Document V3RxakkKe1wJywKMOp10Qnw4

7. cacreont dons Georjean L Adams ea ois 03/29/99 04:22 PM ConcaPosmay Corporate Product Responsibility an 290-O4-O1 TmTs Tel: 737-4795 Fax: 736-927B To: DavidA SonColrporeMgUSuGoMUCompSote To: cc: Sbjct Re:8Follupo-Fiwsh Subject: David A. Sonstegard/US-Corporate/3M/US@3M-Corporate Re: 8e Follow up - Fish "Wat santtothe Bacommiteson Fda 1:30pmandTo's ep: What I sent to the Be commitlee on Fdday 1:30pm and Tom's reply: 0033 116666331199 To DullBeconETTISIWSOSM-Corerse To: Dale L. Bacon/ET.ET&S/3M/US@3M-Coqx)rate Trims) PA arma sO Conor Thomas J. DiPasquale/I.A-Legal/3M/US@3M-Corporate a Cop S OMCoors Bill Weppner/LIS-Corporate/3M/US@ 3M-Corporete So PaameoE Copa 6 Copa John P. Pasinski/US-Corporate/3M/US@3M-Corporate JonBee CaromaMS OW Core John L. Butenhoff/US-Corporetei3M/US@3M-Corporete Prt ESCopa WISOWSopot Richard E. PurdyAJS-Corporale/3M/UB@3M-Corporate Longanda Copa US OWCope Jeffrey H. Mandel/US-Corporate/3M/US@3M-Corporete Sbjct: 80 Folp-oFawh Subject: 8e Follow up - Fish 03 166320 AATTTTOORRNNEEYY CCLLIIEENNTT PPRRIIVVIILLEEGGEEDD 03 166320 thas boonmorstan oh snc wa viewed Rs ypotnsi onfood chancoraminatn. Alar It has been more than 3 months since we reviewed Rich's hypothesis on food chain contamination. At that mawa acid horewisnha Gta 6SUPPOR & SUOMRESon.Wht Sans ofCanGnta time we decided there was insufficient data to support a submission. What is the status of obtaining data Lo thersupp ofeh oa nae report to either support or refute the need to report? ete Gm. amt om 38 2PM rrr Forwamled by Georjean L. Adams/US.Corporate/3MAJS on 03/29/99 04:12 PM 2. ~-~.... : .: !..,,,!, ~,, ams Dp Thomas J. DiPasquale aca 03/26/99 03:21 PM tent arntrr Office of General Counsel otcomentcrestisn arc cy sso doeardvy This communicat~n co(ltaJns confide~ial infonv,alJo~ intended only for Ihe addressee(s) named below and may a. contain information that is legally privileged. gS 0 Com Po S504 USA Building 220-12E-02, 3M Center, St. Paul, MN 55144 USA Tar Tel: (651) 733-1891 Toare Fax: (651) 736-94~9 To GeofeunlACdToSUpS oriea9MICoUoSrs To: Dil Bacon ETASOMCSapOoM CC: StickSBLerAcoohahoWonrgsoFB eeAoyaA prUrCSsioCCp CpnoaapapoonpminaaroU0IoSSnoOCo0MomCCCmSCoaoopormmomeoooreee Subject:. Georjean L Adams/US-Coqx)rate/3M/US @ 3M-Corporate Dale L Bacon/ET-ET&S/3M/USO3M-Corporate Bill Wepprmr/!.l~.,orporate/3M/US @ 3M-Corporate John P. Pas~nsld/U,S~rate/3M/U$@3M-Coq0orate John L Butenhoff/US-Colporater3M/US@ 3M-Coq)orete Richard E. Purdy/US-~rate/31WUS@3M.Coq)orate Jeffrey H. Mandel/US-Coq~orate/3M/US@ 3M-Corporate Re: 8e Follow up - Fish ~ Grea, In ot sre hei 8nea 0suppor rut th Pypcthsi wit anyparlerie Fam. Georjean. I'm not sure there is a need to support or refute the hypothesis within any particular time frame. roc Corocy,th work was ssh ot par of outlolpa 1ssssent ofevita ff I recall correctly, the work was itself not part of our formal plan for assessment of environmental Subject 0 Prtacive Orcer In Famerv. 3M. No. C2.04.630 Made Availableby 3M for Inspection and Copyingas Confidential Information: Made Available by 3M for Inspection and Copying as Confidential Information: Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309 11000033..00000011 03 166321 Ex1h0i0b3it commamevomn | 3MA01373218 3MA01373218 ceeaxxnppnooossuturreue.n.deTTrhhteearrkeeeaarerxeetmemansaninvyyeootethhfeerrtttnh0eerociroieesnscficrmirccuoulrlatritinnegglwaiwtiththihinnethihmenecscoaomcmphpanansnyayanabcbeoo.uuAt ppSaawtthhessdooiffseecxxuppsoossseuudrreeo,,abrbluuettrwwtoheis wuecwareenekngkuo, itaaduiccnnoodgmmdeporprtcareeukhhmeeeenennsxtsit.ievvTeenhseeiivxxseppwooeissflufuorbrreeetsnaaetssoesscdeeossenssdmfmbireoemntnthtopprfaolranen,fhu,wtwioelitthEhhPemtimAmeieainantadbebefaleocsrsh,,oimmnuitsioelteaswsnintoconepns.uesrs,Ap, sooosbwbjejeeescc.tdtiiifvvseecnsus,t,shs1eeet.cdj. uessdahhgdoomuuiekeldrintbthbeies o`ooffuhtrchogosusoieediwnwnhghoosdaoartcirheueemmmdnaenanaenst.gahTgiroihnnuiggsadtbwthheetielil neebincnevovinriorrpeoooennnrdmmaeeted,nentdbtaaoillnthteeoxxfopptorhosetshcuuerreeEporpPorAojejmeaccnttdhtphfeoePr uPporulrurraddnoyey,whhanyysphppsoiuotgrthhpneeeoesdssiaisesnsdpd.ereIsifsseoienrrrvvythiee,esasnjuvddggimeveennt consideration, then it should be incorporated into the comprehensive plan, assigned a pdodty, and given hTaonm eceresscursce aallorcatiyon. |don'see i asstandingaloneor separate fomthebroaderplan the necessary resource allocation. I don't see it as standing alone or separate from the broader plan. Tom Rich's respofonTsome: Rich's response to Tom: PhPlalaatnn!!PFTTOhSaithisisstktihhaleensgsatammmaeresitsnatealmlilainnmggtmteeacclhhnsniaiqqnuueedyyyooouuuhwhaaavnveebabenecetnhuesurisinngagnffoowrhthheeenlwlaasesttyyceeoaaurr.. hTTahveherheiaeissdracahhlisigghhtoppsrruoopbbpaaobbriiltittyy hatthhoeautidtPsskFkhaOaosSssrsniesoisekstziomlslsineeisgnndgtm.lmlooaenndggnnaeaggtomo..amYYmooauulwsweaernreed Given a an in 1963. Again you want another plan when given a plan in 1983. Again ntearhly 9e0s. Andyou we could have had data to in the eady 90s. And you support authorized no testing. AuApsspeI rrreemccaaalnlllawwgeeeomobebttnaaitinnteeeddaddmaadttiaastpthheaarttseceaadggteleetstsctcoeonantmtataihinntPPFFOOaSSeiindnttthhheericrpaplllacastsmimnalglsoastftAhApaprtrdi.l.aTtThahaeesnnpyyaooruutaoasfsphpaarirttopoflfaaannn. AoAunpnrdpdeettnrhhoemannnayynyooaduugatessamibacieedncwwtaeteuhesahaemaoddfd1tiosphppuaetutrttstoeaogdgceett.hthheeeBrtraetaaaemlpllaeatihnnasuutannidnndoietairarlbtthehaedteBrtoaBhstaestattcoreollolleeluecunutbmdinrobgeurrleoalnfla.et.hcAakAtsssdoaoaftnfadnoao$wsw0wapwraeeortyssoiotfillutlh.hheaaivvreepnlnacontt. gotten any data because of that tactic. Battelle is an albatross around our necks and so are you. PcrPeolureillmdimihnianavarreyydgdaoattteaininndhdiciacaatdteaeststahthaaatntdaamddouurtlteeeaagaglsletessshuhamavmveeeSr500twtiimemeewssoarasesmnmouutccshhtniunctkthhpeleiairrnppnlilaanssgmmwaaittthhhaaBannttithheooksese.eeDeaaoggriltestys.o. uWWee drcraeotaualleidzoeshwswaaeevenehihaiagavloveftetzoaeanopptleuhlaaanint.s.dkaYYataoosuusacencosdonsnimsntmiounaraunelatlllsalyy.sitiYggsnonuooumrresemlouoeurwrrpiofpluwlaarennpsswraoaengnrderdsensstotaait rtnstnutnueecnwwkppdlplaalannensnstirnthhgaaswt stisttlhhlooeweBawxsastttnhtteehenledtlceoc.oloiflDlelPecnoFctnitOi'gootSnny.ooouff pedpaotlvlauoteiaosnsaellannntdhudiaedoldaeafamonmarvtngiaoerguio.er r.rFeinsrokFtorgaar2sl2s00eiysyseesaammsrseotntfhhptfeseu. oddiYciavvhoiisuesiimosconinlochiwaatslsosbub.ereepernnosgsirtaeallsilisnnggintthhueencdocelorllsleetcactntiiodoninnogofftdhdaeataeanxnteeeenedtdeoefddPffoForrOS evaluating the environmental impact of fluorochemicals. PiFsPpFOrOoSSbaiibstlthyhweeomrmososest.t c|onnaeermrooouuussptpoaolgletlu.atanntt ince since PCBandyouwan! PCB and you wahl 1to avoid avoid calectingdat collecting data that that indicates tha indicates that tit is probably worse. I am outrage. `MMSauabddjeeecAAtvvtaaoiillPaarbbollteeebcbtyyiv33eMMOrffodorrerIInnIssnppPeeccattliioomnneaavrnn.dd3CCM,ooppyNyioin.nggCa2as.s0CC4o-on6nf3ifid0de9enntitiaall IInnffoorrmmaatitioonn:: Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309 11000033..00000022 03 166322 3MMA0A101337733221199