Document V3MJ1ZzajDow1VB1NL5e9NGe4

onsanto (NAME * LOCATION) W. B. Papageorge - General Offices FCftCMCC April 17, 1970 Earth Day -- The Question of PCB? : Regional Vice Presidents Plant Managers District Sales Managers U.S. Subsidiaries U.S. Plant Communicators j . V ; f APR 20 1970, As a result of recent publicity about polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) and the possible threat this chemical poses to the environment, we have prepared background information for your use on Earth Day, April 22. We have anticipated some questions you might be asked and provided some answers. ' Please do not present any Teach-In "visitors" with prepared handouts on PCB. You may use this information in verbal conversations should the occasion arise. Press queries on PCB may be answered with a copy of the attached news release.. Press queries for further information should be directed to E. V. John, Organic division public relations manager, in St. Louis. stw Attachment W. B. Papageorge' DSW 378668 STLCOPCB4099919 ANALYSIS of v.ariance Source Samples Labs Within Total Siam of Squares 3 6 7 4 6.4 0 ......... 11714.99 7068.22 55529-.61 DF Mean Square 4...... ...9186.60 ...... 7 1673.57 28 252.44 39 F Sig. 36.31.......... 99.9%+ 6.63 99.9% Estimated Std. Deviation := /252. 44 =15.9 (within labs and samples) Estimated Error Including Sample s = 37.0 Laboratory A veraqe A 113.6% B 7 6.5% C 108.3% D 60.6% E 6 S. 6% F 83.2% G' H Anniston 82.0% _ /3.6o 11.6% WGK Sauric A'-oraao (I-I arrf A,nn iston tot Use .-q \ 2S 79.4% 3S 84 .6% 4C 54.1% 5C 65.3% 6C 136.1% Overall Ave. = 83.9% (w/o H and . Anniston) 78.5%' DSW 378669 STLCOPCB4099920 - \. ' / QUESTION AND ANSWER SHEET ON............... POLYCHLORINATED BIPHENYL - . This question and answer sheet, for verbal use only by Monsanto personnel, is accompanied by our recent news release replying to charges that PCB threatens the environment. . 1. How was PCB first identified in the environment? Late in Feb., 1969, the San Francisco Chronicle carried a major feature story about "a menacing new pollutant" found in the San Francisco Bay area. The article was based on research done by Dr. Robert Risebrough of the University of California. In his search for residues of pesticides (DDT and DDE) he encountered "interfering substances." A few years prior to Dr. Risebrough's work, two Swedish scientists at Stockholm University's Institution of Analytical Chemistry reported they, too, had encountered . - .. ' *' ' these other substances. The Swedish scientists were able to identify some of these "materials as polychlorinated biphenyls or PCB. Based upon this work, other scientists, in this country and throughout the world, have looked for and identified PCB. -more3?86?o STLCOPCB4099921 They subsequently asked themselves two questions -- is PCB a threat to the environment, and, how is PCB entering the environment? - Since PCBs are,not broadcast or spread around the land, . as are pesticides, the scientists theorized the source must be industrial wastes. Monsanto Company has been in contact with many of these scientists and agencies throughout the world. Monsanto is as concerned as anyone about this potential problem. We are continuing our own research programs as well as cooperating fully with other studies. Since Monsanto is the sole manufacturer of PCB in this country (there are other producers, worldwide), it was obvious from the beginning th^t we would be singled out for criticism. , 2. Is PCB as hazardous to the environment as recent charges would indicate? The question of hazard to the environment is relative. Some scientists have discovered it is harmful to certain species of fish and birds. Whether it is harmful to man is a question which is still under study. -more- DSW 378671 STLCOPCB4099922 .;/ " 3 - Recent charges, regarding the hazard to man, have been based upon technical bulletin toxicity descriptions and warning labels carried on shipping containers. These warnings are common throughout the industry. Users of industrial chemicals are accustomed to handling these materials with caution. As far as we know, at this time PCBs are not a threat to the world population. 3. What is Monsanto doing about this possible threat to the environment? (See attached news release.) When the subject first came to our attention in 1968, we began a six-point program. The program consists of: A. Working with scientists around the world to properly identify and measure PCB in the environment. Our contacts have resulted in meaningful exchanges of scientific data. This effort has been directed toward locating the source of PCB emissions. B. One possible source of PCB in the environment could be from manufacturing facilities. For this reason, we have been modernizing many of our manufacturing techniques, installing new pollution abatement devices and generally have "tightened up" our plant techniques. -more- DSW 378672 STLCOPCB4099923 4 C, Earlier this year, we alerted all our customers to the possible threat posed to the environment by PCB. At the same time, we offered our technical services to assist them in the proper handling, use and disposal of these products. . D* We have had under way for nearly a year toxiological studies to determine the effect of higher chlorinated hydrocarbons on animals. Early results from these studies indicate PCB is not highly toxic as has been charged. E. We have also begun studies to determine the biodegradability of PCB. We have come to early conclusions which indicate lower chlorinated products are degraded in the environment. Higher chlorinated substances do appear to resist degradation. We are on the trail of some promising leads to - solve this problem; F. Finally, we are working toward the introduction of alternate products which will be either new formulations or rapidly degrading compounds which retain the functional characteristic of PCB but pose no threat to the environment. * -more- . DSW 378673 STLCOPCB4099924 4. Is the public in any immediate danger? It is our opinion that the public is not faced with any immediate danger to its health from PCBs. Contrary .- ' - to the sensational headlines of recent days, PCB is not commonly found around the household. The major market for PCB-containing products is in electrical equipment. It is also used in closed system heat-transfer applications. The "plasticizer" uses are very limited and are restricted to specialty products. 5. Since PCB does linger in the environment and could be a long-term threat similar to DDT, should it not be banned? Monsanto Company and the electrical industry believe these products are so vital to our society that they should not be banned. One major electrical equipment manufacturer has told us that a ban on the use of PCBcontaining products would mean major power failures throughout the world. We believe that strict control over the use and disposal of PCB, and substitution in uses that cannot be controlled, is the answer to this problem. We are working toward this solution. -more- DSW 378674 STLCOPCB4099925 6 6. If PCB is only used in specialized or "closed systems", why would Monsanto publish a bulletin which said PCB is used in many other ways? Our bulletin 0/PL-306, referred to in recent publicity, '' ' ' . was first published in 1960 when there was no evidence that PCB could be a threat to the environment. When the possible threat was brought to our attention two years ago, we discontinued circulation of the bulletin. The bulletin was designed to be a "sales tool." It had many suggested applications in order to increase our sale of these chemicals. Monsanto is not unique in this marketing approach. To our knowledge, PCB has never been used in all these applications as has been charged. 7. Where does Monsanto produce its Aroclor products? Monsanto produces Aroclor products containing PCB at its William G. Krummrich Plant, Sauget, 111., and its Anniston, Ala., plant. 8. How long has the company produced these chemicals? About 40 years. -more- DSW 378675 STLCOPCB4099926 .\.s-"0 .. i 7 9. How much PCB has been produced? Monsanto*s production figures are confidential and will be released only to the appropriate governmental agencies. * -0O0 .if i U DS\N 378676 STLCOPCB4099927