los Angeles Calif : File No 01 PEC 624043 * Assured : Thorpe Insulation Claimant: Leonard Brokenshire Accident: 12-55 Comm No 63 LA 250-245 | Gentlemen We respectfully request that the above captioned case be dismissed for lack of coverage as alleged per our letter of August Lack of prosecution and De Minimis Very truly yours Pacific Indemnity Company , ; ig JJT JJT JA Tobin By Hran Stearns & Gross Attorneys At Law 9200 Colima Rd Whittler Calif a wT T . ae ewe FR la DIVISIONOF | . RESSIVED RESSIVED . INDUSTRIAL INDUSTRIAL : cs = ACCIO103 4hJELES 4hJELES ay : \ ade t P. GLAVER WSINGAND 1866-19671 ELLSWORTH A KENDIE 4 CUG^ N^L. STOGA WILL JA OLGASON KENDI STOCKWELL WEINGAN . ATTORNEYS AT LAW A. WARS NORRIS t WTAJAM M. ANGERED t JETA D. MACARTHUR . / _ 807865 . 807865 200 we^ TFOURTH STREET 807865 SANTA ANA CALIPORNIA 92701 92701 . 716m 41.8 <a 900 WEST FIFTH AVENUE POMONA CALIFORNIA 61780 716 1689 6. , DIANELAS TERUSZA TERUSZA J. POSADL OGS GY . an IN REPLY REPEN TO ; Los Angeles . June 19 1967 Worlemen's Compensation Appeals Board 107 South Broadway Los Angeles California RE LEONARD BROKENSHIRE V VARIOUS EMPLOYERS 63 LA 250 245 . , ' Gentlemens a There has year issue should been no action on this matter for over a We believe a notice of intent to dismiss and if valid objection is raised thereto that this case be restored to calendar for a full one day hearing Yours very truly NO KENDIG & STOGICELL STOGICELL BY Bilrad Joseph JOSEPH BILCHAK mic F cc: Aetna Casualty and suraty Company - S 33CC - 1096193 McLaughlin Evans Dalbey and Cumming Stearns Gross and Moore Fireman's Ginocchio Zonni , and Taylor Fireman's Fireman's Fund American Insurance Company rae 08, ) + FOH WORKMEN'S WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD " ' STATE OF CALIFORNIA S WORMSATIONWORMSATION WORMSATION SVA CASE NO 63 LA 250 245 LOS ANGELES ANGELES OFFICE WORMSATION WORMSATION APPEALS SCARO S FILED - - LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE ) Applicant , APR 1 7986 MINUTES OF FURTHER | VE | ; } HEARING ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY COMPANY ) a corporation et al . 7 ) Defendants AND . ORDER TAKING OFF CALEI THIS CAUSE came on for hearing at 9:00 a.m. March 29 1966 in Department 5 Workmen's Compensation Appeals Board Los Angeles California before the Honorable ROBERT W. DUBEAU Referee - G. C. Faurot Reporter Leonard Charles Brokenshire applicant Stearns & Gross by Richard Gross attorneys for applicant . APR 1966 8.8. Miller . . S. C. Schweitzer Representative for Thorpe Insulation S. Schweitzer + Fireman's Fund Insurance Company McConnell & Cramoline by J. F. Holzer attorneys for Marine Engineering & Supply Co Pacific Employers Insuranc Zonni Ginocchio & Taylor by Wm Blanchard , attorneys for Accurate Insulation Co Casualty Insurance Co. of Californ Weingand Kendig & Stockwell by Ross C. Irvin attorneys for Mudet Cork Corp Fiberglass Engineering & Supply Company Armstrong Contracting & Supply Co The Aetna Casualty and Surety Company George R. Haswell by Charles P. Carlstroem attorneys for Riley Stoker Corp Liberty Mutual Insurance Company McLaughlin Evans Dalbey & Cumming by John F. McLaughlin attorneys for Armstrong Contracting & Supply Co The Travelers Insurance Company F. W. Harrington Representative for Accurate Insulation Co Mission Insurance Company a corporation successor to , Enterprise Insurance Company a corporation 1 807867 Collins Insulation Phil Representative for Plant Facific Indemnity Company a corporation Company ; . NO WITNESSES & fF NO EXHIBITS 5 2m 7 & g 97234 DISPOSITION In order that additional parties may be joined GOOD CAUSE APPEARING THEREFOR IT IS ORDERED that this matter be TAKEN OFF CALENDAR subject to being reset upon request of any of the parties Service of this Order is waived 97234 97234 ~ 14 16 REFEREE liker FC. . WORKMEN'S WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD 9 2 25 28 DIVISION OF INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENTS _. WORKMEN COMPENSATION APPELS STATE OF CALIFORNIA BOARD 807868 807868 807868 807868 807868 VG. | Case 63LA 250 245 Applicant ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING SUPPLY AND & corporations et ARMER | . CORNING FIBERGLASS COMPANY COAST ) INSULATING PRODUCTS COMPANY INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY COMPANY a corporation NATIONAL - AUTOMOBILE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE a . . corporation COMPANY . Defendants ies Order Order JoiJoniinningg Party PartyParty Defendant Good Cause Appearing IT IS ORDERED THAT FIBERGLASS INSULATING OWENS CORNING COMPANY COAST PRODUCTS COMPANY INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY COMPANY a corporation NATIONAL AUTOMOBILE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY & corporation ; * parties is joined as party defendant herein Refeos WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD Dated at LSoesptAenmbgeerle2s2Cali1for9ni6a 7California SERVED BY MAIL ON PERSONS SHOWN ON THE OFFICIAL ADDRESS RECORD oe -~ ADDRESS RECORD Dec 9/22/67 By 1 nee Copy of notice of hearing application and joinder of 2/9/66 served all newly joined parties and their attorney and Reece Insulation Co tnt, kane tev oe tn STATE OF CALIFORNIA * fo LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE VS. . Applicant_ ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY COMPANY a corporation et al i Defendant Case NU70 3 631A 250 245 NU703 Notice of Time and Place of Further Hearing On the Petition of The Travelers Insurance Company for contributi under Labor Code Section 5500.5 NOTICE TO ALL PARTIES | You are hereby notified that further hearing will be held in the entitled action at 4107 LOS ANGELES STATE OFFICE BUILDIN10G7 SOUTH BROADWAY . LOS ANGELES CALIFORNIA October 9 1967 | 9:00 A.M. all day | WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD Daved at Los Angeles California NOTE CONTINUANCES AND FURTHER HEARINGS ARE NOT FAVORED an : "sm . SERVED BY MAIL ON PERSONS SHOWN ON THE OFFICIAL ADDRESS RECORD Date By t 9/13/67 www.HAM so | dake em eget ARR A ek A ee eth ee, \ DET TMENT OF INDUSTRIAL RELAT i DIVISION OF INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENTS WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD COPY 807870 STATEOFCALIFORNIA CASZ 63 LA 250-245 ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING & SUPPLY CORPORATION TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY ; Defendants SUBPENA DUCES DUCES TECUM . PLEASE BE SURE THE WORKHEN'S COMPENSATION AFEHALS BOARD NUBE IS ON ALL RECORDS YOU SEND IN ANSWER TO THIS SUBPOENA The People of the State of California Send Greetings to PACIFIC . - 3200 Wilshire Blvd. , Los Angeles Calif INDEMNITY_COMP : WE COMMAND YOU or appear before a referee of the - Coe! WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA THIS 107 South Broadway DATE Los Angeles California September 27th 19 HEARING 9:00 o'clock As to casintthie fy entitled matter and to bring with you and produce following described documents papers books and recorder ANY AND ALL COPIES OF WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION INSURANCE POLICIES AND DALIES RELATING TO MARINE ENGINEERING & SUPPLY COMPANY BETWEEN- CERAM For failure to attend and to produce said documents you may be deemed guilty of a cconntemtptempt and liable to pay in the parties aggrieved all damages surrained thereby and forfais ans hundred dollars in addition thezers This rabpens is inued at the request of the person making the decloan trhearet versi e ho erenof SEP 12 1987 19 WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD AN. t., * . * a com, af aL yan Pe F me By Sazmery Assistant Secretary Rafww SECRETARY APPLICABLE ONLY IF INITIALED BY REFEREE OR ASSISTANT ae ay this subpens by mailing the records described to the Workman's Compensation Appeals Board Yoofu may fully correly with rernede California within five ) days of the date of service of this subpens attaching the copy the ashens n^marking the mlamelo with she shage imminerad sure al~-nal~-n~-n a, aac . 807871 Le " wwe a 807871 WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPFALS BOARD 807871 807871 P STATE OF CALIFORNIA _ 5 CASE NO 63 K.A. 250-245 " * g | LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE ob E rns fa ne PD : 6 AAppplipcantlicant , T VB. .g ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUFFLY - | COMPANI et al _ _ 3 Defandents OI ORDER FOR APPORTIONMENT CONTRIBUTION rah IT IS ORDERED that defendants hereinafter named pursuant 12 Stipulation filed herein on January 12 1968 pay to the TRAVELERS 13 14 | INSURANCE COMPANY the following sums as their proportionate share of all liability for this injury for reimbursement for permanent disa- 15 bility temporary disability and medical expense heretofore paid by 10 | TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY _ 17 PACIFIC EMETOTERS INSURANCE COMPANY PLANT RUBBER & ASBESTOS COMPANY 18 LIBERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY FIREMAN'S FUND INSURANCE COMPANY 19 INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY COMPANY NATIONAL AUTOMOBIIE AND CASUALTY IN- 20 SURANCE COMPANY CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY OF 21 CALIFORNIA MISSION INSURANCE COMPANY 22 AEINA QASUALTY & SURETY COMPANY 23 24 | 1968 DATED AT LOS ANGELES CALIFORNIA .164 .194 .008 .058 .052 .019 ...0.20424 .245 this 22nd 2339.46 2767.41 2767.41 114.12 827.37 741178 271.03 271.03 1554.89 350.00 3494.93 day of January 25 Le 26 SEAL SEAL . , 27 Referee WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOAF | . 28 SERVED BY MAIL ON ALL PARTIES LISTED ON THE OFFICIAL ADDRESS RECORD 29 | Date 1-22-68 By D.P.Brennan D.P.Brennan 30 1.18 of Hestions : SAN KOSAVONLIN BARNEY 7. RVANS RVANS WRA SLAIR HALJEV . RAT S SUMBING KAROLD HEHNETT N^ DL GAYLORD F. BART BAO RTN ON GE GER MR AGNILI PLAN A SCHUM ER SCHUMERSCHUMMER RUMENM, SALMA . RECEIVED RECEIVED TRE . servers Pia Mclaughlin Evans Daleet & Cummina ATTORNEYS AT LAW 1917 NORTH NIGHLAA VON HU^L BUITE 710 S te S ete pone tae OPS ane Sah 166 AKADLES CALIFORNIA HOOSE : 319 446-4961 a807872 : January 11 1968 ., ae ae , ; , Workmen's Compensation Appeals Board 107 South Broadway . Los Angeles California RE IKCHARD WCAB File No. CHARLES 63 LA BROKENSHIRE 250 245 vs. vs. ARMSTRONG ARMSTRONG CONIRAGI & & SUFFIX ( ms Gandemen Your attention is respectfully invited to the following < )} Attached please find executed Compromise & Redeze for your approval - ) Request is hereby made for further hearing to permit examination of . and preseon f rt ebuattatl eivio dennce ( . ( > (REE) Please enter our appearance as amoeneys for Please set case for trial as there are now fumes in content Arrforafic lingh heree in d are | STIPULATION WITH REQUEST FOR AWARD AFTER ^' LEMENTRY FROCERDINGS UNITER LABOR CODB CTION 5500.5 . dated Januzey 10 1968 1968 Copies to , Brobeck Phleger & Harrison tVr eryul truy ly your me, Facific Employers Insurance Co MCLAUGHLIN EVANS DALBEY & CUMMING Liberty Mutual Insurance Co. Humming Humming Fireman's Fund Insurance L.A Humming Weingand Kendig & Stockwell By < B. Industrial Indemnity L.A. Ray National Automobile & Casualty Ins.Co Casualty Ins Co. of Calif Humming Humming B. Cumming Mission Insurance Company Travelers Insurance Co.  DALBEY & CUMMING EVANS LAUGHLIN 1717 North Avenue Suice 710 AngelesHighland Los , California 90028 3 Bollywood 6-8541 em Attomeya for DefendancS 807873 807873 807873 807873 807873 11.3 11.3 mrs JAN sam ... 10 ' WORKTHM E WEORNKM'ENS 'S PENSATION AFFRALS BOARD OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA M ~ 2 7G 23 7 11 LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE Applicant, 13 v CONTRAC ARMSTRONG 15 COMPANY et al AND SUPELY Defendance CASE NO 63 LA 250 245 STIPULATION WITH REQUEST AFTER SUFFLE FOR AWARD MENTRY PROCEEDINGS UNDER LABOR CODE SECTION 5500.5 17 The parties to this agrement enter into the following stipulations and request the Workmen's Compensation Appeals Board issue its Findings and Award without further proceedings So I | . LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE Applicant herein while employed 1941 February by various employers commencing in to and including 8 1963 developed asbestosis 25 ARMSTRONG The Applicant elected to proceed for benefits against NTRACTING AND SUPPLY COMPANY insured during the period of exposure 2 Compensation at various times by AETNA CASUALTY AND SURETY COMPANY and TRAVELERS 28 INSURANCE COMPANY That the Workman's III Appeals Board then Industrial 31 Accident Commission issued its findings and Award on November 6 196 32 wherein the Applicant was awarded permanent disability of 62 which 08 78 4 HH a^the rate of 52.50 per weak squaled 13,020.00 temporary disability for the period beginning February 9 1963 through June 9 1963 at the race of 70.00 and further medical treatment for the balancebalance of life Applicant's 1 8 IV disabil ty That puzsuent es said Findinge and Award TRAVELERS INSURANCE MFANI has paid 14,263.00 consisting at 13,020.00 for permansut disability indemnity 960.00 temporary disability indemniatnyd 285.00 medical expense . . 12 The Applicawnats employed by the following at various times between 1941. and February 8 1963 vhose workmen's compensation insurance carrier during said period of exposure is also designated 13 Plant Rubber & Asbestos Works Riley Stoker Corporation Permissibly insured Liberty Mutual Insurance Company 16 Marine Engineering & Supply Pacific Employers Insurance q ThorTphoerpeInInssuullaattiioonn Company aka Insulation Company Pacific Pacific Employers Insurance . Company and Firemsa's Fund Insurance Company | Fiberglass Engineering & Supply Company Owens Corning Fiberglass - Astna Casualty & Surety Co. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. Reece Insulation Company Indemnity - Industrial Company and National Automobile & i John Manville'Sales Manville'Sales Corp. Munder Cork Corporation . 25 Casualty Insurance Ins decurate Insulation CompanyCompany Casualty Insurance Company Travelers Insurance Company Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. Company Casualty Insurance of and Mission Insurance Company 30 Coast Insulation Company Inc. Pacific Employers Insurance Company ~ ~~ awh 7 oe 2. 16 19 22 26 27 29 273300 30 32 Armstrong Corporation Travelers Insurance Company & Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. VE ; For their respective employers the insurmce carriers 807875 percentage of liability is as follows 807875 ; Pacific Employers Insurance Company Flant Rubber & Asbestos Company - 164 194 $ 2339.46 807875 2767.41 Liberty Mutuel Insurance Company 008 114.12 Fireman's Fireman's Fund Insurance Company .058 Industrial Indemnity Company Casusley Netional Automobile and Insurance Company 6052 . . 0114 827,37 741078 , 271.03 . Casualty Insurance Company of Mission Insurance Company CompanyCasualty & Surety The Travelers Insurmes Company . 109 .024 1354.89 350.00 .245 3494.93 118 1683.27 VII - That a Findings and Award be issued assessing Liability in the percentages set forth in paragraph VI and that the monetary amounts designated in said paragraph be ordered paid forthwith to the Travelers Insurance Company Dye Vey DATED this 10 of day , 1963 & Cas aka FIBREBOARD RUBBERCORPATION ASBESTOS WORKS s, * FIBREBOARD J ^' PACIFIC PACIFIC EXSURANCE EXSURANCE COMPANY LIBERTY LIBERTY MUTUAL MUTUAL INSURANCE CCOMOPAMNPYCAONMPYANN Y acy to INSURANCE BFIRyEMAN'S MAN'S MAN'S MAN'S FUND COMPANY CASUALTY . . : Byfa SURETY & CASUALTY ofof a COMPANY . Aeee , CASUALTY INDUSTRIALTeam INDEMNITY INDEMNITY eng teagan +. INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY COMPANY iis _ By K fe. COMPANY COMPANY /3- et etter at eet ee Roz ae om * 10 123 & 18 17 19 19 21 23 24 28 29 30 34 32 NATIONAL AUTOMOBILE AND CASUALTE 807876 INSURANCE COMPANY - ar INSURANCE Cet ta id COMPANY a a . a . Fem Ne ie . es a er ano tes NTT Hoty ~ : ge oe OMY oi the tw wae \ 19 Oks rn wc 19 \ eur a 2 td kemerey ain Sid -? hadnt + i ~ WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD 807877 . 807877 807877 807877 807877 807877 BR STATE OF CALIFORNIA CASE NO 63 LA 250-245 @ @ LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE " Applicant 47 VE se MINUTES oF +] ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLE FURTHER HEARING , COMPANY & corporation PLANT INSULATION COMPANY MARINE ENGINEERING AND AND SUPPIT COMPANY FIBERGLASS | ENGINEERING AND SUPPLY COMPANY REECE ORDER TAKIMI =, INSULATION COMPANY THORPE INSULATION - COMPANY MUDET CORK CORPORATION ACCURATE INSULATION COMPANY AETNA OFF CALENDAR CASUALTY & SURETY COMPANY & corporation THE TRAVELIERS INSURANCE COMPANY a , corporation FIREMAN'S FUND INSURANCE COMPANY & Corporation CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY OF CALIFORNIA COMPANY Successor MIS ION INSURANC^ INSURANC^ , Successor Interest to Enterprise Insurance Company a corporation PACIFIC & corporation PLANT IRNUDEBMBNIETYRIN&DEMNITAY SCBOEMSPTAONSY Cisted at > California OCT13 OCT13 1987 WORKScorporation PACIFIC INDEMNITY COMPANY a corporation RILEY STOKER CORPORATION LIBERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY e . Meller 6. 6. Meller corporation PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INSURANCE Let MatRE OFFER COMPANY & Corporation CORNING IN'S COMPENSATZOL~fi FIBERGLASS COMPANY COAST INSULATING PRODUCTS COMPANY INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY COMPANI a corporation NATIONAL | AUTOMOBILE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY & corporation FIBREBOARD PAPER APPEALS #GARD ANNA OF CALIFCHNIA CALIFCHNIA 67 10-13 BED 10-13 10-13 e 10-13 PRODUCTS CORPORATION & corporation ; Defendants THIS CAUSE came on for triel October 9 1967 at 9:00 a.m. in Department 5 of the Workmen's Compensation Appeals Board Los Angeles California before the Honorable ROBERT W. DUBEAU Referee oy Beth Irene Marriott Official Reporter " : APPEARANCES Leonard Charles Brokenshire applicant ele Sere sivas etd iit Se} . . oa . ... 807878 807878 807878 807878 807878 H APPEARANCES Contined N & fh & S ^' 7, ; 8 9 10 # 12 3 14 19 Enrold F. Shoop representative for Fireman's Fund Insurance Company . McConnell & Cramoline by K. F. Holzar attorneys for Pacifi Employers Insurance Company Brobeck Phleger & Harrison by Attorney Selaroni attorneys for Plan Rubber & Asbestos Works and Fibreboard Faper Products Corporation Charles P. Carlstrom by William N. Roberson attorneys for RCiomlpaney yCompaSnytoker Corporation and Liberty Mutual Insurance F. W. Harrington representative for Mission Insurance Compa & corporation Successor in Interest to Enterprise Insurance Company & corporation Zenni Ginocchio & Taylor by William Blanchard attorneys f Casualty Insurance Company of California and Accurate Insulation Company E. Weingand Kendig & Stockwell by E. E. Kendig attorneys for Aet^-aCasualty & Surety Company Clapton & Penny by Robert R. Wills attorneys for Industria Indemnity Company , Evans Cumm & Ci umn mig ng by Ray B. Cumming and BarrFy. Evans attorneys for Armstrong Contracting and Supply Company and The Travelers Insurance Company Albert A. Atkinson representative for National Automobile and Casualty Insurance Company . . 18 WITNESSES; None | EXHIBITS NONE * 20 - DISPOSITION . 3 and Pending the probable resolution of all issues by stipulation 24 ' GOOD CAUSE APPEARING THEREFOR . 1 . IT ISORDERED the entitled case be and the same hereby is taken off calendar subject to being reset upon written reques 27 of any party hereto Service of this Order is waived 29 - 30 Letpoaet of y bee bf Csation Appetie ooffC|sCastiaotniCsoatinon Appetie Basta WCAB Perm 319 ( 540 mirty Pave 319 319 one wifStive Pan Qe Lofefpr, WORKMEN'S COMCOMPENPSATION ECOMPENSATNION SCOAMPENSATTION ICOOMPENSATION N APPEALS BOARD = Qa 3-79 3-79 3-79 aio ; ; DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD STATE OF CALIFORNIA . 807879 807879 807879 an Bintan oF allagad. WYssaye 12050 12050 ee amen as paunty ANSWERING forth DEPENDANTS DEPENDANTS all har masarial allegations THANK ET KOLEGLUKOS KOLEGLUKOS KOLEGLUKOS LA POMORS x Employment ' wo . dramas Occupies . . . - DEFLAIN BELOW . x : . PONGAL PONGAL 19 LAKEN ON BAPE UN MAY BY ESET a ae CORRECT MAX ACCIDENTALES CORRECT ACCIDENTALES CORRECT FILED ZZ ACCIDENTALES AGORE FILED RECEIVED AGORE IEERT B RECEIVED RECEIVED IEERT IS IEERT AM INDUSTRIAL IEERT INDUSTRIAL INDUSTRIAL 166 K^ SLELN^ U~ AN ACCIDENTALES " _ Uobility for salf procured frontmat UebiUebl iliti y fot r fuy tura medical treatment wince Abadlegi coms _ Earings Y Perioda et dombliky IT IS FURTHER ALLEGE Cafendants beginning diability Indemnity theough_ wom MOWED A ELATISUSCOSULADO CONTAINS , s S^ KTELAST DAT WHOSEN AJID GICAREY DATE OF KATUSE TO WOSA ES A APVOGTHSP EAT VOGTHESKEAAAST CO SE STATED . amount of MONE at rate of pie OF NOTINOC TIE CE DPerfaecntdiacnets do not waive the right to raise additional kausa in accordance with the provisions of low and the Rules of if otherissues develop Entitia me t foretrd ial~- All defendants medical repo havre tbes en medical . Additional reports will be filed before . Additional reports trial wanted umn TLS aeenue 9 CIA WEAK FOR FORU 201 1,4 _ OVER PHIL COLLINS . KAS TELLIN TEG LLIS NGE SE OF KUSHED ATTORNEY 381-3211 ext 414 QAYMODE 109 1908 1 694 47 + aemione, Weee the State California of HT ) oe of FACE FACE FACE FACE _ 71-1 ( M 127201 /" / ana 127201 i oF 80780 and am and Inknown Pacific Employers Insurance Company In answer the application we and we raise reserve checked below ad itional other allegations make james not now known to be proper and develop later we reserve the right to raise such additional issues in accordance with the provisions of law neces ary malofets he Commission . , [2 Employmene . (Sf Earnings at the time of injury EI Namire and exseatof disability (FI Occupation of employee Ext Lisbility for treatment InjInjuuryry arisinogutemopflaonydmoecncturring (CT Stamme of limitations . a Insurance coverage and Employer "oo. Medical reports have been served as fined in covering letter Disability indemnity has been follows TTeemmppoorraarryy NJ and including Permanent Sht and mcluding Total . ; Total We believe that the presentation of our evidence will require a minimum of , Estimated number of witnesses if available fee ock @s week : Rebert E. Guthrie Authorized Representat Adre^a 4050 381-2611 Calif Nota A COPY of this Answer shall be served on all adverse Tel3e81-2611 . moved must be muda here 4050 parties . Wilshire Blvd. , naration Los Angeles of mach service and the parties Attorneys Partion served ee: STEARNS and GROSS at Law By Richard T. Gross Attorney , 9200 Colima Rd Whittier California REG ah . . Pop se IRAVIONOM IRAVIONOM OF 10,15 teo Ganu e caem@ a eae n ootp 8078 1 DEFARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS " WORKMEN'WSORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD STATE OF GALIFORNIA CEDNARD CHARLES BROKENSHI Applicant Vo Case No. 63LL 250 245 HOTICOEF TIME AND FLACK OF FURTHER LAMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND HEARING + SUPPLY COMPANY & corporation at . . , L^ SANGET.2ANGET.2 OFTNES Defendants ASTRALE CAALILFIORFNIOARNIA 1986 MILI^FEB 119896 86 NOTICE TO ALE PARTIES . You are hereby notified that further hearing will be held in the entitled action et 4107 LOS ANGELES STATE OFFICE BUILDING 107 SOUTH BROADWAY LOS ANGELES CALIFORNIA March 1966 . 100 A.M. all dey " Deted at LOS ANGELES | FEB 9 1966 I'SI'S COMPENSATION COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD| . NOTE CONTINUANCES AND FURTHER HEARINGS ARE NOT PAVORED See attached Jeinder for service GRAMOLINE GRAMOLINE MCCONNELL MCCONNELL MCCONNELL Appor MAR 22 - GRAMOLINE NOTICE TONDER TONDER ethan ' + Signature or person serving notice BEFORE THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFOR I CASE NO 63 L.A. 250-245 LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE } . Applicant ) Me * ge ARMSTRONG CONTRACKING AND SUPPLE ) COMPANY # 0orporation PLANT . INSULATION COMPANY MARINE ENGIN- ) s , MINUTES OF FURTHER HEARING REFING AND SUPPLY COMPANY FIBER- 7 AND GLASS ENGINEERING AND SUPPLY CON- ) ORDER JOINING PARTY PANY REECE INSULATION COMPANY ee THORPE INSULATION COMPANY MUDEE ) TAKING CORK CORPORATION ACCURATE IN- ORDER DEFENDANT OFF CALENDAR SULATION COMPANY REINA CASU- 11 ALTY & SURETY COMPANY & corporation THE TRAVELERS INSURANCE - COMPANY a corporation FIREMAN'S INSURANCE COMPANY a corpora- LOS ANGELES tion CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY OF CALIFORNIA & corporation } MISSION INSURANCE COMPANY Su^- * cessor in Interest to Enterprise ) DATED AT FILED gy JUL 15 1964 PACIFIC INDEMNITY corporation PACIFIC INDEMNITY COMPAN^ } a corporation corporation ) Defendants RA INS Shifoonam ) 9 5 92 THIS CAUSE came on for hearing on July 13 1964 at 9:00 a.m. in Department 13 of the Industrial Accident Commission Los Angel - California before the Honorable CHARLES GLASMAN Referee | GladyMs. Behling Reporter | PRESENT . Leonard Charles Brokenshire Applicant Stearns & Gross bp Richard Gross Attorneys for applicant 2 50 Weingand Kendig & Stockwell by Ross C. Irwin Attorneys for Armstrong Con- tracting and Supply Company Aetna Casu- alty & Surety Company Mudet Cork Cor : poration Fiberglass Engineering and Supply Company . Zonni Ginocchio & Taylor by Ben F. Taylor Attorneys for Accurate Insula- tion Company and Casualty Insurance Company of California . 0 pp test Bk 33 7 Power 138 138 21-49 BAIN 69696 ; . * . . . wes a Yoo sof ' . - ue . o . a ry aa a . ye + ae out . ' - 80783 4 ya }? atte PS ange *S fs BEFORE THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFOR . 7 T LEONARD CHARLES CASE NO BROKENSHIRE 63 L.A. ) 250-245 Applicant ) ow . i ZA } ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY } - ae COMPANY a corporation PLANT INSULATION COMPANY MARINE ENGIN ) EERING AND SUPPLY COMPANY FIBER- . MINUTES OF FURTHER EZARING . AND GLASS ENGINEERING AND SUPPLY COM- ) ORDER JOINING PARTY DEFENDANT 10 PANY REECE INSULATION COMPANY THORPE INSULATION COMPANY MUDET } : CORK CORPORATION ACCURATE INSULATION COMPANY AEINA CASU- AND ORDER TAKING OFF CALENDAR ALTY & SURETY COMPANY a corpora- tion THE TRAVELERS INSURANCE ) COMPANY & corporation FIREMAN'S 11 FUND INSURANCE COMPANY & corpora tion CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY. OF CALIFORNIA a corporation > DATED AT OS ANGELES FILEC FILEC cessor in Interest to Enterprise ) MEEN Insurance Company & corporation PACIFIO INDEMNITY COME , a corporation Defendants 1964 . INS CL INSA ME N THIS GAUSE came on for hearing on July 13 1964 at 9:00 a.m. in Department 13 of the Industrial Accident Commission Los Angele . California before the Honorable CHARLES OLASMAN Referee Gladys M. Behling Reporter N . PRESENT Leonard Charles Brokenshire Applicant . Sterms & Gross by Richard Gross Attorneys for applicant ; Weingand Kendig & Stockwell by Ross 0 Irwin Attorneys for Armstrong Contracting and Supply Company Aetna Casualty & Surety Company Mudet Cork Copporation Fiberglass Engineering and Supply Company Zonni Ginocchio & Taylor by Ben F. Taylor Attorneys for Accurate Insula tion Company and Casualty Insurance . Company of California 0 pp test BK 33 . FOAM 310 Pee? Tats eed 9oF e Mfi 20: : * . rte eA a Ray aa ee a NE Be UR Nae ' 80784 . : , z REFORE Hi fj REFORE THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORN s CASE NO 63. LA 250 245 LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE Applicant | . SA : ; , ARMSTONG ; ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY COMPANY a corporation at al Defendants AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL OF PETITION FOR SUPPLEMENTARY PROCEEDINGS TO ESTABLISH APPORTIONMENT OF LIABILITY AND RIGHT OF CONTRIBUTION PURSUANT TO LABOR CODE SECTION 5500.5 3 At At & Pa JA JA = STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES : az. REFERLE m . REFERLE REFERLE 57 KATHLEEN DAWSON being first duly swota Bays that ; affiant is a citizen of the United States and a resident of the county aforesaid that affiant is over the age of eightem years and is not a party to the within entitled ection that affiant's business address is 6725 Sunset Boulevard Los Angeles 28 California that on January 6 1966 affiant served copies of Petition for Supplementary Proceedings to Establish Apportionment of Liability and Right of Contribution Pursuant to Labor Code Section 5500.5 on the parties listed below by placing said copies .. in a sealed envelope with postage thereon fully prepaid in the . United States post office mail box at 6725 Sunset Boulevard Los Angeles 28 California addressed as follows Plant Rubber & Asbestos Works 537 Brannan St. San Francisco California - Pacific Indemnity Company 3200 Wilshire Boulevard Los Angeles California Riley Stoker Corporation 9 Neponset Screet Worcester Massachusetts Liberty Mutual Insurance 6006 Wilshire Boulevard Los Angeles California Company . RESCIVE RESCIVE | i . JAN 13 1986 1. KERIKSERTISITI priser a mgr my . marta tsgee rn ov + ae - 80785 Marine Engineering and Supply Co. 941 East 2nd Street , Los Angeles California 90012 KATHLEEN DAWSON January Subscribed and sworn to before me this 6th day day 1966 Fran " 19 19 23 24 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 Yaw / . wees 6+ non ena - 807886 807886 - 807886 a eee . 807886 aw 807886 807886 7 COVED \ INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT a. , COMMISSIONE COMMISSIONE ANGELSANGELS . _ 20 GLAUBHUB GLAUBHUB K BARR DWAY NS | WIA BLAJA GALDEY \ DAY & SUNMIS MARGLO BENNETT i i 15 et gee ow 15 MCLAUGHLIN EVANS QALBEY QALBE&Y CUMMING 0718 SUNSET POUL~ VARO LOS CALIFORNIA BOONE TELERISON January 5 1966 1966 os 1986 JAN 11b AND EXHIBIT Cee _ .CASHE HOO EXHIBIT EXHIBIT .CASE pe ed Industrial Gb.44 Gb.44 Ys M Accident Commission , 107 South Broadway Los Angeles 12 California Re . Casa No. 63 LA 250 245 Isonard Charles Brokenshire & Supply Company et al vs. Armstrong Contracting Gantlemen Consistent with the Petition of Travelers Insurance Company for supplementary proceedings we are requesting that the following employers and carriers be joined as party defandents Elang Rubber Rubber & Asbestos Works 537 Brannan St. San Francisco company California and its insurance Pacific 3200 Wilshire Blvd , Los Angeles California Indemnity Co. Riley @ Stoker Corporation 9 Naponset St. setts and its insurance company @Liberty 6006 Wilshire Blvd g Los Angeles Calif Worcester MassachuMutual Insurance Co. SSrearlySreeaalylySrealy * Engineering employer Herine Engineering and Supply Co. 941 E. 2nd St. Calif The carrier for this particular to date unknown Los Angeles , is We are serving a copy of this letter upon the persons listed above as well as serving them with a copy of the petition for Supplementary Proceedings and the documents attached thereto We ask that this matter be restored for a full day hearing Yours very truly MCLAUGHLIN EVANS DALBEY & CUMMING BFE kd oe: Stearns Gross & Moore By #G 00 WZoeminnigandGinoKcecnhdiiog & StTaoyclkowrell Barry . : RECEIVER JAN 12 1938 UAN LAKE LAKE YAEL ON Elta ee 80787 , 807887 Harold Shoop Representing Thorpe Insulation Company and Fireman's Fund Insurance Company McLaughlin Evans Dalbey & Cumming by John McLaughlin Attorneys for Armstrong Contracting and Supply Company and The Travelers In- suzance Company . Harold Bennett Representing Accurate Insula tion Company and Mission Insurance Company successor in interest to Enterprise Insur- ance Company . No appearances by or for Fiant Insulation Com- pany Marine Engineering and Supply Company and Reece Insulation Company | GOOD CAUSE APPEARING THEREFOR IT IS ORDERED That Pacific Indemnity Company & corpora- tion be and it hereby is joined as a party defendant f DISPOSITION To permit further investigation on issues of coverage and employment and GOOD CAUSE APPEARING THEREF^ R re IS ORDERED That the entitled matter be taken off calendar subject to being reset upon request of any of the parties Serrice of this Order has been w^/iredby the parties, thereto except Pacific Indemnity Company , to be served on Pacific Indemity Company Copy of this Order Referee INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION ofe R BEFORE THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORN CASE NO 63 D.A. 250-245 LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE ). , Applicant ) yaome 8 10 14 VE } ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPELY ) COMPANY a corporation ELANT INSULATION COMPANY MARINE ENGIN- ) EERING AND SUPPLY COMPANY FIBER- GLASS ENGINEERING AND SUPPLY CON- ) . PANY REEDE INSULATION COMPANY THORPE INSULATION COMPANY MUDET ) CORK CORPORATION ACCURATE IN- SULATION COMPANY AETNA CASU- ) ALTY & SURETY COMPANY a corpora- } tion TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY a corporation FIREMAN'S FUND INSURANCE COMPANY & corporation ) CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY OF CALIFORNIA , & corporation ) MISSION INSURANCE COMPANT Sue- cessor in Interest to Enterprise ) Insurance Company a corporation a 2 MINUTES OF FURTHIA DEARING Loy . US ANSELIG OPPICE ACCIDENT COMMISSION INDUSTRIAL OF CALIFCO ALR IFNORINIAA MILD JUN26 1964 WILLIAM WILLIAM KAPLA Ab8t. KAPLA CEEEE CEEEE 19 N N N Defendants ) THIS CAUSE came on for hearing on June 23 1964 at 9:00 a.m. in Department 13 of the Industrial Accident Commission Los Angeles California before the Honorable CHARLES GLASMAN Referee _ ~ . Gladys M. Behling Reporter , FRESENT Leonard Charles Brokenshire Applicant Stearns & Gross by Richard Gross Attorneys for applicant Weingand Kendig & Stookwall by Ross Irwin Attorneys for Armstrong Contracting and Supply Company Astna Casualty & Surety Company Mudet Cork Corporation Fiberglasa Engineering and Supply Company Zonni Ginocchio & Taylor by Marco J. Zonni Attorneys for Accurate Insulation Company and Casualty Insurance Company of California 10 pp test BK 29 -1- | 196 196 ui tease . roytt a . . eRe ._ os ott aia ve . xe me - wf , Representing Harold Shoop Thorpe Insulation Company and Fireman's Fund Insurance Company MaLaughlin Evans Balbey & Cumming by John MaLaughlin Attorneys for Armstrong Contract- ing and Supply Company and Travelers Insur- ance Company : Harold Bermett Representing Accurate Insulation Company and Mission Insurance Company successor in interest to Enterprise Insurance Company 8078 9 Insulation Company an . IT IS STIPULATED That Aetne Casualty & Surety Company vas the workmen's compensation insurance carrier for Fiber- glass Engineering and Supply Company from January 1 1953 to September 1 1955 _ IT IS FURTHER STIFUL That Aetna Casualty & Surety Company was the workmen's compensation insurance carrier for Mudet Cark Corporation from December 31 1956 through Decembez 31 1959 and that the applicant was employed by Mudet Cork Corporation from March 1967 through February 1959 IT IS FURTHER STIPULATED That Casualty Insurance Company of California was the workmen's compensation insurance car- rier for Accurate Insulation Company from Aprii I 1959 through February 1 1961 and that the applicant was employed by Accurate Insulation Company during this same period IT IS FURTHER STIPULATED That Mission Insurance Company successor in interest to Enterprise Insurance Company was the workmen's compensation insurance carrier for Accurate Insula- tion Company from February 1 1961 through March 25 1961 and that the applicant was employed by Accurate Insulation Company during said period 020 > 807890 IT IS FURTHER STIPULATED That Fireman's Fund Irisurance Company was the workomen's compensation insurance carrier for Thorp Insula tioInnsula tion Company from October 1 ber 1 1957-| 1956 through Octo- DISPOSITION DISPOSITION . At the request of the parties the matter now stands adjourned until 9:00 a.m. on July 13 1964 in accordance with the Notice of Further Hearing dated May 27 1964 INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION STATE OF CALIFORNIA . GROHARD CHARLES BROKEN eo Case No. 63 LA 250 245 SUPPLEMENTAL SUPPLEMENTAL Notice of Time and Place of ; ve. | ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY COMPANY * Corporation et al } Further Hearing ON DEFENDANT TRAVELERS INS PETITION FOR SUPPLEMENTARY SUPPLEMENTARY FROCKED TO ESTABLISH APFORTIONMENT OF LIABILITY AND RIGHT OF CONTRIBUTION . PURSUANT TO LABOR GODE Defendent | SECTION 5500.5 NOTICE TO ALL PARTIES You are hereby notifitehadt further bearing he be l heldd in the entitled actionAL ACCIDEANCIDTENT COMM 4107 LOS ANGELES STATE OFFICE BUILDING 107 SOUTH BROADWAY BROADWAY CARDIA CARDIA , . LOS ANGELES CALIFORNIA _ JUWBJuff 196&4 14 9:00 1964-9 A.M. 1/2 DAY LM.- TWO DAYS | KAPU WILLIAM WILLIAM KAPU ; Dead uts LOS ANGELES INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION . NOTE CONTINUANCES AND FURTHER HEARINGS ARE NOT F^ VORED NAME AND ADDRESS OF PERSONS SIXT _ Datz 5-27-64 5-27-64 : Leonard C. Brokensbire Stearns & Gross 9200 06lims Liebscher Ave. Forw^Gallk Bd Whittier Cal District Armstrong Contracting & Supply 00.4340 Blvd.La90058' Plant Insulation Co.2741 8. Yates ve.IA Co.5933 Telegraph Fiberglass Eng Supply Thorpe Insulation Co.2741 Rd.LL fates Ave.^ A Mudet Cork Corp.6116 Walker Ave. Maywood Cal Accurate Insulation Go.8823 Mottier St. IA90003 Fireman's Fund Ins.C^.Box Ins.C^.Box 232S3 pring Att Shoop Casualty Ins.Co.of Cal.610 S. SpringSt.LA Hission Insurance do.successor to Enterprise Ins.Go.300 S.Kobart Blvd. Astna Cas Surety Co.2404 Wilshire Blvd. Iravelers Ins 00.3600 Wilshire Blvd. LA McLaughlin Kendig & Stockwell CatalinaIA McLaughlin Evans Dalbey & Gimming 6331 Hollywood Blvd.IA90028 Agoodman EIGNATURE OF PERENN DERVING NOTICE PORN 400 ~fiREY65 TOYS ' ve.q10m va alPde ~ aN 5 : . ' . * Yr { @ 807892 807892 807892 - 807892 807892 , HEFORE THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIP CASE NO 63. L.A. 250-245 3 LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE 1 mao Applicant gy 10 12 14 ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND } SUPPLY COMPANT & corporation FLANT INSULATION COMPANY ) MARINE ENGINEERING AND |, SUPPLY COMPANY FIBERGLASS ENGINEERING . d ; AND SUFFIX COMPANY } RESCE INSULATION COMPANY - THORFE INSULATION COMPANY ) MUDET CORK CORPORATION : ACCURATE INSULATION COMPANY ) AETNA CASUALTY & SURETY COMPANY & corpora ) TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY * corporation } FIREMAN'S FUND INSURANCE COMPANY & corporation ) CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY OF . CALIFORNIA & corporation ) ) ENTERPRISE INSURANCE COMPANY . a corporation ; Defendants } GOOD CAUSE APPEARING THEREFOR : ORDER JOINING PARTIES eo, DEFENDANT . : 12 . IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT Plant Insulation Company Marine Engineering and Supply Company Fiberglass Engineering and Supply Company Reece Insulation Company Thorpe Insulation Company Mude Cork Corporation Accurate Insulation Company Fireman's Fund Insurance Company & corporation Casualty Insurance Company of California a corporation and Enterprise Insurance Company & 28 serporation be joined as parties defendant in the above entitled . cause Braves 28 29 RB Braves ; Braves Braves , Baron DATED AT LOS ANGELES CALIFORNIA . 30 Referee COMISIC May 7 1964 . INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSIC _, R^ NN20 Ocneg Hit 10 oe FIQED je SERVED wt 1-6 SERVED GEA os on ERA PbS LINSAZ . om, . i , . . + So ag bee Ee 6 BE oe a A Pad 807893 807893 807893 807893 807893 807893 1 BEFORE THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA BW CASE NO 63 LA 250 245 i Es GL G& 4 KM Applicant w vs. 7 ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY COMPANY a corporation Bet Bet al $ Defendants APPORTIONMENT LIABILITE N FOR SUPPLEMEESTANBLISH I PETITION = PROCEEDINGS TO ESTABLISH LIABILIT'E 19 OF PURSUAPPUUNRRSUSATUNTANT5T5O00.L5ABOR CODE , The Travelers Insurance Company a corporation of said Petition alleges and av^rs as follows , I in support &EVANG ALATW MIRANGIZ FALIORNA SL^ MCLAUGHINATORNEYSNOMATIN DOM~DD 169123975982 ANGELS 91239759829123975982 VICI 1629 LOS 9123975982 alleging asbestos Applicatiwoans filed in the above matter on March 15 injury on February 8 1963 by reason of exposure to 196 resulting in the occupational disease of asbestosis ; II At & hearing upon this application before the Industrial 9123975982 9123975982 Accident Commission at Los Angeles California on July 30 1963 commencing 9122397599822 said application was emended to allege a period of injury February in a 9122397599822 1941 and ending on 8 1963 ' III 229 At a further hearing before the Industrial Accident 229 Commission on July 30 1963 the applicant elected under Labor Code 25 Section 5500.5 to proceed against the last employes Armstrong 0 Contracting and Supply Company and its Insurance Carrier your 2 Petitioner with respect to its period of coverage from April 2 1961 , to January 1963 0 IV . 30 The Industrial Accident Commission issued its Minutes of 31 Further Hearing and Award on November 6 1963 a copy of which is 32 attached hereto and marked Petitioners Exhibic A Your Petitioner 57-64 57-64 be wun * Station np tngnr artanWetebn r wotnet Station Station Station Station Station Station . a eee sermcqama 5 Mat . ~~ @ 1 - 1 has complied and is still complying with the terms of that Award v Based upon the medical evidence filed in the above matter copies of which are attached hereto your Petitioner contends that applicant's injury consists of the industrial disease known as asbestosis asbestosis which is due and caused by applicant's exposure to asbestos during his period of employment employment employment from 1971 to February 8 1963 1941 Vi do 12/13/64 Your Petitioner further alleges that applicant was employed and exposed to asbastos during that period of time by various &EVANS ASATW ENVATSON CALIPOMNA7-170 KA 19797 MOLAUSIENATORNEYGosmatolANGELSHOLYWOD 1909 LOS 298 employers who were insured for workmen's compensation insurance by various insurance carriers as set forth in Exhibit B attached bereto 1 VII That 5500.5 pursuant to Labor Code Section 5500.5 your Petitioner is entitled to a determination by the Industrial Accident Commission with regard to an apportionment of its Liability as well as to 298 right of contribution with respect to payments which it has made 20 20 under the terms of the Commission's Decision of November 6 1963 21 2 WHEREFORE it is requested that a hearing be scheduled in 22 the above matter for the purpose of determining the above issues Dated April 22 1964 . , ' 2 Respectfully submitted MCLAUGHLIN EVANS DALBEY & CUMMING ByFFuu Fu 0 0 2 Actorneys for Petitioner 0 0 0 0 0 32 2 2 2 . . oy 968408 968408 968408 968408 968408 OF OF EMPLOYEMM PLE OYN MET NT Plant Insulation Co. _ 2741 5. Yates Avenue Los Angeles Calif Marine Engineering and Supply address unknown FiberSupplyglass Engineering and 5933 Telegraph Road Los Angeles Calif Reece Insulation Company address unknown Plant Insulation Company Thorpe ^ venua Company ThorpeS. Insulation Yates Los Angeles Calif Corporation Muder Cork 6116 Walker Avenue Maywood California Accurate Insulation so. 8823 Martier Street Los Angeles 3 Calif 1941 to April 1950 . t { April 1950 to December 1952 ADuegceumsbter19155952 to 1955 to July 1956 March March 1957 to October 1959to October 1959 to April 1961 Corporation Supply Armstrong Contract and SupplyDistrict Boulevard 1961 April co February 1963 INSURANCE CARRI unknown unknown Aetna Gasualty and Surety Company Fireman's Fund Insurance Company Aetna Casualty and Surety Company Casualty Insurance Company of Califor and Enterprise Ins Company Travalers Insuranc Company and ^ stna Casualty and Suzet Company eereet EXHIBIT B oh I a . an : 807896 807896 - 807896 807896 807896 OF CALIFCOALRIFNORINIAA COUNTY OF }es . BAETE Evans one of e bedag duly minem depanas and maya _de CONCES OF RECORD ; at the m^"kinand abesa anailed ession t^et de k^lder Apportionment Apportionment of Liability and Richt of Contribution Pursuant to Apportionment Ap ortionment Section 5500.5 and Amerso che kom that the mouer le t^'t^' his . sza kstensiqiye moramo on to the mothers allek are theres mated amounusu bis Information and bellef and an to blode matars thes h 12belii t toebevwe ra Salmaribed and mean to betere nos dayday them pull pull 277 ( . , Resary Pubito in and for vald Commey and Stora AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL 1013 C.P. be STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF . CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE SY MAN - 10154 P. 2 biting a residdielnyt of the county that is oferesolt a a effmy cititra of lathoeveUrnithteeadStagtese of vighteen years and is not party so mithis bar melded cheer eddraga karisma is \ cSuersrsiokeBsar otac of Californiira couenesteklein tmheimsbceraoufsatnehed ses a party Lhurste and that h 3 That Canton sesr ervedvthe e mid skin 25 on the In sold plabcy ipln acigng a tras cspy therest macloved 2 in sueled moalape with postage chorvus jully propell in the United States post offci nal ber ^ 2 addreassfsole lod ws 2 3 Afland's signataraj . 3 Subscribed and men to before me ^ it 2 day af 19 Abomey at lave SBAL Rowery Publie in and for said County Califorada Fisk cerd^zatael service sas budinaus address endy unless business address and residence or the sema Be ON seni Ra * 807897 THE I BEFORE THE INDUSTRIAL a on ACCIDENT COMMISSION OF CASE NO 63 L. A. 250-245 STATE OF CALI70 $ & . 5 8 & 9 . 10 hh IS 14 9 9 2 y LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE . } , f Applicant J YE a a } . MINUTES OF FURTHER HEANINO : AND . AWARD . ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY COMPANY & corporation & SURETY AEINA CASUALTY SURETY COMPANY & corporation TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY a corporation _ Defendants dQ. } - j j j . REI INSA THIS CAUSE came on for hearing this 4th day of November 19t nine a.m. in Department 7 of the Industrial Accident Commission Los Angeles California before Honorable RICHARD BARRY Referee M. A. McNeal Court Reporter 2 PRESENT: 9 Leonard Charles Brokenshire applicant applicant applicant 8 Stearns & Gross by Richard Gross attorneys for 2 Joseph Bilchak representative for Travelers 0 Weingand Kendig Stockwell & Callanan attorneys for Aetna by E. Kendig 0 2 3 2 - & 28 0 2 FFo orr mJitm D~SHEYVA AR D~ YAR VA WITNESSES None ( None EXHIBITS Applicant's 1 - Reports attached to and listed in transmitta letters of 4/22/63 and 10/30/63 EDGAR4/8/63 Defendants A Report10/30/63 HURLEY report 10/16/63 P. MAUER M.D L. MOTLEY M.D 3/13/63 report report report 4/8/63 4/4/63 EDGARF. MAUER M.D CHESTER P. BONOFF M.D JOSEPH SCHMERLER M.D. 3pp ret a Mokke ME 80789 fl IT IS STIPULATED BY AND BETWEEN THE PARTIES PREARESPERESNEN L. That Leonard Charles Brokenshire born July 9 1907 wa YH employed by Armstrong Armstrong Contracting and Supply Company & corporat fF as an asbestos working foreman at Los Angeles California duris - period that began in 1941 and continued to and including myr 9 10 10 12 99599 February 8 1963 2. That said employer's insurance cartier during the pario that began April 3 1961 and ended December 31 1962 wRS Travelers Insurance Company a corporation and that the carrier during the period that began January 1 1963 to and including February 8 1963 the last date of applicant's employment was Aetna Casualty and Surety Company a corporation 3. That applicant's employment during the period of covera by Travelers Insurance Company and Aetna Casualty and Surety Company contributed to applicant's asbestosis which constitutes an injury which arose out of and occurred in the course of his said employment 4. That applicant's earning capacity at the time his sald injury culminated in disability was in excess of the maximum 5. That all medical treatment has been furnished 6. That said injury resulted in temporary disability that began February 9 1963 and ended June 9 1963 entitling the applicant to payments at the rate of 70.00 per week during said period less the sum of 250.00 that has already been paid 7. That applicant's condition is now permanent and stations 9 59 indemnity 8 That applicant has permanent disability as the result of said injury that is equal to 62 of total which is equal to 248 weeks of permanent disability at the rate of 52.50 pei week or a total sum of 13,020.00 payments to begin June 17 19 3 9. That applicant is in need of further medical treatment s PRM 338 omitg Gat irom Bay -2- - oem : og a tae . ket et Ob3 l way i ae aay . . . at Ee atyt ae , / 80789 1"entitled to have it furnished to him by the defendant insura H carriers for the balance of his life a 20 That the payments and the further treatment will be Compeny e furnished by Travelers Insurance Aetna Casualty and . & Surety Company agreeing to reimburse Travelers Insurance Company &@ in such amounts as they agree to adjust between themsalves 2 11. That Travelers Insurance Company and Aetna Casualty and Surety Company reserve their right to proceed against defendant employers and insurance carriers who are not present in order to assert their contribution rights based on the allegation that . applicant's exposure extended over a period of time not covered by the insurance coverage of either of the present defendant insurance carriers and that this aspect of the case is to be considered as taken off calendar at this time to await the fil^r of adequate allegations and the joinder of all necessary parties defendant ; 12. That an Angrd may be made a part of the Minutes and be filed as such without the necessity of any further compliance wi the provisions of Labor Code Section 5313 DISPOSITION N Submitted A Ba AR AR D AWARD is made in favor of Leonard Charles Brokenshire again Travelers Insurance Company a corporation Aetna Casualty and . FORK 339 oa eis 1b Petal kl 1 ge eo Surety Company & corporation to a reimbupr ors tioen to thereof Travelers Insurance accoir n daca con rdc ane ce with the understanding set forth hereinbefore in the sum of 13,020.00 together with interest as provided by lar payable to applicant at the rate of 52.50 per week beginninogn June 17 1963 plus temporary disability indemnity for the period February 9 1963 and ending 70.00 being June 9 1963 at the rate of sums entitled to credit for all per week defendants beretofore paid on account of temporary disability indemnity plus further medical treatment for the balance of his life less the sum of 500.00 to be paid directly to applicant's attorneys as the reasonable value of the * Berv1988. Rebar INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION 2592 30 PORN G99 1,40 1919 APP 1,40 Az llahallha alla ~, in 7 . tos . rl aA ; 807901 807901 807901 807901 | CASE NO 63 L. A. 250-249 LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE - wk . LAMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUREL COMPANY & corporation ANTENA CASUALTY & SURETY COMPANY & corporation TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY & corporation REFEREE HEARING DICTATED NOV. 4 198.3 NOV 4 1963 oe / eo : 1941 endin 1963 1941 andand . Feb. 8 - Stearns & Gross by Richard Gross attorneys for applicant ~ Joseph Bilchek representative for Travelers Weingand Kendig Stockwell & Callanan by E. Kendis attorneys for ^stna . REFEREE'S NIEMORANDUM ON FURTHER HEARING The applicant has proceeded against the last employer who had two insurance carriers The parties were able to enter into stipulations that permitted an Award all as reflected in the Minutes The stipulated rating was substantially based on Dr. Mauer's description of the restrictions that applicant apparently has It was recognized that applicant has a progressive disease and that his permanent disability may increase in the future However it is permanent in the sense that it is ipraversible The insurance carriers who have liability by reason of the stipulation will proceed against other defendants in a supplemental proceedings in order to assert their rights of contribu- DISPOSITION Submitted MMC RICHARD BARRY _ REFEREE ow . - Cote . f. Mek Sayre _~ ~ 807902 a CASE NO 63 Lo k 250-245 LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE REFEREE RICHARD BARRY HEARING JULY 30 1963 DICTATED JULY 30 1963 VS. ; . ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY CO AEINA CASUALTY AND SURETY COMPANY & corporation TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY & corporation ALLEGED INJURY Beginning in 1941 February . and February , 1963 = Stearns & Weingand attorneys Gross Kendis for Aetna by Richard Gross attorneys for applicant Stockwell & Callanan by E. Kendig Casualty and Surety EREE'S MEMORANDUM ON HEARING In his application as amended at the time of this hearing tl the applicant alleges injury to his lungs by reason of exposure_to exposure_to asbestos during a period that began in 1941 and ended 2/8/63 The Aetna Casualty applicant alected to proceed against the last employer Armstrong Contracting and Supply Company However the case could not go forward because and Surety Company did not have all of the coverage of the last employer They admitted coverage beginning in January of 1963. Their information is that Travelers Insurance Company had coverage from April 2 1961 which is the beginning date of applicant's employment with the said last employer and up until the time Aetha's coverage began Travelers Insurance Company was therefore joined as a party defendant No other insurance carriers were joined because the informa- tion with respect to the prior employers as set forth in applicant's attorneys letter of 4/25/63 is quite sparse Apparently Fiberglas Engineering and Supply Company was absorbed by Corning Fiberglas8 and their carrier was the defendant Aetna Aetna also insured Mudet Cork Corporation Apparently Casualty Insurance Company of California and Enterprise Insurance Company were the carriers for Accurate Insula tion Company None of the prior employers were joined at this time They will be joined at a later date if liability is established against the last employer whose insurance carrier as a matter of asserting their rights to contribution can then proceed against the other em- ployers and their carriers Dr. Schmerler in a First Report Of Injury diagnosed a chronic emphysema and fibrosis Apparently he has been the attending physician His bill in the sum of 159.50 will be paid by Aetna Applicant's Dr Hoffmann indicated a diagnosis of possible asbestosis Defendant Aetna's Dr. Mauer diagnosed pulmonary fibrosis that is probably secon- dary to industrial exposure to asbestos He recommends further tests including respiratory function tests and Aetna will see that they are made Meanwhile Aetna will also make a monetary advance to applicant disability began His claimed period of temporary 2/8/63 and ended 6/10/63 He is now working as an estimator for an asbestos firm A copy application and a will be served on better advised of this memorandum copy of applicant's Travelers Insurance together with a copy attorneys letter of Company so that they : of the 4/25/63 will be MMC DISPOSITION Continued to be reset for one full day not before two months from this date FILED SERV ^ E <D 6363wee EE EEA EE ERA INS CL__ INSA N. CL__ SUIF oO ; RICHARD BARRY REFEREE * , . , | a . | 807903 807903 _ 807903 807903 807903 "! , ~ sa ~ ae OF 5 } : 4 ~ KUAT ET HOFFMANN M.D. ZYLDERAKER MEDICAL GENTEN QUITE 16 1818 STU^ SKRAKERADAM NORWALL CALIFORNIA UNANLASITY d1o d1o PU + Pea t e ia Soa . Stearns & Groes Attorneys at Law 9200 Colima RdWhittier./Calif Whittier./Calif Re Leonard Charles Brokenshira ' Dear Sir . . On the 11.20 196M2r. B.C. Brokenshire came the first time to my office complaining about pain in his chest especially on hi left side After examining the Pat the diagnosis was U.R.I. chi vulmonary fibrosis poss asbestosis B.P.was 120/82 Because of his vain on the left side EKQ was taken.Findings taken.Findings Chests Iray taken 11-29-62 in Studebaker Hospital 13100 Studebaker Rd.i Norwalk showed the following impression The changes are those of extreme chronic pulmonary disease manifested by fibrosis and emph sema The possibility of an occupational process must be seriousl considered ; . The second and last time I saw Pat in my office office on the 11 of December 1962. He had slighly improved.He was told changing of his job would be advisable to furthermore improve his condition Yours very truir Hust De t Me pe OMIT MES TET Yat ae Tet a ; oom JOBKAN J. SCHMERLER M. D. F.C.C.F. LAINITA MEDICAL CENTER 19994 SOUTH OLARK AVENU ; - BELLFLATWOR CALIPERSUL^ CALIPERSUL^ Poesde FOI pAS. Varok 4 1963 SO WHOM ISS HAY CONGREN Ha Leonard Brokenshire Mr. Leonard Brokenshire ves examined - me me on February 25 1963 and on March 4 1963. Is suffers from marked euphysem and possible chrezio ambestosis of the lungs Patient la dyspnsac on walking at moderate peas and severely drapeso vhan usllsing feat of ellabing stairs However he is comfortable slowly siting sitting standing or walking Brokenshire Kr is definitely partially disabled and is unable to perform his previous duties which included climbing ladders while beavily weighted Rehabilitation of this patient for a different occupation is definitely necessar a t JJS D. Ae! Dy Joseph T merlar M. / , / o . 7 . 807905 807905 807905 807905 ae U.SC. CARDIO- BROKENSHIRE Ty | Lannard C. 1 LOS ANGELES 17. CALIFORNIA PULMONARY FUNCTION STUDIES 5080 October 16 1963 . Dr. Edgar F. Maue three The total vitali capacity supine vas decreased in marked degree The time vital capacity for seconds was decreased in a marked degree and slightly Less than the total vital capacity observed standing The maximal breathing capacity mas decreased in a marked degree The rezimal breathing sapucity was increased from 78.8 to 112.7 .litors p^rminute after one bronchodilator treatme with Isupral indicating the presence of a moderate degree of bronchospasm The shape forted spirogram of the exhulation exhulation tracing reveals a vary slight withoutwithout evidence of air trapping prolongation of the rapid Inspiratory time on the 55.6 . rap pirogram is prolonged indicating expabity for 0.5 seconds was 1494 ml loss of lung elasticity The timed vit of the observed total vitul capaci The pined vatul espacity for 10 seconds was 2475 ml 92.5 of the ces observed total vital capscity normal The residual air was measured both by open circuit and the helium closed circuit methods and found to be decreased slightly The total lung capacity was decreased in a marked degree The modey factor occupies ratie normal predicted values resiad iruoacclupies 34.9 of total lung increase in ratie above the capecity as decreased in a moderate to marked degree and representsa slight The ventilati ventilati The ventilation factor is the average of the timed vital capacity for three seconds the maxical breuthin caparity the and the residual percent of the total lung capacity all bucks of the normal predicted value The alveolar nitrogen was expressed on 1.15 after breathing oxygen for 5 minutes normal The nitrogen washout curve was obtaine . with continuous recordings of each broath on oxygen breathing on the nitrogen matel a total time of 4.5 minutes was required to reduce the and tidal nitr gen wo The shape of the nitrogen washout curve is smooth and uniform The nor with nitrogen forced washout is to an end tidal of % exhalation the alveolar should not or less within 5 minutes and exceed 1.55 The nitrogen was out this case with the nitrogen meter indicates normal air distribution in t lungs . moderate oxygensaturation arterial blood moderate to marked decrease , at rest was 91.9 on air breathing a 90.0 with step axercise a marked decreas exercise saturation was The repeated at miles per hour fast with a walking on the treadmill in a steady state grade on air breathing and found to be 50 the as with the stop exercise With intermittent pressure breathing positive exercise till on compressed air only at reat the saturation was 96.2 normal Th exercise was repeated at 1.5 miles per hour with< a 23 grade on 32-75 oxygen breathing increasing the inspired p0s from 146.9 on air breathin to 231.2 on Hg and with this laval of oxygen breathing the saturation wea 96.2 normal 97 or more After breathing 100 oxygen the saturation of the arterial blood was 99.7 the CO2 content 46.6 vols percent and the pH 7.45 T CO2 content on air breathing was decreased slightly both at rest and with exer- 150 dise 14.59 The arterial blood The hemoglobin was pill was normal at rest and increased alightly with exe grams based on oxygen capacity measurement and further checked with the Deckman DU Spectrophotometer cyanmethemoglobin method The heciatocrit was 46.45 *- wate ye ee PO 807906 JOSEPH J. SCHMERL^ AM. F.QQ.P. LAAMDEN MEINGIA GENTER 16986 BOUTS BLANK AVENUE SELLFLOWER CALIFOSSMA Vigastn Pete March 4 1963 * TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN Bet Leonard BrokenshiBrrokeneshire Mr. Leonard una Brokenshire azamined me me on February 25 1963 and on March 4 1963. Ko suffere from marked suphysens and possible ohranio asbestosis of the lungs Patient is dy yasanon valking at a moderate pass and severaly dyermeso when walking fast or climbing stairs However he is comfortable sitting standing or walking slowly ; Mr. Brokanehire is definitaly partially disabled and is unable to perform his previous duties which included climbing ladders while heavily weighted Rehabilitation of this patient for s necessar necessar different occupation is definitely Oo. ( Schwerler ww ww J. K. Joseph f Schwerler JJ5 _ f _ 807907 KURT O. HOFFMANN M.D. STUDEBAKER MEDICAL CENTER 10 AUITE - 18126 STUDERAICEN AZAD NOB NOB CALIFORNIA CALIFORNIA ' UHIVEAGIT adj . Fam PTX om ... ... April 17.1963 e Stearns & Oroas Attorneys at Law 9200 Colima Rd Whittier./Calif Whittier./Calif Re Leonard Charles Brokenshire , Dear Sir : . ; On the 11.20-1962 Nr L.C. Brokenshire came the first time to my office complaining about pain in his chest especially on his left side After examining the Pat the diagnosis was U.R.I. chro Tulmonary fibrosis poss asbestosis B.P.was 120/32 Because of his sain on the left side EKG was taken.Findings Chests ~ Iray taken 11-29-62 in Studebaker Hospital 13100 Studebaker Rd.in . Norwalk showed the following impression The changes are those of extreme chronic pulmonary disease manifested by fibrosis and emphy- ' sema The possibility of an occupational process must be seriously considered The second and last time I saw Pat in my office on the 11 of December 1962. He had slighly improved.He was cold changing of his job would be advisable to furthermore improve his condition Tours very truly Vast Auffie m~, , / ie] ... 807908 | . EDG^ RP. MA^ ERMO 1920 WiCSHRIRH { an LQ018YARB LQ018YARB . 101 ILS October 30 1963 * 57 ALIFORNIA ~ Aetna Casualty & Surety Company 2404 Wilshire Blvd. Los Angeles 53 Calif^rnia Attn Ray Skoney Res Leonard Brokenahire - ver Asastrong Construction Co. Gentlement . Pulmonary fustion studies ware done by Dr. Hotley on October 16 1963 These studies reveal abnormal findings characteristic of pulmonezy fibrosis The figures reveal a moderate reduction in pulmonary fune tion It is obvious that this reduced function is due to the patholo gical changes noted by examination and particularly by the ray have been regarded as due to the inhalation of asbestos fibers These On the basis of these studies it is my belief that Mr. Brokenshire could be employed at an occupation which did not involve a degree of exertion which would cause shortness of breath In other words & 5 sedentary job which involves an ordinary amount of walking about an office or even about an open site on level ground would not cause any difficulty Any axertion such as climbing ladders or climbing stairs might produce dyspnea and discomfort although this would not increase the severity of the disease at this time Any work pre- . scription should also insure the avoidance of insulating materiale particularly asbestos and fine dusts This implies that his condi- tion has not changed since the last examination April 14 1963 Asbestosis is a progressive disease It is likely that the degree of pulmonary fibrosis will progress in the coming years The lesions is permanent it is in all likelihood progressive but at this time it is not totally disabling as indicated above Should any question azise following the receipt of this report please do call upon D Yours sincerely EFM hj Edgar F. Hauer K. D. , oe Le sa at oy % tetas a 5080 "2 807909 Loe The pulmonary ventilation measurements at rest reveal a normal minute ventilati^n a sormal oxygen uptake and a alight decrease in the percent of oxygen expected from the inspired air breathed The RE when calculated on th basis of the resting oxygen uptake was +0.27 of his normal predicted value Wi step exercise the minute ventilation was within the normal range the oxygen uptake was decreased in a moderate to marked degree and the percent of oxygen extracted from the inspired air breathed decreased in a soderate degree time was not prolonged after one minute of step exercise Dyspo exercise ef ective effective 75.or Direct tension dessurements of arterial blood at rest geyaal a poo 36.6 mm Hg normal 40 and a p-- eof 80.5 m g normal 95 The tidal air at rest based on the expired p00 and the arterial p002 was 66.15 normal 75.or moral Vith treadmill in a steady state at 1.5 miles p hour 77.4 with a 2 the artpe CO r wasi 35a .5 mlm lig and the arterial PO2 77.4 mme Kg The effective tidal sir with the treadmill exercise was 72.8 capacity beseen beseen the expired and the arterial p002 normal 75 or more The carbon monotide diffusing capacity measurement at rest was 5.58 and with step GIBT 18.31 CO uptake ce per minute por m Hg alveolar p00 Our normal valuba voldalya tast from 8 to 20 st rest and from 20 to 50 with step exercise The tast was obtained with direct recording of the brachial artery pulse and this test was essentially normal.a The average blood pressure as recorded directly from the brachial artery at rest supine vas as follows systic 132 disstolic 62 and mean 80 mm Hg summary the pulmonary function studies reveal the absence of emphysema ag significant factor in case There is a marked reduction in the total epocity indiecting & restrictive condition of the chest and lungs most aristic of fibrosis The spirogram reveals no significant obstructive factor for the rapid forced exhalation A moderate degree of bronchospasm was decorated as best indicated the increase in the maximal breathing capacit by after no presit presit no bronchodilator treatment with Isupral There is significant hypoxia both at rest and with exercise The resting hypoxia was corrected with pozIntermittent positive pressure breathing on compressed air only indicating the presince of poorly ventilated areas However it can be noted that the arterie by direct tension geasurement is higher proportionately then the arterial blood oxygen saturation based on Tan Slyke measurements of oxygen content and . XyB papacity This would indicate the perfussion of some blood through non- . ventilated areas a characteristic finding in fibrosis Also it can be noted that ren on a high level of oxygen breathing 32.75 oxygen there was a decrease with exercise The carbon dioxide is being blown off adequately decreque in the exercise oxygen uptake in this case indicates the presence sligi The of increased pulmonary vascular resistance and the inability to increase the pulmor ary blood flow corresponding to the decree of exercise gis This again is a fairly common finding in restrictive conditions of the chest and lungs as best demonstrated in this case by the decrease in the total lung capacity These studies would be consistent with hypoxia resulting from the fibrosis which also increases pulmonary vascular resistance and the inability to expand the pulmonazy vascular bed in the normal manner corresponding to the cild exercise given These findings would indicate the presance of a severe degree of pulmonery function impairment ao . . HIM Z. , Burley Z. Z. Katley M.D. Director * | . 807910 HESPIRATORY LABORATORIV.S.C. SCHOOL OF MEDICINE and the Hospital of the Good Samaritan 1212 Shatto St. Los Angeles Calif _ NO5080 BSA 2.11 DATE LUNG VOLUME MEASUREMENTS BTPS Predicted * Observed L. SPIROGRAM RECORDINGS . VITAL CAPACITI Supine pl wee - 2637 Standing al 1925 aa : 2810 OCR 14. 1961 ( Normal 6.7 59.5 VITAL CAPACITY Standing TIMED sec . 1725 Standing min MAXIMAL BREATHING CAPACITY ... 4725 Before Bronchodilator Standing 147.0 #After Bronchodilator.Isuprel 147.0 7 2931 78.8 78.8 112.7 57.6 62.0 53.6 76.7 Intrapulmonary 2. RESIDUAL SUFINE MEASUREMENTS Test of Intrapulmonary Mixing Alv K = 1.1 after 5 min Residual Air aloe 1437 Residual Total Lung Capacity A Vital TLC ml 6300 he Residual Air % of .... 28, Bis? Zs2 65 12601 Predicted 1. OXYGEN CONTENT VOL ........ 19.0 20.0 Observed 18.2186.26 icted Observed a 18.32 2. OLIGEN SAIURATION Fanoood 966 91.9 964 a 3. CO CONTENT VOL ..... 48.5 4. P/ GLASS ELECTRODE 7.40-45 7.40-45 466 7.44 ne 48.548.5 46.0 7.40-45 7.40-45 7.47 5. HEMOGLOBIN ... _ 14.5 the 59 15.2 14.95 14.95 6. HEMATOCRIT ....... 45.0 LDeh 42.1 PULMONARY VENTILATION MEASUREMENTS : RESPIRATIONS VENTILATION VENTILATION 3 min....sq. l 14- 2214-22 4100 2.6-3.8 18.5 3.56 3. OXIGEN UPTAKE ml min sq.m . EXTRACTED FROM BSA 120-115 120-15 120-115 . 4. OXYGEN% EXTRACTEDFROM INSPIRED AIR BREATHED soo 56 445 445 127 3.5 ; 20-30 8-10.5 500-600 5-6 21.0 O14. : _4_ 08 47 47 EXERCISE ONE MINUTE STEP UP TEST (_ 21 Duration of Dyspnea Dyspnea 42 ) Steps on Stool 8 in High sec Normal 90 sec or less BTFS Body Temperature Barometr essure Saturated Standard Temp tot. wits ag new @@ Mame Curualty & Surety Company | April 8 1963 t HISTORY CONTINUED = -2- Rat Mc Lechard Brokenebira his retutrona donty occupation Prior to November 1982 he wES mure of shortness of breath Promingup end dem Ladders perhape for the last five years He also noted this on sexiss Ha donu ot g douh gh His miles do not svall He has a sense of emstriction around the lower chest noted mainly in bed If he works in his garden this sense of constriction is noted Fehet nightnight He has nevar coughed up blood He was one pilles at He stopped smoking six or seven years ago because of distaste Na vas not instructed to do se PAST HISTORY He was born in Arizons He came to Long Beach at the age of nine and then to s^Mago where he lived util he had finished - the ninth grade Then he wear to work at Whiting Head in the Sash and boor Department Next ha was in pipe Lins constructim | for Richfield for a short time and later worked as a casual working Laborer Ta 1927 he started with insulation for a marine engineer He did this for two or three years md then worked in the oil fields agaia Baginning in 1937 he began to work steadily in the insulation field He was laid off during the var but has been at this trade steadily since 1941. He has worked with various forms of asbestos and with styrofoam Re garding the latter he was recently informed that there is a gan released when this material is cut This gay he says is a mactica product of the bubbling process which forms it PAST = ILLNESS F^'tient states he has always been healthy He tells his doctor that he is tired and can't seem to breathe wall He took soms pills that made him dizzy so be stopped taking them Yesterday he started on what sounds like IPPB therapy MARITAL MARITAL HISTORY - He has been 21 His wife has been ill for a married for years living long time He has one son age 14 and well Arm meee oe ~ 2 2 ' 4 at. . ot . , } et yo 3 807912 807912 807912 807912 Me ewmirimmemermin 807912 Aetna Casualty & Surety Coupeny - Rat Lecard Brakesskise April, 1963 ma, | FANIL HISTORY ~ His mother died omcer at ageKving wall of 60 His father died at age 85 = Fold aga Two brothers and one sister are and No family history of tuberculosis hypertension or diabetes SYSTEMS ' Central Nervous SysteNmo syncope Eyes Vision is good He wears glasses for reading . Bare Tose and threer ~ Infrequent colds No history of arthme Respiratory history asthma or pneumonia - See above No of bronchitis feels Intestinal Occasionally he sicknes but he gives no specific rectal system constipa- tion , bleeding op melanz on the verge offsea Ne constipa- Urinary No dysuris nosturia blood or stones nourisheddoes position and he EXAMINATION = Mr. Brokanshire is a well developed well white man in no pain or distrass His coloirs good not cough He is comfortable in the supine Height 73 1/2 with shoes Weight 203 1/2 lbs with Indoor clothing Blood pressure 150/90 . SKULL AND SCALENIMBRANES Negative SKIN AND KUCOUS Ss = The pupils sacommodation equal react NIMBRANESround Clear are round regular sacommodation to light and ~ Not obstructed THROAT Claar THROAT No thyroid enlargement or adenopathy THORAX 1 Symmetrical The expansion is fairly good THORAX Heart Symetrical The beart does not appear to be enlarged The tones are of good quality regular in rete and zhythm There are no thrills or murwuLTY ae 807913 Aetna Canualty & Suraty Company April 6 1983 ote : Lecuard Brokanabire . 1 * * GHYSICAL EXAMINATION CONTINUED = Lunge = The lungs era resment Breath sounds are sorawhat . suffled No males heaorrd is no ABDOMEN - Hodesetely chase Ko sasses There wheezing tenderders IES He clubbing He deformity or Unitation of motion There is no edama of the lextremities lextremities Urinalysia The urine is yalles and slightly cloudy Spacifi Gravity 1.017 pH 7.5 Albummin negativa Sugur negativa . Hierd scopic Rara red call occasional white call for epithelial cells no casts , Blood Count 6300 Hemoglobin 14.2 grees or 91 Beurocrit ast White coat 6300 Differencial Neutrophils 544 Eosinophils 64 Lymphocytes 354 Konocytes $ Sedimentation ret^'20 m hour These are normal values, excepting for the alevation of the sedimentatien rete The electrocardiogram is within normal limits Chest ray reveals bilateral inflammation more pronounced in the bases with old pleural reaction A copy of Dr. Bonoff's report is enclosed : DIAGNOSIS Pulmonary fibrosis probably secondary to industrial exposure to sabestos 20 COMMENT According to the history given by Mr. Brokenshire he has had mild symptoms of shortness of breath for approximately five years prior to the acute onset of shortness of breath which occurred in November 1962. In view of the work history of handling insulating materials since 1941 it is necessary to | ati 8 wees -- on . War ra lea SE ED Oe De A oR 807914 wb Casualty Astrie Ap il8 1963 & Surety Company -5- Mar Lecard Brokenshira . COMMENT CONTINUED ox considehirs pulmmary Issicuass due to occupational exposust It woulbde necessary therefore to determine what the pracise Beties of exposure to substances adversely affecting the lung had been ^ syou know certain saboef ssat beo sts os do produce chronic pulsonary lesion known as asbestosis H. Brekenshire does not cough on raise sputum therefore it La not possible to search for asbestos broin n hc ish bri onca hil al ^ of a sinqautainotnitoaftisveecosencodndaarryy carcarddiiacapcuilnmovnoalrvyemdeinstsbcioullidtybeanudsiadbeytri performing respiratory function studies at the Pulmonary Function Laboratory under the direction of Dr. Motley at the Hospital of the Good Sammican At the present time it is cartzio that there should be no further exposure to subsemees capable of causing pulmonary fibrosis At the present time on the basis of information availabis the pulmonary lasions found here must be regarded 48 occupationaL Thank you for the privilege of examining this BEN Yours sincerely Exulaner egz enel Edgar F. Kaser M.D. - 8 et vm J : ' . won wn : pe Le LTS pe Sine ARNG 807915 807915 807915 807915 807915 woes 807915 CHEATER P. BONOPR M. ^ OB~WILD S^ NGAVADU S^ NGAVADU LOG BE CALIFO CAt LIa FOn ta^ n^ 85318 Leonard Brokeashiro Dr Edg F. Mams Apri4l 1963 Rosatgen ezamination of the chest reveals a made atesemmi- pateky accentuation of the markings throughout bath lung falde sparing nomewhat the left upper lobe region Several of the areas of involvement show sazzi~ whatmodular change particularly in the right upper lobe and at the left base There is diffuse centration of the raticular pattern throughout the right lung ac- fleid and the lower half of the left lung field Rather marked pleural thickming is present along the lateral chest wall on the at the left base There alse appears to be right and In the pleural in the some calcification with portion of the left lung field interally There appears to be slight flattening of the diaphragms particularly the left The cardiac shadow is within normal Umits of size shape The ^ ilaraad mediastinal areas show no gross absormalaintdy IMPRESSION I Old pleural thickening 2 Chronic inflammatory process involving bath lung Helde The possibility that this Vepresents one of the pasumedoniases Cansot be excluded Thanking you for the reference of this case am oo sincerely a om CPB bs 807910 } 807910 : ' 1. . Wilshire Lol AWIKIA GASULITY & SUREUY CC 2404 DOCTOR'S FIRST REPORT Blvde 54 OF WORK INJURY COMPENSATION a STATE 1150.basedately afterfirst examinatie mall one cosy Ofvision Leber States its famarch Q. Bes 965 San Francisca Pa^fiat repou rt wr ithn the queas ll t quesi tioo ns n fuls ly Division is misdansanne Laber Code Sections 6407-4413 a tal, Name other doemes examination treated 2/25/65 for H. H. IL ACCIDENT OR EXPOSURE Did employen nocify employer of this tajury aKeoplayes's wesc __ af cams of * injory or flinczer Patient worked for many years in construction construction construction company handling asbestos NATURI EXTENT bjostive AND 12. OF INJURY OR DISEASE dadalo l bjostive Endings et cesar ensopatianel ^ ltouryand empeceAL Chronic emphysema & Abrosis of lungs complainan dinanasen met 11. ayu By whom kan i^ Mhia offios , Fladinga : Chronic emphysem & fibrosis of lungs 14. TreatmentES General bygiane IFP trakteants of Fi. 15. Kind cass boke O ag kempital Nem and address of 1 lxxpicalbred datiemLITIE i Inimesed may may 16. Further washisant Recensed fro 17. Ertimated period of disability for Regular work_6_mantha_ work_6_mantha_ an Modified work ana ern tty 18. Describe any permanent disability or disfigurement disfigurement expected work_6_mantha_ an Exrient Exrient hilhill he unania unania Sell Plame I'll work 85 SZEFLAUSIT SZEFLAUSIT 19. El death ensued give date REMARES New any caloriag injuriteinjurite or dirunasa noval for iperial aestimating er lateracary two other pertineau information 1 a Zz ONLY UNDER EXCEPTIONAL PRIOR TO SHOULD A CIRCUMSTANCES WILL HERNIA ^ CONSIDERED DISABLING IF INJURED EXCEPTIONAL CIRCUMSTANCES CIRCUMSTANCES WORK POSSIBLE NOTIFIED CLADSACCEPTED + ACCEPTED Joseph Sahmanlar THAT HIS Nama ( 727 dreta dreta Digter n BCGNATURE 4 if OPERATION OPERATION CL^A'DS fie z Date of reporte BAS 3/83 Addieecs STUFSFTUFF 16704 5. Clark uve., Bellflower __Tel No_1017-7748 FOOD LA Use reverse side if more space required . obpat 190 90d TO oro Ps . . . ' Aes Soe: ~ : t ee Ben Dae a a EERE 3 cat 807910 807910 807910 807910 807910 807910 A^ TRIA CASUALTY + & SUNY C. 2404 Wilshire ^/lvd Lado Sie DOCTOR'S FIRST REPORT Lado - OF WORK THUJURY INSURANCE STATECOMPENSATION FUND A150 Immoskato yefter first date mill was copy BOXISK LOS Statistics Research Feibarea report with the Division in a miedemanas Labor Coda Sparinaa 6407-6413 Aarwer all questions fully L. Armstrong Constmation Ca. Cal 2. Address Eph 7 Sea Franchina i g 3 Business ( Felt 4. EMPLOYEE JANE Leonard 1. Address EMPLOYEE 6. Occupation 7. Das injured..m a Asbestos vorken House . I8. nInjured juyorur efirdst 5/25/63 5/25/63 Host Fukapshira E ce VACY 959500 M De waskad 2/3/63 Comssy uke M Whapped Whapyepared ?. Sn ef ant . 10. Nema ocher doctors who creased employes for this injury 11. ACCIDENT OR EXPOSURE Did employce nocify employer of this injury Employee's star of cense . of injury or IllneserPatient worked for handling asbestos many partisn construction construction construction company = das ovine INJURY OR Include fadings rabjandra 12. NATURE AND EXTENT OF If compted Gad^nspakar daar of sexans enposione OR DISEASE and expovzna objective ' Chronic emphysema ^ Fibrosis of lungs aupluses and diaprasa 1 rayn By whom cakan ms anzust i his ofioe Findings Obronic emphysema & fibrosis of lungs 14. TreacmanEY General hygiene ISFB treatments 7 of Offic 15. Kinmd as 10 Name and Addrem of kospital If bospitalized darn : Regular 16. Further wasumeit kospital disbility kospital 17. Estimated period of disbility for work mondba 18. Describe any parmanent diFsuablillitywoorrdkisfigurement expected 1982 as amayionglamayyiongly 19. If death emngi iveedd art Estimated stay_ Medified work sorts Resident will buenable to : naaminating 10. REMARKS New my icing injurias or dismen noni fur special ' perzin e informaudan informaudan er laboratory laboratory terti other perzinne ) . Z POSSIBLE CIRCUMSTANCES CIRCUMSTANCES N. ONLY UNDER EXCEPTIONAL WILL A HERNIA THE INJURED SHOULD BE ADVISETDO CONTINUS WORE IF A^ CONSIDERED UNTIL NOTIFIED THAT ACCEPTED Laragh Echmanlar Degree N Degre Degree CLADE LaraghLaragh Echmanlar ei f PERSONAL Y LW SIGNATURE J seidtcner Datoaf report 3/13/63 Addreer Day 15704 5. Clark 138 DISABLINO ? PRIORTO ISOAPCECREAPTTEIDO_N,, ae: ___Tal 7-7248 Potu LA if Use reverse side if more space required . woes 1-44 1-44 1-44 oy wee mee led , en ww? . Pia we AREER, bites, RE AR co Pa, 807917 . "as, ) 807917 807917 . 807917 INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION STATE OF CALIFORNIA LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE LCase | No._63_INA_250_o245 ._No._636_IA_2503_245 _IA_250_245No._63_IA_250_245 ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLE COMPANI . and Place of NOTICE TO ALL PARTIES You are hereby nocified that further hearing will be held in the entitled ' 4107 LOS ANGELES STATE OFFICE BUILDING 107 SOUTH BROADWAY LOS ANGELES CALIFORNIA NOVEMBER 4,1963 D ees LOS ANGELES , 9:00 L.X. ALL DAY ENIXSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION ; NOTE CONTINUANCES AND FURTHER HEARINGS ARE NOT FAVORED RAHS AND ADDRESS OF PERSONS SERVIO DATE October October 2 1963 , Ave. Leonard C.Brokenshire 14717 Liebscher Stearns & Gros9200 Colima B. Whittier Norwalk ContracSttioncgkwellSupply S.Catalina Wilshire 90005 Weingand Armstrong Armstrong & Co. 4340 District Blvd. Aetna Cas Surety Co. 2404 Blvd. 90054 Callanan S.Catalina TravelersKI enndsigCo. 3600 Wi&lshire Blvd.661111LA90005 LA IA 90058 90005 nem Fonu 4064 V % M. Stern H. Stern OF ZYGNATURE DERBON SICHYTHSIECHYTHE HOTSEC echo sone ten ' aoe getas mh RTs 07918 BEFORE THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFOR , I CASE NO 63 D. A. 250-245 LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHLAR , Applicant v8 1 MINOT OF HEARING j j AND ORDER JOINING . * } PARTY DEFENDANT ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY COMFANY AETNA AND SURETY COMPANY CASUALTE & corporation corporation : 5 INSURANCE TRAVELERS | COMPANY 10 COMMIaSSIONte dorporation } mo LOS OFFICE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMISION WATE ACCIDENT PILED AUG1 1963 Defendents . WILLIAM KAPLAN IL 5 : AESI UZSKATAZY CAUSE ; THIS came on for hearing this 30th day of July ' 23 1963 nine 1.0 in Department 7 of the Industrial Accident Commission t 18 Los Angeles California before Honorable RICHARD BARRY Referee X. McNeal Court Reporter se FRESENT FRESENT H Leonard Charles Brokenshire applicant Stearns & Grosa by Richard Cross attorneys for applicant Weingand Kendig Stockwell & Callanan by E. Kendig attomeys for Aetna Casualty and Surety Co. ny 20 2 2 2 830 Peaw dat baat a0 SEE e ALTNEr SSES teers None) EXHIBITS 3pp None : eens SERVED 7/30/63 MMc LA P Travelers Ins Co. 3600 Wilshire Blvd. 5 ~ Stearns & Gross 9200 Colima Rd Whittier L. C. Brokenshire 14717 Liebacher Avel Norwalk - Armstrong Contracting & Supply 4340 District Blvd. LA 58 ~ Weingand Kendig Stockwell & Callanan 611 S. Catalina LA 5 ~ Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. 2404 Wilshire Blvd. LA 54 o a 80791 I ae 8 9 957828 99995978228 _ GOOD CAUSE APPEARING THERIBOR i IT IS ORDERED that the application be amended to allege a 1941 ended period of continuing trauma that began in and on February 8 1963 : i IT IS ORDERED that TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY A CORPORATII be and it hereby is joined as a party defendant sa insurance carfler for Armstrong Contracting and Supply Company during the period of applicant's employment with that company that began on April 2 1961 up until the time coverage began by Aetna Casualtz and Surety Company ory 9 95 782 8 IT IS STIPULATED BY AEINA CASUALT ANYD SURETY COMPANY " 1. That it was the insurance carrier for Armstrong 9 9 59782 8 9957828 Contracting and Supply Company for the period that began Jamuary 1 1963 and continued through the last date of applicant employment That it alone or possibly in conjunction with Travelers Insurance Company will make a monetary adv^nce to applicant and will pay the medical expense incurred in the sum of 159.50 for the bill of Dr. Schmerler DISPOSITION Continued to be reset for one full day not before two months from this date 959782 28 2828 remit iis 13TH mage ART nO Siw ment COMMIF 1, ACT enuivenntfi gravis OF . na ape ag th INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION \ STATE OF CALIFORNIA 807921 ZZCHARD GILARERS BROKENSHIRE NOTICE OF HEARING ANDISTRONG ve. CONTRACTING AND SUPPLI o Applicant \ COMPANY | : + Case 250-245 . 148 ANSEL Defendants WILLIAM KAPLAN [ AEST SIGRATANTSIGRATANT You hereby notified that en spyScations for compensatite copy of which streched bureco has been filed vich 4107 LOS ANGELES STATE OFFICE BUILDING 107 SOUTH BROADWAY A an JULY 30 1963 9:00 AM und that mid time and place the Industrial Accident Comunistita of the Scave of Califorais will proceed har und dip of the ssid application in the manner prsecribed by law chaude maNaivtae TThhee ppaarrddoo eerraa aappeeoossaaaall embarks seential posed asanteovany all Latest forasanteovany fue some dabim dabim this busings endestin^'en der ali kaming 7/9/63 weft 2h by. William Eaplik x . mel The undersigned certifies that es en complayer of the Industrial Acci^meComminion she searvceodpythoef fsaoirdegnooitnigcenotios atached parties California with the partage thereon fully prepaid and to addressed . or ruidoncs as follows wo wisz Deve ; 7/9/63 7/9/63 Namas and Address of Persons Servad Liebacker Ave. Norwalk Calif Leonard Charles Brokenshire 14717 Whittier Califo . Stearns & Gross 9200 Golim^ Road Co. 4340 District Alrdo Loko 50 , Calif Calif Armstrong Contracting & Bupply Wilshire Blvd. Lode 54 Calif . Aetna Casualty & Surety C0 2404 611 S. Catalina D.A. 5 Calif- Weingand Kondig Stockwell & Callanan . Llovi Llovi : Llovi Llovi MATURE OF PERDON RATING KOTICE . TAS eae ee 'IN LE TR RM oe airy yes 4 STATE OF CALIFORNIA im nr APPLICATION 80792 / ACCIDENT ) + 7 DUSTRIAL COMMISSION oe 723 Lode STE ae 1. SO hs * PLEASE PRINT OR TYPE NAMES AND ADDRESSES CASE NO 63LA 250245 | CHARMES BROKENSTEHE SR MERPor i 14717 Lisbacher Lisbacher Avenge California Avenge Norwalk California al Security =8022 _. ARMSTRONG INSULAT CO, = 4340 District District Blvd. _ Los Angeles 58. California LEIKA INSURANCE COMPANY Siearee's wetvbaskse exons . | 2404 Wilshire Boulevard ' 7/9/07 employed 1981-8 _19_63 : Califomis IFONAED CHARGES BEX ;, _19_63 Ag 0Gg0koyTy : BLUE JO MASST Ios Angeles Qis Qis 1981-8 1981-8 - K A^ JERTEN contained arising . WHERE course employamas follower remlilag in e os Asbestosis JUDA Asbestosis do 4928 5846 MESTE ESET JARNEHAGENS SAYGIO Tunga_affectedthe insuranca on date injury medical constmaqtdistinct Who form^bed Pr Kurt Hoffmann GATO 6. Wag Dr. Joseph WORTH OF WEEK ST~"TO PAY whahanshah whansha whahanshah whahanshah VERSO whansha hour GATO & VEZA B J. Schmerlespaid by appliesnt : GIVE RAM^ SKP BRATOGA VOD TYLATES TILL MIKEY LEO STAYA VBS JA TUKFIALR LE 7. This spplicetim la filed to damarmine Hability fort . ... 2. Temporary Temporary & Medical reports ae Permanens cimbility * Medical th A^ d Medical cost ms 194 * - STATE ART #TEEN#KASAIN War was 628SLES EP MIP OTHER APPENALTIES M^ S pWr HEoRp EFeOr RE # requested that time and place be fined for hearing and that an oward be made granting such relief as way be C:ompensation Laws DatW ed WE EES ES California March March 8 19' 63 ' MTS Number of witcazes COAT Esituattimee dof erial 1/2 day 3-19-6.3 3-19-6.3 Murph Murph Murph Within STEARNS AND GR^ ZE BY 6 Cat fo ere : ae APPLICANTS ANKET 9C 200oli RdmWaa lttier California . A FUTBAFUTLBALAAANAI NI FUTBALANI LET ALOT BE DIE 10 ~ ANAJLLAURA KENYANY FREE VRYN EDNA SEMT ENA BIP STONEKTER ULUSLIT and in exhibits FUTBALNI FREE FREE FREE FREE EDNAT EDNAT SEMENA ~ ANA JLLAURA to 204 GTTY STONEKTER STONEKTER ULUSLIT KENYANY mila na na THEN A nanana nnaa WadeqWuadequaa't 'Watdequa'ttepteprr6EMN6T EMteEprN6TEMENtTepr6teEpMrE6ENMTENT SHIFTANt~ Anu SONGUIN BUITESTHE CLASA sati MON PR InOE abT oLeD aer SHIFTANt~ SHIFTANt~ SAFITE LAWS THE APPLIESAT meee TENDANTES thutb a" TT TENDANTES LA HP s^ PR tb 4 IF AYODHET AYODHET AP LIESAT AP LI,ESAT BUITES 4 cinbied, ThtDOD MEET AYLEYZO AYLEYZO AYLEYVZ E13O 45 IF AYODHET ES KENYANY PASSIER AND ES oF wriekenas eqeectig DE MALING VEES PTAPE Hebetteu, dscecet sescrtnesy tibtae? beast, SUt be TILL TENDATENNDANTETS ES JAFLIES DE a. PROOF OF SERVICE STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) | | COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ) I am employed in the County of Los Angeles State of California I am over the age of 18 and not a party to the within action my business address is 222 N. Sepulveda Blvd. Suite 1900 El Segundo California 90245 On August 24 2007 I served a copy of the following on interested parties in Case No. BC 342 363 PLAINTIFFS REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE REGARDING CALIFORNIA INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISION DOCUMENTS MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT THEREOF XX By Mail caused each envelope with postage fully prepaid to be placed in the United States Mail at El Segundo California to SEE ATTACHED PROOF OF SERVICE LIST ' XX State I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the above is true and correct | am readily familiar with the firm's practice of collection and processing correspondence for mailing Under that practice it would be deposited with the U.S. Postal Service on that same day with postage thereon fully prepaid at El Segundo California in the ordinary course of business I am aware that on motion of the party served service is presumed invalid if postal - cancellation date or postage meter date is more than one day after the date of deposit for mailing in this affidavit Executed on August 24 2007 at El Segundo California _ CANDY NELSON | Wm Wm Henry Saller vs. Bondex International Ir Los Angeles Superior Court BC 342 363 W File No. 05-1407- 05-1407PLAINTIFF'S SERVICE LIST Crown Cork & Seal Company Inc. CC Elementis Chemicals Inc. Harcros Chemicals Inc. Armstrong William H. ARMSTRONG & ASSOCIATES One Kaiser Plaza Sulle 625 Dakland CA 94612 Tel 510-433-1830 CA Speed Dial 408 Fax 510-433-1836 General Motors Corporation Brown Jr. Eugene FILICE BROWN EASSA & MCLEOD 1999 Harrison Street 18th Floor Oakland CA 94612-3541 Tel 510-444-3131 CA Speed Dial 71 Fax 510-839-7940 Crane Co. Jfkes Frederick J. KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART PRESTON GATES ELLIS LLP 10100 Santa Monica Blvd. 7th Floor Los Angeles CA 90067 Tel 310-552-5000 Fax 310-552-5001 CA Speed Dial 118 MC Corporation Nicol Farah MCKENNA LONG & ALDRIDGE LLP 444 South Flower Street 3th Floor _os Angeles CA 90071 Tel 213-688-1000 CA Speed Dial 52 . Fax 213-243-6330 Crown Cork & Seal Company inc CC Loomis Joni Lynn MORRIS POLICH & PURDY LLP 1055 West Seventh Street 24th Floor Los Angeles CA 90017 Tel 213-891-9100 , CA Speed Dial 11 Fax 213-488-1178 Bondex International Inc. Dowman Products Inc. RPM International Inc. 7PM Inc. Van Dam Tina WALSWORTH FRANKLIN BEVINS & MCCALL LLP One City Boulevard West Fifth Floor Orange CA 92868-3677 Tel 714-634-2522 Fax 714-634-0686 CA Speed Dial 37 Page 1 of 1