Document QXxnz4oRmRrJ0paqM49yw4q76

. L/Li'i. WJC CD/ UH/ CD URL 08161 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO WESTERN DIVISION FRED A. WALLACE 881 N.W. Columbia Street Port Charlotte, Florida 33948 ) ) ETTA W. WALLACE 881 N.W. Columbia Street Port Charlotte, Florida 33948 ) ) ANGELA MAY WALLACE, by Etta W. Wallace, her mother, natural guardian, and next friend, 881 N.W. Columbia Street Port Charlotte, Florida 33948 ) ) ) ) and SARAH JOANNE WALLACE, by Etta W. Wallace, her mother, natural guardian, and next friend, 881 N.W. Columbia Street Port Charlotte, Florida 33948 Plaintiffs, -vs- ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) Murray 5 Murray A 1(0*1 fC't55i?N*t as CHRYSLER PLASTIC PRODUCTS CORPORATION 3130 West Monroe Street Sandusky, Ohio 44870 CHRYSLER PLASTIC PRODUCTS CORPORATION c/o C T Corporation System Statutory Agent 815 Superior Avenue, N.E. Cleveland, Ohio 44114 CO.L P A ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ] 9ANDUBRY. OHIO 44470 CASE NO. C 84-7864 Nicholas J. Walinski, Judge FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT Jury Demand Endorsed Hereon AKE V. LJUNG ) General Manager ) Chrysler Plastic Products Corporation ) Sandusky, Ohio 44870 ) Current address unknown ) NORMAN P. PHILLIPS 1819 Millsboro Road East Mansfield, Ohio 44906 ) ALBERT W. CRAMER 1427 Chandler Drive, S.E. Huntsville, Alabama 35801 ) ) ) ROBERT D. GUSTINE 5183 Christine Drive Ann Arbor, Michigan 48103 ) ) ) ) ) RICHARD ALTHISER ) Production Color Department Supervisor ) Chrysler Plastic Products Corporation ) Sandusky, Ohio 44870 Current address unknown RON C. ABBOTT ) ) Production Color Department Supervisor) Chrysler Plastic Products Corporation ) Sandusky, Ohio 44870 ) Current address unknown ) WILLIAM C. HOLSAPPLE ) ) Production Color Department Supervisor) Chrysler Plastic Products Corporation ) Sandusky, Ohio 44870 ) Current address unknown ) THE GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY ) ) 1144 East Market Street ) Akron, Ohio 44305 ) MONSANTO COMPANY 800 North Lindbergh Boulevard ) ) ) St. Louis, Missouri 63167 ) B. F. GOODRICH COMPANY ) ) 500 South Main Street ) Akron, Ohio 44318 ) ) Murray 5 Murray co l r a a 9 9QC AT.* C ft * 4 * ' ftANDUSKY, OHIO -2 c u s tn ti11 FIRESTONE TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY 1200 Firestone Parkway Akron, Ohio 44317 CONOCO, INC. 1007 Market Street Wilmington, Delaware 19898 UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION Old Ridgebury Road, Section C-2 Danbury, Connecticut 06817 UNIROYAL, INC. World Headquarters Middlebury, Connecticut 06749 ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) \ y DIAMOND SHAMROCK CORPORATION 717 North Harwood Street ) Dallas, Texas 75201 ) POLIMEROS de MEXICO Current address unknown ) ) ) KANEMATSU-GOSHO (USA), INC. One World Trade Center New York, New York 10048 ) ) ) ) ) JOHN DOE, INC., I ) Polyvinyl chloride resin manufacturer ) Current address unknown ) ) JOHN DOE, INC., II ) Polyvinyl chloride resin manufacturer ) Current address unknown ) ) JOHN DOE, INC., Ill ) Polyvinyl chloride resin manufacturer ) Current address unknown ) ) JOHN DOE, INC., IV ) Polyvinyl chloride resin manufacturer ) Current address unknown ) JOHN DOE, INC. , V ) ) Polyvinyl chloride resin manufacturer ) Current address unknown ) ) Defendants. ) Murray & Murray co l p a ) a iCO*L 0'CSS<C--l ASSOCIATION lAMOUlKY. OHid 44470 -3- FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION Now come plaintiffs and, for their first amended complaint against defendants, state as follows: 1. Plaintiff Fred A. Wallace (hereinafter "Wallace") was, at all times pertinent hereto, a resident of Erie County, Ohio, and worked at Chrysler Plastic Products Corporation's plant in Erie County, Ohio. 2. Defendant Chrysler Plastic Products Corporation (herein after "Chrysler") is a corporation incorporated in the State of Delaware. Chrysler is licensed to do business in the State of Ohio and, at all times pertinent hereto, has transacted business and maintained operations inErie County, Ohio, known as the Sandusky facility, that gave rise to the activ URL 08164 ities and claims set forth herein. 3. Defendants Ake V. Ljung, Norman P. Phillips, Albert W. Cramer, Robert D. Gustine, Richard Althiser, Ron C. Abbott, and William C. Holsapple (collectively referred to hereinafter as "Individual Defendants") are present and/or former employees of Chrysler and, at all times pertinent hereto, exercised direct and/or ultimate supervision in a management capacity over Wallace and/or the Sandusky facility. At least one of the Individual Defendants is a resident of the State of Ohio. 4. Defendants The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company, Monsanto Company, B. F. Goodrich Company, Firestone Tire & Rubber Company, Conoco, Inc., Union Carbide Corporation, Uniroyal, Inc., Diamond Shamrock Corporation, Polimeros de Mexico, and Kanematsu-Gosho (USA), Inc., and defendants John Doe, Inc., I, John Doe, Inc., II, John Doe, Inc., Ill, John Doe, Inc., IV, Murray & Murray co .l r a. a .ec.*. SAL ASSOCIATION aTTOOnCt* at * AW -4- and John Doe, Inc., V, whose current addresses plaintiffs, with due diligence, have not been able to uncover (collectively referred to hereinafter as the "PVC Resin Manufacturers") are corporations incorporated and with a principal place of business in Ohio, a foreign state, or a foreign country, which, at times relevant hereto, have been in the business of manufacturing and selling to the Sandusky facility of Chrysler in Erie County, Ohio, polyvinyl chloride resin, a substance containing the vinyl chloride monomer, a known carcinogen. 5. Wallace was employed at the Sandusky facility of Chrysler continuously between October 9, 1972, and April 19, 1978. 6. At all times since the commencement of his employment at the Sandusky facility of Chrysler, Wallace has inhaled, ingested and/oVabsorbed into his body quantities of toxic and carcinogenic substances, including polyvinyl chloride resin and vinyl chloride monomer as a direct and proximate result of the activities Wallace was required to perform in his employment at Chrysler's Sandusky facility. 7. The levels of toxic and carcinogenic substances, including polyvinyl chloride resin and vinyl chloride monomer, to which Wallace was exposed were above safe levels, permissible exposure limits, and threshold limit values. 8. Wallace's continuous, repeated exposure to toxic and carcinogenic substances, including polyvinyl chloride resin and vinyl chloride monomer, at the Sandusky facility of Chrysler has: (a) caused Wallace serious physical injuries, including cancer and associated pathologies, all of which are permanent; Murray & Murray co.l p. a URL 08165 SAHCUgKY OHIO 4447Q -5- URL 03166 (b) inflicted upon Wallace severe continuing physical and mental pain and suffering and extreme emotional distress; (c) rendered Wallace permanently and totally disabled from employment; (d) repeatedly required Wallace to obtain necessary hospital and medical care and will require same for the remainder of Wallace's life; (e) resulted in a permanent loss of Wallace's earning capacity; (f) shortened Wallace's life expectancy. 9. At all times since Wallace's date of hire, Chrysler and the Individual Defendants knew or should have known that the work performed by Wallace at the Sandusky facility gave rise to the inhalation, ingestioh and/or absorption into his body of quantities of toxic and carcinogenic substances, including polyvinyl chloride resin and vinyl chloride monomer, the dangerous propensities of which were known to, or should have been known by, Chrysler and the Individual Defendants. 10. Chrysler and the Individual Defendants intentionally exposed Wallace to toxic and carcinogenic substances, including polyvinyl chloride resin and vinyl chloride monomer, at unsafe levels during the course of Wallace's employment at the Sandusky facility of Chrysler as a condition of continued employment, as a result of which Wallace sustained the injuries and losses referred to herein. 11. During the course of Wallace's employment with Chrysler, Chrysler and the Individual Defendants intentionally withheld and/or concealed from Wallace and his physicians material information and warnings concerning the toxic and carcinogenic substances to which Wallace was continuously and Murray & Murray co i. p. a AT ,.4*. -6- repeatedly exposed, including polyvinyl chloride resin and vinyl chloride monomer, including information as to the dangerous propensities of such substances, the effects of overexposure to such substances on human health, signs and symptoms of overexposure, and the precautions to take to avoid overexposure. Chrysler and the Individual Defendants knew or should have known of the material nature of the information described herein, information concerning which Wallace and his physicians were unaware and unkncwledgeable. 12. Chrysler and the Individual Defendants knew or should have known of the serious health hazards to Wallace which would result from continuous, repeated exposure to the toxic and carcinogenic substances to which Wallace was exposed at Chrysler, including polyvinyl chloride retin and vinyl chloride monomer, health hazards which could have been prevented had Chrysler and the Individual Defendants fulfilled the duties and obligations enumerated herein. 13. Chrysler and the Individual Defendants, by their intentional conduct, failed to provide Wallace with a safe place to work. 14. Chrysler and the Individual Defendants, by their conduct, acted in willful and wanton disregard for the life, health, and safety of Wallace. 15. As a direct result of Chrysler's and the Individual Defend ants' intentional conduct, Wallace sustained the injuries and damages described herein. WHEREFORE, plaintiff Fred A. Wallace prays for compensatory damages from Chrysler and the Individual Defendants in the amount of ten Murray & Murray co *. a. URL 08167 S*NO'j9xr. OHIO 44070 -7- million dollars ($10,000,000.00); for punitive damages in the amount of ten million dollars ($10,000,000.00); for reasonable attorney and expert witness fees; and for such other and further relief as the Court deems proper. URL 08163 SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION 16. All well-pleaded allegations contained in paragraphs 1 through 15 of the First Cause of Action are repleaded as if fully rewritten herein. 17. The PVC Resin Manufacturers negligently failed to take proper steps to instruct and warn Wallace of the dangers of overexposure to polyvinyl chloride resin and vinyl chloride monomer; failed to provide Wallace with information on the dangerous carcinogenic propensities of polyvinyl chloride resin and vinyl chloride monomer; neglected to inform Wallace of the effects of overexposure to polyvinyl chloride resin and vinyl chloride monomer on human health; failed to instruct or warn Wallace concern ing the signs and symptoms of overexposure to polyvinyl chloride resin and vinyl chloride monomer; and failed to provide information to Wallace as to precautions to prevent overexposure to polyvinyl chloride resin and vinyl chloride monomer. 18. Polyvinyl chloride resin and vinyl chloride monomer are inherently dangerous products as to which the PVC Resin Manufacturers are strictly liable. Polyvinyl chloride resin and vinyl chloride monomer were sold by the PVC Resin Manufacturers in a defective condition unreasonably dangerous to Wallace. Said polyvinyl chloride resin and vinyl chloride Murray & Murray co i_ p a 8ANDVSKV. OHIO 4447Q -8- monomer reached Wallace without substantial change in the condition in which they were sold. 19. The above-described actions and omissions of the PVC Resin Manufacturers were in willful and wanton disregard of the life, health, and safety of the ultimate users of their product, including Wallace. 20. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of the PVC Resin Manufacturers described herein, Wallace sustained the injuries and damages enumerated above. WHEREFORE, plaintiff Fred A. Wallace prays for compensatory damages from the PVC Resin Manufacturers in the amount of ten million dollars (510,000,000.00); for punitive damages in the amount of ten million dollars (510,000,000.00); for reasonable attorney and expert witness fees; and for such other and further relief as the Court deems proper. URL 03169 THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION 21. All well-pleaded allegations contained in paragraphs 1 through 20 of the First and Second Causes of Action are repleaded as if fully rewritten herein. 22. As a direct and proximate result of the conduct of Chrysler and the Individual Defendants and the PVC Resin Manufacturers described herein, plaintiff Etta W. Wallace has incurred loss of consortium of her husband, Fred A. Wallace; and plaintiffs Angela May Wallace and Sarah Joanne Murray & Murray co.l * a. AANOU6KY OH'O MATO -9- Wallace, the children of Fred A. and Etta W. Wallace, have incurred loss of consortium of their father. WHEREFORE, plaintiff Etta W. Wallace prays for compensatory damages in the amount of five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000.00); and plaintiffs Angela May Wallace and Sarah Joanne Wallace pray for compensatory damages in the amount of two hundred fifty thousand dollars ($250,000.00) each. tienn i s E^f-faTray Kirk J. Del 1i Bovi MURRAY & MURRAY CO., L.P.A. Attorneys at Law 300 Central Avenue Sandusky, Ohio 44870 Telephone: 1-419-627-9700 Attorneys for Plaintiffs JURY DEMAND Plaintiffs hereby demand trial by jury. Dennis Murray Kirk J. Delli Bovi MURRAY & MURRAY CO., L. P. A. Attorney for Plaintiffs oaR O idn Murray & Murray co l p * A cCOAL iSftOC'*TCN AT'0N!*8 A -r LAW flANOUlir. OHIO AA?0 -10- CERTIFICATION This is to certify that a copy of the foregoing instrument was served upon defendant Chrysler Plastic Products Corporation in the foregoing cause by sending a copy of same by ordinary mail with postage prepaid addressed to M. DONALD CARMIN, Eastman & Smith, 800 United Savings Building, Toledo, Ohio 43604-1141, on this day of May , 1985. Denni s" t^tturray Kirk J.HteTli Bovi MURRAY & MURRAY CO., L. P. Attorneys for Plaintiffs URL 08171 Murray & Murray co l b * A- U4* SANDUSKY, OHIO 444 70 -11- SUMMONS IN A CIVIL ACTION ^Unitril plates district Court FRED A. WALLACE, et al. , O'iTHiCT Northern District of Ohio. Western Division___ DOC*J NO. C 84-7864 V. CHRYSLER PLASTIC PRODUCTS Plaintiffs, CORPORATION, et al., TO. (NAME ANO AOORtiiOf OCFENOANTi Uniroyal, Inc. World Headquarters Middlebury, Connecticut 06749 Defendants. YOU ARE HEREBY SUMMONED and required to serve upon PLAINTIFF'S ATTOflNtV (NAME ANO AOORESS) Dennis E. Murray MURRAY & MURRAY CO., L. P. A. Attorneys at Law 300 Central Avenue Sandusky, Ohio 44870 Telephone: 1-419-627-9700 --------- ------ -------- ^-- ------------------------------------------------------------ an answer to the complaint which is herewith served upon you. within twenty (20) days after service of this summons upon you. exclusive of the day of service. If you fail to do so, judgment by default will be taken against you for the relief demanded in the complaint. ZO r~ co ~-j CLERK ( 8 V) OCPUTV CLERK 5. Gaiiaa tana smith DATE mar s-1985 RETURN OF SERVICE Service of the Summons and Complaint was made by me* name OF SERVER DATE title Check one box pe/pw to indicate appropriate method of service D Served personally upon the defendant. Piece where, served Left copies thereof at the defendant's dwelling house or usual place of abode with person of suitable age and drscretion then residing therein. Name of person with whom the summons and complaint were left: _______ _ D Other (specify)__________________________________________________________________________________________________ ________________ TRAVE L STATEMENT OF SERVICE FEES SERVICES TOTAL DECLARATION OF SERVER I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that the foregoing information contained m the Return of Service and Statement of Service Fees is true and correct. Executed on______ 0#r* Signature of Server AdcJreu 0/ Server a ^ -J J i 1 -J \ i a 71--3 CD CO -J I i 1) Al Id :>r> wra O 4 O' r< f oel u*ai 3* Cii-il Pi&caOu-'a