Document VJ4DeQBmaZE1aN1gwwqZVjgop
S0f4 Iff* ADO HK/U.TH
mmm.'t ioa,m
NOV 1979 [bacoiS)
pars
e live in a society that is much
Wmore pollution-conscious than previous fenerations have been. As
a result, many people have raised
questions about what effects pollu
tants have on the human body.
Among the pollutants that have
caused concern are polychlorinated NphenyK (PCB's).
by Caroline Haglund
PCB's have been used in a wide
range of products, including electri
cal transformers, capacitors, car
bonless copy paper, and fluorescent
lights. They have also been used in
paint, varnish, plastics, food wrap
pings. adhesives, microwave ovens,
television sets, air conditioners,
ceiling caulk, ftre-resistant fabrics, tal spills. Although copy paper
electric wire insulation, hydraulic containing PCB's is no longer made,
fluids and lubricants, wood pre it turns up in paper used for recy
servatives. and other items.
cling at paper mills, and the PCB's
Polychlorinated biphenyls have are discharged in the effluent.
been contaminating our soil, water, Only in the past ten years have we
and air since 1930. but their greatest begun to realize the danger nf
contamination comes from the air. polychlorinated biphenyls in our
When products containing these lakes, streams, and rivers--particu
chemicals are disposed of in larly in the Hudson and Mississippi
junkyards, landfills, or incinerators, rivers and in the Great Lakes.
PCB's become airborne as dry par Among foods containing residues of
ticles or vapors and settle on water PCB's. fish have the highest amount
and land, thus entering the food (with residues also found in milk,
chain. Scientists also believe that poultry, eggs, and beef). High con
PCB's can be assimilated directly centrations were found in the fat of
from the air. pasting through the large salmon and lake trout from
lungs and into the bloodstream.
Lake Michigan. In April. 1978, the
PCB's enter waterways and run State Department of Natural Re
offs from landfills, sewage, dis sources discovered uncommonly
charges from industry, and acciden- large amounts (10.000 parts per mil
Cwiitinc Haglund is a free-lance writer who lives in Green Bay. Wisconsin. She and her husband. Bob, have five chil dren. ranginii in age from 11 to 2.9.
lion) in Wisconsin's Sheboygan. Onion, and Mullet rivers--the result
of leakage of industrial wastes from a dump site.
The heat-resistant and long-lasting qualities that make PCB's particu larly suited to industry also ensure that they will remain in the environ ment for a long time. They do not break down except at extremely high temperatures (higher than l.000*C.). A bacterium has been discovered that will slowly decompose the
chemicals, but it is most useful with fresh emissions at disposal plants.
Small amounts of polychlorin ated biphenyls pose no threat to adults, but deposits stored in women's tissues may subtly affect unborn children and nursing infants, and may also lower disease resist ance. Research with monkeys at the University of Wisconsin indicates that this low exposure causes hy
peractivity and learning problems. At the University of Wisconsin's
Biotron and Regional Primate Re search Center in Madison. Dr. James R. Allen and Dr. Robert E. Bowman lead research to determine effects of low-level exposure to PCB's. Rhesus monkeys are used because they metabolize PCB's much the same as do humans.
Dr. Bowman is conducting a study in which the mothers are given only .3 to I part per million (ppm) of PCB's three times a week in feed-- approximately the amount a person might receive if he eats Lake Michi gan trout or salmon once a week. Tests show that although adults are
not significantly affected, infants are hyperactive and have learning difflcullies.
PCB's are more toxic than they
Moau c "UW5
008703
___LIFFfi*HFALIH
JOYCE MCCLINTOCK. UA Acuno Editor
LEO VAN DOLSON Ph 0 MPH SOdCial Edwon* Editor
ROLANO HEQSTAO WALTER E MACPMERSON MO j R SPANGLER CooiriOuimg Editors
BYRON STEELE Art OtfOCIQr
HOWARD BULLARD OMtQnor
ELLA M RYDZEWSKI EdMonti SACiwary
RlCHARO KAISER Bra** Editor
EDMUND M PETERSON Circulation Manogor
ROBERT SMITH AMociata Circulation Managar
MARTIN RUSS Marhating/Advariiaino
SAMUEL L OESHAY MD J WAYNE MCfARLANO. MO CARROL S SMALL. M 0 ALBERT S WHITING. MO MOOteai Conauttanta
ELMER KELLN. OOS oantat Haaim Conaultani
ALICE G MARSH. SeO . RO SO* OMtawc Aaaociation NwtHtion Conawttant
MARY ALICE WHITE. R 0 fdOO Conaultani
9W> Ymt of Publication Voluma 94. No. M.
MBVEMfair, 19T9
4 PCff*e--the hidden parti Caroline Haglund
Information on a pollutant that we should Da con* earned about.
7 On# short-term health sduoedon prepram that works! Robert Stotz, M.P.H., with Melinda Howes
10 Hypertension--the tricky ailment Blaine Fein
10 Dreeat-feedlng--boon to baby and mother Caroline Andrews Hetwick
16 Looking at tahota
Mary Alica White, R.D. Reading labels of ingredients on food cans and packages can be vary enlightening
20 Root-canal therapy William Cart. O O S. When the pulp in a tooth dies, does that mean the tooth must be pulled?
22 Our lonely children Ruth Jaeger Buntain Whan a chlkj is cur off--physically or emetionarty-- from his parents, ha suffers inestimable loneliness
20 Our Thankagtotng Day
Lucille J. Goodyear One woman's perseverance was largely responsible for the establishment of a national day of thanksgiv ing in the United States.
20 GMttng Junkies off Junk foods
Patricia Homing
A psychiatrist feels strongly that regulating their diet
can help drug addicts who are trying to overcome
their drug addiction.
HOMS 008704
LIFE HCALfH-MOVCMMA I9r* 3
were first thought to be. The Federal standard for levels of this pollutant until recently has been 5 parts of PCB's per million parts of fish and poultry and 2.5 ppm for milk and dairy products. "The present data,
both behavioral and pathological, indicate severe toxicity with a con
tinuous diet at 2.5 ppm of PCB's," says Or. Bowman. After receiving this amount daily in their food, adult monkeys develop chloracne (similar
to a bad case of acne) plus hair and weight loss. There is a high rate of abortions and stillbirths. Infants are smaller, and some are born with un developed thymus glands. Of eight adult female monkeys in the 2.5-ppm group, eight conceived, five infants
were carried to term, and three sur vived past weaning at four months. Only one live birth occurred in the 5-ppm group.
The Food and Drug Administra tion recently reduced permissible levels of PCB's permitted in fish, milk and daity products, poultry, and eggs sold across State lines, ef fective August 28, 1979. Levels for fish were lowered from 5 ppm to 2 ppm; for milk and dairy products, from 2.5 ppm to 1.5; for poultry, from 5 ppm to 3 ppm; and for eggs, from .5 ppm to .3 ppm.
The FDA asked the governors of eleven States (Connecticut. Illinois, Indiana, Massachusetts, Michigan. Minnesota, Nw Jersey, New York.
MONS 008705
Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin) to warn consumers, particularly pregnant and nursing women, to stop eating fish such as coho and Chinook salmon from the Great Lakes, and freshwater trout and catfish.
PCB's found hi mothers' nHt el monkeys
Because PCB's accumulate in fat. they build up in mothers' mHk. In fant monkeys that nursed, at first gained constantly for two months, then lost weight and showed signs of PCB poisoning. At four months the remaining three infants were placed on a synthetic-milk supplement. By eight months of age their eyelashes
UPE A HCALTM-NOVtMeCR l79 5
were thicker, swelling of the eyelids declined, and facial acne disap peared. These monkeys are more than two years old now, but remain, hyperactive. Younger siblings also exhibit definite toxic signs, even though the mothers were off the PCB diet for one year before breed
ing again and appear healthy. Although the number in these
studies is relatively small. Dr. Allen feels it is adequate because of strict environmental conditions main tained at the Biotron. Many other monkeys have been used in experi ments with varying PCB dosages. In all cases (excepting .5 to 1 ppm), similar signs and symptoms devel oped. A total of 50 tow-level PCB monkeys will be tested by the end of the current three-year project.
Common reactions of monkeys to PCB's ere loss of eyelashes, dry,
crusty skin, and excessive skin col oration. Short exposure at 2.5 and 5
ppm produces skin changes. Adult female monkeys are affected more than males because the females have a higher percentage of fat in which PCB's can collect. Menstrual cycles arc altered, with irregularity and ab normal and prolonged bleeding oc curring.
Metabolic studies on experimental animals show that PCB's may pro duce cancerous changes and pro mote existing tumors. Monkeys ab
sorb more than 90 percent of an oral PCB dosage, with the chemicals concentrating in the skin, adrenal glands, ovaries, liver, and brain. They cause severe stomach ulcers and cell abnormalities. Symptoms of nausea and loss of appetite in humans accidentally exposed to large amounts of PCB's suggest similar effects. Any cancerous com plications may not be apparent for 20 to 30 years after exposure.
The impact of PCB's on human health was magnified in I960 on the Island of Kyushu. More than 1.000 Japanese used rice oil contaminated with PCB's. Symptoms of poisoning ranged from nausea and abdominal pains to memory loss, bone and joint deformities, chronic bronchitis, asthma, and pneumonia. Abortions, stillbirths, and small infants oc-
6 (.#* * HCM.TM--NOVCMMR taT#
curred. Nine of thirteen infants were born with dark-brown skin.
Industry has long recognized the dangers of polychlorinated bi phenyls to workers. Inhalation causes lung irritation and severe headaches, plus chloracne. PCB's were known to be toxic to the liver as early as 1937. For the past seven years. Monsanto Industrial Chemi-
cai Company, sole United States producer of PCB's, has limited pro duction of these chemicals. A 1976 Federal law prevents manufacture as of January 1, 1979. Foreign com panies have exported PCB's without restrictions, but distribution and
processing in the United States was scheduled to end by July I, 1979. Products previously made with these chemicals are in wide use, however, and manufacturers with products (such as capacitors) in which PCB's are completely enclosed may dis tribute those they have on hand.
A 1975 Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) survey of nursing
women throughout the country found detectable levels of PCB's in breast milk. Levels ranged up to 12 ppm, with an average of 1.8. Milk of mothers living in New York. Michi gan. Wisconsin, Kansas, and Texas contained the highest levels. No in jurious effects have been reported, but a supplementary study is under way to determine whether these breast-fed infants suffer symptoms of PCB toxicity.
IIMisfits sf nursing ludwilgh dangers Should women nurse their babies?
Should they first have their milk tested? A test for more than a dozen chemicals, including PCB's. is now available at Raltech Scientific Serv ices, Inc., in Madison, Wisconsin, for $60. Refrigerated or frozen sam ples of a mother's milk may be sub mitted in specified containers by her physician or by herself.
"Pediatricians feel it is premature to suggest a discontinuation of nurs ing because of the presence of PCB's in milk," says Dr. Allen. "The benefits obtained were felt to outweigh by far the potential delete rious effects." But Dr. Allen em phasizes that pregnant woman and
nursing mothers should not cat fish, particularly from the Great Lakes.
Most levels of PCB's in fish exceed 5
ppm. As more information is ob
tained. this recommendation may he modified.
Dr. Bowman believes it is too
early to say whether PCB's contrib
ute to hyperactivity in children.
While some cases may result from
exposure to PCB's, many other
causes exist. All research to date has been with small amounts of com mercial PCB's. Monkeys have not
been tested with PCB residues ia
fish or other contaminated foods that may be either more or less toxic rhaa
commercial mixtures. A study is un
derway using residues from Great
Lakes' fish, but there are not yet any
monkey offspring from mothers fed
this diet.
While actual data are incomplete,
enough is known lo put a high prior
ity on PCB research. The possibility
that human infants are receiving ex
posure at levels producing symp
toms in monkeys makes it all the
more urgent that research continue
and (hat human exposure to PCB's
be minimized.
IP
BIBUOGKAFHY
ABC't a/ KB't. Public mtornmtm (**an. pMm W1S-30-7S-I29. UototMv of WHmm* torn OrmPronaa,naatSot Mpm at Urn VtUmmtfn
. A. Xwilli '*TO IPact, mi i Maaaiar> Mpom of PfTi 'i >sa Moafcayi," TtorireUey.fcJJI.Mai
i 0. N. Nortack. rkfiHWin l rv
loacat Bonaoata ot 1 ___ . _________ STphiuyt EapoaMw." fQfor priimai ejm N
*va-.a^al CsaS-a-r-e-oa--a a-s M- yIiwaUarinaii1v*t2)P, pISMnSv.rU v. ml /. a. Aka*.
i." Food Cumm. Tookof.. lemie). M
data* SipaiUar 22, IMS ------. M. P. Momm. mmO J a AMait
"Correlation ot PCI SoUy IwrSaa With *kavioreJ Toxicotoay in MooSayt." PXorem, Moehmm. IvAav . * (]>, IMS
Carauaa. L. A.. D. A. Swaotti. onS 1. B. AUaa.
i ia tha Iaflat I
greiaaui at tbs Syaawbm * 1
Eimraaumal Panama: Aaiau
_
--law, as nsaarere. or aia aaaaaat Nossaasa
Couaetl of (ha Natiaaal laaUay ot Salaaaai. bat*
in Surra. Coaooctktu. laao I-}. IffT lla areas.)
macaw. ``MycMoriireue aWunylt a Wa ianaaa maar." ChomltHj, *ot. 4*. No. *<May. IMS), a*
MONS 008706