Document XO5nwj5xmb8qg4rd8QnD1pLOB
FILE NAME: Insulators Workers' Comp Claims (IWC) DATE: 1956 DOC#: IWC010 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: Claimant - McCarrell, E. 0.
i
; .__r;'-n2 -
formerly a wholly cwned subsidiary or ^rc:'uc '"3 Corporation, under it3 then nans or the niany, Ine., which wa3 permssably self-Insured; the
-
supply Company whose compensation carrier
as ?iv>ifi~ nnplcyers Insurance Company; Larry Carr, d/b/a Los
-^el-
-sirleerat Ion and Engineering Company, whose cospen-
3ation o a r M r - is unknown; J. T. Ihorpe Incorporated, whose compen
sation oarsr_er was Pacific Employers Insurance Company; Johns-
"
at Ion, whose compensation carrier wa3 The
Travel'fra -- " nCe Corr:pany; Pla*t insulation Company whose compen sation carrier was the Paciric Employers Insurance Coxapany and .
Fireasy s
Insurance Company; and the Cfrens-Corning Glass
Co=5 - y WhSSS compensation carrier was The Aetna Casualty & Surety Compary, a corporation; all or which above alleged e m p l o y e s
being At various locations throughout the State of California, sus tained an injury arising out of and occurring in the course of his
emplc^nt, allegedly consisting of occupational exposure to asbes
tos, s u i t i n g in the claimed injuries and disabilities to the ches
claimed herein.
2 . The actual weekly wages of the employee at the tire
of clc-VU3 d injury were maximum.
- '
3 . The nature of the employee's present disability Is In dispute and the employee has returned to work Irregularly since . the cessation Ox payments of temporary disability
it. Disability Indemnity has been paid to the applicant herein in t h e sum of $it,160.00 at ?lto.oo per week for the period
of Beefier 5, 1955 through December 4 , 1958. The amount due and
unpaid to the employee 13 in dispute.
5 . The parties hereby agree to settle any ard all elate
on accv-^nt of said injury by the payment of the sum of $13,500 00
over av-d above all monies paid heretofore, which sum is to be con
tributed as follows:
,
\
-2-
o
i
1. Flbreboard Paper Products Corporation,
2 formerly known as The Paraffine Company, Inc., sued
3 herein as Paraffine Company, Inc., and by Plant
4 Rubber & Asbestos Works, formerly a wholly owned
5 subsidiary of Flbreboard Paper Products Corporation
6 under it3 then name of the Paraffine Company, Inc.
$ 3 ,2 9 5 .CO
7
2. Standard^Accident Insurance Company,
8 a corporation
^7/ , v- 5,700.06
9
3. Travelers Insurance Company, a corporation -- 2,9^0.CO
10
4. Fireman's Fund Insurance Company, a
11 corporation
. 5.00
12
5. Liberty Mutual Insurance Company, a
13 corporation
14
6. Pacific Employers Insurance Company, a
185.00
15 corporation '
16
7. TOTAL
.
'
.
1,350.00 $13,50Q.c{)
17
From said cum shall be deducted the sum of
18 for attorneys' fees payable to William T. Hays, attorney for appli
19 cant, as .well a3 the deduction of any and all valid liens of record
20 from said sum.
.
'
,
21
6. It is agreed by and between the parties hereto that
22 any and all medical treatment not already furnished by the defen
23 dants herein Is to be borne by the applicant only, and not by any
24 of the defendants herein.
.
25
7. That applicant's attorney, William T. Kays, requests
26 an attorney's fee
, and has received the previous
27 attorney's fee in the amount of
C.-
, if any.
'
28
8. The name and address of applicant's attorney 13:
29 William T. Kay3, 6331 Hollyviocd Boulevard, Los Angeles, California.
30
9. REASONS FOR COMPROMISE:
31
A bona fide dispute exists between the parties as to
-XO whether or not the applicant in fact sustained an industrial injury
-3-
'
i
o
o
aa alleged, It is further contended that the disability payments to date in fact should be acreditcd to any claim for permanent dis
ability, assuming an industrial injury to have occurred, rather than!
as temporary disability inasmuch as, the condition was permanent ab initio. It 13 further denied that the applicant is in need of or entitled to further medical treatment, assuming that he sustained
7 an industrial injury.
8
It is further agreed by and between the parties hereto
r V11 i' 1 0
12
that in the event said Compromise and Release is approved, a dis missal with prejudice may issue in favor of Larry Carr, d/b/a los Angeles Market Refrigeration & Engineering Company, CUung^gppnirg Glass Company, and the Aetna Casualty & Surety Company, a corpora
13 tion. Further, the parties desire to avoid the hazards, delays and
14 costs of further litigation, and buy their peace. All medical re 15 ports now of record are, by reference, made a part of this agreement
16 as though written herein.
-
17
10. The undersigned respectfully request that this
IS Compromise and Release agreement be approved.
.
19
ll. Upon approval of this Compromise and Release asreenarl;
20 by the Industrial Accident Commission, and payment in accordance !
21 with the provisions hereof, said applicant releases and forever dis
22 charges said employers and insurance carriers, and each of them, and 23 their officers, agents, servants, employees and assigns of them, and. 24 each of them, and the nurses, physicians and surgeons of then, and
25 each of them, whether acting individually or on behalf of them, .o* .
26 any of them, from all claims and causes of action, whether now known
27 or ascertained, or which may hereafter arise or develop as a result I
of said injury and/or employments, including any and all liability j 28
of said employers and said insurance carriers, and each of them, to ;
*"
i
29
I
the deoendents, heirs, executors, representatives, administrators ;
30
"
t
or assigns of said applicant, and in further consideration of pay- j
31
ment in accordance herewith, applicant agrees that this release will. 32
U
o
1 apply to all unknown and unanticipated injuries arid damages resulting
2 from such accident, casualty, event, employment and/or employments,
3 as well a3 all those now disclosed and all rights under Section lf/*2
4 of the Civil Code of California are hereby waived.
5
Section lf&2 of the Civil Code of California reads as
/
6 follows:
7
"A general release does not extend to claira .
\
v/hich the creditor does not know to suspect
X
8
to exist in his favor at the tine of execu-
.
ting the release, which, if known by him,
`
9
naist have materially affected M s settlement
' .''
with the debtor."
10
11
12. It is understood and agreed by all of the parties
12 hereto that the applicant herein has not received unemployment coa-
13 pen3ation disability benefits from any source. .
* .
14
' WITNESS THE EXECUTION HEREOF thi3 ; '. day of
'
15
. '
.* 1959> at Lo3 Angeles, and San Francisco, California.
16
17 R v l i 6 , >IcCAlu\Ei2i, Applicant''
18
HAYS & KG LAUGHLIN
19
20
By
Attorneys for Applicant
21
ARKSTONQ CORK COH?ANY, A CORPORATION;
22
TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY, a corpora
tion, .,
23
By: HERLIKY & HERLHSTTl '
..
24
jj AUhfn ^ 25
Per / W
Attorneys foj above defendants
26
ARMSTRONG CORK COMPANY, a corporation;
27
STMT/`ID ACCIDENT INSURANCE COM?Ain, a
corporation
29
29
Ray^rcTtAis'liPk, 'iituorney for asove
r dpfe^ants 30
FIBREDOARD PAPER PRODUCTS CORPORATION,
31
formerly known as The Paraffine Company,,
Inc., sued herein as Paraffine Ccr.~rany,
- 32
Inc., and by PLANT RUBBER & ASBESTOS
A
Y/ORES, formerly a wholly owned subs idler
of Fibreboard Paper Products Corporation ;
under its then name of The Paraffine
*'
Company, Inc.
.
By: BROBECK, PHLEGER & HARRISON
t' * Pgr p-- ---> -
. _
* --*~-- ~ **
Rerialdo Sciaroni,' Jr., Attorneys! for
above defendants
- !
UNITED CORK COMPANY, a corporation; LIBERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, a corporation,
George R. Hasweli, Attorney for above ;
Refendants
'
B. Lou Lamoreaux, Attorney
JOHNS-MANVILLE SALES CORPORATION, a corporation; .THE TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY, a corporation,
By Vul-
Joseph Bilchak, Attorney for above
!U'
defendants
PLANT INSULATION COMPANY, a corporation;!
FIREMAN'S FUND INSURANCE COMPANY, a
corporation, .
Harold Shoop, Representative
MARINE ENGINEERING & SUPPLY COMPANY; J. T. THORPE, INCORPORATED; PLANT INSULATION COMPANY; PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INSURANCE COMPANY, a corporation,
By: CLQPTON/i: PENNY
^
//. , o y
,/Ct - V U f - f - A a Per _____ ______ _________________ __
Robert C. Runs, Attorney for ab re .
defendants
TATE OF CALIFORNIA )ss JOUNTY OF -i^QSrANGEL )
O n this A q / d a y of i'-:-
, 19 ">7 , before me, the
undersigned, a Notary Public in and for the said County and State,
residing therein, duly commissioned and sworn, personally appeared
2RVEY 0. McCARRELL, known to me to be the person whose name is sub
scribed to the -within Instrument, an d acknowledged to me that he
executed the same. />
,, ,
IN W I T N E S S 'WHEREOF, I h av e hereunto set m y hand ana airixec
ray official seal the 'day and year in this Certificate first above
written. v.
"N
7 //
Notary Public in and for said County and State of California . .
. ,f '
BALTIMORE NEW YORK
YCLARKSBURG
ulsa
Sr uouis CHICAGO ubs ANGELES IOLANTA pnTS BURGH SAN FRANCISCO NEW ORLEANS MIAMI PHILADELPHIA
A J K X A N l D E I R <& i ^ L I E X A H I D I E I R
INCORPORATED
INSURANCE
AVERAGE ADJUSTERS
CONSULTING ACTUARIES
2225 NORTH C H A R L E S STREET, BALTI MORE 18, MD.
November 2, 1960
TELEPHONE TUXEDO 9-4304
BELL SYSTEM TELETYPE BA 582
CABLE ADDRESS "ALEX8LUE"
Mr. William L. H u g h e s M a n a g e r Insurance Department Armstrong, Cork Company Lancaster, Pennsylvania.
Travelers Policy No.
RPB 4991518
Dear Sir:- Please note disposition made of the following claim;
Date of Accident;
November 14, 1956
Claimant;
E. 0. McCarrell
Location;
Sun Valley, California
Claim No.;
B-8289902
Disposition: Remarks:
$6,855.00 6.464.00
" 333.27
- Compensation - Medical - Expense
REVISION
3 ^
Very truly yours,
ALEXANDER & ALEXANDER INC.
Indicate Whether:
7 rw.
LOSS DEPARTMENT
Workmen1s Comp._______ Auto Liability B.I.___
P.D.___ General Liability B.I.
P.D.
s jm
BALTIMORE
NEW YORK CLARKSBURG
TULSA ST. LOUIS CHICAGO LOS ANGELES ATLANTA PITTSBURGH SAN FRANCISCO NEW ORLEANS MIAMI PHILADELPHIA
ALEX A N 3IEIR & AXJEXATVIIDIER
INCORPORATED
INSURANCE
AVERAGE ADJUSTERS
CONSULTING ACTUARIES
2225 NORTH C H A R L E S STREET, BALTI MORE 18, MD.
TELEPHONE TUXEDO 9-4304
BELL SYSTEM TELETYPE BA 582
CABLE ADDRESS "ALEXBLUE"
July 27, 1960
Mr. William L. Hughes, Manager Insurance Department Armstrong Cork Company Lancaster, Pennsylvania
Travelers Policy No.
RUB 4991518
Dear Sir: Please note disposition made of the following claim:
Date of Accident:
November 14, 1956
Claimant: Location:
E. 0. McCarrell Sun Valley, California
Claim No. : Disposition:
Remarks :
B 8289902
$6,505.00 6,461.58 333.27
Compensation Medical Expense
REVISION
Indicate Whether:
Workmen's Comp. _______ X Auto Liability B.I.______
P.D.______
General Liability B.I.___
P.D.
Very truly yours,
ALEXANDER & ALEXANDER, INC.
j&.
xiaX o -v
LOSS DEPARTM1EENNTT
V
BALTIMORE NEW YORK CLARKSBURG TULSA ST. LOUIS
CHICAGO LOS ANGELES ATLANTA PITTSBURGH SAN FRANCISCO NEW ORLEANS MIAMI PHILADELPHIA
A lexander
AuEXArairaiEa*
INCORPORATED
INSURANCE
AVERAGE ADJUSTERS
CONSULTING ACTUARIES
2225 NORTH C H A R L E S STREET, BALTI MORE 18, MD.
July 13, 1960
Hr. William L. Hughes, Manager
.
Insurance Department
Armstrong Cork Company
Lancaster, Pennsylvania
Travelers Policy No.
4991518
Dear Sir: Please note disposition made of the following claim:
Date of Accident: November 14, 1956
Claimant:
E. 0. McCarrell
Location:
Sun Valley, California
Claim No. : Disposition:
Remarks:
B-8289902
$6,855.00 - Claim 6,461.58 - Medical 333.27 - Expense
REVISION
Indicate Whether:
Workmen's Comp.____ X Auto Liability B.I.___
P.D.___
General Liability B.I. P.D.
s jm
Very truly yours, ALEXANDER & ALEXANDER, INC.
f a il.
LOSS DEPARTMENT
V
TELEPHONE TUXEDO 9-4304
BELL SYSTEM TELETYPE BA 582 CABLE ADDRESS
"ALEXBLUE"
/
BALTIMORE NEW YORK CLARKSBURG TULSA
ST. LOUIS CHICAGO LOS ANGELES ATLANTA PITTSBURGH SAN FRANCISCO NEW ORLEANS MIAMI PHILADELPHIA
^JEXAKTIDIEIR & AJEXATOIDIER
INCORPORATED
insurance
AVERAGE ADJUSTERS
CONSULTING ACTUARIES
2225 NORTH CHA RL E S STREET, BAL TI MORE 18, MD.
March 22, 1960
TELEPHONE TUXEDO 9-A30A
BELL SYSTEM TELETYPE BA 582
CABLE ADDRESS " ALEXBLUE"
Mr. William L. Hughes, Manager Insurance Department Armstrong Cork Company Lancaster, Pennsylvania
Dear Sirs
Travelers Policy No. RUB 4991518 _
Please note disposition made of the following claim
Date of Accident: Claimant: Location: Claim No.: Disposition:
Remarks:
November 14, 1956
E. 0. McCarrell
m J t I * Tfcll
Sun Valley, California
B-8289902
$4,160.00 2,265.00 6,548.55 337.27
- Temp. Total - Perm. Partial - Medical - Expense
Very truly yours * ALEXANDER & ALEXANDER, INC.
Indicate Whether:
Workmen's Comp ____ X _ Auto. Liability B.I._____ _
P.D.______ _
General Liability B.I._____ P.D._____
s jm
BALTIMORE NEW YORK CLARKSBURG TULSA ST. LOUIS
CHICAGO LOS ANGELES ATLANTA PITTSBURGH SAN FRANCISCO NEW ORLEANS MIAMI PHILADELPHIA
A lex a n d er
INCORPORATED
INSURANCE
AVERAGE ADJUSTERS
CONSULTING ACTUARIES
2225 NORTH C H A R L E S STREET, BALTI MORE 18, MD.
November 18th, 1959
TELEPHONE TUXEDO 9-4304
BELL SYSTEM TELETYPE BA 582
CABLE ADDRESS "ALEX8LUE"
Mr. R. C. Schiedt, Jr. Insurance Department Armstrong Cork Company Lancaster, Pennsylvania
Dear Mr. Schiedt:
Re : Ervey 0. McCarrell Sun Valley, California File B 8289902 - Comp. D/A November 14. 1956
Recent inquiry of the Travelers Insurance Company indicates that a Hearing was held, wherein other defend ants were joined. A tentative agreement for a settlement was reached, however, further details as to various contributions are still being worked out. The Travelers have promised to advise us when this has been finalized. The tentative settlement agreement is for $13,500.
The above is for your information and file.
Sincerely
R
~^%n^-^s<^js-V- Avf-^^i ^.--jisf-' ''-'.A';.;-#>-5'--' s '^r>f!^ % ' - r H / - ^ .:
"^.f,--it'^ ; 'V' '.-'T*-*::-V"./ ;,;,''.'-.%*<''.* *"*.--. -1/"- - '.f./{*>'';v
, Ji
'*
~f *.%.;?.V*I-
.......... '
.... ` .... ' .... ..*3
August 28, 1959
Ths Travelers Insurance Company
510 V. Sixth S treet Los Angeles^ 11, C a lif.
Qantlsaan
Attention* Mr. Joseph Bilchak
Subject* /'' MMir. Ervey 0 . McCarLfill-.
jfB-8239902 ^ C a lif . #56-LA-176-681
In reply to your August 21 le t t e r , ve l i s t vhat ve b e lie v e to be the Standard Accident Insurance Company p o licy numbers oovering Mr. McCarrell' 8
employment prior to 1952*
1911
1915 1916
1917 1918
1919 1950
1951
AZ-561217
AZ-571901 AZ-590150
AZ-609225 AZ-639900
AZ-663100 AZ-638300
AZ-713180
The enclosed Thermo-fax o f our August 18 le t t e r to Mr. McDonald o f Standard yjjJL giro you the names o f the men you might vish to contact. Ve sent Mr. Boss a sim ilar se t o f P hotostats, an ticip atin g your future request. I f you have not as y e t received them, ve suggest you contact Mr. Boss, neaager o f
the Los Angeles o ffio e o f AC&S, immediately.
Ve agree S o cia l Security records do not n ecessa rily give the vhole story. Hovever, due to the fa c t th at the pipe covering aechanica often work for a number o f employers during the course o f a year, one might conceivably accumulate h is en tire earnings for a p articu lar year aa each aaployer i s required to report the f i r s t $3,000 paid up to and including the year 1950,
$3,600 up to and including 1951, and $1,250 up to and including 195.
Ve tru st th is infbxmation w ill help in apportionment proceedings.
^
Tory tru ly yours,
ABMSTRQJfG CORE C0MPAHX
Enclosure
JL. B. Boss, AC&S, Los Angeles J . E. S e lle r , AC&S, Lancaster
R. 0 . Sohledt, J r . Insurance Department
CLAIM DEPARTMENT
FRANK O. MENNEN, Golm Manager
August 24, 1959
BRANCH OFFICE 510 W e*t Sixth Street LO S ANGELES 14, CALIFORNIA Telephone MAdison 8*0311
B 8289902 Armstrong Cork Company Re: Ervey 0. McCarrell 56 LA 176-684 -
Armstrong Cork Company
Lancaster,
Pennsylvania
Attention: R. C. Schiedt Insurance Department
Gentlemen:
At a recent Hearing on the above captioned matter a question of coverage for workmen's compensation insurance by Standard Accident Insurance Company was raised. Our California Inspection Rating Bureau does not have any records with regard to coverage by Standard Accident for Armstrong Cork Company; therefore, we have been asked to determine if you could supply us with the policy numbers for the periods during which Standard Accident carried your workmen's compensation insurance in California.
In addition to t h e above an attempt was made to determine apportionment between the various defendants based upon Social Security Records. However, this was not possible due to the fact that the amounts from any given employer in one year are only recorded up to a maximum of $3,600.00. We have been asked therefore, to ascertain if possible, relative to the periods of employment of Mr. McCarrell, in terms of days land gross earnings during those periods of employment.
Thank you for your anticipated cooperation.
Very truly yours -
JB:mr
.Hearing Representative
HOME OFFICE:
700 M A I N S T R E E T , H A R T F O R D 15, C O N N E C T I C U T
August 1$, 1959
Mr. T. C. McDonald Manager, Claims Department Standard Aecident Insurance Company 548 8 . K ingsley Drive Los Angeles 5, Calif
Bear Mr. McDonald]
At the phone requcst 0f Mr. C. B. L itsin g er o f the Standard Aocidmt Insurance Coapeny, Pittsburgh o ffic e , we enclose P hotostats o f toe e n in gs record o f B. 0 . McCexroll Vhlle in the aploy o f Armstrong Cork Company froa 1944 to 1956 in c lu siv e. Be vas not in Armstrong* s m ploy during the yaars 1947 and 1948
Standard Accident vas the insuranoe ca rrier up to and inclnding the y**1 1951 a fter vhich Travelers toofc over. P rier to May 10, 1949# the a a jo rity o f McCarroll* s eaploynm t vas v ith other employer* as the records v i l l in d ic a te .
I f tou hve any questions regarding vorking conditions, ve suggest ycu
contact Mr. R. B. Boas, Di st r i ot Manager o f the Lois Angeles <ottLcjot
Armstrong Contraeting and Supply Corporation, a ufaolly-om ed subsidiary o f Armstrong Cork Company.
Yery tru ly yours,
ABKSTBOBQ CDRK C0MPAH7
ia
Sxcioauras
R. B. Rosa, AC&S, Loa Angeles J . E. Z eller, AC&S, Lancaster
R. C. Schiadt, J r . Insurm ce Department
August 18, 1959
Mr* R* B. Ross Armstrong Contr 4400 B* Bandinl Loe Angelos 23,
and Supply Corporation rard >
Dear Mr* Rossi
Subject 5* O. McCarroll B-S239902
Ve aclose a sim ilar Bet o f p h otostats which vas requested by Standard Accident Insurance Company la s t veek.
Mr. Joseph Bilchek o f Travelers Los Angeles o ffio e requested in January o f th is year some general inform ation about McCarroll' s employment record with Armstrong, but vs b eliev e he should have the enclosed photostats* In the second retrospective rating o f our 1956 poliqy, Travelers estab lish ed a $20,000 reserve on th is claim , which resu lted in Armstrong depositing about $23,354 with Travelers.
Since .Travelers Armstrong coverage only Included the years 1952 to 1956 in c lu siv e, p rior insurance companies should be involved when apportionment
proceedings are in itia te d by Travelers i f I t v&s the la s t insurance carrier Involved.
Ve suggest you pass th is id ea along to Travelers Los Angeles o ffic e at the
time you turn over McCarroU* a employment records.
.
Very tru ly yours,
ARMSTRONG CORK C0MPAHI
JE2 Enclosures J . I . Z eller, AC&S, Lancaster
R. C. Schledt, J r. Insurance Departsant
<
,>,
`'if*
,-ti<,*t^`j*freii>li:i~vl;i|<TilLir't*l'!-vi;t^
.'_i* ' -t)>l
--- ---- ._ .
' ';:.'!f/ i ^.1tr-l-i I SwV:--r^'-
t y - ^ a t A - - - a ^3p
,
" I H W ' jp-
\l 1 '4--*." r ;;'*"r ~i - i- t ''jr
f
J ,hs;jt I .,LJLTM.L-.L.l^.LJ,.X^!Ll^1
:*
*" " ^ Tr ^|r~/1rT~R''''*?jjr-~*|p
F"-- ET^J* '""'{T
l
A.,.!
rT
r
--U .
N E0H E]0BD EESESEEliO EE3nD D ED L,E:iCEl.O ij rrm 1er"*? -- e**"*----
*
g***??fr*,-''tTPT"-PT?~r m ii-* >*'-- 71 pr*^"*4 r-i--
r.
fT''?fTc^^_t4 F--- - l***-+*--
ngpiEjEjEB B B B B B B E E B m O E B O EEEESEfOOEm liJLitJbJlEli El-jLiJi|j Silij*Ili e~t ff~~y r^~^"
i .:
-2^|:-^i3SlEl
*1^illlIHfa'^liiwiji
g
q
-srTMe*55^*
r^F'i p i F
T | % J W : / V , U y ] p ~ L 3F T - v r i v / i
-*-- t I1. 1" ' W - ,'|'"'."'" "V ' " ' H T V ` W - T " JM*' " |W ' W " " 1
...UIMlAI* S-A4 MrkwV..i>*Ul** ****& ` **..*4 + V 1*"* '*
.. ........... .... _
...... _ ................................... ... .............. ........ Evitici*h*
.. ;J U U D t 3 0 t ^ E J i 3 E OE ! S i i H i i L . . ^ i C ^ H ^ j i a E ^ ^ m ^ E j ^ C Z J E a L I M
.,,,,jJum^ SmS Haasa SHOiaEijiialELS_S E IS a ia i^ O P E ilia S E Z IE lE E iS ra E lliS ^ IE a E M
1 .;L'i35LilEJOEaE!ElE3E!aBSBj
oQQaopiiiatiEaa^wataiK.v,
5 '"'
.,,, -,
.-yjg--j w i'<i>nf
V
11 ..'. : iM ry,V
iI r' ""'1^i3ji VfT|T'jL
JL';-rT--Jr'--">^-4 1r 1- -Lr.',' "WC:5!IfLV,-j.V"T.I-.;, 'i'.1-""'i .*'I'.j I*-p> r ip
-- ,--
r '.ir ','J,
l;
*=~lW*'vpy"r-y:-Ppry .T?;!'.1iWttTjwy
`mr+<mh1p*<Vr*'F71i '
' ,: ' .,'4sv;; .'l? '.r;'.-,'i
./,>-;-v,*''AV/iT *cY/.w.:.;'<"-,J ''r;; ,'',,."j...'w;U'*T?^s'u
iin.r... ------i ..*LM.<*liii W tfM giifcjrnt
jhdirt.- ./-KlL.'taVt.&fc-;.-. A t'.i: 1*&.<-!&
*<>i* k --.-,'-y ^
.../i*LiL?-a5^
:'l?
P'h g**
mZMiiiuM urnmtititm^am
*vu
i
M f n ^ a u - U y - f-|j-|||iiiViiifia,`i
rnuiti>MIUkttiMr t 'inll ftiliirtiA
a.iatoy
'aewiwiuwuuiaku
Vd*il
;ilY .>-- w
`- m v
..,' r ' '^"7yW
B
*\\-'-r,r\<:. 1 K*"TT r .^wnrH^- I*"1. 1* 1?'*11
I"- Sf *? '
-. W`' '<
" I P
*/.
\'-, ^ - 1" "'
;
v - ;' ' y* W W * 1 S**>
y
5355
B5E25!Z5!$Z$*SOEB^SSC55CTSfT?,7r\-,r'
1
!
a
/
\ A C
Yv\~
(LjLsis-uAQ*
j ' yrYX
b 7 'i ' i "* .\c
i.i
^ k 1ll'l'/V'M-
0 2 .1 3
ix , e j / Y ^ Y j ^
\i & j / d ^ w ; ; 2 / / /
z t$
o^4 t/f^*/- *5wA
py w v w $ $ \ , 0 ^ 2
1 *5 0 54-.'
BALTIMORE NEW YORK CLARKSBURG TULSA ST. LOUIS CHICAGO LOS ANGELES ATLANTA PITTSBURGH SAN FRANCISCO NEW ORLEANS MIAMI PHILADELPHIA
A lexander
A uexanidieir
INCORPORATED
INSURANCE
AVERAGE ADJUSTERS
CONSULTING ACTUARIES
2225 NORTH C H A R L E S STREET, BALTI MORE IS, MD.
June 17th, 1959
\ZC 5
TELEPHONE TUXEDO 9-A304
BELL SYSTEM TELETYPE BA 582 CABLE ADDRESS
'ALEXELUE"
Hr. R. C. Schiedt, Jr. Insurance Department Armstrong Cork Company Lancaster, Pennsylvania
Dear Mr. Schiedt:
B 8289902 re: E. 0. McCarrell Sun Valley, California P/A November 14, 1956
Supplementing our letter to you of June 26, 1958 pertinent to the above case, we inquired of the Travelers recently in respect to the status thereof and are now in receipt of their reply, which reads =
"Please be advised that other defendants have been joined, social security records and coverage information as well as copies of our medical file are currently being served upon the other defendants. We anticipate a Hearing on this matter in the next few months."
The above is for your information and file.
Sincerely
1 4 S I .1 3 \ o
R
ALEXANDER & ALEXANDER, INC.
SL
'iWl* t>T@PT.
OSS DEPARTMENT
f
January 27# 1959
Nr* Joseph Bilchak The Trareler* Insurance Company 510 Vast Sixth S treet Los Angeles Li# C alif*
Baer Sir* j
Subject! /claim #1-3289902
J E* 0* McCarreil
56 U 176.634
a//*/>/<&
In reply to your le t t e r o f January 20, th is nan n s employed as a building mechanic by Amstrong Cork Company fo r the f ir s t time in 1944*
Prior to 1952, Standard Aooident Insurance Company was Armstrong Cork Company's insurance carrier*
Hoverer, these building mechanics often worked for more than one employer daring the course o f a year. In fa c t, our records in d icate McCarreil had no employment with Armstrong during 1947 and 1913.
Very tru ly yours#
ABMSTROSG CORK COX?AST
R. C* Schiadt# Jr* Insurance Department
JZ2
\
6^
CLAIM DEPARTMENT FRANK O , MENNEN, Claim Manager
BRANCH OFFICE 510 West Sixth Street LOS ANGELES 14, CALIFORNIA Telephone! MAdUon 8-0311
January 20, 1959
B 8289902 Armstrong Cork Comp 1 Re: E. 0. McCarrall 56 LA 176-684
Armstrong Cork Company Lancaster, Pennsylvania
Gentlemen:
We are currently processing a Workmen's Compensation claim on a former employee before the Industrial Accident Commission here in California, It is necessary for us to know the name and periods of coverage of your Workmen's Compensation carrier for the period January 1, 1944 to January 1, 1952, It is our understanding that one of your prior insurance carriers was Standard Accident Insurance Company written through an agent in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
This information has been requested by our attorneys handling this claim. Therefore, any preferred attention you can devote thereto will be greatly appreciated.
Very truly yours,
JB:kb
i
tentative
HOME OFFICE.
700 M A I N S T R E E T , H A R T F O R D 15, C O N N E C T I C U T
V
BALTIMORE NEW YORK CLARKS8URG TULSA ST. LOUIS CHICAGO LOS ANGELES ATLANTA PITTSBURGH SAN FRANCISCO NEW ORLEANS MIAMI PHILADELPHIA
A l e x a n d e r & A msxaotdhsm
INCORPORATED
INSURANCE
AVERAGE ADJUSTERS
CONSULTING ACTUARIES
2225 NORTH C H A R L E S STREET, BALTI MORE 18, MD.
jane 26th, 1958
II!
TELEPHONE TUXEDO 9-4304
BELL SYSTEM TELETYPE BA 5S2 CABLE ADDRESS
"ALEXBLUE"
Mr. R. C. Schiedt, Jr. Insurance Department Armstrong Cork Company Lancaster, Pennsylvania
. .
Dear M r .Schiedt:
{ re: E. 0. McCarrell
\ Workmen's Compensation
We requested a status report from the Travelers on the above case and ve quote from their letter of June 20th, 195 as follows:
"This case is becoming very complicated and costly, due to the advance state of asbestosis.
"The latest reserves set ftp on this case is temporary total disability $k,000; permanent partial disability $7500; medical $8500.00 and expense $10 0 . "The rnan is disabled and we believe will be so indefinitely, with constant medical treat ment. We are endeavoring to join numerous other de fendant employers, in order to show that there was other exposure to asbestosis besides the exposure at the Armstrong Cork Company.
"We have filed an application for hearing, but have not as yet received a setting date."
The above is for your information and file.
Sincerely ALEXANDER & ALEXANDER, INC.
BALTIMORE NEW YORK CLARKSBURG TULSA ST. LOUIS CHICAGO LOS ANGELES ATLANTA PITTSBURGH SAN FRANCISCO
Si AlLJKXAISlIMSIl*
INCORPORATED
INSURANCE
AVERAGE ADJUSTERS
CONSULTING ACTUARIES
2225 NORTH C HA R L E S STREET, BALTI MORE 18, MD.
May 20th, 1957
fa
TELEPHONE TUXEDO 9-4304
BELL SYSTEM TELETYPE BA 5S2
CABLE ADDRESS "ALEXBLUE"
Mr. R. C. Schiedt, Jr. Insurance Department Armstrong Cork Company Lancaster, Pennsylvania
iV 211957 IYi.fi
Dear Mr. Schiedt:
Workmen's Compensation - 1956 re: E.O. McCarrell
Sun Valley, California n/a n / i k / ^ File B 8289902
This case is now before the California In dustrial Accident Commission for a hearing.
are:
The reserves being carried by Travelers
Temporary Total Permanent partial Medical Expense
$ 1,000 3>500 2,000 100
The above is for your information and file.
Sincerely
Mr* James E. Tannon Alexander & Alexander, Inc* 2225 Borth Charles S treet Baltimore IS , Md.
Dear Jims l
March 1 , 1957
In reply to your February 25 le t t e r , we are lis t in g three lo ca tio n s in or near Los Angeles where Travelers can in sp ect our in su la tin g jobs:
B* f* Qoodrioh Company
5400 East Olympic Boulevard
Lob Angeles, C alifornia
(Southern C alifornia Edison Company Redondo Steam Station Plant 2, U nit 6 Redondo Beach, C alifornia
Douglas A ircraft Company DC-S Building Long Beaoh, C alifornia
Our records in d ica te Mr* McCarrel started working for Armstrong in 1941* However, between 1944 and 1949 a period o f s ix years, he only worked a to ta l o f 7 weeks, in d icatin g th at he had other employers. From 1950 on, he worked q u ite regularly for Armstrong.
These a sb estos!s claim s are on the in crease, and we are wondering i f toe manufacturers o f th is high temperature in su lation which ve use could be o f some assista n ce in toe defense o f these claims*
Very tru ly yours,
R* G. Schiedt, Jr* Insurance Department JEZ
'4
BALTIMORE NEW YORK CLARKSBURG TULSA ST. LOUIS CHICAGO LOS ANGELES ATLANTA PITTSBURGH SAN FRANCISCO
AlJKXASIDIEIR Ss A i x a ^i d e m
INCORPORATED
INSURANCE
AVERAGE ADJUSTERS
CONSULTING ACTUARIES
2225 NORTH C HA R L E S STREET, BALTI MORE 18, MD.
TELEPHONE TUXEDO 9-4304
BELL SYSTEM TELETYPE BA 502
CABLE ADDRESS "ALEX8LUE"
February 25, 1957
EBSG
Mr. William L. Hughes, Manager Insurance Department Armstrong Cork Company Lancaster, Pennsylvania
7 M
'
WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION INSURANCE Policy No. RUB-U99l5l8__________ .
Dear Bill:
We are enclosing herewith copy of the Travelers letter of February 19th concerning Occupational Disease claim of E. 0. McCarrel who has acquired a lung condition which has been attributed to his handling various asbestos material while an employee of Armstrong Cork Company.
We particularly want to call your attention to the last paragraph of the attached letter concerning a proposed survey .. of an insulating job currently in the vicinity of Los Angeles, California. We shall appreciate it very much if you will notify your Contract Department to afford the Travelers every opportunity to complete their inspection of these operations.
JEFrmw Enclosure
MAMCH orna
AMMMtmATKM DWA*TMHT W. A CAJTVHt, 0 # k . M--
nu'fJerl 3& 3EmrJ**
February 19, 1957
/
MAMCH OfMCI 1003 M .rcan H I. Tni* IWW* J01 loat laH im or* Sir* ol C o lw t * 4
lA LT lM O tt 2, M ARYLAND Tel..*..-. lf 4 0 t0 M f 00,0
Alexander & Alexander, Inc. 2221 N. Charles Street Baltimore 18, Maryland
ATTN: Mr. Fannen
HE: Armstrong Cork Company Policy: RUB-4991518 Policy Period: 1/1/56-57 Claim #: B-8289902 Date of Accident: 11/1A/56
HE'S' vr:D
-EB I N
*
e
r
-.
r
0
;
*
Dear Sir:
h ^ r ^ W c o n a i " TM ^ r ^ u .
S t d X of variousasbestos mtteriale * 1 1 . in the employ. of th.
f
S * C mnlni. This man has been with our assured since
atraroxiaately i ^ ^ a l t h o u g h we understand he does estimate that p o s s i b l y
f S a n t year h f . employed by other in.ul.ting c o m p a n y .
W. underatand that recently Mr. McCarr.ll >'ad coughing
th, coughing became so :severe
hat he
. ,, j ^ d by a doctor
TJI T St. J T c TM
T
to^our^laim*department becauee of the occupational
present t i . he la unabl. to
and hae to conserve
hi3 strength as much as possible.
Our claim department has set up an estimate of $6600.00 on this claim.
This is to advise you that our engineering department is
* J"1"
i slr of an insulating job currently in operation in the vicinity of
urvy
P o U f A m U This way it is felt that we will then be able
this exposure.
HOME OFflCE
7 00 M A I N S T R E E T , H A RT F O * D l i , C O N N E C T I C U T
- Page 2 -
As soon as vie have anything future for you in this matter v w i U our findings to you.
suhmit
TFB/slg
Very truly yours,
r 4
rv 4
T. F . Bryant, Asst. Office Manager
jLO- it-r'J~S
-0. h4^
\ tr *1 ' ? '1 ft* 7_
\ 33
0 & So
1 Sl
p/A ',-',
Z o *r-)
0 ',' V t
n < $ \\ A - &
1
fyfjj.
\
' E mployer's report of industrial injury
'
STATE OF C ALIFO RN IA
d e p a r t m e n t o f in d u s t r ia l r e l a t io n s
DIVISION OF LABOR STATISTICS AND RESEARCH
Every question must be answered fully to avoid further correspond ence. FAILURE TO FILE IS A MISDEMEANOR SUBJECT TO MAXIMUM FINE OF $100.
(Labor Code. Section 6407-6413)
*
Claim Department
1
THE TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY
510 West Sixth Street, Los Angeles 14, Calif.
DE.C 10 1956 SMB
Please make this report in DUPLICATE so that we can file copies with Division of Labor Statistics and Research in your behalf.
. .
,
work injury to an employee which causes disability lasting longer than the day of the injury or which requires medical services other than first ^t7eaT m eni muTt reported within five days after the injury. If the injury results in death, a report must be made by telephone or telegraph directly
to the Division of Labor Statistics and Research not later than 24 hours after death.
_______________________
EMPLOYER
Armstrong Cork Coiapany (Give name under which
1. Name concern does business)
g_--a'ndl205~Haple Avenua ^.LrLoa 2. Office address Street) (Manufacturing shoes, retailing men's N ature of business clothes, trucking for hire, etc.) .......
nsula tico
Angeles,
California
DO NOT WRITE IN THIS COLUMN
Case No.
Employer No.
mjUSBD TMPLgEE0> H cC al0fell
(No.^r"i22l5?_Hart Street 4. Name--------------------- ----------------------------T*--PT*
5. Address .Street) --------... ............- -- 1------------ --------
6. Age.. s i
9. Number of hojirs 10. Wages: $.
7. Sex:
(v0 Male.:
Female.
T 30.&0 per day.
____ uP week- E o
_per hour, or
.per day. or $-
____-Soe. Sec. No,rfLsr:--s. .SSl-01-6316
<.y.'andNorth Hollywood
8. Check ( V) M arried-
^gle-
___ Number of day worked per week.
I5k.00 .per week. (If earning at irregular rate, such
Indos try Age
as piece work or on commission basis, enter actual average weekly earnings for convenient period not to eaceed one year.) 11. If board. '~ V "tr or other advantages furnished in addition to wages, give estimated value $..... ..................... per day, or X .
,,per week
Sex and Marital Status
ACCIDENT
a^a^Va lle y
12. Place of accident <Ym" otTTQ
13. On employer's premises No)..,...i.,..:Jy ..
steam ifr3 u n Valley
14. Departm ent.
.(County) Loa Angolea
IS. Date of accident- 11-14-51
id. Hour of day_
X S ./ P .M . 17. Did injury result In disability beyond day of
accident? * N o ) __ 18. If yes, give date last worked------------ ----- ---------_---_--_--_--_--_--_--_--_---_--_--_--_--_--_--_---_--_-_ _ 19. Was injured paid In full for
thisdav? N -? r ^ Q S .... 20. If injured in a mine, check (V ) accident location: Surface.-----------Mill------------Underground----------- Shaft
CAUSE OF ACCIDENT 21. Occupation (job titlg)._.A3.ke.3.i.Q3
___ o r k o g - Z o g c g a a iL
occupation? Check (V) Less than 6 months.----- --- ; 6 months to 2 years.-- .------- ; over 2 -y
(Describe briefly, auchas: loading truck, operating
rv n l
n rr T r i m ' l l
occurred? drill press, shoveling dirt, walking down stairs, etc.)-------n i. j- w . ,
22. How long employed by you at this 23. W hat was employee doing when accident tfhT n r
Weekly Wage County
Accident Date Occupation
o tne lungs aha caused "coughing*
laaTInsulating fine p&rtTcTe
Accident Type Agency
-- .............
.......
'
' (Name the specific machine, tool, appliance
25. What -- eh ie. tool, substance, or object was most closely connected with the accident?
gas. liquid, etc., involved)
-
-- -----
(State if gears, pulley.
26. If mechanical apparatus or vehicle, what part oi it? (Y ^or *tCd 27. Were mechanical guards, or other safeguards provided? No)
(Yes or __28.a!Was injure..dtihuLsa.ia?nkagant--hbeUTmat.?aak1.eNanaob)k,y employer and work^sT
29. W hat do you recommend for preventing this type of accident? Do not say. "By being more careful." Specify what should or should not be done)
As t?ira tor3,,a.hauld-fac.,,,,H-Qg:n-- !---------------------- -------:-----
Agency Part Mech. Defect
Unsafe Act
NATURE OF INJURY AND PART OF BODY AFFECTED
(Describe in detail the nature of the injury and th e part of the body afiected.
For am ple: am putationa U 3 6(3 SOVGl*
30. of right hidex finger a t second joint, fracture of riba, lead poisoning, dermatitis of left hand, etc.) --------- O
soreneas in lungs and short breathing,
31. N am . and address of p h y r i c i a m - ^ I S O G ^ ^ ^
Personal Defect
COUghll SZ
Nature of Injury
32. Name and address of hospital
....-- (Yes or w a o
......... ------.
33. Has employee returned to work? No) --
34. If yes, give
36. Did injury result in death? -N<yo")- or_So 37. If yes, give date-
38. In case of death, give name and address of nearest relative-
T1 --*l-lj"5^M- Atwhat *-
,, p e r hour,.
Location Extent of Injury
39. Names and addresses of witnessea-
40. Is injured related to Employer?-
CL, 73. Signed by-
C-4587 Rev. 7-53 printeo in u.s .a.
_Hol
If so how?_
-
Signature
Date of this report- _ll-3_-56-Official position-- District Manager
Filing of this report is not an admission of liability. " . . . No report of injury required to be filed by an employer or an insurer by this chapter shall be admissible as evidence in any adversary pro
ceeding before the Industrial Accident Commission." Labor Code, Section 6413.
Insurance Carrier Report Lag Coded by
8-
*.
V n f c ' i L - t L - i - - W * ' ' _* * V lL .a " , ',, J L - ; * .--.Im -V . j.i-'.-^ .J i- -:.' x u -* - r - V v- .'X3k- ._ * . 7/--
* J k ^ L S M^ f * < hC ^ 3