Document RQZxpjYw11X9nRxaeqYv6Or7
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT
f AL-1288
1
Drastic Cut in Asbestos Exposure Urged Centex Unit Awarded Johnson
By Federal Agency for 250,000 Workers $19.1 Million Contract Disclose
By Sail Bronson
For VA Hospital Jqb
However, whan the British plant was res-
.r > 1
Of Antii
*(// Reporter of Th* VaixStust Journal
Federal researchen are urging a- drastic
reduction In the occupational exposure ot
man than 250,000 workers' to asbestos, a
fcpeWB carclnogan, to aqo-tenth ot the cur-
Mpt federal ttandard. Gbrdnogena are can
cer prOduclnjf'oi^hMtthig agents.
In an unpqbltebftd report, the National In-
uStttm* for. Occupational Safety and Health
ncommsrai that worker exposure to air-
boms nbatmar be. limbed to 100,000 fibers
per M alr.ta eight hours. In ad
dition; ttwMMfuttkM'Want peak concentra
tions of eacpmififrklarted to (00,000 fibers
per cure
Raae^ on lft-mlmite
l- .Current
. standards limit asbestos
co taro cnilllasrnjSm'jNff ctibtfc meter at air.
This standanf was pfomulgatdd By the Oc
cupational Safety and Health Administration
in 1(72, at Which time Industry was given
four years to comply. Plants were required
tudled In 1972. 11 was found that there was a
greater Incidence of asbeNtoats than the
British standard warranted. In fact,
at
the workers exposed for 10 years to It years
had some kind of chest abnormality, and the
rale of abnormalities Increased with the
rate of asbesloe exposure.
Other studies show an Increased mortal
By < Wall Strict JoCRRa-L Staff Reporter
DALLAS-Cemex Oorp. said Us J. W.
flv a Waia 8+st
Bateson Co. unit was awarded a contract of' WASHINOTOft
(19.1 million lor the seoond phase construc closed that the I
tion of a 400-bed replacement hospital at the Veterans Administration Hospital tn Colum bia, S.C.
Centex said Bateson s work will be per
has been Invest^ -medlcaHsappy b.
' 'The' New
ity rate from cancer among workers ex formed by Its subsidiary. Cardinal.Contract `made the dlscloe
posed to asbestos, says John Dement, an In ing Co., the concern that Is currently per -statement It tile,
stitute industrial hygienist. A British study forming the initial construction work, .
`^xchsipge Comm,
published this year showed that workers ex
'inth rmmuno-Sd.
GM Agrees toposed, to asbestos from 1933 to 1950 had 1.8
timys as 'much chance of contracting lung cancer as the expected number of cancer
son said that the. "Comprehensive tefth an btyeafigx'
LeadrExposUteDtitcdicases in the general population. Mr. Dement
adds that British secientists found that In
JWinson A Jphru
workers employed up to IS years beyond
wx, ^^Thow tohif.ltieTnve
To1950, during a period when industry Im
proved Its engineering controls and technol ogy for plant environment, the excess can
nstittytei %hal The'butcom A* M- bald'in Its ?SC s
cer case statistics continued to show up.
to set p Improved ventilation systems! In the interim period, an "emergency" expo sure standard remained in force after it was set by OSHA under pressure from the AFL-
CIO. The institute recommendations In 1072 to
OSHA were well below those actually car ried out. "`Our 1972 recommendations were designed to protect workers from asbesUnls. or chronic lung disease," says Vame rose,
tfiptitute director for criteria documentation, S'Uiqt, gig. necessarily-tram-eaneef. We are
k*\ow *ugvmtlngltM.'lea>t detectable fccpow* level-In the-Workplace. Th< reason is (gpt -we deb t knc&.wtiat could possibly bwa
`Excess of Cancer Risk'
By a Wi.i.Stkcit JocXNAL 8f//Brvor<sT
In a South Dakota gold-mine study pub
WASHINGTON - General Motors Carp,
lished this year, researchers found that the notified a federal occiqiational TiealLh
440 workers had three times as many cases agency that it will furnish many of the rec
of respiratory disease as expected, based on ords on worker exposure to lead that the
the stale mortality rates. These workers agency had threatened to subpoena. -
were exposed to less than 250.000 fibers per
The National Institute for Occupational
cubic meter In eight hours.
Safety and Health said GM's medical direc
"We re saying reduce exposures Uo as tor, Dr Robert C. Welncek. notified the
bestos) to a bare minimum because we agency that the data would be made avail
can't tell you how low you have to go to able af a meeting-next month. "We are oon-
eHliimnuinnaatiea
aa ocaanncceerr..nrlustk*." s*a>y'i MJ*irr
Duveomeeiniut
1
fitinU
Utbt thc
v- i
d^titw-hich will
. t -*
...
be
,
submitted
. *
All studies have shown an excess ofcancer*} wtf reflect.giramneem with employe healtii
risk at aU levels of exposure lo asbestos." The reason for aSRAraevaluating the
.. .
a. rftL. k. tfe*.` t5y.^Y*M* /of^f,nt*stdoantaly'
a fair and the letter
obde-
-V-.
safe level of exposure over the working life bestos standard stems from a 1974 suit by * c are"
time without adverse health effects." :
the AFL-CIO's Industrial union drpartpient
^t^fhai QwMy i>onrt--teS ;*
. ' against the Department of .Labor cornplaln-
Federal officials hope- the GM records, which go back more than 20 years, will help
!*' The isfriaL yisnty of- tiny asbeptos fSberaff ing about several boinlaln the11972 exposure. } fRetia8gvifc. the kg*!l#' well docamenled. Standard. The-. -^FL-pIO petitioned fair
It the exposure to asbetce dust in the work changes to be made fit tha'jequlned medical
place Is slashed. Industries that use the ma records that employers maintain on work-
terial such as construction and oil refining, era. and a requested that the timetable fur may come under increased pressure to sub lowering asbestos . exposure . limits*-, he
stitute nontoxic materials. Asbestos is used stepped up.
in fireproof textiles, shingle Insulation, and
The federal cqurl of appeal* in WR-shing-
thermal piping, among other products.
ton, D.C.. directed DOHA to reconsider those
"It's not possible to establish a safe expo two provisions of the standard At that time,
sure level for thy carcinogenic activity of aw the entorcemerit agency decided the stan
bestoa,"' says 2&- John F. Rhklea, director dard possibly wasn't protec tive enough at
ft tbe^nstitute^i^betsfore, emphasis Wxxild asbestos workers''health and |t decided lb
he piiced oh prohibits the occupational repropose tbie `entire standard! beyond the
nee of esbettgfjin -wtber (has completely court directive/says an.BfiHAjipakesmati.
closed operations, and on substituting other
OflHA enlisted the aid of the National In
determine whether there ts a relationship between lead levels In workplace air and lead levels found fa workers' blood. TVe rec ords involve GM's Munde. Ind., DelepRemy lead battery plant. In late November." Institute offibtaJs .saNUhey were considering subpoenaing thr-crecords because GM had., declined io mak^fthenj available.
Tte rnmpany stud K would furnish monlii'i ing tlnta from tfffi ti> 1978. os well as a study of women employed al the plant from 1972 to 1975. It also agreed to discuss sub-, mission of the earlier data. GM added that it would explain numerous factors which !' li.mil the use" of the data in conducting the study the institute has in mind.
products whenever poestble."
stitute for Occupational Safety and Health in
Tttf 49ff -tMfitytf iwoommengatMnd on the re-yyaluialion to study dtw research de
Coal-Burning Capability
aibestotM OSfU Were baaed tiyiert da the velopments and j|xplore advances In protec
research H Ugfrfottete. Oca#ational
tive technology'as they related.to asbestos
Ordered for New Utilities
Who* flocietyr WhKh evaluated 3 workers exposure. f*The OSHA Spokesman said the
WyaU
Jotknal 8**ft Reporter
la an asbestara factory. Based on that work, agency will hold public hearings early next
WASHINGTON - The Federal En-'
the Institute concluded that a two-mi!lion-fi year on proposed, revised standards before
erery AdmltUslraUon Intends to require
bers limit would prevent asbestosla.
promulgating the final rule.
20 proposed eleclnc utility plants to be
built with the capability to bum coal.
The latest EEA orders ure part otfa
Jacquin Aides Fined Pacific Options
federal pruran^ to require utilitJei to burn abundant ` roul, rather than the
For IS1 ot Assisting SEC Liquor Inquiry
Octen 1 RorftAm
BonkAm BonkAm
Cf l* 0 O SAom
Otvtov Dtvwv 0*tnv
orko
Zi .
41 M
40
4W3V-.
- j-m - - Ac* - - AJ - n y
Voi LObl Voi Lost Vot Lost Ckar
5 r * i
sv>
5 >H
4`* w*.
1 vt a* i
1
2m
44Vd
60 m yru
2* n u
5 U>-4
jIvt
a 4bis d 46*4
niore-acarce supplies of oil and natural
Ka.. to penenfr electricity The agency
already has Hnnoinred Its inlenUon to
order 122 other r>r<`vposed power plants
lo burn coal, -mo ba-s required 74
inp plants to convert tn coal from oli an*I l'Ji.s
If .ill the f-XA orders xire carried
)1' tKki i LaxOt. ./* * >- , -1-|
in<'rP'4!RP