Document VJVjkd0GE9Kq689wgkYyMxRej

Polyvinyl Chloride Pneumoconiosis: Epidemiological Study of Exposed Workers Giuseppe Mastrangelo, M.O.; Maurizio Manno, M.D.; Guido Marcer, M.D.; Giovanni Battista Bartolucci, M.D.; Carla Gemignani, M.D.; Giulia Saladino, M.D.; Lorenzo Simonato, M.D.; and Bruno Saia, M.D. Among 1216 workers who were employed in a polyvinyl chloride production factory and who had had no previous dust exposure elsewhere,, 20 cases of pneumoconiosis were found. Chest x-ray abnormalities were characterized by limited profusion, irregular type and low gravity. All 20 workers had been exposed to high PVC dust levels. The chest x-ray changes were observed after a minimum ex posure of five years and, in a small percentage of cases, were associated with slight restrictive respiratory function impairments. Moreover, in the whole group of workers 388 cases f31.9%) were found with non-specific x-ray abnor malities mainly related to age and smoking. Polyvinyl chloride (PVC) dust is particularly relevant to a consideration of the anatomical, clinical and radiological signs of pneumoconiosis found in workers ex posed to `'inert" dusts because of the high annual produc tion of PVC and the number of exposed workers Within the framework of a national survey on vinyl chloride hazards to humans, coordinated by the Chemical Workers Unions, the authors examined the working population of plants producing PVC in Porto Marghera. Italy One group of workers was exposed to PVC dust; another group worked in departments polluted only by vinyl chloride monomer (VCM) The characteristics and prevalence of pulmonary radiological abnormalities found are reported and their pathogenic mechanism is discussed in this article. Methods and Population Environmental dust samples were collected and both concentration in air and particle size were measured In From (he Institute o Industrial Medicine. Untvettity ofFadow*, Padoua, Italy 540 the drying, sacking and blending departments. PVC dust concentrations were higher than the TLV {10 mg/m1 of total dust) in about 60% of the samples. In the polymerization departments, no concentration higher than the TLV was found In the samples taken, particles with diameters of 1 pm to 5 pm constituted 4.5% to 309% of total dust weight. All the workers answered the European Coal and Steel Community fECSC) questionnaire for chronic bronchitis and emphysema,1 and were submitted to chest x-ray lac-' cording to ILO standards) and spirographic examination (Codart-Expirograph. Bilthoven, Holland) Chest x-ray films were read by two independent physicians utilizing the ILO/UC Pneumoconiosis Classification. 1971.2 For statistical analysis, a consensus reading was used. For each worker examined, present and past working histories were carefully recorded and particular consideration was given to previous dust exposure. Of the total. 1,216 sub jects had had no past exposure to organic or inorganic dusts; 731 had been exposed to PVC dust (employed in drying, sacking and blending of polymer); and 485 had been exposed to monomer atone. Results Table 1 shows the mean and standard deviation of age and of length of exposure, the number of subjects and the percentage of smokers in the two groups; those exposed to PVC dust and those not exposed There are no signifi cant differences in age and smoking habits, but the dura tion of exposure is higher in the workers not exposed to ' dust In 20 sublets (16%), we diagnosed a typical pneumoconiosis. ie., chest x-ray changes (irregular opacities or frankly micronodular images) of at least class 1 profusion, according to the ILO/UC classification. The RSV 0016968 Table 1. -- Age. Exposure, Number ol Subjects and Percentage ol Smokers in PVC Oust Exposed and Non-Exposed Groups. PVC dust exposed group PVC dust non-exposed group Age (Years) Mean S.D. 37.7 35 7 6.8 8.5 Exposure (Years) Mean S.0. 6 1 4.0 8.6 4.5 No. of Subjects 731 485 % of Smokers 73 9 68 7 mean age of this group was 449 ( 5.2) years and the mean length of exposure was 11.6 ( 5.4) years; 16 sub jects (80%) were either smokers or ex-smokers Table 2 summarizes the distribution of cases in relation to age and length of exposure. In all age groups there is an increase of disease prevalence associated with increasing length of exposure. In the case of x-ray changes. 16 sub jects had class 1/0 profusion, two cases, class 1/1; one case, class 2/1, and one case, class 2/2. In spite of age and the considerable exposure, the majority of cases observed were in a low profusion category, thus indicating a slow 'Jevolufron of the disease. The changes were characterized - by irregular opacities: ten cases were type "s"; three cases* type "t"; six cases, type "p"; and one case, type "r" P^fhe opacities were diffused, mainly over median lobe areas Two subjects showed slight restrictive spirographic impairment All had had jobs which involved high air borne dust levels (mostly drying and sacking) for at least five years. None of the 20 subjects was in a group unex posed to dust None of them had experienced previous occupational exposure to organic or inorganic dusts We considered the above alterations to be PVC pneumo coniosis In 388 subjects (31.9%) we found slight chest x-ray alterations consisting of linear or irregular vanishing opacities, or both, classified as class 0/1 profusion; the re maining 808 subjects were class 0/0. Table 3 reports the total population distribution, ex cluding 20 subjects with PVC pneumoconiosis. Results are presented in a two-way table -- each entry reports the number of observations Samples are classified according to age (three classes) and polyvinyl chloride dust ex posure: "PVC +" represents presence and "PVC -- absence. In the table, "x-ray + " indicates the classes with class 0/1 profusion To assess the influence of both risk in dicators we performed a two-way analysis of variance for proportions (Snedecor and Cochran).* The column mean is adjusted for row effects and vice versa. We also tested whether row and column effects were additive or whether interaction was present. The results (Table 4) show that both age and exposure were significant factors influenc ing x-ray abnormalities -- since the interaction is not significant, the effects are simply additive. The square of a multiple-partial association coefficient for qualitative data was calculated to measure the degree of association between the dependent variable (x-ray changes) and each of the two predictor variables (age and exposure)* Age and exposure are alternately held cons tant. Age is a most important factor. When exposure is held constant, 33 2% of the x-ray changes are shown to depend upon age; when age is held constant, 6.5% are shown to depend upon exposure. Table 5 summarizes the distribution of cases (same subjects as Table 3) according to smoking habits in workers exposed and not exposed to PVC dust In Table 6. the two-way analysis of variance for proportions shows that both risk indicators have a significant influence on chest abnormalities. There is no interaction of factors Habitual smoking plays a major role and, when exposure is held constant, is shown to be responsible for 17.1 % of the changes. When smoking habits are held constant, exposure to PVC dust is shown to be responsible for 8.9% of the x-ray abnor malities Discussion X-ray changes of at least class 1 profusion, found in 20 subjects, are considered PVC-mduced pneumoconiosis. This claim is based on the following: (1) Reading of the chest films was performed by two independent physi cians. who were not informed of the age, job. length of ex posure or clinical history of workers A consensus reading was required for the pneumoconiosis diagnosis. (2) Special attention was given to the absence of any previous occupational exposure to organic or inorganic dusts. (3) The changes were found in workers who had ex perienced prolonged exposure in departments with demonstrated PVC dust pollution. The length of exposure was about 12 years on the average and never less than five. No radiographic signs of pneumoconiosis were found in subjects working in departments free of PVC dust, although the average period of exposure was longer Table 2. -- Distribution of PVC Pneumoconiosis in Age and Exposure Classes (The percentage on the group of seme age and exposure is shown in parentheses). PVC Oust Exposure (Years) <5 5-10 >10 < 30 -- - Age (Yean) 31-40_______ 41-50________>50 -- 2'(2 4) 2(3.8) 5(8.3) 8(9 0) 1(5.9) 2(9 5) Journal of Occupational Medicine/Vol. 21, No. 8/August 1979 Table 3. -- Distribution of Cases with Class 0/1 and 0/0 Profusion According to Age and PVC Oust Exposure. PVC + X-ray X-ray PVC X-ray + X-ray < 30 20 133 17 119 Age (Years) 31-40 41-50 78 123 197 108 45 55 158 67 >50 35 17 15 9 541 RSV 0016969 Table 4. -- Two-Way Analysis Al Variance lor Proportions (Same cases as in Table 3). Source of Variation Age PVC oust exposure interaction Error Oegrees of Freed an 3 l 3 1168 Sum at Squares 30.9713 0 7843 0 9682 227 9403 Mean Squares 10 3238 0.7843 0.3294 0 1919 F 53 81 * 4.09T 1.72 'p <0.01 tp < 0 05 pneumoconiosis (731 subjects) the prevalence rose to Table 5. -- Distribution of Cases with Class 0/1 and 0/0 Profusion According to Smoking and PVC Oust Exposure. 2.7%. Waxweiler et al1 reported pulmonary fibrotic changes associated with respiratory function impairments in % subjects exposed to PVC dust Lilis et al' studied the Nonsmokers Smokers chest x-ray films and changes in respiratory function of PVC + groups of PVC production workers who had experienced x-ray + x-ray PVC - X-ray + rzrx-ray. 40 215 147 308 25 107 12Z..T7- ----------??fv exposure of different degree and length. They found a 4.3% to 22.7% prevalence of chest x-ray changes (small, linear, reticular and/or rounded opacities) and sptro- graphi.c_impairme_ntsj-elated_to the duration.pi exposure^ and'to tFTe'"presence '"of dhesf *-ray Chang5?!`Af the'se" tn these workers (Table 1) . . authors did not employ either the ILO/UC International Previous'experimeritai data on animals and reports of - - C1assifnratJor*-or any other, no comparLso^concemiog-tbe-; human lung biopsy indicated the possibility that the im reported prevalence can be made with the present data. pairments described above can be attributed to PVC dust Apart from 20 cases of pneumoconiosis, mild non inhalation In 1970, Szende et al' reported a case of specific alterations (profusion of Ofl class) were found pneumoconiosis in a worker exposed to PVC dust. Chest both in the group exposed to PVC dust and in the group x-ray films showed small patches which became denser exposed to VCM alone. Such changes are related mainly toward the hilum. Biopsv revealed multiple granuloma to age and smoking habits, and the role of exposure Is tous centers consisting of foreign amorphous material sur minor rounded by granulation tissue composed of histiocytes, lymphocytes, plasma cells-, eosinophils and foreign body giant cells Such centers were associated with moderate diffuse fibrosis A histiocytic-macrophage reaction in alveolar septa, References 1 CommisMon of the European Communities: Notes on the 1967 ECSC Questionnaire for Studying Chronic Bronchitis and Pulmonary Emphysema. 1972, A Minette. D Bnlle, R van der Lende. F. Sanna- observed by Frongia et alfc in guinea pigs exposed to PVC dust in a sacking department, developed into lesions with multiple granulomatous centers with giant cells during the course of exposure Rats exposed to a similar working Randaccio. and U Srmdt (Eds.) Industrial Hygiene and Medicine Texts No 14. Office tor Official Publications of the European Com munities, Luxembourg, 1973 2 Jacobson C and Lamhart WS ILO/UC 1971 International classification of radiographs of the pneumoconioses Med Radiog' environment developed marked thickening of in Phofogr 4867. 1972 teralveolar septa with an evolution similar to that in the guinea pigs Such experimental and pathologic data confirm the results of this epidemiological study Lung changes are j Snedecor GW and Cochran WC Statistical Methods. Sixth Edi tion Ames the Iowa State University Press, Eighth Printing. 1976. pp 472-901 4 Biaiock HM Social Statistics, Second Edition New York. McCraw-Hill Book Company. 1972. pp 4S8-459 directly related to PVC dust while VCM exposure alone fails to cause these changes. Therefore, unlike Lilis et al.7 we believe that pulmonary changes are not pathogenically similar to other vinyl chloride induced abnormalities 3 Szende B. lapis K. Nemes A. and Pinter A Pneumoconiosis caused by the inhalation or polyvinyl rhiortde dust Med Lav 61 4 j J-436. 1970 fa Frongia N. Spinazrola A. and Bucarelh A Lestoni poimonan spenmentali da inalazione prolungata dt polveri di PVC in ambiente di (fibrosis of the liver, scleroderma-like skin changes, lavoro Med Lav 65 321-J42. 1974 peripheral vascular damage) In the present study there was only a 1.6% prevalence of pneumoconiosis in a total population of 1,216 subjects. Nevertheless, in workers exposed to effective risk of 7 Llis R, Anderson H. Miller A. and Selikotf IJ Pulmonary changes among vinyl chloride polymerization workers Chest 69 299*303,1976 8 Waxweiler R|. Stringer W. Falk H. et al NIOSH. Neoplastic risk among vinyl chloride polymerization workers, 1-16 Ann NV Acad Sci 271 40-48. 1976 Table 6. -- Two-Way Analysis of Variance for Proportions (Same cases as in Table 5). Source of Variation Smoking PVC Oust exposure tnteraciion Error , Degrees ot Freedom 1 1 1 1192 Sum of Squares 7.8850 1 7847 0 1023 251 9125 Mean Squares 7 8850 1 7847 0.1023 0.2113 F 37.31* 8 44* <1 *0 < 0.01 542 Polyvinyl Chloride Pneumocomosis/Mastranaelo et al RSV 0016970