Message
From:
Sent: To:
CC: Subject: Attachments:
rich.gold@hklaw.com [rich.gold@hklaw.com] 6/25 /2 0 1 7 8:53:10 PM Brown, Byron [/o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=9242d85c7df343d287659f840d730e65-Brown, Byro] Dimitri.Karakitsos@hklaw.com Fwd: Cancellation of Friday 6 /2 3 meeting imageOOl.png; image002.png; image003.png; image004.png; image002.png; image005.png; imageOOl.png; image002.png; image003.png; image006.png; image007.png; image008.png; image009.png; image007.png; imageOlO.png
Region calling everyone together to explain the Agency's posi ti on needi ng 8 years and SlOOmm of data gathering.
From: "Ebright, Stephanie" <EBRIGHT.STEPHANIE@EPA.GOV<mai1t o :EBRIGHT.STEPHANIE@EPA.G O V Date: June 25, 2017 at 3:32:50 PM CDT T o : "David C. Weber" <DWeber@bdlaw.com<mai1t o :DWeber@bdlaw.com, "Cora, Lori" <Cora.Lori@epa.gov<mai1t o :Cora.Lori@epa.g o v , "Sheldrake, Sean" <sheldrake.sean@epa.govcmai1t o :sheldrake.sean@epa.gov Cc: Scott Coffey <coffeyse@cdmsmi t h .com<mai1t o :coffeyse@cdmsmi t h .c o m , "' (deborah.a.edwardsOexxonmobi1.com<mai1t o :deborah.a.edwardsOexxonmobi1.com>)'" <deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.com<mai1t o :deborah.a.edwardsOexxonmobi1.c o m , 'Hans Feige' chfei ge@fei g e .uscmai 1t o :hfei ge@fei g e .u s , "'Elizabeth Weaver (elizabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .comcmai1t o :elizabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .com>)'" <elizabeth.weaver@nortonrosefulbri g h t .comcmai1t o :elizabeth.weaverOnortonrosefulbri g h t .c o m , Scott Coffey <coffeyse@cdmsmi t h .comcmai1t o :coffeyse@cdmsmi t h .c o m , "Gustavson, Karl" cGustavson.Karl@epa.govcmai1t o :Gustavson.Karlepa.gov, "Fred WOLF" cfrederick.wolf@total .comcmai1t o :frederick.wolf@total.c o m , Annie Von Burg cAnnie.VonBurg@portlandoregon.govcmai1t o :An ni e.VonBurg@portlandoregon.g o v , "Jim Mckenna (ji m . j .mckenna@oregon.govcmaiIto:jim.j.mckenna@oregon.gov>)" cji m . j .mckenna@oregon.govcmailto:jim.j.mckenna@oregon.g o v , "myron.burr@si1troni c .comcmai1t o :myron.burr@si ltronic.com>" cmyron.burr@si1troni c .comcmai1t o :myron.burr@siltronic.com, "rjw@nwnatural.comcmai1t o :rjwnwnatural.com>" crjw@nwnatural.comcmai1t o :rjw@nwnatural.c o m , "max.mi 11er@tonkon.comcmai 1t o :max.mi 11 er@tonkon.com>" cmax.mi11er@tonkon.comcmai1t o :max.mi 11er@tonkon.c o m , "Laura.J .S .Brown@usdoj.govcmai1t o :Laura.J .S .Brown@usdoj.gov>" cLaura.J .S .Brown@usdoj.govcmai1t o :Laura.J.S .Brown@usdoj.g o v , "Loren R. Dunn" cLDunn@bdlaw.comcmai 1t o :LD un n@ bdlaw.com, "'Anne Fitzpatrick'" cAFi tzpatri ckGeosyntec.comcmai1t o :AFi tzpatri ck@Geosyntec.com> > , "Emerson J . Hi 1ton" cEHi1ton@bdlaw.comcmai1t o :EHi1ton@bdlaw .com, "Augustus E . Wi nkes" cAWinkes@bdlaw.comcmai1t o :AWi nkes@bdla w . c o m Subject: RE: Cancel 1ation of Friday 6/2 3 meeting
Hi al1 .
For Monday's meeti n g , havi ng heard no objecti ons to a noon start ti m e , the meeti ng will be from 12-4 paci fi c. For those in Portland, the meeti ng will be at the EPA Oregon Operati ons Offi ce bui1di ng at Fox Towe r , 805 SW Broadway, Portland. The meeti ng will be in the bui1di ng's 20th Floor conference room.
For those unable to attend in person, pi ease see web conferenci ng informati on below.
Thank you and 1ook forward to our discussion tomorrow.
Techni cal Di scussi on of Pre-RD Sampli ng Instructi ons for web conference parti ci pation. For the audi o porti o n , pi ease di al 1-719-457-1414 Passcode 934632# For the vi deo porti o n , pi ease cli ck the fol1owi ng link and fol1ow thestepsdescri bed below: h t t p s :/ / c d m s m i t h .g l o b a l m e e t .c o m / S C O T T C O F F E Y c h t t p s : / / u r l d e f e n s e .p r o o f p o i n t .co m/ v2 /u r l ? u = h t t p s 3A__cdmsmith.globalmeet.co m_S COTTCO FFEY&d=DwM F-g&c=14jPbFlhWnYXveJ 5ri xtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwJDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWJbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcllOcCOOP-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=R_JAMGzOz5rh2FyvZsSe__nfifHTdl-1VvXTLlnqT-rE&e=> Step 1 - A wi ndow will open prompti ng you to enter name and emai1 address. Enter thi s informati on so you can be identi fi ed in the meeti ng room. Step 2 - The next wi ndow will open and ask for a Password. Ignore this andchoose at 1ower right " Conti nue as Guest"
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tiers 8&9
ED 002061 00087530-00001
Step 3 - The global meet window will begin to open and a pop-up will show asking to connect audio via computer, or cal 1 -in. PLEASE CLOSE THIS WINDOW as you've already entered the audio through the manual 1ine/passcode 1isted above.
Meeting Agenda:
* Introducti ons * Ove rvi ew of EPA's sampli ng Pi an includi ng the purpose of developi ng and presenti ng the Long-Term moni tori ng pi an with the Baseli ne effort
* Di scussi on/Questi ons
* Ove rvi ew of stati sti cs that support EPA's approach to trend moni tori ng and necessary zones/exposure uni ts for ROD RAOs/metri cs/targets.
* Di scussi on/Questi ons
* Acti on Items/Next Steps
Stephanie Ebrig h t , Assistant Regional Counsel U.S. Envi ronmental Protection Agency, Regi on 10 1200 Si xth Avenue, ORC-113 Seattle, WA 98101 206.553.0774 (phone) 206.553.1762 (fax)
From: Ebright, Stephanie Sent : Fri day, lune 23, 2017 10:09 AM To : 'Davi d C. Weber' <DWeber@bdlaw.com<mai1to :DWeber @b dl aw .c om; Cora, Lori <Cora.Lori@epa.governai 1to :Cora.Lori @ e pa.g o v ; Sheldrake, Sean <sheldrake.sean@epa.governai 1to :shel drake.sean@epa.gov Cc: Scott Coffey ccoffeyse@cdmsmi t h .comcmai1to :coffeyseOcdmsmi t h .c o m ; ' (deborah.a.edwardsOexxonmobi1.com<mai1to :deborah.a.edwardsOexxonmobi1.com>)' <deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.com<mai1to :deborah.a.edwardsOexxonmobi1.com>>; 'Hans Fei g e ' chfei ge@fei g e .us<mai 1to :hfei ge@fei g e .u s ; 'Eli zabeth Weaver (elizabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bright.comcmai1to :elizabeth.weaverOnortonroseful bri g h t .com>)' celi zabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .comcmai1to :elizabeth,weaver@nortonrosefulbri g h t .c o m ; Scott Coffey ccoffeyseOcdmsmi t h .comcmai1to :coffeyseOcdmsmi t h .c o m ; Gustavson, Karl cGustavson.Karl @e pa.governai 1to :Gustavson.Karl@epa.g o v ; Fred WOLF cfrede ri ck.wol f@total .comcmai1to :frede ri c k .wolf@total.c o m ; Anni e Von Burg cAnnie .VonBurg@portlandoregon.governai 1to :Anni e .VonBurgOportlandoregon.g o v ; li m Mckenna (jim.j.mckennaOoregon.governai Ito:jim.j.mckennaOoregon.gov>) cjim.j.mckennaOoregon.governai Ito:jim.j.mckennaOoregon.g o v ; myron.burr@siItronic.comcmai1to :myron.burr@si1tronic.com>; rjw@nwnatural.comcmai1to :rjw@nwnatural.com> ; m a x .mi 11 erOtonkon.comcmai1to :m a x .mi 11erOtonkon.com>; Laura.1.S .BrownOusdoj.governai 1to :Laura.1.S .BrownOusdoj.g o v>; Loren R . Dunn cLDunn@bdlaw.comcmai1to :LD un nO bdlaw.com; 'Anne Fi tzpatri ck' cAFi tzpatri ck@Geosyntec.comcmai1to :AFi tzpatri ck@Geosyntec.com; Emerson 1. Hi 1ton cEHi1ton@bdlaw.comcmai1to :EHi1ton@bdlaw .c om ; Augustus E . Winkes cAWinkes@bdlaw.comcmai1to :AWi nkes@bdla w . c o m Subject : RE: Cancel 1ati on of Fri day 6/23 meeti ng
Thanks Davi d . For the agenda Monday, EPA is agreeabl e to di scussi ng the stati sti cs that support EPA's approach to moni tori ng and sampli n g . We will have our techni cal experts there for the di scussi o n . Fol1owi ng that di scussi o n , we are interested in talki ng about next steps to movi ng the sampli ng effort forward.
I will pi an on attendi ng the meeti ng as counsel for several parti es will be present.
In terms of 1ogi sti c s , it sounds like the reserved conference room is only avai 1able unti 1 4. EPA is avai 1able to start the meeti ng at noon in order to al 1ow more ti me for di scussi o n . Pi ease 1et me know if meeti ng from 12-4 paci fi c ti me works for everyone and if s o , we can update the invi t e .
Thanks and we 1ook forward to our meeti ng Monday.
Stephani e Ebri g h t , Assi stant Regi onal Counsel U.S. Envi ronmental Protecti on Agency, Regi on 10 1200 Si xth A v en ue, ORC-113 Seattle, WA 98101 206.553.0774 (phone) 206.553.1762 (fax)
From: David C. Weber [mailto:DWeber@bdlaw.com] Sent : Fri day, lune 23, 2017 8:41 AM
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tiers 8&9
ED 002061 00087530-00002
To: E b r ig h t , Stephanie cEBRIGHT.STEPHANIE@EPA.GOVcmai1to : EBRIGHT.STEPHANIE@EPA.GOV; Cora, Lo ri <Co ra.Lori@ ep a.go v<m ai1to : C o r a . L o r i epa. g o v ; S h e ld r a k e , Sean <shel d r a k e . sean@epa.governai1to : s h e ld r a k e .sean @ ep a.go v Cc: S c o t t C o f f e y ecoffeyse@cdmsmi t h . comcmai1to : coffeyse@cdmsmi t h . c o m ; ' (d eb o rah . a.edwards@exxonmobi1 . comcmai1to : d eborah. a.edwards@exxonmobi1 . com>)' cd ebo rah . a.edwardsOexxonmobi1 . comcmai1to : deborah. a.edwards@exxonmobi1 . com> > ; ' Hans Fei g e ' c h f e i ge@fei g e . uscmai1to : h fe i ge@fei g e . u s ; ' E l i zabeth Weaver (e liz a b e th .w e a v e r@ n o rto n ro s e fu l b r i g h t . comcmai1to : el iz a b e th .w e a v e rO n o rto n ro se fu l b ri g h t . com>)' ce liza b e th .w e a v e r@ n o rto n ro se fu l b r i g h t . comcmai1to : e liz a b e th .w e a v e r O n o r t o n r o se fu l b r i g h t . com>>; S c o t t C o ffe y ccoffeyseOcdmsmi t h . comcmai1to : coffeyseOcdmsmi t h . c o m ; G u sta v so n , Karl cG u sta v s o n . Karl @epa. governai 1to : G u sta v so n . Karl@ epa. g o v ; Fred WOLF cfr e d e r i c k .w o lf @ t o t a l. comcmai1to : fre de r i c k .w o lf @ t o t a l. c o m ; Anni e Von Burg cA n n ie .VonB urgOportlandoregon. governai 1to :A n n ie .VonBurg@portlandoregon. g o v ; Jim Mckenna ( j i m . j . mckenna@oregon. governai I t o : j i m . j . mckennaOoregon. gov>) c j i m . j . mckennaOoregon. governai I t o : j i m . j . mckennaOoregon. g o v ; myron. b u r r O s ilt r o n ic .c o m c m a i1to : myron. burr@ si1t r o n i c . com>; rjw O nw natural. comcmai1to : rjw@nwnatural . com>; max. mi 11 er@tonkon. comcmai1to : max. mi 11er@tonkon. com> ; L a u r a . J . S . BrownOusdoj. governai 1to : L a u r a .J . S . BrownOusdoj. g o v > ; Loren R . Dunn cLDunn@bdlaw.comcmai1to : LDunnObdlaw.com; 'Anne Fi t z p a t r i ck' cAFi t z p a t r i ckOGeosyntec.comcmai1to : AFi t z p a t r i ck@ Geosyntec.com; Emerson J . Hi 1ton c E H i1ton@bdlaw.comcmai1to : E H i1ton@bdla w .co m ; Augustus E. Winkes cAWinkes@bdlaw.comcmai1to :AWi nkes@bdlaw.com S u b je c t : RE: Cancel 1a t i on o f F r i day 6/ 2B meeti ng
Stephanie -
I 'm wri t i ng to f o l 1ow-up on our di s c u s s i on from y e s te r d a y a f t e r n o o n .
As d i s c u s s e d , the pre-RD group i s prepared to meet with EPA and the City/State/NWN/Fed group a t 1:00 pm on Monday, June 26, a t EPA's Oregon O p e ra tio n s O ff i ce to 1earn more about EPA Regi on 10's pi a n , i n e l udi ng the te ch n i ca l underpi nni ngs o f EPA's approach to moni t o r i ng and sampli n g . We t h i nk i t i s i mportant th a t both te ch n i ca l and 1egal r e p r e s e n t a t i v e s be p rese n t a t t h i s meeti n g . We al so 1ook forward to di s c u s s i ng wi th EPA i deas about how to coordi nate the di f f e r e n t i n v e s t i g a t i on e f f o r t s under s e p a ra te work p i a n s . Howeve r , a t t h i s t i me, the pre-RD group i s not prepared to meet wi th EPA and the City/State/NWN/Fed group f o r purposes o f negoti a t i ng and di s c u s s i ng the terms and scope o f our proposal .
To be c l e a r , the pre-RD group remai ns prepared to meet wi th EPA o n ly to negoti ate and di s c u s s the terms and scope o f our p r o p o s a l. We r e s p e c t f u l 1y requ est t h a t such negoti a t i ons and di s c u s s i ons be conducted in c o n fi denti al s e s s i ons pursuant to FRE 408. Our requ est i s consi s t e n t wi th EPA p o ii cy and w i l l help f a c i 1i t a t e meani n gful and e f f i c i ent di s c u s s i o n s . The pre-RD group remai ns commi tt e d to mov i ng forward wi th our p r o p o s a l. Time i s o f the e s s e n c e , and we are i n tent on d e l i v e r i ng high q u a l i t y data in a 2-y e a r t i me p eri o d .
Pi ease 1e t us know i f EPA w i11i ng to go forward wi th the Monday meeti ng under the condi t i ons d e s c r i bed above.
Regards, Davi d
D a v id C. Weber Pri nei pal
BEVERI;D G E .DiI:AMOND , P .c . T i Ex. 6 - Personal Privacy \ F +1 . 206. B15 .4801 DWeber@bdl aw. coiTKmai 1 to : DWeber@bdl aw. com>
From: Ebright, Stephanie [mai 1to :EBRIGHT.STEPHANIE@EPA.GOV] Sent : Th ursd ay, June 22, 2017 9:35 AM To : Davi d C. Weber ; C o ra, Lori ; Sheldrake, Sean Cc: S c o t t C o f f e y ; ' (d eb o rah . a.edwards@exxonmobi1 . comcmai1to : deborah. a . edwards@exxonmobi1 . com>)' ; ' Hans Fei g e ' ; ' E l i zabeth Weaver (elizabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .comcmai1to :el izabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .com>)'; Scott Coffey; Gustavson, Karl ; Fred WOLF ; Annie Von Burg ; Jim Mckenna (jim.j.mckenna@oregon.governai Ito:jim.j.mckenna@oregon.gov> ) ; myron. b u rr@ siltro n ic.c o m cm a i 1to : myron. burr@si 1t r o n i c.com > ; rjw@nwnatural. comcmai 1to : rjw@nwnatural . com>; max. mi 11 er@tonkon. comcmai 1to : max. mi 11er@tonkon. com> ; L a u r a . J . S . Brown@usdoj. governai 1to : L a u r a . J . S . Brown@usdoj. gov> ; Loren R. Dunn ; 'Anne Fi t z p a t r i c k ' ; Emerson J . Hi 1ton ; Augustus E . Wi nkes S u b je c t : RE: Cancel 1a t i on o f F r i day 6/2 3 meeti ng
Hi Davi d ,
Thanks f o r your emai1 . EPA i s avai 1able f o r a meeti ng wi th the pre-RD group and the Ci ty/State/NWN/Fed group on Monday, June 26, in P o r ti and s t a r t i ng a t 1:00 pm. We are prepared to meet unti 1 5 pm to a ssu re t i me to g e t through e ve ry o n e ' s q u e s ti o n s .
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tiers 8&9
ED 002061 00087530-00003
In terms of agenda for the Monday meeting, we are anticipating the same technical discussion that we pianned to have on June 23 r d , whi ch was to di scuss the si mi 1ari ti es and di fferences between the EPA pi an and the pre-RD group pi an and the City/State/NWN pi a n ; obtai n a better understandi ng of the pre-RD group's proposed SMA del ineati o n ; and di scuss the stati sti cs that support EPA's approachto trend moni tori ng and necessary zones/exposure units for our RAOs/metrics/targets. We will have EPA's experts avai1able for a robust exchange on the pi a n s . We questi on the need for 1egal counsel for thi s meeti ng but if parties insist that thei r 1awyers are there, we will have EPA counsel there t o o .
We are encouraged to have al1interested parti es at the table a n d , at thi s ti m e , do not bel ieve a second pre-RD group only meeti ng on Tuesday is necessary.
Those attendi ng the Monday meeti ng for EPA a r e :
Sean Sheldrake Scott Coffey Eri c Bli schke John Kern Karl Gustavson Stephanie Ebright Eva DeMari a Becky Chu
We can host the meeti ng at the EPA Oregon Operations Offi ce bui1di ng 1ocated at the Fox Tower, 805 SW Broadway, Portl a n d . The meeti ng will be in the bui1di ng's 20th Floor conference room. We can set up a conference line for those not able to attend the meeti ng in person.
Thanks agai n for the di scussi on 1ast week and we 1ook forward to conti nui ng the di scussi on next Monday.
Best, Stephanie
Stephani e Ebri g h t , Assi stant Regi onal Counsel U.S. Envi ronmental Protection Agency, Regi on 10 1200 Sixth Avenue, ORC-113 Seattle, WA 98101 206.553.0774 (phone) 206.553.1762 (fax)
From: David C. Weber [mai1t o :DWeber@bdlaw.com] Sent: Wednesday, June 21, 2017 1:57 PM T o : Cora, Lori <Cora.Lori@epa.govcmai1t o :Co ra.Lori@epa.gov> > ; Sheldrake, Sean <sheldrake.sean@epa.govcmai1t o :shel drake.sean@epa.gov; Ebri g h t , Stephanie <EBRIGHT.STEPHANIE@EPA.GOVcmailto:EBRIGHT.STEPHANIE@EPA.G O V Cc: Scott Coffey <coffeyse@cdmsmi t h .comcmai 1t o :coffeyse@cdmsmi t h .c o m ; ' (deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.comcmai1t o :deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.com>)' cdeborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.comcmai1t o :deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.c o m ; 'Hans Feige' chfeige@feige.uscmai1t o :hfeige@feige.u s ; 1Elizabeth Weaver (elizabeth.weaverOnortonrosefulbright.comcmai 1t o :el izabeth.weaverOnortonroseful bri g h t .com>) ' celizabeth.weaver@nortonrosefulbri g h t .comcmai1t o :elizabeth.weaverOnortonrosefulbri g h t .c o m ; Scott Coffey ccoffeyseOcdmsmith.comcmai1t o :coffeyse@cdmsmith.c o m ; Gustavson, Karl cGustavson.Karl@epa.govcmai1t o :Gustavson.Karl@epa.g o v ; Fred WOLF cfrederick.wolf@total.comcmai1t o :frederick.wolf@total.c o m ; Annie Von Burg cAnnie.VonBurgOportlandoregon.govcmai1t o :An ni e.VonBurgOportlandoregon.g o v ; Jim Mckenna (ji m . j .mckenna@oregon.govcmailto:jim.j.mckennaOoregon.gov>) cji m . j .mckennaOoregon.govcmailto:jim.j.mckennaOoregon.g o v ; myron.burrOsiltronic.comcmai1t o :myron.burr@si1tronic.com> ; rjwOnwnatural.comcmai1t o :rjw@nwnatural.com> ; m a x .mi 11 er@tonkon.comcmai1t o :m a x .mi 11er@tonkon.com> ; Laura.J.S .Brown@usdoj.govcmai1t o :Laura.J.S .Brown@usdoj.gov> ; Loren R . Dunn cLDunn@bdlaw.comcmai1t o :LD un nO bdlaw.com; 'Anne Fitzpatrick' cAFi tzpatri ckOGeosyntec.comcmai1t o :AFi tzpatri ck@Geo sy nt ec .c om; Emerson J . Hi 1ton cEHi 1ton@bdlaw.comcmai1t o :EHi1ton@bdlaw .com; Augustus E. Winkes cAWinkes@bdlaw.comcmai1t o :AWi nkes@bdla w . c o m Subject: RE: Cancel 1ati on of Fri day 6/2 3 meeti ng
Lori -
You're welcome. In terms of schedule, the pre-RD group's cal 1 with the City/State/NWN/Fed group is scheduled for Thursday, June 22.
Consi stent wi th your request, the pre-RD group is agreeable to meet wi th EPA and the Ci ty/State/NWN/Fed group on Monday, June 26, in Portland. We would prefer a Noon or 1:00 pm start-time in order to accommodate out-of-town travel schedules.
Fi nal1y , we would like to reschedule our meeti ng that had been pianned for June 23 between the pre-RD group and EPA only to Tuesday, June 27, in Portl a n d .
Regards,
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tiers 8&9
ED 002061 00087530-00004
Davi d
David C. Weber Pri nei pai
BEVERIDGE DIAMOND, P .C . T [ x. 6 - Personal Privacy j F +1.206. B1 5 .4801
DWeber@bdl aw. com<mai 1to :DWeber@bdl aw. com>
From: Cora, Lori [mai1t o :C o ra.Lori@epa.gov] Sent: Tuesday, June 20, 2017 3:52 PM T o : Davi d C. Weber; Shel drake, Sean; Ebri g h t , Stephani e Cc: Scott Coffey; ' (deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.com<mai1t o :deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.com>)'; 'Hans Feige'; 'Elizabeth Weaver (el izabeth.weaver@nortonrosefulbri g h t .comcmai1t o :elizabeth.weaverOnortonrosefulbri g h t .com>)'; Scott Coffey; Gustavson, Karl; Fred W O L F ; Annie Von Burg; Jim Mckenna (ji m . j .mckenna@oregon.govemaiIto:jim.j.mckenna@oregon.gov> ) ; myron.burrOsiltronic.comcmai1t o :myron.burrOsi1tronic.com>; rjwOnwnatural.comcmai1t o :rjwOnwnatural.com>; m a x .mi 11erOtonkon.comcmai1t o :m a x .mi 11 erOtonkon.c o m>; Laura.J.S .Brown@usdoj.govemai1t o :Laura.J.S .Brown@usdoj.gov> ; Loren R . D u nn; 'Anne Fitzpatrick'; Emerson J . Hi 1t o n ; Augustus E . Winkes Subject: RE: Cancel 1ation of Friday 6/2 3 meeting
Hello, David. Thanks for your message and your group's cooperation to meet and coordinate with al1 parties interested in performi ng sampli n g . On alternative meeti ng dates, Sean's message provi ded EPA's avai1abi1ity to meet in Portland next week excerpted below:
"EPA is avai1able to meet in Portland the week of June 26th on Monday, Tuesday, Thursday afternoon, or Fri day with everyone (We can host the meeti ng at the Oregon Operati ons Offi ce/Fox tower on Monday or Fri day). Thi s will al1ow EPA to di scuss matters with a broader group interested in conducti ng the sampli ng work together, and also ensure attendance of our stati sti ci an and be abl e to revi ew GIS data from the Pre-Remedial Design Group."
Sean's message speci fi cal 1y asked to hear from everyone whi ch day would work for a meeti ng on the two pians. We can host Monday or Fri day, but if another day works better for everyone, someone else will need to supply the space. I understand from Sean that John Kern, our stati sti ci a n , is avai1able to meet in person Monday and Tuesday. But EPA can meet Thursday afternoon or Fri day as well just 1ikely wi thout the benefi t of M r . Kern. I also wi sh to rei terate that we are wai ti ng for the GIS data referenced by Exxon Mobi1 representatives. We have yet to receive th at.
Pi ease 1et us know when you can meet next w e e k .
Lori Houck Cora | Assi stant Regi onal Counsel U.S. Envi ronmental Protection Agency | Region 10 P: (206) 553.1115 | F : (206) 553.1762 | cora.1ori@epa.govemai1to :cora.1ori epa.gov> Fol1ow EPAnorthwest on Twitter! https ://twitter.com/EPAnorthwestehttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url ?u=https3A twitter.com_EPAnorthwest&d=DwMF-g&c=14jPbFlhWnYXveJ 5rixtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwJDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWJbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 Hcll0cCO0P-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=NXIUmrEj 3qecO-_lXFi19Dddlqo7hwlEfrljRY5PM0Q&e=>
From: Davi d C. Weber [mai 1to :DWeber@bdl aw.com] Sent : Tuesday, June 20, 2017 3:35 PM To : Sheldrake, Sean csheldrake.sean@epa.govemai1to :sheldrake.sean@epa.gov; Ebri g h t , Stephani e cEBRIGHT.STEPHANIE@EPA.GOVcmai1to :EBRIGHT.STEPHANIE@EPA.G O V ; Cora, Lori cCora.Lori@epa.govemai1to :Cora.Lori@epa.g o v Cc: Scott Coffey ecoffeyseOcdmsmi t h .comcmai1to :coffeyseOcdmsmi t h .c o m ; ' (deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.comcmai1to :deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.com>)' edeborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.comcmai1to :deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.c o m ; 'Hans Fei g e ' chfei ge@fei g e .usemai1to :hfei ge@fei g e .u s ; 'Eli zabeth Weaver (elizabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .comcmai1to :el izabeth.weaverOnortonroseful bri g h t .com>) ' celizabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .comcmai1to :elizabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .c o m ; Scott Coffey ccoffeyse@cdmsmi t h .comcmai1to :coffeyse@cdmsmi t h .c o m ; Gustavson, Karl cGustavson.Karl@epa.govemai1to :Gustavson.Karl@epa.g o v ; Fred WOLF cfrede rick.wol f@total .comcmai1to :frede rick.wolf@total.c o m ; Annie Von Burg cAnnie.VonBurg@portlandoregon.govemai1to :Annie .VonBurg@portlandoregon.g o v ; Jim Mckenna (ji m . j .mckennaOoregon.govemaiIto:jim.j.mckenna@oregon.gov>) cji m . j .mckennaOoregon.govemaiIto:jim.j.mckenna@oregon.g o v ; myron.burr@siltronic.comcmai1to :myron.burr@si1troni c .com>; rjw@nwnatural.comcmai1to :rjw@nwnatural.com> ; m a x .mi 11 erOtonkon.comcmai1to :m a x .mi 11erOtonkon.com>; Laura.J.S .BrownOusdoj.govemai1to :Laura.J.S .BrownOusdoj.g o v>; Loren R . Dunn eLDunn@bdlaw.comcmai1to :LDunnObd la w. co m; 'Anne Fitzpatri ck' cAFi tzpatri ck@Geosyntec.comcmai1to :AFi tzpatri ck@Geosyntec.com; Emerson J . Hi 1ton cEHi 1ton@bdl aw.comcmai1to :EHi1ton@bdlaw .com; Augustus E. Wi nkes cAWinkes@bdlaw.comcmai1to :AWi nkes@bdla w . c o m
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tiers 8&9
ED 002061 00087530-00005
Subject: RE: Cancellation of Friday 6/23 meeting
Lori and Sean -
At your request, the pre-RD group has offered to meet this week with the City/State/NWN group via conference cal 1, 1ikely on Thursday, June 22. Meeti ng in person on short noti ce is not feasi ble si nee our group members are not al1 local.
We were di sappoi nted by the cancel 1ati on of our next meeti ng on June 23 to further di scuss our group's proposal. As we discussed, time is of the essence. We propose to be in the field in 2017, and are intent on deliveri ng high quality data in a 2-year ti me peri o d .
Therefore, pi ease 1et us know your earli est date for a second meeti ng between the pre-RD group and EPA on our group's proposed scope of w o r k . If possi bl e, we would sti11 very much 1ike to meet on June 23 as original1y pianned, or on a date next week that is mutual 1y convenient.
We 1ook forward to heari ng from y o u .
Regards, Davi d
David C. Weber Pri nci pal
BEVERIDGE & DIAMOND, P.C. T rEx!V'-"pereona7p'rivacy/ F +1-206.315.4801 DWeberObdl aw. com<mai 1t o :DWeber@bdl aw. com>
From: Sheldrake, Sean [mai1t o :sheldrake.sean@epa.gov] Sent: Monday, June 19, 2017 1:05 PM T o : 'Anne Fitzpatrick'; David C. Weber Cc: Scott Coffey; ' (deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.comcmai1t o :deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.com>)'; 'Hans Feige'; 'Elizabeth Weaver (elizabeth.weaver@nortonrosefulbright.comcmai1t o :elizabeth.weaver@nortonrosefulbright.com>)'; Scott Coffey; Gustavson, Karl; C o ra, Lori; Fred W O L F ; Annie Von Burg; Jim Mckenna (ji m . j .mckennaOoregon.govemailto:jim.j.mckenna@oregon.gov> ) ; myron.burrOsi1tronic.comcmai1t o :myron.burr@si 1tronic.com>; rjwOnwnatural.comcmai 1t o :rjw@nwnatural .com>; m a x .mi 11 er@tonkon.comcmai1t o :m a x .mi 11er@tonkon.com> ; Laura.J.S .BrownOusdoj.govemai1t o :Laura.J.S .Brown@usdoj.gov> ; Ebright, Stephanie Subject: Cancel 1ati on of Fri day 6/2 3 meeti ng
Hello everyone,
We are wri ti ng to inform you that EPA is cancel ling the meeti ng scheduled for thi s Fri day to di scuss the di fferences between EPA's proposed sampli ng pi an and the Pre-RD Group's proposal. We are cancel ling Fri day's meeti ng for a few of reasons.
Fi rst, we want to provi de more ti me for the Pre-RD Group to meet with the other interested parti es who also want to parti ci pate in the fi rst post-ROD sampli ng efforts before further di scussi ng the two pians. We are aware that a meeti ng of al1 interested parties was bei ng put off to prepare for Fri day's meeti ng and we do not want that result. EPA wants al1 interested parties to meet about the sampling effort to assure an effi ci ent and successful negoti ati o n . EPA too wants to di scuss a cohesi ve sampl ing pi an that meets al1 cri ti cal objecti ves in a forum that will al 1ow everyone to hear the same messages. Therefore, EPA wants the next meeti ng about the two pians to include al1 interested parties. To faci1itate al1 interested parti es to me et, EPA will defer begi nni ng negoti ati ons for 2 addi ti onal weeks (to the week of July 3) to provi de al1 interested parti es ti me to coordi nate and meet with each other as much as needed, and to meet joi ntly with EPA at 1east once before begi nni ng negoti ati o n s . Second, EPA's stati sti ci an was not avai1able to meet unti1 next week. Thi rdly, EPA has not received the GIS data Exxon Mobi1 mentioned was used in the group's data gaps analysi s . EPA needs ti me to revi ew such data to further evaluate the Pre-Remedial Design Group's proposal.
EPA is avai1able to meet in Portland the week of June 26th on Monday, Tuesday, Thursday afternoon, or Fri day with everyone (We can host the meeti ng at the Oregon Operati ons Offi ce/Fox tower on Monday or Fri day). Thi s will al 1ow EPA to di scuss matters with a broader group interested in conducti ng the sampli ng work together, and also ensure attendance of our stati sti ci an and be abl e to revi ew GIS data from the Pre-Remedi al Desi gn Group.
Pi ease forward thi s message to the whole group, as I don't have contacts for al1 parti ci pants. Lastly, pi ease 1et me know what days would work for each of your g r o u p s .
Thank you for your attenti on to thi s matter.
s
Sean Sheldrake, Unit Divi ng Offi ce r, RPM EPA Region 10, 1200 Sixth A v e ., Suite 900; Mai 1stop DOC-01
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tiers 8&9
ED 002061 00087530-00006
Seattle, WA 98101 ,.206 ,_5.53.,12 20_.desk
^ Ex. 6 - Personal Privacy j c e 1 1
fittp:77yoserrn t e .epa.gov/rlO/cleanup.nsf/si tes/ptldharbor<https://urldefense.proofpoi n t .com/v2/url?u=http3A vosemite.epa.gov__rlO_cleanup.nsf_sites_ptldharbor&d=DwMF-g&c=14j PbFlhWnYXve!5rixtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWlbZCIGosedl og4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcU0cCO0P-q1GCV9-YcT9 2w&s=614 2u9VTAGQNVi-4vHm8BK4x9LlNDMzdFXHWxQ2bcFI&e=> [FB icon]<https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A www.facebook.com_EPADivers&d=DwMFg&c=14j PbFlhWnYXvel5 rixtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWlbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcUOcCOOP-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=4PDe-MOOSDaOGMl bQdPnl5XgzKfBWCB3KCkIz_8qDM&e=>[sci dive_round]chttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https3A www.epa.gov_scienti fic-2Ddiving&d=DwMF-g&c=14jPbFlhWnYXve!5 rixtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWlbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcUOcCOOP-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=3VAKIOTEfcvqtpjHGBq_CpxPH3gzcxPdyVDjXg_Bqpw&e=>[fii ckr icon for signature b l o c k ] c h t t p s : / / u r l d e f e n s e .p r o o f p o i n t .co m/ v2 /u r l ? u = h t t p s 3A www.fiickr.com_photos_usepagov_sets_72157629017469667_wi th__14530254926_&d=DwMF-g&c=14j PbFlhWnYXvel5 rixtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWlbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 Hcll0cCO0P-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=tNnlOvbdNdZIHoj BZu2ABslmUCIQc9ohuWG9wauPozE&e=> Over 47 years of sci enti fi c divi ng in support of EPA's mi ssi on
From: Sheldrake, Sean Sent : Fri day, lune 16, 2017 3 :07 PM To : Anne Fi tzpatri ck <AFi tzpatri ck@Geosyntec.comcmai1to :AFi tzpatri ck@Geosyntec.com Cc: Scott Coffey <coffeyse@cdmsmi t h .comcmai1to :coffeyse@cdmsmi t h .c o m ; (deborah.a.edwardsOexxonmobi1.comcmai1to :deborah.a.edwardsOexxonmobi1.com>) cdeborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.comcmai1to :deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.c o m ; Hans Fei ge chfei ge@fei g e .uscmai1to :hfei ge@fei g e .u s ; Eli zabeth Weaver (el izabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .comcmai1to :elizabeth.weaver@nortonrosefulbri g h t .com>) celizabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .comcmai1to :el izabeth.weaver@nortonroseful brig h t.com>>; David C. Weber cDWeber@bdlaw.comcmai1to :DWeberObdlaw.com>>; coffeyse@cdmsmi t h .comcmai 1to :coffeyse@cdmsmi t h .com>; Gustavson, Karl cGustavson.Karlepa.governai 1to:Gustavson.Karl@epa.g o v ; C o ra, Lori cCora.Loriepa.governai 1to :Cora.Loriepa.gov>> Subject : RE: Exxon data--evaluati ng SMA deli neati on
A n n e , Davi d , Pi ease see the attached tabi e we di scussed thi s past Wednesday that would be hel pful to generate a speci fi c agenda for thi s comi ng Fri day. Let me know if you have any questi o n s .
Thank you.
S
Sean Sheldrake, Unit Divi ng Offi ce r, RPM EPA Regi on 10, 1200 Si xth A v e ., Suite 900 ; Mai 1stop DOC-01 Seattle, WA 98101 206.553.1220 desk
| Ex. 6 - Personal Privacy i C e l l
Fttp":'77yoseriffte epa.gov/rlO/cl eanup.nsf/si tes/ptl dharborchttps ://url defense.proofpoi n t .com/v2/url ?u=http3A vosemite.epa.gov_rl0_cleanup.nsf_sites_ptldharbor&d=DwMF-g&c=14j PbFlhWnYXvel5 rixtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWlbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcU0cCO0P-q1GCV9-YcT9 2w&s=614 2u9VTAGQNVi-4vHm8BK4x9LlNDMzdFXHWxQ2bcFI&e=> [FB icon]chttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__www.facebook.com_EPADivers&d=DwMFg&c=14j PbFlhWnYXvel5 rixtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWlbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcUOcCOOP-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=4PDe-MOOSDaOGMlbQdPnl5XgzKfBWCB3KCkIz_8qDM&e=>[scidive_round]chttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url ?u=https3A www.epa.gov_scienti fic-2Ddiving&d=DwMF-g&c=14jPbFlhWnYXvel5 rixtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWlbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcU0cCO0P-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=3VAKIOTEfcvqtpjHGBq_CpxPH3gzcxPdyVDjXg_Bqpw&e=>[fiickr icon for signature bl ock]chttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https3A www.flickr.com_photos_usepagov_sets_72157629017469667_wi th_14530254926_&d=DwMF-g&c=14j PbFlhWnYXvel5 rixtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWlbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcU0cCO0P-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=tNnlOvbdNdZIHoj BZu2ABslmUCIQc9ohuWG9wauPozE&e=>
Over 47 years of sci enti fi c divi ng in support of EPA's mi ssi on
From: Sheldrake, Sean Sent : Fri day, lune 16, 2017 10:59 AM To : 'Anne Fi tzpatri c k ' cAFi tzpatri ck@Geosyntec.comcmai1to :AFi tzpatri ck@Geosyntec.com>> Cc: Scott Coffey ccoffeyse@cdmsmi t h .comcmai1to :coffeyse@cdmsmi t h .c o m ; (deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.comcmai1to :deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.com>) cdeborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.comcmai1to :deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.com> > ; Hans Fei ge chfei ge@fei g e .uscmai1to :hfei ge@fei g e .u s ; Eli zabeth Weaver (elizabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .comcmai1to :el izabeth.weavernortonrosefulbri g h t .com>) celizabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .comcmai1to :el izabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .c o m ; David C. Weber cDWeber@bdlaw.comcmai1to :DWeber@bdlaw.com Subject : RE: Exxon data--evaluati ng SMA deli neati on
Hi A n ne,
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tiers 8&9
ED 002061 00087530-00007
Unfortunatel y our stats person isn't avai 1able next Fri day in terms of goi ng over say our MNR recovery rate D Q Os, but I think we do have a quorum to go over SMA deli neati on/data gap questi ons next Fri day whi eh I agree would be a good di scussi o n , if we get the additi onal data in ti me to 1ook it over in some detai 1 . We are al most ready to convey our di fferences tabi e as wel 1-- hopeful ly we coul d use that to further generate an agenda for next week. I thi nk it would al so be useful to schedule a cal 1 or meeti ng on Monday or (better) Tuesday the fol1owi ng week if we can confi rm avai 1abi1ity for key team members for iterns we can't get through Fri day due to ti me or avai 1abi1it y .
Thank you.
S
Sean Shel drake, Unit Divi ng Offi ce r, RPM EPA Regi on 10, 1200 Si xth A v e ., Sui te 900 ; Mai 1stop DOC-01 Seattle, WA 98101 ,206.,_553..12 20_.desk
^ Ex. 6 - Personal Privacy jC e 1 1
fittpfZ/yosmite.epa.gov/rl0/cleanup.nsf/si tes/ptldharborchttps://uri defense.proofpoint.com/v2/url ?u=http3 A _ y o s e m i t e .epa.gov_rl0_cleanup.nsf_sites_ptldharbor&d=DwMF-g&c=14j PbFlhWnYXvel5ri xtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWlbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcU0cCO0P-q1GCV9-YcT9 2w&s=614 2u9VTAGQNVi-4vHm8BK4x9LlNDMzdFXHWxQ2bcFI&e=> [FB icon]<https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A_www.facebook.com_EPADivers&d=DwMFg&c=14j PbFlhWnYXvel5ri xtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWlbZCIGosedl og4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcUOcCOOP-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=4PDe-MOOSDaOGMl bQdPnl5XgzKfBWCB3KCkIz_8qDM&e=>[sci dive_round]<https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https3 A _ w w w .e p a .gov_sci enti fi c-2Ddi vi ng&d=DwMF-g&c=14j PbFlhWnYXvel5ri xtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWlbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcU0cCO0P-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=3VAKIOTEfcvqtpjHGBq_CpxPH3gzcxPdyVDjXg_Bqpw&e=>[fii ckr icon for signature bl ock]ch t t p s ://urlde fe ns e.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https3A www.fiickr.com_photos_usepagov_sets_72157629017469667_wi th_14530254926_&d=DwMF-g&c=14j PbFlhWnYXvel5ri xtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWlbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcU0cCO0P-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=tNnlOvbdNdZIHoj BZu2ABslmUCIQc9ohuWG9wauPozE&e=> Over 47 years of sci enti fi c divi ng in support of EPA's mi ssi on
From: Anne Fi tzpatri ck [mai 1to :AFi tzpatri ck@Geosyntec.com] Sent : Fri day, lune 16, 2017 9: 39 AM To : Sheldrake, Sean <sheldrake.sean@epa.gov<mai1to :sheldrake.seanOepa.gov>> Cc: Scott Coffey <coffeyse@cdmsmi t h .comcmai1to :coffeyse@cdmsmi t h .c o m ; (deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.comcmai1to :deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.com>) cdeborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.comcmai1to :deborah.a.edwards@exxonmobi1.com> > ; Hans Feige chfei ge@fei g e .uscmai1to :hfei ge@fei g e .u s ; Elizabeth Weaver (eli zabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .comcmai1to :el izabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .com>) celi zabeth.weaver@nortonrosefulbri g h t .comcmai1to :elizabeth.weaver@nortonrosefulbri g h t .com>> Subject : RE: Exxon data--eval uati ng SMA deli neati on
Hi Sean, I agree it was a productive di scussi o n . Elizabeth is worki ng on your request thi s morni ng for cori ng data col 1ected by NewFields from RM 5 to 6.
Would you sti11 1ike to di scuss the geostats next Fri day and how we derived our sampl e counts, and the steps we used? I thi nk it would still be a worthwhi1e di scussi o n .
Regards, Anne
Anne Fitzpatrick, LHG Geosyntec Consultants 520 Pi ke Street, Sui te 1375 Seattl e , _WA_.98101_____ D reCt : ! I Ex. 6 - Personal Privacy Offi ce : '701-496-1450'' Cel 1 : i i Ex. 6 - Personal Privacy Emai 1 l--'TTt'zpt'fT'ik@geosyntec. comcmai 1to :afi tzpatri ckOgeosyntec.com>
PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL / JOINT DEFENSE COMMUNICATION / ATTORNEY CLIENT WORK PRODUCT
From: Sheldrake, Sean [mai1t o :sheldrake.sean@epa.gov] Sent: Friday, lune 16, 2017 9:02 AM T o : Anne Fi tzpatri ck cAFi tzpatri ck@Geosyntec.comcmai 1t o :AFi tzpatri ck@Geosyntec.com Cc: Scott Coffey ccoffeyse@cdmsmith.comcmai1t o :coffeyse@cdmsmith.c o m Subject: FW: Exxon data--eval uati ng SMA deli neati on
Hello A n n e , Thanks agai n for your presentati on thi s past Wednesday and a producti ve di scussi o n . For next w e e k , would there be a way you could transmit the GIS 1ayers to us? Unfortunately, we don't have
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tiers 8&9
ED 002061 00087530-00008
our statistician avai1able next Friday, but we would 1ike to get into some detai1s on the SMA delineation if we have a chance to go through the dataset you used.
Thank you.
s
Sean Sheldrake, Unit Diving Officer, RPM EPA Region 10, 1200 Sixth A v e ., Suite 900; Mai 1stop DOC-01 Seattle, WA 98101 ,206.,5.5.3.,12 20._de sk iEx.6-PersonalPrivacy jce11 http:77yosemite.epa.gov/rlO/cleanup.nsf/si tes/ptldharbor<https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https -BA__naOl.safelinks.protection.outlook.com_-BFurl-3Dhttp-25 3A-252F-2 52Fyosemi t e .epa.gov-252FrlO252Fcl eanup.nsf-252Fsi tes-252Fptl dharbor-26data-3D02-2 57C01-25 7CAFi tzpatrick-2540geosyntec.com257Cl4015f52441b4ca6aa2b08d4b4dll01c-257C7125495671b047f48977c4cl7bc205cb-257Cl-257C0257C636332257412965713-26sdata-3D-252BbTP-252BO-252FMkMsODi8iv-252BWXuCHekQGICO-252F3AR8UtRfCB2l-253D26reserved-3D0&d=DwMF-g&c=14j PbFlhWnYXvel5ri xtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWlbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcU0cCO0P-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=cyYIV2OGd4Vl4zXBvVmhDUtadswFlZl2xtzCFk0AcgE&e=> [FB icon]<https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__naOl.safeli nks.protection.outlook.com_3Furl-3Dhttps-25 3A-252F-252Fwww.facebook.com-252FEPADi vers-26data-3D02-257C01-2 57CAFi tzpatrick2540geosyntec.com-257Cl4015f52441b4ca6aa2b08d4b4dll01c-257C7125495671b047f48977c4cl7bc205cb-257Cl-257C0257C63633225 7412965713-26sdata-3D2QKK5li S9lVU9XEzEMLo2W3SXdd-2 52BVlUl5t6cSlvF7Zk-2 53D-26reserved3D0&d=DwMF-g&c=14jPbFlhWnYXvel5ri xtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWJbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcU0cCO0P-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=hCqUMgBbMyuwSldA6f5db2QB5ovyM4uxvZGfzlj 5 6 l & e = > [ s c i d i v e _ r o u n d ] < h t t p s : / / u r l d e f e n s e .p r o o f p o i n t .c o m / v 2 / u r l ? u = h t t p s 3A__naOl.safeli n k s .protection.outlook.com_-3Furl-3Dhttps-25 3A-252F-2 52Fwww.epa.gov-252Fscienti fi c2Ddiving-26data-3D02-25 7C01-257CAFi tzpatrick-2540geosyntec.com-257Cl4015f52441b4ca6aa2b08d4b4dll01c257C7125495671b047f48977c4cl7bc205cb-25 7Cl-25 7C0-25 7C636332257412965 713-26sdata-3D8l00AiXWrHBqgcgi rHAR252Btl3R3tg-2 52FeQSbYWl2arNlC4-25 3D-26reserved-3D0&d=DwMF-g&c=14j PbFlhWnYXvel5ri xtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWJbZCIGosedl og4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcU0cCO0P-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=9SZbMZ70jvVi047yN9dlc2FbRBRGhThkuo_v8Ad-wsE&e=>[flickr icon for signature block]chttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__naOl.safeli nks.protection.outlook.com_-3Furl3Dhttps-25 3A-252F-252Fwww.fl ick r.com-252Fphotos-252Fusepagov-252Fsets-252F72157629017469667-252Fwith252Fl4530254926-252F-26data-3D02-257C01-25 7CAFi tzpatrick-2540geosyntec.com257Cl4015f52441b4ca6aa2b08d4b4dll01c-257C7125495671b047f48977c4cl7bc205cb-257Cl-257C0257C63633225 7412965713-26sdata-3Dl A7wLHYpN5uD2oeAl 6N6rMyZYOyQ2pgCooxEjtGxzMs-253D-26reserved-3D0&d=DwMFg&c=14j PbFlhWnYXvel5ri xtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWJbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcU0cCO0P-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=vBt3SjPi18a9nE5xtYsldlcb9s03BQhoUogfb9WzpLQ&e=> Over 47 years of sci enti fi c divi ng in support of EPA's mi ssi on
From: Sheldrake, Sean Sent: Thursday, June 15, 2017 12:12 PM T o : 1eli zabeth.weaverOnortonrosefulbri g h t .com<mai1t o :elizabeth.weaver@nortonrosefulbri g h t .com>' <elizabeth.weaver@nortonroseful bri g h t .com<mai1t o :elizabeth.weaver@nortonrosefulbri g h t .c o m Cc: coffeyseOcdmsmith.comcmai1t o :coffeyseOcdmsmith.com>; Cora, Lori <Cora.Lori@epa.gov<mai1to:Cora.Loriepa.gov>> Subject: Exxon data--evaluati ng SMA deli neati on
Hello Elizabeth,
It was good to talk to everyone yesterday.As one fol 1ow u p , is there a way you could send us the data you referenced? It's also in our fi 1e , but I'm hoping youcould find a way to emai 1 or FTP the informati on most qui ckly so we may get into anal yzi ng it. It sounds like the MS Access format wi th a key or 1egend that explai ns al1 the fi elds is al1 we need to get into thi ngs in detai1.
Thank you.
S
Sean Sheldrake, Unit Divi ng Offi ce r, RPM EPA Regi on 10, 1200 Si xth A v e ., Suite 900; Mai 1stop DOC-01 Seattle, WA 98101 r.?06_,_553_,1220. desk [Ex.6-PersonalPrivacy |Ce 11 http://yosemi t e .epa.gov/rlO/cleanup.nsf/si tes/ptldharborchttps://url defense.proofpoint.com/v2/url ?u=https -3A__naOl.safeli nks.protection.outlook.com_-3Furl-3Dhttp-25 3A-252F-2 52Fyosemite.epa.gov-2 52FrlO252Fcl eanup.nsf-252Fsites-252Fptldharbor-26data-3D02-2 57C01-25 7CAFi tzpatrick-2540geosyntec.com257Cl4015f52441b4ca6aa2b08d4b4dll01c-257C7125495671b047f48977c4cl7bc205cb-257Cl-257C0257C636332257412965713-26sdata-3D-252BbTP-252BO-252FMkMsODi8iv-252BWXuCHekQGICO-252F3AR8UtRfCB2l-253D26reserved-3D0&d=DwMF-g&c=14j PbFlhWnYXveJ 5ri xtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YWlbZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcU0cCO0P-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=cyYIV2OGd4Vl4zXBvVmhDUtadswFlZl2xtzCFk0AcgE&e=> [FB icon]chttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__naOl.safeli nks.protection.outlook.com_3Furl-3Dhttps-25 3A-252F-252Fwww.facebook.com-252FEPADi vers-26data-3D02-257C01-2 57CAFi tzpatrick-
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tiers 8&9
ED 002061 00087530-00009
2540geosyntec.com-257Cl4015f52441b4ca6aa2b08d4b4dll01c-257C7125495671b047f48977c4cl7bc205cb-257Cl-257C0257C63633225 7412965713-26sdata-3D2QKK5li S9lVU9XEzEMLo2W3SXdd-2 52BVlUJ5t6cSJvF7Zk-2 53D-26reserved3D0&d=DwMF-g&c=14jPbFlhWnYXvel5ri xtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUw3DAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2l<_YW3bZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyl<0LL2 HcllOcCOOP-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=hCqUMgBbMyuwSldA6f5db2QB5ovyM4uxvZGfz3j56l&e=>[sci dive_round]<https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https3A__naOl.safeli n k s .protection.outlook.com_-3Furl-3Dhttps-25 3A-252F-2 52Fwww.epa.gov-252Fscienti fi c2Ddiving-26data-3D02-25 7C01-257CAFi tzpatrick-2540geosyntec.com-257Cl4015f52441b4ca6aa2b08d4b4dll01c257C7125495671b047f48977c4cl7bc205cb-25 7Cl-25 7C0-25 7C636332257412965 713-26sdata-3D8l00AiXWrHBqgcgi rHAR252Btl3R3tg-2 52FeQSbYWl2arNlC4-25 3D-26reserved-3D0&d=DwMF-g&c=14j PbFlhWnYXvel5ri xtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUw3DAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YW3bZCIGosedlog4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 HcU0cCO0P-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=9SZbMZ70jvVi047yN9dlc2FbRBRGhThkuo_v8Ad-wsE&e=>[fiickr icon for signature block]chttps://uri defense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__naOl.safeli nks.protection.outlook.com_-3Furl3Dhttps-25 3A-252F-252Fwww.fli ck r.com-252Fphotos-252Fusepagov-252Fsets-252F72157629017469667-252Fwith252Fl4530254926-252F-26data-3D02-257C01-25 7CAFitzpatri ck-2540geosyntec.com257Cl4015f52441b4ca6aa2b08d4b4dll01c-257C7125495671b047f48977c4cl7bc205cb-257Cl-257C0257C63633225 7412965713-26sdata-3Dl A7wLHYpN5uD2oeAl 6N6rMyZYOyQ2pgCooxEjtGxzMs-253D-26reserved-3D0&d=DwMFg&c=14j PbFlhWnYXvel5ri xtS_Fo3DRrpL7HUwlDAc4HIc&r=btZnmVqpKvZ54gR2K_YW3bZCIGosedl og4oqxBYgW7g&m=c_w2lL9YGbdfljyK0LL2 Hcll0cCO0P-qlGCV9-YcT92w&s=vBt3SjPi18a9nE5xtYsldlcb9s03BQhoUogfb9WzpLQ&e=> Over 47 years of sci enti fi c divi ng in support of EPA's mi ssi on
NOTE: Thi s e-mai 1 is from a 1aw firm, Hoi 1and & Knight LLP ("H&K"), and is intended sol ely for the use of the individual(s) to whom it is addressed. If you bel ieve you received thi s e-mai 1 in error, pi ease notify the sender immediately, delete the e-mai1 from your computer and do not copy or disclose it to anyone else. If you are not an existing client of H&K, do not construe anythi ng in this e-mai1 to make you a cli ent unless it contai ns a speci fi c statement to that effect and do not di scl ose anythi ng to H&K in reply that you expect it to hoid in confi dence. If you properl y received thi s e-mai1 as a cli e n t , co counsel or retai ned expert of H&K, you should mai ntai n its contents in confi dence in order to preserve the attorney-client or work product privilege that may be avai1able to protect confidentiality.
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tiers 8&9
ED 002061 00087530-00010