Document O9eap9MjmOyLXv0MpV3emKY1
John T. Caution & Associates, Inc.
M'Cl4l64'< CNUI
*9r o**'C* io> n*
C0*.UI4U1. OHIO 4)1'#
4MCA C30t *14 121.414}
1 PLAINTIFF'S 4 EXHIBIT
cont/iow tiaviecs
WOHKHtN) eOW#tN*ATIN
gMCM*UOr`'KT C9M#tMAriON
ociu**Ti/s4t. a*err
Huy 14, 1973
Mr. CharLes M. Harvey Jta Walter Corneracion 1300 M. Dale Mabry Highway Taapa, Florida 33604
Dear Mr. Harvey:
U# have been sending you reucli iniovmetion about the feet thee asbestos has Laen highlighted as one of che dangerous substances to which employees in this country are exposed. W art herewith enclosing further Information for your reading.
\
You know that we had Hr. Thomas Hsncuso nxosine your plant for a year and although we haca to say It, his raeocunendation was to tear down the plant that had been built about a hundred years c;o and rebuild it so as to enclose all the exposures to esbestosis, not only for your employees, but for tne renters and hewaowners around tha plant.
V believe that you ar incurring a substantial liability which would almost require that you substitute seme otlicr subf.tar.ee for asbestos, such a* fiber glass or other products.
W are in $ position to help you in this aria, and we hope that soiuatise in che future you will .return to us as a client.
Yours very truly,
JOH* T. CANTLOM &
JTC/bsa
uc: .`iv.
Mr. Mr.
JTarl
s. j
U J'.
rtnno.'i.rL A - Ml ias. ia*. asj;i :hai r ; . <\r 'tv.- `i ' i ** aw v,.,
Id* ..................
ty( r:n'.....ii `t.iy ix;.;. ,*.u>**. or lo.t'l >'i'*
.4 ii. ins. iii<i io; an* !r : ' ii.t.1 ynft "iK'H !' uatii. Mr
ia mu*ired nr.uer ini* mm. . , ` ^ii'ultiiv method at an a*
,.,r>o< has Vnm .approved by i*tor.
: ' .si 103 lu simcinJia 3 ` o lliia 4py apnrcvr:i v* tnc Album*
^. *** Alirfrrtm.vs Ticthnrt t.'r s .^*t 16 1 61-2-: 11 and i 51.43
.r' "... .AdutUuktPiior may, after no**. pwrief or cptraior. withdraw
an alientauve method .*-*' . ulor jwraorsifm *a) of Mi of
Where Me leal result* uin3 " *.vo method <ln not upchuatciy ** " -hether % jotires i m eompli . ,i standard. die Adinintstrnur
..ro Uie use of Mo reference ** . it* orpiiraienL
AwiUL*l!l* of iMfurmaliun.
**
.j+*y*** mU UvU*w* tw. w? ^oli** . tuirwei by. 'Jut Administrator in
.........e with Uie prormous of Mu ' .!* bo wrallaVie to tl*e public.
v : ecore*. n*ooru, ot in.'orrnn*
f 1.30 \
Tlic provixinn* f>l thit nitniart .i* n* iMir.ii.ie vo uicm rwurcou M>cv*flcd in t i 1.^3.
pcrtini: u'uvtMtai iivuu-.t tliat 1* lnut* lid/1.! rti* llrviiruni' h Mitli friuUo a*ls**inn mSUi'fii llinil vtiiiuhv 'vjtll lli rvii'.prt* (tu-jn*. rvt lotth .n Mi* :r-r.'rnih.
il> NotlvO of liiU'ntmn to ucni.'ii'P
f 01.31 iiriiiiiiiiio..
Miall Ue iirovuluti in the .vttmniMi\..<'-
Term). u.ied ::: 11.1.'. subnart re delined in to*: act. it: ;.ui,u;ii i /. of ;i*m ptut. 01 m tiux lerunn ar. fglluwj.
ta) 'WtlMufV' tm-ane tetluehle, imoute. am.;ot>i:vilUe. clUTiouie. croeidulite. . trciuon* e.
hi "(`tobeslos maU'i-ial" mean* at*
lirttlus or iny luaiuTiti) eontaimaa to** beaioe. '
ici 'Ta4tienlate ubuioe in.Uiial"
meana finely divided imruelce of aeiiestue
at Ic.u-.t 30 dttya ihior so vusif'scne^nirtu of iur.il tivinoliuon or iinytuint prior '<j ec'.ni.iu.i'r iii-riH of (ii-ni'ji.ur.n >ugjret 'o
para"rnuii <d>ti* of tala secuoit.
"uih nuliee than mciuue Ute feilovtns. UtfoiMiaugu:
th N'.ui'.o of owner or operator.
(Ii* Acldrest 01 owner or oneraior. uni Utf-'crtniioa ut uic tiuiiulns. ;iue* lure, farttiiiy, or tnsMilauon to e tie-
lUOliMirti. t tv 1 Addrras or Inca I ion of Me build*
mu 1 erial. tdi ``Atbetlos luiliiija'" nirnna any
roild aiuie product of aahcsio* ininin: or
dip, Ktrurutre, fnciiit.v 0.* sn-taUn'iga. (v) sencduir*i nartuiu and eoiuolvUon
date* of (irniolLiion.
miiUu eueraUone widen eontauia ae*
tvt) Medioit of rtemelUioit to b* em
bastes.
;
<e.' "Ouuide/air'' means the air out*
`d? 'y:t**nr mi*'
fires.
tfi "VirtWe emtwtnv,j`' mrtrtnj anr
vn^aions widen arc vlsninlty delectaUO
MilhOMi i.he aid of inMinimenu an.t wnten
contain particulate AliiCjio* material.
ployed. ` tvd) rroecduree i bu emntercd ve
.pc.**. l.w :CO**!*Vi**.?.!* of ..it* ith.-n-Tj
tb 'fhe foilowtus iireeeo'irti dia.l be urnl to prevent euiissmn* of pnruei.iuve ubestea material to mdshlc air:
til Triable .uue.nos nuitcriafs. ucci lu
.u.t tiiut cmuuuoa dau. provided | fil.33 liiiiimuitdiiinlArtl.
ineulale or fireproof any bu.:ei'. puji*. or
. . -.wreew obtained dr. ilie Admin.u aceoruniue v w the proviiinns .-nisi-Ci be available to Hit uutt-
. . that u:n atlmtvln; rails toe*
. .he Artatncrtra'Gi- by any person
_,;_iS roetvtu. retain*. or ii.fowna. r sartlctilo.' purt LiiCi-ynf toUivr
'a> Atiiriiloe mii'j* Tliere rltnH be no vi*Ula rinwiloiu to tliu euuiiic sir fr.iii any r.iiietiAe mm except f* frovidtU in pArasrsnii tfi of 'Mi* tecihsu. C'tt'id*
Hiernec of fulicrtcs maieriaui la not eonvuiered a part of an idUMSin; tnnt
<b* lloachvnyj: Tlte Mirfiwln* m( rrtOii-
- .i'v;v*4c data*. if m.tuc public. w^v'j with atcalna lailum-i is prohibiten, Mnifs* method* or orocefrc* en- except lor temitcrnry rcsKlway: cm an
n profcelW-n * irahe secret* of area of asbceion eve iicpoeMs. Hie tlcptiii* - * * .'rawv. mo /.omuimra.ior will eon* lien of .istoc*to* tailinas on roauwayc cov
-h loevrd*. upon*. or informs* ered Titli eaow or ice U eontidcrcd "nur* - :s patnietitar pan thereof. coajW fAClnp.-
**tl sr. termUne* with U*c ;iurT.o*C* 'C> .Nfannfacturine: Tlirrd rlirll lx> no i^.'4 of lilt* lb of tliw Muted visible endaaivns to tho ontMdc air. ex*
:ade. rxenu t nai such rcrertw. re* ffW a* provniftl in iiarr:rvpli (ii c.1
*.r il>i-mnti*n, or a.trticular pari tide .icenon. from any bslhitnc or Mr'.'r-
Ji~7 eo unclosed to otiter ofOecrs. Utro m widen the feUovrrns overanona
* --rr, or authorised repreremauvn* arc rontiueted or dlrrotiy from aw of Hie
*Cnitrj sutie* etuteerned wr;* car* follorimr orcrsuoiw :f ti:e>* are eon*
* -til lit* ptovistoiu of uie set or dueled udijide of btdUiiiva or timrutrn.
'iinsr.1. in any proceeding under (1> Tie manufacture of noth. cord,
wick*, lulling, lane, tf.me. roite. nnr.a.
``A fsutf aullt/i(T.
`yam. rovutc. i&. or other ter.ulo ma-
icmU,
The p.*oniucts of UiU part eiiail <3> Tho mannfuciitre of ccmer.t prod* ' * C< rrr.i itCU Hi ai.y 11*4.444.4; U* ptw* it *.
* ' ''ii? Slain or pnlnlcal rubdlviupA 13r Tiir manufacture of ilrcunoAnj
.Vena: Adoptlna and rn/oreins any emu* t.ttlRs rtuuiaiion (*pgUeaWft to a T'uy eourre. prattled thai rue A
and Utadihiins mM.iiala.
14' Tito manu/aeture of Irlrtinn products.
1S* hTto mnnnfaeiuro Af paper, min imart!. and fell.
load-iuprortlns Mi-uciiuol member. 1 iiail bo wotted and removed from any uiehi-
MS. Ktiatcitiro, facility, or tiisioiiatisit
aubject <4 Mis parasraph beiore wreck* iBC of !onrt*nmpei'tinr MUieturnl metnisen u conmieneeti. Use 'rL-Uiie .vocmos ilobrti shr.il bo weticrt rhemadoly :o ut* ure tiiai vtich ti/i-rti 1 cm..m** et dumui all ibi?c* of oniiolitieit and rdated ban
al in;? oi'crcuon*. till ,*:*i pips or load.Miri'ortlu* rnv:*
i-ttml member Me! ia cevered villi fri able at,bealee inmtltiiips nr rireprcwlr*:
inulci'iil sliall Lo dropped cr MroM i. to Me ground frmn any in.n,n.uriurv.
facility, vr uv-ialiatinn ;ubiecr. :e :imv
pavuyrupti, but sltotl be tartiuily ibv-
tr*d or takea td sreiytd icvrl.
1 id 1 No fiiabte asonirti dehru hnl to dropped or utrewst to Me rrrtuno frem
r.*ty buli'-iiic. siuietu:e. facility, at in*
stallativin nibieet to M:.< i ar.*.?i.M`i or from any tbror 10 any (Uiir Wiow. f\>,*
busUlis'rta. structure, facut'iet. or ut*
svalUdioa*i. Sd icct er erertrr ir iwwt.
friable asbssioe itrbrti Mail be tirm-
prtrtafl
i`w crr.pp.ti v.h ds*it-tikist
ciSSV.fi nr rontaineri.
131 fourree iin-ier*. to Mi$ pan ,rrr.cn
aro o.irtsnpi from Me re'pftrvuienu bi tj m.oi a'. n -(. -tu n:.sr.
t4' Am owiuror v.peraicr of s vifir.cillion rtperklii'tt v*h* inset.tut `.0 uemc*'..>n a
1 UmfUt:; rre-.ii.uion Lt net !c.(e '1 t*m;: the uutd.\r4e prescribed ""it nsrt.
`ti ditirlnp tii* rtater or opoiairtr ' .' l.-a.i.*y yep*ee, uhcr than r. u*
fJi The manuCivrtiue of flonr tile. iT The manufacture of pnisus, eoacbies. cntidh*. adUolvra. sv.i'aiita.
<1* Tte htunufaeinro of iiltiinct and ;xi.ber inetcii.-,!.:.
n*' 1 h>? manu:;ulitre ei flv.t.rti'!.
buildiiis. s: met tire, f r.**ii; tv. nr uknsiiinisb (P tti;i.*ii Use i>re'*.*irtns ot Uv... yrapt*. *inid bn ap|.'..vni';o but witaiu h.*-< been dmlar'al b*' I'rwrr :a:e nr (..!
iptiheiily >*t Kraeusi.Uv unso'uul sr;t wliirl* in i'.;;i*.:**r Cl a:v.iv..ur,t: v* .*:11
vos:.*? oc.*iV!d or otwr.ticti l.y the
(ii> 0',tts,*'.li"ii: A.*:* iu'n*r "t *:'sr**t* U rM'iiiii (*<!.1 tug icp.'s:vniiv.!" .>1 tin.
to u'jt-m ricj*tuh. iKensrj. ftivahi j'.ior ta injjiui.uc jniut.-ne*
% idirtraJou. or otwatloit ef lucit
ter.' a <!>.*:t A** "f*:: rt1-",..w;r. v.ii iiiiviin*
10 i.rnti'hol', ui,\
1, f.
rial, rtf mdnrtri'l 'jv.idii:; uncitui
apaninsrit t*u;l-'l`.-* iuv.ih" i-cru t;'*.n
;in--_*r,;.i-ii u.` .-r i'.jii .:** :vi t: :'**; ;*
1..drill.t.iu* *,:.< :f.<d hv p.v.jrnn-..
il> 1,1 ill,.-. *tv'.it:i a:*.c tlte ;..ti;pr ...*
friable :ibfM.*,j ncbui :<s,
;*v
four ttwrtdinc 1uds.1i, imicKfc. l.isii?*y, yab-sripu t.i*t3)tu e: t..a
*
N * * .
**
riofiAt iioiiui. vou in. mj. **--U'e.vr, *
, itr:
-u
RUCK AND RSOvlATlCNS
. . S.inyini!: Ticrc >hall He no'"faHile unly for oo lame as It tai:r* to hut clown
-'ll* u me euuv.ie nr (ram mo he cMemtinn nvucraviu:: Uio psnucuiate t, -uB application- of material* eon- inwestoo material.
' i? more than l percent. nbcit<v, or.
/ weicnt
urcd 'o ''n.nilate or
{ OImI !l<.|*urhng.
roof ecuiDmeiH Bud aiar'uuerr, en*
Tlie owner or onerutor of any extslme
i, provided in P!rranrr::ih > of Hus source to winch Uiis subnait is aiiiiitculile
'.an. 3rJrnyon materia..; uigu to tn.-iu-. shall, within 39 days after the infective
it fh-eproof bulletins*. u.-sciures. date, jicendo me foilowin; infonnatlou
... uid sonduhe jiuh c3niam. less to (ho adixinibitrauir:
- i perecui, asbestos on a ary valent (ai A dcscruition of tits cni.istqn eon*
trot viucpnicui used for carh recess:
Sources subject to thia aarnyraph
<U> If a fabric flhr device is used to
;.;etnot from the reouivemcnU of eontrel cnauiion*. the iircyaure drop
:jia;, I 51.37. .ana J si.ub.
across the laone niter tn inenes a-atcr
Any ownor or operator who inlands ^080*
-.*/ nsuesios mniertaU lo insulate or
tl) If mo fabric filter rtertef utilises a
.vsf buiKine*. jcnscuirer, pine*. con- woven fabric, the air flow urimeabillty
imdnmeiu. and machinery shnll Sn ^tV^nJu/fl.,; and. If the fabric Is jyrt*
used m iho precc: of uumuir i*..V '*'*-
Hit) pi'iuuiry purpx.o
rr:;unr,r Uto
voltinio of the watin i,y rcmoviit^ <*vmbumilile matter.
<i) `Trowctlanf* mrmtB a fuel aurt o\i.
di/.or ptiysH-atty ut cncuuritiy ee."tbui*u
"'hit'll unuerraea cnmPu-t;wn to wioviue rocnet propulsion.
(J) '`Corylliutri alloy means anv metal
to which lierylliuin has brert auued n ortltic to inerefuo its beryiliuin cquwnt
and which com am* more than 9.1 -<r*
cent beryllium by wy.sht. Del ''Propelians plMif' means any
facility cup.aced in the mlxutc, cauitnii.
or incchutiu; of propellant.
61rtinUhnn M.uularW.
.: meh intention to tnc acmmutra- theuc. indicate whether the flu yim Is (a) Emusioiis la the aunorhere from
' .cant 30 days prior to the eom- spun or not tiituu
itahoiiAJv sources jupject uj the nrou*
. :-ncns of me luirnymi* operation. . rrport huii include the followtoy uiStion:
.'.'nuie of owner nr operator.
Adarcts of owner or operator,
location of soraytnc operation,
c'rorc'iures to oo followed to meet itiiremeui* of this pnraaraoft.
rather titan meet Lite no-vtsihlc.r. requirement* i*f psracraohe (ai. . d >e* of tills seetion. an owner or if may -lees to use the methods
t>s" ) Cl.23 to dean emmnor.s ..mu ;vur:etiUUe adiexo* material
.-uch embuton* eseaiio to, or are to, the ouuldc tic.
12) TX the fabric AUcr device utlllrcs si fiitcd fabric, the density tn ot/yd*. the minimum Uiicbnaes in inches, end the **nflo* pertreabitlty in fiVinln/ft'.
to) Such information shall accompany Hit Information rewired by } 51.18, The appropriate Conn Is contained tn appen dix A U U*Jc part.
Subpart C--National Emission Standard for Qorytlium
| 61 JO AppUcnbiltiy.
The prertcientf of this subnart are ap plicable to the foilowinc stationary wurecs:
<a> xtmction plan*, ceramic plants, foundries, inciticmiurs. and propellant
sioiis of ttus suhpoft. mail net exreci: 10
trams of beryllium over a n*haur period,
caeca*, as provided in paruo.-seti tm ;1
title sccthm.
<t>> father Uian meet tlie ry.ure*
mem of paraeraph <s) of this section,
an owner or operator may request :.p-
l>reval irom the Ailniiiiisirator to rr.yet
an ambient concmurntlon limit on beryi*
Hum m the vicinity of the stationary
source of 3.01
avarnged over s
3Q*dar peeled.
(D Approval of stieh requests nuv be
Granted by the Auatmlsu-ator proncea
that:
(U At least 3 >Tar.i of da:a is avuii.
able which in the Jinlement of the Ad-
-1 Air.* Jvmuiip,
plants wldeb yroeeai berrlllum ura. beryl* mlnisitnior dcmenswanM uiat th* fu
... .cleaning It elected. a* permit*
: Ci.;2:f,\ the requirements of this must be <aci.
"abric filter eo.'.eetion devlee*
; tiseti. ettceut os noted tn para-
. ib> and <e> of this section. Such
must ae operated at a pressure
. ito mot e man t inches water yace.
-urea aero** the Alter fatirte. The
;>ermcaiiillty. fs determined br
' method DT37-C9. must not exceed
lui/ft' for woven faones or 35
:: ft* for felted fabrics, except that
V min/ft* for wotvn and O fey
for felled fabrics Is allowed far
air from asbestos ore dryer**
" uare yard of (Kited fabrte niece
.-. at '.cost u ounces and be at least
. resiili inch
tlirourhoui.
fabrics must not eOntaln All
.nor than that wtuch is spun.
:: thruse of faun: filters creates r rxjiiosion hacaru. the aanunl'-
authorize tue use of wet col* M c..st;ncrt to oper..:-* with a unit
. ms energy of at lca*t so incites . ...ae pressure.
aclnututiAior mnv auchorlr.e f Ahet-uis re-mumr:*.; other tlisin
. tAcm in uarasr.-.;.;'.s <a> and ib' iv'.ifiit ;f me ov r.rr er operator
ifam, beryllium oxide, beryllium alleys,
ac Um'lllum-enntalnlny waste. m> Mueliine slisps widen proeeji
loemiluaa. beryllium OKldet. br any alloy wtien such alloy eonUizu mere than l
percent bsryhium by weihh
f 61.31 Urfluilivw.
Terms used In UiU subuart are de* fmed in Use act. In subpart A oi this port, or In this seetion as fellows:
to) "aorylltum" means the element beryllium. Where wetenu or ebneemraJer.s are auceitlert. such weichts er con* emitratlons apply ts beni'i'.uu only, encludlmr ilia trrutiu or eoncentration of car aceoeiatnt ilsmcnts.
Oil 'Zxrrschon plant** means a fn* ciiicy chemical!'/ preeeaafny beryllium owe le beryllium nut ai. alloy, or ox.de. or performing any of the intermediate mrps In three preecases.
e 'Beryllium ore'* means any natu* raiiv occurrtr.c material mined er Aihcred for Its brryillutn eotucr.s.
<0) "Maciuue sliop'' means a fartuty yj.-formica cnttlsa. ^intiinc. : twistna. ruthiuc. deburr.ns. !;i;*pu:a. eleetroahmuieai umehinuic. otchme. or
sliutlnr n'i*rai;nus. e< "Caraaite plant" means a :i\i* fiatudns plant preduum; ecrauhe ite:iu<.
ture tinbivtu eaiiconh-aiionj of scn'lhiun in the vtcmtty of Uto i-tationaiy source will not uNered 0.91 iu in', aver.*.ecu ovrr a 30-hay period. Such 3-ycar p.jiaod sail: be the 3 >cnr* endhie 59 days before the flecuvu date of this ittantiarh.
HI) Tlic owner or rtxrator reeurts sueh approval in writhic v.audn 33 days after Uto effective date of this .*-.sn*j.ird.
uii' The ov.-r.cr or operator submits b report to the Administrator within 45 days after iho efTective date of this standard wnlcft retort includes the feilowiiiff information:
t< Dercapuou of aamtiHnc mathed Includins the method and frequency of calibration.
tfi) Method of samplo an.dysl*.
fr* AverdCtPC t..chiUau3 for ::c:rrminln$ 33-day averou* cotwtturaiioai:
t<(> Number, tdrnit:;.'. and lacauon tadftrCM, cearuiiiiitvs. er thstar.ee .utd headIns from pianu gf samui me si tes.
'O Crfitir.d Ktfvauons and heifiht above iirauna nf tam.i.m; iuicts.
'/< I't.uvt anrt j.vtiplih.t af>*a p'.*tj ihowp-.e I'Pitssioii poiMia as-.w i.ttnpiut! site*. I'hi'ii'irat'itic tcauirvi > uui.*.ca:f.l' atfcvtliii ti. *|ier..uii iin.r.i.'iiia pl.ii.:
bui.btu* l:e:u'.n and lucnit**:4.* *hatt tc
in<`lut..sl.
'::.ies te Hie sat:..'action of the
if' roundiy* means a facii.iy vti-
t;< :i,fur:ii;ition !te;?r.a;r for e*t.
....rator mat tm,* f.hcr.r.p of par* cas^ in tii* ntrti'ute or csii..r; of main;*
rriciin inritiduvi ;a:it he:.: '
. a>n*<tos mat erf l is vquiviient unylUum mrtal nr alloy.
insttiu mametcr. ex.t .<.*.* tompytihur.1
1 -f hie uvtet'.bcb ci,ut;:ftH*iic..
tp> "Deryihhm-rt'niainutc wn*:?"
air.rtia.-.iiu: i...v.r,::m'tit au- xc.iB* - mat<'i'tr.i coituiimume.i unit COiiC.
a *.i>* hiu section av.:*; be ffoperly t>
atuhur briyihum et,..i:;i.uui!MS
i.'j) A ibv.grtpiinn ef 'IMa anil tii. -:*
... usee, oikrat^l. nuiintamed.
or pmeratvil duvniu any p.-uri-: * or duty.: 1 illC'ilUlix lir 1 tl. :>! - * U: vit >0 It- *
I. c:,\*s :*<;iy lie n--it caiv fiurthc cvT-ra'.loti porfomicd by a leurur *uw.*eit :r.n thi1 ,ur .*.-.iiipiu*.': i>.*.-. < :): > *. num*
a tuturucucy cor.u.t.mts .utd then to Mus subtiaru .
,
Sec and luC'.tuon of *.tiuptu>c
rtsti.it ucsmrs, vou a, ho.
a/ju *, t era
OC
o