Document Qg7MgypYVporoax7Yyp3pdz85

Message From: Sent: To: CC: Su bject : Ringel, Aaron [/0=EXCHANGELABS/OU=EXCHANGE ADMINISTRATIVE GROUP (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/CN=RECIPIENTS/CN=1654BDC951284A6D899A418A89FB0ABF-RINGEL, AAR] 6/7/2018 3:19:18 PM [ Ex. 6 l@valero.com] !_____ .Ex. 6______ja)afpm.org];! Ex. 6 i@marathonpetroleum.com]; Freeland, Jeff K. EOP/WHO | Ex. 6 " '] " Re:"[XT"E^ " L e t ' s do Ex. 6 S e n t fro m my iP hone > On J un 7, 2018, a t 1 1 :1 7 AM, [ ________________ Ex. 6________________ j@val e r o . com> w r o te : > -------------------- > My God ; E X . 6 ! > l------------------- ' > S e n t fro m my iP hone > ....................................... On Dun 7, 2018, a t 1 1 :1 3 AM, ! Ex. 6 j@ afpm .org> w ro te : r ------------------- . ---------------------- -" " i J ! Ex. 6 s? i t ' s j Ex. 6 -------- a c . i. a ijm l. . . M e - s . s a . a e ________ From:! Ex. 6 j@ m a ra th o n p e tro l eum. com> se n To: ! Ex. 6 j@val e.ro.,.CQ.m>-_________ _ Ce : uRihge"T7"' a r rT V F ngT7aro"n@ep` '.`gov> ; Ex. 6 j@ afpm .org> ; F re e la n d , D e ff K. EOP/WHO [ Ex". 6 ! u--------------------------------------- ! >>" "Su B J e e t T"Re ^RKiTJ" hur sday ________ _ I ' m s t i l l f i n e w it h ! Ex. 6 ! Open t o o th e r s u g g e s tio n s to o ____________________________ _ > On Dun 7, 2018 , a t 1 1 :1 0 AM, ! Ex. 6 j@ valero.com > w ro te : > > I ' m 100% on bo a rd no RFS d is c u s s io n , and 50% on b e in g a b le t o make i t . Where do you a l l w a n t t o do it? > > S e n t fro m my i Phone > on Dun 7, 2018, a t 1 1 :0 6 AM, R in g e l, A a ro n < rin g e l.a a ro n @ e p a .g o v > w r o te : >> 100% f i n e by me! > > S e n t fro m my iP hone > On Dun 7, 2018, a t 1 1 :0 5 AM, ! x. 6 lO m a ra th o n p e tro l eum. com> w r o te : > > I ' m s t i l l i n ! D u st as lo n g as we d o n ' t t a l k a b o u t th e RFS. > On Dun 7, 2018, a t 9 :5 2 AM, R in g e l, A aron <r in g e l . aaron@ epa.gov> w r o te : .---------- -j So a re we d o in g t h i s t h in g t o n i g h t o r n o t? I know ; Ex. 6 p s s u p e r pumped a b o u t th e caps and a l l . . . . 1------- : -Aaron >> ---------9r.igj.n^...M .sA ag.-.--r..-________________ , From :! Ex. 6 i@ m arathonpetroleum .com ] Sent J T o : j________________ lx_-6_________________ i . v a l e r p _ . . c o m > P mo rg > Cc: F re e la n d , J e f f K. EOP/WHO [_______________ Ex.6 _______________ R in g e l, A aron <r in g e l. aaron@ epa.gov> S u b je c t: RE: [EXTERNAL] RE: T h u rs d a y >>>>>>--------- ! r---------------------------------------------------- , ! Ex. 6 jh a s a ! Ex. 6 >> ' 1 --------- O r ig in a l M essage-------- From: [m a il to : 9valero.com ] Sent: June 0 7 , 2018 8 :5 3 AM > > To: tfpm.org> Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA 8.14.2020 Production ED 002061 00157606-00001  > > Ce : i._____________ Ex-.A______________ i@ m a ra th o n p e tro l eum .com >; F re e la n d , J e f f K. EOP/WHO <; 'x.' |> ; R in g e l, A aron c r i n g e l . aaron@ epa. g o v> 5g jg 't;'" Re'':''-'[i)aRNAL]''' RE: Thursday And to t h in k I was a b o u t to i n v it e you! Ex. 6 S ent fro m my i Phone On Jun 7, 2018, a t 8 :4 9 A M ,[ Ex. 6 j@ afpm.org> w ro te : T hought y i nz T h u rs d a y . Ex. 6 il h e a r i t ' s bumpi ng on a S ent fro m my i Phone On Jun 7, 2018, a t 8 :0 5 AM, I th o u g h t we w ere i Ex. 6 Ex. 6 i@ m arathonpetroleum .com > w ro te : On Jun 7, 2018, a t 7 :5 8 AM, i________________ _____________________ !@val e r o . com> w ro te : We can do 1a t e r in th e month I f t h a t w o rk s S ent fro m my i Phone On Jun 5, 2018, a t B: 52 PM, F re e l a n d , J e f f K. EOP/WHO -f ' g- . - --- > w rote : I ' m s e e i ng i f ! _______________ Ex: 6_______________ l I f t h a t f a l l s th r o u g h , I ' l l do w h a te v e r . S t i 11 t r y i n g t o f i g u r e t h a t p ie c e o u t , b u t i f i t d o e s n ' t , w i l l 1i k e ly h o s t o r we can h i t a b a r . -------- O.ri.gi .na_l__Mes_s_age_-------- F rom : [ _______Ex_6_______ '@ afpm .org> Sentri._Tue.sday.,...Ju n e..3!.L...20JL8...B.: 0.2 PM ,__________________ , T a.:..!,____________ Ex._6______________ m a ra th o n p e tro l eum. com>; [ Ex. 6 j Ex. 6 [Valero.com >; R in g e l, Aaron crin g e l.a a ro n @ e p a .g o v > C 'c r'F re e la n d , J e f f K. EOP/WHO f "exIF * ' i S u b je c t: RE: [EXTERNAL] RE: T h u rs d a y We d o n ' t n e c e s s a r il y need t o keep p u s h in g i t . We can keep and n o t w a it a n o th e r m o n th . Or we can j u s t do b o th . Ex. 6 -------- pr.ia.Da.l...Mes5ja.a.e--.--.r_________ , From : i_______ ,______5/:..______ ,, _______i@mar a t hon p e t r o l eum. com> sent;.:...Tji&s.day.^..J.unfi...5.*...2.(11.8...S.:lL9..AM..., r------- . T o : ;________________ E x .6 _______________ j@ vale r o . com>; Ri ng e l , A aron < r i ng e l . aaron@ epa.gov> ; | Ex. 6 j@ afpm .org> JCc: F re e la n d , J e f f K. EOP/WHO <f x'.' ] S u b je c t: RE: [EXTERNAL] RE: T h u rs d a y I ' m f i ne movi ng i t t o th e n to o soL..^?.-..6_.l can c h e e r f o r th e Kni g h t s . I ' m f o r w h a te v e r, w anted t o j o i n to o when he h e a rd we w ere d o in g t h i s happy h o u r . Ex. 6 ix. 6 -------- Qri._qj.nal_ .Mes.sa_qe_----.7_______________________ F rom : [ ____________________ Ex: 6____________________ j@ val e r o . com] S e n t: T u e s d a y , June 0 5 , 2018 9 :1 7 AM r------------------------------ , T o : Ri ngel , Aaron < r i ngel . aaron@ epa.gov> ; i Ex. 6 jSafpm._o_rg>________________ Cc: F re e la n d , J e f f K. EOP/WHO { Exl 6 ]>; j Ex. 6 m arathonpetroleum .com > L L S u b je c t: [EXTERNAL] RE: T h u rs d a y Or we can do i t t h a t 1a s t week o f June : ) Ex. 6 ------------Q .c .iri.i.n a .]...J V U is .s .a n p .= .---------- F rom : [ ______Ex._6_______ j S e n t: T u e s d a y , June 5, 2018 8 :1 7 AM T o : ' Ri ngel , Aaron ' < r i ngel . aaron@ epa. g o v > ; I Cc: F re e l a n d , J e f f K. EOP/WHO < :@ marathonpetroleum.com> Ex. 6 S u b je c t : RE: T h u rs d a y Ex. 6 i@afp.m...q_rq.> 1 --Ex. 6 I ' 11 [_____________________ __________________________ ! b e fo r e I g iv e i t up. -------- O ri g i n a l M essage--------From : Ri ng e l , A aron [mai 1to : r i n g e l . aaron@ epa. g o v ] Sent1L._TudayJ-..lunfiL-iL.-.2l8.-.8i.l6.-AM.., To: j_______________ _Ex._6__________ ..>>>.>>>>>>> Cc: F r e e l a n d , J e f f K. EP/WH f b@ vale r o -. c-o-m->-; Ex. 6 i@marathonpetroleum.com> l" Ex. 6 .Maf.p.m_,_qr.g> Ex. 6 Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA 8.14.2020 Production ED 002061 00157606-00002 S u b j e c t : RE: T h u rs d a y I ' m wi t hi____Ex. 6___ j i ' m [_________ a u d ib le on o u r p r e v io u s ly scheduled d r i n k s . Ex. 6 -Aaron - 0 r i.a ln a]...Me ssacie- From: [ Ex. 6 S e n t: Monday, June 4 , 2018 1 0 :0 1 PM @ valero.com] To: L . a `Fpm. or g> .>>.>>>>>>>> c c : F re e ia n d , j e f ? k . eop/ who L7.7.7.7.7.7.7.7.7.7.7.7.7.7."r."rji;."i!."r."r."r."r."r.r."r."r."r."r."r."r."r."r."r."r.J:>; l i E x .6 p@ m arathonpetroleum .com >; R in g e l, Aaron < r in g e l. aa ro n ife p a . gov> i S u b je c t: Re: T h u rsd a y s o ld . [ ______________________________ S ent fro m my iP h o n e On Jun 4 , 2018, a t 8 :5 6 PM, I Ex. 6 Ex. 6 land I a re w e a rin g Pens je r s e y s . i@afpm.org> w r o te : S ent fro m my iP h o n e On Jun 4 , 2018, a t 9: 5 2 PM, F r e e ia n d , J e f f K. EOP/WHO 4_ Ex. 6 x. 6 > > > > Caps p la y t h a t n i g h t . W i l l have t o cancel i f t h a t ' s th e ni g h t o r you can [ i x. 6 i c a l l i n g an Ex. 6 >> > Sierra Club v. EPA 18cv3472 NDCA 8.14.2020 Production ED 002061 00157606-00003