Document Rjaxd6VNZjB8dDL1ZE7eXG90V
September 22, 2023
Comments for Annex XV Restriction Report on the Manufacture, Placing on the Market and Use of PFASs; Evidence for Question 3: Emission in the EndofLife Phase.
Submitted via the webform made available by the European Chemicals Agency at https://comments.echa.europa.eu/comments_cms/AnnexXVRestrictionDossier.aspx? RObjectId=0b0236e1885e69de
This information is submitted on behalf of the American Chemistry Council's (ACC) Performance Fluoropolymer Partnership (hereafter "PFP"), whose members include the world's leading manufacturers, processors, and users of fluoropolymers, including fluoroplastics, fluoroelastomers and perfluoropolyether polymers.1 The PFP's mission is to promote the responsible production, use, and management of fluoropolymers. We invest in research to support our mission and inform a scientifically sound, riskbased approach to regulation.
This submission provides an updated schedule to the data generation described in our submission on June 2, 2023 (ID# 9823e8c96f2f4973807d77dfcba3dc2b). Continued interest in rigorous sampling and analytical methods has led to refining benchscale reactor design in order to provide sufficient exhaust flow to enable PFAS detection limits on the order of 1 nanogram per dry standard cubic meter. The breadth of analytical results will provide important insights into the fate of fluoropolymers in municipal wastetoenergy plants and inform the need for regulatory action based on questions about the incineration of fluoropolymers at the end of their service life. The objectives of this study are:
1. Determine sampling and analytical techniques necessary to measure full mass balance on organic fluorine across a combustion system and achieve tracelevel detection limits for C4 C14 perfluorocarboxylic acids (PFCAs), C4 C12 perfluorosulfonic acids (PFSAs), and trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) at benchscale exhaust gas flow rates.
2. Identify, minimize, and monitor sources of external PFAS contamination. 3. Evaluate the generation of nonpolymer PFAS and other products of incomplete combustion
from the combustion of commercial fluoropolymers under conditions representative of full scale municipal wastetoenergy plants in the EU and US.
The PFP has developed the following timeline for achieving these objectives: No. Task
1 Design impinger system for efficient halide collection to enable benchscale mass balance determinations.
2 Develop experimental plan for operating bench-scale reactor system.
1 https://fluoropolymerpartnership.com/
700 2nd Street, NE Washington, DC 20002, USA
Completion Date 3 Nov 2023 1 Dec 2023
1
Performance Fluoropolymer Partnership Comments on Emission in End-of-Life --Annex XV Restriction Report I September 22, 2023
Page 2 of 2
3 Develop GC-MS method to determine Ci - C4 fluorocarbons in exhaust 5 Jan 2024
gas.
4 Share Quality Assurance Project Plan with USEPA technical staff for
2 Feb 2024
review.
5 Conduct process hazards review of design for integrated reactor system 1 Mar 2024
and revise system design based on results of review.
6 Revise Quality Assurance Project Plan based on feedback from USEPA. 15 Mar 2024
7 Characterize elemental composition and thermogravimetric behavior of 19 Apr 2024
fluoropolymer test material(s).
8 Test capability of key components of reactor system to meet design
3 May 2024
criteria for inherently safer operation.
9 Fabricate and assemble integrated bench-scale reactor system.
7 Jun 2024
10 Conduct preliminary testing to test stable operation of integrated
2 Aug 2024
bench-scale reactor system at conditions representative of full scale,
perform calibrations, and develop detailed operating plans.
11 Demonstrate measurement capabilities of FTIR (HF, COF2, SiF4) and
16 Aug 2024
continuous gas analyzer (O2, CO2, CO, NOx).
12 Evaluate background PFAS and fluorine contamination of key
4 Oct 2024
components of integrated reactor system.
13 Assess fluorine transport efficiency across reactor system via mass
18 Oct 2024
balance.
14 Under conditions representative of full-scale municipal waste-to-energy 28 Feb 2025
plants in the EU and US, conduct fluoropolymer combustion
experiments to determine levels of C4 - C14 PFCAs, C4 - C12 PFSAs, other
Method 1633 analytes, TFA, C1- C4 fluorocarbons, and fluoride ion in
exhaust gas.
15 Conduct independent review of experimental results to verify the data 28 Mar 2025
were generated in accordance with the Quality Assurance Project Plan,
evaluate blanks to assess external contamination, and validate data
quality.
16 Document experimental program methods, results, and conclusions in 23 May 2025
comprehensive report.
17 Review comprehensive study report with stakeholders.
20 June 2025
18 Submit final study report to European Chemicals Agency and USEPA.
11July 2025
Sincerely,
Jay West Executive Director Performance Fluoropolymer Partnership
AmericanChemistry.com
2
700 2nd Street, NE Washington, DC 20002, USA