Document RGy4r57Gx52wQpN8GKn22gyX
PCCoFosOstSt--bboeennnerefefiipttraaonndaaullcyytssiiiossnoofifnrreqeuppaeiealat.tiinngg tthhee cchhrroonniicc ssttuuddyy ooff tthhee ppootteennttiiaall eeffffeeccttss ooff
PFOS on reproduction in quail.
IoInnbsttheherevpperrdeevvaiitoouutsshlleyy clceooannsddtuudcctoteesdde ssittnuuddtyyh,,o ttdhhaeeteexx(p1pe0erriimmmgeeknngtt)aa,ll ddpeersseiicgglnnudaaanndddattchhceeurffaaatctet ttahhsaasttissgoonmmmeeenteeqqouufiivvaooccaNalloeefOfffbeescctetssnawweberlreee:
AAcoodbdnvsvjeeeurrrnvssceeetdioEEnfafffteewcctihtthsse CCkloenonaoncswcotenntdnrotsrasaleetiionoinnns((tiNhNeOOArAdaEEniCegC)et.s).,(10aRRnmeedssguu/ulklltngssc)e,oorfftpattrheihenocyluppdrfreeaocdvvtiioooaruuscssclfyyuorcacdooteennlddeauumsccsitteiengddenmsstthueuenddtyypoowwftiilleal nbbNteeoebeevOvnaaebllfusuieaattrtseveaddtbhaliientn
Gouldbegained by repsating the studya lesserconcentrattoiobotnaisn a NOAEC, conjunction with known sensitivity ranges, and uncertainty factors to determine the
could be gained by repeating the study at lesser concentrations to obtain a NOAEC.
potential
benefits
that
WWoorrkk pprroodduucctt
AAPFssOhhSoorrtcrrxeepspooosrruttrsseuummsmtmaurdaiyrizziiinnnggatdthhdeeippnootteeonnttiiaaall rbboeeunegefhfsits,s,iomoraltlaaecckkottfhheterhreeao,fc,offso!rr rrreeappneegaaettiinfnoggr ttthhheee qqsuutaauciily.cchhrrooTnnhiiecc
oaaPfnnFataOhllyySssitissherxwweipsilollhlsoppulrrdreeessNeesOnnttAut dEtthyhLeewinlleiikrkeaeldyydfoieitbfiofeeencmttaooonndaehthaereovauorigevahvibissleeeesd.dtimriiTsakhkteeaasgsorsfeseastethseesmstsecmnmotpsestafnicfrastaanwgmmoerourlefeodrbaaccethccoeuunrrasatGteeubdleeysas.titiimnmTiaahnatteege
ower of the
lower
NOAELthats not drivenbythe doses nthe experimental desian. threshold NOAEL were to be made available. The greatest impact
NOAEL that is not driven by the doses in the experimental design.
would
be
on
obtaining
a
AAssssuummppttiioonnss IInnffoorrmmaattiioonn nneeccesessarsytatoorddyoo tthhiiss aannaallyyssiiss sis ccuurrreennttlyy aavvaaiilaabblleeaatt tthhee EENNTTRRIIXofofffiiccee..
cost
Name Cost Rais Hours _Sublotal _Responsibiiies
JJNJoooahhhmnnneNGGeiiweesssyytod
$$SR1a7t22e75%5
Hours
3808
3$
Subtotal
52225000 2,200
ARRRseeesvvseeipeswowsrnoorsepoinpboeoriflrtitttise,sesicmosatrtangee, wi report
JPDDoaeeuhnnlniissJNeeoenKKweaassyyted
$ $ s5
175
310150
30
$ $ 5s
:- 5,250 Assess benefits, estimate cost range, write report
SSMPehhalaauiulusnnJsoaRRnSoeohasaorrtkkwell $$$$19211532050
$ $ ss
--
KeenSmyth $75 Melissa Shotwell $ 95
Karen Smyth
$ 75
5
5
$SS$ 347735075 AACddommiminnsmsuupuppponorirtt c(a9%toifolanbosr)
S$
$
8295470
8,295
Total estimated Communications
Total estimated
cost(6%
cost
of
labor)
SMMaadduee AAvtvaboaiPillraaobbjtlleeectbbeiyyve33MMOcrffdooertrIIInnnssppPeeccattliioomnneaavrnn.dd3CCM,ooppyNyoii.nnggC2aa.ss0CC4o-on6nf3ifid0de8enntitiaall IInnffoorrmmaatitioonn::
Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309
22110022..00000011
Exhibit 2102 MA02513752
3MA02513752
CCoosstt--bbeenneefifitt aannaallyyssiissooffkkeessttrreell cchhrroonniicc ffeeeeddiinngg ssttuuddyy
oBBfaassseepaddcooenns.tthheeHiionnwffeoovrrmemraa,ttiioosnninaacvvaaaiitllahabbelleequninaltthhaeenlIditteemrraaattluulrraee,r,dtthhaeeretthnhroertsehtsoolhpd cffooarrmeevfofffreeecctstss,ssebeueetmmsesatttoo sbbeeeessdii,mmiilvaaerrgeiinntaaatinnouunmmabbneedrr
iaoinndfvvdeestrpritteoeencbbarirealastte.sesps,a,Hcaaoennws,aaemmvsoeounr,ncghg:s-siasnppsceeecaciiteethsosepuuqnpnucrceeaerdilrtattaaaoiinrnnd,ttyyfamafnacactaltolaorrrrgiduissmaeuurnsseeteddncooiitnultirodisspkkbecaaassmrssnaeeisdvssoesmrmeetnesot,nrstsb.e.udtuIIcffeeddaaatottrasaeewweleiedrmsries,naaavtveveaagiitelaahtbaebltlieaeonmffooorrannaagdnn
saasppndeeddccitiaiieoepsnsplauuilnenscdcepereurtnctaaciieeinnsrttt,yyasiffuanatccctyhtoorfra..asctEEaoNNrstTToRpRoIIXpXdreewwtdiiellalrtccomooir,nnndedauunctchtateraagpnnuotmaaennneatalnilayytlssciiossbueoolndffettfbhhieeesccmtuuoarrdrbreeeennttglotyairkkennndeooudwwcfnnerssooppmreeeccciloiieemnssdinusscaeattneinsntisgthivieaityyacmhrraaornnnogggnee-
feeding study with a top and applied uncertainty
feeding study with a top
predator such as kesirel factors to determine the
predator such as kestrel.
potential
benefits
to
be
gained
from
conducting
a
chronic
WoAWrsohkrokrptprrrooedpduourctcttsummarizing the potential bens, of lack tharco, fo conducting a kestrel chronic
PFOS exposure study in additon to a rough estimate of the cost range for the study A short report summarizing the potential benefits, or lack thereof, for conducting a kestrel
PFOS exposure study in addition to a rough estimate of the cost range for the study.
chronic
AAInssfssourummmaptptitioinoonnnssecessary to do tis analysis i currently avaliablea the ENTRIX offic.
Information necessary to do this analysis is currently available at the ENTRIX office.
cost NJNaoamhmen.eGiesy JJJDoooehhnmnninsNGNeeeiKwewasssyytteedd PDaeunlisJeonKeasy SSMPehhaiauasluusnJnoaRRnoSeoahsaorrtkkwell KaenSmy Melissa Shotwell
Karen Smyth
Rats
S$$R1a7t22e7555
ss$$ 1111575500
$S$$ 18211532050
S$s
$
7595
75
HHoouurss SSuubbttoottaall _
288 0S$5 232,522000000
20
$ $ ss
3,500
--
$ $ ss
:.- -
55 $$5S363357755-
S$ 6434650
$
6,440
RReessppoonnsisbibililiitiieess ARRseesvveiieeswwsrbreeepnpoeorfrttts, estimate cost range, wie report
Assess benefits, estimate cost range, write report
AACoddmmmmiiunnnsisuucppaptpoiootrtns
_ (6%of
aban)
TTCooottmaallmeeussnttiiicmmaaatittoeendds cc(6oo%sstt of labor)
`MMSauabddjeeecAAtvvtaaoiillPaarbbollteeebbcyiyv33eMMOrffodorerrIInnIssnppPeecactltiimooennraavnn.dd3CCMo,oppyNyoii.nnggC2aa.ss0CC4o-on6nf3ifid0de9enntitiaall IInnffoorrmmaattiioonn:
Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309
22110022..00000022
3 IMAG2513753
3MA02513753
CCoosstt--bbeenneefifitt aannaallyyssiissoofef egggg iinnjjeeccttiioonn ssttuuddyy AiAnnnjooettchhteeorrn pspotosussdsiyibvwiiliiltyyh ii5no n aadd&ddr biittiioornn sttopo,e,cooiersss.eeppTaahrriaastteestffuroodmmy,w, ottuhhkeeicchihrnrooclnnuiicdceffeqeeueaddiiinnaggnssdutudmdlieeass ddliifsscoculrucssossameepddaraarbbioosdvoveen,, 0iisseaaxnnisteeiggnggg dsdinpaajetetacacitieaaosllno-onsnseggtnusdwwiyiiitthvwhiityaahdddd5dsiittotiioorbnn6uaatlbloirnssd,ppesencpciieieeccssihecssso.uuuccThlhhdiaabsssestkkuueedsssyettdrrweetlosloulboodrvr iinbbcaaaleludddteeehaaeqggunllaeeesisl.c.anfdoFFrrrmoaommamollnatthgrhdi:isssfopdderaactctaiaoemswwpeesareccisooonuunlsddtoiddeeefxrraiivsvcteeoinrgaas ai together for bids. species-sensitivity distribution, which could be used to obviate the need for among-species sensitivity factors
all together for birds.
Workproduct AAiWsnfshoehorckotrirtpotnrrroeesppdtouourdrcttytssiuunmmammadrairdizziiinnggotatthhieerooppuootgnteehnnteitiaallsbbeentnefeoiffititssf,,hmoorcrlolaaascctkkattthnheegerreeeoofff,,orffoohrreccoosnnuddcuuyc.cttiinnggaaPPFFOOSS eegggg
injection study in addition to a rough estimate of the cost range for the study.
AAInssfssouurmmmaptptitioinoonnnssecesstaordyo this analysis s curren avelabe a the ENTRIX office.
Information necessary to do this analysis is currently available at the ENTRIX office.
cost
Name Cost Rate Hours Subtotal _ Responsibiities _
JJJNoooahhhmnnneNGGeiiweesssyyted
SS$ R1a7t22e75%5
Hours
2808
$ 35
Subtotal
3225000 2,200
AsRRRseeeevvseispewoswrnboerspeniopbeoriflrtitttsie,sestimate
cost
range,
wre
report
JDPDoaeehunnlnissJNeeoKenKwaeassyyted
55$$ 11117553500s 20 $$ss
3,500
s:-
Assess benefits, estimate cost range, write report
SMSPehhalaauiulusnJnsoaRRnoSeoahsaorrtkkwell 3$$$ 91115322500
s$ $ s
--- -
KaenSmyth Melissa Shotwell
Karen Smyth
S75 $ 95
$ 75
5
5
$$SS33853575- AACoddmmmmiiunnnssiuucppapptooirrottns (8%of labor)
S$
$
6440365
6,440
Total estimated Communications
Total estimated
cost(6%
cost
of
labor)
SMMaadduee AAvtvaboaiPillraaobbjtlleeectbbeiyyve33MMOcrffdooertrIIInnnssppPeeccattliioomnneaavrnn.dd3CCMo,oppyNyoii.nnggC2aa.ss0CC4o-on6nf3ifid0de8enntitiaall IInnffoorrmmaatitioonn::
Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309
22110022..00000033
4 I3MMAA00Z2551133775544
CChhiirroonnoommuuss tteennttaannss ttooxxiicciittyy tteesstt tT"hThhee odarnnieevesssttuutddhyye tthvhaaatltuiiesssppucuabblllciisushlheaedtdediinn fttohhreewelaitrteaeratrtuuqrureealoiotnny CCcrhhliilreoornna.oommuuBssecfteaannuttsaaennsshrreeeppvooarrtltsueaa Ivvseerrmyyulcloohww ltthohrwreeessrhhootlhlddanvvaatllhuuaeet to"ohTbbhassitseerrwdvvirelievddehsffoorarthooaettgvhhrveeearrelaussteppseebccaciineaeosl,f,ctuiitltnaiitsserdelkikdeeufloclyyir nttwhghaaautttneiicffrattrhqhaeueiatntleeittssyytt iciinssrietrrceeeorppliaeeo.agaitteceBaddleuucrinansdudkesearersGGstLheLPesP.s, vmttaehhlnaautttestthfhiseoermvvaaaqululucuaheetssilcowwiwiillnlevbrbeeerthiggbarrrneeaaatttetehesra.r..t TImIffehssaisuusccwuhhrilleaahsattetevsasetnt daiiassgrccdreoonaendctduoubclcetotnegeeiddfc,,italiiittn-mrmreueulsdsetutvcaiiinnnnctgcllueuudndnedecpeotthrihteneatinsss,taaymmsineeuceeehcnnodadlpsopogoisiincunrtatvsslivrmmiaselke,aaasgssurusroreeewsddtshmiinnaenttnhdhteserfeppoprrrereaovvdiqiououucuaststiicossnttiunud(dvyfyerrtataeinnblddyraaataellnsssdoo. ffameescceuuainnnsdiduttirhytey)e)..ssteaIIdnnnidmaaaeddnrdddti.otioenAnc,L,oliiyot goWwiuocouraullrllddye-qbrbeueeleeuusvstae,snfEut NleettTonoRdmfmIpeoXeauhianssatusulsr,reiesnuPPtcFFihOaOeaSSdsctcosohnunecrscveeeinvnta(trrloa,axttigiiocornonwiilntnehsbbtooasttnhhidntthhrceeeopnoorvuvoeednrrucllycyiiitoninonggnwwwia(afttetheerrtrWili2atiy6sfwwaaeneldlll
as in the sediment. At your request, ENTRIX has initiated these toxicity tests in conjunction with Wildlife
International. ENTRI will desiqn the experiments in conjunction with Wildlife International, arrange to have
`menbausedsoncferrepsul!ls. these studies to be conducted,
manuscript based on the results.
oversee
the
studies,
interpret
the
results,
and
prepare
a
report
and
Workproduct
IaIWnnniitdtoiiaraklal ipinmtrtaoeenrrduppusrrcecarttatitapiottnntoooffbetthheseurrbeemssiuutlltestdpprfroeersseepnnuttbeeldidcavvteeirrobbnaalliylyn..thFeFiinnpaaellerww-irritattvoeinnowrreeedpp,oorrottpbbeaansseletdderooanntutrtheheethrraeetssuuwllittsls
acccoononmdmcpplaauarsrmieeoaaannsnnuddosfcccroo"inpcnlottrrraatrossettcbtttehthehserrueebIssmfuuellirtttstasetwwduioitt.fhhotrthhpeeupprbrelievcvaiiotoiuousnsllyyinpputuhbbelliissphheeeeddrw-wroeorvrkiketwtooeeedti,thheoerprcecononnlfiftiiermratttuhhree
previous. that will
previous
conclusions or "correct" the literature.
AAWissdssiuufmmopptItniitooennrnssational wil conduct the n-fe phofathesstuedy andprovide al aboratory reports,
W aaasnnisddldoclddiifoeoacctuIuenmdmteeenwrnitntaatahttitioicoonhnnaeml ttiwoocialElElNcNToaTRnnRIadXlIuXy.cs.tisthTTwehhileelinW bW-loifiieldpflprifeohevaisIIdnenettedoerfrsnnetahaptteiaoornnsaaattulel dlppyyooraorttnsiiodondnpeorocofsfvittihodhneeesassalttluruldedayybmoaaarnnadddteoraayrnreryygeapcrcoodorsisttnstssg,
atthhhsreesooummcgoiohassttetodnaapepwpoprirftoohptprhcrieihaaiettreemcaaiocppnapptlrraooacaantccahhll.ya.sbios33raMMwtoilmrml iabaeysey wdwpiirirsosehhvcidttt.oeodaarrEsrreaNapnTngagRereIaXtffeoolrcryattnhahesealadasnenoacayilmsytaitocicknaaelsl tasshuureeppsppmeoorarattdrrieinnattnreeegrmegnamaalerlllndyytinsoog.fr
tanahonnrtddoiuppngaachylyuodffoonerrecttohhoseeftastanhnoaefalirlyaynscsaeoelsnyswttriwiacticathhltnolnaroobfoommrraaWartkroik-r-uifuepps.e. dITTirehhnceettlcyceo.ossrttEneeNsasTtttitiRmomicIaaXottoeencndaiissunacfflooarrlshEEoeNNmTTfRsaRtIk.IeXX
tasks these
tasks
only and oes. arrangements
only and does
not include costs of analytical or for Wildlife International to conduct the test.
cCoosstt NJNoaanmmneeGiesy JDJJooeohhnminnNsGNeeweiKewsastsyyteedd SPDPahaeuaunlluisJJneooRnnKoeeaassyrk MKSMeohelralsieussnasaaSSRmhSoyohattorhvktwelelll
Karen Smyth
SRRaatt2ee75 $$$s 172117575550 $s 11530 $$121305 $$S715892550
$ 75
HHoo2uu4rrss 3 SSuubbttoot6taa8ll00
4524
45
$
6,600
$s 7875; $
7,875
s$
.
s$
-
1110 60SS$$ 1929550000
16 $S991,2800
$$
$
17623998
17,623
_DRRaeetssappaoonnnaslsyiisbbiiislfi,tiieoepssortroviow DDDeeasstiaiggnan,n, aoolvyveserirsss,iiggrhehttp,dodaratttraaeavanineaawllyyssiiss, rreeppoorrtt wwrriitinngg TATadabmblileenaasnnuddppffioigrguutrree pprreepp TACCoodotmmmamlimunenussinutcipicampataotiitorotenndss c((6o6%s%tooff blaobror])
Total estimated cost
`MMaaddSee AAvuvtaoaiiPllbaarbbollteejecbbiyyve33eMOMrcffdooerrrtIIInnnssppPeeccattliioomnneavarnn.dd3CCMo,oppyNyoii.nnggC2aa.ss0CC4o-on6nf3ifid0de9enntitiaall IInnffoorrmmaattiioonn:
Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309
22110022..00000044
5
5
3MAG2513755
3MA02513755
WWhhiittee ppaappeerr oonn eeccoollooggiiccaall rriisskk aasssseessssmmeennttss ooff PPFFCCss iinncclluuddiinngg PPFFOOSS aannddPPFFOOAA "TcTohhmiisspawwrhihisittoeensppaawppieelrr bwweiilll mrraeedvvioieewwfeccguuarrrrtedennnttglyy appnuubbulliissshheecddoneecclcouolslooiggoiniccsaallcoirisnskckeaarssissneegsssspmmaeecnntttsssoofoff PPFPFCFCsCs.s., CeCovonantltruraaasstttossrsaannoddf cunocmerptaariinstoyn.sanwdildl abtea reporting made regarding various conclusions concerning impacts of PFCs, evaluations of
uncertainty, and data reporting.
Workproduct PPPWeFeeoeCrrrs-k-rrpeIevnrvcoiieldewuwudeeicddntglliPteerFraaOttSuurreeanppduubbPlliFiccOaaAtt.iioonn Tbbhaaesseedddocoounnmcceuunrrtreewnnittllyydppeuusbcblrliiissvhheeedtdheeeccaoolploopggriioccaaalclhrreiissskk aaanssdsseecssossnmmceleunnsttissonoosff dooPfofFcpCpurrseemvveiininooctuuluswsldilyyilngccgioovnnPeddFuuaOccSdtteiedsdacnuaadssssssPieeFossnOssAommf.eecnnuTtrtsshreeaannntdddosctiiuadtmeunsentniaftyndwmmiitllissetdtnaaedkksseecssra,,ibneudunnctpcherereotrtavaaipiinnpdtatriieeoessaicsaahknneaddsssddaaeantstdaascmggoeaanpnpscs.lb.uassiTToehhndees odnoctuhmemeonst twicllugrtiveentaidnfisocrumastsiioonn aonfdcusrcreinetnsttactauls vanaditrmeentdhsodasn.d provide a risk assessment based
on the most current information and scientifically valid methods.
Assumptions
APaPcusuabbsulluiiisfsmhehedpeddtbioyeenccEosoNllooTggRiiIccaaXll orrriissakkreaasosssteeessrsswmmiesenenttrssetatoodybbeeavrraeeivavibielewew.eedd
for
for
tis
this
white
white
paper
paper
have
have
afeady
already
been
been
acquired by ENTRIX or are otherwise readily available.
Cost Name Cost JJJNoooahhhmnnneGNGeieewsssyted JPDDoaeeuhnnlniissJNeeoenKKweaassyyted SSMPohhaiaausluunJsnoaRRnSoeohasaorrtkkwel KaenSmyth Melissa Shotwell
Karan Smyth
$RRaatt2ee5 $$$$11721077555 $$$$ 12111530505 $$$$78!255905
$ 75
HHoo6uu0rrss _ SSuubblot1oa6lt._a_5l00 RROevesesprposnoesneisbdiiballiilaittiiaeenssaes, view and mput for final dat
2226000005S$$$ 35313G50,7,055000000
WAWOsivrstietieersseppterwrimimdtaaahrtnaydaddamrnaaaahfnltyasliss,i,revdrieafwt
and input
review
for
final
draft
4222055 5S5$$
4333,,837307570505
AoAATsassibsssiilsstottwawwintiidtthhhidddgaaauittraaaeaaanpnnaeaalllpyyysssiiiss,,,
draftreview draft review
draft review
4333000 0S5$$ 22,2$,82,8855500000 ATLLidiattmebeirlreanattsuauurnrepedpssfoeiegraautrrrccehhprep
30 SS$$ 171242,,6122"351702 TACCodotommalimmneusmsnutiupicmpanaotitortiendsc(c(66oa%%stotofof laanbboosrr))
$
72,637 Total estimated cost
SMMaadduee AAvtvaboaiPillraaobbjtlleeectbbeiyyve33MMOcrffdooertrIIInnnssppPeeccattliioomnneaavrnn.dd3CCMo,oppyNyoii.nnggC2aa.ss0CC4o-on6nf3ifid0de8enntitiaall IInnffoorrmmaatitioonn::
Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309
22110022..00000055
5 IMA02513756
3MA02513756
WWhhiittee ppaappeerr oonn tthhee iimmppaaccttoofftthhee 22000000 pphhaassee oouuttooff PPFFOOSS
TeThrhiaisstuwwrhhieitteeonppaatphpeeerrcowwinlicllleniinlnrccallutudideoensaa ommfeePttaaFOaaSnnaalIlynyssitishseooeffnttvhhieereoexnxiimstetiinnnggtoppuaubsblsliiecclslyys aatvvhaaeiilaahbibsllteeoriddcaaattlaavfferronomdm pppreeee.err-a-rrneedvviiepewowseetdd:
22pli0th0e0a0r0s0a.e.t-uoreuIttmmso.anayythbTbeheeicsppooonspsscasiepidbnelltreeratowtoiiolniinnscrcleluoludfydeePoFccnOoommStphpaeiarnriPistshFooenOnssSenttoovaniooraottlhhnyeemtrrceaccnlhhteermtmoeisiccuaalasltlssssesildikskaeettahDDbeDDaTshTeisttthhotaahrltiacthhaaalEvvtNreeeTnuuRdnnIddXpeerrreghg-oaosnaneenadsslirmpmeioaiasldatry-r
ggopueehtnnaleesirneraae-dtoteeuaddtns.dffoorresT33tMhMa.ibslipTTsahhhepeedeeerixxniwisstitthlilinenggrfesddlytaattyaoaenaccraathnnoefbbheePsFeeOvvtaaaSlsluku.asattneeaEddlNyfftToiocRrraIluuXssreeweosiIununllttIdshNissadlarsretoaavvbiiiekaeweswefaaonnthpddraottthhpeeEosNwwehThitRittheeIaXtppaaahppalaesorrweaccrlaarennleavd0be8eyl
oeeafnufffntoolurirntatelbbdeeuapppnuuddtt effaoosrrtttttaohhbetdldhissuuerhriiewnnhdggilittnheheetphafefopoellfliororswwftiinnygogea33rvoo(tof0if t5t5heeiyysneedwtaasar.rsssk.ttoo
maintain a database of ENTRIX would also like
maintain a database of
PFOS snalyleal to propose that a
PFOS analytical
results lower
results
wihlevel
with
annual updates to the white paper review of trends.
WW orokrkpprroodduucctt
W eWhnhivititeeonppmaaeppneetrr baasasssseeesdsssioinnnggpttuhhbeelciilmmyppaaavccattilooaffblttheheep2e2o00r00-00roppvhhiaaossweeo-d-ooututotaootnnurttehh.ee ccRooennfccoerenentntrtraiatatiiloodnnassotoafbf aPPsFFeOOoSSf PiinnFOtthShe.e
eacanonnanavlcilyryetontiintccrmaaalletrrineotsnuobslatossfs3eadPsuFroroOnep,ploporurtstbealdidclyinntathhveeailrraeebvvliieeewwpeeedderel-irtreearvtaiueturweree..d
Annual update of trends of environmental literature. Referential database of PFOS
Annual update of trends of environmental
concentrations of PFOS.
AAssssuummppttiioonnss
TTinhhdeeivippduuubballliissshhaeemddplPPesFF.OOSS Rllaiftteehrreaartt,uurremeerraaarrneellyVyarlreeuppeoosrrttassnccdoonngcecenenentrtrraaalttiiosonanmsspalainnnddgssplpeoeccciafitfiiicconsssaamamrppeilinnmggorlloeoccaacttoiioomnnmssooonff
irrbneeedppeoiovnrritdtiiounnbaggtlammiseneatetmhhdoopddlfses.os..mTTphhRueebaltbbihcuuelrddy,ggaemevtaeppiarrlneeassbvleeeanntltueeeeddrsahhtoaeurnrreedeaagsasesnsnuduemmrfeaelsswsitthalhaamtnttpothtlhineegbdodaaltotnaaceacwwteiioilsllnssbbaeerayssreuutffoffmicaiiobeclrnieateianncastosfmutitmctchaoaennnr
`specific details been obtained
specific details
fromfrom
from
investigators. publicly available
investigators.
literature
and
it
will
not
be
necessary
to
obtain
further
Cost Yoar1 Cbuodsgtet NYaemareI budget JJJNoooahtmnnneNGGeiiweesssyyted JDoehninsNe eKwasyted PSDPahaeuaunlluisJJneooRnnKoeeaassyrk SMKMeaheaieliussnnssSaamRSSyoohtaowrhktewlelll
Karen Smyth
Rate $$S R1a7t22e7555 $S 117550 $$Ss 12111533005s $$$S971559250
$ 75
Hours 3Hours
_Sublotal__ 5 8260 Subtotal
ORRovesesprposonenseisdbibaitillatitiiaeonsaslysis, review and input for final dra
1143330000S$$|S
222628.,,072705550000
OIDIddaveetenpsrttsifbfeyyaesppodeearrdttiieaneseinangnttnaelliaytrensaridtasu,tmurrareeen,v,tiewwawirrinteeaennppdcrrieiimnmpaaruryyt
craft for final
draft
draft
40 $s
- 6,000 Data base design and maintainence
444000 $SS$$ 4843,8800000 TTLaiatbbellreeataaunnrded sffieigagururrceehpparrneodpp data entry
540 S$$ 33,785000 AdLimteirantusrueppsoeratrch and data entry
50
S$$S$
23.,795610 522,391611
ACTCodootmmamlimnemussnutuipicmpnaaotiitortoncds(ac(66ot%%stoioffoalanbboasr))
$
52,311 Total estimated cost
Annual ongoing budgot
`JANoNnahamnnmueeGa_ileosnygoing! buSdRRgaaett2tee15
Hours 24Hours
JJoohmnNGewiesstyed S$ 172755 DJoehnnisNseKwasyted~~ $ 11705
44230040
PSDPaaheuunailisnjJeooRnnKoeeaassyk
$S$$ 112311350550
30
8
MSehlasusnaSRhooatrwkell $$ 91520 485
KaeaSmyh Melissa Shotwell
Karen Smyth
S75 $ 95
$ 75
1545
15
_Sublotal_ Responsibilities.
53$ Subto667t.,a660l000000 RiRRdeeeovvsniiipeetowywnpaasenmirbnuiiualnialteilnueutpspdpdauaibtleeatons, draft annual update.
$
7,000
$s 4500- $
4,500
Databasedesign and maintanence Identify pertinent publications, draft annual update
Data base design and maintanence
$$$$ 4926790650 TLTiaacbbrllaeetaaurnneddsffieiggauurrrecehpparrneodpp data entry
$$1142,2575 ALditmeirantusruepspeoratrch and data entry
$$SST 26111.,,914422668588 TACCoodotmmmamlimunenussinutcipiacmpataoititoortenndss c((6o5%s%tooffilaabboorr))
$
25,928 Total estimated cost
`MMaaddSee AAvuvtaoaiiPllbaarbbollteejecbbiyyve33eMOMrcffdooerrrtIIInnnssppPeeccattliioomnneavarnn.dd3CCMo,oppyNyoii.nnggC2aa.ss0CC4o-on6nf3ifid0de9enntitiaall IInnffoorrmmaattiioonn:
Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309
22110022..00000066
7 7 33MMAAG022551133775577
MPMoanociinftiitoocrrrRRe&g&iDDonaanndd eennvviirroonnmmeennttaall iissssuueess aanndd iinniittiiaattiivvee iinnvvoollvviinngg PPFFCCss iinn tthhee AAssiiaa--
Pacific region
AAeltayytooounurshrreieqqpuuseeswstit,,thJJtoohhhennkGeGyiieslsayybohhraaasstriiinnoitasiatateenddd ttahgsiseneecfffifooerrtst..inTToAoswwiaaa.rrddIttnhiiissseennwdda,,y,wweewewwiiclllanccooannsttsiinunurueee totohataesstithaaebblisisschhiewwnecorerkktiihnnaggt
is done wil be ofthe highest quai. relationships with the key laboratories
is done will be of the highest quality.
and
agencies
in
Asia.
In this way, we can assure that the science that
WoWrorkk pprroodduucctt OrOerrpaaol rrrteeppuooprrottsns raaessquiiessssstuueeasss waaerlrrliveeasoomrrakiinniffnoogrrmmaalalttiipooonnrtbbeeencctoommdeoescsuamavevaanitillasabballeveaaiaannbddlepprtreeoppGaaMrr.ee qquuaarrtteerrllyy wwrriittteenn
reports upon request as well as making all pertinent documents available to 3M.
AAJosshssnuummGpiptetisioyonnwssil atend meetings and develop jin projects wih Chinese colieagues from whom
Jhfhoeeeshcctnasa.nnGiooebTbstotyaaiiawnncilhiilninafefotovtrreemmntaadthtiieomosnneeaeagnntoidnadlgoossvvJeearPnr dGwwhhdwoioelmvmenlhheoeeepdccjoaafinnont"eebxpxueerryorttjfeasscvootosmmrswee"itiihinnnfflCtulhueheeninncfceeoesrettmoocommofalailseinunatptgaapiulinnyeisqqnuugfaralosiltimttayyonwodfafhrhothcmees
aaIreannsbdduolrtrrsaee.tffereTrireosennoaccecehtimhemaevatreetedrtrehiiasaelilsssgenaaagtnnoeddadlscvvoaJaniPltiddGraaattcwiitooinlnal bn.ooeffedmmeteotthh"boouddyss
by analyzing pil. samples at the SM favors" in the form of supplying standards by analyzing split samples at the 3M
laboratories or their designated contract lab.
CJCooohssnttGlesy. time and materials as usual Costs for traveltokey meetings may be incured, but JcGtoroosahstcntkeeeGsdstiteqiimsumayaar:ttteeteissrmleywwiiaalllcncbbdooeumnpptarriotoenvvrgiiidsadelesaddnadaasnnrdcuosluaainappglpp.rreooCsvvioeemsddatstbboefeosffrooorrtferecaovaaensnlyyttortiraankvvetehyel miisnseeexuuttnninddqegeursarttraamtkkeeaernyn.p.breovCCiionodscsetutdssrrewwdCii,llolsbbbtueest wtrialclkveardy qfuoamrteqrulyaratecrcotounqtuinagrseradnedperonldlinigngeUsptiomnastecstvoifecso.sts in the next quarter provided. Costs
will vary from quarter to quarter depending upon activities.
SMMuaabddjeeecAAtvvtaaoiillPaarbbollteeecbbtyyiv33eMMOrffodoer rIInnIssnppPeecactltiimooennraavnn.dd3CCMo,oppyNyoii.nnggC2aa.ss0CC4o-on6nf3ifid0de8enntitiaall IInnffoorrmmaatitioonn::
Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309
22110022..00000077
8 IMA02513758
3MA02513758
MMaaiinnttaaiinn RReeffeerreennccee MMaannaaggeerr ddaattaa bbaasseeoofflfiitteerraattuurree oonn ppeerrfflluuoorriinnaatteedd ccoommppoouunnddss
TpThehirissfuiisosraannnatooenndggoociinonmggpeeofufffnoordrtts.ttoo mmaWaiinenttaaipinneraforrreemffeerrseeenntatiriaacllhddeasattaaobbfaassaeevaooiffabppleeeeereH-rfveeivraieetwwureeeddappnuudbbliliccclolyyntaaivvnaauioilauabsbllleey lluiitpeedrraaatttuuerreethooinns
database. perfluorinated
database.
compounds.
We perform searches of available literature and continuously update this
WMWoororrkktppyrroorddepuuoccrttts are provided with information on the number of recent published PFC related
haaMreroticcndltseahst.ly.abraEEelspleeeocccrtttarrsoonnnabiircceeuupopprbddotaavatitideenesseddttoowanittthdhheepin33rfMHoormddvaaatittaiaotdbbonaaeSssoMdeen aaptrhreeoenppnrrurooemvvqiidbudeeeesdrdtoqqfuuaraerrceteerrynly.tl.y
Any aicle ncuded In published PFC related
Any article included in
the database can be obtained and provided to 3M upon request.
AATshssesuufmmopcptutisiooonnfssthe database continues to be lmied to publshed articles and reports related to PFCs. The focus of the database continues to be limited to published articles and reports related to
PFCs.
Cost Name Cost JJJNoooahhhmnnNeGGeiwieessstyyed JDDPoaeehunnlnissJeNeokenKwaeassyyted PRMReayyauianlsnJsHHoanooSeleetsmmowel KarenSmyh Melissa Shotwell
Karen Smyth
$RRaatt2ee% 5$$$ 172117475555 5$$$ 12111430355
$ 120
SS7G5 $ 95
$ 75
HHoo2uu6rrss _ SSuubbttoot6taa8ll00_ RlRdeeossnptpolnoysnipsboiibrliriliottiineetsserature
1524
15
$ 3$ s
6,600
2625- 2,625
Kenify Identify
Identify
partment pertinent
pertinent
erature literature
literature
50 s$$ 6000- Database maintenance, monthly and quarterly updates
151100000
$
6,000
S$79550 $
950
DLLEiniattetetarrraabattrauuisrreeceissmeeesaaairrincncthhecnaatnacbea,semonthly and quarterly updates
100 $S$$7$ 27115,,44502209110 CTCEoonotmtmaemlrumnaeuisrnttciciiaclmeatastiitooiennndssdca((4ot4a%s%btaoosffeblaobror))
$
25,096 Total estimated cost
SMMaadduee AAvtvaboaiPillraaobbjtlleeectbbeiyyve33MMOcrffdooertrIIInnnssppPeeccattliioomnneaavrnn.dd3CCMo,oppyNyoii.nnggC2aa.ss0CC4o-on6nf3ifid0de8enntitiaall IInnffoorrmmaatitioonn::
Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309
22110022..00000088
o IMA02513759
3MA02513759
CCoolllleecctt aanndd mmoonniittoorr PPFFCCss iinn mmuusssseellss ffrroomm nneeaarr--sshhoorree NNoorrtthh AAmmeerriiccaann mmaarriinnee
eEeNnnTvvRiirIroXonnwmimleepnnrtotvsside oversight, QAIGC and report preparationfor a rcect(ubcanirac) to the Uriversoif SRSEaaaNsssTkkRaaallItXcrchehwaeodwiulylaspnnmroattovdoideaaennaaaolmlvyyaezznreesgiegssmhaaemtm,nppQltleesAss/Q1ooCff ommabunuisdsassnorelelsshpsoootrtbobrtpaacrniaenlepedadsraaffrtmoioopmmnlefttsohhreefaNNmpOOrAoAjNAAeOcMMtAa(uAsssussebaelcnlodWWnattariatecccnhht) tPPtoor-rootghsgreriaamsmU.in. ivsEEeaNrNsmTTiptRyRlIeIoXXsf aaahnannsnntuuaaa1ll0rllyecaniondnyttdhhuemactfatuduotuenrreeear((sraaabenbogouseutamtamasew itnwetsos.1totoho Tthehorebeetearioyynseeuaahlrrissddtwoeeirlalyicy)an)lcwwsuhhadeemennpNNUlepOOsAA1fAAro5mhh0aaassNnifaiOnsliAishAheeesddaonfaadlvl aootfrhflietohnhueestaoacnhnaaoaliblyyntssaleeinssenttshhiaaanmtt ttpahhlneeedsyy wfnacntt otonacomniduectteonn these samples. The results will include up to ~0 analytes of various chain lengths and
functional moieties.
Work product Work product
TThhee iinniittiiaall wwoorrkk pprroodduuccttss wwililll bbee aa SSaammplpilinngg aanndd AAnnaallyyssiiss PPllaann ((SSAAPP)) aanndd aa QQuualailittyy AAssssuurraannccee
Project Pan (GAPP) produced by ENTRIX and cos stmale provided separately blow. On an Project Plan (QAPP) produced by ENTRIX and cost estimate provided separately below. On an ongoing basis, ENTRIX wil prove an anual repo, including satus and trends. When enough ongoing basis, ENTRIX will provide an annual report, including status and trends. When enough aihasbeen accrue, a manuscript wil be proparod or ublcatn in hepeer reviewed, open data has been accrued, a manuscript will be prepared for publication in the peer-reviewed, open erature. literature.
AA3sMsssuwuimmlpptptiriooovnnissde technical assistance as needed. This may include purchase of sandards and
3aoafMccSco.ewssislslTftsopohreoinnvssUirdtrueuomfmteeSencnthvtanaititlciooaGnnloianinncsistthcihsettafftinrrhsscetteyyeaeetsaanrunmuneneetindleththdlee. annTneehacclieesysssssmeaasarryyyanininnsdscttlruarudrimremaeenpnngutessrcfaahoraeeseippnuuorrrc-cfhahsabatsaosernedaddbtaboyrydrtsythhaeeSnpUUdt
osSSaaaf mmmSppp.llleeeTsaahnnewiaalylUyssbaoeesfs
SaaannnwaddiylloozvtcohoedenrrdpOQuecrAAt
ytaahessaer,saipnppspdrterroopuppemrrniieadtntieetna.gl
aIotnnfiasslayeesvsseatisiimmaaaabtntieedydd attrfhhrraeaotntmgsaeppNppfOrorooArxxAiimnmatealertIe-lnllayybao33dr00da00itontro,y
40a0nspit
400
saSpaadlmidatitpoitolneneasalslw22oilr0l0%s%I~peiookffeansrsaeaaclmmyopzvpleeleedryss pwsweiairllml pybbleeeeasrc,coodnn3ecdMlpucecwintieedlddinpgraaossvoiOQndeAAadvrssaeaaicmlmalpbpyllieleiotsy,f, ifeerointemhderrNe2aOssAtArroee.uffeegrreIhennnccaaeeddedmmsitaaiiotgtennr,aeiatsalesnd,
dCuopnlticaacteisborasnpikae-lrecsoevenreyessafmorpVleesl.da3tMonwoilfl samp provide spit. directly or indirectly, through a designated
contract lab analytical services for validation of sample splits.
Cost sucComosmstat ryfor fist yearof mussel monitoring program
CinocsltudsiunmgminatriyalfoGrAfPirPstaynedarSoAfPmussel monitoring program
DeiDosneccrslrucSidrpiisnptu~tiiloboinncniotinaltQrAaPcPtasDDniidrreeSc1ctA4t 2Pcco.os5stt0
Markup
Markup
5C_Gaatteoggoorryy ss1uu6bb2lto7ot5taa0ll
EEUENNNoTTTfRRRSIIoXXsxullpababcobooonrrnstreasct
$ 142,750
Ss$ s8a300 $ 51,400
1a40%%ns5$$
142,750
E95rs 54,484
TEONTTARLIXEeSxTpIeMnAseTsED CO$ST 8,300 10% 5$
2096,757485
TOTAL ESTIMATED COST
$
206,779
NWaWimrtiteee.QQAAPPPPaanndd JJJNoooahmmmneGGNeeiewsssyyted DPJDoaeehunnlniissJNeeoenKKweaassyyted WPPPeaaaluttrslricsJikoanBBsrehraasoddtlleweyysl KaenSmyn Melissa Shotwell
Karen Smyth
SSAAPP oforrbRboaiomtmeenointiotorHrioinnu~grspprrooggrraamm_Sublolsl
Rate
SSWZ $ 275
Ho211u0rs05$5
Subtotal
3275500 2,750
$ 175
SSm1 $ 150
2444000 0S$$5
3,500
G50400 6,000
$S$$ 9m1153250 411 1000 s$$S95511,,422000000
S75 $ 95
$ 75
22100 0S$$$ 7.112,5955070000
0s$$
men 1,278
22,578
RReRveeisseppwoonnissniiabbliiliditioieecssument
SWSRttiealvtt;tiieesewtdiacaalfitlnsasadalmomdpcopiuclnmiunegmgndetodnsestsiiggnn
Write draft documents
QWAiGtCeddeastidgoncuments Write draft documents
TATQadaAbbw/llQieerCaasnnduddepspffiiiggogunturree
prep,
prep,
document
document
editing
editing
ACodmmminunsucpaptoortns (6% ofiabor)
Tomesmaegeot Communications (6% of Total estimated cost
labor)
SMWaadduee AAvtvaboaiilPlaarbbjollteeecbbeyiyv33eMMOcrffdooerrtrIInInssnppPeeccattiiioomnneaavrnn.dd3CCM,ooppyNyoii.nnggC2aa.ss0CC4o.on6nf3ifid0de9enntitiaall IInnffoorrmmaatitioonn::
Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309
22110022..00000099
010 MA0Z513760
3MA02513760
Annual budfogrUeoft$ porotfmiusosenl monitoring program
DAesncnruiapltbioundget UDoesfcSripltaiboonr
for
U
of
S
portion
of
Salary Benefits Total mussel monitoring program Salary Benefits Total
ccoossttss
_%%oonn
pprroojjeecctt
_
U`oGfraSdulaatbeorassistant (benofis14.11%) $2000 $3104 $2510 100%
GLLrPaaaobbdsooutrradaaottetcootrraoyysrmsmaailsantfnaaeanglgte(oebrwre(((nbobeeeofnnnitceesfff1iiit4sss.1334144%%%%)))) $$$$4422440,,00000000000 $$$$1114403,98,916%600004 $$$$ 84259258,,1609060840
122205550%%%%
ofPos-tSHHduoouoburctrltoloyytrlalaaallbbfooeLrrlalo((b5wSo00r00(bNheMr@ n@eS$Tfi7.ts.553004/Mh%r))) $32,000 $10,880 $ 42,880
25%
U of S - Subtotal Labor
UULabooofrfSSatEEoxrxyppeesnnupsspeelssies
IInnLInssasttbtrrrouuurmammteeeonnnrttytsmssuauupipppnppltlliiieeeensss/aNNniictrreooggeenneeftc..
TTIPrnurasabvltvreieulclmateinont
maintenance
costs
OOPUffuffbficlsieScass-tuuiopSppunplbliciteeoossst,,tascclooEmmpxpuputeetnersr,e, stte.elleepphhoonnee,,
copy
copy
OUUUvoooeffrfSShSSeSu-abudStbuot(bot5tta2ao%llt)aLLlaabEbooxrrpaaennnddseEEsxxppeennsseess
_
OovefrSheTaodta(l5L2a%b)or + Expenses
U of S Total Labor + Expenses
SSuubbttoottaall 325104 $$$S 42115740,,71472040400 5$$ 813340,,37775120O40
$ 54,314
55$ 111200.,000000000 s$ 182,000000 55$S 5285,,650600000000 $5$$ 32911,,,555600o000o0 $s$$s 43999383,,698s013t045 $$14428,,873550
$142,750
Annual budgot for ENTRIX portion ofmussel monitoring program
ADensncuraipl tbiuodnge_t _for EDNeTsRcrIiXptiLoanbor
ENTRIX
Unit portion of Unit
cost mussel
cost
_Unit_Quantity __ monitoring program
Unit Quantity
CCoosstt
ENTRIX Labor JJPooahuhnlnlGGoeinesesysy $$ 272173555 hhhooouuwrr 424000 $$$12171100,00000
JotDDPaeeanNnuiielsswJeesokKtnaeeaydsy $$$$171114345555 hhhhoooouuuwrrr 4442000 0S$5$ 2557.,,878000000000
MelJioshsnaSNheowtwseteldl $$91575 hhoouwr 2400 $$ 1970,0000
ENTRIX-SubtotMaleliKLKsasaabareoerSnnhSSommtwyyethhll $$S$
7595
75
howhour
hour
2020
20
$s$$ 1258110,,9950000000
`ECECNoNoTmmTRmmRIuIunXXin-LcicaaSatbutiioboortnnossTtao((tl44aL%5l%aboooffrLLaabboorr))
ss$$
29,900
3110m8 1,196
ENTRIX LaborTotal
$ 31,096
EENNTTRRIIXX EExxppoennssoess Travel $2150 ps ENTRIX- SubtotSSaaalmmEppxlpleeenssshheTiipsprp.apiivnneggl $$$4,24,,01005o00o trips EEEENxxNppTTeeRRnnIIssXXeeE-mmxSaapurrebkkntuuospptae((ls11E55Tx%o%pt))ealnses 'EENNTTRRIIXX EToxtpaelnLsesaT+obtaExl poensres
ENTRIX Total Labor + Expenses
2Ssa44,33o0O00
5$s 4s81,,032w00s00
s s
as91t,,s52s44ts55
41,451
`MMaaddSee AAvuvtaoaiiPllbaarbbollteejecbbiyyve33eMOMrcffdooerrrtIIInnnssppPeeccattliioomnneavarnn.dd3CCM,ooppyNyoii.nnggC2aa.ss0CC4o-on6nf3ifid0de9enntitiaall IInnffoorrmmaattiioonn:
Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309
22110022..00001100
"11 IMAG2513761
3MA02513761
CiCnoontnshseiiddeeenrrvmmieetrthhooonddmsseattonodtaassdsseeevssesslottphheemenntaathtuuorrdeesaatnnodddecchthaearrramacictnteeerrisissottuiiccrsscoeofsftthhee ttoottaall PPFFCC llooaadd
in the t"eTThhnheiisvseinttravaossiknkromissnme0teonntlltoooaokknThaadittsdmmweeietlvthhebooleddossapttooomnaatesssstpheerssoossjdecttshtheetthonnaaatdttuwueirreleteiaarnnnmvddoilccnvhheeaartrashaceoctetuUerrririisscvtteeiicrcssssitoofyftothhfeeSatlosatakalal tPPcFFhCCew[lao0na2ddbuiintn
tmmmhaaaeiyynetnaaavillsnisroooanppmwrroooervvnkiitdid. enagTaahrnnioslooawippiolpplnoosbrrhetuuinpnatithjyyoaitnttotoaplpprloaaorjwrettsncneetarrtchcwwaeititsthwhsilolkkeeinyyIvnolflalaovbbreomorartatahtiteooornrUiieeanssnivdaeannrosddityiinnnofsslfttuiSuteunattcisooeknnatssthcehIinnequwAAaasslintiaaybttouooft
mssittsuautddioniiietoacssianliinnaaAAnwsdsiooiaa.rr.koinnTTg-hhgeeroeilppanrrtgooiojjeesncocstuthriwwcpieillslt.hiianntvvTeeahssletltopiigwrgaaosttjeeeaccpptcoosesisssilsibblltieeoncsSlinuoofduuoerrr,cmceeaassmtioooofnnf gPPaFFnotCdChssetorIinntinhttifhhlnueegeseentnnchevveiirtoodhennevmmeqeelunnoattplimtffyrefoonmomtf
hoSofaifsmtmmpoelretiecthhsa,ool ddaissnncdttloouodriiiddnoeegnnnt-atgibitfoiyyointssgioocuusraroccnueedsrsc..ebiso.tTTihhcTeeshssaeeemppwwrlioielljlesciinfntoccwrlluuinlddldeeiv,n,icaadlunnudaaaellly,yssPaeeFmssCosoon,ffgsisonaatcmmhlpeupldrlieetnhssginootgfhfseddtiiihffsfeeeorrmdeeeennrtvtsettlyooyfpppeemcssaeconohftf
sccreaoocmmmopgpponloueiutnsnid,od.ni.nctlTTuehchdeheinnnnig,,quabbebyysi,ouutssicteehaeoonffdrrreeeblllaiaaottttviiivceveescrraoaanmtttioproisslebsuootfffiootthrnhseeinvvodfaaivrriiivdooauuurassiloPPuPFsFFCCC,s,so,uaarnnincddcelsutthhdeveiiinilrrgliistsbhooeemmeedirsersost,,meraaemnnrisdndeodppf.aaetttatecerIhnmn
raadeeddctidoetitgrioomnnnii,t,nioettnhhipissotteeppcnrrhtoonijjaeeiqlccuttsewwosiu,illrl ctddheeeesvveeorllefoolpapvtaiaarvinenodducspporrnPootFvvrCiiibdsduee,tpiorpbnoruosotoffowoiolfflfvcfcaooorcninouccuseesppnttstooonnulrctthheeoesnuuwssPeeiFllOooSbff,essttdaPaebbFltleeeOrAmsisoioanltneooddpp.eetsshettIionor
dpeprnreiivmtemiaarrmrroyyninmppeerrneeptccouuurtersssinoonrtirsgas.l.CsoIIttGuriiscs eppsooorssos0sfi'ibbv*llaaeerniottdouo sOddeaePtttFeeiCrrmcmssi,inn.beeuIttthnhweesilolssmoofouuecrrcucceesasooienffritaaiaanntltltyhshrroooofnppoosPggteFearObniliScce, nsciPhherFeromOrgieAiccnaaallossntdoiinnpthettehshei.er
emmmneaavayyisrouaanrllsmseoomeenbbnteetuppsooifonsssgtsoitbiaCbll1le,e.2.:oCr1g3FFaiinonniaracll0lay,1l,5ytt-ahhbniiossdunrrOedeTsMsFeeraaairrntcciohshs.apprrIoomnjjeesoccsottlmowwteieihlllcasaddlseeevaveermllaooatppisossaannobddaf lsaaatanppbpcplelleyycnamminterebotteghheoodnddessviseffolootorroppttehehedes.
fmofoorrregaatthnshieuecrFoeormrggceaaonnnmitipccooaafulllntylod--tbsabo.lo,uunondrdgaFnittchhaaaltlty-ccbaaonnunbbdee
accounted for In the F in samples so that
accounted for in the
currently denied and a mass balance can be
currently identified and
quantified developed
quantified
organic F compounds.
WTWhooerrkkprpporrdoouddcutucscttof this research project wil be annual reports, including an ora discussion of the.
Trsreechsseeuunllttpssi.r.iocduTTmcehhteeestiorrneefgsstsuhullitsasssrwweaispillpel rabobrpeecrhippautpuebrb.loliijseshch3eteMddwieilInlmn pbttlehhoeeayneppneeeuseerarw--lrirerleevvpibieoeewrwteeesxdd,,t,ienooncdpplueeeddnnintgIlhiiteeearronaapttpuouorrrreaetluaadnnniisddtcyu1ppsr0rseecissooee-nnnattoueetfddhthoaaerit
papers a hei discretion scientific meetings as appropriate.
papers at their discretion.
3M employees will be extended the opportunity to co-author
AAssssuummppttiioonnss TemeTrqqehiuuaissiisppuimimsrseeeaannmttetthnraarteessseeonnfyyeeeeeteaadodrteraedlpdp.r.oroorjjgeeaccIIrtttti. ciiassSl3lMMaayss-swbwsuiouilulmlmneedppddrrFoo.vvttiihdhdTaaeehttettewI3ecMcoMhhrnnokohhllaaoowssggiyly,tt,hbheememeectnnothheenooccdddeeussscs,,stsaaessrdrttyyaabnnydedeaxaxarpprddeesssrrt,,tiuissdmmeeeaatnettfteororipiaaoddlslosost-daattonhnhcdede. atamennecddhantstieeucccrihheannmniiccewiiinaaltlnnsgaaoottf tttthoohetathlUUeooor3fgfMaSSn.,iicauuabnnoldldryeea-rtbroottrhuhieenesdddioiFrrree. cctthtTieioihonrneodofwefsoJJirPPgknGGwaitiieleelssdyby.e.cocnTTothhnaeedcuissoctturtuedddaeesnnbttnyaeaacnneddsstsoourardreppynoostst,tot pdddoooesccvte-aadlnnooddcp ttuthehseceehmmnUeiecsttihahonionddswsstirlaalannmgddeonaattnnoafalotlhryyezzseeu3sbsMaasmmelpaqplbueleosesr.na. TtoaThnrhiaealesysUUoeosro.ftfhSSeAwiwrimlidlloepprsueiugrcncrhaoatcemsdephalcaaeonnsneeptewrrwao.cpLLtoCoCsr--aMMlasSSfI/inMMoeSmScetIinshnseeeaaaUrryrlloyytfo22S00d00ew77vileaalonnbdpde duesveetlhoispeidnshtrautmwielnltofuotrisnuebasleoqftueent sapneacilyfsiecse.xpAermimoernetscotmo bpeletceonpdruocptoesdalafnrdomthetheperUsoonfneSl.will be
developed that will outline all of the specific experiments to be conducted and the personnel.
CECoNosTstRt IX wil manage a sub-coniract 0 the U of and provide oversight as well as QA/QC and
tddEaaoNtttaTahRemmIUaXaonnfawaSgigl.elemmmeaennntat gaaenndda
report preparation. There sub-contract to the U of
report preparation. There
ill be S and
will be
no marko-ntuhpefundspassedtrough provide oversight as well as QA/QC and
no mark-up on the funds passed through
to the U of S.
`lCGoooassdtt
assnudmsmuoaurrycfmeofosrriffm niirrtsshttyea yeeeanarvroirofrfoUUnoy moeffnSt
research
research
program
program
on
on
PFC.
PFC
Dleosacdriapntdiosnources in the eDinrvoicrotncmosetnt Markup Category subtotal
UDoesfcSrsiputbiocnontract EUNoTfRSIXsulbacboorntract
$D2i0re9c,t 1co1s3t $s mwo 209,113
eSs Markup
Category $
s22u200b905t,1o131t1a%33l
EENNTTRRIIXXolaxbpoornses TEONTTARLIXEeSxTpIenMsAeTsED
G
OS$$_S
T
5300 23,900 8,300
15%6%
15%
$
s$
2235995,,53504342545
TOTAL ESTIMATED COST
$
243,992
`MMaaddSee AAvuvtaoaiiPllbaarbbollteejecbbiyyve33eMOMrcffdooerrrtIIInnnssppPeeccattliioomnneavarnn.dd3CCMo,oppyNyoii.nnggC2aa.ss0CC4o-on6nf3ifid0de9enntitiaall IInnffoorrmmaattiioonn:
Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309
22110022..00001111
?12 IMAG2513762
3MA02513762
AAnnnnuuaallbbuuddggeettffoorr UU ooffS rreesseeaarrcchh pprorgoramgoornnPaPEFmCC llooaadd aannddTosstooaulrucersicinntethhse%e eeonnnvviirroonnmmeenntt
DeDsecsrcirpipttiioonn
SSaallaarryy BBeenneeffiittss
Costs Total
Costs
pp%rroojioeencctt SSuubbttoottaall
UUooff S lla`aGbbrooarrduate assistant (benefits
Graduate assistant (4be1n1e%fit)e Laboratory manager (benefi1t4s.1314%%))
$$$422422,,00000000
$$$ 1343.,119005440
$$ 2255581,91060404
11200500%%%
$$2215541,71040404
LPaobsotradotocrtyormalafnealgloewr ((bbeenneefifittss 3344%%)) $$4342,000000 Post doctora`lGrfealdlouawte(bteinoefnitswa3i4v%er) $32,000
$$$ 101140,,,898868000
$$S 4452862,,588908860000
11200500%%%
$ 4124,878400 $$ 462,580800
HHoouurrllyy
labor (S00h@S7 50M) Graduate tuition waiver
labor (500hr@$7.50/hr)
$ 6,5OO
$$
$
3750 6,500
3,750
UofofSS --SSubutbotottaall LLaabboorr
s$ 9922.,997744
UULaboooffrSSatEEoxrxyppeesnunpsspeelssies
Instrument Laboratory
Instrument
sssuuuppppppllliiieeesss//NNiittrrooggeenn
eettcc..
TIInrnassvttrerulummeenntt mmaaiinntteennaannccee
TPurbalvieclation costs
OOUPfouffffbiicclieecSass-tuuiopSppnuplbliciteeoossst,,tasccloomEmpxpuputeetnersr,e, stte.elleepphhoonnee,, ccooppyy
ExUUUpoooeffnfSSSseSS- usuSbbultobotttaaolltaLLlaaoEbooxrrpaaennndd.ses
OEvxeprehneseasd (52%)
OUvferhSeTaodta(l5L2a%b)or +Expenses.
U of S Total Labor + Expenses
$$$ 111552,000000000
$$$$ 18582,,060000000000
$$
$
2500 5,600
2,5OO
$$$ 44l1,550m000
$ 44,600
$$$11337771,,555377944 $$$22007991,,,151131393
AAlnonannduuaaalnl dbbuusdodgugeretcteffosorrIEEn NNthTTeRRIeIXXnvppioorrrottniioomnnenootffUU ooffS
Dleosacdriapntdisonources in the environmUennittcost
ENTRIX Labor Description
ENTRIX Labor
Unit cost
KGGaeieyss.yDy,eJndoiohsnns $ 221775550
NewKsatye,dD, eJnoihsen $ 117550
SShhoNottewwewelslllt,edMMe,elJliiosshssnaa
$
$
95175 95
ENT-RSubIlotXalSSLmmaybytothhr., KKaarreenn $ 7755
ECNCEoToNmmRTmIumRnXIuiXnLc-iaacStabuitoiboorntnossTtao((tl66aL%%laboooffrLLaabboorr))
ENTRIX LaborTotal
rreesseeaarrcchh pprrooggrraamm oonn PPFFCC.
Unit
Unit
Quantity
Quantity
__
GCoosstt
hhhooouwwr 343000 $$$ 8620850,25000
hhoouwr 440 0S$ 67.,000000
how hour
hour
2040
20
S$$$
1900 7,000
1,900
hhoourr 1100 S$$ 7253790500
$ s$$ 22= 34,899505606
$ 24,856
EENNTTRRIIXX EExxppeennsseess Travel S$ 2150 wps 2 5 4300
SSaammppllee sshhiTipprppaiivnneggl ENTRI-X Subtotal Expenses
$$S 442,.,O10O50O00
trips
2
5$$s 4484,,03030000000
EEExxNppTeeRnnIssXee -mmSaaurrbkktuuoppta((l11E56%x%p))enses
s$ 81,32o80
$ 1,245
EENNTTRRIIXXEExxppeennsseessTToottaall
s$ 99,554455
EENNTTRRIIXX TToottaall LLaabboor+r+ EExxppoennsseess.
$5 3344,44001
`MMaaSddeeuAAtvvbaoaiPijllraaobbetlleeecctbbiyytv33eMOMrffdooerrrIIInnnssppPeeccattliioomnneaavrnn.dd3CCM,ooppyNyoii.nnggC2aa-ss0CC4o-on6nf3ifid0de9enntitiaall IInnffoorrmmaatitioonn::
Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309
22110022..00001122
313 I3MMAAC022551133776633