Document RaQ46k4mKobRe9E5BBDaxNakk

' Government : Federal Alert-- new legislation High-dose inhalation cancer tests suggested A new study conducted by and for the federal government concludes that inhaling a single large dose of a known carcinogen can cause cancer in one species oflaboratory animal. The report goes so far as to suggest that short-term, high-dose laboratory studies of other known carcinogens "may be appropriate for government and private researchers." Conducted for the Consumer Product Safety Commission, the $700,000 research project examined the effects on rodents of inhaling doses as high as 50,000 ppm of vinyl chloride, a known liver carcinogen. Previously, most inhalation-based carcinogenicity studies with animals have involved comparatively small doses of chemicals given routinely over relatively long periods of time. The current study was performed by Dr. Bernard McNamara and co workers at the Chemical Systems Laboratory at the U.S. Army Aber deen Proving Grounds in Maryland. Started in 1975, the vinyl chloride study exposed groups of mice and rats to single one-hour doses of vinyl chloride gas in air of 50,000,5000,500, 50, and 0 (controls) ppm. In addition, other groups of tne rodents were given 10 one-hour exposures to 500 ppm vinyl chloride five days per week for two weeks. Yet another group of the animals received 100 one-hour exposures to the chemical at 50 ppm, five days per week for 20 weeks. All were then kept in cages for the re mainder of their lives, usually about two years. A reproduction study conducted simultaneously, however, failed to detect any mutagenic or carcinogenic effects in succeeding generations of rodents whose forebears had been exposed to vinyl chloride vapors. But the carcinogenicity study, particularly the single-exposure ex periments, seems to be the focus of study. Several important points arose from the study. For example, only mice and not rats demonstrated any carcinogenic effects from one expo sure to vinyl chloride. And the sin- gle-duse experiments produced only adenomas, or benign tumors, gener ally at the highest single-dose levels, virtually all of which subsequently failed to progress to carcinomas, or malignant tumors. Moreover, and perhaps more im portant. the report notes that pneu monitis, a condition of acute, local ized lung inflammation, "was evident in all animal (mice) groups exposed to vinyl chloride in doses of 500 ppm or more." Most toxicologists believe that a dose of a chemical that makes an animal acutely ill should not be used in a carcinogenicity study because it can produce results unrelated to a compound's cancer-inducing poten tial. Specifically, the study found that nearly 33% of the mice exposed to 50,000 ppm of vinyl chloride for one hour developed adenomas of the lung; about 17% of the mice exposed to 5000 ppm also developed adenomas; at 500 ppm 13%, and at 50 ppm 10.1%. By contrast, 10.0% of tne animals used as controls (no exposure) de veloped adenomas. Progression to carcinoma, the re port notes, "was minimal" among the mice. Only three of the 137 mice (2.2%) exposed to 50,000 ppm of the plastic monomer later developed carcinoma of the lung. At lesser doses a barely perceptible increase in car cinomas was found. For example, at the next lowest dose of 5000 ppm of vinyl chloride for one hour, one mouse out of 143 (0.7%) eventually devel oped a pulmonary carcinoma. All of which leads to skepticism among industrial toxicologists. Dow Chemical toxicologist Peny Gehring, for instance, say's that because of the high level of pneumonitis among the test mice, "the relevance of the results is highly questionable." He notes, too, that only mice and not rats were af fected by the vinyl chloride exposure. "Adenomas in the lungs of mice," Gehring says, "have a very high spontaneous background," particu larly when the mice are in physiolog ically stressful situations such as nearly being anesthetized by vinyl chloride gas. Yet the Consumer Product Safety Commission in releasing the study concludes that its "findings further support the thesis that a single ex posure to a high dose of vinyl chloride, or perhaps other similarly acting carcinogens, could pose a risk of can cer to humans." Dow's Gehring ob serves that long before viny'l chloride was recognized as a liver carcinogen in the early 1970's, "we knew that 3000 ppin or higher levels were not uncommon-- we -h*:i!cl have tumors all over the place |n >w.|" . i ms yatciy report lists new leg- \ islation introduced between! . March 19 and April 25. Senate and House bills are listed under} areas of interest by bill number, { primary sponsor, and the com- - : mittee(s) to which it has been re- i : ferred. . " :1 SENATE . rr; ; Energy. S. 857, 858. 859--Hart (D.-Coki.g * : Provide tax credit for oil produced from 1 I shale, regulate surface mining of oil shale, 1 Vs** environmental standards for oil shale} j. operations; referred to Finance. Environment j ;& Public Works, Energy & Natural Re-i sources. ' Nudear. S- 742--Percy (R.-III.). Sets iy> new3 federal panels to coordinate nudear waste i ' management pro-ams. details procadures i for state participation in decisions on siting > I of such waste repositories; held at desk.;-- j : S. 797--Jackson (D.-Wash.).'Allow* Oe^i ' partment of Energy to take tMs to spent.; t commercial reactor fuel, construct facilities I for its storage; referred to Energy A Natural. | Resources.* . . S. 798--Hart (O.-Coto.).- Sets t*j NudeW'i , Regulatory Commission licensing proce- < dwes tor away-from-reector storage of spent1 ' fuel; referred to Environment & Public ; . Works * .. j ; S- 926--McGovern (D.-S.D.). Suspends lor - three years granting of luttxe nudear power t plant operating licenses, pending review of i , existing, potential salety delects: referred to : : Environment A Public Works. RAD. S, 700--Danfortn (R.-Mo.). Gives , ; corporations a 10% tax credit for every; doilar spent on RAD; referred to Finance. i- - -;! - HOUSE - - - : - . - : Energy. Hfl. 3749--Mwphy (D.-N.Y.). Sets < federal standards tor siting, construction, ,i ' operation of liquefied gas fscMe* in or near i the coastal zone; referred to Merchant Ma-' . rine A Fisheries. Interstate A Foreign Com- i l merce. _ ; Environment H.R. 3247--Hance (D.-Tex.M Allows federal pre-emption of state taws . building of fie crude oil pipeline by : Sohio between Long Beach, CafiL. and I l Midland. Tex.; referred to interior A Insular Affairs, Interstat# A Foreign Commerce. - Heelth. HJt. 3132--Holttman (O.-N.Y.gt Establishes interim occupetional salety,' health standards to protect employe** from f nonionizing rsdiatmn; referred to Education A Labor. HR. 3566--Hammerschmidt (R-Ark.L Ex- tends moratorium on possible saccharin ban by FDA from 18 to 36 month*; referred to Interstate A Foreign Commerce. Nuclear. H.R. 3283--Atkinson (O -Pa l. Prohibits utilities from passing on repair costs and cost of buyino substitute power when nuclear power plan: is shut down lor salety reasons: referred to lm*rstate A For. eign Commerce 3 AjPkP'.jlMtiC* 14 C&SN May 7. 1979 UCC 006552