Document MKp4rdrJvYe9oBjQa1O1Q0bV
Building B-101
Dow U.S.A.
The Dow Chemical Company 2301 N. Brazosport Blvd.
Freeport, Texas 77541-3257
OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH SUMMARY REPORT
LOCATION: PERIOD COVERED:
UNTT V (VINYL CHLORIDE PRODUCTION) April 4 - May 3,1994
MEDICAL
C. K. Browdy, M.Dj Occupational Health Associate
g-X
Date
C O N F ID E N T IA L
cc: L. J. Burmeier J. H. Saunders, M.D. Summary File
Wp3o3 00C>3n
oo
OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH SUMMARY REPORT
This is a voluntary participation program. The group population is seventy. Thirty-one individuals have current information and were not examined at this time. One individual is in the Management Examination Program. Thirty-seven individuals were examined between April 4,1994, and May 3, 1994, for a 97% participation rate.
The Chemical and Physical Agent Inventory (CPAI) for Unit V, the vinyl chloride monomer production plant, shows that potential exposures are low. This plant is not yet in operation. All individuals are followed on the periodic core examination.
There were thirty-six audiograms done. There was one standard threshold shift as defined by the OSHA Noise Standard. This individual is not in the Texas Operations Hearing Conservation Program.
Three individuals have limitation of respirator usage based on initial screening of the medical examination data. Please see Attachment A for medical limitation of respirator usage. If these medical restrictions interfere with an individual's job requirements, further evaluation at the Occupational Health Department should be arranged to fully assess the need for medical limitation of respirator usage.
Individuals with life-style factors that are amenable to medical or dietary intervention include the following: eight smokers, twentynine individuals who are overweight, four individuals with uncontrolled hypertension, and fifteen individuals with elevated cholesterol levels. Please see Attachment B for a graphic representation of this data. Assistance in modification of these life style risk factors can be obtained by contacting the Health Promotion Department (238-4334).
Attachments
C O N F ID E N T IA L
P&S153619
ATTACHMENT A
August 24, 1994
MEDICAL LIMITATION OF RESPIRATOR USAGE
The following three individuals may wear respirators for escape purposes only:
The following sixty-seven individuals have no medical limitation of respirator usage:
ATTACHMENT A
Page 2
C O N F ID E N T IA L
a>n
$ a
3)
Co Oi CoO>
ro
ATTACHMENT B
August 24, 1994
Data from "UNIT 5 8/94"
% TX OPRS % UNITY
RISK FACTORS
% UNIT V
C O N F ID E N T IA L
30
co CuJl Ottoo)
IHS Hie #00-4961
1993-95 OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH PROGRAM UNIT 5/VINYL CHLORIDE, OC-501
MONITORING PROGRAM
1. RATIONALE
To fulfill OSHA requirements of the vinyl chloride and benzene standards, establish a monitoring base and to evaluate the need for any additional engineering controls. Initial monitoring will be conducted immediately after plant startup. Chemicals evaluated will include vinyl chloride, benzene, ethylene dichloride, and methylene chloride. Respiratory protection will be used for any job tasks with a significant potential for exposure to concentrations above the acceptable guidelines. Respiratory protection will be continued until monitoring data has proven levels to be below acceptable exposure standards.
Area noise level monitoring will be conducted as new equipment Is installed to determine the need for hearing protection, additional engineering controls and identify any job classifications that may need to be included In the hearing conservation program. Personnel monitoring will be conducted for job classifications where 8-hour TWA exposures may exceed 85 dBA. After plant startup, a comprehensive area and personnel noise survey will be conducted to identify all areas with noise levels greater than 85 dBA and determine If any job classifications need to be included in the hearing conservation program.
2. SAMPLING STRATEGY
When Unit 5 reaches the final stages of construction, job classifications will be evaluated periodically to determine the need for chemical and/or noise monitoring. Monitoring will be conducted on an as needed basis until startup. As soon as possible after startup a comprehensive noise and chemical survey will be conducted. The sampling strategy (number of samples and job classifications) will be determined at that time.
3. SAMPLING METHODS
Sampling for vinyl chloride, ethylene dichloride, methylene chloride, and benzene will be conducted using 1 gram charcoal tubes and air sampling pumps. Pumps will be calibrated both before and after use at 50 cc/min for 8-hour TWA samples and 200 cc/min for excursion samples (as outlined in DLMHM-83-25A). Analysis will be performed by the Industrial Hygiene Laboratory.
Personal noise levels will be measured using Quest noise dosimeters (Model M-7B) and area noise levels will be measured using a Quest noise level meter (Model 215). All dosimeters and meters will be calibrated both before and after use.
4. QUALITY CONTROL AND EQUIPMENT
Routine quality control procedures shall be an integral pari of the sampling and analysis procedures and functions. These shall include:
a. Routinely introduced sampling of blanks and spikes (known content) along with other samples for analysis
b. Routine checking, calibrating, and maintaining in good working order all equipment and instruments. Air sampling pumps will be calibrated both before and after use.
c. Routine checking of procedures and results. d. Participation in Dow's Analytical Proficiency Testing (APT) Program.
C O N F ID E N T IA L
31
CO cn
CoO>
N>
03
IHS Rio #00-4961
1993-96 OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH PROGRAM UNIT S/VINYL CHLORIDE, OC-SOI
Pago 2
MONITORING PROGRAM (CONT.)
5. EVALUATION CRITERIA
AflfiUL
Vinyl Chloride Ethylene Dichloride
Benzene Methylene Chloride Noise
Exposure
Excursion
jaukfellne____________Guide_____________ Source*
Ippm 10 ppm ippm Ippm 50 ppm
90 dBA (8-hr TWA) 85 dBA (8-hrTWA
5ppm-STEL
2 ppm 5 ppm-STEL
90 dBA-Ceiling
OSHA-PEL ACGIH-TLV Proposed OSHA PEL OSHA-PEL ACGIH-TLV
DowlHG OSHA-PEL OSHA-Action Level
* OSHA-PEL - Occupational Safety and Health Administration - Permissible Exposure Limit ACGIH-TLV - American Conference of Governmental Hygienlsts-Threshokf Limit Value Dow-IHG Dow Industrial Hygiene Guideline
C O N F ID E N T IA L
r &s 153624
Distribution List for Unit V VCM Exposure Plan
Unit V Staff
Others
S
n>
a
no
2:
HH 2
g
33 03 Eft
03
(CVJli
Unit V Industrial Hygiene Monitoring VCM Exposure Follow Up Program
Introduction Areas Addressed
This document is intended to explain the responses of Unit V personnel to the results of personnel monitoring data showing levels of Vinyl Chloride in above the "Action Level" as defined in OSHA 1910.1017 Vinyl Chloride.
Information
Monitoring results were communicated to the individuals involved immediately upon receipt of the information or at first availability of the individuals.
Sampling Techniques
Sampling techniques were critiqued and suggestions to the individuals were made.
Lab Hoods
A review of the effectiveness of the Laboratory Vent Hoods was conducted and action was taken to correct any deficiencies.
Monitoring Plans
The frequency of monitoring of personnel showing VCM levels above the "Action Level" was increased and specific tasks noted.
Sampling Devices
Tracking of problems associated with the sampling devices was begun and the supplier of these devices was contacted for recommendations on the problems with leaking seals.
Program Plans
Action
1. Determine by leak testing with an HNU which bombs are leaking and track the frequency of failures.
2. Replace Technova sample "bombs" on the samples with the highest frequency of failures.
3. Continue monitoring of people one day per week during the sampling process until data shows this is no longer needed.
By Whom
Date
Beginning 10/27/94 on PM schedule. _
As needed basetfon the data collected in #1.
Beginning week of 10/31/94.
TASafety\VCMProg.doc 10/27/94
Restrictedfor use within Dow
1
Unit V Industrial Hygiene Monitoring VCM Exposure Follow Up Program
Introduction Areas Addressed
This document is intended to explain the responses of Unit V personnel to the results of personnel monitoring data showing levels of Vinyl Chloride in above the "Action Level" as defined in OSHA 1910.1017 Vinyl Chloride.
Information
Monitoring results were communicated to the individuals involved immediately upon' receipt of the information or at first availability of the individuals.
Sampling Techniques
Sampling techniques were critiqued and suggestions to the individuals were made.
Lab Hoods
A review of the effectiveness of the Laboratory Vent Hoods was conducted and action was taken to correct any deficiencies.
Monitoring Plans
The frequency of monitoring of personnel showing VCM levels above the "Action Level" was increased and specific tasks noted.
Sampling Devices
Tracking of problems associated with the sampling devices was begun and the supplier of these devices was contacted for recommendations on the problems with leaking seals.
Program Plans
Action
1. Determine by leak testing with an HNU which bombs are leaking and track the frequency of failures.
2. Replace Technova sample "bombs" on the samples with the highest frequency of failures.
3. Continue monitoring of people one day per week during the sampling process until data shows this is no longer needed.
By Whom
Date
Beginning 10/27/94 on PM schedule.
As needed based on the data collected in-#l.
Beginning week of 10/31/94.
REDACTED
C O N F ID E N T IA L
T:\Safety\VCMProg.doc 10/27/94 bw
Updated 2/1/95 bw
Restrictedfor use within Dow
JJ s*
0)
caPcoOn
Unit V Industrial Hygiene Monitoring VCM Exposure Follow Up Program
A Vinyl Monitoring/Technova Follow Up meeting was held February 1,1995. Attendees were
Agenda Items were: Review of written plans and action items Review of monitoring data Review of maintenance on Technova samplers Brainstorm additional items
Action Items resulting from the meeting were:
Replace Vinyl "bombs" with new type - no plungers. Establish a ppm program based on leak test data. Meet again in 6 months to review status of Technovas.
REDACTED
C O N F ID E N T IA L
R&S153628
T:\Safety\VCMProg.doc 10/27/94 bw
Updated 2/1/95 bw
Restrictedfor use within Dow
2
UNITY VINYL CHLORIDE EXPOSURE
Policy A
OSHA
The Occupational Safety and Health Administration Standard for Vinyl Chloride states:
1. No employee may be exposed to Vinyl Chloride at concentrations greater than 1 PPM averaged over any eight hour period.
2. No employee may be exposed to Vinyl Chloride at concentrations greater than 5 PPM averaged over any period not exceeding 15 minutes.
3. No employee may be exposed to Vinyl Chloride by direct contact with liquid Vinyl Chloride.
The OSHA rule simply means "that we must never knowingly be exposed to vinyl chloride in concentrations above the prescribed limits, and that every precautionary measure is taken to keep from being over-exposed unknowingly".
NOTE: A detailed explanation of the air monitor system, specifications and operating discipline are maintained in the Environmental Section ofToolbook.
C O N F ID E N T IA L
AIR MONITOR
ALARM
Some of the situations that may arise and the correct procedures are:
Response to a vinyl chloride air monitor alarm:
1. Notify everyone in the plant via an intercom as to the location ofthe air monitor alarm and wind direction (stack monitor alarms are not considered leaks, but should be announced over the intercom).
2. Either a HNU portable analyzer or an organic vapor portable (OVA) reading of 500 PPMV of VCM constitutes a leak under TACB Permit C 19041 Section 7H. Because ofthe HNU analyzer limiting range (1000 PPM), the OVA is the portable analyzer of choice when pinpointing VCM leaks as defined by TACB Permit C 19041.
3. Respiratory equipment (5 or 30 minutes SCBAs) must accompany the person who is attempting to locate the leak. Respiratory equipment must be worn if more than 1 PPM is determined by the portable detector:
a. for concentrations 1 PPM to 3,600 PPM, a self-contained breathing apparatus must be used. Because of the limited air supply, 5 minute air packs should be used for escape only.
6/9/93 T:\SAFETY\SAF_PLCY\POL_A DOC Reviewed 8/10/94 RWT
Continued on nextpage Page: 1
Policy A
AIR MONITOR ALARM, cont.
b. at concentrations greater than 3,600 PPM but less than 10,000 PPM do not enter the area except for purposes of rescue or prevention of greater hazard. (36,000 PPM in air is the L.E.L. for Vinyl Chloride.)
4. Barricade leak area so that exposures outside ofthe barricaded area will be less than 1 PPM Vinyl Chloride.
LEAK DETECTION The Unit V Leak Detection/Elimination Plan must be followed.
ELIMINATION
NOTE: Actionfor anypositive reading identified as
PLAN
Vinyl Chloride.
1. Locating the leak source.
2. Defining boundaries ofthe area of high vinyl concentration.
i
3. Restricting access to the high vinyl area with barricades, tape, and signs.
4. Requiring the use of air supplied respiratory equipment be mandatory for entry into the area. 5 minute escape packs are not acceptable for entry.
5. Notifying the appropriate supervisor.
6. Monitoring equipment cleaning procedures if maintenance is necessary.
7. Resurveying the leak site after repairs are finished.
EQUIPMENT OPENING
The National Emission Standard for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) states: "Before opening any equipment for any reason, the quantity of Vinyl Chloride is to be reduced so that the equipment contains no more than 2.0 percent by volume Vinyl Chloride or 0.0950M*3 (25 gallons) of Vinyl Chloride, whichever is larger, at standard temperature and pressure".
NON-ROUTINE SAMPLING
Any non-routine sampling must first be evaluated for proper compliance with OSHA rules before proceeding with sampling and a procedure written.
C O N F ID E N T IA L
R&s 153630
Stt/93 T:\SAFETY\SAF_PLCY\POL A Reviewed 8/10/94 RVVT
Page: 2
OCS Unit V Basic Safety Ori ntation
Background
This unit orientation module is designed to allow temporarily assigned personnel to receive basic unit specific safety orientation without repeating information already received.
Department Safety Rules
All Texas Operations Safety Rules and Standards apply in this Unit and are expected to be followed. In addition the following departmental rule extracts apply to all personnel working in Unit V
Prior to entering the Unit Vprocess area you must complete the VinyUBenzene hazard communications.
No items shall be put in your mouth in the process, labs or shop areas.
Fire resistant clothing is required in designated areas around Unit's V's directfire equipment.
Unit V's safety showers are equipped with orange drop switches which alarm in the control center. The drop switch must be activated when using the safety shower.
Diked areas require monogoggles to be worn. Vehicles may enter the process area on a must need basis
only with authorizationfrom an area technician.
C O N F ID E N T IA L
Unit Emergency Procedures
An arealblock plot plan is shown on the back of Visitor's Card and Safe Work Permit. Also an OC-501 floor plan is available.
Four Assembly Points at each comer of the Unit. Entire process area contains hazardous chemicals Restroom & eatingfacilities are located in building OC-5Q1 There are manual Pull Switchesfor the Building Fire Alarm
located throughout each building.
In the event of an emergency, while working in Unit V , the following procedure should be initiated.
Reporting an Emergency: Ifyou are involved in or observe a spill, incident, or other type ofpotential emergency event you must notify the control center by intercom or phone (7980/233-4023). Ifdanger is imminent you should report condition to Industrial Security, x-66666 and notify the control center.
R&S 153631
October 1993 Revised 3/7/94 bw/rt
T :\S*fety\0rientaftU5Orient-doc
Restricted for use within Dow
1
V
OCS Unit V Basic Safety Orientation
Unit Emergency Procedures (continued)
Assembling & Evacuating: When the block unit emergency horn is sounded all safe work permits are cancelled and you must immediately report to: Alert: OC-501 Conference Room (160 AJB) unless
otherwise directed. A decision will be made onfurther action. Gas Release or Evacuate: Procede across and upwind to appropriate assembly point. Building Fire Alarm: Immediately exit the building and go to the OC-501 Parking Lot. A decision will be made on further action.
Communication
^nit V ^eves ^ ^ *s very important that you are aware that the following chemicals are located in the Unit and that you understand and respect the potential significant health threat each chemical poses if handled incorrectly.
VINYL CHLORIDE ( VCM ): Is an OSHA regulated chemical. Brief exposures to high concentrations of Vinyl Chloride may result in central nervous system depression, tiredness, and even death. Vinyl Chloride has poor warning properties, as the odor threshold is quite high. Lons term chronic exposures may result in lung, liver, and kidney effects and can also cause changes in the skin, bone, and blood circulation. Vinyl Chloride is a human carcinogen, linked to angiosarcoma, a cancer of the liver. A rhedical surveillance program has been institutedfor Vinyl Chloride to lookfor early signs of Vinyl Chloride exposure. Details of this program are located in the OSHA Standard or can be obtained through the Occupational Health Department. The Permissible Exposure Level (PEL) is 1 ppm as an eight hour time weighted average. Jobs or tasks which require protective equipment, including respirators, will have job procedures outlining any necessary protective steps. Contact with liquid Vinyl Chloride may causefrostbite.
BENZENE: Is an OSHA regulated chemical. Some of Unit V's process streams contain Benzene. This chemical is listed as a carcinogen.
October 1993 Revised 3/7/94 bw/rt
T:^ifety\Orientat\U50riem.doc
Restricted for use within Dow
2
C O N F ID E N T IA L
R&S 153632
OCS Unit V Basic Safety Orientation
Hazard Communication (continued)
ETHYLENE DICHLORIDE ( EDC ): This chemical is listed as a potential carcinogen. Excessive inhalation exposure may cause nausea and lor vomiting.
METHYLENE CHLORIDE: This chemical is listed as a potential carcinogen. Inhalation may cause irritation, sleepiness, dizziness. Contact with the skin may cause a burning sensation, numbness, irritation, possible bum.
CARBON TETRACHLORIDE: This chemical is listed as a potential carcinogen. Inhalation may cause irritation ofeyes, nose & throat, tiredness, dizziness. Alcohol consumption may increase effects.
HYDROGEN CHLORIDE ( HCL ): Inhalation may cause severe irritation and injury to nose, throat, and lungs. Liquid contact may cause severe skin bums.
CELL EFFLUENT ( CAUSTIC ): May cause severe injury to eyes ifexposure is prolonged. If unattended, may cause severe bums to the skin.
CHLORINE: Inhalation may cause severe irritation ofnose, throat and lungs. Short single exposure may cause severe skin bums.
The Unit V material safety data sheets (MSDSs) are available to you and are located in control center. Our Industrial Hygiene Manual is located in the control center as well.
Personal Protective Equipment
Minimum Safety Equipment which must be worn includes:
Hard Hat Side Shield Safety Glasses Mouthbit respirator (Acid!gas) Monogoggles carried on person when in a process area.
C O N F ID E N T IA L
r & s i 53633
October 1993 Revised 3/7/94 bw/rt
T:NSafcty\0ricnuAU5Oricr\Udoc
Restricted for use within Dow
3
OCS Unit V Basic Safety Ori ntation
<
Unit Facilities
As illustrated on the QC-501 plot plan, the following are available to you:
The rest rooms are located in the OC-501 building, Eating facilities are located in the OC-501 building.
Telephones are availablefor emergency use in every building except the motor control center.
In case offamily emergencies you can be contacted via the Control Center at 233-4023.
Lockout/Tagout
Unit V abides by the U.S. Area Safety Standard No. 3 Lockout / Tagout It is a requirement that before working under this system you have User training and have passed the proficiency test
Specific LO/TO procedures relevant to this Unit only will be reviewed prior to beginning work on that job.
Safe Work Permits
Safe Work Permits can be obtained from the Process Technicians in the permit room adjacent to the control center.
The Safe Work Permits will be posted in the permit room and should be returned there when the job is complete.
C O N F ID E N T IA L
R&S 153634
October 1993 Revised 3/7/94 bw/rt
T;\Safety^Oricntai\U50nentdoc
Restricted for use within Dow
4
51
HUMAN HEALTH
\i
Vinyl chloride is a colourless flammable gas at room temperature and pressure, with a pleasant, sweet odour at high concentrations. Human exposure to this synthetic compound is generally by inhalation and less frequently by skin absorption. Until very recently, its documented health effects were confined to Raynaud's syndrome-type sympt ms (a syndrome characterized by deadening of sensations at the fingertips, whitening of fingers, and pain and sores on the hands), skin changes, bone lesions, acroosteolysis (deprivation or removal of calcium from bones in hands or feet), central nervous system depression, and disorders of the circulatory system (SOEHS 1975j EPA 1975; ICF 1974).
In 1971, a link was drawn between the inhalation of vinyl chloride monomer and malignant changes in rats. Later animal studies have further confirmed first reported cases. Subsequently, hepatic angiosarcoma (a rare form of liver cancer) cases among occupationally exposed workers were reported (SCC 1981; NTIS 1981).
In 1976, there were 48 known cases of vinyl chloride-related hepatic iosarcomas in the world, 47 of which involved the handling of large quantities of
P efied vinyl chloride under pressure (SCC 1981). After detailed research and study,
vinyl chloride is generally considered to be a confirmed human carcinogen (Doc. TLV 1981: U5DHEW 1981; Doniger 1978; Senate 1974); as a result, its use has been restricted under environmental, drug, public health and regulatory Jaws.
Due to the tremendous usage of the chemical, its deleterious effects have been widely studied and documented. A number of agencies have reviewed vinyl chloride toxicology (VCT 1980; SCC 1976, 1981). Several reports have dealt with its carcinogenic, mutagenic and teratogenic effects. The compound is listed by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency under the TSCA Inventory. Due to the large volume and repetitive conclusions of these tests, only the most recent or more significant of these have been documented.
The toxicological data summarized here have been extracted from reliable standard reference sources. It should be noted that some of the data are for chronic (long-term), low-level exposures and may not be directly applicable to spill situations.
7-1 Recommended Exposure Limits
*
The exposure standards for vinyl chloride are based upon its carcinogenic
Jrties. Canadian provincial guidelines generally are similar to those of the USA-
^CGIH unless indicated otherwise.
52
Guideline (Time) Origin
Time-weighted Averages (TWA)
TLV (8 h)
USA-ACGIH
PEL (8 h)
USA-OSHA
Action Level
USA-OSHA
Recommended Exposure Level
USA-NIOSH
Time Weighted
Ontario
Average Exposure
Permissible Con centration (8 h)
B.C.
Concentration moyenne (8 h>
Carcinogenic Substance (duration unspecified)
Quebec Saskatchewan
Short-term Exoosure Limits (STEL)
Ceiling (15 min sample.
USA-OSHA
Ceiling (15 min sample)
USA-NIOSH
Concentration
Quebec
maximale (15 min)
Maximum
Ontario
Other Human Toxicities
IDLH
TCLO (intermittent)
Recommended Level
5 ppm (10 mg/m3) 1 ppm 0.5 ppm 1 ppm 2 ppm (5.2 mg/m3) 1 ppm, carcinogen 1 ppm, cancerigene None given, carcinogenic substance
5 ppm Minimum detectable 1 ppm 1 ppm, cancerigene 10 ppm (26 mg/m3)
No data *500 ppm
Reference
TLV 1983 NIOSH/OSHA 1981 GE 1978 NIOSH Standard 1974 Ont. Reg. 1982
B.C. 1980
Quebec 1979
Saskatchewan 1981
NIOSH/OSHA 1981 NIOSH/OSHA 1981 Quebec 1979
Ont. Reg. 1982
RTECS 1979
Inhalation Toxicity Index
The Inhalation Toxicity Index (ITI) is a measure of the potential of a substance to cause injury by inhalation. It is calculated as follows:
ITI = 1315.12 (Vapour pressure, in mm Hg/TLV, in ppm) At 20C, ITI = 1315.12 (2524 mm Hg/5 ppm)
= 6.6 x 105
R&S153636
# -2.1
Irritation Data Skin Contact*
53
Exposure Level (and Duration)
SPECIES: Human Unspecified
Unspecified Unspecified
Effects
*
Reference
Sclerotic changes of the skin and various lesions.
Allergic dermatitis.
Degenerative skin changes which histologically showed destruction of the elastic network of the connective tissue (hands, forearm, face).
TDB (on-line) 1931
TDB (on-line) 1981 SOEHS 1975
7.2.2
Eye Contact.
I___________________________
posure Level wid Duration)
Effects
SPECIES: Human Unspecified (liquid)
Unspecified (liquid)
Inflammation of conjunctivas and lesions in the cornea due to inflammation.
Contact of eyes with escaping compressed vinyl chloride can produce frostbite.,
Reference Lefevre 1930 Ccc. TLV 1981
7.3 Threshold Perception Properties
7.3.1
Odour.
Characteristics: Mild, sweet, pleasant (Verschueren 1934) Odour Index: 100 (20C) (Verschueren 1934)
54
Parameter Threshold Odour Concentration Detection Threshold
Media In air In air
Concentration
Reference
4000 to 25 000 ppm
w*rschueren 1984
1200 to 2000 ppm AWQC 1978
7.3.2 7.4 7.4.1
Taste. No data. Toxicity Studies Inhalation.
Exposure Level (and Duration)
Effects
Reference
Acute Exposures
SPECIES: Human
25 000 ppm (3 min) 8000 to 12 000 ppm (5 min) 10 000 ppm 4000 ppm (5 min or more)
1000 ppm
500 ppm Unspecified
Unspecified
Dizziness and disorientation.
Intoxication signs are manifested.
Noticeable anesthetic effects.
Dizziness and confusion. Higher concentrations may lead to unconsciousness and death.
Slight anesthesia, drowsiness, slight visual disturbances, faltering gait, numbness and tingling of extremities.
TClo
After "massive" and apparently repeated exposures: euphoria followed by a state of inebriation similar to that of alcohol intoxication, epigastric pain and anorexia.
Two deaths reported from accidental acute VC poisoning. Cyanosis, local burns, congestion of lungs and kidneys, and failure of the blood to clot were noted.
TDB (on-line) 1981 ICF 1974 Patty 1981 SCC 1981
TDB (on-line) 1981
DPIMR 1981 TDB (on-line) 1981
SCC 1981
%
R&S 153638
55
xposure Level land Duration) SPECIES: Dog 170 000 ppm (1 min) 100 000 ppm (4 h) SPECIES: Mice 86 000 to 123 000 ppm (1 min) SPECIES: Guinea Pig 200 000 ppm (18 min) 20 000 ppm (30 min) 5C00 ppm (30-60 min)
SPECIES: Rat ^>000 ppm (4 h)
Chrcnic ExDosures SPECIES: Human Unspecified
Unspecified
Unspecified
Effects
Narcosis Cardia arrhythmia
Narcosis
Reference
EPA Assess. 1975 EPA Assess. 1975
EPA Assess. 1975
Death
tclo
Pulmonary edema, hyperemia of kidneys and lungs.
INRS 1975 DPIMR 1981 INRS 1975
tclo
DPIMR 1981
In 16S workers, the incidence of Raynaud's syndrome was reported as 6 percent and the incidence of liver enlargement as 30 percent.
TDB (on-line) 19S1
Several studies of workers exposed to VCM showed various degrees of liver damage (usually enlarged liver) and enlarged spleens.
EPA Assess. 1975
Clinical examination of exposed workers in Dundee Research Project - deficient circulation in the extremities (Raynaud's Phenomenon); osteolysis of
terminal phalanges of the fingers and to a lesser extent of the toes; degenerative skin changes with destruction of the elastic network of the connective tissue;
SOEHS 1975
*
R&S153639
Exposure Level (and Duration)
Unspecified
Unspecified (mean 7 yr, 2 yr and lSyr)
Unspecified
Unspecified
56
Effects
Reference
paresthesia of the fingers with thickening of -die end segments; general symptoms of fatigue, breathlessness on exertion, dizzi ness, increased sweating, and pains in the upper epigastric region.
Three thousand workers employed in the PVC manufacturing industry were examined. Acroosteolysis with or without Raynaud's syndrome was found in 31 of these.
SOEHS 1975
Thirteen autoclave workers, mean SOEHS 1975 age 39, showed first symptoms from 1-1/2 to 3-1/2 years after exposure began. Found Raynaud's syndrome, clubbing and shortening of the fingers, skin changes resem bling scleroderma, with disorders of the circulatory system being the most common symptom. Labors tory tests showed reduced liver function in 11 of the workers.
Thirteen PVC workers showed sirr iar symptoms to those listed abc ve. Two of the men who had been removed from exposure, one for 6 months and one for 1-1/2 year, subsequently deve loped signs and symptoms of VCM disease in hands and feet.
SOEHS 1975
After repeated chronic exposures, the mam neurological symptoms were headaches, irritability, dizziness, sleep disorders, diaphoresis, memory loss, general asznenia and paresthesia.
SCC 19S1
Ofrgesissu
*
7.4.2
Ingestion.
Exposur Level (and Duration)
SPECIES: Rat 500 mg/kg
Effects LD50
7.4.3
Carcinogenicity.
Reference RTECS 1979
Exposure Level (and Duration) SPECIES: Human 500 ppm (4 yr, intermittent) ^^00 ppm (15 yr, ^Pmtermittent)
.^specified
Unspecified
Unspecified
Effects
Reference
TCLO, carcinogen.
RTECS 1979
Inhalation - equivocal tumorigenic agent.
RTECS 1)79
Report of four deaths at B.F. Goodrich Chemical Company caused by the rare angiosarcoma of the liver. On investigation, NIOSH concluded vinyl chloride was a probable occupational carcinogen.
NICSH Standard 1974
As of March 1976, there were 48 SCC 1981 known cases of vinyl chloride related liver angiosarcomas, 45 of which had resulted in death. All 9 of the Canadian cases worked in one plant in Shawinigan, Quebec, and 9 of the U.S. cases worked in one plant. These deaths had occurred over a period of 14 years, with the number
per year showing an increase
with time.
A study of former Monsanto Company chemical plant employees has shown an increased incidence of cancer among workers
COHSN 1932
%
58
Exposure Level (and Duration)
Unspecified Unspecified
1-10 ppm (long-term)
1 ppm (5 h/day, 5 d/wk, 35 yr) SPECIES: Rat 50 000 ppm-h
Effects
Reference
exposed to vinyl chloride; 34- of 110 deaths were from cancers: lung* mouth, digestive system and lymph glands. One death was due to liver cancer. Only worksites where there had been exposure to vinyl chloride and polyvinyl chloride were examined.
In addition to liver angiosarcomaS} lung cancer has been found in some epidemiological studies.
Lilis 1981; Apfeldorf 1981
A study of VCM and PYC process ing works revealed that in the VCM cohort there were signi ficantly elevated mortality rates due to malignancy of the lymphatic gland and hematopoietic tissues and the gastrointestinal tract, the latter primarily due to tumours of the liver.
Weber 1981
The long-term effects such as
EPA Assess. 1975
angiosarcoma, liver damage,
Raynaud's syndrome may be due
to levels as low as 1-10 ppm;
onset of angiosarcoma is estimated
to be 13-20 years; however, a few
rare cases of shorter times
(3-6 yr) were found.
A study of epidemiological results and various statistical models places the risk of liver angio sarcoma at 1.5 x 10-& (5 out of a million) at this dosage.
Gehring 1979
Carcinogenic dose calculated from various concentrations and times including single doses.
Hehir 1981
%
R&S 153642
59
exposure Level (and Duration) 6000 ppm (4 h/d 12 to IS of pregnancy) 600 ppm (S h/d, 5 d/wk)
250. ppm (39 wk) 250 ppm (35 wk) 50 ppm (30 wk) 34 g/kg (" yr)
g/kg (3 yr) 250, 5CC, 2500, 6CC0, 10 000 ppm (127 wk)
SPECIES: Hamster 500 ppm (4 h/d or 30 wk) SPECIES: Mouse 5000 ppm-h
2500 ppm (5 h/d for 6 wk, intermittently)
Effects
TClo carcinogenic effect (inhalation).
Reference RTECS 1979
Angioscarcoma in 23 percent of animals; this was increased to 50 percent by administration of ethanol in water (5 percent by volume). It was concluded that ethanol is a co-carcinogen in relation to vinyl chloride.
Toxic dose, carcinogenic effect (inhalation).
Toxic concentration, carcinogenic effect (inhalation).
TCLO, carcinogenic effect (inhalation).
Toxic concentration, carcinogenic effect (oral).
TDLp, carcinogenic effect (oral).
Induction of angiosarcoma in the liver and other organs, and other cancers. The percentage of animals having liver angio sarcomas varied but was around 10 percent; 50 ppm exposure resulted in no angiosarcomas.
-
Radike 1981
RTECS 1979 RTECS 1979 RTECS 1979 RTECS 1979 RTECS 1979 Maltoni 1974. IN NIOSH Standard 1974* ICF 1974
TClo, carcinogenic effects (inhalation).
RTECS 1979
Carcinogenic dose for mice determined by a variety of exposure periods and concen trations.
Toxic dose, neoplastic effects (inhalation).
Hehir 1981 RTECS 1979
R&S153643
60
Exposure Level (and Duration)
Effects
Reference
250 ppm (35 wk, intermittently)
-50 ppm (30 wk, intermittently)
50 ppm (6 h/d for 12 wk, intermittently)
Toxic concentration, carcino genic effects (inhalation).
TCLO, carcinogenic effects (inhalation).
Toxic dose (inhalation).
RTECS 1979 RTECS 1979 RTECS 1979
SPECIES: Animal, unspecified
25 ppm (4 h/d for 1 yr)
5 liver angiosarcomas, 4 zymbal
Patty 1981
gland carcinomas and 1 nephroblas
toma in 120 test animals.
SPECIES: Rats, Mice, Hamsters
0-30 000 ppm (vari us exposures from single to 52 wk) (inhalation) 0.03 to 50 mg/kg (single dose to 5/wk for 52 wk) (ingestion or injection)
10 ppm (4 h/d for 1 yr)
1 mg/kg
A major study involving 7000 animals of various species, strains, and sexes was conducted. The results indicate that vinyl chloride is a multi-potential carcinogen affecting a variety of organs and tissues. Liver angiosarcoma was detected in all species; many types of tumours were found. Vinyl chloride shows carcinogenic effects whether it was administered by inhalation or ingestion and shows a clear dose-response relationship. Newborn animals are the most sensitive. Vinyl chloride shows carcinogenic effects even down to 50 ppm.
Maltoni 1981
1 liver angiosarcoma, 2 extrahepatic angiosarcomas and 2 zymbal gland sarcomas in 120 test animals.
Patty 1981
3 liver angiosarcomas, 1 extrahepatic angiosarcoma and 1 hepatoma in 150 animals.
Patty 1981
4
Sw
cn
4Caa*>o.
A Teratogenicity and Mutagenicity.
Exposure Level (and Duration)
Effects
Reference
SPECIES: Human Unspecified Unspecified Unspecified
Unspecified
Increased frequency of chromosomal aberrations in lymphocytes of exposed workers.
Increased fetal wastage among wives of male workers who have had occupational exposure to vinyl chloride.
An epidemiological study was made of an area where the general population was exposed to VCM. The population was shown to have an excess of birth defects compared to other communities; the fluctuation in defects corresponded with VCM fluctua tions in the environment.
An epidemiological study of workers in a plastic/rubber plant revealed a greater percentage of chromosomal breakage compared to workers in other industries: however, the breakage did not correlate to VCM exposure and thus another agent(s) is suspected.
NIOSH/OSHA Bulletin 1978 NIOSH/OSHA Bulletin 1978; Hatch 1981 Laval 1981
Heath 1977
SPECIES: Rat
1500 ppm (during the first, second or third trimester of pregnancy)
Increased fetal mortality and other fetotoxic effects when administered during the first trimester; no embryotoxidty was noted when vinyl chloride was administered during the second or third trimester.
.SPECIES: Chinese Hamster
00 or 5000 ppm A h/d for 5 d)
Chromosomal changes in bone marrow cells.
Patty 1981 Patty 1981
62
Exposure Level (and Duration)
Effects
SPECIES: Hamster
600 mg/kg 20 pph (5 h)
Cytogenic analysis assaying for chromosomal aberrations following administration of vinyl chloride fin vivo).. No results reported.
Hamster lung cells were tested using microsomal mutagenic assay. No results reported.
SPECIES: Mouse
3C00, 10 000 or 30 000 ppm for 5 d
No dominant lethal effects.
SPECIES: Drosophila melanogaster
1 pph
Sex chromosome loss and non disjunction tests have been performed (in vivo). Route of administration was by inhalation.
SPECIES: Salmonella typhimurium
11 percent (in air)
2 to 20 percent (in air)
Positive Ames test - concluded that vinyl chloride induced point mutagens but only after metabolic conversion.
'Positive Ames test results by several investigators.
Reference RTECS 1979 RTECS 1979 Patty 19S1 RTECS 1979
Senate 1974 Fabricant 1981
7.5 Symptoms of Exposure
General symptoms of exposure found in most information sources have not been specifically referenced. Only those of a more specified or unusual nature have their sources indicated.
7.5.1
Inhalation.
1. Irritation of nose and throat.
2. Headache.
R&S153645
63
3. Overexcitement (TDB (on-line) 1981). . Anesthetic effects (Patty 1981).
5. Narcosis. 6. Numbness and tingling of extremities (TDB (on-line) 1981). 7. Visual disturbances (TDB (on-line) 1981). 8. Dizziness and disorientation. 9. Inebriation. 10. Faltering gait. 11. Euphoria. 12. Epigastric pain (TDB (on-line) 1981). 13. Anorexia. 14. State of shock (Lefevre 1980). 15. Loss of consciousness. 16. Coma. 17. Death as a result of cardiac or respiratory failure (Lefevre 1980).
7.5.2
Ingestion.
Ingestion is unlikely; however, if ingested, vinyl chloride would be toxic and cause tissue damage (AAR 198'.).
7.5.3
Skin Contact.
1. Dry skin. 2. Allergic dermatitis (TDB (on-line) 19S1). 3. Frostbite. 4. Irritation and burns from absorption of phenol stabilizer (GE 1978). 5. Various lesions.
7.5.4
Eye Contact.
1. Irritation. 2. Inflammation of conjunctiva. 3. Corneal lesions due to inflammation (Lefevre 1980).
7.6 Human Toxicity to Decay or Combustion Products
Polyvinyl chloride breaks down into hydrogen chloride and carbon dioxide when ubjected to excessive heat or pressure. Extensive studies have shown that phosgene has >t been detected under any practical circumstances (SCC 1976), although some sources
R&S153647
64
report this product (GE 1979). Similar decomposition products might be expected when vinyl chloride bums.
7.6.1
Carbon Dioxide and Hydrogen Chloride. Carbon dioxide is a colourless,
odourless gas which in elevated concentrations may act to produce mild narcotic effects,
respiratory stimulation and asphyxiation. Its TLV* is 5000 ppm (8 h - TWA) and 15 000
ppm (STEL) (TLV 1983). Hydrogen chloride may be present as a gas or a liquid. In contact with human
skin it causes irritation, inflammation, bums, blistering dermatitis and profound tissue
damage, depending upon concentration and length of contact. In contact with eyes it can
cause stinging, burning, opaqueness of the cornea and comeal necrosis. Inhalation causes
coughing, choking, ulceration of the mucosa, bronchitis, pneumonia and, in cases of
exposures to extremely high concentrations, pulmonary edema and death. The TLV is
5 ppm (8 h - TWA) (TLV 1983).