Document ZBqrmepBj0jwpJyx0QOxXKzDL
110>
ACUTE TO X IC ITY TO TH E EARTHW ORM (Eisenia fetida)
TE S T SUBSTANCE_______________________________________ __________ *
id entity: Perfluorooctanesulfonate; may also be referred to as PFOS or FC -95. (1-Octanesulfonic acid, 1,1,2,2,3,3,4,4,5,5,6,6,7,7,8,8,8heptadecafluoro-, potassium salt, CAS # 2795-39-3)
Rem arks: The test substance is a white powder. Sample w as taken from 3M lot number 217. Sam ple w as stored under ambient conditions prior to testing. Purity determined to be 86.9% by LC/M S, 1H-HM R, 19F-N M R and elemental analyses techniques.
M ETHOD__________________________________________________________
M ethod: The study was conducted using a protocol based on procedures outlined in the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (O EC D ) Guideline No. 207. T est type: Static, artificial soil substrate GLP: Yes Y e a r C om pleted: 2002 Species: Eisenia fetida A n alytical m onitoring: Test substance concentrations in soil measured by LC/M S/M S at Days 0 and 14; in earthworm tissues after test term ination. S tatistical m ethods: LC5o values calculated by moving average method or binomial probability with non-linear interpolation using the computer software of C .E . Stephan. Treatm ent group means were compared to control means with Dunnett's test (a = 0.05) using SAS Version 8 to determine if significant differences from the control occurred. T es t organism source: Obtained from Worm Man's Worm Farm, R & K Trading Co., Monroe Township, NJ T es t organism age a t stu d y in itiatio n : Adult (with ciitellum)
Test conditions
T es t m edia: Artificial soil of the following composition:
Quartz sand
31.5 kg
Kaolin clay
9.0 kg
Sphagnum peat 4.5 kg
Calcium carbonate 1.125 kg
Artificial soil prepared in bulk by blending 70% sand, 20% kaolin clay and
10% sphagnum peat. The pH of the bulk soil prior to hydration was
adjusted to 6.0 using calcium carbonate. Moisture content adjusted to
-3 3 % by weight.
im jut 29 AH 9s25
CONTAIN NO CBI
000197
Lighting: Fluorescent lights, intensity measured as 494-775 lux. Photoperiod was 24-hours of continuous light.
Stock and test solutions preparation: The test substance was
first dry mixed with the test soil. Approximately 4 kg of each test
concentration and the negative control was prepared separately.
The soil, test substance and deionized w ater were mixed together
for 20 minutes prior to separation into the appropriate exposure
vessel. Test soils w ere prepared and held overnight at
approximately 20C prior to adding worms to allow the soil to
become less fluid.
Exposure vessels: One liter Nalgene beakers containing
approximately 750 g of prepared soil, except for the 625 mg/kg
(m easured) concentration, where only 650 g would fit in the vessel.
The beakers w ere covered with plastic wrap, which was perforated
for air exchange.
Number of replicates: four
Number of test organisms per replicate: ten
Number of concentrations: five plus a negative control
Test media parameters:
Initial and final % moisture (controls):
3 3 .9 ,3 2 .1
Initial and final % moisture (1042 mg/kg):
32.5, 34.5
Initial and final soil pH in water (controls):
6.9, 8.3
Initial and final soil pH in water (1042 mg/kg): 8.0, 8.3
Initial and final Temp., C(controls):
2 2 ,2 2
Initial and Final Temp., C (1042 mg/kg):
2 2 ,251
1 One outlier of 25C
Element Basis: LC50 - mortality. NO EC - burrowing behavior, body weight and clinical signs of toxicity. A t test initiation, worms were placed on the surface of the soil in each test chamber and observed for burrowing behavior. On Day 7 and Day 14, the contents of each test cham ber were removed to determine the number of surviving worms and to evaluate sublethal effects. On Day 7, following observations, test soil was returned to the test chambers and the worms w ere placed on the soil surface in order to again observe burrowing behavior. Method of calculating means of measured concentrations: Arithmetic mean
00198
RESULTS
Nominal concentrations: <LOQ, 7 8 .1 ,1 5 6 , 313, 6 2 5 ,1 2 5 0 mg/kg Measured concentrations (Day 0): <LOQ, 7 7 .0 ,1 4 1 , 2 8 9 ,4 8 8 ,1 0 4 2 mg/kg (as dry weight)
Element values: 7-day LCso (95% C .I.):
3 9 8 (2 8 9 -4 8 8 ) mg/kg
7-day NOEC:
289 mg/kg
7-day LOEC:
488 mg/kg
14-day LC50 (95% C .I.):
373 (3 1 6 -4 4 0 ) mg/kg
14-day NOEC:
77 mg/kg
14-day LOEC:
141 mg/kg
All elem ent values w ere calculated using the Day 0 measured
concentrations in the test soils.
Statistical Evaluation: The 7-day LCso value and 95% confidence interval were calculated by binomial probability. The 14-day elem ent values were determined using the moving average method.
Analytical Methodology: Analyses of test soils and earthworms w ere performed at W ildlife International Ltd. using high performance liquid chromatography with triple quadrupole mass spectrometric detection (HPLC/M S/M S). W hen determining the concentration of the test substance in the samples, the sam e and most prominent peak response for perfluorooctanesulfonate was used. No attempt was made to quantify on the basis of individual isomeric components.
On Day 14, following observations and body weight determination, all surviving worms from each treatm ent group were placed on moistened filter paper and allowed to purge their gut contents for approximately 24 hours. The worms were then euthanized by freezing and stored frozen prior to analysis. The LOQs (limits of quantitation) in soil and earthworms were 29.3 and 50.0 mg/kg, respectively, in this study. The mean percent recovery of matrix fortifications analyzed concurrently during sample analysis was 87.3% in the soil and 86.6% in the earthworm tissue. Soil samples collected at test initiation had measured values from 78.1% to 98.6% of nominal. Measured values for samples taken on Day 14 ranged from 87.5 to 103% of nominal.
000199
Summary of analytical chemistry date for soil, Day 0:
Nominal Test Concentration,
mq/kq
Measured Replicate Values, mg/kg (dry weight)
Mean Concentration, mg/kg (dryw t)
Percent of Nominal
Negative Control
All < LOQ (29.3)
<LOQ (29.3)
78.1
7 4 .6 ,7 2 .7 ,1 0 4 , 7 4 .7 ,6 9 .4 , 66.5
77.0
98.6
156
144, 138
141 90.4
313
312, 266
289 92.3
625
5 2 6 ,4 4 9
488 78.1
1250
1152,906, 894, 93 0 ,1 4 0 5 , 966
1042
83.4
Summary of analytical chemistry date for soil, Day 14:
Nominal Test Concentration,
mg/kg
Measured Replicate Values, mg/kg (dry weight)
Mean Concentration, mg/kg (dry wt)
Percent of Nominal
Negative Control 78.1 156 313 625 1250
All < LOQ (29.3) 7 4 .9,8 6 .2 143, 142 302, 308 5 3 2 ,7 3 5 1 0 5 9 ,1 1 2 9
<LOQ (29.3) 80.6 143 305 634 1094
103 91.7 97.4 101 87.5
Summary of analytical chemistry data for earthworm(1), Day 14:
Day 0 Mean Soil Concentration,
mg/kg
Measured Replicate Tissue Values, mg/kg (wet weight)
Mean tissue Concentration, mg/kg (wet weight)
Negative Control
All < LOQ (50.0)
<LOQ (50.0)
77.0
189, 201
195
141 2 0 9 ,1 9 6
203
289 240, 263
252
488 1042
1105 No surviving worms
1105(a)
_
hours to purge gut contents. The entire mass of worms collected from each treatment group was composited, euthanized by freezing and stored frozen until analyzed.
(2) Results may be unreliable as limited number of worms were available for analysis
000200
Biological observations after 96-hours: Earthworms in the negative control, and the 77.0 mg/kg treatm ents appeared healthy and normal throughout the test with no mortality or overt clinical signs of toxicity. On Day 7 there was 90% and 100% mortality in the 488 mg/kg group and the 1042 mg/kg group, respectively. On Day 14, the 1 4 1 ,2 8 9 , and 488 mg/kg groups exhibited 7.5, 2.5 and 95% mortality, respectively. Worms in the 488 and 1042 mg/kg groups exhibited an aversion to the soil during observations of burrowing behavior on Day 0. On Day 0 after one hour, some worms in the 488 mg/kg group were not burrowed, and in the 1042 mg/kg group many remained on the soil surface. After two hours, all but one worm in the 488 mg/kg group had burrowed but in the 1042 group most worms remained out of the soil. On Day 7, all surviving worms burrowed into the soil within 15 minjutes. On Day 7, worms found dead in the 1042 mg/kg group were on the side of the test chamber, not in the soil.
Cumulative percent mortality:
Day 0 Mean Soil Concentration, mg/kg
Neg. Control
77.0 141 289 488 1042
Day 7
0 0 0 0 90 100
Control response: Satisfactory
Day 14
0 0 7.5 2.5 95 100
Average Earthworm Body VVeights:
Day 0 Mean Soil
Concentration, mg/kg
Neg. Control
Day 0 weight,
g
0 .2 9 ,0 .2 3 , 0.23, 0.26
Day 14 Weight,
g
0 .2 1 ,0 .1 9 , 0.18, 0.20
Mean Total Weight Change,
g
-0.06
77.0
0.25, 0.25, 0.26, 0.25
0 .2 0 ,0 .1 9 ,0 .2 0 , 0.18
-0.06
141
0.26, 0 .2 7 ,0 .2 3 , 0.26
0 .2 1 ,0 .1 7 , 0.14, 0.20
-0 .0 7
289
0.27, 0 .2 5 ,0 .2 3 .0 .2 5
0 .1 7 ,0 .1 7 , 0.16, 0.18
-0.08
488 0.24, 0.25,0.23, 0.24
0 .0 8 *
-0 .1 7 *
1042
0.25, 0.25, 0.24, 0.25
No surviving worms
` Statistically different (p < 0 .0 5 ) from the control group using D unnett's test.
000201
CO NCLUSIO NS The perfluorooctanesulfonate, potassium salt 14-day LCsofor the Earthworm, Eisenia fetida, was determined to be 373 mg/kg with a 95% confidence interval of 316 - 440 mg/kg. The 14-day no observed effect concentration was 77 mg/kg. Subm itter: 3M Corporation, Environmental Laboratory, P.O . Box 33331, St. Paul, Minnesota, 55133 DATA Q UALITY________________________ ___________________________ R eliability: Klimisch ranking 1. R E F E R E N C E S _____________________________________________________ This study was conducted at W ildlife International, Ltd. Easton, MD at the request of the 3M Company. O THER__________________________ Last changed: 6/17/02
000202
PFOS: AN ACUTE TOXICITY STUDY W ITH THE EARTHWORM IN AN ARTIFICIAL SOIL SUBSTRATE
FINAL REPORT
W ILDLIFE INTERNATIONAL, LTD. PROJECT NUMBER: 454-111 Environmental Laboratory Project Number U2723 OECD Guideline 207
AUTHORS: Anne B. Sindermann
John R. Porch Henry O. Krueger, Ph.D. Raymond L. Van Hoven, Ph.D. STUDY INITIATION DATE: October 17,2001 STUDY COMPLETION DATE: May 10,2002
SUBMITTED TO: 3M
Environmental Laboratory 935 Bush Avenue
St. Paul, Minnesota 55106
Wildlife International, Ltd.
8598 Commerce Drive Easton, Maryland 21601
(410) 822-8600
Page l o f 52
000203
Wildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
2- -
GOOD LABORATORY PRACTICE COM PLIANCE STATEM ENT
SPONSOR: 3M
TITLE: PFOS: An Acute Toxicity Study with the Earthworm in an Artificial Soil Substrate
W ILDLIFE INTERNATIONAL, LTD. PROJECT NUMBER: 454-111
STUDY COMPLETION DATE: May 10,2002
T his study was conducted in compliance w ith Good Laboratory Practice Standards as published by the U.S. Environm ental Protection Agency in 40 CFR Parts 160 and 792, 17 August 1989; OECD Principles of Good Laboratory Practice, ENV/MC/CHEM (98) 17, Paris, 1998; and Japan MAFF, 59 NohSan, Notification No. 3850, A gricultural Production Bureau, 10 August 1984.
000204
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-3 -
QUALITY ASSURANCE STATEM ENT
This study was examined for compliance with Good Laboratory Practice Standards as published by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 40 CFR Parts 160 and 792, 17 August 1989; OECD Principles o f Good Laboratory Practice, ENV/MC/CHEM (98) 17, Paris, 1998; and Japan MAFF, 59 NohSan, Notification No. 3850, Agricultural Production Bureau, 10 August 1984. The dates o f all inspections and audits, and the dates that any findings were reported to the Study Director and Laboratory Management were as follows:
ACTIVITY: Test Substance Preparation
DATE CONDUCTED: November 2,2001
Test Substance Preparation
November 19,2001
Observations - Day 7 Matrix Fortifications Body Weights - Day 14 Analytical Data, Draft Report Raw Data, Draft Report Final Report
November 27,2001 November 27,2001 December 4,2001 January 11,2002 January 10 and 11,2002 May 6,2002
DATE REPORTED TO: STUDY DIRECTOR: MANAGEMENT:
November 2,2001
November 5,2001
November 19,2001 November 20,2001
November 27,2001 November 28,2001
November 27,2001 November 28,2001
December 4,2001
December 5.2001
January 14,2002 January 11,2002
January 14, 2002 January 16, 2002
May 6,2002
May 10,2002
Jduties H. Coleman Quality Assurance Representative
Date
000205
dlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
SPONSOR: 3M
-4 REPORT APPROVAL
TITLE: PFOS: An Acute Toxicity Study with die Earthworm in an Artificial Soil Substrate
W ILDLIFE INTERNATIONAL, LTD. PROJECT NUMBER: 454-111 STUDY DIRECTOR-
W ILDLIFE INTERNATIONAL. LTD. MANAGEMENT: Director, Aquatic Toxicology and Non-Target Plants
000206
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-5 -
TABLE OF CONTENTS Title Page......................................................................................
1
Good Laboratory Practice Compliance Statement..............................................
2
Quality Assurance Statem ent.............................................................................................................. 3
Report Approval....................................................................................
4
Table o f C ontents...................................................................................................................
5
Sum m ary.....................................................................................................................
7
Introduction.......................................
8
O bjective..........................................
8
Experimental Design............................................................................................................................ 8
M aterials and Methods........................................................................................................................ 9
Test Substance...................................................................
9
Test Organism................................
9
Artificial Soil and Test Soils Preparation............................................................................... 9
Analytical Sampling............................................................................................................... 10
Analytical T e stin g ...............................
11
Test Cham bers.................................................................
11
Physical Properties o f Test Soils............................................................................................11
Environmental Conditions............................................................. ........................................ 11
Observations........................................................................................................................... 12
Body W eights.......................................................................................................................... 12
Reference Toxicity T e st.........................................................................................................12
Statistical Analyses ............................................................................................................... 12
Results and D iscussion........................................................
13
Environmental Conditions...................................................................................................... 13
Physical Properties o f Test Soils......................
13
Observations........................................................................................................................... 13
Statistical A nalyses.......................................
14
Reference Toxicity T est..............................................................................................
14
Sample Analysis...............................................................................................
15
Conclusions..........................
15
000207
W ildlife International, Ltd.
6- TABLE OF CONTENTS
- Continued -
Project Number 454-111
References........................................................................................................................................... 16
Table 1.
TABLES Moisture, pHw, and Temperature o f Test S oils..............................................17
Table 2.
Cumulative M ortality and Observations o f Earthworms Exposed to PFOS in an Artificial Soil Substrate................................................................ 18
Table 3.
Average Body W eights o f Earthworms Exposed to PFOS in an Artificial
Soil Substrate..........................................................................
19
Table 4.
Day 14 Measured Values for PFOS in Earthworm Tissue .......................... 20
A ppendix 1. A ppendix 2. A ppendix 3, Appendix 4.
A P P E N D IC E S Personnel Involved in the Study ......................................................................21
Changes to the Study Protocol ........................................................................ 22
Artificial Soil and Test Soils Preparation ......................................................23
Analytical C hem istry.........................
25
000268
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-7 SUMMARY
SPONSOR: 3M Corporation TITLE : PFOS: An Acute Toxicity Study with the Earthworm in an Artificial Soil Substrate
WILDLIFE INTERNATIONAL, LTD. PROJECT NUMBER: 454-111
TEST DATES:
Study Initiation: October 17,2001 Experimental Start (OECD): November 2,2001
Experimental Start (EPA): November 20,2001 Experimental Termination: December 4,2001
Study Completion: M ay 10,2002
TEST ORGANISM:
Earthworm (Eiseniafetida)
AGE OF TEST ORGANISM :
Adult (with clitellum)
SOURCE OF TEST ORGANISM :
Worm Man's Worm Farm R & K Trading Co.
116 Pergola Ave. Monroe Township, New Jersey 08831
MEAN MEASURED TEST CONCENTRATIONS:
Negative Control 77.0 nag a .i / kg 141 mg a.i./ kg 289 mg a.i./ kg 488 mg a.i./ kg 1042 mg a.i./k g
RESULTS:
7-Day LC50: 398 mg a.i./ kg 7-Day NOEC: 289 mg a.i./ kg 7-Day LOEC: 488 mg a.i./ kg 14-Day LC50: 373 mg a.i./ kg 14-Day NOEC: 77 mg a.i./k g 14-Day LOEC: 141m ga.i./kg
000209
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
- 8-
IN T R O D U C T IO N Wildlife International, Ltd. conducted this study for 3M at the W ildlife International, Ltd. toxicology facility in Easton, Maryland. The in-life portion o f this test was conducted from November 19, 2001 to December 4, 2001. Raw data generated a t W ildlife International, Ltd. and a copy o f the final report are filed under Project Number 454-111 in archives located on the W ildlife International, Ltd. site. Key personnel involved in the conduct or management o fthe study are listed in Appendix 1.
O B JE C T IV E The objective o f this study was to determine the acute effects o f Perfluorooctanesulfonate, Potassium Salt (hereafter referred to as PFOS) on earthworms during a 14-day exposure period in an artificial soil substrate.
EXPERIM ENTAL DESIGN Earthworms (Eisenia fetida) were exposed to a geometric series o f five concentrations o f PFOS in soil. A control group was maintained concurrently in soil without the addition o f PFOS. This route o f administration was selected because it was representative o f the natural exposure o f earthworms to chemicals.
Four replicate test chambers were maintained in each treatm ent and control group, with 10 worms in each test chamber. Observations o f m ortality and clinical signs were conducted twice within the first four hours o f test initiation, and then on Day 7 and Day 14. The m ortality results were analyzed with the moving average method to determine an LC50 value.
A t Wildlife International, Ltd., reference toxicity tests with a reference toxicant, chloroacetamide, are conducted periodically to assess fee sensitivity o f fee test species and test procedures. These studies are conducted under separate protocols, as independent studies. A summary o f fee results from fee most current reference toxicity test is presented in this report.
000210
W ildlife InternationalLtd.
-9 -
Project Number 454-111
M ATERIALS AND M ETHODS The study was conducted based upon the procedures outlined in the protocol, "PFOS: An Acute Toxicity Study with the Earthworm in an A rtificial Soil Substrate." The protocol was based upon procedures outlined in the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) Guideline No. 207, Guideline fo r Testing o f Chemicals, Earthworm, Acute Toxicity Tests (1). Changes to the protocol are listed in Appendix 2.
T est Substance The test substance used was received from 3M on October 29, 1998 and assigned W ildlife
International, Ltd. identification number 4675. The test substance was a white powder identified by the Sponsor as FC-95, lot 217. Information from the Sponsor indicated the purity o f the test substance to be 86.9% with an expiration date o f August 31,2006. The test substance was stored under ambient conditions.
Test O rganism Adult earthworms (Eisenia ftida ) were obtained from Worm Man's W orm Farm , Monroe
Township, New Jersey. Approximately 18.5 hours prior to the test, 280 worms were selected and placed in a container o f prepared artificial soil substrate adjusted to moisture content o f approximately 33% by weight, for the acclimation period. On the day o f test initiation, the worms were rinsed briefly with deionized water and indiscriminately distributed by pairs into groups o f 10 worms each. Each group o f worms was weighed tren placed on the soil surface in the appropriate test chamber. The worms were not fed during testing.
A rtificial Soil and Test Soils P reparation The artificial soil was prepared in bulk by blending 70% sand, 20% kaolin clay and 10%
sphagnum peat (Appendix 3). The pH o f the bulk soil prior to hydration was adjusted to 6.0 using calcium carbonate. The bulk artificial soil was stored in a sealed container under ambient conditions until used to prepare the test sods.
000211
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-10-
Test soils were prepared by stirring the test substance into a portion o f bulk soil before mixing it with the remainder o f the soil and deionized water (Appendix 3). Sufficient deionized w ater was added to the dry artificial soil to achieve a moisture content o f approximately 33% by weight. Test soil components were mixed for a total o f 20 minutes to ensure a homogeneous mix. Negative control soil was prepared in the same manner as test soil, but without the addition o f test substance. Seven hundred fifty grams o f prepared soil were added to each o f four test chambers for the control group, with the exception o f the 625 mg a.i./ kg concentration in which no more than 650 g would fit into the test chambers.
Test concentrations were adjusted for the purity o f PFOS, which was reported to be 86.9% by the Sponsor. Therefore, test concentrations and the LC50 values are reported as milligrams o f test substance active ingredient per kilogram o f soil on a dry weight basis (mg a.i./kg). Test soils were prepared and held overnight at approximately 20 2C prior to adding worms to allow the soil to become less fluid. The target nominal concentrations were 78.1, 156, 313, 625, and 1250 mg a.iVkg dry soil. M ean measured concentrations at the time o f soil preparation were 77.0, 141, 289, 488, and 1042 mg a.i./kg soil.
A nalytical Sam pling During the test, samples o f the experimental soils were collected to determine the homogeneity
and stability o f the test substance in the artificial soil and to verify test concentrations. Samples were collected a t soil preparation to determine homogeneity, measure test concentrations, and establish Day 0 values for evaluating stability over the course of the exposure period. On Day 14, samples were collected from one replicate o f the control and two replicates o f each test concentration to assess stability o f the test substance under test conditions.
A t test termination samples o f tissue from the earthworms in each treatm ent group were analyzed to determine the concentration o f PFOS in the worm tissue from each treatm ent group. All surviving worms from each treatment group were placed on moistened filter paper for approximately 24 hours to purge gut contents. The entire mass o f worms collected from each treatm ent group was composited, euthanized by freezing and stored frozen until analyzed.
000212
W ildlife International, Ltd.
- 11-
Project Number 454-111
A nalytical Testing Chemical analysis o f the soil and worm samples was performed using HPLC/MS/MS
methodology (Appendix 4).
Test Cham bers The test chambers were one-liter Nalgene beakers covered with plastic wrap which was
perforated for air exchange. A11 test chambers were identified with the project number, test concentration and replicate.
Physical Properties of T est Soils Soil temperature was measured in one replicate o f each treatm ent and control group a t test
initiation and termination using a hand-held thermometer. M oisture content and pH measurements were made on soil samples collected from each batch o f soil prepared for treatm ent and control groups a t test initiation. An additional soil moisture content measurement was made after test initiation to verify the soil moisture. A t test termination, samples for moisture content and pH measurements were collected from one replicate o f each control and treatm ent group. Measurements o f pH were made on suspensions o f soil and deionized water using a waterproof hand-held pH meter, and are reported as pH* values. Soil moisture content was determined by measuring the initial weight o f the soil sample, then weighing the soil sample after drying for at least 24 hours at approximately 105C. The percent moisture was calculated using the following formula:
% M oisture = [(wet weight - dry weight) wet weight] * 100
Environm ental Conditions During the test, the worms were maintained in an environmental chamber set to maintain a
temperature o f approximately 20 2C. Air temperature was measured a t least once daily in the environmental chamber. The photoperiod during the test was 24 hours o f continuous light per day provided by overhead fluorescent bulbs. The target light intensify during the test was approximately 400 to 800 lux, and was verified on Day 7 o f the test.
000213
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454*111
-12-
O bservations A t test initiation, the worms were placed on the surface o f the soil in each test chamber and were
observed for burrowing behavior. On Day 7 and Day 14 o f the test, the contents o f each test chamber were removed to determine the number o f surviving worms. All surviving worms were observed for behavioral or pathological abnormalities. On Day 7, following observations, test soil was returned to the test chambers and the worms were placed on the soil surface in order to observe burrowing behavior. On Day 14, following observations and body weight determination, surviving worms were placed on m oist filter paper in dean test chambers and allowed to purge their gut contents for approximately 24 hours. The worms were then euthanized by freezing and held prior to analytical testing.
Body W eights On Day 0, group weights for all replicates were collected prior to being placed in the test
chambers. On Day 14, all surviving worms were removed from each replicate test chamber and weighed. Prior to weighing, worms were rinsed with deionized water and blotted dry on paper towels. Group body weights were measured from each test chamber, and average individual body weights were calculated.
Reference Toxicity Test A reference toxicity test was conducted under a separate protocol to determine the LC50 value
for earthworms exposed to the reference toxicant, chloroacetamide, in the soil (2). The test was conducted under conditions sim ilar to those used in this test, and with earthworms from the same source, to monitor the techniques used and sensitivity o f the test population. The worms were exposed to chloroacetamide in fire soil at nominal concentrations o f 7 .5 ,1 5 ,3 0 and 60 mg a.i./kg dry soil.
S tatistical Analyses The LC50 value and 95% confidence interval were calculated using the computer program o f
C.E. Stephan (3). The program was designed to calculate the LC50 value and the 95% confidence interval by probit analysis, moving average method or the binomial probability method (4,5,6). In this study, the 7-day LC50 value was calculated using the binomial probability method and file 14-Day
000214
Wildlife InternationalLtd.
Project Number 454-111
-13 -
LC50 value was calculated using the moving average method. Mean body weights at test initiation and test termination as well as the mean change in body weight during the test were determined for each treatm ent and control group. Treatment group means were compared to control means with Dunnett's test (a=0.05) using SAS Version 8 (7) in order to determine if significant differences from the control occurred.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Environm ental Conditions
A ir tem perature in the environmental chamber was within the desired range o f approxim ately 20 2C, remaining at 22-23C throughout the test. The worms were maintained under continuous lighting a t an average intensity o f 627 83.9 lux, with a range over the surface o f the test chambers o f 494-775 lux.
Physical P roperties o f T est Soils Measurements o f soil pHw, temperature and moisture content at test initiation and test
termination are presented in Table 1. Soil pHwranged from 6.9 to 8.1 at test initiation and from 8.3 to 8.4 a t test termination. Soil temperature was 22C, within the desired range o f 20 2C a t test initiation and a t test termination. A ttest termination the 1042 mg a.i./kg Replicate A soil tem perature was 25C. It was suspected that the Replicate A chamber was placed too close to a light ballast and w as not indicative o f the soil temperature for that treatment group. R eplicate B was m easured and found to be 22C. Soil moisture content during the test ranged from 29.5 to 33.9% a t test initiation and from 31.4 to 34.5% at test termination, indicating that there was little change in soil moisture content during the test.
O bservations The data from weekly observations o f the worms for mortality and other signs o f toxicity are
presented in Table 2. There were no mortalities in the negative control group during tie 14-day te s t All control worms were normal in appearance and behavior throughout the test period. On Day 7 there was high m ortality in the 488 and 1042 mg a.i./kg treatm ent groups. On Day 14 there was some
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-14-
mortality in the 141 and 289 mg a.i./kg treatment groups and very high mortality in the 488 mg a.i./kg group and complete mortality in the 1042 mg a.i./kg group.
Worms in the 488 and 1042 mg a.i./kg treatment groups exhibited an aversion to the soil during observations o f burrowing behavior on Day 0. On day 0 after one hour, some worms in the 488 mg a.i./kg group were not burrowed, and in the 1042 mg a.i./kg group many remained on the soil surface. After two hours, all but one worm in the 488 mg a.i./kg group had burrowed but in the 1042 mg a.i./kg group most worms remained out o f the soil. On Day 7, all surviving worms burrowed into the soil within 15 minutes. On Day 7, worms found dead in the 1042 mg a.i./kg group were on the side o f the test chamber not in the soil.
Statistical Analyses A 7-Day LC50 estimation o f 398 mg a.i./kg with 95% confidence limits o f 289 and 488 mg
a.i./kg soil was determined using the binomial probability method, since the data did not fit either the probit method or moving average method. A 14-Day LC50 was determined using the moving average method since the data did not fit the probit method. The moving average method was acceptable except for the indication that the confidence limits may be too close due to the lower mortality in the 289 mg a.i./kg soil than in the 141 mg a.i./kg soil treatm ent group. Therefore, the 14-day LC50 estimation for earthworms exposed to PFOS in an artificial soil substrate was determined to be 373 mg a.i./kg soil with 95% confidence limits o f 316 and 440 mg a.i./kg.
After seven days o f exposure the no-observed-effect-concentration, NOEC, was 289 mg a.i./kg soil and the lowest-observed-effect-concentration, LOEC, was 488 mg a.i./kg soil. The 14-Day NOEC was 77 mg a.i./kg soil and the LOEC was 141 mg a.i./kg soil.
Average individual body weights, and the change in body weight from test initiation to test termination, were calculated from the Day 0 and Day 14 replicate measurements (Table 3). A slight loss in body weight from test initiation to test termination was expected in both the control and treatment groups since the worms were not fed during the test. Mean body weight at test termination
000216
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-15-
as well as the mean loss in body weight among worms in the treatment groups were statistically significant (p<0.05) at 488 mg a.i./kg dry soil compared to the control group.
Table 4 contains the 14 day measured values for PFOS in earthworm tissue.
Reference Toxicity Test The 14-day LC50 value for earthworms exposed to the reference substance, chloroacetamide, in
an artificial soil substrate was approximately 19.4 mg a.i./kg dry soil with a 95% confidence interval o f 15 and 30 mg a.i./kg dry soil (2). These results are consistent with those observed in previous studies, and verify the adequacy and consistency of the methods used in this study (454-111).
Sam ple Analysis Chemical analysis o f test soils and earthworm tissue was conducted at W ildlife International,
Ltd. and is reported in Appendix 4.
C O N C L U S IO N S The 7-day LC50 estimation for earthworms exposed to PFOS in an artificial soil substrate was determined to be 398 mg a.i./kg. The 7-day NOEC was determined to be 289 mg a.i./kg and the 7-day LOEC was determined to be 488 mg a.i./kg. The 14-day LC50 estimation for earthworms exposed to PFOS in an artificial soil substrate was determined to be 373 mg a.i./kg. The 14-day NOEC was determined to be 77 mg a.i./kg and the LOEC was 141 mg a.i./kg.
000217
:e International, L td,
-16REFERENCES
Project Number 454-111
1 OECD Guideline 207. 1984. Guideline fo r Testing o f Chemicals, Earthworm, Acute Toxicity Tests. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.
2 W ildlife International, L td. 2000. Chloroacetamide: An Acute Toxicity Study with the Earthworm in an Artificial Soil Substrate. Project No. 100R-105.
3 Stephan, C.E. 1978. U.S. EPA, Environmental Research Laboratory, Duluth, Minnesota. Personal Communication.
4 Finney, D.J. 1971. Statistical M ethods in Biological Assay. Second Edition, Griffin Press, London.
5 Thom pson, W .R. 1947. Bacteriological Reviews. Vol. H, 2:115-145.
6 Stephan, C .E. 1977. Methods for Calculating an LC50. Aquatic Toxicology and H azard Evaluations. American Society for Testing and M aterials. Pub. No. STP 634:65-84.
7 SAS Institute, Inc. 1999. SAS/STAT User's Guide, Version 8. Cary, NC, SAS Institute, Iric.
000218
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-17Table 1 Moisture, pHw, and Temperature o f Test Soils1
Mean Measured Concentration
(mg a.i./kg)
Negative Control
Test Initiation M oisture Content2
(%) _
33.9
Test Initiation
pHw3
Test Initiation T em perature3
(C)
Test Termination Moisture Content
(%)
Test T erm ination
pHw
Test T erm ination T em perature
(C)
6.9 22
32.1 8.3 22
77.0
31.9 7.9
22
31.4 8.4 22
141
29.5 8.1
22
31.5 8.3 22
289
31.4 8.1
22
33.0 8.3 22
488
31.0 8.1
22
32.3 8.3 22
1042
32.5 8.0
22
34.5
'Measurements taken from one replicate test chamber at each concentration. Measurements taken from prepared soil two days alter preparation. Measurements taken from prepared soil on Day 0. Measurement of soil temperature in Replicate B was 22C.
8.3 254
000219
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-18-
Table 2
Cumulative M ortality and Observations o f Earthworms Exposed to PFOS in an Artificial Soil Substrate
M ean
Day 7
M easured
Concentration
Number
( r o g a i /kg)
Rep. Dead*
Effects12
Negative Control
A 0/10 B 0/10 C 0/10 D OflO
10 AN 10 AN 10 AN 10 AN
Day 14
Number Dead
Effects
0/10 10 AN 0/10 10 AN 0/10 10 AN 0/10 10 AN
Replicate " Percent
Mortality
0 0 0 0
Group Percent M ortality
0
77.0
A 0/10 B 0/10
10 AN 10 AN
C 0/10
10 AN
D 0/10
10 AN
0/10 10 AN 0/10 10 AN 0/10 10 AN 0/10 10 AN
0 0 0 0
141
A 0/10 B 0/10
10 AN 10 AN
2/10 8 AN 0/10 10 AN
20 0
C 0/10 9 AN, 1T+S 1/10 9 AN
10
D 0/10
10 AN
0/10 10 AN
0
0 7.5
289
A 0/10 B 0/10
10 AN 10 AN
0/10 10 AN 0/10 10 AN
0 0
2.5
C 0/10
10 AN
0/10 8 AN, 2 R
0
D 0/10
10 AN
1/10 9 AN
10
488
A 9/10 B 8/10
IA N 2 AN
10/10
. ._
100 95
8/10 2 T + R
80
C 10/10
__
10/10
--
100
D 9/10
IA N
10/10
---
100
1042
A 10/10 B 10/10 C 10/10 D 10/10
_ _
--
10/10 10/10 10/10 10/10
_
-- -- --
1Q0 100 100
100
100
1 Mortality date are presented as the cumulative number dead per number exposed. 2 Observed Effects: AN = normal in appearance and behavior, T=thin, S=soft, R=reduced reaction to mechanical
stimuli
000220
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-19-
T able3 Average Body Weights o f Earthworms Exposed to PFOS in an Artificial Soil Substrate
Mean Measured Concentration (mg a.i./kg)
Negative Control
Replicate
A B C D Mean Std. Dev.
Average Earthworm Body Weights (g)
Day 0
0.29 0.23 0.23 0.26 0.25 0.029
Day 14
0.21 0.19 0.18 0.20 0.20 0.013
Total Change
-0.08 -0.04 -0.05 -0.06 -0.06 0.017
77.0 A
0.25 0.20 -0.05
B 0.25 0.19 -0.06
C 0.26 0.20 -0.06
D 0.25 0.18 -0.07
Mean Std. Dev.
0.25 0.005
0.19 0.010
-0.06 .0.008
141 A 0.26 0.21 -0.05
B 0.27 0.17 -0.10
C 0.23 0.14 -0.09
D 0.26 0.20 -0.06
Mean Std. Dev.
0.26 0.017
0.18 0.031
-0.07 .0.024
289 A
0.27 0.17 -0.10
B 0.25 0.17 -0.08
C 0.23 0.16 -0.07
D 0.25 0.18 0.07
Mean Std. Dev.
0.25 0.016
0.17 0.007
-0.08 0.014
488 A
0.24
B 0.25 0.08 -0.17
C 0.23 -- --
D 0.24 -- --
Mean Std. Dev.
0.24 0.008
0.08 1
-0.17 --*
1042 A
0.25
B 0.25 --
C 0.24 --
D 0.25 --
Mean Std. Dev.
0.25 0.005
--'
--
_ --
-- -- --
1Body weight Was statistically different from (p<0.05) the control groups using Dunnett's test. 2Change in body weight was statistically significant (p<0.05) at test concentration when compared to the control groups using Dunnett's test
000221
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
- 20-
Table 4
Day 14 Measured Values for PFOS in Earthworm Tissue
Number (454-111-)
Sample Nominal Exposure
PFOS Concentration (mg a.i./kg)
Measured1
Mean Measured (mg a.i./kg)
W -l
0.0
< LOQ2
-
W -2A W -2B
78.1 78.1
189 195 201
W -3A W-3B
156 156
209 203 196
W -4A W-4B
313 313
240 252 263
W-5 625
1105
-
1Measured values were calculated using MacQuan, version 1.6 software. Manual calculations
may vary slightly. *The method limit ofquantitation (LOQ) in earthworm tissue was 50.0 mg ai./kg on a wet-weight
basis and was calculated as the product ofthe lowest calibration standard (0.000500 mg a.i./L) and the weight/volume dilution factor oflhe matrix blank sample (100,000 L/kg).
000222
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
- 21-
Appendix 1
Personnel Involved in the Study
The following key Wildlife International, Ltd. personnel were involved in the conduct or management o fthis study:
1. Henry O. Krueger, Ph.D., Director, Aquatic Toxicology and Non-Target Plants 2. John R. Porch, Supervisor, Non-Target Plants and Insects 3. Anne B. Sindermann, Senior Biologist 4. Raymond L. Van Hoven, Ph.D., Scientist, Analytical Chemistry
000223
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-22Appendix 2 Changes to the Study Protocol This study was conducted according to the approved study protocol with the following changes:
1. Test soils were prepared, and analytical samples collected, one day prior to test initiation. 2. An additional soil moisture measurement was made. 3. Soil moisture for the 156 mg a.i./kg level was 29.5%, slightly below approximately 33%. 4. Test soil for the 625 mg a.i./kg level weighed 650 g rather than 750 g. 5. Earthworms used for foe study weighed less than between 300 and 600 mg. 6. Earthworms were conditioned for approximately 18.5 hours rather than 24. 7. The soil temperature in Replicate A o f the 1250 mg a.i./kg treatment group was 25C at test
termination, receding foe 202C range specified in the protocol.
000224
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-23-
Appendix 3 Artificial Soil and Test Soils Preparation
A rtificial Soil Preparation
H ie artificial soil was prepared in bulk by mixing the following constituents in a soil mixer for
approximately 20 minutes:
quartz sand
31.500 Isg
kaolin clay
9.000kg
sphagnum peat 4.500 kg
calcium carbonate 1.125 kg
T est Soil P reparation A total o f approximately 4 kg (wet weight) o f test soil with a calculated soil moisture content o f approximately 33% was prepared for the negative control and each of the treatm ent groups. Test substance concentrations were based on the dry weight portion o f the soil. The calculated dry weight o f 41 o f prepared soil, with a moisture content o f 33%, was 2.680 kg. To account for the 4% moisture content typically present in the bulk soil stored in ambient conditions, 1208 mL o f water were added to 2680 g. o f bulk soil minus the weight o f test substance. Amounts o f test substance, bulk soil and water were as follows:
Concentration ime a.L/kg test soil)
Negative control 78.1
156
313
625
1250
Nominal Weight* and Volumes to Prepare Test Soils
Required Amount o f Actual Amount of
Test Substance fg)
Test Substance (g)
----
0.241
0.2410
Bulk Soil (g)
2680.0 2679.8
0.482
0.4819
2679.5
0.965
0.9650
2679.0
1.927
1.9270
2678.1
3.854
3.8541
2676.2
W ater (mL)
1208 1208 1208 1208 1208 1208
The appropriate amount o f bulk soil was weighed into a tared Hobart mixer bowl. Approximately a handful o f dry soil was removed to a Nalgene beaker and the measured amount o f test substance added and mixed in with a metal spatula, after using dry soil to clean test substance off
000225
Wildlife InternationalLtd.
Project Number 454-111
-24-
o f the weigh boat. The soil and test substance mixture was added to the Hobart bowl. 1208 mL o f deionized water was added and the soil mixed for 5 minutes. After the 5-mmute mix, the sides o f the bowl were scraped and the soil was mixed for an additional 15 minutes. Prepared test soil, 750 g for each replicate, except for the 625 mg a.i./kg concentration, which received 650 g, was placed into test chambers labeled with concentration and replicate. Negative control soil was prepared in the same manner, without the addition of test substance, and 750 g was placed into each negative control test chamber.
000226
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-25Appendix 4 THE ANALYSIS OF PFOS IN ARTIFICIAL SOIL AND EARTHWORM TISSUE IN SUPPORT OF WILDLIFE INTERNATIONAL, LTD. PROJECTNO.: 454-111
000227
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
SPONSOR: 3M
-26REPORT APPROVAL
TITLE:
PFOS: AN ACUTE TOXICITY STUDY W ITH THE EARTHWORM IN AN ARTIFICIAL SOIL SUBSTRATE
W ILDLIFE INTERNATIONAL, LTD. PROJECT NO.: 454-111
3M ENVIRONMENTAL LAB PROJECT NUMBER: U2723
PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATOR:
MANAGEMENT: W illard B. Nixon, Ph. Director, Analytical Chemistry
5-I -00~ DATE
000228
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-27-
Introduction
This study was conducted by Wildlife International, Ltd. for 3M at the Wildlife Internationa!, Ltd. analytical chemistry facility in Easton, Maryland. Samples were collected for the determination o f Perfluorooctanesulfonate, Potassium Salt (PFOS) in artificial soil and earthworm tissue and were analyzed using high performance liquid chromatography with triple quadrupole mass spectrometric detection (HPLC/MS/MS). Samples were prepared and analyzed between November 27 and 28,2001 and December 13, 2001. Raw data generated by Wildlife International, Ltd. and a copy o f the final report are filed under Project Number 454-111 in archives located on the 'M idlife International, Ltd. site.
A nalytical M ethodology A rtificial Soil
Submitted artificial soil samples were analyzed for PFOS according to the validated procedures documented in WTL study number 454C-120. The entire submitted soil sample was blended for approximately two minutes prior to sub-sampling the requisite 10-g aliquot for the analytical determination. The artificial soil sub-samples were extracted with methanol, agitated for a minimum o f 30 minutes on a gyratory shaker table a t approximately 250 rpm and then vacuum filtered with qualitative filter paper. The filtrate was then transferred to a 200-mL volumetric flask and brought to volume with methanol. Approximately 20 m illiliters o f each sample was transferred to a separate vial and centrifuged for approximately 5 minutes a t 2000 rpm. Dilutions into the calibration range o f 1he HPLC/MS/MS methodology were performed with a solution o f 50% methanol (HPLC grade, 99.9+%) . and 50% NANOpure water. Samples were then analyzed by direct injection. Concentrations o f PFOS were determined by reverse-phase high performance liquid chromatography using a HewlettPackard Model 1100 High Performance Liquid Chromatograph (HPLC) with a Perkin-EImer API 3000LC M ass Spectrometer equipped with a Peridn-Elmer TurboIonSpray ion source. Chromatographic separations were achieved using a Keystone Betasil C column (50 mm x 2.0 mm, 3pm particle size) fitted with a Keystone Javelin C]8 guard column (20 mm x 2.0 mm). A method flowchart is provided in Figure 1 and the instrument parameters are summarized in Table 1.
000229
Wildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
E arthw orm Tissue
-28-
Submitted earthworm tissue samples were analyzed for PFOS according to methodology developed a t W ildlife International, Ltd. Approximately one gram o f each earthworm tissue sample was weighed directly into tared scintillation vials to which 10.0 milliliters o f methanol extraction solvent were added. The samples were concurrently extracted and homogenized using a tissue shredder (Janice and Kunkel) followed by sonic dismembration. The sample extracts were centrifuged and diluted into the calibration range o f the HPLC/MS/MS methodology. Dilutions were performed w ith a solution o f 50% methanol (HPLC grade, 99.9+%) and 50% NANOpure water. Samples were then analyzed by direct injection HPLC/MS/MS as described previously. A method flowchart is provided in Figure 2.
P rim ary and Secondary Stock Solutions
All prim ary and secondary stock preparations were adjusted for the purity o f the test substance (86.9% ). A 10.0 mg a.i./m L primary stock solution o f PFOS in methanol was prepared by weighing 1.1508 g o f 1he test substance and bringing to a final volume o f 100 m illiliters with methanol. Secondary stock solutions (1000,100,10.0,1.00, and 0.100 mg a.i./L) o f PFOS in methanol were prepared by serial volumetric dilution from the prim ary stock.
C alibration Standards and C alibration Curves
Calibration standards were prepared in 50:50 methanol: NANOpure water by appropriate dilutions o f the 1.00 mg a.i./L stock solutions o f PFOS in methanol. Calibration standards o f PFOS, ranging in concentration from 1.00 to 10.0 pg a.i./L, were analyzed with each artificial soil sample set and calibration standards o f PFOS, ranging in concentration from 0.500 to 5.00 pg a.i./L, were analyzed with the earthworm tissue sample se t The same and most prominent peak response for PFOS was utilized to monitor PFOS in all calibration and study samples. No attem pt was made to quantify PFOS on the basis o f individual isomeric components. The calibration standard series was injected at the beginning and end o f each run, and one standard was injected, at a minimum, after every five samples. Linear regression equations were generated using peak area responses versus the respective concentrations o fthe calibration standards. A typical calibration curve for PFOS in artificial soil and earthworm tissue is presented in Figure 3 and Figure 4, respectively. Representative ion
000230
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-29-
chromatograms o f low and high calibration standards for the artificial soil are presented in Figures 5 and 6, respectively and representative ion chromatograms o f low and high calibration standards for PFOS in earthworm tissue are presented in Figure 7 and 8, respectively. The concentrations o f PFOS in the samples were determined by substituting peak area responses into the applicable linear regression equation. Concentrations o f PFOS in the samples were calculated on a dry weight (soil samples) or wet weight (earthworm tissue) basis using the at-instrumeat PFOS concentrations and the appropriate weight/volume dilution and/or moisture correction factors.
M atrix Blanks and M atrix Fortifications
A rtificial Soil
Selected 20.0-g aliquots o f artificial soil were fortified with the appropriate stock solutions o f PFOS prepared in methanol using a gas-tight syringe. The fortified soils were then homogenized using a W aring blender for approximately 2 minutes. A 10-g aliquot o f each homogenized fortified soil sample was weighed into a tared weigh boat and transferred to an 8-oz. French-square bottle for extraction. The m atrix blanks were unfortified artificial soil.
E arthw orm Tissue A 1.00-g aliquot o f negative control earthworm tissue was fortified with the 1000 mg a.i./L
secondary stock solution o f PFO S prepared in m ethanol using a gas-tight syringe. A m atrix blanks was prepared with unfortified negative control earthworm tissue.
Lim its o f Q uantitation A rtificial Soil
The method limit o f quantitation (LOQ) in artificial soil was 29.3 mg a.i./kg on a dry-weight basis and was calculated as the product o f the lowest calibration standard (0.00100 mg a.i./L), foe weight/volume dilution factor o f foe m atrix blank samples (20,000) divided by foe percent solids for foe test system soil (68.3%).
000231
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-30-
Earthw orm Tissue The method lim it o f quantitation (LOQ) in earthworm tissue was 50.0 mg a.i./kg on a wet-weight
basis and was calculated as the product o f the lowest calibration standard (0.000500 mg a.i./L) and the weight/volume dilution factor o f the m atrix blank sample (100,000 L/kg).
Exam ple Calculations
Exam ple C alculations Sample number 454-111-5, nominal concentration o f 78.1 mg a.i./kg in artificial soil.
First Initial Weight: 10.0 g First Final Volume: 200 xnL Second Initial Volume: 0.0500 mL Second Final Volume: 50.0 mL Dilution Factor: 20000 Mean Soil Moisture Content: 31.7% Percent Solids: 68.3% LCMS Dilution Factor: 20000/0.683 = 29283 PFOS Peak Area: 23914
Calibration curve equation: Slope: 8981195 Intercept: 1011.0532
... .
peak area - (v-interceot)
PFOS (mg a.t./kg) measured a t instrument = ---------- ---------------
PFOS (mg a.i./kg) in sample = PFOS measured at instrument (mg a.i./kg) x LCMS dilution factor
23914 - 1011.0532
8981195
x 29283
= 74.67
. ._
PFOS (mg a.i./K s) in sample __
Percent o f Nominal Concentration = p p o s ^ l/K g )
x 100
= 74.67x100 = 95.6% 78.1
Calculated with HPLC/MS/MS instrument software: MacQuan, version 1.6.
000232
Wildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-31-
RESULTS
M atrix blank samples for each m atrix type were analyzed to determine possible interferences. No interferences were observed a t or above the corresponding LOQ {Tables 2 and 3). Representative ion chromatograms o f artificial soil and earthworm tissue m atrix blank samples are presented in Figures 9 and 10, respectively. M atrix fortification samples for artificial soil had recoveries ranging from 75.6% to 103.2% o f the nominal concentrations with a mean recovery o f 87.3% o f nominal (SD=11.2; CV=12.8). A representative ion chromatogram o f an artificial soil m atrix fortification is presented in Figure 11. The earthworm tissue m atrix fortification (Figure 12) had a recovery o f 86.6% o f the nominal concentration.
A rtificial soil samples collected a t Day 0 from the 78.1 mg a.i./kg, 156 mg a.i./kg, 313 mg a.i./kg, 625 mg a.i./kg and 1250 mg a.i./kg treatm ent levels had mean measured PFOS concentrations o f 77.0 mg a.i./kg (SD=13.6; CV=17.7%, n=6), 141 mg a.i./kg (n-2), 289 mg a.i./kg (n=2), 488 mg a.i./kg (n=2), and 1042 mg a.i./kg (SD=201; CV=19.3%, n=6), respectively (Table 4). These values corresponded to mean percent recoveries o f 98.6%, 90.4%, 92.3%, 78.1% and 83.4% o f the nominal concentrations with an overall mean percent recovery o f 89.6% (SD=15.3; CV=17,1%, n -18). A representative ion chromatogram o f an artificial soil test sample is presented in Figure 13.
Artificial soil samples collected a t Day 14 from the 78.1 mg a.i./kg, 156 mg a.i./kg, 313 mg a.iVkg, 625 mg a.i./kg and 1250 mg a.iA g treatm ent levels had mean measured PFOS concentrations o f 80.6 mg a.i./kg (n=2), 143 mg a.i./kg (n~2), 305 mg a.i./kg (n=2), 634 mg a.i./kg (n=2) and 1094 mg a x /k g (n=2), respectively (Table 5). These values corresponded to mean percent recoveries o f 103%, 91.7%, 97.4%, 101% and 87.5% o f the nominal concentrations with an overall mean percent recovery o f 96.3% (SD=10.7; CV=11.2%, n=10).
Earthworm tissue analyzed on Day 14 had mean measured concentrations o f 195, 203 and 252 mg a.i./kg for nominal exposure levels o f 78.1, 156, and 313 mg a.i./kg, respectively (Table 6). The measured value (1105 mg a.i./kg) for the 625 mg a.i./kg exposure level was suspect due to the limited sample size (3 worms, approximately 0.2 g total weight) available from this treatm ent group. A representative ion chromatogram o f an earthworm tissue test sample is presented in Figure 14.
OOO2 3 3
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-32REFERENCES
1. A m erican Society for Testing and M aterials. 1991. Standard Specification for Reagent W ater. D l 193-91, ASTM Section Ii W ater and Environmental Technology, Vol. 11.01:45-47.
000234
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
IN STR U M EN T:
-3 3 -
T able 1
Typical HPLC/MS Operational Parameters
Hewlett-Packard Model 1100 High Performance Liquid Chromatograph with a Perkin-Elmer API 3000 M ass Spectrometer equipped with a Perkin-Elmer TurboIonSpray ion source. Operated in multiple ion reaction monitoring (MRM) mode.
ION SOURCE:
Perkin-Elmer TurboIonSpray
ANALYTICAL COLUMN:
Keystone Betasil Cig (50 mm x 2.0 mm, 3-pm particle size)
GUARD COLUMN:
Keystone Javelin C!S cartridge (20 mm x 2 mm)
OVEN TEMPERATURE:
40C
STOP TIME:
5.00 min
FLO W RATE: M O B ILE PHASE:
250 fiL/min
30% NANOpure W ater w ith 0 .1% Form ic A cid: 70% M ethanol
INJECTION VOLUME:
5.0 pL
PFOS PEAK RETENTION TIM E:
Approximately 4 minutes
PFOS MONITORED MASS:
499.0 amu - 99.1 amu
000235
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-34Table 2 Artificial Soil M atrix Blanks and Fortifications Analyzed Concurrently During Sample Analysis
Number (454-111-)
Sample Type
M A B -1 M A B -2
Soil M atrix Blank Soil M atrix Blank
PFOS Concentration ____ (mg a-i./kg)_______
Fortified Measured1
Percent Recovered1
0 . 0 < LOQ2 < LOQ2
_ --
M ean M easured (mg a.i./kg)
_
M ean Percent Recovery
--
M A S-1 M A S-4
Soil M atrix Fortification Soil M atrix Fortification
36.6
28.5 29.3
77.7 80.1
28.9 79.0
M A S-2 M A S -5
Soil M atrix Fortification Soil M atrix Fortification
586
565 533
96.4 90.9
549 93.7
M A S-3 M AS- 6
Soil M atrix Fortification Soil M atrix Fortification
1464
1503 1106
103 75.6
1305
89.1
O verall M ean =
87.3
Standard D eviation3
11.2
CV= 12.8
____________ N =
6 __________
*Measured and Percent Recovered values were calculated using MacQuan, version 1.6 software. Manual
calculations may vary slightly.
2 The method limit of quantitation (LOQ) in artificial soil was 29.3 mg a.i./kg on a diy-weight basis and was
calculated as the product ofthe lowest calibration standard (0.00100 mg a.i./L), the weight/volume dilution factor
o f th e m atrix blan k sam ples (20,000> divided by th e percent solids for the te st system so il (68,3% ).
000236
Wildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-35-
Table 3
Earthworm Tissue M atrix Blank and Fortification Analyzed Concurrently During Sample Analysis
Number (454-111-)
Sample Type
PFOS Concentration (m gal/kg)
Fortified Measured1
Percent Recovered1
W M A B -1
W orm Tissue M atrix
0 .0
<LOQ3
B lan k
-
W M A S-1
W orm Tissue M atrix Fortification
100
8 6 .6
8 6 .6
1Measured and Percent Recovered values were calculated using MacQuan, version 1.6 software. Manual calculations may vary slightly.
1 The method limit of quantitation (LOQ) in earthworm tissue was 50.0 mg a.i./kg on a wetweight basis and was calculated as the product ofthe lowest calibration standard (0.000500 mg ai./L ) and the weight/volume dilution factor of the matrix blank sample (100,000 L/kg).
000237
W ildlife InternationalLtd.
Project Number 454-111
-36-
Table 4 Day 0 Recoveries for PFOS in Artificial Soil
Sample
Number (454-111-)
Nominal Concentration
PFOS Concentration (mg a l/k g )
M easured1
Percent Recovered1
M ean M easured (mg a.i./kg)
M ean Percent Recovery
1 0 .0
< LOQ2
-- - --
2 78.1 3 78.1 4 78.1 5 78.1 6 78.1 7 78.1
74.6
95.5
x =77.0
98.6
72.7 93.1 SD= 13.6
104 133 CV= 17.7%
74.7 95.6
69.4 88.9
66.5 85.1
8 156 9 156
144 92.1 141 90.4 138 88.4
1 0 313 1 1 313
312 99.6 289 92.3 266 85.0
1 2 625
526 84.1 488 78.1
13 625 - 4 4 9 71.9
14 1250 15 1250 16 1250 17 1250 18 1250 19 1250
1152 906 894
930 1405 966
92.1 72.4 71.5 74.4
112
77.3
x * 1042
SD= 201 CV= 19.3%
83.4
O verall M ean
89.6
Standard D eviation
15.3
CV=
17.1%
N 18
^Measured and Percent Recovered values were calculated using MacQuan, version 1.6 software. Manual
calculations may vary slightly.
2 D ie method limit of quantitation (LOQ) in artificial soil was 29.3 mg a.i./kg on a dry-weight basis and was calculated as the product o fthe lowest calibration standard (0.00100 mg a.i./L), the weight/volume dilution factor
of the matrix blank samples (20.000) divided by the percent solids for the test system soil (68.3%).
000238
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-37-
Table 5
Day 14 Recoveries for PFOS in Artificial Soil
Number (454-111-)
Sample
Nominal Concentration
PFOS Concentration (mg a.i./kg)
M easured1
Percent Recovered*
Mean M easured (mg a.i./kg)
M ean Percent Recovery
2 0 0 .0
<LOQ2
-- _ -
2 1 78.1 2 2 78.1
74.9 95.9 80.6 103 8 6 . 2 110.4
23 156 24 156
143 91.4 143 91.7 142 91.1
25 313 26 313
302 96.5 305 97.4 308 98.3
27 625 28 625
532
85.1
634
101
735 118
29 1250 30 1250
1059 1129
84.7
1094
87.5
90.4
O verall M ean:=
96.3
Standard D eviation:-
10.7
CV ==
1 1 .2 %
N>=
10
1 Measured and Percent Recovered values were calculated using MacQuan, version 1.6 software. Manual
calculations may vary slightly.
2 The method limit of quantitation (LOQ) in artificial soil was 29.3 mg a.L/kg on a dry-weight basis and was calculated as the product ofthe lowest calibration standard (0.00100 mg a.i./L), the weight/volume dilution factor o f die matrix blank samples (20,000) divided by the percent solids for die test system soil (68.3%).
000239
ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-38-
Table 6
Day 14 Measured Values for PFOS in Earthworm Tissue
Number (454-111-)
Sample Nominal Exposure
PFOS Concentration (mg a.i./kg)
M easured1
Mean M easured (m ga.i./kg)
W -l
0 .0
<LOQz
-
W -2A W -2B
78.1 78.1
189 195
201
W -3A W -3B
156 156
209 203 196
W -4A W -4B
313 313
240 252 263
W-5 625
1105
-
1 Measured values were calculated using MacQuan, version 1.6 software. Manual calculations
may vary slightly. 2 The method limit of quantitation (LOQ) in earthworm tissue was 50.0 mg a.i./kg on a wet-weight
basis and was calculated as the product ofthe lowest calibration standard (0.000500 mg a.i./L) and the weight/volume dilution factor of the matrix blank sample (100,000 L/kg).
000240
W ildlife International, Ltd.
-39-
Project Number 454-111
METHOD OUTLINE FOR THE ANALYSIS OF PFOS IN ARTIFICIAL SOIL
W eigh approxim ately 10.0 gram s o f each sam ple into a tared w eigh boat. T ransfer to 8 oz. French square bottles. 4
For each sample, m easure 100 mL o f m ethanol w ith a graduated cylinder and transfer into th e French square bottle. 4
Cap bottles and place on shaker table. Allow the sam ples to shake for a m inim um o f 30 m inutes a t approxim ately 250 ipm . 4
Vacuum filter w ith qualitative filter paper and rinse retained soil 3 tim es w ith m ethanol into filtrate. 4
T ransfer the filtrate into a 200-m L volum etric flask and bring to volum e w ith m ethanol. M ix w ell w ith several repeat inversions. 4'
T ransfer approxim ately 20 mL o f each sam ple into a separate glass centrifuge tube or scintillation vial ami cap. Centrifuge sam ples for approxim ately 5 m inutes at 2000 rpm .
4 Prepare appropriate dilution(s) to bring final concentration into the calibration range o f th e LCMS methodology. For all dilutions, use 50% m ethanol: 50% NANOpure w ater dilution solvent, gas-tight syringes,
and Class A volum etric glassware. 4
Am putate sam ples and subm it for LCMS analysis.
F ig u re 1. A nalytical m ethod flow chart fo r the analysis o f PFOS in artificial soil.
000241
W ildlife International, Ltd.
-40-
Project Number 454-111
M ETHOD O U TLIN E FO R T H E ANALYSIS O F PFO S IN EARTHW ORM TISSUE
W eigh approxim ately 1.00 gram s o f each sample into a tared scintillation. 4
Add 10.0 mL o f m ethanol to each sam ple w ith a glass Class A volum etric pipette. 4*
Homogenize each test sample for approxim ately 1 m inute using a hand-held tissue shredder. Rinse the hom ogenizer w ith the appropriate solvents) in between samples. 4
Sonicate each sam ple for approxim ately 5 m inutes w ith a sonic dism em brator. 4
Cap the vials and shake well. Centrifuge the vials at 2000 rpm for approxim ately 5 m inutes. 4
Prepare appropriate dilutions o f study and Q C sam ples to w ithin the calibration range o f the PFOS LC/MS/MS m ethodology w ith 50% NANOpure :50% m ethanol. 4 Amputate sam ples and subm it for LCMS analysis.
F ig u re 2. A nalytical method flow chart for th e analysis o f PFOS in earthw orm tissue.
000242
"Wildlife International, Ltd.
-41-
Area
Project Number 454-111
Figure 3. A typical calibration curve for PFOS (artificial soil). Slope -8981195; Intercept =1011.0532; r =0.994.
000243
Wildlife InternationalLtd.
-42-
Area
Project Number 454-111
Figure 4.
A typical calibration curve for PFOS (earthw orm tissue). Slope =23387; Intercept =2337.9114; r =0.999.
000244
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-43-
PF0S_1
STD 0.00100 m s .fA .
467SA-011O-16
4.98 In 1 period
PFCS No Internai Standard Use Area
1: 4.97 MRM, 298 scans
499.0->99.1
Noise Ttues.
30.0
Quant Thres.
1.0
Min. Width
3
Mutt. Width
6
Base. Width
40
RT Win. (secs) 20
Smooth
1
Expected RT
4.04
Area 10695 Height 1146 Start Time
End Time Integration Width Retention Time
Integration Type
3.67 4.34 0.67 4.00 A -8B
Thu. Nov 29, 2001 05:52
100i 90 80 70 60 SO 40 30 20
to
o4 15
46 67 101 41 01 121 0.09 1.38 2.03
175 206 181 201 2.70 3.37
intensity: 10000 ops
239 241 4.04
203 281 Scan 4.71 Time
Figure 5.
A representative ion chromatogram o f a low-level (0.00100 mg a.i./L ) PFOS standard (artificial soil).
000245
W ildlife International, Ltd.
-44-
PFOS.S
STD 0.0100 mg a .U l
4675A-0t 10-20
4.98 in 1 period
pros No Internat Standard Use Area
1: 4.97 MRM, 298 scans
49S.0->99.1
Noise Thres.
30.0
Quant Thres.
1.0
Min. Width
3
M ult Width
6
Base. Width
40
RT Win. (secs) 20
Smooth
1
Expected RT
4.04
Anta 9991S Height 10171
Start Timo EndTime Integration Whim Retention Time Integration Type
3.70 4.37 0.67
3.99 A -V B
Thu. Nov 29, 2001 00:16
Project Number 454-111
intensity: 10000 eps
Figure 6.
A representative ion chromatogram o f a high-level (0.0100 mg a.i./L) PFOS standard (artificial soil).
000246
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-45-
PFOS 1
S T O 0.500 u g a.i./t
467SA-011D-6
4.98 in 1 period p ro s No Internal Standard Use Area
1: 4.97 MRM. 298 scans
499.0->99.1
Noise Thres.
30.0
Quant Hires.
1.0
M ia Width
3
Mult. Width Base. W idh
6 40
HT Win. (secs) 20
Smooth Expected RT
1 4.05
Area 13949
Height 1470 Start Time
3.77
End Time Integration Width
4.41 0.64
Retention Time
4.05
Integration Type
A -B B
Fri, Dec 14, 2001 12:43
10(H 908070 60 SO 40 30 20 10 o4
intensity: 15000 cps
242
36 74 114 150 178 g l 41 81 121 161 201 241 0.69 1.36 2.03 2.70 3.37 4.04
283 281 Scan 4.71 Tim
Figure 7.
A representative ion chromatogram o f a low-level (0.000500 mg a.i./L) PFOS standard (earthworm tissue).
000247
W ildlife International, Ltd.
-46-
PFOS.5
STD 5.00 U9 a.UL
4875A-011D -t 0
4.98 in 1 period
pros
No Internal Standard
Use Area
1: 4.97 MRM, 298 scans
4 9 9 .0 -> 9 9 .t
Noise Thres. Quant Ihres.
30.0 1.0
Min. W idlfi
3
Mutt. Width
8
Base. Width
40
RT Win. (secs) 20
Smooth Expected RT
1 4.05
-Area 11B40S
Height 12241
Start Time
3.70
End Time
4.29
Integration Width
0.59
Retention Tune
3.94
Intgration Type
A -V B
Fit. Dec 14. 2001 13:07
Project Number 454-111
intensity: 15000 cps
Figure 8. A representative ion chromatogram of a high-level (0.00500 mg a.i./L) PFOS standard (earthworm tissue).
000248
W ildlife International, Ltd.
-47-
PFOS_7 454-111-
MAB-1
ThU. NOV 29, 2001 06:28
4.98 In t period
pros
No Internal Standard Use Area
1: 4.97 MHM, 298 scans
499.0->99.1
Noiso Hires.
30.o
Quant Hires. t.o
Min. Width
3
Mult. Width
6
Base. Width
40
RT Win. (secs) 20
Smooth Expected RT
1 4.04
Area 0 Height 0 Start Time B id Time Integration Width Retention Time Integration Type
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Project Number 454-111
intensity: 10000 eps
Figure 9. A representative ion chromatogram of an artificial soil matrix blank sample (454-111-MAB-l). The arrow indicates the approximate retention time of PFOS.
/ 0 0 0 2 ''9
W ildlife International, Ltd,
-48-
PFOS_7 454-111-
WMAB-1
Fri, Dec 14. 2001 13:20
4.98 in 1 period TOS
No Internal Standard Use Area
1: 4.97 MHM. 298 scans
499.0->99.1
Noise Hires. 30.0
Quant Three. 1.0
Min. Width
3
Mutt. Width
6
Base. Width
40
RT Win. (secs) 20
Smooth
1
Expected RT
4.05
Ana o
Height O
Start Time
0.00
End Time
0.00
integration Width
0.00
Retention Time
0.00
Integration Type
Project Number 454-111
intensity: 15000 eps
Figure 10. A representative ion chromatogram of an earthworm tissue matrix blank sample (454-111 WMAB-1). The arrow indicates the retention time ofPFOS.
000250
W ildlife International, Ltd.
-49-
PFOSJB 454-111-
MAS-2
Thu, Nov 29. 2001 06:40
4.98 In 1 period
TOS No Internal Standard Use Ana
1: 4.97 MRM, 296 scans 499.0->99.1
Noise Thres. Quant H ires
30.0 0 .5
Min. Width MuH. Width
3 6
Base. Width
40
NT Win. (secs) 20
Smooth
1
Expected RT
4.04
Area 35671
Height 3641
Start Time
359
End Time
436
Integration Width
057
Retention Time
4.00
Integration Type
A* - V0
Project Number 454-111
intensity: 10000 ops
Figure 11. A representative ion chromatogram of an artificial soil matrix fortification sample (454-111MAS-2, nominal PFOS concentration of 586 mg a.i./kg, dilution factor = 146413x).
000251
W ildlife International, Ltd.
Project Number 454-111
-50-
PFCS_8 454-111-
WMAS-1
Fri, Oec 14, 2001 13:26
4.S8 in 1 period
pros No Internal Standard Use Area
1: 4.97 MRM, 298 scans
499.0->B9.1 Noise Thres.
30.0
Quant Thres. Mm. Width
1.0 3
M ult Width
B u s . Width RT Win. (secs)
Smooth Expected RT
6
40 20 1 4.0S
Area 22590 Height 2367
Start Time
3.70
End Time Integration Width
Retention Time Integration Type
4.34 0.64
3.94 A-VB
1001
Intensity: 15000 cps
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20 235
10
04
19 81 79 41 81
116 141 176 204 121 161 201
0.69 1.36 2.03 2.70 3.37
278 241 281 Scan 4.04 4.71 Time
Figure 12. A representative ion chromatogram of an earthworm tissue matrix fortification sample (454 111-WMAS-l, nominal PFOS concentration of 100 mg a.i./kg, dilution factor = lOOOOOx).
000252
W ildlife International, Ltd.
-51-
PF0S_13 454-111-
Thu, Nov 29, 2001 07:04
4.98 In 1 period
pros
No Internal Standard
Use Area
1: 4.97 MRM. 298 scans
489.0->99.1 Noise Thres.
30.0
Quant Ihres. 1.0
Min. Width Mutt Width Base. Width
3 6
40
RT Win. (secs) 20
Smooth
1
E je cte d RT
4.04
Area 23883
Height 2478
Statt Time End Time
3.69 4.36
Integration Width
0.67
Retention Time
3.99
Integration Type
A - SB
Project Number 454-111
intensity: 10000 ops
Figure 13. A representative ion chromatogram of an artificial soil test sample (454-111-2, nominal PFOS concentration of78.1 mg a.i./kg, dilation factor = 29283x).
000253
W ildlife International, Ltd.
-52-
PF0S.1 454-111-
W-2A
Ftl, Dec 14, 2001 13:38
4.98 in 1 period PROS
No Internal Standard Use Area
1: 4.97 MRM, 298 scans
499.0->99.1
Noise Hues. 30.o
Quant Hues. 1.0
Mk). Wktth
3
Mutt. W kitli
6
Basa. Widtti
40
RT Win. (secs) 20
Smooth
1
Expected FIT 4.05
Area 46847 Height 4953
Start Time End Time
Integration Width Retention Time integration Type
3.70 4.37
0.87 3.94 A-BB
Project Number 454-111
Intensity: 15000 cps
Figure 14.
A representative ion chrom atogram o f a n earthw orm tissue test sam ple (454-111-W -2A, dilution facto r= lOOOOOx).
000254