Document Q5bQ1gnr4bD19Q8EKRdV6qp6

FILE NAME: Oil Industry and American Petroleum Institute (API) DATE: 1935 Nov DOC#: API089 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: Trade Journal Editorial RE The Copeland Bill Volume 27 N umber 11 INDUSTRIAL AND ENGINEERING \J EI TL HT7i JTLVVX/TXT0O TX D \ V X N ovember 1935 Harrison E. Howe, Editor E D I T O R I A L S HbyEthCeOSPeEnLatAeNthDe CBoILpeLl.andABsiplla,sSse.5d, culnelaetssinthSeecctoionnte2x0t1o, twhehriwchisesaiynsd,ic"aatsesu.s"ed Iinn tthhiiss saecct, wamasendmmaetenrtiawllhyichwseeavkeerneelyd libmyitsamn ultiptoilpeoinnsiweoienzufriwnesditho"iafnndththeeirterremsp`escciteivnetififcieoldpsinioofn'cmoemapnesttehnet T Not only does tmhiesbbrialnl daesdnporwodbuecftos.re -a committee pthhiasrmlaancgoulaoggeisatsp,ppehayrseidolmogoirsets,thoarntoaxiycoealorgaisgtos,."ofWfichiaelns oshfatlhl ebeHionussteitustpeedciifny ctahsaets onfotmmisborraentdhinagn, obnuet siet ipzurore tohfotsheeinAamuetrhiocraitny CtohelmeaircnalhoSwoctiheitsywcoounldferarfefdectwtihthe rhiedreesm"otvheadt fsoaridtrisainlgtoletsheeizjuurreisdaiccttiioonnsohfatlhl,eocnlamimoatinotn's, cheUmnidset.r mOisnbermanudsetdgodrfuugrsthaenr dindtehveicbeisl,l tSoelcetaiornn t4h0i2s., rpersoimdeinnceen.t" offIemnadgeirnien thhies opwonssihboilmitey toowf nc!onvTihcteinpgura Paragraph B, we find: "Any representation concerning any effect of a drug or device shall be deemed to be .. ptioosnetoof tmheulptiupblelicsebizyursewieseptoingaffuoprdmiamtemrieadliaotfefeprerodtefocr false under this paragraph if such representation is not supported by demonstrable scientific facts or substantial tsrailde aonrddewchoimchpoisseedi;the(cr)(as)o idneimceipctailvteolyhmeailstbhr;an(dbe)dpuas and reliable medical or scientific opinion." The same language is to he found in the chapter on false advertise to be a definite cheat to the public; or (d) so grossly adulterated or misbranded as to be unquestionably ment, where, in Section 601A, this same sentence is used. First, it should be noted that there is a clear haTrmhofusel tsopohnosnoersitngmathneufaamcteunredrms.ent have made it im dopeminiaornc,ataionnd bthetawt eienneadcehmcoanssetrtahbeleapscpileincatitfiiocnfaiscttsoatnhde paonsdsihblaevtehustsefaadrfasismtlyultraenseisotuesdlythtoe pinrocltuescitoanllitnhethpeubdliec eafcfte,cttshoeffdorrutgesoofr tdheevicsecsie.ntiIsnt,thaendenifnorpceamrtiecnutloarf tthhies s"corripgtiroonssslyofdaerctiecpletisves.u"bjeTcht etyo hseaivzeuregroafcitohueslyphcraosne cthheeimr issto,uinsdininttehreprfeietaldtioonf.deFmuornthsetrramboleref,acatsmaannd biyn c"esodemditshberarnidgehdt atos tsoeizreenmdeurlttihpeleminimtemrsitnaetentlsyhidpamnegnetrs moreraeltyoxcaiclloilnogghisitmdsoeelfsanpohtatrhmearecoblyogbiesct,oma ephoynseioilnogtihste, oaguasitnosht egaroltshs"lybmutisabrreanudnwedilalirntgictloescoornsaegnatintostptrhootesectlieosns heyimesseolff tahcehceomuirstt, aanndd wthheo pcraonfebsesioqnuaallifmieadnbwefhoorecathlles dangerous than "imminently." This situation in itself shows conclusively the sort cmoaucrotloagsyo,npehysksiiollleodgyan, dorctoomxipcoeltoegnyt icnanthuenfqieuledstoiof npahbalry mofakopepiomspitoiossnibtlheaat hfualsl gbueeanranotregeanoifzepduriintyanofepffroordtutcot tesItnifyChinapthteorseIIb, rPanarcahgersaopfhsBci,enthcee.term "drug" for th>e aItndshoriuglhdteboeussudffeicaileinngt towirtahllythaell caodnvsoucmaitnegs opfusbulicch. ppurerppoarsaetsioonfsthriescoagcntizneodwiinnctlhudeesU"naitlel dsuSbstatatenscesPhaanrd lneogifsularttihoenrtowethakeesnuipnpgoarts oift thpaisssbeisll,ththeaHt iotumsea,yasnudffeirf mStaacteosp,eioar, NHaotmioenoaplaFthoircmPuhlaarrym, aocropaeniya soufptphleemUennittetdo poSssoimblee hcaovnefuitsiroengaienxissotms ereolfatthiveelostot grtohuends.tatus of ianncyluodifngtheatmto.r"neyWs,hitlheatitthise tphreeamcobnlteenatniodncoonftesxotmoef, cahleamwisctsanunindcelrudtheesbuiclhl. deIftinmituiosntsbeasremmaeymhbeerdeedemtheadt ttihoensacatrme atokebiet colnelayr tthhoastethceonscuebrsnteadnciens faonoddsp,redpruagras, wise for the purposes of that act alone. This is made and cosmetics, nevertheless the language may be too