Document VGng1Rw8a6OO4mpNwg1Nazjyo

PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT l FENWAL INC .Tb'IX 710 380 1072 - ASHLAND NASS %2>' . ATT: PHILLIP JENNINGS 10^19 RESULTS OF TEST PROGRAM AIR MILLED ATRIZINE 80 W EATCH'M 2089-128-I MAXIMUM EXPLOSION PRESSURE 123 PSIG MAXIMUM RATE OF PRESSURE RISE 2000 PSI/.SEC-. MINIMUM OXYGEN CONCENTRATION 18% MINIMUM IGNITION ENERGY 470 MILLIJOULES. DUST CLOUD IGNITION TEMPERATURE 1130 D/F- DUST LAYER IGNITION TEMPERATURE 750.D/F MINIMUM EXPLOSIVE CONCENTRATION 0.17 OUNCESyCUBIC FOOT IGNITION SENSITIVITY . 0 .04 - -WEAK ' . FXPL OS I ON SEVERITY 1.08 - STRONG '^pDEX. EKPLOSIBI.LITY 0.04 - WEAK AIR MILLED BLADEX 80 W HERBICIDE BATCH 2089-128-2 MAXIMUM EXPLOSION PRESSURE 142 PSIG MAXIMUM RATE OF PRESSURE RISE 2600 PSiy.SEC MINIMUM OXYGEN CONCENTRATION 20% MINIMUM IGNITION ENER6Y 396 MILLIJOULES DUST CLOUD -IGNITI ON TEMPERATURE, GREATER THAN 1600 IVF DUST LAYER IGNITION TEMPERATURE v 380 dyp MINIMUM EXPLOSIVE CONCENTRATION 1 0.17 OUNCESyFT S IGNITION SENSITIVITY. 0-04, WEAK EXPLOSION SEVERITY 1.61, STRONG INDEX OF EXPLOSIBILITY 0.06, WEAK JOHN P. COLL SHELLDEV MSTO FENWAL INC LAM 027539 ABS-009794 o cv --* CoO UOJ orr <oM U na/20 'N0I1VH1N33N00 3AISCTIdX3 WflWINIW LAM 027540 \ooa ABS-009795 - .X H cs 00 3 43 vO C rO co CM &m o o H mi o oo o -o r-4 H# mt 43 VO ec co h a o ooO o r-C c-' 1 AJ o cd o i H 1 M H1 CM 1 vO VO 1u Cl to o tO CU 1 m H o .1 vn .X 43 <r j*2 CM H o CM H 1 GO CO O 3 *3 o ca O CO | do <r o\ oo H 43 *O 43 r- *h M CM O H ON H <r o s OX ox ro . til EXPLOSIVITY OF BLADEX 80W HERBICIDE dAMMERMILLED- 43 O CT) CO u * cu o 03 AJ O a a) (0 H 4) rH JS o o Ua OJ u CU CO a. 3 O 'O a cc m M <0 * * a 43 o AJ 43 cd AJ H J 3 H AJ 3 CO AJ O CO Pa o Pa O O o CO CM CM H 1O OO H r* HH 4) AJ cd H 3 4J .X 03 03 O 43 PU, & 43 aj a Cd AJ tH Cd 3 U* AJ 43 CO T3 OO Pa X 43 AJ cd H a AJ X co ca O 43 Pa ^ 03 C o rl aj td Ui o CU o H H U -H <0 co l 'd CM M o c o 31 mh AJ 43 o Na -a to o u* 41 cu iH O JC a AJ 3 U CO to Pa c o c H (0 AJ c0 o u o X # <r VO o O o Ho o *H o NO vO vO CM VO o o O r-t o\ O <r CM 1 rH t0 1 GO A co 1 O r--( CM 1C CO CO 1 I o m CM CM | o O O o o O Jd *H cd .-i O CM Ul CM .X r--{ Cd to o < ON ON CM O o a AJ 43 <r ro o H H <r H o ?. H, CO O C <T rH A oo AJ 43 43 U-i > "N*. CO 00 CO to N H 43 C O k 03 CO CO 3 -H GO e cu . cu CU i-l AJ 4) C . GO > o c H <0 ca 3 43 d * m k > c2 rM AJ 3 H Pi U o AJ 43 43 4) t4 CO U CO CO - 43 d > PS i--t AJ td cd o * AJ U 3 -H tM > PS $4 *3 T"l CO AJ (0 Cd Cd AJ m 43 3 14 c 0) H >> Po O AJ *d 41 O 43 U 43 U 4) Va fM> >* 01 a P* 3 3 AJ 00 o o <0 CO H AJ -H Ui 43 X 43 o C cd <-4 ^a * u e o c CO CO CO >M cu 43 o o 41 43 C 43 e co Ui c 43 tA 0) U Pa Ui Pa 43 00 CO >N 01 AJ H 0) cH o JD 00 o S 43 X CU U 43 AJ c o C o H -r4 > c o H AJ g(0 * o g X w <2 cd cd T< AJ CO o H CO P H H iJ H C CJ 00 * *H M P. cw X X X*9 X X*9 to a > < 00 w CU UX4 CU X U3 c to lam 027541 AJ <Q 41 CU 41 U O AJ td 5 d 43 Pa *m 03 pH O id c o AJ CO 43 3 cr s p 41 > cd AJ id o * ABS-009796 IV EXPLOSIVITY OF TECHNICAL BLADEX HERBICIDE AND WETTABLE POWDERS is m ff 1 K SO rH u o <r rsi Q co o O 2H 1 H ed | CQ Pi to a. J X No o CO 43 4) n XJ XJ r\ xj CM (0 CO XJ ti-l cm d lui -----------^ Io z UH r--C N * 3 N o 4J H 03 o U-J u a) 3 co ^ T3 in in cn oH GO * GO 43 a> u o >% o r-< CJ e H cn pu CO H Vi to 3 oo s^ w H cn fH e o co rH c C0 oH o moo nVi XJ M m cl O CM O SO cd CO 3 C0 h on < CM X Z cm n Z CM * -K * cu 5H 1 <r CM X r*. <r O w 1 MT *H p <r cn 1 l l PU H prf X PQ CO 4) PU 4) No o O to O GO O o 4) 4) /--n XJ XJ O XJ n CM CO CO xJ UJ XJ CM c M-X 44 ^ CM o H ^ N "** 5S 4H 3 N O CO H 03 O XJ 4) 3 mm o 03 03 in u rH m r** CU 43 Vi o > o orH 43 c rH M H cn CL 00 CO 3 W fH C to o o o o o to rH rH o o oVi XJ Vi m CL r- O W V--y v_y m C7\ O O <T CM oH <C CM CO Z c0 Z CM 3 Q <0 z CM CM rH O O rH as rH %o- cn H Os H * CM O^ rH C3 o 4) Z to c rH o CM Vf XJ rH CO 4) XJ c0 cn Vi CM rH 4o) O frO-r^ o 43 d cO XJ XJ cd XJ O C a) *x 3 03 0) 4) Vi P- a& CO 4) Pu a o o c o fH xj 4J cO rH u D fH B .4U tO -H 40 XJ C 4J o M T<JJ rH rH -H XJ s CO M 4) 3 cn n 43 N n XJ n fUX XJ su xJ 4-1 MM oCL ONON NO cd > rH rH N-V rH 03 o XJ O O rH o o so rH O <n O so sO so 03 so 00 rH rH m CM 6 H o rH o m jst O <3 43 oZ so CM cn C3 43 o SO rH jd o CO 43 oz >s XJ 3L H > XJ X * XJ -H fH 43 CO Vi d y-N ^-S XJ lu a c 43 43 H XJ 40 rH 03 < rH fH ro 40 XJ u XJ 3d *o C3 o 40 XJ o o o 03 03 3 /*> cn to a 40 o H fH H y-v y~N Pu Pf ee v_y v-* y--\ <r\ -H 0) C 43 CO 43 > 43 CO c w >f XJ S fH Q 44 Od CO 4) fH 5 5ex -a 4J SC C Vi fH Ox 03 Vi 43 44 43 CL O O. X (0 H SM H Q v O 0 c0 rH N X (0 Q X <0 43 > dw a s-y O ** MHHo Pu cC P2 s IH M 2: yf v5-My n O z C o 43 H 3 XJ rH fH C 40 W C 40 o C fH 43 -H V) 3 XJ O fH rH 10 CL > X w fH 00 > c fH o fH 0) 3 XJ o rH d rH cd Pi a. > x w to cH XJ cd es o 43 X0J) 03 XJ o fH XJ a Vi XJ c 43 U d o o XJ cn 43 jd 40 fH J3 cn rl n XJ X4 N O CO O K lam 027542 ABS-009797 \ . GCOd W OCL. W < n H u 5 g < w Q M U M C. pi W Ed X Id .-J pq J -< o *-< z 5 w fc-< ft. o s M > M tn o w CM I< O o <y VO r~H CL g CO to H \o g 3 1 od -H to Xw oV cu 3k XX *H o o GO <M 3 r rH Ha cn B rH 3 I to VO o cn CO o H vo tCI I eC X to o Pa X rH rH rH o to 30 4J Oo 3 to t-1 o H * < ON <1) C 3 xj co c co o 0) /--* rH CO X u X--s n > 4J n 4-> U-l U U-l *-*. VM o iM H X r^. cx 01 N NO N 33 C0 4-1 O O CO tn 1 c CO m o < rH e <r in s o U-l rH H H o o v-'' o w 'w/' co H to CO H m X J0 c0 01 JO X X H 2 X* 3o tn o O o o CM r-- rN rH rH vO lilt B U <v cl X 4J (X o cn J-r sO *H < o\ 0) c 3a 4J fH CO CO c< POQ iwO -C 4-1 C 4J 04 4-1 14-4 ^ U-l N *". c- 0) NO N c3 3 cn cn uo a r-N. I < PQ 4J CO 3 o OO GO CO CO O a. to CD H rH U4 rH O^o w vcoj tH jda 3 a> O rH O rH CO CO cO *3 O O rH X X *-< X C4 rH rH *T H O cn CvOO rH Ov I rH O r-H ii cm a rH CO <u o^ ii mx <? co o o ii to ^ O CO <u o& Na ov vo m rH 5o X H w Csl H Q O ON Sx P3 pui CX3. . O CJ m o u M tn a) XJ a} rH rH rH H e u QJ g g cO SS to 4J 0) Om 0 cn to 0 P 4J H <CM X 0 X 41 u 4J CO Q O MJ rH O3 H cn V4 rH 0) X rH cn rH k4 H O 3 rH O O cx U CO -H rH E CO O cO CX B cd E-c X cn W X "s n /-n 4-1 n C4-1 4J UJ N O N O rH `v-/' H ^ cn m O 00 I CO rH CH *K -K I I I I I II II II av vo <r m S- H O X rH u Q rf ctf <r o cn XJ rH ^ XE *<-- \0 0 0 M W 0) 4J cd rH HX rH O -H JO 0) E V4 4J t Cd CO 01 a 44 rH g03 CO H cn 32 ^cn rH Xf 0) P0 J H 4J 0) cn B 5n cx rs rn rH u HI H O 3 > rH O Oa cn O O CX -H rH H 6 c0 0 cd CX E cO H X cn W X --x n y-% 4J #> 4J 4J H N ^O N 0m m0 w 0 w0 00 I mm N r> cs I I II ii ii lam 027543 ii C 0 H 4J CO rH V O.-H 6 iw cO -H cn 4J c *0 M 3. 4J GO U C c 0 CJ 4J H 4J GO O 4J rH 0) < 3c H n *H co to X nH c a -H u-i to *3 CJ O GO U< Pa GO 0 c U O U-i C O 0 CJ Ou O -H O. CJ H cx 4J > cx -0 tn H 4J H t_><% 0) >r- H n CJ -r >v 4J fH >v > 4J X H H 3 ^*x y--v 4-1 U 3 4J O O /X, O CJ CJ (u X H 3 3C > *H 3 0) cn 3 GO----O H H H 00 /--S /-S # c 3 tn 3 tn X U cn cn tn . u *3 xj c *H Pa cx cx 0.-"-N 0) 3 U-l c GO 0 GO > to *r-> >X O \ 0 3 C *H 3 C H 3 C U-l CO rH N *H 3 tn 3 -H tn 3 -H 0 X (0 X 3 ftjv/ju O V-/ 4-1 H ^ V-r \J?N^ H 4-1 0 r-4 <2 rH (0 4J 0 H 3 rH 3 u 3 * 6& C> CL > VC o.> VC M H H O 0 to X X Cj od Cd S H H S !T M 111 U1 e 0 H 4-> -rH C GO -H *H H O O 4C ABS-009798 e MC N O X <u CM en CO CO Cl 1 CXl 5 tHc O OV CO o CO a X u q X CO CM I pd tHc A< 3 .j Cl Q J o 2: 0) c 01 01 4J H cd cd X Cl c CO o O Mm rH 4CJ r-- J= CL 01 rH Cl eg oq 01 05 035 r-- Cd 4- l C 03 tH a V* O <S H C ao L* X ai co a co oc CL CO 0) tH PQ >v O X mm rH rH H a rH Cd 03 3 un .X 05 o CJ m Mid3 rd 35 *-h 01 35 cd 35 I1I II Cr* >3j. o 01 4J 03 rH 3 4J .x 05 cd O 01 Ai-S o 01 4J 01 CQ 4J rH cd 3M 4M 01 03 -O oa P- X a 41 4J cd rH 3U 05 cd o 0) 35 W'b - \ 4 * p3 2| W tH in H 01 Xw 1 H X r-i CO a. 0P) o en tH < H 01 co cd J o in PQ vO O CO cd m o jj O. .n rH H vO 0) o Ol 01 Cd erf S05 H t-0 o CO PL tLHi O X < VI CM' 1o 5 GQ o X CM .H VO* w r av CJ o rH -rf CO 1 oa 3 Cl PQ CM < rH * rH X pi H03 r-- cv cn S *H o h H m .X o ocd o5 a> jj tS V4 VO 0) *a o oX o\ m J0 O (0 . at o3 01 601 o J3 JJ r-- r-- oC0- 3 4J 1 c cd <H c PQ > o ^X 4H rH rH rH 03 Cd 3 o X 03 O CM o 0) Cd M* MD 55 X CM rH CM O VO o VoO r---I CV CJ rl o cn CO A O CM <r jd o veg o CO c o vO .X 4u-1 O cd 0) V3 O & rH 3 rH rH a tH d 03 3 rH 5| rH X en to rH O| < vO CM 01 rH td O a 0) o 0) 3 o A CJ C/3 G u 01 g 2 pcdj 4J cd c PQ o o MM rH o3 rH Cd -C 4M c r-- r-- CL Q 4O-1 4J * MM 4J 4-> - MM 4M N *"-- "-ON NO lam 027544 M > M cn o J O CO Oi PQ en <u rH en rH CJ 1 o X 1 w O VO O erf GO cd O in X PL U 0) 05 L4 O 1 c id <H C O CO GO o. 01 01 c a. CO PQ ?sjs o mm CO O wo 5 03 tH rH rH rH Ow CQ )M tH < 3 rH <d 3 CM CO Li S <d % m rH 01 35 cd 35 3 wo m un 0) O co m cm o CM rH M CO O vT N CO * ov cm ov -h <r <m m rH O rH vO in _y o at at os 40J) cd L4 r1---- *1o3 o ox en <r M O <d 01 o^ 01 35 m & W uca xw XQ - jj oj CO Jm c c 01 o 4-1 tH 4-1 CO o 4M JJ X w at 4J a o -s /t a 01 03 Ai Ai 4-1 tH 0) ij a at c >M rH O) -< 3 c 3 03 0) o o C at rH T3 43 tH cd CO O CO co^t --.> O tH tH tH v-i rs /-N /tn > JJ <r PQ 5^ r-- c-- o3u MM a 01 CL 3n tH M < Q PL en CO d Li 03 MM c 01 id 0) CL o tH o. tH na CL Pt en H K* 4J >% uH 01 -*H 0) Jm en en en U O LI c. Cm CL w CL V/ tX N-X *<--) <13 >\ 3 O Mm c o mm <d rH M X tH en o 03 c w 3 tH at CO > at c h 3 tH </J tn at c 3 -H O X X cd X id at --> ^4 u o > v-/ V at op 4M r< 4J O H 4J H H U fi t-f c 03 > <d cd -I a. > cd Cd H Pi D. > d pi MHha CO X X 03 C tH cd 4M c o CJ ABS-009799 p R H XQ 00 X *-< M X 2: H w W He E X P LO S IO N C H A R A C T E R IS T IC S OF P E S T IC ID A L DUSTS M ax O Vi X OV H P. > c as CM r-f O VO CM O O cn o *H t- o H VO Co fH <n CM >> oo V. rH C P ao > X -H l U an co C\l o VO ---- CM vo m mo H CM 1 cI o -rl >> *H Cl p p C rH *H 01 > c cn to M V p CO d Cl O 01 3 01 4 0) CD 03 -Sfc tu H p CC 01 S-I P< 0 VO co o CJ (7\ k <3- IA .o o OO IA O t-- CM 0\ rH O * o 0 m co CM CM' VO LTV O OO o O 0 m CM ^^ O m mCM. O O CO 0 0 IA 04 1 11 LTV ---- O CO rH O CM O M O oo oo O VO m r--1 <3 o o s <n to wm 4) cn rC o, rn as O +> S-i c COONO IA VO cn cm #-) rH t-- cm H ITS co CJ co rH O OO irv CJ rH O cn irv co 1A o H VO rH O CO O CM -- M rH IA 0J 01 01 O 01 irv rH rH rH H rH O O **--* P PP P P d dd d d C cC C C P H H p H irv co m irv O 0 rH O O- O V 2 U 2 n 2 C G 2 Ft t* CJ 0 01 01 01 01 01 0 m p pp p p Cl 01 01 01 01 0 0 XJ *3 *3 XI *0 c CC c c M hH hi M VH 'w' irv . CM 0 3O cc p0 E 0 . t-- rH rH CO rH vo r-l 01 N EH O a &0 p 0) Cl m p p U53 1 O c Cl 2: 0 rH CO c 0 hH 4 X T3 3 O H co O 0 -- 4- --1 a V c al P to P >. t M c-l aS *1 CO <nv rH O r-l rH x rH * * 'O O m pr t- t-- CM .VO * 0O CO irv -3 PT CO H irv O vo CM t--* O <n H rH CO m cn P M 2i--=i d c >< OV. X3 <d o o X o u #--I VO H rH I I I I I I OO rH GV rH LAM 027545 n n ++ irv -3 *H in m VO VO O vo 0 O 1 1 1 rH vo h rH * CM .A A O' ON rH O O O VO CM CM O O CO r-- CA cn CM rH O r- co O O * .pr CM PI O cn OJ O VO rl i-H rH rH rH SrHr> H rH rH rH .--. G b. So P C MOO O 00 CO CM PT d O via 3 r- CM _3 CN co H CM VO trv -3- rH CM CM H PT OA C--| ----- M -I ''--" O C hH C XJ O <1 7*^ r-l H & ,, CO cc P. M -- <30 1 PP S -I -a rC 0 3 3 fe in il j C rl H in 0 rH rH M ^ rH H 01 3 Q m o TC 4) a. E tn Ot oo oa Vi u n Cl o P- CU oV HJ -P e d Vi V V oo (O 05 Oo CO % ci Cl a 0) * P-| P c m as X 01 1 s' X oi TJ c MO o rH H rH O I l rH v HOA 01 o O rH rH P- as X > p^ O 01 c Ppv u o > OO o tn IA H CJ C 0) P c O I 1 CM p cn a; 3 o P v in. o A XI 3 07 P 0011 rdH ci 3 . 3 O xl rH CJ o O rH *H & a >d *C4J Ppp 0 r-< & Cl XL PU 01 P .u .p 0 iH -rH V> 01* co ^o P ~H > -N P -rH oo 3 Cl Pd h01. C -r4 P6 w c c pp cl >1 +> MP c CPl c rOC c en oo H rH P P-- V O P d u Ctn L--- a xi o po^4 >*-- cn cn explosivity properties of technical atrazine and ATRAZINE 80W Property Median Particle Size.yi Ignition Temp., F Layer ^ Cloud \ Hinimua 02 Cone., %V Ignition Energy, Millijoules Min. Expl. Cone.-., oz/ft3 P max (psig/conc., oz/ft3) Rnax (psi/sec/conc., oz/ft3) Explosion Severity Value Rating Ignition Sensitivity Value Rating Explosivity Index Value Rating T MOLR 1806-131-5 Tech. Atrazine 2.6 Melts below 335 1655 21 457 0.21 .92/0.6 800/0.6 0.32 Weak 0.023 Weak 0.0073 Weak MOLR 2089-128 Atrazine 80W 2.2 Melts below 335 1130 18 470 0.17 123/0.5 2000/0.6 1.08 Strong 0.04 Weak 0.04 Weak Lam 027546 ABS-009801