Document XRVM5k7p6xbOn48EnZYxnDY6w

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company Frederick H. Ecker, President New York City Anthony J. Lanza, M.D. Assistant Medical Director March 20, 1931 Mr. Allan Hardwall 15 Broad Street New York City Dear Mr. Hardwall: Herewith is the report of the asbestos study. This is the summary report of the American plants studied. The Canadian summary report will be forthcoming shortly. In this report the plant of the Johns-Manville Company at Manville, N.J. is designated as Plant A. I am also sending a copy to Mr. Sayer and if you wish additional copies, please let me know. Needless to say, I will be very glad to discuss this report or amplify any portions of it if you so desire. It is, of course, understood that this report is confidential and it will be given no publicity by us except with the consent of the firms concerned. After you have had a chance to go over it, I should like the opportunity of discussing with you and your associates the question of publication. With best regards and assuring you of my sincere appreciation of your unfailing assistance which made this report possible, I am, Sincerely yours. Enc. A.J. Lanza, M.D. Assistant Medical Director. V Metropolitan Lots Insurance Company ' NiwUbu Cm Axron i.uu.iki. <Umx<U<W8wlw wxk to, ua iUu Vardaall* IS fe-oad Stmt, a* lark City Bmur Sr. luitilli brntth la ttt nport tf tla utwW m. Wj la tba asaaary raport af tbs Aaariasa plart* stadlad. Xba CatwMta 1MU7 rjtrt will to rortteoKLac sbarUy U this r*pcn tba plajrt oC tba Jrhni fcrrMli Oa^ur t hvrllla, > J. Is daalgaatad aa run i. X u tXaa sarnllac a oejf ta Ik. Sara' sad if yoo wlsb additional aopiM, plaaaa 1st aa kaoa. IxsUxm Vo aay Z will ba wwy (ltd to dlanai this tapuci or aapllfr u? portiaao of it if yon M daalra. It la, of tmt, taianUoj tbit till raport is act fidaatlal ud it sill ba {lm aa pabllslty by * a*oapi wit* tk anwnirrl of tla firm amt road. Iftor 70a bswa bad a aha ana ta (a awar It, I abnald lika tbs 099arVaxO.br of dltwring wit* fa Pitb baat rogaida aad aaaorlsc yon of y adatian of pwar aafatlU< aaoirti aaa akin* wmA* tidJl n X aa, <r. J*s.. __ xrrxrrr ct rn aona or AiWTaa dost xi uai or taura ntou IMuirUl ImJU kmit NUixkiUiri Sarvlta tartu latrapalltu lift Zutnati Coayaay lit Yark : II ;I SSSSSSBESSSSSS Qi Mtkora rlil ta cjmi tkilr lUatn lliiti ti tU Uni at tleil la -wt till arady >ullU, tfjiiuil; Ui ifriiUU ui Myliriti af ttt ulutii (HptaUi vka m>nti4 ( tk> fiUnt vtnt aM pr avary ZMlllty far aacmrl&f ttU. Um ta Sr. Tuatut af Ui gainnltf $t fiucl- mil far Ml lltaml ud nlaAla adrlia la Utiiyritlci X-rv fUu aat ta Sr. 9. T. lirlaattar, Baitad lUlai Mill laalt* larriaa, i* Ctefi af til Baltad Itataa luiu af Siaaa Cairmtln Cllsla la Milir, ntlihnaa. mat lataryratatlaa af all Ua X-ray fllaa llitit la tlla rvyart la fiUmd. Alaa te 8r. T. Attar Salta, aad Sr. luiill lyaak af CSaritataa, S.C. far la* far-Mtlwa aa< adrlea, yartlaaltrly aa ta tla f*Uila(7 af aataataala;* ta Sr. W. V. Tilt af Qi/laitat, I.C.; ta Sr. /aaa)A I. tyatt af Imrt, X.T., ud Sr. X. X. Salim af lav Taft, far aaalatla* la Utiryrittai X-ray fUaaa; > ta l'r Till 0. Snasa af Luiuur, h,; ta Sr. Z. Z. Stmuit af SaarlHi, Qvataa, Canada; ta Si. 1. 0. dardiar ud Kr. >ult X. Cwl nj af knau Ulmtiry, vka Sara udiruku Ui a lady af tla ?atAalalaal ifTn'.i af Ua Utalatln af ulutia iut Unm atlaal ccparlaaatatlaa, HU Ua ud af (rut fiaa Ui lalnyallUa Ufa Imvuii Couyaay. *Aakai*.aaia Badlaa la Syatta ana land, ta&aalk B. lyul, 1.0. aod T. A Salts. S.S., CbarlMtit, S.I., Tainal af Aaarlaaa bdlul Aaaaalatlaa, U(Ut 10, H, til. ti, Xa. , >. UI*U1. I< r _* 01731 c a jrva'r . . t:.* rr- .-varohu .*. #*/ * ^ r* a . . . .T .rr . . sJ rj i?- * i-Tll . 1 % , -- * . < rf *w ,- f .'u : _. ., ' " ' ri - - utbopcct;s Za X*S* tha latrtyalltaa Ufa Znaumaaa Caayaay au ajyroachtd Vy flna rapraaantLad tha aaVaataa lndnatry la tha Ualtad Stataa vltb tit ra^aaat that ahyjlaaie and? ha aaUa af that ladoat77. tit afflalala ra;rtaaatla tlMt flnaa vara iaalrau af uaarulalac If ulaataa that au as aie-rpatlaaal haaard La thalr ai ulUUaatli had, If aa, Mat na tha antnra ef til a basard hat ihval l >a ivaa Va }rarui ar aaatrsl It. iiait thla tlaa aararal artlalaa had ajyaarad la lacllah aailttl JaaraaXa Cararthlaf a panaaoalaala dma ta aaVaataa tut. Alla la ait ar rva laalatad laataaaaa tha aaararraaaa af thla tjy* af jnruaooaalaa W had >ata daaarlVad La Aaarlau Journal*, tha laduatry ltaalf aptirai ta Va tan* on* lafara4 af tha axlataaaa af aBT aoaryatlooal dlaaaaa. Tha haaard af a 111 oa tut with ayaalal rafaraaoa ta tha last* haa lead Vat# ayyraaUtad ud a (raat daal af atndy ui raaaaroh haa Vtaa ayyllad ta tha atlloa Cut jroblaa, yrlaartly la tha atal alaltif Lada* try, la Oraav Sntlaa, tha Oaltad Vtataa, tha Srltlah Saalalaaa, a wall aa la wthar e'-.ustftaa. Tha aatnra af tha affaata af alllaa dmat arpraaaad la tha tara *alltaeala,l vlth tha raraltaht axtruordlaary yradltpaaltla* ta pulaaaary tthanulaali, la anil Qtat affaata haaa Vaaa utttUVai arlth tha lahalatla* af tut aamtalh- Lac fraa alllaa la Tama* aaaaata. Tha affaata ay aa tha yulaasary ttaroa af duata caatalclBd aaaVlaad alllaa - alllaataa - ara atlll a fanila flald far Idraatlfalias. Vat avldaaca la aaeuvulatlad that aartala af thaaa duata yradaaa pathslecUal raaulta tulta dlatla:*. fraa tnia allleaala. i - * *- a * V- * r. * 01732 * /W;'-* '&***- I V-- 3- .tn ; * -uaavogf v *- vr Vii* #r>- > ,-%*.,Jk. . \ * '* <-- r -- I I'Za % > ' i I Ac* -v*k < --r*r --cr ri; t >. 1J :.* - Tic uai ubutoili Ui bun t;;Utd to Ui jotaaoocclooU uutd 37 ubtilci tut ut it tUl ka utt 1a tUi rryort. ataliiU;, tka ubtiut f taatrtt la a hj-4rt>4 avpiilai ellloata aoulctL&c prlsertl? of llll* 44.1* breccia 43.Of Tatar U.H Alia farrow Iraa tat alokel era yratul la nail putlttu. Till iNatnUl varlet? af aakaatea aaat coastal? aaevastaro4 la tiiLfutat ea akrjoatlla ut . la an at Ui faar varlatloa of tka Laeral aa^attia, La 01*1 It maw 11r oararo La aaaai. 21 alatll ka karma la aLo4 tkat allloaala (aa4 )rai*tl? aakoatarla) terelaye 0017 alroly, taller froa fire ta flftaam Mt arma tomet? ar tmt7floa ratio to kacaat tiUbllabit. Ti'i mta ofyrofraea la Lafl*iate4 aelalr kr-tka totaya af all-.ra Ulek tka lane a receive act tkla 4ettrt, La tara, tyuti te*a Ikraa OLTlaklee: tka asoast ef alllea la tka Itil, tka (aaatltr af teat la tka air, aat tka stilt af aopevaro. lailTltoC 141aara:raar L(kl ka laeladat aa a feurlk rarlakla; keve-rer, llttla la kaoaa af tka venatlaaa La aueiftlbUll; La lien axpaocc ta aaat. Tkara 4aaa aat appear ta ka proa aat, La >1imi ttin aakcataa la aLaat .* fakrlsatad La Xartk latritt, tko eleafoat cllalaal picture vtlek la aa aeecapakle La caaowltlaa oltk a trua alllcaala kaiart, araak aa kart rvak a La Lee eeww.ltlea. It ai^i ka U(it tkat loci af tka aakaataa >liata arm af taa recent arl(Lc far tka typical affattaaf a alllaata twt ta keeose car.lfaat, kit tkla tktary vault not tp;lf ta tka iltir a Lace ar ta all of tko fakrleatla r ?laa*.o. Tu lMu'.rlcl lull! inl: of tit IcircpeUiac Life luuucc -"--air' r_>- *. <* 01733 c' r-- ycoa ' vc J'-- r-IA } D3iT AWDEL8 *!! Ayt-orotu QAd littoO f Iwvllu: SotA tii la? lac* r (1) *a& tbo olootrlo proclpltatar (S) ro uo4 for tii uUiitUi of air u;lii, for tut*, At ttt trullLac lrrold ut La iIim proxlaity to Ui ttnam, Bath of Utn fcraa if ipvttu at* adapt#* for til* nr*, u Uij at* tnurtriAtli, HiUr lit ) aa! UJoitoC far tit tail nc of tka.air onoplot At tit ynyir lml, aoA or* mrwiiy imilni. So laplaror otllooto tbo tut by 0071 rotLac tbo Air aat Hob La* ylifltc It iitt a rut nrfui nrtnl by a Ufilt La a aoatalAor. tko U(tU uod w ilotLlla* wtir, ULUtBlit to yorcnv CetkoVu ymut tii Utlen of oeao of ti< tuu, yorttnlwly U7 ollloo oklil Lc#t to yrtiut. So IniBoir ou Aitutil *1 u oUctrleally firins r::i!7 jury .- tir roto rf Air ouylM no o*nrt by aooao of a roolotaaeo typo of floo Aotor olti aa Uellaot AAAanotor ft: aiuimi til prunri Alfforoaco. Uol ourpli ropro* ntf tto toot ol1o<it*4 fro* a film of 100 coble foot of aLr. fit oloctrte proelplvotar lo duLcsod ipu tbo Cot troll proclpltator priotlplo wot for roovrorLac <uto aa4 fnio touarolally. Sit prlAclplt tipom oa olootrlfyiLC tti dut portlclto by tin put Uritfi aa olostrootAtle fltl< ui tin nuU( tiu to oottlo cot p> tint of oollo* lol4. So oloolroototlo fltll ?t oot op by soaao of o troaoforoor opontlac fro* tAo U|itU( lLaot oa ISO rolto, Alto rutLac aorroat. ALr lo troaa tiroofi ui AppATOtu by aooao of a oaaII rotojy fAa, ru by a aotor, So fiutlty bo Lac II *Coparatlbo fotto of laatrmoe*.; fer Botomialoc Ataaopborto Butt*, mill Suits Snilotla So. ltd, Tnuwy OipAnaiat, buAiBctoo, D.C. ^ (I) OotoralAAtloa of Supootoida b7 Alto mot lac*Con-oat Sroolpitatorv*, plillp OrLaSor oae Sobort I. Seatoa, Jooiul or ladutrlol Xyjltat, Tol. T7I, jL. A, Jua, lilt. | c - 4- ,'4 s* .*,?* :u v O' C 4. .- j-- xr i , -a *;* -3* * . saasvrad bp Miu af 3 fin aatar. (w;lii af <ut trashed froa Vmjj ul yip*lla naar tba call Is* alsa vara aaoarad far ikn'.:C All aasplaa aara ahlypad ta Ui Isdu trial Xxclaaa Utnlo<7 af tha Batrepelltac asd the Alt eecats csda asaardls* ta tha (1) ciVhoU esoapted >7 the 0.8. Bareaa ef Blaea asd the 0.1. Ptblle Xealth Barrloe. Hmolai U a laa p va MO mi erase la It* iTMtilt diameter vara atat. leal ualjiii vara a>4a far tatal (fraa auad eaablaed] elllaa atssrd* Uf ta LSa soerpted atanrtari aatM ef IlUatraat.l)) ?>ren'.t|i fraavaerf af ?u-tlela Slat: Za tla flrat Bias*, atadtea (1) etlp pmrtlolea 20 alarau asd uadsr la i It a vara ec"rted. ft has b*s 4<ri:Aitnta4 rifutatlf Utt as allied pmrllelad excaadltd IS <Ur;u - a aiircu <twli one-eVillasth pan af a aatar ar aaa IrhaasasdUl pan af a alllLaatar - la grastaat diameter, aatar tla las* tlaraa, 2sd far Utla raaaac Ut larger partlalaa UU..) ara sat rota 141rad itia deter* isLtlsd tut aaar.ta. Later, at It appeared froc aaca af til pabllahed anlalaa(4) SfVtgllat) that ututaa ptniclaa aaek 1 a rje r La alia vara feud 1s leaf tlaraa, It vs* t:ttr. t: ccth*. all panlrlaa asd un differar.lisl :ie;t :t all llsaa IS alersaa aad vsdar. Pall avarpln aelletted bp tSa Lap Laser asd the alaatrla prealpltater vara vacated. isrepkete*rapbe af these tut panicles vara fmrtbe* ealarged By helaj projected spas a atraaa >f aaast ef a laatars altda prvjeettr, the aalupK partlalaa tala* aaararad Vlth a rtltr. Xnevlnc the aatlra eslaifeaeat Cb7 aetaal (1) CocyaraUva Taata ef Xaatraanta far Betermlalad Atsaatsarla Cute*, Pmblle Zaalts Bulletin Be. 244, ?reassT7 Sepanvent, lasSlsftea, P.f. *Tte l. alya'la e' Siilsata atl Carbonate fates*, .. Xlllebrmtd, Pull at la 4U '.'.S. Oaolefleal Surrey, faaalxftea, S.C. I ,4) *pulxeBar7 Abeatol*. V. X. Cocke, British Badleal Jeornal, Deo amber 9, I; 01/36 / .\ c \ . -1. WT MJtraul), It *u Htr t ulttUU thi trtlul ytrUelt iU(.(t) *T Ut u*.*f Ium'i () lHvltlala >r*WMllty jjr, ta* ItprlUM *f U< fuatl** t* V* wmnt la tu< mii Uirtu * arc ylttttt aa trilattu ;. .* . a --d . 4# sU . - * H*tM< ttt jrtMUlt; f mvTUM u nUtu. lUct tk< 11a* 1* trtiikt, tir>UttM ud latr)tUUM tt ttilrid r*cl*a it futliuitt. & uCnti tn rt^trud la UUl )*nuiM yr it>li fnl *ad ala* la ta* *imiiidlit nL0t af Ut tut la iini{Tiu. Star* la aa laCl*ttC 'X#ji**V*.a<- .* Sii rtUtltuU) Wtnu Ui tut mill ut Ut itrrtoUi| nlikti. C- T: 'liiiiXj; ; *\. - *4 M I ^ a* . *<* r:: .. r iHutll;, Ut Miflu ut ut LatlaCaC La Lha UMjiUhi la tUt ry*n. Mil I. 1 tkm lr )lutt ut >y tiftranti Ut cut count ta tUllu jj-tlol* >tr ttlit f**t tt air. ttt ylaata LaalaCaC ar* all la Ut Cnllit lutu aaC art aalair it a tartlit utan. It Till Va a*t*4 Utt ut gmtt la plaat A ara af jrtlel*t 10 airrta* aaC udtr, rail* la Ut cta*r ;laatt all ta* partleltt *rt aauataC. ItTtrtatl***, direct tta^irlMi la *. -x ;ii.' ) * **r*duc u' :. 4 paaaltla, u U u aaaryl* taJua r Ui asmar af partltlta 10 aBLtrau aaC utir latt 'u. M pare cat af ta* tmelt, ttitt Mill It trlCart alt* Utt if r*rrC t* Cut centre! w# ara tcaatraaC aalj alt* ta* i--V)r iuu. It la alt* laptrtut t* aet* ta*t tttrut ta* Cut la ta* Jn^rttlu " ^ J i.:-.* r*a la tnttlttUf all tu* t* utiitii, ta* oactrarr La ta* iui ta ta* ttaar Ct|*rcMti. la ta* cardiac, aplaslac *ad *a*ltc mu utuui It tUtt St yr tut. af ta* Material u*C. 0a tpeeia! jilt ta* ytrmut* *f uVuut m; a* () 0r**a, X. *A n>oloMlcro|Tpfcie IiUi: fcr ta* Betendaatlu *r r*j-ii#l* (It* tt Palat v>4 Xafc^ar ?Lu#et*V Journal Tranklm laatttate, l*li, itt, tJT. (t) TMpf'.c, 0%S. - Vital Steileii:*, Jefcn *ll#r 4 Sou, I.T.. HS1, j. til. -- < r**> ** 01737 c . #.* -I- oaomcxi xx tsa rum tta yraaaaata la Uh jluVt rara rarj alaliar Vt aattt* ailla La (UMrtl. Tar tUwtntiti, tta yntMi la Uu >r<jartUii ra-aa if flat X la OuilM *t IhcU: liWitai la nMlni la tap aad Uni an ryaa tta Mur aad tta wtaaUt la itanlta lata y<< ailla ui rn fir ttati fl tiaui la ardar la irul aad 17a tta nim. Trie ttara tta utiiui la akrralad lata trull aad ttaalad arrar la Wyyarr tltt alttar karlMtal ar Ttrtlaal ayaaira, alailar la ttaai uta la tta taztlla alUi. Altar yaaalac ttmk tta eyaaar, tta mtarlal la dlaakarfad lata tnita. faata aaaXai.taria* tttarlal la first m Ump a pnat aaaVna aad Uaitarpl lata to.aka ttlafc ara rhaalad rr*r ta tta apaaars aad tta aatarlal la r*4 U:ta ttaaa la ^ tta aaaa aaaaar aa tta baa aatarlal. Til aatarlal, ifti: '.alaf dlashar|al froa tta arytaar 1* yjt onto a Tikratlaa ar altJcLac aaraac Ibin tta lerj ntm an jiatoad aff *T a rartlaa kata aad liars lata a tla ta ta uta ipit La ttxtllaa. tta . atari fltraa fall lx* ttrea^h tta aaraaa m a:ttar aald aa net ar uta la urirt aa aaVaataa aaaaaat. Tta aattta la raoalrad la talaa, ayaaad, aad tan raa tlmp rartlaal ryaaars. !( la Uiatartta lata truta. tta flllad traaka fraa tta aarttaal aad fcarliaatal ayaaara aaalelal&c alttar tta aaWataa fltra, taa aattaa ar tta auU aatarlal art truiptnta ta aayarmta iiirtfi tlaa. u Bitata, ttaaa aatarltlt ara raithad aad daayad cat# tta flaar In >rayartiaa ta tta aistara daalrad aad tta raatltla* alaad aatarlal* art ttaa paaaad Untp 1i _; -T - -,`4^ J 01740 c Y-- - 10 - tfri.Tr ?. >n il a--a a Jj . a ; * 4rr`_jj3fc ii : S- irva:... .. ... r a: V< ft* "fl-IT . * .*T <1 ;,,* l twiTJ..: .Jaahrm i:: l.'4M *. . ft alxl&t plakar. in thia elrttra 1 dlaahftrgad froa tha plekar, It It rpry~d vtth llftit ftUirtl ell. b ftfttftrlftl is ttra pmatti iiw ftattulnl eo- teyer ftftd Ulr to ttt iUn<f kU la tkt mK r*oa. Tea f Utti airtrn plak<ra seta this seurry*r >7ftu, while t third -- nhfne 1* attippad TlU * (wild dart a a ttiik essrsyt tk* antarial tc ft tint* kl* la ttt urt rra. & *V*i 1 ftf ttt tn >7itiM la ta feollltate tha head1! lac af ttt ptln if afttarlftl at the um tine. ftli third --white la mat o<Uppod with a all a>ray. &e ehjset if tfta tlx fjnj la pn--rlly ta antra* tkt --all ash eaten flkrti end hold than anaafthad la tha eottaa fthre tkmtknt tkta )nmiM if arllit, qUolaii tmlai. Zaoldeatftllr, It la apparent that It ala* UUilikii tha ftftccat if <ut. Tha --tarlal la --rated with ftknt par at. f *11 at thla paint, hat >7 tha tlaa It raaahaa tha 1m tha all haa dlalnlshnd ta lata than 1 par aaat, Vhlla ftlaarnl all m maad la tha jnftntlia raaa of plant 0, It qtmU; ui aat ai iffluiliu aa la plant 1. la plant I all na tat uti, aar na thara any attaapt at hsaldlflaatlaa ar any ryitaa af dant aaftaaitln*. Cardiac aehlnaa vara fad he h.-.1. Zc plant A thara an a hoaldlfplac, TAtu fttine an* hftfttlnd lyitaa, AUi la plant 1 nataral kr--ldlty nffliid far tha preaaaa. Za plant X tha aardln* nftahlnaa vara afftlppad arlth a tut -->* ayataa, hat It m aat arrialaatly uad. Za plant C aardlai ana Uii la tn hftlldlad*. aaa af fthlah tu aflipped nth aa air aeaditlaalac ayttan, and la hath HlUlafi tha awahlaaa had axkaait etulpnaat. Til planta, > ul C, had artlflslal haalllty Install a tlou la thalr plncis* respa. In tha faraar tha taaperatare ni 7*T.t ralntlra b--iuty ft par eaat. a Ota plant, C, had ft fe--Idlfleatlea er*taa la tha talatL&c t 01741 c4 alas Is Ui *savls dspartsaat vfcara tfca ralatlTS feoaldlt? **-* JO par asst, vilk a t-rj M> tii^nnn af *?., m iM^tnl nu & rtUtln haaldlt? if 44 y*f . U Ua mrU( rM sf flul 1, AmIMm tram )Uit 1, ASik u uamiurUr dsat?, It nC( in*r ts*t tt* tut kwrt vaa sat euiiln oaift is Ui >nfwuu r*n if ylMW J sad C. TSa tut iwti tn UUmUat tu, Au uuliint la UU Ukt if Ui |niMlUi lUttui far iUImni daat, tiuUlUit "*J Ui 1UM lutu Nkli* Zaslta Oamas,* aaaal? 10 aUUu paj-tlalss (10 ad anas sad utir) par nil* fsat. Imrir, *i an act juUftii Is aanatad Ut Vmui ukMUili 1* milimr iiiiMi, axisiaai iy, uu lUlMltli Ui UtmIhU if paralaslkls tut MUM la lL|kir. UWituii 1* pstSslaflasll? utfirut fm lUliuli, ssd Ui nc^irluH fir data sat smal sa attaapt ta daflsa as srtltrti7 -1 at/atirt af daattsaaa. vert cottk: Tsrtaw aauvu, nU sa a lilac, kutUflMltw, sad laaal ojsau, tssdsd ta rttwi Ui dsat. JararUslsai, tt ass arlisst Uit \rj van -ij aaaassafsl. It slsa ta aiyamt Uit, if It la otpastad ta aastral dsattsaaa la tSaaa plaats, flaal rallaaaa auit raat pi pnyarly uuvrutit tuut HUf ut. Zs plaat C Is asa dspsrtaast sa aKparlasatal laataliatlaa a sat (. la s>lta af loaa aWtasa fsalts, Uli Atlfaut, aa Ua Wall af corps ratlTi dmat aasats, rsdsasd Ua dsat >f 00 par asst, sad vita finlar alts rat laaj vlll preWlJjr Va TO par cast. affiatlTi. Jar all yraatlasl psryaass, tali la oslta aatlafats!7. Zt la aaltSsr praatlastla sir saasMlaall? daslrsSla ta Isa tall luk'iftlpaut sa will salts Ui sir satin!? dsat fraa, rraa If till *1 salts af lorxira is Baatp Trsdaa (drsalta ladsi try*, Jatlia iwm WUatia Ja. 10T, O.t. mill Isalts tarrlss, Vasaisctia, D.C., lUt. 1)1-74 2 5 X -\ C V- -u t s; <* *--- * * ll r,r* ?**1M*> ft* onl t*f*atir* Mitutii *f tk< M; uiii *ar* *f * fair aont if ataot^aari* filUttii. Xt 1* Am Oi 1* d)iii ti u aim* lr* iwcil *f rut rrr a lnt ri*d *f tu** tht UU iifiui mtuln >r*ih 4m. tt* PJ>ll**tlm f ohuit w tax-til* HdLsirr Isnlni infltintli tlffinltj, MfiiliUj tktn tti amtruUn if u >Ual 1* nd Ui* II ut >mm W C7ply 4m <nft Hitlii \* Ui lim. T i Xt li tMtruu t* taruu ^suat ifjtntu la uv ylut n u spin*t*i Wli flrrl, aa4 dn at*k Iti ffttlcnojr Vy tut imu. !Ui imtiii wUl r***d la aarlac Ui *h41w a)invi *f **t| anir. *n maim cirmian Xt tu *o* iVrliu tut tti 4:hsii1i *f ulutcili mt nit Hidj b 1-rtf rilu *f ta* *a**t. JL la ta* aarly *t*4*a *t ilUinii, u< lypiou f a* ubiilM vor*r **r anally lAdaflait* ui lastasluiT*. Til ftllov- l&C ta>l* in Uni sa pay*l**I uulutltn, ^*cta*r vita X-rxy niu *f 12t ;ira*u uniU; nrtU( la ululu ;luli la ta* Salt<4 lutu. It Cuulu r*rtlt* in la*lat*4 liri. ftiM iuii vert a*l*t*4 vert *r Itu at nuu fn* u)i( thin bavin* a*r* taaa tar** ytar* ef iqliniit la taa ladx*tr7. Tti lttirinutliei *f ta** niaa ill ar* teiil *a ta* rwllaii if eoj>*- t*at r**av**t*l*ii*t, bat ta*7 tat* tan atu4i*4 Ij ****nl *ta*rt o>rlu*ti la tan fl*ld. ta* 4lff*raae** *f *plal*a **r* *r a ala*r a* rare, aa4 tatrx tu |*a*raX air*a*at u t# lat*r>r*tatla. Ta* rtU* t*r* fm4 utrratlrtlj, ta* X-ray floAia** t**k lat* ta* ykyaloaX aaaalaatlaa and ta* ** f |ta* Individual, aad only ta*** tr*r* lluui a* fiiltlti ibt m*a tair* *aa * ~a t t 7 1- - i : / rrrrr 01743  i -------\ \ u. M aajir tlutmuit. All <*atira*d nn geld*d Vy tbilr cxy-triia* La alll* ait* tat itlar tyjut ay raiMittllili, Itaai Ut fllai ilunt aa ttitUn * **-* vx*pj . fir laViiWali tin ftrtttr nMlrUn Lata diabtfaX* tad *a*r*tlvia. OcOy " txavti tla* **a tall itiUar U* Ladlrldada tlui<4 *a (iiMfit in yr*>~*aiLag ir iWnm if latlMtlooi if taWnalMli ut, la till ni;iit, t'l Via - mine; . :r *: tj| ItfltMl 1' ?! "ft . -- :*fic rlmn if tlm Mix* van La taiird. Iltl tba nitfiy ertrlian if iLUmli U AM) 1% ni flit tint a great tul if un tknU Vt LmtU ti unruutai, If f+aalVla, ttiU*r r Mt uVMm1 |riiU7i<i t* ttkirvUtu WmIIm. I tlHi I XX MUttU U llMIlftHtlW If UlM 1U ladiTttmla, fSU twtr aye? tana ui iyi>ni hiujiUim. fin f ttm >*r- ii **r* Mt >by may miiait. i nvr.-t : . --* fur-* r Ik* uni if utiitnli in Ut14i< tat* t iUjim, nm 11141 - r -% I uri iieiad iU|i. fit flm 1U4) atn*u Uni tti aba* by I-nj ttiUmUu liflilti 104 >*Ul>t7 nfllilut la antt V* nrrut a H14301I1 if yoiaa aliill, Vet abo Uti a* tifLatti ipflMi. TV* aiaina IU41 ** axial It Ui..'- : *> ** t - wn sttuln Inc yatbal*& abi tin 4ftalti rjrjtcti. in tlin IMMftili' nn utlTily ocM't f-a fa*tt>7 nrt, 1*4 It u ait ffutlwlli ti nil ay 41ittaitlea litnu tin *a tli Wan *f .4 Mittal iltllQ *r ilullUtj. -r jii *-*7 Ia41rl4ull Wia full tti ollllt*4 cattail** yulxos*ry UnlTMUt t*4 bu-VW >byl**l 41**illlt *r tiul llwtmty, thy Mill Uti bna tluilfin u tblrt ivqi, Vat ai nU tin litai. `Obi utntif nrlir Hat 4i|r* iW|i> ntlrw cf bn n tntrt tat Vicaji of zlX M' t*i run jntliu upUHi itt4f, Vat li ttiu ntln tuit in ^nia. 'ti--. ir 4- V3 y I . | -- _____ , 0I7H I- ' ?------ c ?\ .. 14 * I s .:** ; ?** X* *U1 <r T>1 II a*t if * itua f 114 X-ray tt*M fiw M 4Upi4 u itad 4<rt uVtituli; IUX7-UTM u flr*t **>; thlrt7-jLiji at 4*aktfal; mi tnatr a* aiiun. T%11 XI kilt AIM* ttat VAlT Ukt UUtIImIi nt tf iUtr*f<v rltl )ilttn aiVttuiU #r utlrtlr fru *f tTVjttw, kilt ii nt tl Ulrt7*imi tltt initftl ut ima *t *t tvuti rttk r~f~**-- Ui^mm m tr-- af tnfUn. u4 tn(k tn Ut r^ttM mh totitiaoil if, tat um f Um tun cx&ltlttd Ui rt*a( tr trliut >f 'ikirt lal* in* la trta iUIimU. tertitl of tint lUint u H|tUn iteM ttet ttay tin 'Otn'flattC ut! Mr* n mtrdid, tat Ut --1 njtiili ihtnU ut ta )Uu< li Utn lUtMtiU if nlOtitm Ijrapuai. TUt III dm tta tttrTwi.i If tjr?a*A ul ctutf.' _m StlUfll >H>Un C^rpiH Cn|b 1st miirtJ 7tul to40 14 It 10 >1t 10 '-r Tb laolioaot tf rttartulooit (tato< myoa X-ray fllaa) a* rataalta -1 la nut rr ti taU lntoroitla* aa4 Ujirtut. ;'n raa it T>trraltti (OoaW: Tatar**!**!* (aatlrt) TtUl truluf tnlttn J ! Pattvftl 01 SO lmUTt~~ a l to i-V It TtUtt in t XI, tieluln, ta* llrtitoo lat* jt^itlr*, 4**taral, r*f*r* to Uo tun olatilflt* la Tall* IX. >m tat* iu tltotttti a* >rtteMjr aotlTo ea tit ft mil tp. . Hut . ,>4t -------------------------------------------- . 1 ' 1 TT , t 01745 V\ ( u- - 'S' Swrla* tba yr#f-r%t af tb at*47 pbfdolaaa aba *tr* prsatlel&c la tka onwint tlaa rbara uWitN ntlin Ut*4 r ^uiUoati, ud tat>4 ita( *14 Mt find u eanC uint if tibaMilaili aaasc Uiii nitm. <ba strut >ftu tbit tun af affairs aa4 ttal foul la multlti rttk a lUltMii basard, ta salortrUqr. {lUeTljgf Ullw lUttlff rmlti f caalastlisi tf aacapatlaa la Ulutiy ud Vr yaan ( ti^nn, It U ti W niatinl, kmnr, Ust U* ladiTldaala an ilutLflal uiuilif U tt* 4*|tnattt la ahlak tt*r **ra tindac *t tl< ttaa af ouImUm r a<r< U(f bad r^tt seat af tbtlr Um. ho bad *banc1 fro* mm tijtrtMit ta aastbar aad tra cm blast t uiUir ttrtai tblr fttn f Nyltfrat la tbs uhttu iadaU7. aiaaa aljr tb* tuaoasta af daat mUmM at tba tlM mt tbla nr7 la Ui rarleta ii^rtntti an hm, thirt 1 m (if af baovlac tba avarar* aaeut tf tut la tba atHijdan Labalad Vf Uni ya^la arrar tba faan af tbalr njlifant. Caaaaftiatlf, It la act fcultli ta aamlata ladlrldaal oaatt (1 ta tiflalta taonti af daat ary ran. Tibi* V tf bpartaaat futtln baabtfal intin ImtUc Cardiac ylaalac aryla lnUi| Traadac law nxxa*** faaklad Vladlac fiabar TlliUtt Otbar fatal toaalaad UU U sd 10 > 11 *1 10 1d t0 e 7 > I a ao e o ,,x.J* ---- -- -^ -T>r'D 017 4 6 - It - tuu TT * Jht* *f Sxvor^rv rr u 7-MJ1 U U 7-mj-v MiM mn SUf mn hul --- Tultln u T SO XT f t*r> vfl ItfallU UM) (1 Ml 3 a - n 3 IU* u IS U) St so ftUitlti U>1m " if liUfiit, tat, Itti 111 U fMTlIM, *T *t laiut niu ui utti* u Ui j> tr (intiK aeljl*aa Ml v tut p*t tXm. tt:a vii * u< mr MUM K U II MUM Sudtr *0 tu-i C ar*?* lull It* U 13 If at 1 tt lua nn % t IS It a it iHiUn % 4 0 so *= fill tlT* 9ull.*tl Iifilln fall (fttal nlut 10t) h-1' < * ' IS) at at .t It 3 tuej a Cfcift aa^utl** >*lttVT NiltfU lifltlU 1 U 1 lakM 1 u 1 Luka* 3 U3ii flu lit wialliX fatal 13 SI 11 fS 1a r St It 1 0 at 017E2 * IT - TLXZ2 Z tti> ZlaHaae aicsa ef ekiit trUU *e itTlUU ilpi Id *U1 Tiittln U u s T hvktfU IIa a* UlTe u? 0 to ***' If U7, ua W tttulM U tti yrtitui ef uteitM mW n tti lull f ttftan Ml St ittdM, u iidlMM la XIMXM JU l1islttiui tni NtiUn U J Itfitln tT BmX ta mlmi IX* 2-r*/ fllaa Mild attiatlta t Ui faat Uul <Xaaa fllai ladltattl a v+rj uaiaal Ualltui if iiU-tmiii ef Ui haaft. Xt It jritaUi Uat tUi la a imjiiu'i^ nlariMit (at la tla allltliul lift f\t epaa tli Inn la effort! ti fmr> Um| tinni via ftlmd lu|i. Xa Ui flrat alXlaaala aladlee, jalllaM 1a Ula 11017 la XJ1T,******** Br. I.I. Ollli af fcarrer, e*i lalerprateX Ui X-rv |UUi if till atal;, aioiital aa faUna: 'fli kaart la alaere* eeaaorptlem (atllaaala) aaata a larger i^. aaraaX atl la Ua aarly lU|ia la greWlV? aaaaad If ila laaraaaai aruaaalatara. Q> eiaiae af Ua kaart riaalaa Ur|ir Uu aanal It Ui aacoad aai aXaa la tia U1N HM*1 H lat ala ef Uiu Unit aa artifice aaeaeiatai rlU uliitcita. },, 0f tXaaa set aaaaelaiei MU aaaai alcaa fama4 rlU utiitaili. ***lla af Uiaa set uneUtii lit! uul iLcaa ef aalaatarla. > >]lur,l Caaaw?tlaw*, 0.*. Tdli loalvh iei-Tlec XallaUa #iS, Jtauory, lilt - u It 1( ftnlUt Uit set nffllllBt Bttlltltl Uj VMS ftil t* tl* affaata if Ua finBottilim >*--* ircauja jti !> Ui tfttrt U ttm mar 11*11 Uj nUUmUy katnu uWUnli u4 ps Iso nary tiktrailtili, u UU71I1 *f ImU iUu **A tUi ut >r*a 1 nt UuUUtr ritln iu --d* la rntri ta UtM tapuilH mrrrlM (nvt lsrsrsso* ud skara Ua flcsrM warm anUUli. tti r IOM 11tn UnlTat far 1 taUl B^aawa af 701 Ilf* raan, 9u ImU ala'sa srt at asm is 11--7 ir Uat nltakla aatalulau au oat X* aniwl at frea mar nMlrlaiia af Ua floraa. Ua mb* 1* tna af Ua aiUaaaa alalas ndar taadU Isssrmaa*. Sii malar af alalas far raaplr- atary tlaauaa la lL*fc la tra ef Ua plsata stsdlad Vat lsa far Ua cUan, taaad 1701 tl* latrafallua salaries** af lilt. Issvrar, Asrl^ Ua lattar yart af 1IU sad Ua first part af lttt tiara au as spldaal* af ItTliicu. &a raaarla af ra* aataW 1 itaait (jlaat X) Uatal Uat sis af temj-fU 4u iUUi aad alO* ( las >amaaat ssd laul Uaaklllty alslaa aara Uatad sa 4s* t* pul*00*17 ruVarvulaal*. IUi appeared ta V< u laordlaata aaant af tuVaramlaala fres Uli plait, Xaarrar, ---y af u* astplapaaa vara Xagraa* aid ala* talaraaleala alala* an lasanllp klfk Is tkla aaatlas af Ua sssAt!7. XasAlalS* tk* Alfflsmltqr Is Alaoaalsc paawaaasleaJa aad Ua taadaasy t* aasfss* It *ttl tmkaraslaala, tlaaa alslaa war* at41*4 ladlaUaaUp. tka pl/tlalaia ska 1*4 treated 11* ladlrldiala **r* latamind, sad laaptul aad auatarlnirtaarti, loaludlo* crsllalla X-ray fllsa, aara lmiti(tt*d wttl tla fallens* rarati. 017 5 .Ja --\ c --JA-Sn. y VV > y- J C*l*r*4 aal* i|* V7| mt>d u tu Tttr ud il|kt Mat3*j <1*4 *f rdtiMJ7 toktrculoal* foU**t&c a 3aarr3a*; Ma in *aa*t*rlM tin aost**. Alan M4 fiv plat luiinu, It (Tldutt r wititttU. * etltrt* Ml* I|t U| tiM U ultitM plirt * jrttr wi rvta MtUi; titd *f pl*U7 ttltmltili tttir tat iittt la ktipUU. CmIUUm kttk laap; at *Tl4*mtt of tiktt* ttili. 4. Celor*4 Ml* *4* 34; tirttd la uiitli* plut tr pm, tad lx aoaUo. Ida pkptltUa Itllma Ml* iw a mii *f iHpllmtd tta*ml*iii. ta* Mt liatti tf kttfiul *r atnitwm*. * Ufinatl*i tttU Vt clU1**4 *f ti* *13*r too ***** osrpt fra 13* dt*U **rtin**l** tUtl |tT* plaoa*T7 tiltnuliiU u Ut tut* *f tMtt. Total *a4 yraaaiat Al**tlllt7 wlala*: 1. *7107*4 la uWitai pUat Urn y<**r*. Kl* pi^tltUa Utw 3* flftt ma* tadir U* ittimtlu wit* aa iU tiul\ltkid h*i *f ttbimliili tint too 7Mn aftar Utiitii apliTMSt *t*rt*4. Alt# 3*4 RlimlMlt *f 13* 1UM7 tad **nrl**l (l*a4*. I, 3*1*, arplifii la **3*at** pliant *l3t 3*t3*. lit 737*1*1** *t*t*a *14 ntrtli ttkirailMl* tit! V*>r*l* 3**1U1 la *p*M. V* X-r*7 *7*11*31*. tut a*ttrdl*( t* papilitu **3*t*a 3*li*a *r* f**a4 la ijvtai. S. B*l*( tta fttrt *3pl*7**at. fi 737*1*1*** * tmtH 31a 41 cLtt*r*at t:** *r* a* l*U**4 V* t*Un* Udt*u 1* #t t*3r*l***t t 3a* a*3**t**l*. 4. i3it* a*l*t m* n-txuliii at tla* it lar%tl(*tla. XI* ptjtldu r*7*rt* **11 a*urt*3*4, ku^ ltklac< ***4 **l*r, * tiT *7u**l*t a* el3tac ** n*(*r*, Ualal*3*4 arpas*!**, Liiottitet oeviti; X-r*J *3m flat aittl-la*: 4J**alaat*4 fu 3*13 lues. 1* rrUan* *.' tikirttliili. Pro1*313 a ****b4 *1*4* **3**l**l*. 017 55  kit* Mil, tklrtiia yiira It ukiitu flMi. la an 1* MMUrlu, Aa laumt'xi mji. XIa atTiUUa tataa fct ku aartanaira aataataala ul f-1 ~~ tikirwlnli; aarttj la ruit la^i 17am latial nu takarala Mrjll aat utaitai kaUai; Wilma takimleala leaf utalatal uWitaali, tUa >aUuf la jrapwa* la( la a Hllilaatarr aaaaar. I aa aat laiiltla ta ImU Ua aUtr Urai tuia at tiUl aat ff- aaaat dlatklllty Mi kal Vaaa diaaaaat aa fcarlnc yalaaaary hlamlKli, Qm Ua Wala at Ua lafaraatlaa aktalaad Ua laU alalaa apaar ta a* tu ta tMMjUMtal takaraalaala; Ural af tana vara lacraaa. Xt u *ora tUa fraMla Uit Uan mi vara Ukamlau at Ua tlaa tkair a^larnat la Ua ' utaatat ylaat a--aa at. Of tfea alfkt disability alala aaaaa, aaa ni uaaaa^llaatat tttom> laala tad v vara aaaoapllcatat aabaateala aaa vara yat aa Uaatllitj b a aaaaa af a tlaulia Uitaaili of ttbaraalaala. la tkla a aaa a r -- r 1. ty aa kaaa af aaa ta*U 4aa ta uawyllailat ajb-aataala la aa ladlrltaal tlU aaa? ;ian a^lqaut la Ui ladaatry.* Kazzjasian 1. frilit|i( k^oivi ta aabaataa tut nun a palionrr flbraala af a tafl&lta tyya tlatlset rroa ilUinii tmutmlo aa (11m, ~t It it af a tya alltar Uu lUliiili, I, . tkara la (aaaaalatal tlU aabaavoala la a Urja ><naiUti af anal taflalta aartlaa aalajyavaat. ~ Ajbaataala data aat lnrolra aa taiml titdlw^ ta ftlaaau7 ttUmlnU. hnaaol aemalaatlaa^ Datalla aat yat pt'.lUil. ,^ 01758 r * *Wrtoili u rtiimt Is this aarlaa af own 4hi mat mui ssy autai ** *t tlwMUtr. latmr, It la ta raarolt fatally. far uaaa)Uutd utaitMU t * St 1* * tam ka* aaak uWalai'i aay ail ta Ua aamUtf af yaraavala Mi saata jasLaoosry l&faatlesa attar Om ttit.nlaila. ,(! Zt la mat yrsatlaakla u jat ta aiUUlll aUaUJti far tta tut aaatast af sir ui Is l* af tt> aajsff Ira tut aasata Is till mart, tia^rat tttt t*a V.t. hkilt lat.tt *arriaa itudart far slUaa last, it la yaaaltl* Ut aakasta slatla aara rasdUy tSss fraa alllas (IlCM). r m Iks asasst af 4sat la tta sir Ls tta uWataa flutt ttatlat ua Va rV- atsattally ntsiH. maririnow 1 fast Ul latiatrf atrlsaaV; faaa tta yrekl** af tut aaatrrl Is sataataa >UMa. S. Ztst ua aa^lsyaas >a aaalaat jiij-i laslly scad rajaotad far asyleywast If thaf tin tskaraslaaia c" >araucaalaala. *. Cut aaylayaaa >* axsaiawl yUtiaslly rrary yssr ar aarttlrly rrary ** aVl^S tsalsda as I-rs aaastnatlea af Ua aSaat. Ua ladaatry ay-oaaar atsilaa aa ktoaa asaaa af ukuUU, sa uU u atstlaa -s affaata af satsi'.aata as tsa tasrt sad tlrrulstlaa.