Document YGVQ7DJaB6XDxLbvEYZ1j6J2E
FILE NAME Newspaper & Magazine Articles NMA
DATE 1967 Dec 26
DOC NMA010
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Washington Post - New Cancer Cause Puzzle to
Doctors
Puzzle w
Cancer
Cause
Cause
; .
Middlesex General Hospital in , New Brunswick N.J. a few
miles from the nation's
. Tuesday Dec. 26_ 1967
| Puzzle to Doctors largest asbestos plant one
No state lists the disease in
. that employs 5000 workers
its workmen compensation
In the past three years no laws so nobody afflicted with
By THOMAS O'TOOLE
Washington Post
WASHINGTON
A fatal
cancer of the chest and
abdominal cavities is cropping
up
antong
the
nation's
asbestos workers
So rare that 20 years ago it
wasn't even in
textbooks The
the medical
cancer
is
called Mesothelioma and
disease brought on by years of breathing asbestos dust
Dr. Selikoff also found that 45 of the mean had died of
lung cancer a rate 6.6 times higher than that in the normal adult male population Even more surprising he found five deaths due to Mesothelioma This incidence of more than
1 percent said Dr. Selikoff
fewer than 19 cases ol
Mesothelioma passed through Middlesex General Only two
of the 19 were not workers at
the nearby asbestos plant one a woman who apparently inhaled asbestos dust in
laundering her work clothes the spinster who lived
husband's second a one block
from the plant
it can be paid damages for his
affliction Even now the first
test cases are in the courts '
where they may conceivably |
stay for the next five to 10
| years The fact that nobody knows |
how much exposur to
asbestos can bring on the
disease
has
created
controversy too
seems almost peculiar to is strikingly high for tumor A relatively new disease Most laws stipulate that
people exposed to asbestos
which is generally considered Mesothelioma is also one of asbestos workers be in an
Ironically those with the deadly
stricken disease
to be extremely rare
Dr. Selikoff then launched a
the most difficult diseases
confront modern medicine
to environment where there is no
more
than
five
million
include a nurse whose father
worked in an asbestos plant
and a man who handled
asbestos for no more than a
.
month
while
he
insulated
the
plumbing in his own house Mesothelioma was first
spotlighted in 1960 when
South African doctor found 32
cases among the people living
follow study
consecutive deaths
of 307 among
It is almost impossible to
treat Middlesex General's Dr.
asbestos insulation workers Maxwell Borow says that even
throughout Northeast surprise
the whole
Again to his
he turned up 10
the most potent cancer drugs have no effect on it
About all that radiation
deaths due to Mesothelioma treatments do he says is
About the same time the remove some of the fluid that
the Pennsylvania
State
builds
Department of Health began a
in
in the lunlgungss from
particles of asbestos dust per
one cubic foot of air - a
regulation that many in the.
asbestos industry fought years
to get approved But with Mesothelioma the disease might be brought on by exposure to as little as one-
tenth or hundredth that
and working in the Cape of blind study to find how "
disease
100
percent limit We're really over a
disease is 100 percent
The Good Hope asbestos fields Mesothelioma
might
be fatal Dr. Borow states
barrel on this one states one
up and Alerted to the probletihins affecting the more than 5000
doctor usually takes less than a year
Because
we
don't
same doctor turned up 57 asbestos
workers
scattered after diagnosis to run
know how much exposure
its more cases in the next two about the state
causes the disease we don't
course To 162 hospitals in the
it it know what to recommend
years many
Southeastern part of the state
Nobody knows why it Despite obstacles like these
Nobody knows how many
attacks
have had they sent a questionnaire
some
asbestos research has begun in a
Americans Mesothelioma Even today asking the hospitals to report workers and not others or handful of places to find out
the all Mesotheliomas diagnosed why some victims of
more about the ailment
doctors have trouble spotting
1958 and 1963
disease get it after an Mount Sinai's Dr. Scheff is
it - whether they're trying to
_
: it in a person still
between Back came 42
documeanppt areentdly
mild exposure University
to now constantly monitoring the
of
Asbestos
diagnose
11 asbestos alive or pin it down at an
cases of the disease only
The
1500 members of the Medicine
of which could not be traced : Michigan School of
Workers
Union in
autopsy
studies in to asbestos exposure
cites one case of a man who metropolitan New York The
In three separate
_
Ten victims of the disease was exposed to asbestos for Philadelphia local of the same
the last three years doctors
about a month while he
turned out to be men who
union has started a sinular
in three states have turned up worked in asbestos plants insulated his house Six years
71 cases Oddly 11 of them
lived to have had no real
Eight were people who
later he was Mesothelioma
dead
of program
Hospital
with
Hahneman
to uncover more
appeared
to
asbestos
The
near asbestos plants most of
* exposure other 60 could all be traced
their
lives
Three
were
Even the nature of the information
to asbestos contact either members of families who had disease is little understood Middlesex General's Dr.
' worked with it one or more asbestos worke Whirle it's generally known that 7 Borow says that he is in the '
because they lived with people who did or
members
a three the disease attacks the lining process of setting up a
in lived
neighborhoods where girl whose father was an of the chest and abdomen traveling exhibit to bring
'
the air was heavily laden with asbestos engineer a nurse nobody knows how it gets . attention to the disease He's
asbestos dust
whose father had worked for there
i
doing
it
with a
3500
dollar
The first American study 35 years in an asbestos plant
When
asbestos
dust
is grant from the Papermakers
was one run in 1964 by Dr. and a woman with two sons inhaled the fibers get trapped - Union which represents the
Irving J. Selkkoff of New who worked as asbestos in the lungs where they form asbestos workers in the New
York's Mount Sinai Hospital insulators in a shipyard
gummy deposits This Jersey plant Dr. Borow
who began the study to see if
Of 10 deaths which seemed explains how asbestosis gets studied
cancer in any way affected questionable asbestos started and perhaps even It wasn't easy getting the
the lives of the asbestos exposures two turned out to lung cancer One theory is money Dr. Borow went to 40
_
insulation workers in the New York Metropolitan area
Tracing the lives of C32 members of the asbestos
workers union who were on the union rolls before Jan. 1
be almost bizarre One was a Swiss cheesemaker who worked almost his entire life around a large boiler covered with Asbestos insulation that flaked off at the touch
that that
the gummy substance builds up around the
asbestos fiber lodged in
| lung
can
cancer elsewhere in
cause
the body
the ;
But
how does it do it Nobody -
organizations before he got it including the American
Cancer Society and the Public
Health Service Any attention the disease
gets might come ---- ----too
1943. Dr. Selikoff found that
255 of them had 1. 1963
Some of what
died by Jan
,
he found did
not surprise him - that 12 of
the 255 died of asbestosis a
Another was a worker in a brewery where it turned out that beer is filtered through pulp filters made essentially of cotton fiber and asbestos
The most convincing study
knows
.
:
Becausiet is such a new
and little understood disease
Mesothelioma is
some
serious
also creatin~
social
and
us
economic problenis
com
soon More than 1 million tons of asbestos is consumed these days in the US with more than 3000 separate uses being reported for the growing
fibe
known but decreasingly fatal due to antibiotics
is the most recent one conducted by a team of
a ARCH 18745