May 15, 2017
MUWO12f.aSaf0iis.0clheECPinonoegfvdntRienorseon1ygn,8lumD0vl3aa.eCAntno.itraa2yl0APP4vo6reol0.it-cNe0yc0Wta0i.no1nd MAgaennacgyement Submitted via Federal eRulemaking Portal 0R1e9:0Evaluation of Existing Regulations; Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OA-2017-
TcReoxhemiegsutmilPnaeegtnostrtrsieycgtioRudeletafhtoeiPromonUlis.AcSyig.neECnancdovcaaoi.lrirotdinoamnncee(nPwtPailGthPrEoorxteec"cttuhioteinveCAOogaerlndicteiyron((EE")OPA)is)13op7nl7ei7at,sseEednvfatoolrucaistnuigobnmthoietf ippPmcsantodrePaaodmvsGkncutome-eascaihsgtasonrsocediodlayemidrntssyeaev,rroneatsorthcn.ugstadonaPpptrndePr-mocicGspzidoauaaeunrpltssktictetpyoretroosmntv.lreecatorsrnsoPfo;tapPfparogeaG,spoerneadmassat,mptoneifaracondegsirrmt;deruiernmbscertiueegl,mrvlsuftseoiauflcaaranruirtieunticrl,hotfchuaenlfaurcoendtaorrudeenerrvsg:doetiasrerrpnycngswoii,,aaezl,tnipnaficioodetcyzinisreo.asmt-wntcbimusuoiad;slnsaaseesnitad;ooannargds,nrceeodmdagooenuetpvrhdlneeeaergtltradoiiaotoipisninvnmntdeartiesleobr;nrefutfeltaaspfoarottemrneeossdddd;,t
COMMENTS Ttraoenhpcdeo/cmofaormnleldoehiwnmddianietngedasctrieofoofmnorrmormefesgnsuptwselaicrltileofiffrceuyrrretrtheogfeuotrlhratmethioeraenAcgst,udiolomanrtsiirn,oeiniqsnstucriaalrutneidmodinnep'gsnoltgmiscoiowaedlsisitfhPsiciPenatGttfihoohonratsshse, iirrdneuepltnelhasteic.feiTEemhOdeesnaoestf
{01041.001 / 111 / 00209140.DOCX}
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tier 3/4
ED 002061 00068623-00001
PPG Comments re: Evaluation of Existing Regulations DPaogceke2t ID No. EPA-HQ-OA-2017-0190
icnemoloistmptslsienumtahbtesaintntatginenxtrgiceaetgtheeudedlaIetbnonyfrvoyirarmvoreanaiqmtliuaoebinrnleetQmaldueaabntletiasntyeotfAhritacsatt,.reianrihenicbuointnnsjeoiscbteesgnsrtaorwwytihtah,nditmhiepnoedsffeaetcabtuivgredu,eidnoesrhonmaerees I. Modifications and Revisions
A. Certified Applicator and Training Rule (82 Fed. Reg. 952). jipTtttrrrIrttaaaauonhrrrueumegpuduhiaasdqqellebpbmteiipteepihuunnillavlurpfiyioiieliipceyiunrrrrnnrdmeeqbroRsinahiggeousmutrugndUleevitriaeeireenrdneaeiorlaPgsesorsgreltnfmulisiqatetumesnsth.emptsuusasgligrptaIepiowniouirmrtosnmpAanidrweipsiltrvtltapmetdotetiahioehtfcrlmstrtiisnoofeeheatiemvauiramnuutittsecchnchoelptmtcitwesheniredilotasa.tsnoebvhehhmtccurmntaeriNeitihaurotacsgimrshaotoaeol.ftheitepionnnneofiAohrpmgermrtonoienicaemldsteftfsiieoiepa.ioencatoenalprrfra1Fltnssaeiatal8tthtc.riR.uimgconhlhgect-errdUeceeEsnoasoetnooidhttrinPtPcrtnaofuchueldeAieteroylercurraerdsnwcse,ratspavteiwsfnepsppcfaip-imaietnathorplipcegoipnvoraualupcacetietennllatnclctseiodsriyimglttazhneovativoeebimarslnneecerRdsslnnisonsire,vihodgUshttpttetiaaatwaeeasrhpPwabttlssoutpe.etseraigelr1reslctTio(nl8rgieasoRasacacfehrbkumyntmelUeewelallltesdarqoepahotPsstawcewurtlire,sryifuteiy)soroir,irar.licc.ewnaneetnneasimetcPTdfaidtritmsfrtiioorstnihfeehceoiivneinadfettoaaonnicsisnatsrdcutociclyeripsaaoutstleeevedoeotltnarrseoinaaamlittloplyfetnsniistyanhffeoewtcsyiinuphewn.cceisdrnpomasarbmciotnTtridstttaeeibpvetoiiheihfentroornwiilgieeatrldeenncsiirissimffmaetta1nrftyiaytduaimwa8atiuieitntnolnnnemniettetasonlgodoodsg.,,tllf lFttsaehhinaggeecdniesecidlfnalaiovpctwcuiaarainrcotleithntlsyympacpateoolranautrtrnrle.gduedenrrlsdey.pocruowoAmnngfnmrupyanremodnlgseodrdsaosrmffeettdouhaferennrdasislntapagmmoteteate/hlnnosedtcciaaaaptlllreeo,i,ngpadcranearrepmdtnathhsetemrodashniErtideiPpsdAkscasr.elwtisEobooPeupurArulcdabedslsioc,rdeeohsssoeutnmahlotleetthsishnttaaaanvttedeea iTrrttsdhheethaeqqeaentuutentiiPsEirref'eePPyermmGdAesaeefondnrouertetre.csrlcaaosAeayltmiatbscitmtsmoetiehcnenpelncetliedegsmrtsmtinhsapselettlaheneatfamtinelavteddteevieEnoneratPlneaa,celAttodaiiroofsnemn.ntdqhsouettdiiihrmnifeefiymnesrlaeeitelvnhmneeretour,avlrtielouanllsdaeptoniarvfdottioetvdhwsiu.eidoasleTrilmkrhesfelitwqenauxiPtateiitPhrbeseGislmatithtraaeyeetlnesfttomoraweruieenaitlccihltmocooamorulsuilmmteenitveteisnaaafggdotteoeesr
{01041.001 / 111 / 00209140.DOCX}
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tier 3/4
ED 002061 00068623-00002
PPC Comments re: Evaluation of Existing Regulations DPaogceke3t ID No. EPA-HQ-OA-2017-0190
B. Agricultural Worker Protection Standard (80 Fed. Reg. 67496) ffPrrm"seaiaeeatfgrlaficqapeorlenotdpueimcecrddletrdiuiuasicvbklatlratetyigeoldutnseai'dr,gosptapagenialtrrrndaeoenogeqvudidawnxiupnedcroisldreeNrlareueskytoqsomroesiveuuottreepoaaisrnrnmcsrteeeesptmbszissirsneoeoletbrncennvnfereaeti2aetdcicd"s0nraaeem1gsmsa5aesaeneg,adadrdfnersEeaeyndqrPfatc"mfuhtnAdieoeaeeedci'stsnstreeirsitvfangwrffetroneneieiawmdccatqinhhuttnueiedecvwederJeefnosadlonscyrrnrfwtkyeoauieipirmtnmatrcerheroeepppwyfsmclrledeeooe2mnemmtrn0etpeceat1pecqaontnt7lrnuiiitg,tvtaocimiunrentneiehicn.pegd"deestnas.tsttnM,arhpscunteiroeltdaieesoncaitfnahcraondilaohfnuandfegdga(gaW,irtetdnhiprscPgeae.uaoSitdlnifE)tntdiuittPefnohheroAwngeeedr bpATFcEtrrtdoaeerureahPtkvisossrtreAunieiepiimscngolnsriPitenoetishtoePssrnmaiiatsrsGtmntaeeeseorfpseadfgyro;rsnneterrhhdroatemtatehiesotahnsprioatefsWaelrpniEoinenrrlmaprPPsacosmbrweSwAhivoltnaceeivoftdttobrduoiraipessnrkoiltrisodecienioacavuhver,nnlrergmaaoednsscnhsiaaeinyuytesnnfdwranefapdtefottihtaraeylierolseotb.talsutfhooelenurTssprudcuoreoehrttraltvioeteeonooitvpsdefchncPuirxeEeaessoibPpneePufjocGrtctoelAteaesodohcrear-ntuidyfsarsgcaroetepeghfrrfm"nspaomapeeduarrwrtosmeoblmemtnsevolrtieersseihfgtsntdrdoernaseaaanaxpdtttlThtdap"eiietesndoaasgedcrtgtestcaaoliksotcrlnhtaiefisuhcgatrdlFpuinihaarneoaroraruetaseenbresrdtcstislseoholeeuoam.dinfentlftyeetctetporpan,dhonerrtteniptoirntvviefhrvorraieecaiidercspo"srnqeyidermphonduonrnatipemptoinssaaaeuvwettlrrntsiinEttoshviafidiuPeeeaenoblssAii.ndydarr.". piAbfTtmuuccsoCanhioulegefnnhnodaiehdnrretddteacudhtriianelueaeoAfgniebfcitC,rilWuasieiiniyptopeettodnsttpeielnPsrhay.oddloxbaSleifniwipctfluenStteloarioedfaarygunouratidrrsse,inbdnctlfokertyeaaatssvahwnneinlearlvaectsdmloqyobcEraisrrtueoaenaeixireksgweennyeprctgienusrmdsaontpliuefutlttinglfcaoalhevwiisedacfotnviitcittdooiamedooitttactniuothhnivghmotpanofihei.eemenZielsnerlnen,ssGoyenapactusnAoaeidnluilcteceieniqgirsEdeiazsisuedurdanZa(iitaciAsnecctdhaphnteaipetuEonuoamaecunrtleyZrnpteorndthseepua)pvdeE,.nkndrrlionrtgesiaPooTidgefciontrlreArothdaiotdoshvtnateweheowae.apfnnspeoreAtemerotfs,arfeoagroE.ts'teWbvuarssZsTwnccihcitiodadPharedncsicfpuearmetSohgrhrpnctrtemyhPeovdtlchtaurinhePueeieecuttnrtehGethanlefgicedtetia,ncia.l,naroglteaecanewaoEpnrrcctTlyiieiPeewoofcvtahrsyWiAhmnumicgiesaitteeltan'hihmPdtsi-aeruvgtiAhSdrsynneireuO,iatEenattgyrnnoihndflcZu.oufdnadeltsilnlaenecreaTmapreaesodEtihhudltrirttoaPoouoyitosdbhfhrrnAnofoeeiheopistdffo'bgghhossyrrGrtioiuuehnrmiettneirvbllmosydnwaangisiuwnpstttetfoefiooeitaaeesnfrfohrnriteeteastnynyeeeartt,.lt
{01041.001 / 111 / 00209140.DOCX}
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tier 3/4
ED 002061 00068623-00003
PPG Comments re: Evaluation of Existing Regulations DPaogceke4t ID No. EPA-HQ-OA-2017-0190
Fteaoacincrrlaoeileuclsoyntmt,. fimonreonnreddcetehrsesfoaWrrysPttSarateriunslieanngbdealnroedcvacilseeartduifttihocoadrtiietolinaey,s ttthoheeimPePfpfGleecmetinvecenotdutarhateegeufsinnttahiller2Tu0la1es8,kaaFntodtrhcteoe C. NPeasttioicnidale GPeonlleurtaalnPt erDmisict h(ParGgPe) Elimination System (NPDES)
ilipbpTrRrumwrsaamiseeetpeeernthosuieqqseissiptrpuegdtnduhttuuelhoieiaegiiliaicrcoPescdtntrretisiiiesdeaPhtddioqotainstm.iiGeeecnupnion,oeAit,cpiaendhuxanribrunpe2evptsaasoElrtap0diempoetsvglArlP1fliieegpaii1onctActadcnsoeenofattCdaositdtinvstttdob(l,nwihkiueFegceryocpeeacsrIracoinereFsnihdsrpevsmEsaepTReesteolPpassspaAairWeats,oneAdesrofule)seakifnena.amstgelatntirstefcnarAcmiepFeeuoddaetiierpesorlsldlgodlenoattrenuuocdoAcuarphsrnleentcslew.eacuitatoeapnrstitmtFirt.ereetogothdicos6hdacra(ei.oWfiCttairnnlhSdruenuWgadetpaecunhdnrnsehstotCcAdeeyeovsmherei)rtuideartklisrrmoncccaroolntpetoiubdetcnohedohcgeriesuemnweftoderutlrmdimmgkllaenitCeaFneoehnanpgidmtnoeestpetdelgt.pttyudapoidrireinrenuldUeUnetwirrggoqcieignacnfngftdoiuivloidtiocbtaforihitmhearIrereudnaeAnoorteqdvrmFisnmsundoupeFIedsumewntrpiFeScIirsnnseFmnRtireteeiisplaaeRtmcntlA.eosletvyiistAen,nfsdiTeaseotciren,ltih.lndiweiht,contdeecaqsiecgePFcdelpupafuPeineuepofNsitrfndGestirniopolosoeeetcPigcrpPiacnrtnmcDeaisopaa,.cei.sswplstpedEixssloideIntlyenaoStFryinseetsbscgsctIpsc,neaiiFPaefctasftaaachiRuGtioiitlrnnohdvaessarsAoPnnddoeedeeettf bhiliTTresdaaCelneensunaelhhWgccnrifrvddeedvaloedeAiueilrnsrseapcdddosednjeouticlekenvisswnatahsnoe.meoewg,ligeeprnmTliaepnrslaatnihelnueiitarnnlcanyged,tyigygllatguyua.BaplllleaidineaeenahTfhrcigdtrfenbnstaaihecaiqottlrgsoceedolemuntsnnoantjliefheote.eroooonCseedCfrTorrpmoeWftnpZvhiashsunoeeiieioroeAotnkasdtnmsultPtacytiairyrsnteGccaetvci--fiidioMnseiorPdtaruunionsnmeuzposmluisestpostnceaa.nrqfltocripyliChuneloucp.usiabWlatltuddhetuoitpAcoinAeedaotabsnrCrhpgcsstecafioceeaooiontuntrttpbhrnoiwcprtzeieraernieaorouotddntatnllrnvelettikeechDoidscrssgonlereuibiievnvsorsnicedpienttineooysrFrveeiuolofItccnecaflanFhntotndtotiimidRarotlinosucntnAtteantporrhhhlnsWeeawmleoaatencailintgbatttdrdtloshesdhaiscsbhdattfotupmCeitaoibnPnnebnlWreegltGrgesdrcemtmtfoAooooPtaimlptmnion.tirevnsstooteTeSreiioqsrpsoaahddttuqotllapeupoiaurattrrrptraieottoeceitsilhro-osttnishtciecronj-uygvooacebauslistnitaottrtiniaihtoctorvesrtnnaeinleoesondyesas,.,tlf TofheInPtPenGt reacnodmamnennudasl srceaploinrgtinbgackantdherepceorrmdiktetienpginrgeqrueiqreumireemntesnttos,elaismiwnealtle aNsottihcee
{01041.001 / 111 / 00209140.DOCX}
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tier 3/4
ED 002061 00068623-00004
PPG Comments re: Evaluation of Existing Regulations DPaogceke5t ID No. EPA-HQ-OA-2017-0190
pfoerrmthoits'sejpoeinrmt aitntdedseavcteirvailtileisabthilaittyaprreocvoismiopnl.etAelny owpiethraintohr issh/hoeurldcoonntlryolb. e held liable II. Process and Policy Reform TtPrmseeshoeunseh,atatsvseaintttmiutaiarTicfoinogaoinanddnetrasemmeemkbdarleenFpetnnhFdro$ttaoeIr2.mFndc5pTfRedu0iorxhcAiussoettahnsu,trfoodarepeupvatuoeltla2odiassio8fytlepiacn0aceoboiafsnvidfoltmspaeiirvtcirseiydiirilsdteeletauioetrigolycnfunlidoardlroeaenoefwtrtgglsopogeiiedrosoaysteinverntredaivdaicrtagerirdiclrdcooeruuaioesrnesayopiistpuoretworesnapoff-nirodptmroschiruetdsemausckuktdltmsicasiycntbaoti,iigodeosnf.lenaaEiWgnnhpPuetdaursAehmnomegi'ddrslsereeauanpgnpcanltri.tupoostsobptthcrilreesriaiosnceanvscgtlteerthusahidgtelniarascdatblpaaittyonpelehnnodd.toEsldipTcPptteihhAaheeseneesrt. fpfIrttFurEtwrcmeeSeqorrlaeneeclpprniuIaPaaaaorlsegmfoFiiaewenmniAspddtvdlirRnsversoissseeeeeietaleeraotpgpAmmicalchdonrrmosiiuatraeasalfcciienlssara.nrootgsaeyepSdceeliebstlllnryo,iedAnoosnpoietnsele.rggcEyrntsPitexs,opyiisterciPccvsytpcelpEraeaaoyAmaaoooiogo,srnnPdllonscpstu'soiedsdeAa,fauenosalnvsntsadtrrtpcvsri--Etheuetahtdi.eroloruosreuedwPdeaanieTkrdtrfsgddilAsroessoye-eiihdiiltemdbrrs'nsfiiessetseaaamotfghrsivrosilatvicenarrealaaaosrndheeeitatgnoktkshridddaqlperfencokloiayratauyennionartaretntmsicopgemaseaxrtngityjiesccsoephrauecEreqodsospeadodsiacimsePlufvndlretstotdslosbouAeaisleubmgrseislyceddlsraneeaim'iwteerscietorscgrvetsytatonaseklhhshasaleunantFsheontiaetsrrtpindstuhIfaa,hditivrspFdrIssenseeauanirekpiRwlcmsontepuifdseeAadoisacpsiasCaalnstgbeecrlilrtshnnuonmoianiovhsrcelydltdfniSeiaeiiesianofratigscdscosrieytnrtscherieiuoeuggretmoewafraoldtiunnclsunnthsnaeoesalhrtlktnedscaiidaenrcldfQnirtletoccatintidoraarivpcokrvluvattefrfsipeceahneamosoyepslyonrcetlooAurerhirtiomadeopfdslctiidpalfrtyfesdenopoinvoovysdmaccuagsofstifseArei.ascuscrueserxrloaetiecdiintenloubpbEosrdthxyypd.ftyiakonarFiPprslrseelcsosiEIorAvftvnamuerFeityrPedPiadisdhtrnostRx,ehasuaeAlsissmaeiw.pckeniacA--edet'nlaosiissedaeadnbslsEslawrdptctprgmiusdbgithPnleeroeoa.rriyfeoelnAetesiyuonileyOpn(nta.etytlrSinhohskrtdtfcttTAaiahthhaeshriioiffnnndeoehioasePraoeosrddgdneeeenesrrt)r,r. AAI"oFnfsdrsampeDmusibensecmliwisectemornarnbtktsoeiortffinocore2rsP0hI1aeon6nsuct,dliodcriEcpdrPooeemvArsa"i'metsi(wnFegnOraatfmnHfidaceunewrmdeovaorriknfse)eq.PEuTtepihrhsieetdiissecfmirFdasriemtoaamlkeoPwegehrwioocorgolkdrr&akewmrhIistnarhscevi(indOnioeepPwtnuPtb.t)eDefArnroasemttlaheseuaricsensehlued,bRvjtaiehisnctkestt
{01041.001 / 111 / 00209140.DOCX}
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tier 3/4
ED 002061 00068623-00005
PPC Comments re: Evaluation of Existing Regulations DPaogceke6t ID No. EPA-HQ-OA-2017-0190
sdteackiesihoonl-dmerask,inagn.d subject to peer review, before it is used to inform any regulatory pTrcoeorfhlonietdeshsuPeercPsovteGsna.trivevenecerceiofniuaatnrbadalgecetuissocnanisesruneptutipufniortcnirltientfodpuuarlttih.rmiesTrkiht-aerbteiaPvosPineeGdswarapearcpneordomanrmceohfteinnthpdelasmatcdeienesdltfasayioiernn,ngtsruttahhrneeesspetfhianrapaetelniszott,aivcteaiirondlnyed
CONCLUSION iiATFrrmFceanmeerngoihdfeaggnsrrpeodymuuaciulrcilellePrmbileaau'eynmsPlvttlee,iiitGeseoodurnatsntnnerrchnatarasscdiaoyepletoihtdigsnvpiimoreoinoucerennmeetnlrgngeat.cwuoevertiroetlsanioieWatrsttdrfsaotehyteooeeslnssdruindultdyptroehehlecaarowtcraeenureekiittstgtsvnnihoihfufifoeropoeyirilunnronwraprislswncimtdoeht,orgiessraeierthraperyawusdonnsesnaaudecvitwnryoldtoihedydsrniefaontwoontvhetneormosxoesmmtsutaridptaeckrmeaerennianotgcanidvedtnrvcrgtaaieoehteiralriadqwotoandsoteaunnthtdesnhams.feidltan.iuoenaecpprcpAnenttTruiafuhdotosfhlttabeceniielamlerocnsihubstncnaeisisetvoaghseuhnrervsshoeceeeiaacglrafsraitieineutlgibtntstogidslhahtdsea,nuhstst.ealeeppi,aoodandoratfnTsodlonisstoacrmeiadiynsisnbcfektaoEtoasbsnisrvPnoFouoytetcnAhmoruh,edraneefecsetedfehmncfdThwooaseaaaaausrrinnnvtosetlaskhydddensl. Sincerely,
ECthhaairn, MPeastthiceiwdes Policy Coalition
VBiecaeuCGhraeier,nwPeosotdicide Policy Coalition
{01041.001 / 111 / 00209140.DOCX}
Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA
Tier 3/4
ED 002061 00068623-00006