Document Md7rQkMR9JBzV6oLwpm8EDkz
2oi The Classification o: Cheat B.adiograpns for Loa'. Workers- Pneumoconiosis. Performance of Two Readers Over a Penoc o: Six Tears. J. R. Ashford. Brit. J. Ind. Med. _i_7, 293-303 vCct. ivcOi.
A Study of the ~
This paper is concerned with the performance over the past 6 years of the 2 doctors
responsible for the classification of chest radiographs obtained by the National Coal Board's
Pneumoconiosis Field Research. A brief description is given of the categories of pneumo
coniosis used in the Research and of the procedures adopted to decide the final or "definitive1-
classification. The readings obtained are then considered in detail and 3 main points emerge
from the analysis. First, it is shown that there have been marked systematic fluctuations in
the reading levels of these 2 very experienced observers. In spite of these individual varia
tions it is found that the standards applied on the definitive readings, which ars based on the
joint discussion by the 2 doctors of films on which their individual readings are inconsistent,
remain remarkably constant over a period of several years. The third main feature of the
analysis is the considerable differences in the magnitude of the reading errors between the
various categories of pneumoconiosis. It is concluded that, although the existing procedures
provide a satisfactory way of estimating the prevalence of pneumoconiosis, it would be de
sirable to increase the number of film readers. The beneficial effect of the system whereby
a running check is kept on film reading standards is also established.
-- Author's abst.
268 Emphysema, Soot, and Pulmonary Circulation. Macroscopic Studies of Aging Lungs. " C". P. Oderr. J. Am. Med. Assn. 172, 1991-1998 (-Apr. 30, 1960).
Two hundred lungs, obtained from persons dying of diseases other than pulmonary
tuberculosis, were fixed in the inflated state to permit study of the relation between emphysema
and deposits of soot. The evidence showed that chronic emphysema usually develops first in
small areas of trapped parenchymal soot deposits; it is manifested by abnormal fenestrations
in the interalveolar septums and by increased diameter of the alveolar ducts. The emphysema
accompanying deposits of soot can be explained as resulting from tissue defects and disarrayed
mechanical forces. Precapillary vessels are found protruding into the air spaces of the al
veolar duct level, providing a possible mechanism for correlation between aerodynamics and
hydrodynamics in the lung parenchyma. The morphological basis for an extensive semishunt
mechanism is demonstrated in the periphery of each lobe.
-- APCA Absts.
269 Radiological Diagnosis in Asbestosls. R. Williams and P, Hugh-Jones. Thorax (London) 15, 103 (June I960).
The authors studied the lung function in 40 patients at the Royal Free Hospital, Lon
don, who had been exposed to asbestos dust in their work for varying periods of time. Of thes>
asbestosis had been certified by the pneumoconiosis medical boards in 21; 10 patients with a
prolonged exposure did not have definite roentgenographic signs of asbestosis; in the remaining
9 patients the diagnosis of asbestosis was doubtful. The changes of pulmonary function ob
served in the patients with asbestosis were those common to patients with other interstitial
fibroses, and consisted of a lowered diffusing capacity together with a reduced inspiratory
capacity, hyperventilation (often accompanied by arterial desaturation) on exertion, with no
evidence of air-flow obstruction except in patients in whom asbestosis was complicated by
asthma or emphysema. Many patients also showed inequality of ventilation and ventilation-
perfusion ratio. These functional changes were related to an independent grading of physical
signs and roentgenographic appearances. Changes in lung function, specific for an interstiti**
fibrosis, often precede definite changes in the cheat roentgenogram, so that finding them in
patients with a history of exposure to asbestos is suggestive evidence of asbestosis whatever
the roentgenographic appearances may be.
-- J. Am, Med. Assn. Absts.