Document Z4Dw0mQvRRLy09XZOgZmQeeaJ

FILE NAME: Colgate (COL) DATE: 1976 Mar 11 DOC#: COL009 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: Meeting Minutes - CTFA Talc Task Force Us- N TlieCosmetiq, Toiletry arid Fragrance Association, Inc. 1133 15th STREET, N.W ., WASHINGTON, O .C . 20005 < Z2/33-177Q TELEX 83-2673 James a Merntt Prtaftfert Norman F. Estrin. Ph 0. W e * n it t f a r t - -r*nc* HlIOTES C7FA T A L C .TASK FORCE A meeting of -the CTF Talc Task Force was held on March .11th, 1976 i at th CTF offices in Washington, D.C. Those in attendance were: {Jearge Sandland, Bristol-Myers Company (chairman) J o h n E * Clements, Pfizer, Inc. Ray Krammer, Whittaker, Clark & Daniels . George Lee, Johnson .& Johnson Baby Products Company Monroe Messinger, Chesebrouqh-Poftd`s Inc. Roderick A . Mundy, Sterling Drug Inc. ' Louis D. Marino, Cyprus Industrial Minerals Company 'D.Ri Pefcterson., Johnson & Johnson Baby Products Company Fred Rpesch, Whittaker, Clark & Daniels Robert Rolle, Johnson & Johnson Baby Products Company John P. Schelz, Johnson & Johnson Baby Products Company Maurice Siegel, Fahrge, inc. . " J,C. .Simko, Jr., Colgate-Palmolive' Company Rdrold Stanley, Pfizer, Iiio. Ian Stewart; Walter c> Mcfqne Associates-. Robert Suffis, The Nennen Company . : S, Thompson, R-T. Vanderbilt & Company j J o h n J . Travers, Avon Products, Inc. I William C. Waggoner, Johnson & Johnson Baby Products Comoany Norman F. strin, CTFA . Kr. Sandlnd opened the meeting and proceeded with th agenda. 1. Status Review l A. Talo ^'[ -- s. ~tan- d- a- rds, and Methods 1" ' " r - j Copies of th- proposed specification and methods, plus I copis of a letter to Dr. Schaffner eere distributed j to task forc members. ! B. status report (dated March 8fchr..1976) , prep.r.hl by. '. s Petterson^on cosmetic talc states was distributed I tc> those present. * a copy of ah article by \jI : CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE QE-CPC2-00000036 Ot ,: Bohl and Dr., Arthur M. Langpr on '`Identification and Quantitation of Asbestos in Talc* was distributed it appears iri Environmental Health Perspectives,. i ' Volume , 1974, pp. 9.5`109. .Also* a copy of the correction to the M a r c h -8,. 1976 Washington Post article bn talc and the summary, of the.draft Talk Paper anticipated from S I the FDA was distributed to those present. C. L 6 w i n .Samples ' t Sp ' Mr. Sandiahd summarized.the contents pf the November, If 1975 letter from Henry DaVis (FD) requesting C T F A . apply -its methodology to several of Dr. Lewin samples '_?I provided on a coded-basis* The results of the analyss were described bv Dr. Rolle. . 2 Mt., Sinai Analyses on.Old Production Samles Dr. Pettrsoh gav detailed background b n Dr, Langer*f work. He stated the objective of the task force should be to de velop and collate data that would lead to presentacin before the Miscellaneous External Panel, in. order to attempt to have talc placed in Category I. The results of Dr. Pooley' 3 analyses.,, sponsored by Johnson s Johnson, were summarized. * It was reported that Dr. Langer performed his anavlses on sam ples- purchased in 1973. M r . Simko described a meeting between himself and Dr. Langer on. T u e s d a y . Ha estimated the samfle of "Cashmere Boucut" tst-d w a s probably a. pre-1970 sample. . M r . -MirndV (sterling) reported on his contacts with Dr. Langer and stated the sample Dr. Langer tested was from 1970 production. 3. Recent Production Data It was agreed by the task force that .it would be extremaly beneficial if induvidual companies, could provide data to the FDA.on recent production. Most coMpanieb present indicated that they possess such data, and would bp willing to provide the data. Mr* Massinger (Chesebrough-Pbhd's ) stated' he would have to confirm this willingness with his management. It was suggested each compahy prepare a letter,, addressed to Dr. Estrin, with a summary of the data on recent production for their products and a commitment to set-up a subseement meeting w i t h FDA to discuss this data, in datail, if f d a so desires. This letter should be delivered to Dr. Estrin by Monday, March I5th. Subsequently, a meeting was set-up for that Monday, March 15th, at- the CTFA offices, with a meeting at F D A to be held in .the afternoon. . 4. CTFA Study on Current. Production QE-CPC2-00000037 Advantages and disadvantages-of bavina uTFA contract an in dependent laboratory to do tests on current pfoluctioi sam ples was discussed. It was noted that, such data Would no doubt be useful, not only in discussions with FDA, but ^Iso as part of a presentation to the Miscellaneous External Fane) and, perhaps, to other panels as well; it was suggested the CTFA methodology be utilized for such a task, but that TEM be used on those samples that have been shown to be positive COfiTINt'ED ON NEXT FACE QE-CPC2-00000038 DOST # LEWIN- # P RODUCT . 1518 1339 1340 1341 1342 1343 1344 1345 1346 1347 1348 1349 1350 1351 1352 72 77 96 97 101 102A 143 144B 151 154 157.A 160 163 75 173A .Lady Ester Face Powder, Rachel Touch and Glow Face Powder Blanchard's Ousting Powder Born'Wild Dusting Powder, Del Labs Tai Winds Spray Talc, Avon Tosca Dusting Powder Pln-Zow Talque, Perf. Beauty Prod. Overton's ."High Brown" Face Powder Early American Old Spice Talcum Powder Bismoline Medicated Powder Mavis. Imported Talcum Avon Beauty Oust Refill ~ Charisma Pinaud Clubman Talc 0H1 de London Talc. Yardley Corsage Dusting Powder TREMOtITE L E W T N ..D O S T X-RAY 10M1 CHRYSOTltt I E T N ' fltfT X-RAY NO 2,800 f/mg. ND ND 3 5,600 ND 7 8 13,000 10 - 12 60,000 15 ND 15 8,900 ND ND 10 1,800 7 ND 5 400 10 - 5 ND ? ND fD 2,000 ND - 2 9,000 ND ~ 6 ND 8 ND NO 9,000 trace ND 10 ? 10 - NO - ND ? NO ND 7 7 by CTFA methodology and also be performed on a random basis on other 'samples. Company representatives were Tolled at this meeting and previously by Mr. George Lee to determine whether they would be. willing to. participate in such a study by assur ing that current production samples would be provided and that financial support.would be given. The results would be made known to the FDA arid probably published in some form. The following companies indicated they would be willing to parti cipate AvOri.Products, Inc, Bristol-Myers Company Colgate-Palmolive Company C o t y ,iric. Faberge -r Inc. . Johnson & Johnson Mermen Sterling In addition, Chesebrough-Porjd's , Mem,' and Yard ley would probably be. interested. The task force agreed to await the results of the meetinas with CTFA before deciding on whether a study on current produc tion should be initiated. . The meeting adjourned in order for a .small group to meet with FDA at 2:00 p.m. to discuss the results of CTFA analyses of Dr. Lewin's samples. / /L 4 A ' norman ?. Estrin, Fh.D, Vice President - Science NFEi.jj March 12th, 1976 QE-CPC2-00000039