Document Vpx3za8v7V1mNBgVBxw3ZxVw

auritoiui )7 u- ? PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT xmrru 07 sum hld juuibt si, 1547 aj nniii exxs^jjjsjzi to nain axs dlscjss anas 07 a. aw. um zx. rn kiot 07 siAraaaocs mia row n?imn?j, aj urtramr av su naa? hi? ra simxc uxaifacr Pnmt tn I 1. J Laa A. V. Lm A. 2. Tithar A, 8* llmbul T, 2rm 0. V. lit* 7. M> JLni1rB< E* M* Cauhnoa J* 2- ZallUi J ?. Ysoinrd -- - Mr. Yoadxrd tsrrad at ehainan rf the itstl&c. ggnlat The nartinc m aallad to #rdar ahertly asftar 3 ?JU la A.X. Tither'i offioo. Is Lfcii had boon praparsd, the mooting prlgarlly haring called fsr ths purpoit of hearing a ft?n V Sr. 4. Jt Lean, af tha Metropolitan. I if* Imruci Company, notarising tie 7Tiat lUtu rf the u^crlanti rill iialmimt earth at tbi Ictus l*intor7. The chairman dispensed vith a rarlev sf the industrial hygiene problans at Lenpoo vhiah hed bsea ecvarad la a prerioau msetixg, and Lrrltad Sr. Laaxt to girt a report of tha information vhiah ha had gathered oa hit rareat trip to tho Saranac Laboratory. Ensrt Vr I>r. lansa 00011900 Dr. Lania reported that daring his roots! visit at Saranac ha had had aeetoi to all tha stnoranda and aotat loft by tha lato Sr. Gardner, aad ha had talked vith practically Terybody thoro vho van eoaoaraod vith tha vtxfc. fortunatsly, Sr, Gardner had had a tbtj eaaabls aecrotar7t bat, unfortonatsly, oho had vtrfctd for his raly approximately one yaar hefora ha diad. Yhila her ova knevledg* of tha experiments did aat go hade hryoad that yaar, tha did hara at har flavor tipa everything that had hepptnad daring tha year and aha van also ahla to prorida iron tha flit* substantial information la eannoetion vith aarllar expsriaeats vith aahaataa. Xvidantly, Sr. Gardner had. planaad ta line a comprehensive artlol* n dahaataot lta affect os animals, ita afftot as homan haloes; at vail aa ralatad raaaareh prohltjrt, prediction problems, tha oaatrol of dnat la dlfforaat hinds tf industrial plants, sta. Ha had praotioally finishad tha part of hla rsport dealing vith tha affaot of ashostot dnjt on hamaa beings, and had. anno tat ed -tha root af it, miking ranch not os and consents. r. Luu vrota to Sr, lenneth Lynch at tha Medical School in Claris ton, S.C., vho had etn assoolatad vith tha lato Sr. Gardnar and hiastlf on a lot of tho aarly vorfc on aabsstoa casts, infornod of tha situation at ha had found it at S&ranao, and, as far aa being alls, to proTide 'smooth oepisa1 vat concerned, told hin it had boss arranged to hero thi lato Sr. Gardner's t to rotary make tha asceseary oopiss and fonrard than. (Incidentally, tha fmttoo* of t>ia *-'"***-" Exhibi Sr. Uih k< iafirmxl Sr. IjuJi that tin Mtirlil rtll k firruik. t* kla u >m u it it lx ehepx it that k rill Mt han tx try tx iaxiphxr tlx latx Set, Gardaer'i haadrrltijLC ad 1* hax reoiirid a reply t* tlx effect tint, after Sr, iyxah kj kal ax eppxrtaaity t uulu tk xaterlal, lx rill litmiu rktio it i piniUi k pit It t{itk7 lx ^Lkllahahlx firm. v 0 ,- Sr, Laitm jLm t lun n i trij to tlx Ynt t!ut tktl tk ftnt ef at ki krisk Sr* Ijxeh that k rill txm^i if pnilli ti kn tlx material wt t kla W- fxrx that tin, kit, tknli it axt Vx ready ikx, it nil lx tmaltlk tmriklut darlxc Sr, Lajula'i akeoaxx. Sr. Lena sail lx mii kxep lx toxah nth J-X tkit tklx, ami aIxx akcut rhat Sr. Lyach emltlxi lx m lx rlt1 thx Bxtxrlxl. lx itUk Ikl thxn vu fiiti a lit if axl trial at At lAAXt tk Vex Lo part--tint dulixc ritk tk iffut if ukrtn tut ox hau VxLacx--newt ti Vx fairly exsplrtx sal La Vallrrel it mil mJCx a utiifAatxry rrpxrt. Mr, T. Srewa ix^xirel ax ti rhxthar Sr. laxta tkxockt Sr. Lyiah roxld attempt tx predxci tbx extirx rvrt errxriic 'axhxitii1 rhlch Sr. Gardx*r had had Lx aiad, xr rixthxr kx mil oxxcertratx air cm tkx part dxalLif nth Hi iffMt si ixbistos 4a.it vx ki Wives; 1# rkiak Sr, Laxsa replied kx lid sat bur, ilxxx Sr, lyx&h roxld xxt dxxldx aVvxt it xxtil after kx had reoilnd tkx xxtn ~ kit kx rax hap in* that all si it eexld Vi jst ixto Mat xxrt if (kp. Vr. Srra rsfimd tx the tirts ritk axVeetoi rkiak Xr. Tihn.I, si tkx Xxtrepelftai lift Itianifli Ox., 2nd xvdxrted at tkx Klata laxa tiu a<*, amd notitk tkat Sr. I/ach lick aari tu if tkx ixfirmatioa xVtaixed from than tuti, lx wrnitia rllk tkx nrit rkiak kx lx about It uadxrtakx. Sr. laxsx &cnk tkat tklx licit kx ixaa. Mr. 7i*hax raaxrtcxd that tkx exapaay kxx a dxfixitx Jik t da Lx Caxada It iffiH tkx effect* if a lvt si prrpacaxdixi&c that kxx t hi da ax lx rxlaiiax tx tkx harmful affix ti si axkxstii-dxxt, axd kx erprmed thx tplxiox thxt a report, if_prtpared >7 Sr, lyuah alovc tkx lixxi nil Lied, mid kx si amtirial kxlp tx tkx cxipvxy. Zxfarrive tx Sr. Lyuok'i itatxaeat to Sr. Lamia tkat kx roxld itx if tkx xatirial salt kla etxld Vx pat ixti 'pnkliakaklx1 firm, Xr. T. 3rorx ealled attestiva to a itipalatiix lx par mscaat ritk tkx Saraxac Laboratory rkiak presided tkat tkxrr mid kx xx jmblieatiax si tkx rarolti si axperiaxmta rithxut ver exxexst. lx axil, if it dxn ton out to kx thx i#rt of report vs voill Vx glad to. ^r* pukliahed, kx heped Sr, lyxch mid aot include aay okjeotioxail* material fm ear pxixi af rim, ax, far axaaplx, axy rilxtioa kitviaa a. 1 Vi 1 to* duet avi exxoxr, rook ai tkx rcfiraaoi rkiak Sr. Sarixar kal udi to th.ii la kis BOBxcrapk. Ex added, tkat rrxx though tkx report ooxtailed iobi matirixl that vain't toe faTorablx, froa oar pxiat si rlmr, vs rtill roall probably kx rilliac ti kart It publiahxd ktaxaix xf tkx Vxxefit tx kx cxixxd from tkx kalaaax si tkx rxpxrt. Sr. Lenta airarxd Xr. 3rm tkat thx latxmt si thx atataxxat la qoxxtlaa rax tkat exy report prepared ky Sr. Lymak roald firrt kx rakmittxd to J'okax-Xaarillx kxfirx kxixc pabliikxd xlirrkart. Xr. 7Isbmr oosacxtxd that kx woolda't vent to ixx aay report ex aibxitxa *0xx tkxasaxl pireeat perfxat*. Ex axatioaxd tkx xickt dust cant rkiak had kxa filed axminrt tkx oompaay at iabiitoi doriac tkx past tvo or tkrxi yeari/' ell of rkiak had ktex roam&rily tkrovx oat, aad ooxxeated apom thx fact that this qxiei aotiox ritk nrpxot t all xickt ;f thi 0141 * hd as adrerix siiiet vkxrx ccaraaity opixlox rax oo&eeraxd, ai tkx rx~ 00011997vatioa had kxxa a*ax tox cood* 'At. Voodard riaaricxd that thx aiatk out, kormr, had tumxd oat qait# dlffirixtly, lixcx it dxrxloped that tkx iadiTidaal IsTolTed rx reported to kar* kal laac eha&cn vnd pathological chaa^**, vhich Lad net k*m Exhibit /w Ox* panirted trouble lx oexaeollax rlti tto drartlrg rf r vlti oxlo 1x44. ilniomaeecax eocrtb vae tint It I7ptrtril7 p--f*x ttow an v- urul eoxcvptlbilitj V* janmli n4 34 pigx 41*4 lx Uu flxxt 4xtX xx4 t| t Jta^ul, 1WI, t7 trim ylgx tod 11x4 fm till m. !iin wre rlill earriTlx* 11 xtti 14 mtli exporcrt, 14 rlti 7 mjitw apn! ttiii t* to beyt u ltxf ax yruiltttli fc x rtid/ *f off wl i. Iftar 19 soxito tx^mn the rarlm eifarta rf tto calelxad Mrti X4 dxflxlta fibrrale lx tto lnxgn, tot ax -g-TM --t ftrii^x Wd/ raaotlxx vlti chronic Inflammation and xxliis that ebtalaad from the r*v. *> a^ufti xrt4 lx tlu lTijktiii ncirtil that x fltrttli rf tie a 111attU t/ys mil later apprar. *Xx /ixuit', 1M| tto hit snuMKtntliu v*r lurtairl vitint notable ehu(, fill vu iiu far it m ttoxght that tha dexerr if paauxaxia tu rrvr. Oax iasdred and fifteen (liua pita nr* 144*4. *IaJ ret lax exprriasxta ixto aaiatala, that lx, irtrxmeax, lxtrsTxrowiax, Intratracheal, as4 ixta tii torn, v*re all eoxplatrd a oar eeatldaraile tixa ag*. Xx general, ttoy iiu that tto raw ax4 aatml wrtl tox rtoX Ter, Surdur sail*4 a Tlax 4 Zatlx< n ill scale tilai (ti to atoct I prints (trrilxlta), 41a* oawplated vara tto Inhalation axpcrtxaxts vlti. v raar 9al It a, xxlxg rdaaa pif* ixjrrtrd alrr vlti a wild tjp# f txtornla.' Sr aarird vara atovm from till cspirlaot axi xr taxdeeaej ta lyriai rf dial *Irv *aderv*7 in axprrixnts using ealaixad earth vlti lxtratraetoal lxl ret lax 1* rainea plga xaixg STfla. 3jr tto s-r*7 refraction artto, till atom 24> errrtehallte. fids ru tto rerti ealeixrd vlti. r4a axi. Ixixlxtlox oxperixorta vrra earrird n vlti guinea pigs prrrlexs ta exposers ta txtorela infect lev, along vlti txiersle infection, aU . after exparure ta txborcle ixfaatiox, Sun asprrixeats rill oextixae far at lull rax sera peer; alxr Into! at lax orporincuts vlti J^-fle vitheut any all 4 infection. *7hx indications art r far that S^flt atlxalxtra txtorelr ixfectiaa.1 It vex felt that thx conclusion reached at tto cxd, tr tto rffrot that tto indication ere that Eyfle itlsrulatsa tubercle infection, vxx rather disturbing axd vax tto part of the report that night glT xa text enoarx. St, Inn vxa naked far itf opinion &a to hnv ueh tixa voull ha required tofart a 4xflxlta eraaluxloaa erxld ta reached about thi, and to atatrd that it probably wild tabs xxtU tto rad rf tto Tear; to thought tto tacfaaioi&a vto tox charge rf tto darting rf aatrail vculd tore tr 04x77 ox hia experixeuti far tto rrat of tto roar, cad, by tto tlxa to c*ti tim|k, tto pathologist vill tors bear able ta catch rp vlti ila lxtrrprrtatloxa rf tit elides. Hr addrd, that vhxx to gate took frrx ila trip tr tto Vast Coaat, airxt tto first of . Juar, ha vouli Ilia ta go bade tr Sarasu, ar aoem ax praalbla aftar that, te flxi out ^uat vhat pregrava has braa ra4x. . . .~ .'**"* \ ** . . -.** *. To ax Ixjqulrr fraa Kr, nuxbaxl ax to vtottor 'tto ladicatloxx art that`Irfla rtlxulataa tabarelo lofeotloa' vxx tto lata Sr, Gardner1 opinion, Sr, Txna ' rpllod. that it vaa not, bet that it vxx Xr, Dolatox'a ixproaalox, aa4 that to la oonaidertd a rarj experienced nan. Kr, Zlmbart lnquirrd farther vtottor ttorr vao anr rrldxnce that Sr, Gardner had reached aaf vxoh ccxclueloa hlxialf( axd Dr, Laoix. anxvired In tto nogatlTa, -( nnnj-tnn^ -6- Xr. Hinbut iIm rafarrad to a prarioue rquo*t hs bad sad*. that Dr. Luu ehscr, if ptititli, &t bmu u th* fculLag npcrliaati with a ua^li of ^ilrnntni rih whlah had esaa fro ths Carhart Isfractorlaa, which was fousd ta aostsda akr7-1t-atU.ita, sad which had pradacsd ths rawalta that had taflusacsd Dr. Ocrducr'i thiakiag. laarpoo iu ikippad utini powdara ta Carhart, Vat haa aarrcr ahippad fli-r*d calciasd aatarlal to thas. sad Laacasch a-a va had asrar im til particular aaarpla af aatarlal la which Sr* 5-trdasr flrat dstaetad ohryataVllits, Xr. Ilmtait fait It wj af iittrni ta iatinlu tka mo aad trl|ia af that aaapla. pro&ptsd his ixxpirr u ta vharthar Dr. Iiu had fod 07 niimoa ta It la Iks 1st 1 .Dr. Gardasr'* isto*. Dr. Lau rtatsd that vhila ha had sat Wu aVla ta all a a hack ra thia saspLa, ha thought it vsald aat Va difficult far 11711* ta aVta-ia tha daalrad laftrjfiatiaa. >y writ lag ta I armas, as they prahahly could provide it roa Iks raaard thsy hoop than af mkn ccrrrixg tha dlffarwat aasplaa uai ia uptrlmti. Mr, lrm axprvuad icuVt that Dr. Qardasr had carried am asy dusting axparisaat vlth that tnpla la ^uatlax. Tha 'Carhart* uxpls had circs. him tha clue tad, ix follarriar p that alia, ha had malyrad fan Lcorpoo fluxsd ealciaed aatarlal aad fousd a rlVrtaatlsl psresataga af chryataVillta la it. 3a kasv, vhsa. ha found aatarlal with thli pirintifi af ehryrtoVilita, that ha had a fhad actor*. hr. Haashast eoataadad. hcvrrar, that tha Carhart satarial--Va which a asa'a death had Von attrlVutsd, enld hart kaaa a product af ilffaraat prrpartlaa fro* Sjila, ar tha jurontift af ekryataVilita it eaatalaad sight hara tin grsatar thsa ia lyfla, aad far this roasaa ha Vallarsd It laportaat ta try to artaVllah tha mrea sad origin af ths Carhart aaxpla. a far as laarpa-o aatarlal was otwinoi. Xr. SmUrt thought it ahould Va artaVllahad vhslhar ar Bit tha physiological affact is esasad. Vy ths psrtiela iIm af ths dsst liha,lad, or Vy ths ehssleal aska-up af ths aaiariel. Sr. Isas* aVaarrad that tha ashaatoa predact pra-etscaa tha affaet asehaaieally. Tith aatartalj that ar* ahaslcally satire, hevrrar, ha aaid ths fixer thsy ara, ths m ra act It# tha7 ara. Eia lapraaslax was that ths tsehxlolax at Saraxas take* ths 3jrfls powder Ja.it aa hs rseaiTaa it frwx Loapoc (which ia ths regular eosaereial grads), aad that it has aasy particle eissa la it. Is prouiasd, hcvrrer, ta writs to Saraasc aad ic^aira vhsthar it was is ad Just as it was rseairad, ar whether any effort had baa aada to aaparsta it aad uae different parti cl# aisaa la ths dsstiag a-rporlaacti. Es ad dad, that hs Valirrad ths tachslaiaa would mt Italy drtarmlas what ths aTtraga piartiela aixaa wars. 3alief vas axpraxad, hcvrrar, that ths dataralaatlaA af ml facta would hjrra as offoct it chatglsg ths ladsatrial hyglass pro Vis* *t Lospac ar tha axsoriaiata Vaisg ssda at 5aracac. 3oth fita aad caaraa sat rial a ara ixrolrad is ths proVI as affootitg Lospos, aad it vas fait that aa furthar tias *sad Va lost ia eoaiag to a daeialo* as to what ml Va data to costrsl* ths dut aituatio* at that plait. giMlac Eofora la&rlng ths aaoti&g, Dr. Ism offarad hla aarrlsaa la asy capacity vhila os ths Vaat Coast darlag ths asst four ssatha. E* was iafanad of ths cespx&ay'a dsalra to a&gaga a eovpotcit Tost list ioa Xxglaotr at Lospae. 3s aaid hs would harp thia ia lad nd lot Xr. Xlioahast hacv if hs soar#a acroaa a* samicjit vhsa ha could racesa old- 00012000 YWm atiox ni uii af tW taxi which rill ImI with 'llllaaaii1, ui aa which *r. rf Lm ixralaa, 1j }rtmll7 upcM Lx vrltlmc, Jr, laa rtaiai tJet W kx Jr. /ibm rail ai Inkllm mli iiioua with Ilia, it La a lx(tln kli nmi r*^mart that n prrrlia far U* >mIc aj ntirlil M UxVmiwu itrti n bM t ha ivaai. Xr. Jma sauartai la fir. Lan tkal, iWli J* kn Mauiii ta talk with fir. hart 1a Lae ixtlia, h mLcht nil ta liieui dti him a mot rijart k ki s&h if a sax a rkri ha ValLrrei iiataussemi aarlh hal hmi the iffKl af rrtarilmc, ar ut aff, the pra<r*fa af trVeremlaaia La a aartaim imiiriiaal rlu, if W hai Wax sa ariLur7 aw, mli kri ilid at a nek earlier iiti thu ka ill. Xr. La* uli ha hrpai Dr. Lmi reel! riait Laopea iariac til riait ta tha Wet Caazt. .fibr. Laaxa aaaarad hla that ha sxpeetei ta; aai Xr. Jlthar nutitii that, vka ha Tlait* tha jlut, ha alt ira ai talk artr imixitrial aattara pmaMllx with Xr. Yextmoat, rathar thaa with a mp af fira ar aiz perple. Xr. Yeitmamt, ha uli, hai a Mn Lxliaata ui tharagh kmlii^i oi oiintuilii af tha whala prehlaa which ha eell hatter lxpart La a eaxTeraatiaa aloaa with Dr. Lou thaa ha eamli if a Larger grsnsf vra sallai la. Sr. Laaca uoi Xr. Ciukit ta irfirx Xr. Viitaut that ha prsWhlr rrxli riait Laapas uaatlaa iarixe tha lattar part af 7ahruai7. Xr. Yaaiari unrai fir. Laaxa that all thaaa praeaat fait ftlta ralLrrai ar*r tha aatas ha hi haca ahla ta ahtaia fro* Dr. Sariur'i filaa, u wall aa tha rapart ha hai aada m tha rzpariacata ia jrsfrtM at Saraaaa, far it maw laaud spparext that tha e a apery would (at practically all that it wculi hara (at hai Sr. Sardaer mat died, except, af couria, hia m expert iaterpratatiom of tha ar? aria rati. /.la Zsallt-aa 0001200.1