Document XOe4Qk7Og0gywxBYe4qmvOJzK

W9 O'f'sj') I PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT MET-145 en INDUSTRIAL DUSTS AND THE MORTALITY FROM PULMONARY DISEASE1 A. J. LANZA* and R. J. VANE* `gs Air and water are the two immediate vital necessities of our lives. ais We take extraordinary precautions to guarantee for ourselves not only an ample supply of water but one of defined purity, and vast engineering .he water-supply projects, costing many millions of dollars, are an accepted and commonplace fact in our times. ed. With respect to the air we breathe, we are more complaisant. Dust arising from industrial processes pollutes the atmosphere of working places, in mine, factory and mill, and the products of combustion, both JJf industrial and nonindustrial, are liberated into the atmosphere of our ork communities with little restraint. In recent years, particularly, in dustrial dusts have received much attention and much efiort has been iual put forth by industrial firms of all kinds to control dusty processes in >38. \m. their establishments. Fortunately, nature has furnished us with a respiratory system which -ray has not only a large margin of safety, but a fairly efficient protective , 937, mechanism. When that protective mechanism is subjected to severe stress for a sufficiently long period of time, it may fail. The extent to j-, which such failure may be reflected in mortality experience is, within certain limitations, the subject of this discussion. >. ; We are concerned here with industrial dusts other than those commonly recognized as poisonous. Lead, mercury, arsenic, manganese and other systemic poisons are excluded, together with the chemical poisons. Those dusts with which we are concerned are both organic and inorganic, and the latter, in turn, may be subdivided into metallic and nonmetallic. There are many possible subdivisions of these three classifications but for our purpose extensive subdivision is unnecessary. Indeed, it is difficult to get sufficiently ample statistical material to give us definite information under the general headings. 1 Read as part of the Symposium on Tuberculosis in Industry at the joint session of the Pathological, Clinical, Social Work and Administrative Sections at the 34th annual meeting of the National Tuberculosis Association, Los Angeles, California, June 23, 1938. 1 Me ropolitan Life Insurance Company, New York City. 419 A. J. LANZA AND R. J. VANE la 1908, Dr. Frederick Hoffman (1) wrote an article on the mortality from consumption in the dusty trades. Ten years later, he produced the well known Bulletin 231, The Mortality from Respiratory Diseases in the Dusty Trades (2), an important milestone in the hygiene of industry. In 1919, appeared the first and second preliminary reports of the Com mittee on Mortality from Tuberculosis in the Dusty Trades (3), of which Committee, Doctor Hoffman was Chairman. An indefatigable worker in many fields of public health, Doctor Hoffman's name is thus linked to the early authoritative publications in this country dealing with dust and pulmonary disease. The various reports of Governmental Com missions in South Africa, Australia, Great Britain and other countries have also stimulated industrial studies and laboratory research into the effects of many kinds of industrial dusts, especially those containing silica. At the present time, while no one would state that we have adequate information about the effects of the inhalation of industrial dusts, we do know a great deal more than we did twenty years ago. Both clinical and laboratory studies have given us some knowledge of what kinds of dusts are dangerous, the circumstances under which they are dangerous, and the nature of their action upon the pulmonary tissue. We have also, learned a great deal about the prevention and control of the dust hazard by engineering methods. But when we seek evidence of the effects of dust inhalation in mortality and morbidity records, we find.that.thi statistical demonstration of mortality and morbidity due to the inhala tion of dusts is anything but satisfactory or complete. This situation is the more regrettable because comprehensive mortality and morbidity statistics would be of the greatest value in clearing up many doubtful points regarding the effects of specific dusts and would bring to light occupations in which there might be a real, but unsuspected, exposure to injurious dusts. Early occupational mortality studies, it must be admitted, gave the first broad clues to the extent of the dust hazard in industry and to the kinds of dust which are most injurious. These earlier mortality studies, valuable as they were, however, were in many instances misleading. Virtually all kinds of dusts were shown to be productive of tuberculosis rates higher than average, whereas recent clinical and laboratory experience points to the very considerable damage to the lung tissue produced by a few dusts, notably silica and asbestos, and to the relatively little evidence of harm done to the lung tissue by organic and many inorganic dusts. INDUSTRIAL DUSTS 421 There arc reasons, obvious to us to-day, why these mortality studies have not been an entirely accurate guide. For one thing, students of mortality did not have the benefit of the clinical and laboratory knowl edge regarding dusts now available and, consequently, had to make their own classifications of dusts on a somewhat arbitrary basis. They were handicapped, too, by the fact that the existing occupational codes often brought together all the men in a whole industry. This did not permit of detailed studies of the mortality of men exposed to a single type of dust. Occupational mortality statistics still lose much of their value because of this same lack of refinement in methods of classifying occupa tions. Then again, factors other than dust, which have a marked in fluence upon the incidence of tuberculosis among men engaged in differ ent occupations, were not as well understood and were not given due consideration in interpreting the results of mortality studies. There are pitfalls in reasoning from cause to effect, especially where tuberculosis is concerned, and the error of post hoc ergo propter hoc is particularly to be guarded against. A high incidence of tuberculosis or other respiratory disease among men in a given occupation does not necessarily indicate the existence in that occupation of a definite oc cupational hazard. It is well established that people of the poorer economic classes, whether in industry or out of it, have a higher incidence of respiratory tuberculosis than do people better off financially. In Miss Whitney's (4) study of Death Rales by Occupation in Ten States in 1930, the ;`andardized death rate for tuberculosis was over twice as high among unskilled workers as among all occupied males while in the Registrar-General of England and Wales' study (5), 1921-1923, the rate for unskilled workers was about two-fifths higher than the rate for all occupied and retired civilian males. Certain occupations, too, are more suited to the physically weak and are selected by them as a means of earning a livelihood. When the followers of an occupation are recruited from the ranks of either of these classes, it is to be expected that a high r incidence of tuberculosis mortality will be found among them. Failure to take cognizance of these factors as possible explanations of a high tuberculosis incidence in certain callings has led to much misinterpreta tion of the significance of mortality findings. It is not our purpose to reassess the older statistical material to which reference has been made. We shall limit our discussion of statistics mainly to the results of the three most recent investigations in which tuberculosis death rates are obtainable for a number of occupations. 422 A. J. LANZA AND R. J. VANE These are the Registrar-General's Decennial Supplement for England ana Wales (5) and two studies made jointly by the Actuarial Society of America and the Association of Life Insurance Medical Directors (6, 7). In the English study, the tuberculosis death rate tor men in a given occupation, ages 20 to 65 years, is compared with that for all occupied and retired civilian males of the same ages. The method of analysis employed in the insurance studies was to compare the actual number of deaths which occurred among men engaged in a specific occupation with the expected number of deaths calculated on the basis of death rates by ages prevailing among standard lives, that is, persons who buy insurance on an annual basis in amounts of $1000 or more and who are not em ployed in hazardous occupations. Thus the insurance standard is a more rigorous one than that of "occupied males in the general popula tion'' since those in the lowest social-economic class are excluded, as are men who are employed in occupations where there is a serious exposure to dust, accident or other hazards. This should be kept in mind in interpreting the figures presented for insured lives in the following discussions. INORGANIC DUSTS Silica: Silica in the form of dust produces a definite, disease of the lungs, namely silicosis, a progressive fibrosis whaSigS itself, may cause disability and death and which carries withifsrafig disposition to tuberculous infection. Silicosis results from the irrilasSSS of dust containing free or uncombined silica. Its pathology has been extensively studied, both clinically and in the experimental laboratory. It has been established that silica particles which penetrate the lungs are under ten micra in their largest diameter and are mostly from one to three micra. Not only must the silica dust be in a state of such fine subdivision, but the particles must be present in large amounts and the exposure of the individual must be prolonged. When such conditions are fulfilled the natural defenses of the body against inhaled dust break down and silicosis results. The precise nature of the action of silica dust upon body tissues is not definitely known but it appears to be a protoplasmic poison and pro duces its effect chemically and not mechanically. A given dust is dan gerous in proportion to the amount of free silica which it contains. The nature of the relationship between silicosis and tubercle infection has not been determined, but the fact of such relationship is attested by overwhelming evidence both clinical and statistical (8). INDUSTRIAL DUSTS 423 No useful purpose would be served by quoting extensively from the impressive volume of mortality data available to show the influence of silica dust on the incidence of tuberculosis. Virtually every one of the many studies is in agreement in showing extraordinarily high mortality rates from tuberculosis for industries and occupations in which large numbers of men are known to be exposed to a real silica hazard. These rates are so high, in fact, as to leave no room for doubt of the causeand-effect relationship between the hazard and the high mortality. A few figures from the insurance investigations (6, 7) may be quoted. Table 1 shows the ratio of actual to expected deaths for the chief occupa tions exposed to silica dust. TABLE 1 Number of deaths and ratio of actual to expected deathsfrom tuberculosis of the respiratory system Ordinary Department Mortality Experience of American Life Insurance Companies* Occupations exposed to silica dust 1915-1926 1925 1956 OCCTTJATIOW Actual death* Rxtio per cent tctu*l to expected Actual death* Rxtio per cent xctuxl to expected Stonecutters--granite and sandstone................... Chippers of metal--(not shipbuilding)................. Mine operatives--underground Copper mine operatives................................... Gold and silver mine operatives....................... Iron mine operatives.......................................... Lead and zinc mine operatives........................ Other and not specified mine operatives.......... 16 8 24 9 4 It t 976 615 913 804 260 1,833 -- 38 16 29 11 12 3 10 2,639 1,667 1,381940 857 -- 1,020 * Compiled from: Joint Occupation Study, Actuarial Society of America and The Asso ciation of Life Insurance Medical Directors, 1929; and Occupation Study, Actuarial Society of America and The Association of Life Insurance Medical Directors, 1938. f Data not available. Among a group of underground miners employed in mines other than coal mines, nearly all of whom were employed in metal mines, there were 65 deaths from cuberculosis in the years 1925-1936 in an exposure of 25,000 life years where 6 were expected, or about eleven times as many deaths as the expected number. There were 13 deaths from pneumonia where 5 were expected. Tuberculosis deaths were fourteen times the expected among copper miners, nine times the expected among gold and silver miners, and eight and a half times the expected among iron miners. In this experience, there was only a small representation of lead and zinc 424 A. J. LANZA AND R. J. VANE miners, but in the earlier study (6), covering the years 1915--1926, there were 11 deaths from tuberculosis in this group or eighteen times as many as expected. The ratio for iron miners, 857 per cent, is unexpectedly high inasmuch as it is thought that most of these workers are exposed to only moderate amounts of silica dust, except for a limited number who are working in hard rock. It might have been expected that their mor tality would more closely approximate that of coal miners. The number of deaths is small, however, and the difference may be more apparent than real. Among cutters of granite and sandstone, there were 38 deaths from tuberculosis in an exposure of 5,944 life years, compared with 1.4 ex pected, or more than twenty-six times as many as the expected number of deaths. Chippers of metal (exclusive of ship chippers) had 16 deaths from tuberculosis where only one was expected. It will be observed that the ratio of actual to expected deaths from tuberculosis for each of the silica occupations is higher in the period 1925-1936 than in the period 1915-1926. The reason for this apparently lies in the difference in the trend of the death rates for men in these oc cupations and the rate for insured persons generally. While the figures are too small on which to base broad conclusions, they suggesQjgfltmai. in silica occupations have not shared in the general decline in the daag rate from tuberculosis. It may be that there was actually an_ij(B^S in the rates for the period 1925-1936 over that for the'period 19l5c39pg Interesting confirmation of these high ratios by English data is pre sented in table 3. English tin and copper miners had a death rate from tuberculosis eleven and one-half times the average; sandstone masons, cutters and dressers, nearly four and onc-half times the average; and metal grinders, about three and two-thirds times the average. Ratios such as these cannot be explained away on the ground of differing social classes or the selection of the occupation by physically weaker types of workers. This evidence is in agreement with reports of silicosis studies from South Africa. Australia, Canada, and Great Britain as well as the United States and is supported by clinical experience of physicians in many parts of the world whose practice has been among workers exposed to silica dust. Coal dust: It has long been known that coal miners are subject to chronic pulmonary disease characterized by dyspnoea and usually termed "miners' asthma," also that the death rate from respiratory diseases is rom exnber atbs :rom :riod :ntly e oc;ures men icath rcase 1926. preirom 50ns, . and .atios social )es of from nited parts silica :ct to :rmed ises is INDUSTRIAL DUSTS high among certain groups of miners while among others the death rate from tuberculosis has been consistently low. Recent investigations have cleared up many points about the hazard of coal dust and have indicated certain differences between anthracite coal and bituminous coal. It is desirable, therefore, in studying the effects of coal dust to consider these two types of exposure separately. In 1934, the Public Health Service (9) made a report on an investiga tion of pulmonary disease among anthracite miners. This report stated what had previously been suspected, namely, that anthracite mining had, under certain conditions, a silica hazard and many anthracite miners were exposed to the effects of coal and silica dust. The evidence tends to show that disabling miners' asthma is, in effect, silicosis, a silicosis modified by coal dust but nevertheless a silicosis. Turning to the mortality record of coal miners, we find that the Medico-Actuarial Occupation Study (7) shows for the Pennsylvania miners (nearly all anthracite) the following figures, based on 144,535 life years, for the twelve-year period 1925-1936: There were 1,699 actual deaths where 613 were expected, giving a ratio of actual to expected deaths of 277 per cent. Of this excess, 37 per cent was due to accidents and 63 per cent to disease. The pneumonia and influenza death rate was five times the normal; tuberculosis, over three times the normal; and accidents, five times the normal. ----- Miners elsewhere (bituminous) presented the following figures: There were 52,522 life years and 330 actual deaths against 187 expected, a mortality ratio of 176 per cent, but of this excess mortality, 84 per cent was due to accidents and 16 per cent to disease. The death rate from accidents was five times the normal; the pneumonia death rate was normal; and the tuberculosis death rate, 61 per cent in excess of normal. In the insurance occupation study (6, 7), as we have pointed out, the death rates for each occupation are compared with the rate for standard ordinary policy holders, a rigorous standard as compared with the rate for all occupied males. When considering the mortality of men employed in mining operations many of which are carried on by unskilled workers, it is especially necessary to bear this fact in mind. Apart from any specific occupational influence conducive to a high incidence oi tubercu losis, we should expect a greater than average mortality from tuberc- culosis among them because of their economic status. Insured common laborers outside of the mining industry, it should be mentioned, have a death rate from tuberculosis about three times as great as that of Stand- i i 426 A. J. LANZA AND R. J. VANE ard lives. Compared with the death rate for laboring groups generally, therefore, the tuberculosis rate for bituminous miners is quite low, whereas the rate ior anthracite miners is as high, if not actually higher, than the average for this class of workers. The number of deaths and the ratio of actual to expected deaths for coal miners is given in table 2. The following quotation from the Public Health Service report (9), previously referred to, is of interest in showing the incidence of clinical tuberculosis among anthracite miners: Several surveys have shown that tuberculosis of the lungs occurs among 1 to 21 per cent of the general adult white male population of the country. In a TABLE 2 Number of deaths and ratio of actual to expected deaths from tuberculosis of the respiratory system Ordinary Department Mortality Experience of American Life Insurance Companies* Coal Miners OCCUPATION Actual deaths Ratio per cent actual to expected Actual deaths- Operatives not underground................ Operatives underground Total................................................... Pennsylvania (mostly anthracite) Other localities (bituminous)....... 14 159 t 125 157 135 t 115 t -- 20 Compiled from: Joint Occupation Study, Actuarial Society of America and The Asso ciation oi Life Insurance Medical Directors, 1929; and Occupation Study, Actuarial Society of America and The Association of Life Insurance Medical Directors, 1938. t Data not available. study of tuberculosis in Framingham, Massachusetts (10), it was found that about 1 per cent were suffering from the disease in an active form, and another 1 per cent were classified as having arrested tuberculosis. Physical examina tion oi 100,924 adult white males made by the Life Extension Institute (11) indicated a prevalence rate of about li per cent when suspected cases were included. A somewhat higher percentage, namely 2^ per cent, was found by the Public Health Service (12) from the examination of 10,000 male industrial workers. Among the anthracite workers examined, the clinical tuberculosis rate was below normal in the younger adult ages, but at ages 35 to 44 clinical pul monary tuberculosis was diagnosed in about 5 per cent oi the hard coal mining INDUSTRIAL DUSTS 427 employees; at ages 45 to 54, in 10 per cent; and at ages 55 to 64, in 20 per cent. No such rise with age occurred in any general population group for which com parable data are available. The prevalence of tuberculosis was greatest among the rock workers. The next to the highest rate occurred among anthracite workers who had changed more than hve years previously from very dusty to relatively non-dusty oc cupations in the industry. The third highest rate was exhibited among per sons who had had appreciable exposure to harmful dusts in other industries. .Among the regular miners working at the face, the rate was definitely higher than in the control group (men whose dust exposure averaged less than 5 million particles per cubic foot) which showed a prevalence rate of less than 1 per cent. When the term of service exceeded 20 years, more than 2 or 3 of which in volved exposure to heavy concentrations of rock dust, about 37 per cent of such employees [classified as rock workers) showed evidence of pulmonary tuberculosis. Service of 25 to 34 years was associated with a tuberculosis rate of 8 per cent among non-rock workers employed in the haulageways, of 14 per cent among the regular miners, but with a rate under 2 per cent among men exposed to less than 5 million dust particles per cubic foot of air. Asbestos: Exposure to asbestos dust may produce a pulmonary fibrosis which, like silicosis, may cause disability and death but which does not appear to carry with it a predisposition to tubercle infection and which has a pathology quite distinct from silicosis. The circumstances under which asbestosis will occur are not too clearly defined and undoubtedly^" there has been a tendency to classify as asbestosis cases in which the causal relationship of asbestos to the condition present has been assumed rather than proved. Our knowledge of asbestosis is based on individual reported cases. The actual number of fatal cases of asbestosis, supported by postmortem examination, is too few to have any statistical weight but the disease itself and its pathology have been clearly demonstrated. Gardner (13) believes that the action of asbestos dust, unlike silica, may be mechanical and not chemical. If this is so, it would well explain some of the con fusing aspects of this disease. The cases described have originated in textile and other asbestos fabricating plants and not in connection with the mining of asbestos. Pedley (14) found that the tuberculosis mor tality rate in Thetford Mines (whence 80 per cent of the asbestos used in the United States is derived) did not differ materially from the rate of the Province of Quebec as a whole. INDUSTRIAL DUSTS 429 rapidly increases as age advances. In the Non-silica Group, the comparative mortality is actually below normal up to age 35; it rises just above normal in the following age-group; but at ages over 45, it is conspicuously above normal. The report does not give the facts regarding the mortality from re spiratory tuberculosis separately for each of the eleven occupations in cluded in either the silica or the nonsilica group. Because of our special TABLE 3 Ratio of actual to expected deaths from respiratory tuberculosis among males ages 20 to 65 years, exposed to specified kinds of dusts, England and Wales, 1921-1923" Silica Dust ACTUAL OCATU erreerzo DfATU RATIO PCI CUT All selected occupations........................................................... Tin and copper mine--underground workers, not super- intending staff....................................................................... Potters' mill workers; slip makers; potters............................ Earthenware, china, etc-, kiln and oven men, and kiln set- ters and placers..................................................................... Metal grinders........................................................................... Sandstone miners and quarriers.............................................. Sandstone masons, cutters, and dressers................................ 654 92 105 50 221 56 150 179 3 37 23 60 17 34 365 1,150 284 217 368 212 441 Nonsilica Dust All selected occupations........................................................... Brick and plain tile makers, moulders, etc., furnace and crucible pot makers.............................................................. Brick, tile, etc., kiln and oven men....................................... Iron ore mine--underground workers, not superintending staff (Staffordshire and North Riding of Yorkshire)......... Limestone miners and quarriers............................................ Limestone masons, cutters, and dressers................................ 162 34 15 13 39 61 150.3 33.7 22 24 38.6 32 108 101 68 54 101 191 ' Compiled from: Registrar-General's Decennial Supplement, England and Wales, 1921, Part II. Occupational Mortality. interest in the facts for this particular disease, we have calculated, from the' original report of the Registrar-General (5), for each of the selected occupations, the number of deaths from respiratory tuberculosis which might have been expected on the basis of death rates prevailing among all occupied and retired civilian males between the ages oi twenty and sixtv-five. These results, together with the numbers of deaths which actually occurred, are presented in table 3. Each of the silica occupations had over twice the average number of 430 A. J. LANZA AND R. J. VANE deaths. The extraordinarily high ratio of 1,150 per cent was recorded for tin and copper miners, while sandstone masons, cutters and dressers had a ratio of 441 per cent. On the other hand, only the Limestone masons, cutters, and dressers in the nonsilica group exhibited a high ratio, 191 per cent. Why these men should have so high a ratio is not clear. It may be that many of them had carried on their trade, at one time or another, in districts where granite or sandstone were cut and, consequently, had been exposed to silica dust. So far as the occupations exposed to silica dust are concerned, as we have mentioned, these findings are in agreement with American insurance experience. Unfortunately, there are only a few occupations exposed to inorganic dust, other than those discussed under silica and coal dust, included in the .American insurance experience and none of these is entirely free from complicating exposure to silica. In the 1915-1926 Medico-Actuarial Study (6), a small group of grinders of metals had twice the expected number of deaths from tuberculosis, while in a some what larger exposure in the period 1925-1936 (7), the number of deaths from tuberculosis was about one and a half times the number expected. In recent years, sandstone grinding wheels have largely been. repW^L by composition wheels throughout industry. It is a fair assumption^ therefore, that most of the grinders were exposed to dust from composi^ tion wheels, silicon carbide, aluminum oxide, etc., althougtundoubfeilTjg some grinders were employed where sandstone wheels are still in use.' This comparatively favorable result is at variance with the result for grinders in England and Wales (5) who had a ratio of actual to expected deaths of 368 per cent. That study covered the years 1921 to 1923, and the proportion of workers using sandstone wheels may have been greater than in the later American insurance experience. The report of the Registrar-General brings out the important fact that grinders in the cutlery industry, where the sandstone wheel is much in use, have a much higher mortality than do other grinders. We have determined from the facts presented in this report that among the cutlery grinders there were over seven and a half times as many deaths from respiratory tuberculosis as expected, whereas among other grinders actual deaths were somewhat fewer than three times the expected. Buffers and polishers of metal, a somewhat similar group, were repre sented in the 1915-1926 American insurance study (6) by 17,000 life years oi exposure. There were 10 deaths from tuberculosis where 7 INDUSTRIAL DUSTS 431 might have been expected and IS deaths from influenza and pneumonia where 11 were expected. In the 1925-1936 study (7) there were 10 deaths from tuberculosis among limestone and marble cutters where one was expected. Here again, as in the case of the British limestone masons, cutters and dressers, the question is raised as to whether some of these men had not worked on granite and other stones as well. Granite and sandstone cutters in the American insurance experience, as we have shown, had more than twenty-six times as many deaths from tuberculosis as expected. American iron miners apparently have a different type of exposure from the British. We have included them in table 1, somewhat ar bitrarily, with the occupations exposed to silica dust. There were 12 deaths from tuberculosis among them where only 1.4 were expected, or a ratio of 857 per cent. This very high ratio suggests that, in some Amer ican mines, there may be a greater silica hazard than had been thought. The number of deaths was small, however, and the result cannot be considered conclusive. METALLIC DUSTS Hoffman (2), in Bulletin 231, emphasized the danger of exposure to metallic dusts (pages 51-161), but the experience of recent years has not borne out his conclusions. There has not been defined in the various industries in which exposure to metallic dust occurs any definite or specific pulmonary disease resulting therefrom. All the indications are that, where pulmonary disease has been described in conjunction with metallic dust, the blame must be placed on coincidental exposure to silica dust. Macklin and Middleton (17), reporting in 1923, point out that silicosis is associated with the use of natural grindstones and not artificial grindstones and make no mention of ill effects from metal dust. Collis (18) bad stated the same general conclusion in his well known Milroy Lecture in 1915 and stated further that the percentage of free silica is the index of harmfulness. Drinker (19) states that there are no data to indicate that iron in the absence of silica caused pathology in any way comparable to silicosis. Carleton (20) states that hematite is relatively harmless compared with flint and other silica dusts; if inhaled over long periods of time, it might cause fibrosis and tuberculosis but further evidence is needed. Under experimental conditions, it is a relatively harmless dust. In a series of experiments by Miller and Sayers (15), when iron oxide 432 A. J. LANZA AND R. J. VANE dust was injected into the peritoneal cavity of animals, the reaction was inert. In the process of welding, metals and metallic oxides are volatilized and inhaled into the lungs in a very finely divided state. Reports have been made of roentgen-ray films, taken during the physical examination of welders, which showed an appearance of nodulation resembling fine silicosis. This has given rise to the question as to whether silicosis might be contracted from welding (21, 22), although all these cases were symp tom free. One of the cases reported by Sander came to autopsy following an accidental death. No fibrous tissue was found and it was concluded that the nodular shadows on the film were caused by collections of iron and carbon pigment in the lymph channels of the lung (21, 23). No satisfactory statistics are available on the mortality of men ex posed solely to metallic dust. Perhaps there is as much dust of this character thrown off in grinding as in any other process and the comments regarding the mortality of grinders and of buffers and polishers, given under inorganic dust, are pertinent here. These mixed metal am dusts from the composition wheels do not seem to have produced mor tality rates irom tuberculosis comparable in any way with those where the silica hazard is severe. - -= ORGANIC DUSTS Until the action of various kinds of dusts upon the lungs was made the subject of experimental studies, the organic dusts, rising from industrial processes, were considered to be responsible for tuberculosis. Knowledge resulting from the extensive studies of silicosis has tended to minimize the possible action of organic dust, both on account of the large average size of the particles and their small numbers when compared with the concentration of inorganic dust particles found in various industries. The presence of pulmonary fibrosis or other structural change caused by organic dust and associated with infection has not been demonstrated among industrial workers. Nor is there evident, in connection with in dustrial processes involving exposure to organic dust, a clinical picture which could be compared with that associated with silica. The late Doctor Landis of Philadelphia was one of a group of physi cians who were among the first in this country to study tuberculosis among industrial workers. His studies included employees of a number was tilized 3 have nation g &ne might ng an d that n and :n ex it this ments given other . morwhcre ic the tstrial dedge limize eragc .h the 5tries. ed by rated th inxturc nhvsiuiosis '.mber [ I I J jI j ji I i INDUSTRIAL DUSTS 433 of textile plants and he stated that there was no evidence of organic dust causing pulmonary diseases (24). The mortality picture as regards organic dust and tuberculosis is confused. In the Registrar-General's Report (5), out of thirteen classes of textile workers, six had above average death rates from tuberculosis but in only one class--wool, worsted, card, comb or frame (not spinning frame) tenters--was the rate as much as 59 per cent above average. No TABLE 4 Standardized mortality <comparative mortality figures) from respiratory tuberculosis of males ages 20 to 65 years in occupations exposed to organic dust compared with that of all occupied and retired civilian males taken as 1,000, England and Wales, 1921-1923* OCCUPATION UOITAUTT 1AT10 Weavers of other textiles................................................................................. Boot and shoe clickers and cutters.................................................................. Skilled boot and shoe operatives, not dickers or cutters.............................. 1,000 1,065 750 1,095 1,057 1,591 796 1,072 898 869 510 731_- 1,162 9<H 1,320 1,821 1,016 2,002 1,262 2,576 * Compiled from Registrar-General's Decennial Supplement, England and Wales, 1921, Part II. Occupational Mortality. other class showed more than 16 per cent excess, while in several classes the rate was qui te low. On the other hand, boot and shoe factory workers showed an 82 per cent excess; tobacco factory operatives had 100 per cent excess mortality, and brush makers and drafters, 138 per cent excess. The rate for upholsterers, coach trimmers, bedding makers was 26 per cent above the average. Table 4 gives the Standardized Mortality for the principal occupations exposed to organic dust. A. J. LANZA AND R. J. VANE In the American insurance experience, covering the years 19151926 (6), also, the ratio of actual to expected deaths was above average for several occupational groups exposed to organic dust. The ratios of actual to expected deaths for the more important of these were: cotton mill operatives, 176 per cent; woolen mill operatives, 134 per cent; upholsterers, 225 per cent; cigar makers and tobacco factory operatives, 174 per cent. The occupations discussed here have been traditionally classified among the dusty trades. One may well question, however, the inclusion in such a list of boot and shoe and of tobacco factory workers. The great bulk of workers in these industries cannot be said to be exposed to appreciable quantities of dust. But taking the list as it stands, there is obviously no resemblance between the tuberculosis ratios for these oc cupations and the very high ratios for occupations with exposure to silica dust. Some condition connected with the work of persons in these trades obviously is associated with the above-average incidence of tuber culosis. It may be that the less robust workers are attracted to them. Whatever may be the explanation, clinical findings would suggi dust is not an important factor in the high incidence of tuberculosis in these trades. FUNGUS DISEASES OF THE LUNGS Dust may convey to the respiratory tract various types of fungi. Some of these apparently have no clinical significance. Others are pathogenic and may produce either acute or chronic disease. The constantly increasing use of the roentgen-ray in diagnosis and in routine physical examinations has served to awaken interest in fungoid diseases about which too little is known and which are not uncommonly diagnosed as tuberculosis (25). Our knowledge of the subject is very incomplete but it is recognized that these fungus diseases are frequently occupational in origin and associated with dust inhalation and may result fatally. Mortality statistics are entirely lacking, but the reports of Fawcitt (26) and the recent studies of coccidioidal infection in California (27) indicate that such pulmonary diseases may be quite important. PNEUMONIA The encct of dust inhalation upon the incidence of and mortality from pneumonia has been the subject of much study without any clear-cut picture of the role of dust resulting (32, 33). The foundry industry has fcd le le is d 1 il :e l II l .t I INDUSTRIAL DUSTS 435 an unusually high mortality from pneumonia (28) and the same is true of certain occupations in the steel industry (29, 30). Exposure to dust is associated with some of these occupations and usually extremes of temperature are also encountered with such other conditions as would tend to cause dampness and chilling. So far as silica is concerned, a high mortality from pneumonia is associated with the silica trades, both in this country and abroad. Whether silica acts as a predisposing cause of pneumonia or due to the accompanying lung damage the prognosis is more unfavorable, cannot be shown from the figures available. For some years, a series of interesting studies has been carried on in Pittsburgh by Haythom and Meller and their associates in an endeavor to establish any possible connection between the prevailing high mor tality rate from pneumonia in that dty and atmospheric pollution. These reports are interesting and suggestive but not entirely conclusive. The following quotation is from a recently published report of these authors (31). It is further seen ... that during the years from 1932 to 1935 when the de pression was at its height, when air pollution from industrial hues was greatly decreased and when economic and living conditions were at their worst, there was a great decrease in the number of deaths from pneumonia. However, the decrease occurred in females as well as males so that the change cannot be attributed to conditions within the plants, such as overheating and rapid chilling of the employees. STJiLMAfiV Early occupational mortality studies focussed attention on the im portance of dust as a cause of respiratory diseases. Virtually all kinds of dusts were implicated. Present day clinical and laboratory studies point to the serious damage to the lung tissue caused by a few dusts, notably silica and asbestos, and to the relatively little damage to the lung tissue caused by many other dusts. The most complete recent mortality studies have been examined in the light of this clinical and laboratory knowledge. These mortality data, while yielding highly suggestive information, are very incomplete and permit only quali fied general conclusions regarding the effects of dust exposure on the incidence of respiratory diseases for even the broad classes of dust with one exception--silica dust. The death rates from tuberculosis among men in occupations in which there is exposure to free silica so 436 A. J. LANZA AND R. J. VANE far exceed those found for men in other pursuits, as to leave little room for doubt that silica is implicated. With regard to silicate and other inorganic dusts not containing free silica, American mortality data are very meagre. The relatively low death rate from tuberculosis among grinders in the small American insur ance experience suggests that the effects of aluminum oxide, silicon car bide and other substances used in manufactured wheels are slight. British data, much more complete, show lower than average tuberculosis mor tality up to age thirty-five, but substantially higher mortality after age forty-five for a group of men exposed to inorganic dusts other than silica dust. Whether this unfavorable situation later in life is due to the cummulative effect of such dusts with duration of exposure or whether it is due to the inclusion in these occupational groups of a substantial number of men who had been exposed also to silica dust, is not dear. There are no mortality data for men exposed solely to metallic dusts. Recent statistical studies, like the earlier ones, show higher than aver age death rates from tuberculosis among men employed in certain occupations or industries in which organic dust is generated. In no in stance, however, does the rate for a group of this kind approach in mag nitude the extremely high rates found among men employed in some of the occupations in which there is exposure to silica du^mc^.the.iig}i tr of clinical knowedge, is it possible to account for the excessSj^ggjity on the score of damage to the lung tissue caused by dusSjjF The relationship between dust inhalation and acute pulmoRsSPQEise remains a field for further investigation. A splendid contribution to our knowledge of this subject has already been made by the United States Public Health Service in their bulletins on The Health of Workers in Dusty Trades (32, 33). A greater volume of data of this kind and more detailed studies of occupational mortality are vitally needed to guide the work of industrial physicians and hygienists in this field. REFERENCES (1) Hopfuan, F. L.: The mortality from consumption in the dusty trades, Bull. 79, U. S. Bur. Lab., November, 1908. (2) Hoffman, F. L.: The mortality from respiratory diseases in the dusty trades, Bull. 231, 0. S. Bur. Lab. Stat., 1918. (3) Hoffman, F. L., Chairman: Preliminary report of Committee on Mortality from Tuberculosis in Dusty Trades, WorIcing Conditions Service, U. S. Dept Lab., 1919. Second preliminary report of Committee on Mortality from Tuberculosis in Dusty Trades, Natl. Tuberc. .Assn., 1919. r- silica o the ether mtial clear, lusts, averrtain io inmagne of light callty sease o our tates rs in more guide u. s. 1. 231, from Lib., Dusty INDUSTRIAL DUSTS 437 (1) Whitney, Jessamine S.: Death rates by occupation, Natl. Tuberc. Assn., June, 1934. (5) Registrar-Generai's Decennial Supplement: England and Wales 1921, Part II, Occupa tional mortality, H. M. Stat. Off., London, 1927. (6) Joint Occupation Study, Actuarial Society of America and The Association of Life Insurance Medical Directors, 1929. (7) Occupation Study, Actuarial Society of America and The Association of Life Insurance Medical Directors, 1938. (8) Sayers, R. R., Chairman: Report of the Committee on the Prevention of Silicosis through Medical Control, U. S. Dept. Lab., November, 1936. (9) Sayers, R. R., Bloomiteld, J. J., Dallavalu:, J. M., Jones, R. R., Dreessen, W. C., Brundage, D. K., and Britten, R. H.: Anthraco-siiicosis among hard coal miners. Pub. Health Bull. 221, U. S. Pub. Health Service, 1936, p. 85. (10) National Tuberculosis Association: Framingham community health and tuberculosis demonstration, Framingham Monograph No. 10, July, 1924, p. 69. (11) Sydenstricker, E., and Britten, R. H.: The physical impairments of adult life, Am. J. Hyg., 1930, II, 89, 100. (12) Britten, R. H., and Thompson, L. R.: A health study of ten thousand male industrial workers, Pub. Health Bull. 162, 1926, p. 161. (13) GARnNER, L. U.: Reaction of the living body to different types of mineral dusts with and without complicating infection, Tech. Pub. No. 929, Am. Inst Min. & Met. Eng., May, 1938. (14) Pedley, F. G.: Asbestosis, Canad. J. Pub. Health, November, 1930. (15) Miller, J. W., and Sayers, R. R.: The physiological responses of the peritoneal tissue to dusts introduced as foreign bodies, Pub. Health Repts. 49, January 19, 1934. (16) Colus, E. L., and Yule, G. U.: The mortality experience of an occupational group exposed to silica dust, compared with that of the general population and an occupational group exposed to dust not containing silica, J. Indust. Hyg., 1933, 15, 395. (17) Mackun, E. L., and Middleton, E. L.: Report on the grinding of metals and cleaning of castings with special reference to the effects of dust inhalation upon the workers,U. K. Home Off., H. M. Stat. Off., 1923. (18) Collis, E. L.: Industrial pneumoconiosis with special reference to dust phthisis, Milroy Lectures, 1915; reprinted by H. M. Stat. Off., 1919. (19) Drinker, P.: Causation of pneumoconiosis. Harvard School of Public Health, 1937. (20) Carleton, H. M.: The effects produced by the inhalation of hematite and iron dusts in guinea pigs, J. Hyg., 1927, 26, 227. (21) Health protection in welding, Industrial Health Section, Metropolitan Lile Insurance Co., (b) 513 L.W. (22) Doic, A. T., and McLaughlin, A. I. G.: X-ray appearances of the lungs of electric arc welders. Lancet, London, 1936,230, 771. (23) Enter, N., and Sander, O. A.: Chronic lung changes in electric arc welders, J. Indust. Hyg. * Toxicol.. 1938, 20, 337. (24) Landis, H. R. M.: The relation of organic dust to pneumolconiosis, J. Indust. Hyg., 1925, 7, 1. (25) Sayers, R. R., and Meriwether, F. V.: Miliary calcifications of the lungs due to unknown cause. Reprint 1431 from Pub. Health Repts. 43. December, 1930. (26) Fawcttt, R.: Fungoid conditions of the lung, Part I, Brit. J. Radiol., New Series No. 99, March, 1936; Part II, Brit. J. Radiol., New Series No. 102, June, 1936. (27) Dickson, E. C-: Coccidioides infection, Arch. Int. Med., 1937, 50, 1029. ,*rr* 438 A. J. LANZA AND R. J. VANE (28) Iron foundry workers show highest percentage of deaths from pneumonia. Statistical Bulletin, Metropolitan Life Insurance Co., March, 1928, 9, 3. (29) Bloomfield, J. J.: Engineering aspects of industrial epidemiology, Indust. Med., 1938, 7, 7. (30) Kibbey, C. H.: Pneumonia and tuberculosis among industrial workers, Am. J. Pub. Health, 1937, 27, 6. (31) Haythobn, S. R., a.yd Melleb, H. B.: Pneumonia, Ibid., 1938, ZS, 483. (32) Thompson, L. R., Bbundage, D. K., Russell, A. E., and Bloomfield, J. J.: The health of workers in dusty trades. I. Health of workers in a Portland Cement Plant, Pub. Health Bull. 176, U. S. Pub. Health Service, April, 1928. (33) Russell, A. E., Britten, R. H., Thompson, L. R., and Bloomfield, J. J.: The health of workers in dusty trades. II. Exposure to siliceous dust (granite industry), Pub. Health Bull. 187, U. S. Pub. Health Service, July, 1929. i I 1 3 No commitments of any kind have been made by the Temporary Organization Committee as to the future policies or program of a permanent organization if and when one is formed, except that it has been arranged so that contributions and membership can become known or can remain unknown as may be elected by the individual contributor. o0o In conclusion - * A large number of people have said that they believe that there should be a central clearing house, - or co-ordinating body - to represent all industry in connection with the industrial dust problem. A Symposium has been held in Pittsburgh on January 15th, 1935. A Temporary Organization Committee was elected to prepare a plan and recommendation as to a permanent organization- 1935). This plan has been prepared and submitted (on February 6th, Whether a permanent organization shall be formed, and how it shall be formed, and what shall be its program is now in the hands of those to whom this ''narrative1' is being sent. Roger A. Hitchins As Chairman Temporary Organization Committee. LASER STOCK FORM FMU mW0V<T2- 12 2 6 l Egilman - By Plaintiff - Redirect. j Anything else? MR. BERRY: No, I think that is all I have, your Honor. MR. CONSTANTINE: Nothing further, your Honor. THE COURT: All right. You may step down. ; (Whereupon the witness was excused.) MR. PLACITELLA: I call Dr. Gerald Markowitz to the stand. GERALD Pk MARKOWITZ, MED. .. residing at 160 West 97th Street, New York, New York, called as a witness by the Plaintiff, having been first duly sworn was examined and testified as follows: DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. PLACITELLA: Q. Where do you currently live? A. I live in New York City, Manhattan. Q. Did you grow up in New York? A . Yes, I did. Q. Where? A. In the Bronx. THE COHUV GHOUP I 1)00 255 50<( zz. ; mm | i 1 Markowitz - Plaintiffs - Direct 1257 2 They wanted to do something about the health of 3 workers in t. hese dusty trades involved with silica 4 andasbestos. 5 Q There is nothing wrong with that? 6 A Absolutely not. 7 Q That was a goodmotive? 8 A Absolutely. % 9 Q Was there also a private purpose or private 10 agenda ? 11 A Yes. I think that the private agenda was 12 they wanted to do something about these lawsuits. 13 They wanted to find a way to combat these lawsuits 14 which were hurting them financially, and that is 15 what their private concern was, and that they did 16 not emphasize so much in their public statements. 17 Q You have in front of you a document which 18 has been marked for identification as Plaintiffs' 19 Exhibit Number 139. Is this the same document? 20 A Yes. 21 Q Where did you find that document? 22 A I found this document in the National 23 Archives, Washington. 24 Q The fact it has got a seal on it, what does 25 that mean? Z-S 9 1 1 Markowitz - Plaintiffs - Direct 1258 2 A It means that the Archive says that this is 3 a true copy of the document in the National 4 Archives. 5 Q What generally, don't get specific because 6 we don't have time, what generally is the document 7 about ? 8 A The document is about the founding of the 9 Air Hygiene 'Foundation. 10 Q That is one of the documents you relied 11 upon in reaching your opinions? 12 A Most definitely. 13 Q Is that the kind of document that an 14 historian like yourself would rely upon? 15 A Yes . 16 Q Do you know whether or not Owens-rCorning 17 Fiberglass was ever a member of the Industrial 18 Hygiene Foundation? 19 A Yes, it was a member. 20 Q .How do you know that? 2 1 A Well, in their membership lists that were 22 published periodically by the Industrial Hygiene 23 Foundation, they listed as a member, they say 24 beginning in 1953. 25 Q You don't know about if there were other