Document Rp4JmNGrr8dg83zz6ba03zJX8

FILE NAME: National Safety Council (NSC) DATE: 1943 June DOC#: NSC293 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: Legal - USA Before Federal Trade Commission In the Matter of Acme Asbestos Covering & Flooring Cov et al. Brief for Respondents Norristown Magnesia & Asbestos Co. and Sail Mountain Co. UNITED STATES OF AMERICA BEFORE THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION D..o...c...k....e. t "N**--o. 4613 In the Matter of ACME ASBESTCOOSMCPOAVNEYR, IeNtGajAu ND FLOORING BRIEF FOR RESPONDENTS NORRISTOAWNDN SMALALGNMEOSIUANT&AINASCBOEMSTPOASNYCOMPANY Attorney for aGbuoyveGneoamrgeed GRaebsrpioenlsdoenn,ts. I REPRODUCED at t h e n a t io n a l a r c h i v e s 1 i \ I Ii 1 I  the national archives UNITED STATES OF AMERICA BEFORE THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION Docket No. 4613 I n the Matter of A cme A sbestos Covering and F looring Company, et al. BRIEF FOR RESPONDENTS NORRISTOWN MAGNESIA & ASBESTOS COMPANY AND SALL MOUNTAIN COMPANY forThtihsebrpiuerfp, oisne oordfersutpoplaevmoeidntiunngduteherepexettietniosinv,eisbrtiielefds htialelfd obfyACcmadewAalsabdeesrt,osWCicokveerrsinhgaman&d FTlaofot,rinEgsqCs.omonpanbye, e&t Mal.a,ttainsodnbyCoPmhiplaipnyL, .frLoemidyt,heEsvqi.ewonpobinethaolff oNfoIrvriesatsobweny Mpaangyn,easinad&wAills,bfeostrosthCe ommopsatnypaarnt,d bSeaillimMitoeudnttaoinaCcoomn osifdCeroautinosnel offorsotmhee Cofomthme imssiisolne,adaisngit fiesatthuerepsriomf athrye pboriseif atimonenodfedthceosmeprleaisnptonfadlelnftasr tshhaotrtthoef bcehianrggepsromveadd,eanind tthhee amended complaint should be dismissed for that reason. Statement of the Case coTmhpelsaeinttwino Orecstopboenrde1n94ts1. wAerfetesretrhveeidr awnisthwetrhsehoadrigbieneanl fciolemdptlhaeinotrisgeirnvaeldcoinmpDlaeicnetmwbaesr s1u9p4e1r.sedTehdebyoraigninaamlencdomed 2 pthlraoinwtsisi,nhcoownnevecetri,oonfwsoitmh ethseigcnoifnisctarnuccetioinn tohfethlieghatmtehnadteidt complaint. enTtsh,eNaomrreisntdoewdncoMmapglnaeinsitac&harAgsebsesotnoes oCfomthpeasenyre(shpeorneidn craatliloednsNaonrdrisotnoewinn)diavliodnugalwwitihth twenoteoritnhger instpoecaifnieudnlcaowrpfuol wcointhsptihraecyefpfericotrotfo saunbdstdaunrtiianlgly19r3e4strfiocrtinthge, psuurppporseessainndg aanndd oetlhimeriwnaistienginatchteuaslalaenidnpinotteernsttiaatleccoommpmeteitricoenoifn"pbroicthe plirceesnssuerde aansbdesntoons-lciocevnesreindgmematbeoridaylisngansdomaelsoor oafll tohfe sulocwh menatst,erSiaalisl"MaonudntcahinargCeosmtphaenyoth(ehreroefinthceasleledtwSoairlesMpoonudn --taiwn)ithgeenitehrearllye--ntienrinthge incatotegsoairdy coofn"spoitrhaecry rpersipoorntdoenatnsd" d19u3r6ing(P1a9r3a4g,raopr,h bEecigomhti)n.g Ta hpearstpyectioficiattiodnusrinags t1o93w5hoart itsheallceognesdpitroachyavaerebeseent dfoonrethpuinrsuPaanrat gtoraapnhd Ntoineef.fecPtuaarate "grbaopthh Tliwceenlvseedchaanrgdesnothna-lticwenhsaetdwmasadteorniael inanthde osfaleloowf pmraetsesruiraels"pipeconcostviteuritneg uenmfbaoirdyimngethsoodmse oofr aclolmopfetistuiocnh ewriatlhinTrtahdee inCteonmtmainssdiomn eAancitn. g of Section 5 of the Fed theTyhenoawmseenlldelidcenansesdwemrsateorfiablsotahs rdeesfpinoenddeinnttshedeanmyentdheadt cthoemapmlaeinntdeadndcodmenpylaianltl ethxecepotthtehratmtahteeyriaaldmaliltegtahtaiotntsheoyf wtheerye wanedre aarte oennegatgimede ilniceinnsteeersstaotfe DcoomnamldercTeulaloncdh,thJar.t iSsaialtM7o0unPtianien dSetrneieest, tNhaetwitYs oprrki.ncipTahle pdlaecfeenosefsbusseitneusps were to the effect that the actions taken under the Na i i REPRODUCED AT THE NAT IONA L A R C H I V E S 3 tciaonnnaolt IbnedudsetermiaeldRiencovvieorlyatioAnctofprSioerctitoon J5unoef t1h4e, F19e3d5 etorailtsTrsaudbelicCenosmemaigssrieoenmAenctt;wthhialet athcetiosnasmteakweans pinurseuffaenctt wtheersee nroetspionndveionltastioant noof tSimecetioennt5ereodf sianitdo aacnty; aunndlawthfuatl asugbresetamnetinatl,lyunrdeesrtsritcatn,disnugp,prceosms boinrateiolinmionrateconcospmirpaectyitiotno pinrepsrsiucree oarsboethsteorswicsoeveinrintgheosraleothaenrd mdiastterirbiaultsionin ovfiololaw tion of Section 5 of said act. asNsetaittheedr boyf twhaeyseorfes"psounmdemnatsryp"leiandethdeabnryiesfuochf Cdeofuennsseel 4forofthheisCobmrimefi,sstioonthuendeefrfe"ctAtnhsawtetrhs"eyatoptheerattoepd o"fupnadgeer MtheayvuonlutinltaSryeptaegmrebeemr,en1t93i5n"v.itedThbayt sthtaetePmreenstidiesntwhfroolmly untrue as an examination of their answers will disclose. Construction of the Amended Complaint it Iist nisecleasmsaernytatboleargthuaet waitththreisfersetangcee toof ththeecopnrostcreuecdtiionng oHfotwheevEern,giltisihs leasnsgeinmtigael atos udsoedsoinbethcaeuasemeonfdCedomcommispsliaoinn'ts. Ccoomunpslaeiln'st ccohnatergnetisonaincohnisspbirriaecfy(Cw. iCthl* r1e)stpheacttthtoe atmheensdaelde aasnbdesdtiosstripbiupteiocnov"eorfinags"beasntodsbpeacpauerseanodf hoitsherreploewatepdrersesfuerre erengceasrdtoof" sthaeidfpacrot dthuacttst"heancdonbsepciaruascey oafcthuiasllcyomchpalergteeddiisn nthoen-alimceennsdeedd cmoamteprlaiainlst"is awsithexrpersepsesclyt tode"filniecdenseind atnhde amended complaint. The distinction is of importance be- Com*m"isCs.ioCn.." references herein are to pages of the brief of Counsel for the f 4 cnaoutscealtlheedseuptowno troesmpeoentdcehnatsrgheasvoethneort tahtatnemthpotesde manaddearine the amended complaint. finTeshe" aLmiceenndseedd Mcoamteprliaainlst"(aPsarthaegrealpevhenOntyep)eesxopfrepsrsoldyudctes fthoermreiinngsptaatretdo"f"wthhiechTtohoeheryesPpoatnednetn. ts"cNlaosns-ifLieicden*se*d *Maas t"esroialilds"braarses, exzipnrce,ssalynddelaficnqeuderteod inbcalnuddse, sfulecxhiblietemrasngaes abbooilveer, tjhaeckceotsn,spairnadcyccahnavragsedcoisvewriinthg.r"eferAenscepotoinltiecdensoeudt aonfdthneonfa-lcictetnhsaedt wmhaitleeriianls.theInorvigieinwalofcotmhipslaainndt tihnevtiwewo dweefrienitiidoennsticoafl "wliitchenthseods"e ianndthe" namone-nlidceednsceodm" pmlaiantte,ritahles creofnesrpeinrcaecytoclhiacregnesded ianndthe" uonrliigciennasledc"ommpaltaeirnitalsw.asWwhiitlhe ftihneedt,eirtms n"autunrlaiclemnseeadnimngatweraisaltsa"kewnatso nboet meaxtperreisaslslyodf ea soirmcillaasrsitfyipede atos "palirctenosfedthme aTteoroihaelsy"pbautetnnt.ot Imt atdheeruenfodreer aelpipmeianraetdedwthheenctohnespamiraecnydecdhacrogmesplawinitthwraesfesreenrvceed,toth"aut nit licensed materials." knTowheledegveid, etnhcaet schoorwrusg, aitneddeeadsbietstiossapmapaetrt,erfoorf ecxoammmploen, Twoaoshemyanpuafteancttuwreads aisnsduedsoladndlolnogngppriroior rtoto ththee ttiimmee tthhee ptoastepntaepderinvcleenatriloyn wisasnoctonwceiitvheind. thSeucdhefcionritriuognatoedf aesitbheesr c"olircreungsaetdedmaastbeerisatolss" poarpe"rnocnla-lsisciefinesdedinmathteeriaslusb."-liceTnhsee wagarseeomnleyntssuc"haass fworams imngadae upnadretroafn"d tihnecoTnofoohremyitypawteintht mthaadtepaantednts.oldUpnpriaotrenttoedthceorisrsuugaantecde oafsbtehsetopsapteanpte, rafwteasr AT THE NATIONAL AR CH IV ES 5 pthreeseisnstuatinmcee, oanf dthweillpainteanltl, laiknedlihuopodtocoanntidnuienctloudbiengmathdee aonfdthseolodthfeorr eyleevaersn ttoypceosmoef. mTahteerisaalmcelaisssifgieedneuranldlyertrtuhee TOonoekoefy tphaeteanmteansdesdetcofomrtphlaiinnt--thethdatefiisnittoionsaiyn, Pthaerraegrwaeprhe awnhdicharearseomunepwahtaetntseidmialanrdmaareterniaolts "wliicthentsheed smamaeterniaamlse."s Tsphierapcyoinwt iitsh threaftertehneceamteondseudchcoumnpplaatiennttecdharpgreosduncotscoans tohrey" ndoon-nlioctenfaselldw" imthainterthiaelsd. efHinaitdiotnheofameietnhdered"cliocmenpsleadin"t bnyotdeexfipnrietisosnly, sluimchitpedrodthuectsterwmoul"dn, oonf-lcicoeunrsseed, inmaotredriinaalsry" nomenclature have been considered as non-licensed. Terminology fusTihneg abnridefatotfimCeosunnsoetlufnodrertshteanCdaobmlemibsescioanuseisinmsoostmcaonny pgluaacgees--itairsisiimngpoisnsibplaertto oaustceorftaihnisthfeaimlueraenitnog doifsthinisgulaisnh ebxetpwreesesniopnaste"nsteadidapnrdoduuncptast"e,nt"etdheprpordoudcutsc.ts Hheorweinabreefohries odneeschraibveindg" ianndmi"npdrothdautcptsipien cqouveesrtiinogn,"cotorrubegactoendstarsubeedstboys ptearpiaelrs,)etco.rmuanypbaetenetiethderpproadteuncttesd (purnoldicuecntsse(dlicmenasteedriamlsa) dCeopmenmdiisnsgioonn'shCowoutnhseeyl, winerehims abdreieaf,ndhawshantotthceoyncsiosntetanitnly! followed the definitions set forth in the amended complaint. coInnfusthinisg btreiremfineovleorgyy.effoTrhteisdebfeiinnigtiomnsadoef totheavaomidensduecdh cliocmenpsleadintmaarteeriaadlsopitsedusaendd tothemetearnmpruondpuactetsntewdhicohr uarne 6 nwoetreconvoetreidncbluydaendyinofththeeTcullaliomchs ilnicethneseTforoohmeyJophantesntMaanndville Corporation or the sub-license agreements thereunder. The Norristown Flexible Range Boiler Jacket fleCxiobulensrealnfgoer tbhoeileCromjamckisestiopnatiennstist(sUt.haSt. tLheettNerosrriPsatotewnnt Nthoe. l1i9c0e2n7s9es4 htoeroetihnearfsteruncdalelredsathide pNaotrernisttoawren"piantveonltv)e,danind cthaiusseproofcCeeoduinnsge"l's(Cne. bCu.lo7u)s. thTehoeryy oafrehiisnvcoalsvee.d Tohnelyonbley mcoemntpiloanintofocflceuxrisbleinrathnegedebfoinilietrionjacokfet"s nionn-tlhiceenasmedenmdead treersipaelcst" to(PathraegrNaoprhrisOtonwe)n. pTahteernet aorre lnioceanlsleegaagtiroenesmwenitths umnadnenrerit;thtehreerewaiss annoyspcoecnisfpiciaraticoyn wasithtorehsopwectortoinflewxihbalet irmanpglieedboorileinrfejarcrekdetsin eaxbceapckt hianndseod wfaary afsromsucthhe mgeanyerbael aplelaergsatiwoanss icnotveenrdiendg "prniomna-lriicleynsteod mmeaatnerpiaiplse" cwohviecrhinigt aapc cessories. saFryortoapporinotpeorututnhdaetrtshtaenrediinsgreoaflltyhenosictuoantnieocntioitnibsentweceeesn tthhee Ninovrernistitoonwnempbaotednietdanind tthhee NTooorrhiesytowpantepnat.tenPt,riroarngtoe lbaorigleerdjiaacmkeettesr (toreaclolvyeraasbpoeicliearl) twyperee owfhpatipies kcnoovwerninags ooff irbigleidfecaotnusrteruwcthiiocnh. faTchileitaNteosrrpisatcokwinng paantdensthcipopvienrgs a(tafkleexs uItphmasucnhotlheisnsgswpahcaet)soaesvewretlol daos wmiatkhinthgeittyepaesyoftomaatpeprliya.l cwlietahr wanhdichuntchoenjtraacdkiectteids. mTahdee. jacTkheet ecvanidebnecemaodnetehiitsheisr obyf tThoeoThoeyohpeyatpenatteendt.products or of products not covered REPRODUCED r. 7 AT THE N AT IO NA L A R C H I V E S onTthheisTproiailntEixnampainraegrrcaoprhre5c8tl,ypsaugme m24a,rizoefdhtihsereepvoidretncaes follows: lar"g5e8.sizAes psiteacteedo,fapfipleexibcloeverrainngge sbooldilefrorjacukseet oins aa rthaengTeoobhoeilyerp.ateInt tcoarnobuetsimdeanthuefaTctouorheedy epiathteenrt.unTdheer fmleexcihblaenifceaaltucrheanogf etheonfletxhieblerirgaindgetybpoeilerranjagcekebt oiislear jeanctkNetowrrhisictohwisncMovaegrneedsibay&a ApastbeensttooswCneodmbpyanrye.spTonhdis pabalteesntthreelajatecskeotnltyo tboe thfoeldfeledxibinletofeaatumroerewhcoicmhpeanct pTahciksagNeorfroisrtoswhinpppinagte, ntthuhsasrendoucirneglatfiroenightot cthheargmeas. titesriamlsoifsrtoumre wrehsicishtatnhte ojarcksehtrinisk-mpraonouffacchtuarreadctenror(Rto. 2101037-5,,2119905,-62,19220-25-,4,3330282-,9)4.8"2-4, 1996-8, 1994, 2003-4, somTheetiNmoerripsrtioowrntopattheentiswsuaasncine eoxfisttheneceToaonhdeyuspeadtefnotr. fNaocrturirsitnogwnColmicpeannseyd, utnhdeerreistpsojnadceknett, pPahteilnipt oCnaAreuyguMstan2u0, i1s93n3o.thiTnhgaut nliucseunasleaibsoiunt eitv.ideInt cpero(vCiodmes. fEoxr. a15r0o)y.altTyhberuet npoorpartiicoencoonntFroebl.ruNaroyrr1is6t,o1w93n4li(cCeonmse.dEJxo.h1n4s9M); athuvaitllleicCenosre cthoensteaintreadnsaacptriiocnescocnoturlodl pnrootvipsoiossni.blyIthiasvteo hbaednoatneydththinagt mtoednot. wTithhetshee tTraonoshaecytiopnatsenotccourrrthede Tinultlhocehnloicrmenasle caogurresee wofasbuinsineefsfsectw. hilTehetheToNohaetiyonpaalteInntduwsatrsianloRt eicssouveedryuAntcitl SfreopmtemJobhenrsoMf 1a9n3v4ille(RCeso.rpEoxr.at1i2o)n adnidd nthoet cToumlleocihntoLicbeeninsge until September 11, 1935 (Com. Ex. 1). MFanuurtfhaecrtumrionrge,Ctohme peavnidyeangcreeesdhotwostatkheaat ltihceenPsehiflriopmCNaroery- 8 briystoNwonrriusntodwernitws ipthateantsuoint lyfoarftienrfriitngheamd ebneten(Rth.*rea1t0e2n1e-2d, , 1104-5; Corns. Exs. 179-182; Res. Exs. 55-66). ^ duNctoiorrnistoofwtnes'stimcoounnyselincocnosninsetecntitolyn owbijtehctethdetoNtohrerisitnotwron finlexthibeleprroancegeedibnogi.lerCjaocuknestelb'seceafufsoertsoftoitsholaldckdoowf nreltehveasniczye bofotthhethreecgoordvearnnmd emntiniamndizethteherecsopsotnodfenthtse wpreorceeeidninvgainto. Aprloldtuhcee eovnidtehnicsesuwbhjieccht wthaes Cadommimttiesdsioonn'sthCeotuhnesoerlycothualdt siteawrcohueldd ibnevcaoinnnfeocrtesduc"hlactoenrneocnti.o"n. TThehereCcoomrdmwisislilonb'es Cthoautnisteilsneovwidesneceeksoftoa "copnunrpecotseittoinfixhiasndbrmieafinbtyainarpgruiicnegs eovnidaelnl cperoodf uacntys siunchthpisurfpioelsde". (C. C. 28-29). There is no TThuellotcehstilimceonnsye magarkeeesmietntclweaars tihnateffitecwt atshantoTt uullnotcilli tahte tTehmepcteodntaronlyhperitcheencoenxtreorcliwseidthwreasferoennlyceutnodebroitlheer jTaockohetesy. pliacteennste,esi. ue.nwdehrenthaendToifohtheey jpacakteentt.wasThmiasdeillbuystrTautellsocthh'es cpoantefunstioinntowhtihchis thperocineejedcitniogn caoufsethde. NAorrfilsetxoiwblne jraacnkgeet btoowilnerpjaatceknettccoavnerbinegmthadeefluenxidbeler tfweaotupraet,enantsd, tthhee NTooorhriesy rpaantgenetbocoilveerrijnagckethtecatnyp(eanodf ism)aatelsroialms audseedw. ithAoutfleuxsiibnlge tthuerinTgooChoemypapnaytenntevaetr aagllr.eedThteo aPnhyilippricCearceoyntrMolanuunfdaecr itthsouligchensceonwceitdhedNlyorNrisotrorwistnow(Rn. i8n92i,ts97o8w, n979in, t1e1re0s6t)s eavnedn because its other licensees were bound by a price control * "R " references are to page numbers of the Official Report of Proceedings. REPRODUCED AT THE NAT I 0 NAL ARCH I VES 9 ppurorvsuisaidoen tihne tChaerieryliCceonmsepsanfyrotmo aNccoerprtisptoriwcen,coanttteroml.ptAedftetor 0 bCeacraemye's seuffbelcictievnes,e CwaitrheyTuwllaoschtuhnerdeearfttehre Tinoohaeypopsaitteionnt wathearneyitprciocueldit mcahkoeseanbdy sueslilnfglexmibalteerriaanlsgenobtoicloervejraecdkebtys cthoentrTooloohneyflepxaitbelnet rabnugtewbaosilesrubjajeccktettso mTaudlelocuhn'dserprtihcee cthlaaitmtshaotf ctohmepaTnoyohmeyadepaatnendt.soldThbeothtesktiimndosnyandindaitcadtiefs f(eRr.en9t81t)r.ices even though it was a minor item in its sales cuCsionmg mfinisgseiornb'secCauosuens(eCl.fCu.rt2h9e)r Natoterrmisptotswntodpidoinntotanissauce raannygefubrothileerr pjarcickeetslisitns haifsteprricTeullloiscths. inTclhuededrecfolredxibalet pNaogreris7to19wncletoarliyssuseho"wasnythafut rtthheerreprwicaes lnisotso''ccbaescioaunsefoirt dthidatnboetcacuhsaengneo iltesgaplriaccet!ionLwikaeswitsaekehne aignafeinrsst (iCn.friCn.g2e9rs) otof Nshoorwris"toawpnu'srpjoasceketto pfaixtenatn,dthmaat,initnainsompreicwesa"y., Nteenedds lferisnsgteomseanyt,saswhthicehreccaomred stohowitss, aNttoernritsiotonwnanpdroetveesntetudalilny f8o5r7c)e.d Tthhee minefrreingfaecrst tthoattaitkefailliecdenstoesinfsrotimtuteit ex(Rpe.ns8i5v5e- lwithigicahtiownastoofenmfoirncoer iitms proigrthatnscewiitnh irtesspseacletstovoalunmietemis cbeyrtCaionulynsenloftorofthaenyCosmigmniifsisciaonnce(.R. T1h01e3)teostnimpoangye 2c9iteodf ahnisd bsoriledfflteoxibtlhee raenffgeectbothilaetr jRacekseptosnbduent tdsidmnaontufpaacytuarnedy r(oWy.alLty. SotneffsiuncshofsaPlehsiliips aCgaarieny mMisalneuafdaicntgurainsgthCeomwpitanneys)s awnads wthaesnntoetsttiefsytiinfyginwgitwhitrhesrpeefecrtentoce thtoe tTheooNheoyrripsatotewnnt jacket patent license agreement. The same witness testi- r 10 Nfleodrris(Eto.wn079o)n ftlhexaitblehirsancgoembpoainleyr jdaicdkeptsa.y Sruocyhaltrioeysalttyo Twoaoshepyaypabalteentwhoerthneort!the jackets were made under the JohTnhse-MleatntverilleoftoJaNnourarirsytow8,n 1a9s35to(Cwohmic.h ECxo.un9s1e)l sfereokms ptoerfdercatwly uinnnwoacruroaunstedwhiennferreenacdesin(Cth.eCl.ig2h9t) oifs tlhikeewfaiscet ttohwatnJouhnndse-rMthaenvjialclekewt apsaatet ntthaatndtimsuebajeclitcetonseNeoorrfisNtoowrrnis's nlaawtufurall parincde pcroonptreorl foonr tihte tojacbkeetsi.nteIrtestwedas repgearfredcitnlgy nperigcoetitaotiownhsicwh iitthwiansfrbinoguenrds. aLnidketwhiesesttahbeillieztatteior nofoAf pthriel 8th, a1n93a5n (eCxoamm.plEexo. f1a03l)icecnitseede bsyeeCkionugnsinelfoirsmnaotitohningtomporore tect its own interests. (CI.t Ci.s28n)o,tethwaotrtNhyo,rriasstowCnomnmeviessriolinc'esnsCedouTnuselllocchonucneddeesr oitrs ijnatcekreesttspaitnenitts apnadtennet.veNr oarsrsisigtonwedn'stowhitihmdraanwyalrifgrohmts tbhoeileTruljlaocckhetlicpeantseenthador nolicreenlsaetioangsrheiepmneonrts efwfeictht oonthietsr nreostp, olincdeennsetsessoomf eToufllowchhomundweerret,heanTdosoohmeye poaftwenhtomat wthearet tailmsoe n(oJtuewneort1h9y39t--haTtroianllyEsxixam(Rin.e7r00r)epoourtt opf.th1e9)e.ighItteeins ototwhenr urensdpeornditesntpactoenrpt.orations were licensees of Norris paAtegnat,inanitdmNuosrtribsetowrenpelaicteednsethsatuntdheer Nito,rrhiasvtoewnnojapclakceet binurtdheinsedprwociethedtihnegteasntdimtohney raencdordexhshiboiutsldinntrootdhuacveed bweiethn reference to them. 6 REPRODUCED AT THE NAT I 0 NAL ARCHI VES 11 Hearsay Evidence I AcUtinodnerto tEhelimhienaadteingCoomfpe"tiPtiloannniend PCriocmem" oCnomCmouirssseiono'sf I aCtotournnseeyl -e(Cxa. mCi.ne2r5-w27h)o rwelaisespehremaviitltyedontotetesstitmifyonwy itohf raen l Mspre.ctGetoorgineteCrlvairekwosf hreesphoanddewnitthThMe rC. laRrokbAerstbeCstloarskCaonmd pviatncyh aonfdthweithreMspro.nGdeenotrgeAtMlalnatdiciniAehsbaensdtosMrC. oJr.poOraztuiroon- aCnodvewriintgh aMnrd. FCloololorpinygoCf otmheparneys.ponTdheenttesAticmmoenyAsqbueostteods lboywiCnogmsmucihss"ioenv'sideCnocuen"setlo wgoellinitloluastrraetceosrdt.heTvhiecewoitfneasls wtoastepsetirfmyitatesd,totwwohyateatrhse apfteerrsohnisinintetervrvieiewwesd hsaapidpentheadt, saosmteoonwehealtsethteold" ihmimpre(sasbioount" fiovfe tyheearpserbseofnoreinttheravti)ewanedd wfuarsth(ears poefrmaitttiemde taobotuesttiffiyve nyoetarosnlpyrewvihoauts)t.he Hpeerwsoans vinietewrvediew"ekdnotwolsd" haimnd bwuthaatsheto "wuhnadtertshteanpdesr"sownitliinterer s(Cpe.ctC.top. t2h5e-2i7n)t.entNioonnse ooff t"heisve"ryeovnidee"ncien" thsheouilndduhsatvrye vbeeeryn apdrmopiteterldy. sIttriciskehneabrsyaythien iTtsriawlorEstxafomrmin.er IatswTatos pNaonryri,stPowlann,t RSauiblbeMr o&unAtasibne, stKoseaWsbyork&s aMnduttmisoonst oCtohmer 1re2s9p1o).ndeTnhtse "(Rte.st1i8m67o,ny18"75g,iv1e8n95s,e1co89n6d, h1a8n9d7, b1y89t8h,e1w89i9t, nItessshwouasldnontevsuerbjehcatvteo beexepnlanpaetriomnittbeydcrtoossenecxuammbineartiothne. preacraogrde;meanntd inbtyendthedis, anso taosptehresioCnosmamriessicoans'ts, antotorrndeiys- i ethxeamtiensetirm. oIntyisisjunstotthcaotmthpeetceinrtcuamsssutamncinegs ahries scuocmh ptlheatet iTnhteegruistey aonfdthdiessitreesttiomotenlly thbye ttrhuethtraisalheattuonrdneerystoiondhiits. Cj sbtrriaeifneddemefofnosrttratotesmabkies oduitrea nceaesde. foItr issupadpmoritssiibnle,hiisf athteaplle, rsoonnlys winittehrvrieeswpeedctwtoerethaessroecsipaotendd.entIst wisitnhotwhcoomn Mneocutendtaiinn aanndy wthaeyy wsthreantsuooeuvselry woibthjecNt otorrisittoswbneinogr cSoanil "siedveirdeedncaes" eovfidtehnicsechsoarafcatrerasis tthoeybearceoncsoidnecreerdnebdy. thIef lCeossmmwiassstieono,fhotilmdien.g hearings is a complete and meaning Misleading Character of Commission Counsel's Brief buAsinpersoslifmicensoguercneeroafllyirriintatthioenU(ntoitepdutSittatmesildisly)thaempornog aptetnemsitpyt toof csohmareactgeorvizeernamsenutnlaewmfpulol,yebeosnatofidaettaactkte,mapntds ttoentcioomnsplyofwthiteh ethxeeculatwiveananddcaadrrmyinoiusttrathtieveexbprraenscsheeds ionf CthoeunGseolvehrenrmeiennt.is aTnheexbcreilelefntfileexdambyplet.he InCohmismzisesailoonu'ss effort to " win his case" he relies heavily: by(al)awOntowhdoat, tuhnedreersptohnedeNnatstiodnida,l asIntdhueystrwiaelreRreecqouvireerdy Act. aut(hb)oriOtyn owfhtahtecsearmtaeinlaowf tahned rweshpiloenditenwtsasdsidtillunindeerfftehcet oinf tahtetemPrpetsiindgenttoacftoemrptlhye wScithhecthhteerwdieschiessiona.nd intentions remFoorvteudnatthealty,thtehemedmaybsersofofthteheNC.Rom.Am. isasrieonncoatnnsoot fraer ctiaolnlsthwehiecchontohme iacctcosnoduigtihotnstothaemnelpiorreavtaei,linasg,wtehlel acsontdhie sItpiwritoutlhdenseepmrevtahialitngthebopthenidnuluthme ghoasversnwmunengt faanrdsionucte. that day. However, it is in the light of that background REPRODUCED AT THE NAT IONAL ARCH IVES 13 pthroatpetrhley schoonudludctbeofjudthgeedr.espTohnedespntisritdiusriwneglltehxaetmppelirfiioedd bSyec.th4e) raepqpuriorveemdebnyt othfethPereCsioddeent(,Rtehsa.t Ethxe. M2--erAchrtaincldeisVinIg, Paplapnr,ovseudbjebcyt tthoreteh-efourervthieswofofthteheCAoddemmineismtrbaetrosr,owf hthene DofivitshieonInanddusdtruyly wtilheod, asrheallmbeembbienrdsinogfupthoen aDllivmiseimonbetros lwawhicfhoritwhaipcphliaesc.rimTihniasl preenqaulitryemweanst phroavdidtehde (fNoarctieonoafl IonfdaulsltrpiarilceRse,cotevremrys Aacntd, Sceocn. d3i(tifo)n)s. oFfilsianlge awndaspudbeelimcietyd VesIsIeIn)t.ialTthoe tohbeviporuosmaontidonadomf itftaeidr pcuormppoesteitioofn th(Aisrtwicales tporiceenabasle aa cmoemmpbeetirtoor.f thNeonineduosftryustohassellfoartgothtteensatmhee aodpmprionbirsituramtorcahsitmsueplofninthteho"sechdiaseylse.rs"Seebyaltshoe RNe.lRea.Ase. BNoo.ar1d10(3R6e, s.4/E24x/.355). ofStehcetioNna5tioonfaltheInAducst trpiraolviRdeecdovtherayt wthheirleeatfhteeraacnt ywaasctiinonefcfoemctpalynidngfowr iathptehreiopdroovfissiioxntys doafyas cporodevistaioknesn odfurtihneg asunctih-tpruesritodlawshs.all Ibne tehxeemlipgthtfroomf ththies pbearcikogdrooufndth, ecoCuopdlee,dthweitChotmhemispsriiocne'sdCecoluinneseldusraiynsg ththaet tthhee ceonnadcutmctenotf othfethreespNo.nI.dRe.nAt.s tdourMinagy th2e7, p1e9r3io5dshfroowms ealnimuinnaltaewfcuolmp"eptiltainonnedin cpormicme"on! course of conduct to seeRkesalitzoingchtahregeweraeksnpeosnsdiennthsiswairthgumenentetr,inCgouninsteol tahnedn wachtiicnhg udnadteer haeVcohluanratacrtyeriAzegsreeams entht eaft"edreMmiasye 27o,f 19th35e Nth.eR.NA..I".R.(AC.. Cw.as9).notHerepigenaolerdes btyheCfoancgt rethssat uTnittille JIunoef 1p4re, s1s9ly35caonndtintuheadt icnerteafifnectpobrytioCnsonogfretshse uAntcitl wAeprreil ex1, Cj 14 1E9x3e6cu(PtiuvbelicORrdeesroslut(iRoens.NoE.x2s6.--77,4t9li).CoAngtretshsi)s. pSoeientalhsoe bAec&omBesincoonnfeusbedreaatnhd asrefeevrisdentoceCoofm". tEhixs. a1g8reaenmden1t5"2. TmheenttwdaoteadreJuennetir1e5l,y19u3n5reulnasteigdn!edCboyma. nEyxo.ne18anisd amadrokceud "wSasecoannd aDborratfivt"e. atTtehme pttesttoimcoanryryshoouwts thceleaPrlryestihdaetnti'st wthiesheNs.I.wRi.tAh. rewshpieccht twoerceonntiontuiinngvaulniddaetredthneoprorrteipoenasleodf. bFeucrotmheermefoferect,iviet usnpteilciafipcparlolyvesdtabtyedthethPatresitidewnat.s nItotwatos n3e05v3e-r5)apapnrdovdeidd nnootrparocvteidde,unadsesrta(teRd. b3y86C-7o,un10se7l5,(C23.3C9,. 9th)efoerntairney AmsebrecshtaonsdiIsnindgusptrlyan.andIt nwoats mfoerrmelyulaftoedr tfhoer Adissbinegstopslaanndof Awlhliiecdh iPsroadtutacctksedD. iviOsinont,hetheothmererhchanadn, tChoernCs.haEixrm. a1n52ofAth&e BCoidse aAucothpoyriotyf daatteedlegMraamy 2s8e,nt19b3y5 ttohethreeqPureesstidaenndt oufrgNinogrrisotfowthne, aPgraeisnidienntcoomfptlhiaencUenwitietdh Scotantteins,ueastkoinogbisteravse athCeoadretimcleems boefr tthoe aCgoredee, sbpyecwifiireed, tion htiivseltye,legdreaamlt (w3,it4h,, 5H, 7o,u8rs&o1f0)L. abTohr,eseMAinritmiculems, Wresapgeecs, CTehrilmdsL, aabnodr, UConnfadiirtioTnrsadoef PSraacleticaens,d PLubabliocrityPorofvPisriiocness,. IAtdmisinnisottreawtioornt,hywhtihcaht inthceluydeddidthneotmeinrcchluadnedisAinrtgiclpelan6., N(Coormris.toEwx.n15se3n).t aThweirree isinnocoemvipdleianncceethwaitthSatihlisMoreuqnutaeisnt received such a telegram, or if it did, whether it replied. foTr hthise iCsotmhemissusmionaunpd tsoubthsetanticmeeoofftthhee cTauselloocfh CLoicuennsseel Agreement and sublicenses thereunder! Ir e p r od u c e d at the na t i ona l a r c h i v e s 15 . proTdhuectTsulaloncdh ilsiceandseequaagterelyemaenndt ceofvfeecrteidveloynlydepalattenwtietdh ainndtheFloborireinfgfilCedomopnanbye,haeltf oalf. AcImt esuAffiscbeesstotos sCaoyvehrienrge twheartebloicthenNseoersriostfowDnonaanldd TSualilloMcho, uJnrt.aiunnaddemr itthethaTtoothlieeyy pthaatetnNt, obruritstiotwanppweaitrhsdrienwevaidnedncheasanndotisbueenncoantrlaicdeincsteede s1i9n4c0e. June of 1939 and Sail Mountain since January of CoNmopacnoynnwecitthionanoyf oetihtheerrreNspoorrnisdteonwtsn soinrceSatihleiMr oreusnptaeicn ttihvee ewviidthedncraew. als from the license agreement appears in Conclusion noAt swiisthutshueallainw cbaustesraotfhethriswtiythpethtehefarcetasl. dTifhfieculCtyomis mattiesmsiopnte'sd Cboyuninseflereinncea,n inefnfuoerntdtoo amndakedisotuotrtiaoncasoef hthaes etovidceansecse itno wmhaickhe tthhee cfoauctrsts ohfavtheisdeecaidseedapthpaetarvisoilmatiiloanr othfatthea lcaawreofucclusrtruedd.y oInf tthheis ewxehabuesltiievvee blireiehfasfilfeadileodnabned ehtalafl,owf ilAl ccmonevAinscbeetshtoesCCoomvmeriisnsgionantdhaFt ltohoeriCngomCmomisspiaonny's, Counsel lias failed. recBoerfdoreis csloosinbgarrween woifshevtiodenpcoeintwiotuht rtehsaptectthetoenStiariel MCoouunnstealinfoCromthpeanCyomthmaits,siaosn,shhoewndoebsy nthoet ebvreienf aotf tthhies cstaatgede, oafsthhee prreopceeaetdsintgheknaolwlegwathieorne tohfatthCe ocmopmapnlyaiinst ltoo tohfefaecffte,ctit thisatloictatiesdloincatOedhioinanNdewhaYsoirtks. saAlessaofmficaetteinr G iti tCohitchaegoe.xteTnhtisthdaettaitil,shoofwcsouthrsaet, Sisainl oMt osiugnntiafiincaCntomexpcaenpyt has practically been ignored in this proceeding. AsTbheestoesvidCeonmcepainsyclaenadr tShaaitl MboothunNtaoinrriCstoomwpnanMyahganveesiano&t abneednJlaicneunasreyesooff1D94o0n,alrdesTpeuclltoivcehl,y.Jr. Tshinecree Jisunneotohfin1g93i9n, wthiethrerceosrpdectto toindaincyatelicaennysecdonmneactteiroinalsof oarnynocnh-laicraecntseerd, mspaotnedrieanltss, sbientcweetehneitrheresespetwctoivereswpiothnddreanwtsalsanads olitcheenrserees. ICtomthmeriesfsoiorne, atphpeeaTruslltohcaht elivceennsief, aingretheemjeundtgmisenutnloafwtfhuel tuhnedreer isSencotiopnrac5tiocaflthreeasFoendewrhayl Teirtahdeer oCfotmhemsiessrieosnpoAncdt, ednetssistshoorudledr wbehicinhclmudigehdt ibne tihsseuetderminsthoef parnoyceecdeiansge. anInd cthisiisoncoonfnetchtiisonC, oamttemnitsisoionnisinreUspneitcetdfulIlmy pcoarllteedrstoantdheDdies Ctioll.erIns,c.,In3c0.,F2.4T.FC. .T1.39C0.. T13h7e9caansed oOf pWpiennshteoinmv.CFo.lliTn.sC&., 3enFtsed". c2edas9e6d1 a(n1d925d)esisistaeldso" pferortminentht.e Tprhaecsteiceresspcoonmd pthlaisinmedattoefr. prior to the Commission's investigation in paRnyesapnodndSeanitls MNoournritsationwCnomMpaagnnyesrieasp&ectiAvseblyesptorsayCtohmat the complaint be dismissed as to them. Respectful NoarnridstoSwainl MMaogunnetasiian &CoAmspbaenstyo.s Company Albeorft CLo.unWseollfe, . 17 the NATIONAL A R C H IV E S APPENDIX Exceptions to Trial Examiner's Report anNdowSaiClomMeouNnotarirnistoCwonmpManayg,netswiao &ofAstbheestoRsesCpoomndpeanntys hceepretint,obytheGuryepGoerotrgoef GthaebriTelrsioanl, Ethxeaimr iantteorrnheeyr,eiann,dfielexd March 15, 1943 as follows: reg1.ardTiongththeespercionncdipapladraifgfrearepnhceonbetpwaegeen 2theofortihgeinraelpaonrdt ltehgeedamaencodnedspicroamcyplwaiintht. reWspheiclet ttohelicoernigsiendalancdomunplliacienntsaeld mtheatearmiaelns d(eodrigcionmalplcaoinmtplliaminittspathraegrcahpahrgseEtioghlticaenndseNd inaen)d, anmone-nlidceednsceodmmplaatienrtia(lsa,meansdbeodthcotmerpmlasintarpeardaegfirnaepdhsinOtnhee, aEnigahltleagnadtioNninien).subTdhieviasimonend10edocfopmapralaginratpahlsoNicnoentwaihniecdh wsigasnifniocatnitnacslufdoeldlowins:the original complaint and which is pe"riTodhisthme eNrcahtiaonndaislinIngdpulsatnriawl aRs eacdoovpetreyd Adcutriwngasthine eCfaferecyt bCyoremsppaonnyd,enthtecowrphoorllaytioonwsn, eidnclsuudbisnigdiTarhye Pohf ilriep sbpuotnidt ennetv, eTrhweasPhaiplipproCveadreybyMthaenuAfdacmtuinriinstgraCtoormopfanthye, National Recovery Administration." an2d. thTeocoprarreasgproanpdhinngusmubbedrievdisio6nohneapdaigneg 3" fo"f othneparegpeo3r3t ooff tthhee retepromrt a"suninliccoernresectd"startaetmheerntsthbayn rethaesonteromf th"enuosnelicensed" as defined in the amended complaint. far3. asToitthsetaltaesst tphaartagthraepchomonplpaaingte c3ovoefrstheviorelaptoiortnsinnsoot tchoenrneeucntdederw. ith the Toohey patent and the Tulloch licenses Appendix. fa4r.asToit tshteatneisntthhaptatrhaegrparpinhcoipnapl apgleac6e ooff tbhuesirneepsosrtofinthsoe Sretsrpeeotn,dNenewt SYaoilrkM, oNu.nYta.inTCheomalplaengyatiiosnlotocatthedataetff7e0ctPwinaes dtoensiuepdpionrtitsit.answer and there is no evidence in the record wh5i.chTois tahne ifnoaucrctuhraptearaagnrdapihncoomn ppleatgee s8tatoefmethnet orefptohret danifdfeurennpcaetsenintedmeptrhooddusctosf. mPaanruafgarcatpurhenausmbbeetwreeden17poantepnategde s1t3atoefmtehnet arsepiondrticiastead bmyucthhempoorretioancscuorfatteheanredcocrodmtphleertee cited. of6t.lieTorepthoertpianrasgorafaprh acsonitclsutdaitnegs athtatthevotloupntaorfypaaggreee9 mdoeenstsnwoteraepspieganredinbyevaidneunmcebetrhaotf rtehsepseonadgernetesmaenndtsthwateriet ethveerfaacptptrhoavtedCobmy mthiessiPorne'ssidEexnht.ibitA1tt8enistiomnaii'kseddir"ecSteecdontod 3D0r5a5fto"f athned ttroatnhsecrteipsttimwhoenryeotfheDofonlaloldwTinuglloacphp,eJarr.sa:t page . me"nQt .siSgonefdabryaasnyyobuodkyn1o'w' , was the voluntary agreevo"luAn.taTryheargereweamsennot upnrtoilviasfitoenr mthaedPerefosirdesnigtnhinagd athpe proved it, and it never was approved nor disapproved." gra7.phTnoumthbeerfeadil5uroen ptoagere1p1oortf tihne creopnnoerctttihonat wthiethrepviasread m(Re.rc2h1a57n,di2s2i5n4g-5,pl2a3n29,th2e3r7e0i,n31m60e-n3t1io6n3)e.d was never used. in8s.o Tfaor paasrathgeraupshe onfumthbeepreludra6l o"nplpaangse" 1i1mpolfietshethraetptohret preavriasgerdapmherischianncdluidsiendginplathnatresftearteremdentto. in the preceding AT THE NATIONAL A R C H IV E S 19 Appendix. in9s.o Tfaorpaasraitgrimapphliensumthbaetrethde1s2oocnalpleadgeV1o2luonftatrhye Aregproeert m(Re.n3t8w6-a7s,1e0v7e5r, 2e3f3fe9c, t3iv0e53o-5r).acted under as an agreement on10p.agTeo 1t5heolfastthesenretepnocret iwn htihceh piasraugnrsaupphponrutemdbebryedth2e6 record. gra11p.h Tnuomtbheereidnc3l2usoionnpaogfe t1h6e owf othrde r"edpiorretcitnlys"o ifnarpaasrait itmiopnliaensdthtoatththeelraestwpasoritniodnireocft scaoindsuplatraatigornapohr:c"ombumt utnhiecrae itshroeuvgidhenTcuellotchhatwitthheorethewr eprreoscpoemctmivuenliiccaetnioseness w(Rit.h35a6n-7d, t1i0o9n8s, d1o10n0,ot20su48p-p9o, r2t0t7h5e, q2u10o4te, d23p5o2r,ti3o0n96o-f7)th."e sTtahteemceintat. pa1g2e. 17Toofththeelraesptosretnwtehnicceh iosfupnasruapgproarpthednbuymtbheereedvid37enocne cited. the13.repToortsuinbdsivoisfiaorn a(sd)itofstaptaersagtrhaapthth4e6 monerpcahgaend2islinogf qpulainreudnudneirfothrme scuobnlitcreancstes.agSreuecmh esntatttehmereenitn ims ecnotniotrnaerdy rteo the evidence (Com. Ex. 1). sub14li.ceTnsoe tahgereefamileunrteoftoDorenpaoldrtTuinlloccohn,nJerc.t,iotno twheithefftehcet tthheatprTicuellsocohr dteirdmnsoot,r acnodndimtiaodnes onfo saatletemofptantyo,ascboensttroosl oTroowhoeoyl pfealttenptap(eRr. o3r16p,ip3e37c-o8v, er6i3n2g, n1o08t3c-4o,ve1r2e0d6,by13t2h2e, 1113,551,9,148470-,12261,831,483-117571-,8;21C1-o2i1n5s., 2E2x6s-.2313,, 225316;-2R4e8s).ps. Exs. of1t5h.e Troeptohret lianstsosefnatrenacse iitn ipmaprlaiegsratphhat54anoyndpeacgiseion23s Appendix. oagfretheemennatt,umreajtohreirteyinrulreefoerrrbeyd atnoyowneereotmheardethbayn Dmountuaaldl T22u7ll5o)c.h, Jr. (R. 391, 907-8, 1072, 1216, 1320-1, 2049, 2174, of1t6h.e Treopothrteinlassot fsaerntaesnciet imofplpieasratghraatpthhe5l5iceonnsepeasggeav2e4 lTicuellnosceh aagnryeeamuethnotsritayndothinerstohafnarbyasthiet tiemrmplsiesofatnhye scuobn foifrmtahteionsuobflicheinsseactaigornesemotehnetrs thparniorabtiodintghebiry rtehsepetecrtimves terminations thereof. in1c7o. nnTeoctitohne wfaitihlurpearaogf rathpeh T59riaoln Epxaagmesin2e4r atnod r2e5poorft tahgereerdepotort athalitcePnsheilipundCearreytheMNanourfraiscttouwrinngcoCmompapnayn'ys wboitihlera jpaactkeentt pinaftreinntgeomnelynt asfuteitr biyt NhaodrribsteoewnnthMreaagtneenseida &ResApssb. eEstxoss. C55o-m66p)a.ny (R. 1104-5; Corns. Exs. 179-182; pa1g8e. 2T5o otfhethsetarteempoerntt "inthopuagrhagrTauplhloc5h9 eantdethaevotroepd otof bhyaveansyameveidiennsceer.ted'', which statement is not supported gra19p.h T64o otnhepawgoerd2s6 "ofusthueallryec''oradndin"saot ftaimr aess't'hieny pinafrear ttahiant sthimerielarwuenrepaotethneterdtipmroesduwcthse,nanjodbbaetrdsifcfoeureldntnporticoebs, fwroomrdsvaarrieounsotressuppopnodretnetds banydthoetheervsi.denSceuchcitqedualiinfyitnhge report or any other evidence. sio2n0. (aT)o otnhepapgaera2g8raopfhthfeollroewpionrgt itnhethheeafdoilnlogw, isnugbdpiavri ticulars : Appendix. por(ati)onThoef threecofirrdst pseangteen2c1e37to cthiteedeffseucptptohratst thoenrley wtheraet price lists; isin(bg) pTlhaenr"e ipsrinoor etovidNen.Rce.Ao.f aasnysta"tgeedneirnal thmeercsehcaonndd sentence. tio(nc) oWf itthhe rerefecroerndcecitteod thcelealarlsyt sshenotwesncet,haatn "elxisatm"inoar p"rpicuebsli'shed" prices are referred to, rather than " quoted pa2g1e. 29 Toof tthhee sreecpoonrdt swenhtiecnhceisinmitshleeafdiirnsgt pbaercaagursaephanon e"xRa.m2i6n1a1ti-o2n" oshfotwhes crleecaorrldy tphaagteM26a0c0Doaungdalthweaspatgeesstifcyiitnegd Jaoshnas-JMohannsv-iMlleansvaillelesmdeinstreixbculutosirvealyn.d was talking about pa.2r2a.graTpohthuendfeirrsts,utbh-diridvisainond f(ibf)thosnenptaegneces29inofthtehefirrest upnodrterinthtehaTt othoehyeyarpeatneonttliamnidtedtheto stuhbelipceantesneteadgrpereomdeuncttss dausritnog pthaertirceuslpaerctirveespopnedrieondtss. whTenhethreeyferweenrceesincleefafrelcyt show that such statements should be so limited. pa2g3e. 3T1oofththee friresptorptarwahgircahpihs iunnadcecrurasutebdainvdisimonisle(dad)inogn. S13e2e2,pa3r1a7g2.raph 67 on page 27 of the report and R. 1216, su2b4d.iviTsoionthe(el)astonsenptaegnece32inotfhethseecorenpdoprta.ragTrhaeprhe uisndneor such evidence as to any respondent. (e)25.onTopatghee f3i2fthofantdhesixrtehpopratrawghraicphhsaruendneortsusbudpipvoisritoedn by the testimony cited or other testimony. Appendix. pa2g6e. 3T3oofthethefirrsetpopratraagsraupnhsuupnpdoerrtedsubbydivainsiyoncit(efd), oonr other, evidence. sub27d.iviTsoionthe(fl)asotnsepnatgenece33inofthtehesecroenpdorpt airnagtrhaapthitunmdiesr iwnatesrapsrettos ntohne-ltiecsetnimseodnmy acitteerdia, lis. ea.n,dR.th4e07w. itnTehses toebstviimouosnlyy wenatsedtaplkroindgucntsotofabaountatruirnegssimorilabrantdospbatuetntaebdouptroudnupcatst. noTt hientmenadkeidn,g aonfdthsehofuolrdegnooint gbepacrotincsutrluaerde,xacseptaiownsaiavreer roefpoarnty, wohtihcehrarienaecictuhrearcipeosinitne,d oorut obmyiscsoiuonnsselfrfoomr ,oththeer respondents or are apparent from the record. Dated: April 2, 1943. A lbeorft CLo.uWnsoell.fe, GAuyttoGrneeoyrgfeorGRaebsrpioelnsdoenn,ts, NoCrorimstpoawnny, Manadgnesia & Asbestos Sail Mountain Company. REPRODUCED AT THE NAT IONAL ARCHI VES