Document Vj8V5NKjLkB6g3Y7EB36B6Nmq

FILE NAME: New York State & NY Times (NY) DATE: 1973 Feb 2 DOC#: NY048 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: NYT Article - Court Bars Delay in Cleaning Up Air CByOEU. WR.TKBENAWROSRDTEHLYASpYedIaNltoCTLheENAeNwIYNoGrkTUimPeAs IR NPgew1York Times (1857-Currentfile); Feb 2,1973; ProQuest Historical Newspapers TheNew York Tiroes (1851 *2002) Finds Ruckelshaus Erred in ) Giving 1 7 States a 2-Year / Extension of Deadline \ By E. W. KENWORTHY Sptdtl to Thi Ker YorkTtoei UnWitAedSHSItNatGesTOCNo,urFt eobf. A1p--pTeahlse J, fCoirrcuthite hDasistroircdteroefd CtohleumEbni*a j: vtoirorensmcienndtailtsPdroetceicstiioonnaAllogwenincyg j| t1w7ostaatdedsi,tiionncalludyinegarNs etwo Ycoomrke, < itnioton lciommitpsl.iance with air pollu*, In an order issued late yes-21 ltiearmdayD,.thReuccokuelrsthsaauisd, tahdamt Winiils--j, t"riantothreofbethset oafgefnacityh,"hiandgarcantet-d], ing the extensions. Neverthe- ] vleisosl,attehde ctohuert s"asitdritchtatrehqeuhiraed ments of the Clean Air Act of- 1j f1e9r7e0d" wanitdh h"tahde tCheornegbryessiinotnear-l g, pbuyrpMosaey o3f1a,tta19in7i5n,gsculbejaenctaitr"o ,, cfienretadinsta"tulitmorityedextaenndsiownse.l"l-de RuTchkeelshcaousurtto idnifroercmtedtheM1r7. hstiamtesbtyhaAt tphriely m15u, st19su7b3,mictotro wreictthedthpelarnesqutioremcoemntpslyoffutlhlye Cmlaerayn AstiarnAdacrtdfsorbmy eethtieng1p9r7i5 tyaeragrestladteart.e, rather than two Such plans, the court said, Continued on Page 34, Column 1 Reproduced with perm ission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited withoutperm ission. Court B_ ars Dela y in Cleaning U*. p Air. I Continued From must include Page 1, Col. 1 proposals for elsOhanuMs, a'yin31a,nn1o9u72n,ciMngr. wBuhcickh: sutnaateccpeplatnabs lew,'esraeidactcheapttahbelehaodr Jtui. 22. The court the plaintiffs. The court direct agreed ed tha t with Mr. S tqruainrsepdobrtyattihoen lacwon.tMrorls.,Raucsicreel** natedtwthoe-yreeqarueesxt toefn1si7osntafteosr Ruckelhaus' p ro v e the approve amended or dis plans by tshheautsimheadfoerxtmenedeetidngnotht eonaliyr fcoormpelxiatenncsei.onTshebecstaautsees oafskiend JMuanne w15il.l,Infoat,ninamthenedeaddmsitnaitse tqiumaelitfyorstasnudbamridtstinbgutplaalsnos transportation controls to tfhoer re maboinliotyxitdoemaenedt limphitostoocnhcehmrbicoanl oxidents. tmraatroyr'sstajunddgarmdesnbt,yaMchaiyev, e19p7r5i, then the administrator must S sdouuAcreccceposo,rldliunttgahnets. toenviroinnfmoremnteadl faorreTnhiaeA,sltCaabotaelmosr,aab,deos,AidIreniszdoNianenawa, ,YKCoaarlnki, ruegp.ar1e5.a plan for the state by Farther, the court ordered natogoettnhsceeyeSkuwptirolelmaapelpmCeoaolsutrthtceerrtuailninlyg Mssaeysin,,nOMeshoaiotra,y,PlaMennidns,ss.yoMluvraais,nsiaNac,ehwTuseexJteatsrs,, tltiahnienymasdetmanttienoiasfntraaetoxptrreinnmsoiatornytoosgntarnaadntt 19I7n0anacott,hear caFseedienrvalolvDinigstrthicet UextMtaehnr.saRinoundcskWfeoalsrshhcaainurgsbtosonanid.mtohnaotxtihdee acWordamnptwlioiatfnhcoteeucthisodleotigemyrmpooisnrsiinbagllteetrhnfoaatr ChaouusrtyheesrteeordrdaeyretdoMprr.oRmuueklgealst*e within 60 days emission stand abnecdauosxeidtahnetys hwaedrebedeinregctrlayntreed lated to the need for transpor- tSitvaendamrde.ans Finally, the of meeting court ordered the the aastnraddnscmefoserr--ctuhraryse.beeUshtnaodzsea, rrdbotehuresyllsliauuwbm, c o n f i d ef an c1,?es ^ nChfln?nnmhtiM aagllensctaytetso provide fo troeviienwsurtehethpalat ntsheoyf r maintenance of the Mtloars.tisJRsuuunecekte7hl.sehOsaenusfDinewacal.s4s,traetnhqdeuaiErredndsatrnad?n-siitnscyresatesmeds, use of . mass SIftatnhdeayrdasreafftoeur nMd adyef3i1ci,en1t97a5s. to maintenance, revised plans vsuiriotntmo ecnotmalpDelecfeopmspelFiaunncde wfiliethd the law. Reasons for Extensions m19u7s3t. be submitted by April 15, Mr. Ruckelshaus said that the w31e,Uren19dre7eq2r,utithrheeedirt1o9p7lsa0unbsmacfitot,rbymJeaent. eccxaoutnestnreostilohonesf"wastueatrtoee eowmfaitrshrsaeinoatnersdt"wboaens ivanimrgobnbiemyneMtnstataayln, da1ga9er7dn5sc,ytthhsaeettptfrhoimer aesrniyx ntehnoeotussguthafftidecsaietanhtlaoydr deenxvopetelroiopebnedctaei'annoeddn pm(sooolonutot)ax,nidstseu--,lphhpyuadrrrtoioccxauirldbaeotesn,s,cmanaribttrtoeonr tscrtoaannntsdrpoaolrsdr.tsattihoant cdoenpteronlds oton msue<ceht goexAnid aonxtisde(ssmaongd). primary am photochemical bient standard haFu in osrsathidis, hroeaasdovni,sMedr.thReusctkaetless August, 1971, that they ilaismeoonuhenedtaeoltsfhigpnoebldlyuttoanliptmriointtienthcgtepstuuhbre cudoneuatilllidnFgdeebf.ew1r5if,trho1m973tJr,aatnnh.sap3to1pr,o1tar9tt7iioo2nn, mroiTunnhisdetirnalgatowarirt.opegrmraintttead twthoe-yaedar ceoxAntetrnwosliesoe.nkoanftceormthpeliaanncneofuonrce17d eGxotveenrsnioonr'sif rehqeufeosut,ndt,huapt onone Dsteafteens,sethCeoNunactiiolnafilleRdesaourscueist ounrambloeretoecmoimsspiolynwsoituhrcthese wsteartee hcoanutsenhdaidngvitohlaattedMtrh. eRluacwkeblsy pnolalnogbyecwauasse nthoet caovnatirloalbletecohr wgriatnhtoiuntg tahne tawdoe-qyueaatreexshteonwsiinogn] "dualctienrgnatthivee"polmluettahnotds,s suocfh raes tbhlea,t acnodmpblyiaenxcteenwdainsgntohtefetiamst-e1i wtraefrfeicncootndtreovlesloopredm.ass transit, fpolarns.uTbhmeitctiansge awatrsanasrpguoertdatliaosnt;' Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.