Document Ob0pBo5291vwdX4NBv1m6Zgv

Page 3956 1 start by talking with you about some things that were 2 never in dispute. 3 First, there is no dispute, nor has there 4 ever been any dispute, about how Mr. Wood and Mr. 5 Grewe died. They died from mesothelioma just like Mr. 6 Ignatowski and Ms. Hines told you earlier. 7 Second, there is no dispute that 8 mesothelioma is painful. Like a lot of cancers, it 9 causes pain, and it requires larger and larger doses 10 of painkillers to keep it under control. 11 Third, there is no dispute that Mr. Wood's 12 and Mr. Grewe's illnesses and deaths, not only cost 13 their families money but also caused them emotional 14 pain. 15 Fourth and finally and probably the most 16 importantly, there is no dispute, nor has there ever 17 been any dispute, that the Woods and Ms. Grewe are 18 nice people. We saw that when they testified here 19 earlier. 20 So those are the things that are not in 21 dispute, and, in fact, they have never been in