Document NedmqxmbGkpEbBnQ9zY1Y4Keb
OCCUPATIONAL DISEASES IN SYNTHETIC RESIN AND FIBRE INDUSTRIES
Jyuko KUBOTA [Department of Pathology, The Institute for Science of Labor]
The prosperity of the synthetic resin and fibre industries in Japan today is accompanied by a rise of incidence of the occupational poisoning and skin disease. In this paper are sketched occupational diseases caused by raw materials, inter mediate products(monomers and polymers), solvents ana stabili zers of the synthetic resin and fibre industries, and also is informed the incidence of these diseases, summarizing the latest literatures.
INTRODUCTION
If the existing concept that indu strial property brings unbalance of supply and demands to increase the in cidence of occupational diseases, the current rapid development in synthetic resin and fibre industries will be a great concern to all of us. In fact, many companies have consulted our office about this concern, and there is also an increase in the number of papers published abroad on this subject.
In view of this situation, therefore, occupational diseases caused by raw materials, intermediate products, sol vents and stabilizers used in synthetic resin and fibre industries are sketched and reviewed in this communication.
1^ PRODUCTION PROCESSES FOR SYNTHETIC RESINS AND FIBRES
or those which have been proposed but have never been used are summarized in the tablesL(Tables 1, 2 I, 11^.
Occupational diseases can be caused by raw materials, monomers, pclw.ers, solvents and additives, and in tnis review, they will be discussed in this order.
2. RAW MATERIALS
l) Formalin : Eesides being used as the raw material for production of carbonate resin, urea resin and polyurethane, formalin is frequently utilized in the process for production jf melamine polymer and for acetalization of poly vinyl alcohol.
As a proof to show that the problem of formalin has lined i'-ncrtance in U.S. where the s\'tactic resin industry has seen a rapid upsurge. I will like
Manufacturing processes for synthetic resins and fibres currently In use
RODO KAGAK'J, Vclume 33, Od ;es 1 - 22(1957).
1 ucc
UODOOk
ucc
066B83
NAME Phenol resin
Urea resin
Melamine resin
TABLE 1 SUMMARY OF THE PROCESSES FOR MANUFACTURE OF SYNTHETIC RESINS
PROCESS
Phenol
TM
f
Formalin
+ hcho
[Addition, co"ie""tl'1|>
f ?H ]
i rc"=->
'
!
L > n.
i Urea Formalin
NH2CONH2 + HCHO (, additi.o---n--)r~/* NH2aCONH-CHoOH'. NH2COCH-CH2OH + nh2conh2
f _H___ PH ^ 1 2i
0=c l -hA !
HO + (acidic)
(Condensation)
NH2CONH Nctlp
NH2C0NH/
k /n
Aqueous cyan- Guanyl amide solution cyanamide
Melamine
Calcium
2NH2CN -> NH2(CNH)KH*CN ----- HIH -C/ \-NH2
cyanamide
2| |
Nv
HCHO
f ,N
J? \ H cr c -n-ch2
1, [j
(Neutral or
Nv / N f
acidti c)\
Jn
C NH2
k hn-ch2
1------REMAjRKS The resolfan initial condensate)is used for paint, adhesive, and final condensate (resit) is used for electrical part and equipments for chemicaI industry. Wood adhesives, textile finish, electrical parts building materials
Plastics, paints, adhesives, textile finish
1 11
Alkyd resin
Phthalic anhydride
-CO
J-co
Glycerol
CH OH l2 CHOH t CHeOH
ch2oco idlOH
/ -COOH
ch2oco-r-cooh
CHpOCo/^ VcOOH
1 ' \-J CHOH I CH^OII
[The material is cured by replacing a portion of the phthalic acid
moiety with oleic aciu or linoleic acid] 00 u 1 II aH
-c c-o-c-6-cHp-o-
Heat-curable, heat-nor\-curable, and acid,-curable resins are available. For paint, plasti cizer, mica, and adhesion of asbestos
C17^31
Vinyl chloride resin
Vinyl acetate resin
Acetylene 3
CHsCH +
fcH2=CH
HC1 --
1
i Clyn
[Frequently used
for copolymers]
CabLe cover, oil pipe, and transport
pipe for acids. ` Acid-resistant
inner lining, film, meat
Acetylene Acetic acid
CH = CH + CH3COOH
|'ch =CH I 2j
^
^ b h3 ^
VC/VA copolymer is used as pigment. Fo, lesion, finish,
glass. Raw material for making polyvinyl alcohol
Polyvinyl alcohol
Polyvinyl acetate is hydrolyzed with an acid or an alkali (/Nlto monomer i.s fcormed)
-CH2-CH-CU2-CH-CH2-CH1jt
,,,, HaO ^
CH2-CH-CH2-CH-C1I2-CHI[ [
OCOCH3 OCOCH3 OCOCH3 CH3C00H
OH OH OH
Adhesives,} oil carrying pipe, raw material for acetal
resins
Polyvinyl acetal
Polyvinyl alcohol
-ch2-cu-ch2-ch11 OH OH
Aldehyde
+ RCHO ---------v
-CH0 -CH-CH,,-CH-C1U 1 `1
00
X/ / cv
[This may be prepared
H
directly from vinyl
acetate resin]
------------ 1,----------------------- -
1 Vinylon, wire laminates, textile additives, plas ties
Polyethylene
n{H2C=CH2)
(-CH2-CH2-)n {poly-addi tion products)
Low pressure poly merization : lub
ricants, medium
grade waxes
High pressure poly
merization : high
frequency insula
tor, acid-resistant
and oil-resistant
4-"
Benzene
Ethylene
Ethyl
inner lining______ High frequency
Polystyrene
+ CH2=CH2
benzene
o CH2CH3
Styrene -CH;
-CH-CHs-1
o
insulator, clear molded products. Copolymerize with butadiene to make
synthetic rubber.
Acrylic ester resin
Ethylene
oxide
CH-, >0
CHj.
+ HCN
Ethylene cyanhydrin
CH2 -CN I ch2-oh
Acrylic acid
h2o, h2so4
CHa=CH C00H
MeOH
CH2=CH t
!
j 0C0CH3 ;
^ /n
Methyl acrylate, ester
[With butanol, a butyl ester is formed]
I
Adhesives, paints, wire laminates, methyl ester
11
06688
Methacrylic ester resin
Acetone
CH3 ^CO
CH.
+ HCN
Acetone hydrin
ch3
CH.
cyan-
oh
CN
o ------------ *
.CH ch2 vCH.
CH. CHS=C N COOR
CH,
-ch3-c-
1
COOR ) n
' Methanol (ROIl)
Painty adhesion, and tlje methyl I ester is used for I the window glass j of aircrafts [ (Organic glass)
ii
Silicone resin
VJl
(Grignard's process) SiCl4 --------- RSiCla, RSiCl3
(Direct process) Si --1 > R2SiCl2, RSiCl3
HaO . . , RaSiCla --------* [R2Si(OH)al
{ RI Si-O-
n
RS^-Cl.
H20
[RSi(0H)3]
fE '
! -Si-O-- R /n
Paints, greases, lubricants, elect rical insulator
Oil for diffusion pump
ucc
066886
%
TABLE 2 SUMMARY OF THE PROCESSES FOR MANUFACTURE OF SYNTHETIC FIBRES
NAME
PROCESS
REMARKS
Vinyon
Acetylene
Acetic acid
CH = CH + CH CH3COOH Acetylene
-- -V CHo=ClI~OCOCHa Vinyl chloride
HHHHHH I I I I! t -> -C-C-C-C-C-C-
H AlH ClA d>
CH = CH +- HC1
CH2=C11C1
Copolymeri zation
COCH3 n
Filter cloth, laboratory coats, others
Rhovyl
P, C, fibre ON
Acetylene CH=CH + HC1
P.C. fibre
Heat with catalyst CllsCHCl -----------------------
HH
-A - A
Polyvinyl chloride
A Ai . n
Filtering cloth, packing materials, Insulating materials
(-CH2-CCl2-CH2-CHCl-) Dissolve in acetone
Rhovyl
Dissolve in a
solvent con taining CS2
Vinylidene chloride fibres,
Salan Be Ion
Ethylene
1.2-dichloro-
ethane
C1
CH2=CHa --CH2C1-CH2C1 ------^
Acetylene CH=CH + HC1
Cl2 CH2CHC1 -----
Trichloroethane
Vinylidene chloride
-HCl CH,,Cl*CHCl2 ------------T3-
2 2 Ca(OH)2 Lime milk
CIUCCl. 2
Screen, racket string, sheets, umbrella. Filtering cloth, shoes, handbags
Vinylon
Polyvinyl acetate
'-CH_-CH-CH_-jlH- 1
i0 ixiCHg < n
COCHa
Saponifi cation
--------------- >
Polyvinyl alcohol
-CH2-CH-CH2-CH II OH DH
Thermal spinning
---------- >
HCHO
Cloth fabrics, socks, fishing nets, filt ering cloth, and others
-CHa-CH--CHa-(^H-
--------
HCH
ucc
066887
Arlon
Ethylene
Cl
CH2=CH2 -
-r
CH2OH I CH2C1
NaCN
----- ->
(jdl20H
CH^CN
-HsO ^ ch2
CHCN
Ethylene chlorohydrin
Ethylene cyanhydrin
Acrylo nitrile
Arlon
Spinning
/Polymerization
Polyacrylonitrile
Umbrellla material, curtains, tents, overcoats, etc.
Dynel (Cherastrand)
Acrylonitrile ..
Cll2=CHCN
^
Vinyl chloride CHa=CHC1
Copolymerization-
Dissolved in acetone \
Dry spinning
\t Dyne 1
Chemstrand is formed by copolymerization of acrylonitrile and vinyl acetate, followed by saponification.
-j Acryronitrile that has fast polymerization rate is always added, and a monomer composition is constantly adjusted to prepare a acetone-soluble copolymer having uniform composition, and this product is Vinylon N.______________________________________________________
Nylon
Adipic acid[H00C{CH2)4C00H] and hexamethylenediamine [NH2(CH2)6NH el were reacted to prepare hexamethylene diammonium adipate which
was then polycondensed to form Nylon
Two industrial processes are available.
Lady's stocking, lace, groves, rain coat. velvet materials
ucc
066888
Perlon T
II Phenol OH
u
Cyclohexanol
,,H2 ,,
OH
(JH;
*u
hooc(ch2)4cooh
Dehydration NH3
--------------
NH,
o
___ v
NHs
6
Aniline
Cyclohexyl amine
____Hexamethylene diamine
[-OC(CH2)4CONH(CHa)4NH]n
ft
Nylon (Continued)
Adiponitrile
CN-(CH2)4CN iH
CH--CH II II
HC b-cm
^
+,h2o
,, ,* . ^ H2n(CH2)6NH2
11] Acetylene Formalin
Te^][hylene
CllsCH + 2 HCHO --* HO-CH2-C=C-CH2-OH -- HO-(CH2)4OH --*
Hexamethylenediamine
H2N-(CH2)6-NH2<. Ha
[-HN-(CHa)6NHCO(CH2)4CO-]I^
Nylon
H00C-(CH2)4-C00H ,J Adipic acid
----- CN-(CH2)4-CN
CH -- CH jj ||
VPH rvj Furan
CH2--CH2 J
1 Cll2
C1 ii2 *-'
+ HP
^0 \
1'
Cl-(CHP)4-Cl
L, Tetramethylene
dichloride
Amylan
PerIon L
(Igamide)
pk,,nni Cyclohexanol
OH OH
QJk,
Cyclohexanone
Cyclohexanone oxime
Caprolactam
Q NOH Beckmann reQ NHa0H > |^S arra"se"nt > ^
.,
^
Ring closure polymerization
Same as Nylon
[-C0-(CH2)5NH-]n
Polyurethane fibres
PerIon V (igamide V)
Acetylene Formalin
CH=CH + 2 HCHO ----k
Butyne,1:4:diol
HOCHaCH=CHCHaOH u
,, ,y -
Butane, 1:4:diol
, Hexamethylene isocyanate
HOCHaCHsCHa-CHsOH
Polyurethane
r-OCOf CHa^OCO-
NH{CHa)6nh_]n
H2N(CH2)sNH2 C--g> HClNHa(CH2)6NHC0Cl C--lg* QCN(CHa) sNCO7^
Acid-resistant filter paper, power belt, cord, insulation cable, etc.
JCC 066889
Terylene
m.
oTercphthalic acid
Glycol
H03C-
-C03H + HO-(CH,-?) 2-011
Fusion under unhydrovs state, polycondensa 11 on
[-0C0
coo{ch2)oco
n
\ Filter paper, tire cord, screen tent, etc.
TABLE 3 Change in the tolerance level of formaldehyde reported in U.S.
Year
Reported by
Tolerance level
1940
State of Massachusetts
20
1942
American Standard Association
10
1944
National Safety Council
10
1945
U.S, Department of Labor
10
1947
Silbermann*
10
1948
Da 11a Valle*
20
1949
Patty*
10
1950
Elkins*
5
1952
A.C.G.I.H.**
5
* The author of the report
** A.C.G.I.H. - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists.
ucc
066890
to show how the tolerance level of formalin has changed in the U.S..
Earlier, we have investigated the effect of formalin gas on human body in
(Table 3).
The so-called "tolerance a plant that carried out acetalation of
level" commonly used by the scientific community is not an absolute one.
polyvinyl alcohol. According to 'that results, following summation can be made.
Rather, it is estimated from the results
of animal tests or based on experience, (1) Many cases showed irritation of
and it shows the estimate of the limit throat, bronchi and mucous membrane of eyes
that allows a workers to work for a
or disturbance of the digestive tracts.
long period of time under such environ The frequency of complaint was 1.9 per ment without harm. Therefore, if the person.
dose increases abruptly and if the daily working time is extended, poison ing or occupational disease may occur in the working environment that may
(2) The workers exposed to formalin gas frequently showed irritation of bronchi and mucous membrane of the eyes. With
not show any harmful effect otherwise. those workers who contacted directly with
In other words, "tolerance level" has to be viewed more carefully. As more
formalin water, more cases of skin dis turbance were reported.
knowledges are acquired, generally the
tolerance level has a tendency to decrease. Thus, if we look at the
(3) The formalin gas concentration in the atmosphere of this plant was in a range
change of the tolerance level of form of 6.5 - 13-14 ppm.
alin in the U.S. in recent years, during 10 year's period it has declined from 20 ppm to 5 ppm* and this is surprising and interesting. There is no other example in the history to show such a rapid change of the tole rance level in such a short period of time. This seems to indicate the enormous concern shown for formalin.
Recently, Professor Sugai of Kyushu University has reported the disease of eyes caused by formalin. They are as follows. The plant investigated was a plant that manufactured formalin, where the formalin concentration in the air was in a range of 3*7 - 27,8 ppm. Thus, the condition seemed to be worse than the above-said case.
This tolerance level of formalin is the level when formalin gas is inhaled. There is also a report of a lethal dose of formalin by injection. Thus, the LD5o which is sufficient to kill % of rats is 5-6 mg. Further more, most of the animals died within 30 minutes. But, naturally, needless to say that the actual occupational disease caused by formalin is caused by gas inhalation, rather than by a direct injection of formalin into body.
Hyperemia was noted in conjunctiva of all of the workers. Eight out of 21 workers showed deposition of pigment along the cleavage of the eyelid. The number of bacteria in the fornix conjunctivae occurred in 1/3 of the members, and 1/4 of the members did not show any bacteria at all. However, there was almost no subjective symptoms. About 1/3 of the workers showed contraction of visual field and two members were proven to have relative central scotoma.
Formalin gas is extremely irritating, and even a trace amount can be detect ed easily. Therefore, severe harm is usually rare. But, in reality, form
Eye drop experiments were carried out with rabbits, and following results were obtained.
alin has been reported to cause derm atitis or inflammation of eyes, and therefore it requires precaution. Inflammation of respiratory tract can also be caused by formalin.
When formalin water at a concentration exceeding 1000 times the acceptable level was-applied 2-3 times, the bacteria in the eyes were killed, but there was no
10 ucc
066891
obvious symptoms. With more than 100 fold concentration, some symptoms were shown, but the animals soon became accustomed to it. With more than 10 fold concentration, strong reaction was noted.
When rabbits with previous history of exposure to formalin were used to run eye drop test, meiosis occur red. This can be explained by the paralysis of the sympathetic nerves and the irritation of the terminals of the eye nerves.
Besides this, another literature5 cautions that reticulocytes may show an increase when formaldehyde poisoning is induced in animals.
There were no recent reports about formalin dermatitis. But, I will like to note that formalin allergy is an established fact for a long time.
2) Phenols : Besides being used for making phenol resins by addition/ condensation with formalin, phenols are well known as raw materials for production of Nylon and Aramine.
Phenol has been known for a long time as a potent antiseptic which has been used widely in medical field.
On the other hand, phenol is also toxic to human body. Particularly, concentrated phenol can precipitate proteins. It is volatile and can easily penetrate into cells. It causes a severe pain in the site of its application. It can quickly paralyze the sensory nerves, and therefore phenol is used frequently for cleaning the ulcerous surface.
About 1/4 of the phenol entered the body can be oxidized, but the remainding 3/4 is known to be excreted in urine within 24 hours.6 In this case, about half of them are excreted in free form and the remaining half are excreted in conjugated form. Among the conjugated phenols, 50 % are conjugated with sulfate, 30 7. are conjugated with glucuronic acid and
the remainder are conjugated with other acids.
When absorbed, phenol shows a toxic symptoms such like headache, drunken ness, change of respiratory `rate, and rarely an intermittent spasm. Since it can stimulate and irritate the kidney when excreted into urine, it can also cause nephritis. Phenol can also be excreted into bile juice and also in the respired air to cause inflammation of the liver and lung.
When a sugar-containing lime is allowed to react with phenol, it pre cipitates the phenol, and thus this can prevent the absorption of phenol.
In the working site, phenol allergy is an important occupational disease. This allergy usually continues for several months, and thus can delay the workers from reporting back to work.
Since phenol has sensory paralysis effect, the patients may not be able to complain. This point requires particular caution.
3) Phthalic anhydride : Phthalic anhydride, along with glycerol, is used as raw material for production of alkyd resins. A portion of phthalic acid is substituted with oleic acid or linoleic acid to obtain a cured resin.
The major concern is the phthalic anhydride which contains small amounts maleic acid and naphthoquinone. Some symptoms attributed to phthalic acid may be due to these mixtures.9
Phthalic acid can irritate skin and mucous membrane. Inflammation of upper respiratory tract and Inflamma tion of the eyes, and rarely bleeding from nose and blood in sputum were found in 14 patients who had visited the clinics of the plant in U.S.A. The patients were particularly annoyed by a constant coughing during night. Some showed symptoms of emphysema and bronchitis. Typical cases were found with the workers who had worked continuously for 1-7 years in the plant.
11 UCC 066892
Phthalic acid combusts above 500C, and therefore there is a danger of ignition. In this plant, there have been 3 accidents of this nature, re sulted in one death.10
Ktlhnl10 has proposed that 0.03 g/m3
should be regarded as the tolerance
level because irritation of mucous
membrane starts at this level. Later,
Menschick11 has seen severe case of
asthma and also found that those
school children who had to go to the
school near the plant handling
phthalic acid frequently had conjun
ctivitis. Based on this evidence,
Menschick proposed that the tolerance
level had to be less than 0.025 g/m3.
He reported that various diseases
were found among 18 workers out of
71 workers. The symptoms were the
decrease of blood platelet counts,
increase of white blood cell counts,
increase of acidophile counts, incr
ease of reticulocyte counts, decrease
of serum Ca and P, and increase of
total serum protein contents. Also,
21 out of 31 patients showed lower
resistance of the blood vessel wall.
Decrease of blood pressure during
exposure to phthalic acid was noted
in 4l out of 43 workers. There was
enhanced tendon reflex, and dermatitis
was also seen. Asthma, which was
of particular concern to the investi
gator, was found in 4 out of 71 workers.
The workers who had shown these symp
toms
had worked in the plant
for few days to 20 months.
Vanadium pentoxide is used as the catalyst in the manufacturing process. According to the study, contact with vanadium pentoxide was said to in crease the susceptibility to phthalic acid.
In Japan also, Kido9 has reported that 18 out of 20 workers had der matitis during two years of investi gating period. According to the results of the patch test conducted on these workers, they were negative against pure sample of phthalic acid,
but was strongly positive to industrial grade of phthalic acid. Based on this evidence, he claimed that the mixture, particularly naphthoquinone, is toxic.
Recently, we have pursued accidental cases of several workers who had to perform- a job of polishing after coating the automobile body with resin paint and resulted in severe dermatitis, and found that the free phthalic acid remained in the phthalic acid resin was the cause.
In this particular incident, phthalic
acid resin varnish was used in the
color developer of the pigment. Besides
this, toxicity of zinc chromate also
was casted as a problem. However, later
analyses of phthalic acid and zinc
chromate revealed the presence of
about 1 7. of phthalic acid and 0.03 g
of zinc chromate per 5 g of the sample.
In a strict sense, therefore, the
toxicity may have to be attributed to
the synergistic effect of both. In
any rates, it is important to note
that phthalic acid has participated
in this incidence.
The phthalic acid
in this pigment was proven only after
heating the pigment at 120C. There
fore, it is significant that phthalic
acid can remain in the pigment in an
amount far exceeding the amount expected.
4) Maleic anhydride : Tanaka has
classified maleic acid's utility as follows.13*14
(1) For production of alkyd resins for paints(maleic acid resin, terpene/ maleic anhydride resin).
(2) Production of maleic acid-treated oils.
(3) Production of hetero-polymer by copolymerizing with styrene, vinyl chloride, vinyl acetate, methyl methacrylate, acryl alcohol, to be used for production of heat-curable resin, particularly for paints, adhesives, dispersing agents,
12 ucc
066893
viscosity regulating agent, and agents for treating of fibres.
(4) For sulfurization of polyester rubbers and tartaric acid.
Tbx1c symptoms by maleic acid were reported in recent years, mainly in the industry that has to do with synthesis and printing industry.
Frequently the areas contacting dire ctly with maleic acid such like eyes and skins are affected. Naturally, inhalation of high concentration of maleic anhydride gas can cause infla mmation of the upper respiratory tract.
Drug-induced inflammation of eyes were reported. According to the results of animal experiments, administration of
0.5 % aqueous solution can cause mild conjunctivitis and corneal opacity, and exposure to a gas(54.9 mg/m3) for 1 hour can cause the same symptom in 50 % of the animals.
Ohwada15
has run an experiment
on the effect of maleic acid on skins.
The chemical was prepared as an oint
ment in lanolin. After storing for
b days, the ointment was painted on
the fron arms, and the results were
read after 6 hours.
Under this con
dition, the EDso(the concentration
at which 50 % of the subjects showed
positive) was 2.1 %. After storing
the ointment for few days, the potency
seemed to declined gradually. If the
ointment was tested fresh, EDso was
0-53 % and EDS was 0.07 % Eased on
this result, I consider that persons
sensitive to maleic acid can be dete
cted if 0.07 7. was used fresh.
5) Chlorine gas : Poisoning by chlo rine gas has been known for a long time. Chlorine gas was used as poison gas in the World War I by Germany (April 22, 1915)> which made it famous.
In the manufacturing industry, chlorine and the chlorine-containing bleach are used in decolorization and
disinfection. Since a danger of poisoning exists in bleaching plant and the plants that electrolyze NaCl and potassium chloride, .poisoning may also occur during the disinfection operation in a laundry plant, bleaching of jute, animal hairs and straws, and bleaching of paper. In chemical laboratory also, poisoning by chlorine gas can occur frequently. In recent years, personnels from artificial resin manufacturing plants(vinyl chloride plants) or water work frequently visited us for consultation about this problem.
As indicated in Table 4, there are many studies about the toxicity of chlorine gas.
The tolerance level of chlorine gas
is indicated in Table 5* Most of the
countries in the world set the tolerance
level at about 1 ppm.
According to
Patty16, 13 states in the U.S.A. adopt
1 ppm as the tolerance level. In Ohio
and Washington, it is 5 ppm. Dalla Valle,
however, claims that it has to be less
than 0.55 ppm.
Symptoms of the acute chlorine poison ing are mainly the irritation at loci of the mucous membrane in contact with chlorine gas. Thus, depending on the extent of its exposure, bronchitis, pneumoniae, edema of lung and bleeding
in lung may occur.
If a large amount of chlorine gas comes into contact, naturally the worker will lose his conciousness and may die.
If a person constantly contacts the gas, he or she may become accustomed to it and eventually can withstand a higher dosage of the gas. This does not mean that the person has become resistant to the gas, but rather he has lost his responsiveness to the gas. It has to be cautioned that, because of this oversight, one may show no symptom after inhaling a large dose of the gas but may bleed from the lung 2-3 days later and lose his life.
UCC 13 066894
mg/Litre
TABLE 4 Toxicity of chlorine gas on human body
ppm 1
Symptoms
0.001 0.003 0.003 - O.OOo 0.01
0.012 0.04 0.04 - 0.06 0.08 0.1 - 0.15 2.5 - 2.8
0.35 1.0
i Will feel the effect after few hours of work' Tolerable limit (long term)
1.0 - 2.0 No significant symptoms after 6 hours of work
3-5 Feel the odor. No serious symptoms after 1/2 1 hour of work
4.0 Endurable limit after 1/2 - 1 hour of work
14.0
Medium degree of irritating symptoms
14.0-21.0 Danger to life after 1/2 - 1 hour of work
28.0
Cough and irritation
35 - 50
Death immediately or after 1/2 - 1 hour of work
900 - 1000 Immediate death
mg/litre = Amount in mg per liter ppm = Parts per million
Japan U.S.A.
IT
It It
It it
TABLE 5 Tolerance level set by law
r
Labor Law State of Massachusetts (1940) Department of Public Health and
Bureau of Mines Lehmann and Hess Conference of Plant Hygiene Inspectors
(19^7) State of California/1948) Conference of Plant Hygiene Inspectors
1.0 ppm 1.0 ppm 1.0 ppm
about 1.5 ppm 2.0 ppm
1.0 ppm 1.0 ppm
mg/litre
14.3 1.43 0.143 0.0143 0.00143
ppm
5000 500 50 5 0.5
TABLE 6
Subjective observation
Typical chlorine odor, green gas
Significant chlorine odor, green gas
Medium degree of chlorine odor, colorless gas
Weak chlorine odor No odor
14
Reaction to potassium iodide paper
Changes blue inmediately
Changes blue immedia tely
Changes blue immedia tely
Changes blue in 3 - 5 si Changes blue after 10 s
or unchanged after 30 sec.
ucc
066895
Because a change was seen in the liver and kidney of the rabbits poi soned by chlorine gas, some investi gators have focussed their attention on the diseases that might be caused by chronic absorption of this gas.
There are many ways for determining the concentration of chlorine gas in the air of the working environment. Usually, the odor will tip off the workers. As indicated in Table 6, it will be convenient and practical to run a test with a potassium iodide paper and also by detecting the odorJ7
Following steps have to be taken, when unfortunately a chlorine gas poisoning takes place.
(a) Move the subject to a gas-free environment to inhale fresh air. The subject has to be moved slowly into a warm room with fresh air. The rescurer should not panlck, but has to have enough self pro tection before making a rescue.
(b) The subject has to be kept warm enough to the degree of sweating, but never apply a pressue on the chest.
(c) The cloth that has contacted the concentrated gas should be removed and replaced with new cloth(since the irritating gas usually has low volatility and high adsorbability, it may remain in cloth and hair to evaporate slowly and prolong the poisoning. Particu lar precaution is required if the room has poor ventilation). However, it has to be remembered that it is more important to keep the subject calm than to force fully change the cloth of the afflicted subject.
(f) The patient has to be kept still and warm, to prevent pneumoniae.
(g) Treatment for the symptoms(it is best to treat the patient under doctor's supervision. In the following procedures, those with * mark should be performed only by physicians).
Treatment:
1. Mild poisoning : Make the patients smell the vapor of the equal mixture of alcohol and ether(In the old days, small amount of aniline vapor was used for this purpose, but this method is now considered to be dan gerous).
* Drink a very small amount of the mixture of alcohol, ether, and dilute ammonia(do not give alcohol or wine, merely to invigorating the patient)
2. Serious poisoning: * Venesect 5^0 - 800 cc of blood, depending on the build of the patient. Oxygen inhalation(with 5 % C02 added). Promote sweating * Cover the chest with cold wet cloth.
3. Eye injury : Wash with a large amount of water (do this with utmost urgency) Wash with 3 % boric acid solution or physiological saline warmed to body temperature(a tea spoonful of table salt is dissolved in 0.5 L warm water of about 37C) * Rub with vaseline * Treat with codeine. Use of tight-fitting bandage is prohibited Avoid exposure to light
4. Against coughing :
* Use codeine.
(d) The patient has to be laid down, while raising the upper part of the body.
(e) Thick coffee or tea may relax the state of Irritation.
lc
5* Against swelling of the mucous membrane: * Use coccaine or adrenaline.
6. General care : Take fluid food such like milk, egg and soup * Take or inject Hypo.
ucc
066896
6) Acetic acid
Acetic acid serves as a starting material for production of vinyl acetate. Vinyl acetate is copolyme rized with vinyl chloride, or poly vinyl alcohol is obtained from poly vinyl acetate.
Acetic acid, regardless of its wide industrial uses, has low inci dence of poisoning. However, recently in Italy, acetic acid has been added to a list of occupationally hazardous substance(1932). Parmeggiain et al.19 have surveyed the workers who had been working for more than 12 yrs in acetic acid plant, and found swelling of skin, tearing of skin with pain, reddness of eyes and mucous membrane of the throats, and in some cases a chronic bronchitis image by chest X-ray. Acidic tooth decay was also seen. And, symptoms in the digestive tract caused by unknown reason was also observed. These workers have been exposed almost constantly to 26 - 75 ppm of acetic acid gas. In some cases, the workers were exposed to the environment where the workers had a possibility of inhaling as much as 260 ppm of the gas. The tolerance level for acetic acid is set at 10 ppm.
7) Cyanide
Chance of using cyanide in synthetic resin industry is numerous in the production of acrylic and methacrylic resins. There is also a possibility of the danger of generating cyanide gas in the production of adiponitrile which is the intermediate for the production of nylon. Since cyanide is well known for its toxicity, usua lly any reactions that involve this gas are run in a completely enclosed system, so that there is no danger of coming into a direct contact with the liquid that contains cyanide com pound or no danger of the gas leakage. It is, however, still possible that the gas can leak from the cyanide storage tank or the liquid may escape
by accident to cause poisoning. Such
accident occurs occasionally during
the repair operation of the equipments.
Recently, there were
cases-of cyanide
poisoning in Japan. In one case, the
accident occurred during the work to
stop the leakage from the cyanide gene
rator, and in the other, it occurred
during removal of a product from the
calcium cyanide manufacturing plant.
Although four persons in the former case
and one person in the latter case suffered
from poisoning, fortunately there was
no death. In another case, which occurred
in another plant, poisoning resulted in
death. In this case, after repairing
the leakage of the calcium cyanide kettle,
the test showed that the leak was not
stopped. The worker panicked an<^ tried
to run and his leg was sprayed with
cyanide gas. After running for about
20 m, he was exhausted and died. In
this case, three other workers tried to
remove the victim's pants and also
suffered heavy poisoning.20
There are many books describing about how to handle and treat such acute poison ing with cyanide, and therefore, we are not going to repeat the procedure here. But, it might be necessary to mention about the works done in recent years that relate to the possibility of chronic cyanide poisoning.
When cyanide is detoxified, it binds
with sulfur to form SCN, and rhodanase
is the enzyme that catalyses such
reaction. If the rhodanase enzyme is
weak or inactive or if the supply of
sulfur is not sufficient, the amount of
rhodan being excreted into urine will
decrease. On the other hand, if the
above conditions are satisfied, the
amount of urinary rhodan should increase
with the amount of cyanide that has been
acted upon. Therefore, if the amount
of urinary rhodan in the urine of workers
is constantly monitored, it should be
possible to estimate the effective
dosage of cyanide and the degree of
detoxification. In recent years,
m$ny companies use
this rhodan test.
1 6 UCC 066897
However, the level of rhodan may vary even if the worker is not exposed to cyanide. For example, cyanide in the cigarette can be detoxified in the body to increase the rhodan content in urine (or the rhodan contents in saliva and urine may increase).
Thus, a true picture may not emerge unless the fate and amount of urinary rhodan is traced constantly for the same person. Currently in Japan, no company is doing this.
Recently, a paper was published in Italy about the subacute and chronic poisoning by cyanide among people who were working in cyanide-related operation or accidentally inhaled cyanide gas. Symptoms such like vertigo, inbalance, problem in gastric tract, difficulty of inhalation in exercise, and pain in heart have been reported. Increase in hemoglobin contents or increase in lymphocytes due to "stress" has also been reported in literature21.
We have observed an increase of the serum cholinesterase activity in person who has shown a symptom believed to be due to chronic poisoning by cyanides. 2 2
Like the case with formalin, there is a trend in recent years to set a strict tolerance level for cyanide. This is perhaps one of the expression to show a tremendous increase in the demand for cyanide.
Thus, Sato23 has carried out an exp eriment with mice to re-evaluate the existing tolerance level(10 ppm). He noted that a mild symptom was seen, even at 5 ppm. Based on this finding, he claims that, perhaps, a level of 2 ppm will be safe.
When a filter paper is dipped in a liquid containing a mixture of subli mate and methyl orange and this wet filter paper is brought Into the plant location, presence of cyanide will cause the color of the filter paper to
change into cherry red or red. If the color does not change within two minutes, it can be considered safe. Kitagawa's detection tube is also available.
8) Methyl acrylate
Methyl acrylate that serves as the
starting material for production of acrylic resin shows irritating effect on skin, mucous membrane of eyes, nose, and respiratory tracts. Although the symptoms may appear at 30 ppm level(in air), this level will cause merely some unpleasant ness and mild headache. Thus, at this level, there is no long-lasting problem nor cumulative effect.
If the concentration is higher than this level, it can cause, severe hyperemia of mucous membrane, epiphora, salivation, increase of running nose, and disruption of respiratory activity. It may eventually lead to convulsion or sleepness, respiratory paralysis and cyanosis, and finally to death. The disturbance of respiratory activity is said to be caused by the action of methyl acrylate on central nerve system.
Animal experiments showed that admi nistration of O.69 g per kg body weight of mouse can cause toxic symptoms.
Acute toxic symptoms will appear at an atmospheric concentration of 200 ppm. The odor can be detected at a level of 0.1 ppm. In the past, the tolerance level was set as 75 ppm. However, Takanarita24 has cautioned that it should be lower than 50 ppm. However, since even 30 ppm can cause some mild symptoms, the tolerance level should be kept below this level for workers who have to work in such an environment for a long period of time.
When methyl
acrylate is painted on
skin, inflammation and edema is noted
at the loci. In some severe cases,
necrosis has been observed at the loci.
Methyl
acrylate has a tendency to
penetrate deep into skin, and can cause
allergy symptoms.
17
ucc
066398
Kitagawa^, along with Takanarita, has modified and improved the method for determination of the level of methyl acrylate.
Precautions needed in the handling of methyl acrylate:
(1) Due to its volatility, the work has to be done in a well ventilated room.
(2) If there is insufficient venti lation, the worker has to wear a gas mask filled with organic filtering elements.
(3) If the hand is contaminated, the hand should be dipped in a wash basin containing 0.05 % potassium permanganate solution which dest roys the double bond of the methyl acrylate. The amount of potassium permanganate to be consumed is six times the amount of methyl acrylate, and therefore the above said concentration of potassium permanganate solution should be enough.
(4) Some people are sensitive to methyl acrylate. Therefore, a patch test should be used to screen the appli cants and those with positive re action should not be hired.
(5) Wear a rubber protective glove.
9) Urea
A portion of the toxicity of urine has been attributed to its urea con tent. Experiments with dogs or rabbits have shown that urea can cause tetani. With pigeon, 1/100th of the body weight, and with frog, l/50th of the body weight can cause an increase in the blood urea content by interdental injection, and can cause convulsion. It is also known that accumulation of urea cakes place in the brain tissue during the convulsive disease.
The only occupational disease caused by urea was the change of skin, and
18
not much has been studied about the disease caused by absorption of urea.
When urea comes into contact with hands and fingers, the skin surface will become thin and the finger print will become unclear. Then, it turns into red and loses senses. If urea reaches deep into the hand, it can cause bleeding and ulcer. 'Contact with urea, together with abrasion of skin, seems to cause the symptoms.
In one plant, examination of 48 workers revealed that 125 fingers were affected quite seriously, and 21 fingers per person were affected during this study period.28
The best way of prevention is to wear a glove. If the worker noted a contact with urea, he should wash the loci carefully with water each time and then wipe the area with dry towel. The glove should be washed frequently. Protective cream may also be coated on the hands. In such case, a film forming type of cream such like Kanekutan D (vinyl chloride) or ethyl methacrylate may be used.
It is also possible to cover the hand and fingers with bandage, but this will lower the working efficiency.
It was reported that, when an ulcer developped, there was relatively little pus formation, perhaps due to bacteri cidal effect of urea.
10) Others
Since the discovery by Reppe in 1938 that acrylic resins can be synthesized from acetylene and carbon monoxide, nickel carbonyl has become a popular catalyst and attracted much attention. This nickel carbonyl is quite toxic, and has been the problem in Nagoya area. In fact, a company has dispatched their R and D personnel to our clinic for health check, because of the concern over such poisoning.27 This has been reported in the paper by Nishikiori and Kawase.as,a^, 0 Toxicity of disulfur decafluoride(SaF10) and tetraethylortho-silicates has also been studied.
UCC 066899
3. MONOMERS
1) Vinyl chloride: Vinyl chloride has anesthetic property, but the toxicity is generally considered to be lower than carbon tetrachloride. -Results of animal experiments gave the following indications.
20 - *+0 % 10 %
5% o.5 ;
Death in a short while 60 Minutes, danger to life 60 Minutes, symptoms appear No symptoms after few hours
The tolerance level has been reported as 500 ppm.
In a plant in the Northeastern portion of Japan in 195few workers working in the production of vinyl chloride showed a Raynold syndrome like disease. Thus, there was a numbing feeling in fingers and toes, the faces turned pale, indicating a problem in blood circulation, accompanied by loss of sensitivity and felt cold. The problem, how ever, disappeared before any causes could be found. Even today, the cause of this problem is not clear?1
2) Vinylidene chloride: Besides
being combustible, vinylidene chloride
is known to possess considerable
degree of toxicity. It has an
effect similar to ethylene chloride.
A strong anesthetic action is
shown at a level 4000 ppm. At S000
ppm level, death occurs within one
minute. Results of animal tests
showed that it is safe at a level
of 200 ppm for 8 hours and at a
level of 1000 ppm for 30 - 60 minutes.
At 250 ppm level,it shows a chronic
cumulative effect.
But, there
is no such harm(no chronic effect) at
100 ppm. The tolerance level is
set at 100 ppm. It has odor similar
to carbon tetrachloride. At 1000
ppm, this odor is obvious, but at
500 ppm the odor is barely detectable. If there is a degradation product, even a smaller amount than 500 ppm can be detected by its odor.
Initial anesthetic symptoms are head ache, vertigo, dryness of lips, loss of balance, and fatigue. Chronically, it shows symptoms such like headache, gastrointestinal problems, vomiting, looseness of the stomach and chest pain.
Since vinylidene chloride contains a phenolic polymerization inhibitor, the phenol may frequently cause irritation in skin or mucous membrane. The poly merization inhibitor usually exists in a quantity of 0.3 - 1.0 %. Without such inhibitor, explosion may occur after a short time of storage unless it is sheltered from air and light, because, in the presence of oxygen, it can form a peroxide of unknown structure, and this peroxide serves as a polymeri zation catalyst to cause a reaction. The peroxide is extremely explosive and is absorbed in the polymer to make it explosive. If the content of peroxide exceeds 15 %, drying the polymer can cause an explosion by heat or by mechanical shock. When the peroxide decomposes gradually, the final products will be formaldehyde, phosgene, and hydrogen chloride. Therefore, any sour odor associated with vinylidene chloride polymer will mean a danger.
Experiments have shown that vinyli dene chloride can cause acute poisoning of liver and kidney. Pathologically, this is a toxic nephritis. Anuria will be the first stage of the poisoning. At this stage, in order to avoid hyderemia --^ pulmonary edema, it is necessary to irrigate the peritoneal cavity with Ringer or Tyrode (modified) solution to regain the electrolyte balance of the blood.32
Last year, there was a case of neuritis optica axialis among the workers working in a vinylidene chloride manu facturing plant in Japan. So far, however, the cause of this disease has not been established.33
39
UCC 066900
3) Acrylonitrile
pubTlisohxeicditybeofof rea,3c4ryalnodntihtreilreefohraes
been it
will not be repeated here. The tol
erance level is 20 ppm.
*The toxic symptoms of acrylonitrile
resemble that of cyanide, and in the
past this was attributed to the forma
tion of cyanide jLn vivo. In recent
years, however, this possibility has
been discounted. When acrylonitrile
is hydrolyzed in acid or alkaline
solution, it released ammonia rather
than cyanide to become acrylic acid.
When an
amount of this compound
equivalent to LDso(i.e. 13 mg/kg) was
given to animals and the dead animals
were autopsied, the amount of cyanic
acid found in the blood of heart was
0.09 " 0*280 Y/cc. This amount
is too small, if we assume that all
of the acrylonitrile administered
have released cyanic acid. Medical
treatment for cyanide poisoning
(20 % dextrose 5 cc/kg, i.v.; 3 %
sodium nitrite 70 mg/kg, i.d. ) has
been a failure. These evidences
thus overturned the conventional
concept.
Other higher nitriles are used more and more today. We have carried out experiments on palmitonitrile and other aliphatic nitriles about their toxicity. They can cause broad necrosis in the loci of injection, and can also cause coagulation and necrosis in liver and glass-like denaturation of the tubules of kidney. These evidences indicate that acrylonitrile has a sizable degree of local irritation and ab sorption toxicity. These higher ni triles have obnoxious odor which annoys the workers. So far, no satis factory* studies 3 hBave been conducted on this aspect.
4) Others : Styrene monomer also
shows a high degree of irritating
character. This has been reported
in many books and therefore will not
be repeated here.
There was a
reported case of the disease of eyes
caused by droplets from the splash of chloroacrylic acid.
4. POLYMERS
In view of the chemical properties, the so-called "polymers" usually do not have as much irritability and toxicity as the monomers.
Recently, however, new types of
occupational diseases called
by a name
"polymer fume fever"37,
or "resinosis" 47 *h*ave been reported,
and therefore they should not be
overlooked.jS They are the inflamma
tion of upper respiratory tract, bron
chitis or allergy-related fever caused
by inhalation of a large amount of
spray or powder dusts. They are
more or less dependent on individual
polymer, and are perhaps due to mech
anical and physical disturbance.
One of the widely publicised
disease of polymer is the problem
of the skin irritation caused by wearing
Nylon stocking. This is more of
a public health problem than occupational
disease problem, because the problem
occurred with women who wore Nylon
stockings.
In fact, in 1Q4o when
Nylon stocking was first introduced,
it created an epidemic of Nylon
dermatitis in the U.S.A.. Various
tests were conducted. Particularly,
the so-called Nylon patch test was
developed and this method was
used widely in an effort to find its
cause. It was found that Nylon or
its intermediate did not cause a positive
reaction on skin, but the reaction
occurred only with the stained Nylon.
As a result, the Nylon dermatitis was
attributed to the dyestuff used in
Nylon, and this problem was solved.
For example, in some reports, raw
Nylon cloth was patched on the skin
of 9 patients suffering from Nylon
dermatitis but the reaction was negative,
except 7 samples of stained Nylon cloth
which showed severe reaction.40 In
another report, experiment gave the
following results. 1
20
UCC 066901
Nylon cloth only Pyrrol derivative of
Nylon Dyestuff used in Nylon ' * Intermediate for the
Dyestuff used in Nylon
Test subjects
42 42
42 42
Positives
0 0
2
6
This result indicates that contami nation by dye itself , particularly by its intermediate, gave the strong est irritability. The cause was found in paraphenylenediamine or its homologs. Naturally, since Nylon prevents the evaporation of sweat, the situation is aggravated by a rash-like change. In addition, mechanical stimulus by Nylon can also enhance suppuration. Many reports claim that this type of dermatitis should be treated as an allergy-related dermatitis.
the rubber covering. Therefore, this material can not be used for making a rubber glove.
Cpichlorohydrin is treated with phenol to remove the chlorine and then the resulted product is polymerized to make epoxy or epoxyd resin. Epoxy or epoxyd resin can irritate the skin by contact. In a manufacturing plant, 8 workers suffered from bulla-like inflammation on hand, head, eyes and other parts of skins in the first 4 months of the plant's operation.43
Literature on the irritability toxicity of individual polymers is relatively rare, except Nylon. In Japan, they are almost non-existing. Recently, we were visited by an official of a company who mentioned that two workers in a plant that used urea resin as wood cement suffered neurasthenia-like symptoms. In this case, however, it is not clear whether the urea resin was the cause or not.
Following literatures are available abroad.
Ethylene tetrafluoride is an un stable, toxic gas, but its polymer also showed toxic effect.
Poisoning or dermatitis by polypropylene (polyoxy pro^lene)-glycol, methyl polysiloxane , Teflon A46, Paraplex G-25 and G-40 has also been reported in recent years. 7
In many cases, however, symptoms which were originally atrributed to the polymers were later found to be caused by the solvents or additives present in the polymer.
During the polymerization of Nylon or during the spinning process, 0.1 - 1.9 ppm of diphenyl or diphenyl oxide may be discharged as vapor. Although this level does not seem to cause any serious problems, it can still irritate the eyes or the respiratory tracts.48
Methyl methacrylate is a substance that can cause irritation in skin and mucous membrane. Similar symp toms were observed when the powder dusts of the polymer was inhaled for a long period of time. Naturally, the symptoms are very mild. Another property of polymethyl methacrylate is its ability to penetrate through
In the loading area of polyvinyl chloride, one may feel a mild irritation caused by the vinyl chloride monomer. Or, in the spinning room, one has a reason to concern about exposure to a low level of acetone and high level (25 - 200 ppm) of carbon disulfide. Since the tolerance level of carbon disulfide is 20 ppm, it is natural to
21
UCC 066902
see a report that neurotic symptoms and irritation symptoms of mucous membrane were found among workers during one year period of operation?9
In the handling of polystyrene, one
ma^ Tse exposed to ethylbenzene. At
275 ppm level, it can cause symptoms
such like neurological excitation,
leukopenia and lymphocytosis. Derma
titis is rare.
Also, aluminum chlo
ride can cause a convulsive bronchitis
or delay the heeling of wounds. If
there is a possibility of the presence
of the residue of styrene monomer,
naturally this will be toxic. In
fact, there is a report to prove
the presence of about 200 ppm level
of styrene in polystyrene. Based on
these reports, the tolerance level of
ethylbenzene was set 100 ppm and that
of styrene was set 150 ppm.
There has been an example of the irritability of phenolic resin becoming a problem. In this case also, later work has found contamination by monomer as the cause.51
5. SOLVENTS
l) Mono, di, tri-propylene glycol methyl ether : This is the solvent for nitrocellulose or synthetic resins. It is not ferrocorrosive, is stable to heat, and can mix with other organic solvents.
The LD50 for rats is 6.6 cc with the monopropylene glycol, 5*4 cc with the dipropylene glycol, and 3-3 cc with the tripropylene glycol.
Symptoms do not appear, even after administering the mono substance at a daily dose of 1 cc for 5 days, up to 35 days.
When a large dose of mono or tri-
propyleneglycol methyl ether is painted on skin and allowed to absorb, it can cause an anesthetic death.
With the same dosage of dipropylene glycol, however, such symptoms were not observed.
Naturally, with a very large dosage of mono-, di- or tri-propyleneglycol, it can cause depression of neurological function, and irritation of the mucous membranes of eyes, nose and lung.
It may be concluded, therefore, that a one time exposure to propyleneglycol methyl ether will not cause any symptoms, and this compound will be dangerous only when used continuously.
2) Dimethylformamide: This is used as a solvent of polyacrylonitrile.
A larger dose will be toxic enough to cause a death in animals. Symptoms are loss of body weight and hepatic disorder, but it does not show anesthetic activity.
In one spinning room, a level of
0.04 mg/litre was discovered. However,
the workers working in this plant did
not show any symptoms.
A tolerance
level has not been established, because
this is a new substance?3
3) Methylethylketone(Butanone) : Concern about the disease caused by methylethylketone occurred mainly as a result of the appearance of Saran paints.
Saran paints are made of 80 7. methyl ethylketone and 20 % salan. Its effect on living body has been attributed mainly to methylethylketone. Methylethylketone [CH3C0C2H5] is an aliphatic ketone. Generally speaking, the more carbon number the molecule has, the more toxic will be the compound. Based on this prediction, methylethylketone will be the second least toxic among some ten kinds of aliphatic ketones.
Main effect is the anesthetic effect on nerve system and the irritation of mucous membranes.
In actual cases,54 headache, nausea, vomiting have been reported. In serious
22
ucc
066903
cases, the victims may fall into comma. If left unattended, it may lead to respiratory paralysis and circulatory problem. However, no death has ever been reported. In the other countries, there was a case where women laborors working in the water-proofing project on raincoats were intoxicated and became uncncious, but later recovered without after effect. Methylethyl ketone(500 ppm) and acetone(450 ppm) were found in the air of this plant. However, in view of the symptoms, it is more likely that the air was filled with higher concentration of the gases. It was estimated that the concentration of methylethylketone was 1850 ppm and that of acetone was 1539 ppm.
Tolerance level of methylethylketone was set at 390 ppm. Haggard stated that presence of 1 - 2 g of methyl ethylketone in blood would start the toxic symptoms, 3 g would cause the loss of tendon reflex, 5 g would cause the loss of corneal reflex , and 9 g would lead to death,55
Results of the administration of methylethylketone to guinea pigs for 8 hours are shown below.
0.6 "/.....Irritation of mucous membrane
1.5 '/.....Anesthetic effect
2.0 %....Death
The magnitude of the acute effect of methylethylketone on human body is believed to be as follows.
0.3 7.....Can withstand for 8 hours without signficant problem
1 7.....Can withstand for 1 hour without significant problem
1.3-1*0 7,. .Danger to life after 4-8 hours
5-10 7.. ..Danger to life after 30 60 minutes
4) Others :
Few years ago, tetra-
chloroethane used for processing vinyl
chloride caused two death by hepatic
disorder in Tokyo area.58 Besides,
various other kinds of solvents, such like dioxane, benzene, tetrahydrofuran, formalin, acetone, and carbon dioxide are in use.
Toxicity of these solvents have been reviewed in other books, and therefore they are not repeated here. However, it is needless to say that these solvents play a great role in the toxification in synthetic resin and fibre industries, and this fact has to be always kept in mind.
6. ADDITIVES
Substances that are added in synthetic resins as plasticizers, stabilizers or color developing agent, may have toxicity.
Phthalate and phosphate are two sub stances that require particular attention. Well-known phthalates are dioctyl phthalate(DOP) and dibutyl phthalate(DBP). According to Carpenter57 who has fed various amounts of D0P to rats, a level of 0.13 - 9.04 % did not cause any problems after 2 years. At 0.4 7., however, the 7. of weight increase was hampered, and hepatic and nephrotoxicities were observed. Based on this datum, he has set the toxic limit for rats as 0.06 - 0.2 g/kg/day(2 years feeding). With guinea pigs, 0.13 7. DOP slightly enlarged the liver, but the disturbance was not severe. At 0.4 7., DOP showed toxicity. With dogs, 0.06 cc/kg/day is believed to be the toxic limit.
DBP attracted the attention of the
public because of the report of
accidental poisoning.50
A 23 year old
worker took DBP mistakenly as a purgatives.
He took a large spoonful of DBP at
roon time and experienced nausea and
vertigo, during the work hours. Few
hours later, the eyes swelled and became
painful with tears running. The victim
visited the hospital next day, and
diffusive edema, granular inflamnation
of cornea and centralized erosion were
discovered. Protein, red blood cells
and white blood cells were found in
the urine. With therapy, a quick reco
very took place and he was discharged
14 days later.
23 ucc
066904
On the other hand, the important
phosphate is tricresyl phosphate, and
several cases of poisoning have been
reported in Japan. Tricresyl phos
phate (TCP) shows the toxicity charac
teristic to ortho compounds. The
to*cicity of metha and para compounds
is known to be much milder. In the
accidental cases in Japan, polyneuri
tis similar to infantile paralysis
occurred. Since TCP is a substance
to inhibit the true cholinesterase
that is related to nerve functions,
the sequence of the incidence of this
disease is understandable.
Agricul
tural chemicals such like parathion
or TEPP are the well known cholin
esterase inhibitor, and they are the
same kind of organophosphate agents
like TCP.
Thompson60 has administered orally
1 cc TCP/kg to chicks in one dose and demonstrated the incidence of motor paralysis and demyelination in 12 15 days period. The serum(pseudo)cholinesterase level declined rapidly to 1/4 of the normal level(same with the brain and nerve cholinesterases). Although the serum cholinesterase(ChE)
level returned to normal level in l4 days, it took 21 days for the ChE of the brain and spine to return to the normal level. Based on these evidences, he made the following com ments. Thus, the pseudocholin esterase rather than the true cholin esterase is affected by TCP, and the decrease of the ChE does not occur in parallel to the demyelination. Therefore, there is a need to pay an attention on other enzymes such like tributyrirase and its change. While 60 - 80 % of the pseudocholinesterase activity was inhibited by TCP, only 35 - 50 7c of tributylynase was inhi bited. Other investigators, however, claim the antigonistic effect of TCP against vitamin E. Therefore, we have to acknowledge that the true mechanism of the demyelination is
still not clear.
In the reports published in Czecho slovakia, 61 autonomic nerve symptoms
were said to be the major symptoms, and others were dermographism, mulnutritions, and blood pressure depre ssion. Other nerve symptoms were polyneuritis(25 %), sleeplessness, headache, neurasthenia, extrapyramidal syndrome(mostly in older persons), and syndrome of the pyramidal tract. In this report, attention was paid to the relation between the route of invasion and the incidence of symptoms. In the case of invasion by absorption through the skin, symptoms of the peripheral nerve system are the most frequent. In the case of invasion by inhalation, attack on the central nerve system is the most frequent.
Recently, there was a report of
poisoning by dibutyl tin dilaurate
(Stabilizer No. 52) which was used as
a stabilizer.6- This substance
irritated
strongly the upper respi
ratory tract, turned urine to urobilli-
nogen positive and showed a tendency to
cause anemic symptoms in blood cells.
Experiments with rats showed a disorder appeared at 0.5 ppm. In this case, the incidence of symptoms was related to the humidity of the environ ment. It is interesting to note that this substance is harmful at temperature exceeding 30C, but is not particularly
harmful at temperature lower than 25C.
REFERENCE
1) Organic Chemistry Handbook(Japanese): Maruzen Publishing Co. pp 9'78-1000 (1951).
2) S. Yanagizawa : Rodo Kagaku, 32(1), 84 - 85(1956).
3) S. Kubotaka and S. Nomura : Unpublished information.
4) H. Sugai : Nippon Ganka Gakkai Zasshi, 50(11), 967-968(1956^
5) T. Baba : Rodo Kagaku, 32(11), 967 - 968(1956).
6) W. Deichmann : Industrial Hygiene and Toxicology(F.A. Patty), Vol. II, 1026(New York), 1949.
7) T. Takase : Chemical Structure and Physiological Action(in Japanese),
24
ucc
066905
Kania Book Store, pp 704 -705 (1941).
8) L.B. Bourne : XI Congr. Intern. Med.
del Lavoro Napoli, 45,1954.
9) X. Kido, K. Torisu : Rodo Kagaku,
2(n), 625-629(1953).
10) E.W. Baader : Arch. Gewerbepath.
Gewerbehyg., 1(5), 419-453(1955).
11) H. Menschick : Arch. Gewerbepath.
Gewerbehyg., 13(5), 455-^75(1955).
12) S. Kubota : Unpublished data.
13) S. Tanaka : Rodo Kagaku, 32(2),
117-126(1956).
14) T. Tanaka : Rodo No Kagaku, 10(5),
321-323(1955).
"
15) K. Ohwada, et al. : Osaka Shi Ika
Daigaku Zasshi, 3(3), 39-43(1954).
16) Patty : Ind. Hyg. and Toxic. II,
549(1949), New York.
17) K. Nishimura : Rodo Kagaku, 1(8),
532-537(1955); ibid., 1(9), 627-
630(1955)
18) F. Flury and F. Zernik : Schadliche
Gase, 117-121. Berlin(193l).
19) L. Parmeggiani and C. Sassi : Bull.
Hyg., 20(10), 1073(1954), an
Abstract.
20) Data, Industrial Hygiene Study
Group, Ammonium Sulfate Industry
Association. 1955.
21) Sfogliano, C. : Bull. Hyg. 1(4),
422(Abstract), 1956.
23) T. Sato, et al. : Report, National
Public Health Institute, Japan,
4(4), 3-5(1955).
24) J. Takanarita : Nagoyo Igaku,
68(8), 60-72(1954).
25) T. Kitagawa, et al. : Rodo Kagaku,
0(4), 202-203(1954).
26) M. Meno : Unpublished data.
27) S. Ishizu : Industrial Hygiene Study
Group, Ammonium Sulfate Industry
Association, 1955*
28) H. Okutani ; Rodo No Kagaku, 10(5),
318-321(1955).
"
29) N. Nishikiori : Rodo Kagaku, 29(5).
234(1953); ibid.. 2(1),201(1954).
30) H. Kawase : Rodo Kagaku, 2(10),
871-872(1956); ibid.. 32(1)7 84
(1956).
31) Unpublished data.
32) Handling Precaution for Vinylidene
Chloride Monomer : The Dow Chemical
Company, Michigan.
33) T. Nishimura: Unpublished data. 34) Society of Organic Synthetic Chemi
stry, Japan: Safety Handbook for Industrial Chemicals,. 1-6, Maruzen Publishing Co.(Feb.,1954). 35) L. Ghiringhelli : Bull. Hyg. 29(10), 1947(1954). 36) Unpublished data.
37) D.K. Harris : Lancet 2, 1008(1951). 38) G.P. Child and C. Clancy : A.M.A.
Arch. Ind. Hyg. Occ. Med. 7(5), 439
(1953). 39) R.H. Wilson and W.E. McCormick :
Ind. Med, and Surg., 24(11), 491 -
496(1955). 40) Chr. Vial-Weissenbach : Berufsdermatosen,
(6), 237-238(1955). 41) J. Pellerat, et al. : Berufsdermatosen,
(6), 237(1955). 42) D.K. Harris : Brit. J. Ind. Med. 10(4),
255-268(1953). 43) J. Pluss : Ztschr. Unfallmed. Berufs-
krh. 47(2), 83-88(1954). 44) C.B. Shaffer, et. al. : A.M.A. Arch.
Ind. Occup. Med. (5), 448-453(1951). 45) G.P. Child, et al. : A.M.A. Arch.
Ind. Occup. Med., (5), 479-482(1951). 46) H.E. Stokinger : A.M.A. Arch. Ind.
Hyg. Occup. Med., 8(2), 196-197(1953). 47) F.W. Sunderman and H.3. Haag : A.M.A.
Arch. Ind. Hyg. Occup. Med. (2), 210-211(1954). 48) L. Parmeggiani and C. Sassi : Bull. Hyg. 0(7), 599-600(1955). 49) G.E. Morris : A.M.A. Arch. Ind. Hyg. Occup. Med., 2(2), 210-211(1954). 50) Barsotti, and Pisani : XI Congr. Int. Med. del Lavoro, 34 (1954). 51) R. Luvoni : Bull. Hyg. 2(5), 505 (1954). 52) V.K. Rowe, et al. : A.M.A. Arch. Ind. Hyg. Occup. Med. 2(6), 509525(1954). 53) E. Holstein : XI Congr. Internat. Med. del Lavoro, 4(1954). 54) F.A. Patty : Ind. Hvg. Toxicol., Vol. II, New York '939-947(1949)
55) S. Ishizu : Rodo No Kagaku, 11(3). 175 - 176(1956).
56) S. Nomura, et al. : Eisei Gaku Kaishi, 2(2), 26-27(1954).
57) C.P. Carpenter : A.M.A. Arch. Ind. Hyg. Occup. Med., 8(3), 219 - 226(1953).
25 UCC 066906