Document MJvRkQQ5xxr2Y9NrD70nmnRXM
+ .
33PMagCCeoonLmgopaarrn)yy
Page t of 63
(
EpidFFeIImNNiAoAlLLogRRyEE,PP2O2O0RR-TT3W-05 Ep`MMideeeddmiicciaaollloDDgeeypp,aa2rr2tt0mm-e3enWntt-05
33MM CCoommppaannyy
SStt.. PPaual,ul, MMNN 5555114444
`DDaattee:: OOccttoobbeerr 1111,,2001"
"Tie: A Longitudinal Analysoifs Serum Perfluorooctnesulfonae (PFOS)and Title: A Longitudinal Analysis of Serum Perfluorooctanesulfonate (PFOS) and
PPeerrfflluuocrrooooccttaannooaatte ((PPFFOOAA)) LLeevveellss iinn RReellaattiioonn ttoo LLiippiidd aanndd HHeeppaattiicc CClliinniiccaall CChheemmisisttrryy
Test Results from Male Employee Participants of the 1994/95, 1997 and 2000 Test Results from Male Employee Participants of the 1994195, 1997 and 2000
FFlluuoorroocchheemmiiccaall MMeeddiiccaall SSuurrvveeiillllaannccee PPrrooggrraamm
SSStutuunddDyyue: Jul1y, 2001
Start Date: J'.uly I, 2001
IRPPrrBoottooAccpoopllrNNovuuammlbbeerr(r(noott aspppplliiccaabbllee)) IRBEEAxxpeepxmmrpoptvtal Eoedited
X
IIRRBB AApppprroovvaallDDaattee:: ((nroott aapppplliiccaabbllee aas tthheesseeddaattaaaarr~ ffrroomm aa mmeeddiiccaall ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee.
pprrooggraamm))
PrPirnincciippaall IInnvveesstitiggaattoorr:. CCoo--iinnvveessttiiggaattoorrss::
SSttuuddyyDDiri~ec'cttoor~:.
GGeaearryyWW.. OOllsseenn,,DD..VV.AM4..,, PPhhD.D.)
`MMiicchheellee MM.. BBuurrlieeww,, MM.S.S.'J
JJJeeefaafnnreMMy.H. .BBuMurrni'iass,, RRnN..N,M.d,MDMPe,.PHM.Hl.P.IH,.
Jeffrey H. Mandel, M~D., M.P.H.I
JJeefffrferyeHHy.. MMaandenl, MMdD.D.e., MMlP.PH.,.H".
1. 3M Medica Department, 220-3W-05, St. Paul, MN 55144-1000
I. 3M Medical Department, 220-3W-05, St. Paul, MN 55144-1000
*"((CCoorrrreeccttiioonnssmmaaddeeffrroomm pprreevviioouuss vveerrssiioonn))
(
Exhibit
1799
11779999..00000011
W3M_MNM0N204284822116633
3PMeCgoemlpaonEy
Page 2 of 63
AABBSSTTRRAACCTT
`TThhee 33MM fflluuoorr~ccchheemmiiccaall mmeeddiiccaall ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee pprroo.mgr"aamm wwaass ccoonndduucctteedd iinn t1999944//9955,,
11999977 2an1dd 22000000 aatttthhee ccoommppaannyy''ss AAnnttwweerrpp ((BBeellggiiuumm)) aanndd DDeeccaattuurr ((AAllaabbaammaa))
mmaannuuffaaccttuurriinngg ppllaannttss.. AAlltthhoouug~h ccrroossss--sseeccttiioonnaall aasssseessssmmeennttssofoftthhee ddaatta hhaavvee been
rreeppoorrtteedd,, tthhee ooppppoorrttuunniittyy ttoo ccoonndduucctt aa lloonnggiittuuddiinnaall aasssseessssmmeenntt bbeeccaammee ppoossssiibbllee asss aa rreessuulltt
of
of a
large
large
nnuummbbeerrooffeemmppllooyyeese
ppaarrtiicciippaannttss
in
in
the
the
2000
2000
fflluuoorroocchheemmiiccaall
mmeeddiiccaall
ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee pprrooggrraamm.. AA ttoottaall ooff 117755 mmaallee eemmppllooyyeeeess vvoolluunnttaarriillyy ppaarrttiicciippaatteedd iinn tthhee 22000000
pprrooggrraammaannddatatleleaasstt oonneeoofftthhee ttwwoopprreevviioouusspprrooggrraamm yyeeaarrss.. AAtotottaallooff110066 ((6611ppeerrcceenntt))
of the
of the
175
175
employees
employees
ppaarrttiicciippaatteedd
in
in
the
the
1994/95
1994/95
program
program
and
and
110 (63 percent) of the
1 l0 (63 percent) of the
175
175
ppaarriticiippaaiteeddiinn
the
the
11999977 pprrooggrraamm,.
Of
Of
tthheessee
175
175
eemmppllooyyeeeess,,
a
a
toalof
total of
41
41
(24
(24
ppeerrcceenntt))
ppaarrttiicciippaatteedd iinn aallll tthhrreeee yyeeaarrss ((AAnnttwweerrpp == 2211,, DDeeccaattuurr == 2200)),, 6655 ((3377 ppeerrcceenntt)) ppaarrttiicciippaatteedd
iinn 11999944/9955 aanndd 22000000 ((AAnnttwweerrpp == 4455,, DDeeccaattuurr ==2200)) anndd 6699 ((3399 ppeerrcceenntt)) ppaarrtiiciippaatteeddiinn
11999977
aanndd
22000000
((AAnnttwweerpr==p
3344,,
DDeeccaattuurr
=
-
3355))..
TThheerree
wweerree
iinnssuuffffiicciieenntt
nnuummbbeerr
of
of
ffeemmaalele.
eemmplpoyleesottooyccoeonndeduucsctt aannyy mmeeaannining~fuull lloonng~ittuuddiinnaall ~assseessssmmeenntt.. OOnnllyy 1144 ffeemmaallee
eemmppllooyyeeeess
ppaarrttiicciippaatteedd
iinntthhee22000000
fflluuoorroocchheemmiiccaall
mmeeddiiccaall
ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee
pprrooggrraamm
and
and
at
at
lleeaasstt oonneeoofftthhee pprreevviioouuss pprrooggrraamm yyeeaarrss..
`SSeerruumm ppeerffflluuorrooooccttaanneessuullffoonnaattee ((PPFFOOS$)) aanndd ppeefrflluuoorrooooccttaannooaattee ((PPFFOOAA)) wweerree assayed in each surveillance program year although the method of analysis (high
assayed in each surv,eillance program year although the method of analysis (high
ppeerrffoorrmmaannccee lliiqquuiidd chhr.roommaattooggrraapphhyy mmaassss ssppeeccttrroommeettrryy)) ddiiffffeerreedd ssllii~ghttllyy bbeetcwweeeenn yyeeaarrss..
A different research laboratory was usd 0 assay PFOS and PFOA in each year.
A different research laboratory was used to assay PFOS and PFOA in each year.
T"Thhee ssaammee hhoossppiittaall llaabboorraattoorryy aannaallyyzzeedd tthhee cclliinniiccaall cchheemmisisttrriieessffoorraallll tthrree~e
ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee yyeeaarrss., TThheessee iinncclluuddeedd:: cchhoolleessteerrooll ((mmg~/ddl)., hhiigghh ddeennssiittyy lliippoopprrootleeiinnss ((HHDDLL.,
(
11779999..00000022
33MM_MMNNo022e48822116644
33PMuCCsoo3mm0ppraa6nn3yy
Page 3 or 63
mmg~/ddll)) aanndd trriiggllyycceerriiddeess ((mmg~/ddl):; aallkkaalliinnee pphhoosspphhaattaassee ((IIUU//LL)),, ggaammmmaa gglluottaammyyll
ttrraannssffeerraassee ((GGGOTT., TIUUL/L)),, aassppaarrttaattee aammiinnoottrraannssffeerraassee ((AASSTT,, I[UU//LL)),, aallaanniinnee
aammiinnoottrraannssffeerraassee ((AALLTT,, II'UU//LL)).. ttoottaall aanndd ddiirreecct bbiilliirruubbiinn ((mmg~/dd)l.). MMoosstt rreeffeerreennccee rraannggeess
rreemmaaiinneeddrreelliaitivveellyyccoonnssatann:t oovveertdiimneeeexxcceepptt ffoorr AALLTT.. IInn eeaacchh ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee yyeeaarr,,
`ppootteennttiiaall ccoonnffoouunnddiinngg ffaaccttoorrss wweerree aallssooddeetteerrmmiinneedd.. TThheessee ccoovvaarriiaatteess iinncclluuddeedd aaggee,, bbooddyy
`mmaassss iinnddeexx,, nnuummbbeerrooffaallccoohhoolliicc ddrriinnkkss ppeerr ddaayy aanndd cciiggaarreetttieess ssmmookkeedd ppeerr cdaayy..
TThhee ccoonnttiinnuuoouuss oouuttccoommeessooff lliippiidd aannddhehpeaptaiticccclliinniiccaall cchheemmiissttrryy tteessttss wweerree
eevvaalluusaiteedd aass rreeppeeaatteedd mmeeaassuurreess iinnccoorrppoorraattiinngg tthhee rraannddoomm ssuubbjjeecctt eeffffeecctt ffiitteedd t1o0 aa mmiixxeedd
mmooddeell bbyy tthhee MMI!XXEEDD pprroocceedduurree iinntthhee SSAASS ssttaattiissttiiccaall ppaacckkaaggee.. RReessttrriicctteedd mmaaxxiimmuumm
lliikkeelliihhoooodd
eessttiimmaatteess
of
of
vvaarriiaannccee
ppaarraammeetteerrss
were
were
ccoommppuutteedd..
AAddjjuusstteedd rreeggrreessssiioonn mmooddeellss
wweerree bbuuiilltt bbyy iinntdrroodduucciinngg aallll ccoovvaarriiaatteessaannddtteessttiinngg tthhee ccoovvaarriiaannccee ssttrruuccttuurree.. SSiiggnniiffiiccaanntt
ccooeeffffiicciieennttss wweerree ddeeffiinneedd wwhheenn tthhee p vvaalluuee wwaass << .0055..
(
TThheerree wwaass aa ppoossiitiivvee aassssoocciiaattiioonn bbeevtwweeeenn PPFFOOAA aanndd sseerruumm cchhoolleesstteerrooll aanndd
twriiggllyycceerriiddeess oovveerr ttiimmee bbuutt nnoott wwiitthh PPFFOOSS.. TThhiiss wwaass aassssoocciiaattiioonn wwaass lliimmiitteedd to tthhee
AAnnttvw,e'errpp
eemmppllooyyeeeess
and,
and,
in
in
ppaarrttiiccuullaarr,,
the
the
21
21
AAnnttwweerrpp
eemmppllooyyeeeess
who
who
ppaarrttiicciippaatteedd
inal
in all
tthhreeee ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee yyeeaarrss..
Ths
This
ppoossiittiivvee aassssoocciiaattiioonn
bbeettwweeeenn
PPFFOOAA
and
and
sseerruumm
lliippiiddss
is
is
ooppppoossiittee
tthhe
iinnccoonnssiisstteenntt
ttooxxiiccoollooggiiccaall
eevviiddeennccee
tthhaatt
ssuuggggeesstteedd
a
a
ppoossssiibbllee
hhyyppoolliippiiddeemmiicc
effect
effect
of PFOA in
of PFOA in
rodents and no effec
rodents and no effect
in primates.
in primates.
Adjusting
Adjusting
for
for
potential
potential
ccoonnffoouunnddeerrss,,
tthheerree wweerree nnoo tteemmppoorraall cchhaannggeess aassssoocciiaatteedd wwiitthh tthhee fflluuocrroocchheemmiiccaall tteesstss,, PPFFOOSS., PPFFOOAA
and TOF. and the hepatic clinical chemisry tests.
and TOF. and the hepatic clinical chemistry, tests.
LLiimmiittaattiioonnss ooff tthhiiss ssttuuddyy iinncclluuddeedd tthhee nnuummbbeerr oOffeemmplpoloyyeeeess wwiitthh tthhrreeee yyeeaarrss ooff
ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee
data
data
(only
(only
245%
24%
of
of
the
the
175
175
ssuubbjjeeccttss)),,
the
the
iinnaabbiilliittyy
to
to
aannaallyyzzee
tteemmppoorraall
cchhaannggeess
duet
due to
small
small
nnuummbbeerr~s
in
in
female
female
eemmppllooyyeeess,,
the
the
uusseeooffddiiffffeerrenntt
llaabboorraattoorriieess
and
and
11779999..00000033
I3MM_MMNN0022448822116655
:
33PMMagCCeootmmpopalann)yy
Pag~ 4 of 63
tthhee aassssoocciiaatteedd ssyysstteemmaattiicc ((eexxppeerriimmeennttaall eerrrroorr)) wwiitthh eeaacchh fflluuoorroocchheemmiiccaall aassssaayy ffoorr t~hhee
tthhrreeee ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee pprroosg~raamm yyeeaarrss aanndd tthhee lloowweerr lleevveellss ooffsseerruumm PPFFOOSS aanndd PPFFOOAA
.
mmeeaassuurreedd iinn eeaacchh pprroo.g~r'aamm yyeeaarr aammoonngg tthheessee eemmppllooyyeeeess ccoommppaarreedd wwiitthh t~hoossee tthhaatt ccaauussee:
eeffffeeccttss iinn llaabboorraattoorryy aanniimmaallss..
11779999..00000044
I3MM_MMNND022448822116666
IkNNTTRROODDUUCCTTIIOONN
33PMagCCeoo3mm0ppraa6nnsyy
Page 5 of 63
"TThhee 33MM Afluuoorroocchheemmiiccaall mmeeddiiccaall ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee pprrooggrraamm iiss ccoonndduucctteedd oonn aa rroouuttiinnee
bbaasissaatitthtshee ccoommppaannyy''ss AAnnttwweerrpp ((BBeellg~iuurmn)) aannddDDeceactauturr((AAllaabbaarmaaa)) mmaannuuffaaccttuurriinngg ppllaanntsts,.
EEmmppllooyyeese ppaar.niicciippaattiioonn iiss vvoolluunnttaarryy.. PPrrioirotroo 11999944,, o0nnllyy otottaall oorrggaanniicc fflluuoorriinnee wwaass
mmeeaassuurreedd aanndd nnoo ssppeecciiffiicc flluuoorroocchheemmiiccaall aannaallyytteess wweerree mmeeaassuurreedd.. SSeerruumm
perfluorooctanesulfonate
perfluorooctanesu[fonate
(PROS)
(PFOS)
aanndd
ppeerrfflluuoorrooooccttaannooaattee
((PPFFOOAA))
hhaavvee
bbeeeenn
rroouuttiinneellyy
aassssaayyeedd ssiinnccee 11999944//9955 rraatthheerr tthhaann ttoottaall oorrggaanniicc fflluuoorriinnee aass tthheeanaanlayltyiticcaall ccaappaabibliiltitiieess hhaavvee:
iimmpprroovveedd.. CCrroossss--sseeccttiioonnaall aannaallyysseess ooftf thhee 11999944//9955 aanndd 11999977 mmeeddiiccaall ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee:
pprrooggrraamm ddaattaa aanndd tthhee 22000000 ddaattaa iinn rreellaattiioonn ttoo AAnnttwweerrpp aannddDDeeccaattuurreemmppllooyyeeess'' sseerruumm
PPFFOOSS lleevveellss hhaavvee bbeeeenn rreeppoorrteedd eellsseewwhheerree ((OOllsseenn cett aall,, 11999999aa,, 11999999b,, 22000001)).. IInntthhee
11999944/11999955 mmeeddiiccaall ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee pprrooggrraamm,,aa ttoottaall ooff 117788 mmaallee eemmppllooyyeeeess ppaarrtiicciippaaiteedd
((AAnnttwweerrpp == 8888;; DDeeccaattuurr =-- 9900)) aanndd 114499 mmaallee eemmppllooyyeeeess ppaarrttiicciippaatteedd iinn tthhee 119999"7] pprrooggrraamm
(Antwerp = 65; Decatur = 34). For these two program years, there were too few female
(Antwerp = 65; Decatur = 8~t). For these two program years, there were too few female
ppaarrttiicciippaannttss ttoo iinncclluuddee iinntthhee ddaattaa aannaallyyssiiss ((OOllsseenn eett aall 11999988)).. IInn tthhee 22000000 fflluuoorroocchheemmiiccaall
mmeeddiiccaall ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee pprrooggrraamm., tthheerree wweerree ccoonnssiiddeerraabbllyy mmoorree ppaarrttiicciippaannttss:: 442211 mmaalleess
((AAnnttwweerrpp == 220066;; DDeeccaattuurr == 221155)) aanndd 9977 ffeemmaalleess ((AAnnotwweerrpp =-- d49g;; DDeeccaaturr== 4488)).. IItt wwaass
suspected that the increased voluntary participation in 2000 was due to increased
suspected that the increased voluntary participation in 2000 was due to increased
employee awarenessofth persistence and prevalence of PFOS in human tissue and the
employee awareness of the persistence and prevalence of PFOS in human tissue and the
eennvviirroonnmmeenntt aanndd tthhee ccoommppaannyy''ss MMaayy 1166.. 22000000 pphhaassee oouutt aannnnoouunncceemmeenntt tthhaatt iitt wwoouulldd
cease the production ofperluoroocianyl chemistry in certain repellents and surfactants
cease the production o(pcrfluorooctanyl chemistry in certain rcpcllent~ and surfactants
by the end of 2000.
by the end of 2000.
RReeggaarrddlleessssoofftthhee ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee yyeeaarr,, tthheerree hhaavvee bbeeeenn sseevveerraall ccoonnssiisstteennttddiiffffeerreenncceess.
bbeettwweeeenn tthhee AAnnttwweerrpp aanndd DDeeccaattuurr mmaallee eemmppllooyyeeee ppooppuullaattiioonnss.. TThhee AAnnttwweerrpp mmalaele:
11779999..00000055
IM_MNo2482167
3M MN02482167
3MPMCaogCemo0pm1ap6ann3yy
Page 6 of 63
eemmppllooyyeeee ppooppuullaattiioonn hhaass bbeeeenn ssii~gniiffiiccaannttllyy yyoouunnggeerr tthhaann DDeeccaattuurr,, hhaass hhaadd lloowweerr BBooddyy.
MMaassss IInnddiicceess((BBMMDI) aanndd hhiigghheerr sseellff--rreeppoorrtteedddadaiillyyccoonnssuummppttiioonn ooff aallccoohholo.l. IInn aaddddiittiioonn,,
tthhee AAnnttwweerrpp mmaallee eemmppllooyyeese ppooppuullaattiioonn cclliinniiccaall cchheemmisisttrryy pprrooffiilleess wweerree ddiiffffeerreenntt ffoorr
sseevveerraall tteessttss iinncclluuddiinngg lloowweerr mmeeaann aallkkaalliinnee pphhoosspphhaattaasse aanndd ttrriiggllyycceerriiddee vvaalluueess aanndd
hhiigghheerr ttoottaall bbiilliirruubbiinn aanndd IH-IDDLL vvaalluueess tthhaann tthhee DDe~ccaattuurr mmaallee eemmppllooyyeeee ppooppuullaattiioonn..
AAnnaallyysseessooff wwoorrkkeerrss' lliippiidd aanndd hheeppaatiicc cclliinniiccaall cchheemmiissttryy rr~essuullttss hhaavvee nnoott bbeeeenn aassssoocciiaatteedd
wwiitthh hhyyppoolliippiiddeermniicc eeffffeeccttssaanndd PPFFOOSS aass rreeppoorrtteedd iinn rrooddeennttss ((33MM CCoommppaannyy 22000000;;
`HHaauugghhoomm aanndd SSppyyddeevvoolldd 11999922:; Iekdedaa ectt aall 11998877;; PPaassttoooorr cett aall 11998877:;SSeeaaccaattcett aall 220000118a;;
`SSoohhlleenniiuuss eettaall 11999933)) aanndd pprriimmaatteess ((SSeeaaccaatt tetaall 22000011b)).. IInn tthhee 22000000 mmeeddiiccaall ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee:
pprrooggrraamm,, ssttaattiissttiiccaall aannaallyysseess aallssoo eexxaammiinneedd tthhee rreellaattiioonn bbeettwweeeenn PPFFOOAAaannddaa ccaallccuullaatteedd
ttoottaall oorrggaanniicc fflluuoorriinnee iinnddce.xx ((TOTF)tOtoocclPliinnii)ccaall cchheemmisitsrtriieess,, hheemmaattoollooggyy,, tthhyyrrooiiddhhoorrmmoonneess
aanndd uurriinnaallyysseess ((OOllsseenn eettaall 22000011)).. AA ppoossiittiivvee aassssoocciiaattiioonn wwaass oobbsseerrvveedd bbeettwweeeenn
(
ttrriiggllyycceerriiddeess aannddPPFFOOAA:; hhoowweevveerr,, tthhiiss aassssoocciiaattiioonn wwaass ooppppoossiittee tthhee ddaattaa tthaatt hhaavvee
iinnccoonnssiisstteennttllyy rreeppoorrtteeddaa hhy.vppoolliippiiddcemmiiaa eeffffeecctt ooffPPFFOOAA iinn rrooddeennttss ((HHaauugghhoormn aanndd
SSppyydcelevvoolldd
11999922;;
PPaassttoooorr
eetaall
11998877))
aanndd
nnoo
eeffffeecctt
iinn
pprriimmaatteess
((BBuutteennhhoofffeeftt
al
al
2001).
2001).
FFuurrtthheerrmmoorree,, tthhiiss ppoossiittiivvee aassssoocciiaattiioonn bbeettwweeeenn PPFFOOAA aannddttrriiggllyycceerriiddeess hhaass nnoott bbeeeenn
oobbsseerrvveedd aait tthhee 33MM CCoonttaaggee GGrroovvee mmaannuuffaaccttuurriinngg ppllaanntt ((OOllsseenn eettaall 2200(0300)) wwhheerere.
eemmppllooyyeeeess'' sseerruumm lleevveellss hhaavvee,, hhiissttoorriiccaallllyy,, bbeeeenn mmuucchh hhiigghheerr tthhaann tthhoossee mmeeaassuurreedd aammoonngg
AAnnttwweerrpp aanndd DDeeccaattuurr eemmppllooyyeeeess ((OOllsseenn eett aall 11999999;; 220000113a;; OOllsseenneet aall 220000110b))..
"The inabilityto,assess temporal changes in cross-sectional studies is a well-
The inability to, assess temporal changes in cross-sectional studies is a well-
kknnoowwnn lliimmiitactaioonn ooff tthhiissddeessiiggnn..TThhee llaarrggee ppaarrtiiicippaattiioonnooff eemmppllooyyeeeess iinn tthhee 22000000
Afluuoorroocchheemmiiccaall mmeeddiiccaall ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee wwhhoo mmaayy hhaavvee ppaarrttiicciippaatteedd iinn tthhee 1199994ad/9955 aannddl/oorr
1199997"/ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee pprrooggrraammss aatt tthheessee ttwwoo mmaannuuffaaccttuurriinngg ssittess aalllloowweedd ffoorr aann ooppppoorrttuunniittyy
11779999..00000066
I3MM_MMNN0022448822116688
3 Company 3M Company Faeroe Page 7 ot'63 0to ccoonndduuccttaa lloonnggiittuuddiinnaall aannaallyyssiiss aammoonngg tthhee mmaallee eemmppllooyyeese ppooppuullaattiioonn.. AAllttooggeetthheerr,, aa ttoottaall ooff 117755 eemmppllooyyeeeess ((AAnnttwweerrpp == 110000;; DDeeccaattuur=r= 7755)) wwhhoo ppaarriticciippaatteedd iinn 22000000 hhaadd aallssoo. ppaarrttiicciippaatteedd iinnaat lleeaasstt oonnee pprreevviioouuss fflluuoorroocchheemmiiccaall mmeeddiiccaall ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee eexxaamm ssiinnccee 11999944/~9955.. TThheerreeffoorre,, tthhee ppuurrppoossee ooff tthhiiss aannaallyyssiiss wwaasstto ccoonndduuccttaa lloonnggiittuuddiinnaall
aasssseessssmmeenntt ooff tthhiiss 66 yyeeaarr ttiimmee ppeerriioodd rreeggaarrddiinngg tthhee rreelaltaioinosnhsiphoiofpf PPFFOOSS,, PPFFOOAA aanndd TTOOFF ttootthhee mmeeddiiccaall ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee ddaattaa ccoolllleecctteedd oonn tthheessee 117755 AAnnttwweerrpp aanndd DDeeccaattuurr mmaallee employees.
employees.
MMEETTHFIOODDSS
3
DaDtaamCColollleeccttiioonn
`DDaattaa wweerree ccoommppiilleedd ffrroomm tthhee 11999944/9955,, 11999977 aanndd 22000000 fflluaoorroocchheermri~ccaall mmeeddiiccaall
surveillance program databases. A total of 175 male employees paricipatedin the 2000
surveillance prob.'am databases. A total of 175 male employees participated in the 2000
pprrooggrraamm aannddaat lleeaasstt oonneeoofftthhee ttwwoo pprreevviioouuss pprrooggrraamm yyeeaarrss.. AA ttoottaall ooff 110066 ((6611 ppeerrcceenntt))
oofftthhee 117755 eemmppllooyyeeeess ppaarrtiiciippaatteedd iinn tthhee 11999944//9955 pprrooggrraamm aanndd 11I100 ((6633 ppeerrcceenntt))oofftthhee: 117755 ppaarrttiicciippaatteedd iinn tthhee 11999977 pprrooggrraamm..OOfftthheessee 117755 eemmppllooyyeeeess., aa ttoottaallooff 4411 ((2244 ppeerrcceenntt)) ppaarrttiicciippaatteedd iinn aallll ttl'hue'cee yyeeaarrss ((AAnnttwweerrpp -=- 2211,, DDeeccaattuurr ==2200)),, 6655 ((3377 ppcenr:cenet)) ppaarrtiicciippaaiteedd
iinn 11999944//9955 aanndd 22000000 ((AAnnttwweerrpp == 4455,, DDeeccaatturu==r 2200)) aanndd6699 ((3399 ppeerrcceenntt)) ppaarrttiicciippaatteedd iinn 11999977 aanndd 22000000 ((AAnnttwweerrpp == 3344,, DDeeccaattuurr == 3355)).. FFoorr ppuurrppoosseess ooffbbrreevviittyy,, tthheessee tthhreeee
ssuubbppooppuullaattiioonnss wwiillll hhearte,aaffiteerr bbe rreeffeerrreedd ttoo aass ssaubbccoohhoonrttss AA,, BB aanndd CC..
`DDeemmoog.mra'apphhiicc dda~ttaa ((aaggee., BBMMYI,, aallccoohhoolliicc ddrriinnkkss ppeerr ddaayy aanndd cciiggaarreettteessppeerrddaayy))
wweerree rreeccoorrddeeddffoorrceaacchh eemmppllooyyeeee iinn eeaacchh ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee yyeeaarr.. AA ssttaannddaarrdd sseettooffcclliinniiccaall
cchheemmisisttrriieess aanndd hheemmaattoollooggyy, ddaattaa wwaass aallssoo oobbataiinneeddffoorreeaacchh eemmppllooyyeeee.. GGiivveenn rreessuullttss
ffrroomm pprreevviioouuss ttooxxiiccoollooggiiccaall ssttuuddiieess,, tthhee lloonnggiittuuddiinnaall aannaallyysseess ffooccuusseedd oonn lliippiidd
11779999..00000077
I3MM_MMNN0022448822116699
.
33PMMaCCsootmmpepalannsyy
Page 8 of 63
c[chholoelesstteerrooll ((mmg~/dd)l)., hhiigghh dde~nnssiityy lliippoopprrootteeinins ((IH-IDDLL,, mmg~ddl)) aanndd tirgiglylycceerdiddeess ((mmg~/ddl))] aanndd hheeppaattiicc a[allkkaalliinnee pphhoosspphhaattaasse ((II'UU//LL)),, ggaammmmaagglluuttaammyy)l ttrraannssffeerraassee ((GGGGTT,, TIUUL/L)),, aassppaarrttaattee aammiinnoottrraannssffeerraassee ((AASSTT,, [I'UUI/LL)),, aallaanniinnee aammiinnoottrraannssffeerraassee ((AALLTT,, IIUUI/LL)),, ttoottaall aanndd. ddiirreecct bbiilliirruubbiinn ((mmgg/lddl)]] cclliinniiccaall cchheemmisisttrriieess tthhaatt wweerree mmeeaassuurreedd iinn eeaacchh pprrooggrraamm yyeeaarr bbyy tthhee ssaammee llaboaratboryo((AAlrllliinnaaaLLatbaobrooartaortorriieyess,, SStt.. PPaaulu,l,MMN)N.). RReeffeerreennccee rraannggeess wweerree rreellaattiivveellyy ccoonnssttaanntt oovveerr ttiimmee,, aalltthhoouug~h ffoorr AALLTT tthhee rraannggee ddeecclliinneedd ffrroomm 2200.-6655 ITUU!LL iinn 11999944//99551t0o 11.-4400 ITUU/LL iinn 11999977 aanndd22000000..
`FFlluuoorroocchheemieicaallAAnnaallyysseess PPFFOOSS aanndd PPFFOOAA wweerree aassssaayyeedd nin 11999944//99.55,, 11999977 aanndd 22000000.. HHoowweevveerr,, tthhee mmeetthhoodd
ofof aannaallyyssiiss ddiiffffeerreedd sslliigghhttllyy ffoorreeaacchh yyeeaarr.. IInn 11999944//9955,, tthheemmetethhoodduusseedd `tet~e'tarbaubtyultaynl,ahm-nmoonniiuumm ttoo ioonn--ppaaiirrwwiitthh PPFFOOSS aanndd PPFFOOAA iinn tthhee sseerruumm ((.J]'oohhnnssoonn eett aall 11999966)).. T"Thheefioonn.-ppiarirss wweerree tthheenn eexxttrraacctteedd wwiitthh ee~thhyyll aacceettaattee,. TThhee aabbssttrraaccttiioonn pprroodduuccttwwaasstthheenn aannaallyyzzeedd uussiinngg hhiigghh--ppeerrffoorrmmaannccee lliiqquuiidd cchhrroommaattooggrraapphh--thheerrmmoosspprraayy mmaassss ssppeeccttrroommetertryy.. IInn 11999977,, tthhee sseerruumm ssaammpplleess wweerree aannaallyyzzeedd bbyylliiqquuiiddcchhrroommaattooggrraapphhyy//mmaassss ssppeeccttrroommeettrryy,, uussiinngg sseelleecctteedd iioonn mmoonniittoorriinngg iin tthhee nneeggaattiivvee--iloonn mmooddee ((AAnnddeerrssoonn aanndd MMuullvvaannrnaa 119999778a;; 119999776b)).. IInn 22000000,, sseerrea ssaammpplleess wweerree eexxttrraacctteedd uussiinngg aann iioonn--ppaaiiriinngg eexxttrraaccttiioonn pprroocceeddmur'e ((HHaannsseenn eettaall,, 22000011)).. OOrnllyy iinn22000000wweerree tthhee eexxttrraaccttss qquuaannttiittaattiivveellyy aannaallyyzzeedd ffoorr PPFFOOSS aanndd PPFFOOAA aass wweellll aasstthhee ootthheerr aannaallyytteess:: PPFFHHSS,~(p(eprefrlfluuoorroohherxxaanneseusluflfoonnaattee)),, PPFFOOSSAAAA ((NN-eetthhyyll ppeerrfflluuoorrooooccttaanneess,yullffoonnaammididooacaecteatattee)),, MMS5T700 ((NN--mmeetthhyyll ppeerrfflluuoorrooooccttaanneessuullffoonnaammiiddooaacceettaatte)),, PPFFOOSSAA ((ppeerrfflluuoorroooncctiaanneessuallffoonnaatteeaammiiddee)) aanndd MMS5S566 ((ppeerrffluuoorrooooccttanneessuullffoonnaammiiddooaaccecatraete)).. HHigighh--ppe~rrffoorrmmaanncceeliliqquuiidd cchhrroommaattooggrraapphhyy/e/elleeccttrroosspprraayy ttaannddeemm mmaassss ssppeeccttrroommeettrryy ((IH-IPPLLOC//EESSMMSSMMSS)) wwaass tthhee
11779999..00000088
3M_MNo2482170
3M MN02482170
35PMMagCCeoosmmppoanrnn6yys
Page g of 63
,
tteecchhnniiqquuee uusseedd iinn 22000000.. TThhee ssaammpplleess wweerree eevvaalluuaatteedd vveerrssuuss aanneexxttrraacctteedd ccuurrvvee ffrroomm aa
hhuummaann sseerruumm mmaatiriixx.. AAnnaallyysseess wweerree ccoonndduucctteedd aatt ddiiffffeerreenntt llaabboorraattoorriieess iinn tthhee. tthhrreeee
ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee yyeeaa~rss.. FFoorr ppuurrppoosseessooff tthhiiss lloonnggiittuuddiinnaall aannaallyyssiiss,,aatottotaall oorrggaanniicc fflluuoorriinnee
iinnddeexx ((TTOOFF)) wwaass ddeetteerrmmiinneedd bbyy ccaallccuullaattiinngg tthhee ppeerrcceenntt ooff PPFFOOSS aanndd PPFFOOAA tthhaatt wwaass
attrtirbiubutteedd ttoo oorrggaanniicc fflluuoorriinnee ((6644..'77 aanndd 6699..00 ppeerrcceenntt,, rreessppeeccttiivveellyy)) mmuullttiipplliieedd bbyy tthhe ppppmm.
mmeeaassuurreedd ffoorr eeaacchh ooff tthheessee ttwwoo fflluuoorroocchheemmiiccaallssaanndd tthheenn ssuummmmeeddttoopprroodduucceeththeeTTOOFF..
DaDtaataAAnanlaylyssiiss BBrriieeffllyy., mmiixxeedd mmooddeellss ccaann bbee uusseedd iinn tthheeaannaallyyssiiss ooff rreeppeeaatteedd mmeeaassuurreess ddaattaa
`wwhhiicchh aarre ssiimmppllyyddaattaasesettss wwiitthh mmuultltiippllee mmeeaassuurreemmeennttssooff aa rreessppoonnssee vvaarriiaabbllee oonn tthhee
same
same
ssuubbjjeecctt
over
over
time.
time.
DDeettaailleedd eexxppllaannaattiioonn
of
of
tthheessee
mmooddeellss
iisspprroovviiddeedd
eellsseewwhheerree
(Lill 1996; 2000)
(Littell 1996; 2000).
Mixed
Mixed
models
models
contain
contain
fctor
factor
effects
effects
which
which
are
are
ccoonnssiiddeerreeddbbootthh
(
fined
fixed
and
and
rraannddoomm..
An
An
eeffffeecctt
sis
fixed
fixed
if
if
the
the
lleevveells
in
in
the
the
ssttuuddyyrreepprreesseenntt
all
all
ppoosssiibblee
lleevveellss
ofthe
of the
ffaaccttoorr,,
orai
or at
leas all
least all
lleevveellss
about
about
wwhhiicchh
iinnffeerreennccee
sis
tbe
to be
mmaaddee..
FFaaccttoorr
eeffffeecttss
are
are
rraannddoommif ift~hhelelevveellss ooff tthhee ffaaccttoorr tthhaatt aarree uusseeddiin tthhee sstuuddyy rreepprreesseenntt oonnllyy aa rraannddoomm
ssaammppllee ooffaa llaarr~geerr sseett ooffppooetneinitiaall lleevveellss..
"TThheeffooccuussoofftthheessatannddaarrddlilinneeaarrmmooddeelliiss ttoommododeelltthheemmeeaannooff yybbyyusuisinngg tthhee
ffiixxeedd--eeffffeeccttss ppaarraammeetteerrss ~8).. TThhaattiiss,,
yy==XXa~++e~ wherey represents a vectorofobserved data is an unknown vector of fixed effects
where y represents a vector or" observed data, ~ is an unknown vector of fixed effect~
ppaarraammeetteerrss
with
wi~
known
kno~n
design
design
matrix
matrix
X,
X,
and
and
&
~
is
is
an
an
unknown
unknown
random errorvector
random error vector
mmooddeelliinngg tthhee
ssatattiisstticcaall
n"nooiissee' aarroouunndd XXBj~..
TThhee rreessiidduuaall
eerrroorrss
~
aarree
aassssuummeedd
to
to
be:
be
11779999..00000099
33MM_MMNNo022448822117711
P33MuMcCCoolnmoppaoarnryy
Page I0 of 63
iinnddeeppeennddeenntt
and
and
iiddeenntiiccallllyy
ddiissttrriibbuutteedd
GGaauussssiiaann
rraannddoomm
vvaariiaabbleess
wwiitthh
mmeeaann
00
eanndd
vv~arsiiannccee 0o%-..
AA ggeenneerraalliizzeedd ssttaannddaarrdd lliinneeaarr mmooddeel iissaa mmiixxeedd mmooddeell wwhhiicchh iiss::
yy ==XX#pr+ zZyy+re
wwhheerree y iiss aann uunnkknnoowwnn vveeccttoorr ooff rraannddoomm--f~fffeeccttss ppaarraammeetteerrss wwiitthh kknnoowwnn ddeessiiggnn mmaattriixx
Z2,, aanndd ~ iiss aann uunnkknnoowwnn rraannddoomm eerxroorr vveeccttoorr wwhhoossee eell~e-mneennttss aarme nnoo lloonnggeerr rreeqquuiirreedd ttoobbe~
iinnddeeppeennddeenntt
and
and
hhoommooggeenneoeousu.s.
If
If
y
y
+
+
&
E
are
ar~
aassssuummeeddttoobbe~
GGaauussssiiaann
rraannddoomm
vvaarriiaabblleess
"ththaatt aarree uunnccoorrrreellaatteedd aanndd hhaavvee eexxppeeccttaattiioonnss 00 aanndd vvaarriiaanncceess GG aanndd RR,, rreessppeeccttiivveellyy,, tthheenn
the
the
vvaarriiaannccee
of ys:
ofy is:
VV == 2~6GZZ'
+R
+ R
"TThheevvaraiancreoofifththeeadadtaatna.,yy.c,ccaannebbee mmodoeleddbbeyyssplpeeccieiffyyidinnggththeessttruuctcurteuoofrf ZZe,, GGaannd dRR.. "7Tfhbeemmodoedell mats matrix ZZ iissddeessiiggnneedd nintthhee ssaammee ffaasshhiioonnaassXX,,tthheemmododeellmmaatt.ifixffoorr hetheffiixxeedd-
effecs paramezer.
effects pararr~ters.
FFoorr tthhee mmaattrriicceessGG aanndd RR., aa ccoovvaarriiaannccee ssttrruuccttuurree msmust bbee sseelleecctteedd iinn uussiinngg mmiixxeedd
models.
models.
Since
Since
oobbsseerrvvaattiioonnss
on
on
diferent
different
subjects
subjects
ars
ar~
assumed
assumed
tto
be
be
iinnddeeppeennddeennst,,
the
the
srucre structure
refers
refers
tothe
to
cthoevcaorviaraiannccee
paiemofrepeated
pattern of repeated
mmeeaassuurreemmeennttss
on
on
the
the
same
same
subject.
subject..
For
For
most
most
ofthesestructures,
of these structures,
ththe
covariance
covariance
between
between
two
two
oobbsseerrvvaattiioonnss
on
on
hethe
same.
same
ssuubbjjeecctt
ddeeppeennddss
cnly
only
on
on
the
the
length
length
ofthe
of the
time
time
iinntteerrvvaall
bbeettwweeeenn
mmeeaassuurreemmeennitss
and
and
the
the
vvaarriiaaanccee
is
is
ccoonnssttaanntt
ove
over
ime.
time.
NNuummeerroouuss ccoovvaarriiaanncceesstUrrcutctuueressexeixsistt..
CCoommmmoonn
eexxaammpplleess
includethe
include the
ffoolllloowwiinngg..
SSiimmpplleecocovavrairiaannccee
ssttrruuccttuurree
((SSIIMMD)ssppeceicfifiieesstthhtattthhee
bosbesrevrvaartiioonnss
aeare
iinnddeeppeennddeenntt,,
even
even
on
on
the
the
same
same
ssuubbjjeecctt,,
and
and
hav
have
hhoommooggeenneeoouuss
variance.
variance.
Tis
It is
uussuuaallllyy
not
not
realsic
realistic
for
for
most
most
rreeppeesatteedd
measures
measures
data
data
because
becaus~
it
it
ssppeecciiffiieess
hat
that
Gbservaions on the same subjectaeindependent. Compound symmetic (CS, therwise
observations on the same subject are.independent. Compound symmetric (CS, otherwise
11779999..00001100
3M _MMNN0o22448822117722
3P3aMMgCeCoiomlmpoparanenysy
P~$e [ ! of 63
,
Kk~noownwaanss vvaarriiaannccee ccoommppoonneennttss)) ssttrruuccttuurree ssppeecciiffiieess tthhaatt oobsbersvateionrsoovnntathhestsaaimmeeossuubnbjjeescctt
hhaavvee hhoommooggeenneeoouuss ccoovvaarriiaannccee aanndd hhoommooggeenneeoouuss.,vavarriiaannccee.. CCoorrrreellaattiioonnss bbeettwweeeenn ~twoo
oobbsseerrvvaattiioonnss aarree eeqquuaall ffoorr aalll ppaaiirssooff cobbsseerrvvaattiioonnss oonn tthhee ssaammee ssuubbjjeecctt.. AAuuttoorree~grreessssiivvee
oorrddeerr I1 ((AA.RR((Ll))))ccoovvaarriiaannccee sstrruuectturree ssppeecciiffiieess hhoommooggeenneeoouuss vvaarriiaannccee bbuutt tthhaatt ccoovvaarriiaanncceess.
bbeettwweeeenn oobbsseerrvvaattiioonnss oonn tthhee ssaammee ssuubbjjeecctt aarree nnoott eeqquuaall,, bbuutt ddeeccrreeaassee toowwaarrdd zzerroo ~wviitthh
iinnccrreeaassiinngg tiimmee iinntteerrvvaall bbeettwweeeenn mmeeaassuurreemmeenntt~s ((llaagg)).. TItss lliimmiittaattiioonn iiss tthhaat oobbsseerrvvaattiioonnss
oonn tthhee ssaammee ssuubbjjeecctt ffaarr asppaartt iinn ttiimmee wwoouullddbbe~ sesesnetnitiaallllyy iinnddeeppeennddeenntt.. AAuuttoorreeggrreessssiivvee
wwiitthh rraannddoommefefffeecctt foorr ssuubbjjeecctt ((AARR ++ RREE)) ccoovvaarriiaannccee sstirruucemtrue~ ssppeecciiffiieess hoommooggeenneeoouuss
vvaarriiaanncceepplluusstthhee ccoovvaarriiaannccee bbeettwweeeenn oobbsseervravtaitoinsoononns. tthheessaammeessuubjebctajairsieesesfcfrrotomm ttwwoo
ssoouurrcceess::1I))aannyyttwwoooobbsseerrvvaattiioonnsssshhaarree aa ccoommmmoonn ccoonnttrriibbuuttiioonn bbecaeusectthheaeyyaaurrc~osonntethhee
ssaammee ssuubbjjeecctt;; aanndd 22)) tthhee ccoovvaarriiaannccee bbeetcwweeeenn oobbsseerrvvaatiioonnss ddeeccrreeaasseess eexxppoonneennttiiaallllyy wviitthh
llaagg bbuutt oonnllyy to tthhee ccoommmmoonn ccoonnttrriibbuuttiioonn ((nnoott ttoo iinnddeeppeennddeennccee)).. TTooeepplliittzz (('TrOOEEPP))
sstrruuectturree ssppeecciiffiieess tthhaatt ccoovvaarriiaanncce ddeeppeennddss oonllyy oonn llaagg bbuutt nnoott aass a mmaatthheemmaattiiccaall ffuunnccttiioonn
wwiitthh a ssmmaallll nnumuberomoffppabarraamemeetteerrrss.. TThhee u'unnsstUr'uuccttuurreedd' ssttrruuccttuurree ((UUNN)) ssppeecciiffiieess nnoo
ppaatttteerrnnss iinn tthhee ccoovvaarriiaannccee mmaattriixx aanndd iissththeerreeffoorree ccoommppleletteellyy ggeenneerraall.. TThhee aabboovvee
sstrruuccttuurreess aarree aapppprroopprriiaatt~e iiff eeqquuaall ssppaacciinngg ((ooffddataata)) iis aassssuumm~ecdl iinn a ttiimmee sseerriieess aannaallyysseess..
In sivations where unequally spaced longitudinal measurements exist, spatial covariance
In situations where unequally spaced longitudinal measurements exist, spatial covaxiance
structures can be used. In the present analyses, equal spacing was assumed given there
structm-es can be used. In the present analyses, equal spacing was assumed ~ven there
w~,e'erree aapppprrooxxiimmaatteellyy33 yyeeaarrss bbeettwweeeenn eeaacchh mmeeddiiccaall ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee pprrooggrraamm eexxaammiinnaattiioonnss.
Akaike' information criterion (AIC) and Schwarz' Bayesian criterion (SBC) are
Akaike's inform,at.ion criterion (AIC) and Schwarz's Bayesian criterion (SBC) are
iinnddiicceessooff
rreellaattiivvee
ggooooddnnesess-so-of-f-ffiitt
tht
that
were
were
usedto
used to
compare
compare
models
models
with
with
the
the
same
same
fixed
fixed
effects, but different covariance structures. SBC penalizes models more severely forthe
effects, but different covariance structures. SBC penalizes models more severely for the
1177999..00001111
3M_MNo2482173
3M MN02482173
P3MaMCgeoCm2opm0a0pan6ny3y
Page 12 of 63
,
nnuummbbeerrooffeessttiimmaatteeddppaarraammeteteerrsstthhaannAAIICC aannddtthhuusstthheettwwoocrciritteerriiaa diidd nnoott aallwwaayyss aaggrreeee
oonn tthhee cchhooiiccee ooff-"boeesstt' mmooddeell.. SSBBCC wwaass pprreeffeerrrreedd..
nthe present study. the continuous outcomes of lipid and hepatic clinical
In the present study, the continuous outcomes of lipid and hepatic clinical
cchheemmiissttrryy
tests
tests
wweerr~e
eevvaalluusatteedd
ss
as
rreeppeeaatteedd
mmeeaassuurreess
iinnccoorproproartiantgitthnhege
rraannddoomm
ssuubbjjeecctt
eeffffeectt ffiitteedd t1o aammiixxeedd mmooddeellbbyytthhee MMIIXXEEDDpprroocceedduurree iinn tthhee SSAASS ssttaattiissttiiccaall ppaacckkaaggee
((LLiittteelll eett aall 11999966).). RReessttrriicctteed mmaaxxiimmuumm lliikkeelliihhoooodd eessttiimmaatteess ((RREEMMLL))oofvf avrairiaannccee
ppaarraammeetteerrss wweerr~e ccoommppuutteedd.. AAddjjuusstteedd rreeggrreessssiioonn mmooddeellss wweerree bbuulilkt bbyy iinnttrroodduucciinngg aallll ccoovvaardiaatteess ((sse bbeellooww)) aanndd tteessttiinngg tthhee ccoovvaarriiaanncce ssttrruuccttuurree. BBaasseedd oonn ggooooddnnesess-so-of-f-ffiitt tteessttss ddeessccrriibbeedd aabboovvee,, AARR++RREE,, wwaass rroouuttiinneellyy ccoonnssidiedreedrttehhede bbeesstt ccoovvaarriiaannccee ssttrruuccttuurree cchhoosseenn ffoorrtthhee mmiixxeedd mmooddeellss.. CCoovvaarriiaatteess iinncclluuddeedd PPFFOOSS ((oorr PPFFOOAAoorr TTOO)F),, yyeeaarrss ooff oobbsseerrvvaattiioonn,, tthhei-nitneterraaccttiioonn tteermmooff PPFFOOSS aanndd yyeeaarrns ooffobosbesrevrvaattiioonn,, aagge,, bbooddyy mmaassss iinnddeexx
((BBIMVIf)lS,, cciiggaarreetttes ssmmookkedppeerrddaayy,, aallccoohhooll ddrriinnkkss ppeerr ddaayy,,yyeeaarraatt ffiirrsstt eennttrryy aanndd bbaasseelliinnee.
(x first observation) years worked. For hepasic clinical chemisiy tests, serum
(at first observation) years worked. For h..c.patic clinical chemistry tests, serum
ttrriiggllyycceerriiddees wwaass aallssoo ccoonnssiiddeerreedd aaccoovvarairiaattee ((OOllsseenn eett aall 220~01l2a))..
RREESSUULLTTSS
PPrroovviiddeedd iinn TTaabbllee 11 aarr~sccrroosss.s-eseccttiioonna]l aannaallyysseess oofftthhee ssttuuddyy ssuubbjjeeccttss wwhhoo. ppaanrtiicciippaateedd iinn eeaacchhoofftthhee tthhreeeeyyeeaarrss ((11999944//9955,, 11999977 aanndd 22000000)) ssttrraattiiffiieedd bbyy Ilooccaattiioona..
AAss rreeppoorrtteedd pprreevviioouussllyy iinntthhee ccoommpplleette ccrroossss--sseeccttiioonnaall aannaallyysseess ooff tthhessee pprrooggrraammss ((OOllsseenn
etal
et al
11999988::
11999999;;
22000011)),,
AAnnttwweerrpp
eemmppllooyyeeeess
in
in
this
this
lloonnggiittuuddiinnaall
iinnvveessttiiggaattiioonn
wweerree
yyoouunnggeerr,, hhaadd lloowweerr BBMMIIss aanndd ddrraannkk mmoorree aallccoohhoolliicc bbeevveerraaggeess tthhaann DDeeccaattuurr eemmppllooyyeeeess..
"TThheeyy aalssoo hhaadd ccoonnssiisstteennttllyy olowweerr ttrriiggllyycceerriiddee aanndd aallkkaalliinnee pphhoosspphhaattaassee lleevveellss aanndd hhiig~heert
HHDDLL
aanndd
ttoottaall
bbiilliirruubbiinn
lleevveellss..
DDeceactatuurr
eemmppllooyyeeeess,,
oonn
aavveerraaggee,,
hhaadd
sseerruumm
PPFEOOSS
levels
levels
11779999..00001122
SW.
3M
MMNN0022448822117744
3P3MaMgCeCo1omm3p0pa1an6n3yy Page 13 of 63
(
ththaattwwerereehihgighheerrbbyyaapppprorxoimxaitemlya00.t..55epplppmmyiinn eeaacchhcrcorossss--sseeccttiioonnaallaannalaylyssiiss.. SSiimmiillaarr
ffiinnddiinnggss wweerree oobbsseerrvveedd ffoorr PPFFOOAA eexxcceepptt wwiitthh tthhee 11999977 ddaattaa wwhheerree tthhee ttwwoo ppooppuulalattiioonnss.
hhaadd ccoommppaarraabbllee mmeeaann PPFFOOAA lleevveellss..
`PPrroovviiddeedd iinn tthee ffoolllloowwiinngg ttwwoo ttaabblleess aarree tthhee ccrroossss--sseeccttiioonnaall aannaallyysseess ffoor tthhee tthhrreeee
ssuubbccoohhoorrtts bbyy llooccaattiioonn.. AAmmoonngg AAnnttwweerrpp eemmppllooyyeeeess ((TTaabbllee 22)),, eeaacchh oofftthhee tthhrreeee
ssuubbccoohhoorrtts hhaadd lloowweerr mmeeaann sseerruumm PPFFOOSS lleevveellss iinn 22000000 tthhaann aait tthheeiirr yyeeaarr oofefnenttrryy
wWhheerreeaass tthheerree wweerree nnoo ccoonnssiisstteenntt cchhaannggeess aaccrroossss ssuubbccoohhoorrtts wwiitthh PPFFOOAA.. AAmmoonngg tthhee
tthhrreeee DDeeccaattuurr ssuubbccoohhoorrtts ((TTaabbllee 33)) mmeeaann BPFFOOSS vvaalluueess ddeecclliinneedd oovveerr ttiimmee bbuutt mean
PPFFOOAA lleevveellss tteennddeedd mto iinnccrreeaassee..
PPrroovviiddeedd iinn ttaabblleess 44 tthhrroouugghh 3300 aarree tthhee mmiixxeedd mmooddeell ccooeeffffiicciieenntt eessttiimmaatteess,,
ssttaannddaarrddeerrorrosrs,,pp-:vvaalluueess aanndd 99:55%% ccoonnffiiddeennccee iinntteerrvvaallss ffrroomm tteessttiinngg ppootteennttiiaall
ddeetteerrmmiinnaannttss oofflilippiidd aanndd hheeppaatiicc cclliinniiccaall cchheemmiissttrryy cchhaannggee.. TThhee nnaattuurraall lloogg wwaass uusseedd ffoorr
aallll ddeeppeennddeenntt vvaarriiaabblleess..
.
T"Taabblleess 44 tthhrroouugghh 66 ccoonnttaaiinn tthhee aannaallyysseessffoorr cchhoolleesstteerrool,l. TThheerreewwaass nnoo cchhaannggee iinn
cchhoolleesstteerrooll aassssoocciiaatteedd wwiitthh PPFFOOSS ((TTaabbllee 44)).. OOvevrearlall,l PPFFOOAA wwaass ppoossiittiivveellyy aassssoocciiaatteedd.
wwiitthh
cchhoolleesstteerrooll
aass
tthheemmaaiinneeffffeecctt
ccooeeffffiicciieenntt
wwaass
ssiiggnniiffiiccaannttllyy
ppoossiittiivvee
but
but
is
its
interaction
interaction
wwiitthh ttiimmee ((yyeeaarrss vvaarriiaabbllee)) wwaass nneeggaattiivvee ((TTaabbllee )5).. PPrroovviiddeedd iinn TTaabblleess S5AA tthrroouugghh 55DD aarrce
sseeppaarraattee aannaallyysseess ffoorr AAnnttwweerrpp ffoorraallll ssuubbjjeeccttss (('TTaabbllee S5AA)) aanndd bbyy eeaacchh ssuubbccoobhoorrtt.. TThhee
PPFFOOAAaanndd cchhoolleesstteerrooll aassssoocciiaattiioonn aappppeeaarreedd ttoo pprriimmaarriillyy eressiiddee wwiitthh tthhee 2211 AAnnttwweerrpp
eemmppllooyyeeeess iinn ssuubbccoohhoorr~s AA ((TTaabbllee 5SBB)).. TThhiiss ffiinnddiinngg ccaann aallssoo bb~e oobbsseerrvveedd iinn TTaabbllee 22 aass
tthhee ssuubbccoohhoornt''s mmeeaann PPFFOOAA lleevveellss wweenntt ffrroomm 11..3322 ppppmm.. tto0 22..3377 ppppmm aanndd tthheenn ddeecclliinneedd ttoo
22.0066ppppmm aat tthheessaammeettiimmeeththeeiirrcchohloelsetseterroollvvaalluueessrroossee ffrroomm 220088 mm~dg L1t0o2/22266mdmg~/ddLLLttoo
222299 mmgg//ddLL.. TThheerme wweerree nnoo aassssoocciiaattiioonnss bbeettwweeeenn cchhoolleesstteerrooll aanndd PPFFOOAA oobbsseerrvveedd aammoonngg.
11779999..00001133
IM_MN02482175
3M MN02482175
E3MSCCooAmmppaa]nnyy
.
he
D
ec
at
ur
employee
p
ap
ul
t
io
n
(Table
SE
or
vers
h
ee
significant
a
ssc
Pag~ 14
iaions
of
63
the Decatur employee population (Table 5E) nor were then significant associations
`bbeetwtweeeenn TTOOFF aanndd AAnnttwweerrpp oorr DDeeccaattuurr bbuutt wwhheenn tthhee ttwwoo ssiitteess wweerree ccoommbbiinneedd tthheerree wwaass aa
Signiant osiive sociation becween TOF and cholestrol Tables , 6A and 68) significant positive association between TOF and cholesterol (Tables 6, 6A and 68). Ther wer osignifica: assctaions becween PROS,PFOA orTOF with HDL There were no significant associations between PFOS, PFOA or TOF with I-IDL
((TTaabblleess 77 tthhrroouugghh 99)).. BBMMI],, aallccoohhoolliicc ddrriinnk~s ppeerr ddaayy aanndd cciiggaarreettteess ssmmookkeeddppeerrddaayy wweerree
the mot significant asians wih HDL. the mosTtgsliy~eifeirciadnetsawsseorceiantioonssigwniithfcIa-InDlyLassocined with PEOSover me when both
Tri#ycerides were not significantly associated with PFOS over time when both
Anerp snd Decatur populations wee examined ogee (Table 10) However, among
Antwerp and Decatur populations were examined together (Table 10). However, among
tihnee ccoommbbiinneedd AAnnttwweerrpp aannddDDeeccaattuurrppooppuullaaitoionnss,, PPFFOOAA wwaass ppoossitiivveelly aassssoocciiaatteedd wwiitthh igscrde (Table 11) as se with th igen ose cosfcient for he main
triglycerides (Table 11) as seen with the significant positive coefficient for the main
ffckofPFO and enon gnifcant posiv mai coffin of years and the negative
effect of PFOA. and the nonsignificant positive main coefficient of years and the negative
cofffoithen coefficient for their innetesrcacrtioonn ((PPFOFAOxAx yyeeasr)s)..Th sigan The significantmmaainn f effect oofe fPPFFOOAA was the consequence of he Antwerp population (Table L1A) and primary subcohort A
was the consequence of the Antwerp population (Table 11A) and primarily s~bcohort A
(able 18) and 10a serexcnt subcohort B (Table 11. but no subeobors C (Table
(table 1 IB) and, to a lesser extent subcohort B (Table 11C), but not subcohort C (Table
11D). Therefore, easton appeared be relied tthe Anwerp workers who
11D). Therefore, the association appeared to be related to the Antwerp workers who
wweerte, rll enrolled iinn thhiiss nlognigtiutucdiinnaall ccoohhorrt bbeeggiinnniinngg nin 11999955,, bbuutt nnott 11595977.. TThheerree wwass nooxt a sigan assoiaon between PFOA and igycries among Decatur rkers Table
a significant association between PFOA and triglycerides a~.ong Decatur workers (Table
115) Among the Antwerp subcohortA,thee mean glcerds eels ose fom 85
11E). Among the Antwerp subcohort A, their mean triglycerid~ levels rose from 85
ng 10 113 mg/L 0173 ml.a the same time te PFOA Ives ncresed from m13#2dpLmto1101253m7~pdpLmtosn1d23thmen~ddedcLliant ethde1s0a2m.0e6 ptimpme.theAilr PtFhOoAuglheehvemlsaiinncfrefaescedofrroTmOF
1.32 ppm to 2.3"~ ppm and then declined to 2.06 ppm. Although the main effect for TOF
as significantly pose, th interaction tr ith im (yes) was ok significant
was significantly positive, the interaction term with time (years) was not significant
((TTaabbllee 1122)).. AAggaaiinn.. tthhiiss aassssoocciiaattiioonn wwaass mmoorree ccoonnssiisstteenntt ffoorr AAnnttwweerrpp eemmppllooyyeeeess ((TTaabbllee: '
1122A)) tthhaannDDeceactauturr eemmppllooyyeeeess ((TTaabbllee 11228B)),.
(
11779999..00001144
aw ozug2176 3M MN02482176
P33aMMgeCCo1omm3p0pa0an6ny5y A`Ammoonngg tthhee hheeppaattiicc cclliinniiccaall cchheemmisisttrryy tteesstts tthhaatt ~wveerree aaddjjuusstteedd ffoorrtthhee vvaarriioouuss cchhaanrgtiinngg ddeemmooggrraapphhiicc ffaaccttoorrssaannddtur'iiggll~y,cceerriidde lleevveellss,, tthheerree wweerree nnoo ssii~gniiffiiccaanntt aassssoocciiaattiioonnss bbeettwweeeenn PPFFOOSS,, PPFFOOAA aanndd TTOOFF wwiitthh cchhaannggeess iinn aallkkaalliinnee pphhoosspphhaattaassee ((TTaabblleess 1133.--151)5),, GGGGTT ((TTaabblleess 1166--1188)),, AASSTT ((TTaabblleess 1199--2211)),, AALLTT ((TTaabblleess 2222:-2244)),, otottaall
bbiilliirruubbiinn ((TTaabblleess 2255 -2727))oor ddiirreecctt bbiilliirruubbiinn ((TTaabblleess 2288--3300).). OObbsseerrvvaattiioonnss aap0ppaarreenntt iinn "TTaabblleess 22 aanndd33 ccaann aalssoo bbee sseeeenn iinn tthheessee mmiixxeedd mmooddeell aannaallyysseess.. FFoorreexxaammppllee,,tthheettwwoo rmaoosstt ssiiggnniiffiiccaanntt pprreeddiiccttoorrssooffalaklkaalliinnee pphhoosspphhaattaassee wweerree riimmee ((yyeeaarrss)) aanndd llooccaattiioonn ((aass sseeeenn wwiitthh tthhee lloowweerr vvaalluueess aammoonngg AAnnttwweerrpp eemmppllooyyeeeess))..FFoorrAALLTT,, eennttrryy ppeerriioodd wwaass aallssoo ssiiggnniiffiiccaannttaas tit rreefflleecctteedd tthhee hhiigghheerr rreeffeerreennccee rraannggee vvaalluueess ffoorr AALLTT tthhaatt wweerree uusseedd iinn 11999944/9955 tthhaann iinn ssuubbsseeqquueenntt yyeeaarrss..
DDIISSCCUUSSSSIIOONN
(
T`Thheessee aannaallyysseess wweerree tthhee ffiirsstt lloonnggiittuuddiinnaall aasssseessssmmeenntt oofftthhee fflluvoorr0occhheemmiiccaall
mmeeddiiccaall ssuurrvveeiillllaannccee pprrooggrraamm aatt 33MM''ss AAnnttwweerrpp aannddDDeceacattuurrmmanaunfuafcatcuturirinngg ssiitteess..
`OOvveerraallll,. wwee oobbsseerrvveedd nnoo aassssoocciiaattiioonnss tthhaatt wweerree ccoonnssiisstteenntt wwiitthh tthhee ttooxxiiccoollooggiiccaall eevviiddeennccee
that
that
PPFFOOSS
pprroodduucceess
aa hhyyppoolliippiidd~emmiic
eeffffeecctt
aat
tthhrreesshhoolldd
ddoossaaggeess
iinn
rraatss
aanndd pprriimmaatteess
((33MM
CCoommppaannyy 22000000;; HHaauugghhoomm aanndd SSppyyddeevvoolldd 11999922:: Ikeeddaacett aall 11998877:; PPaassttoooorr tetaall 11998877:;
`SSeeaaccaatt
eett aall
220000113a::
22000011b::
SSoohhlleenniiuuss
tet
al
al
11999933)).. OOuurrrreessuullttss
ddiid
ssuuggggeesstt
a
a
ppoossiittiivvee
aassssoocciiaatrioonn bbeettwweeeenn tteemmppoorraall cchhaannggeess iinn cchhoolleesstterrooll aanndd trriiggllyycceerriiddeess aanndd PPFFOOAA:;
hHoowweevveerr tthiiss iiss aallssoo iinncoonnsisisstteenntt wwiitthh tthhee ttooxxiiccoolloog~icaall eevviiddeennccee tthhaatt PPFFOOAA mmaayy rreessuulltt iinn
a
a
hhyyppoolliippiiddeemmiJcc
eeffffeecctt
iinn
rraatss
((HHaauugghhoomm
aanndd
SSppyyddeevvoolldd
11999922:;
PPaassttoooorr
eett aall
11998877))
bbuutt
pprroodduucceedd nnoo eeffffeecctt oonn bblloooodd lliippiiddss iinn pprriimmaatteess((BButueteanhhooffffeettaall 22000011))..
11779999..00001155
33MM_MMNNo022448822117777
P~3aMMgeCCo1om6~p3[~a1nn6yy3
P~ge 16
(
EEvveenn tthhoouugghh wwee wweerree asbbllee ttoo p~errffoorrmm aa lloonng~ittuud~inna~l ~assseessssmmeenntt,, ~therree wweer~e
sseevveer~all llii~mitatattioionnss 0to oouurr aanna~lyysseess.. WWee wweer~e llii~mitteedd ttoo 117755 eemmp~looyyeeeess ooff wwhhiicchhoonnllyy 4411
(24 percen) paricipated in all three surveillance years. Although agreater absolute
(24. ~rcent) p~cipated in all thee su~eillance ye~. Although a veater absolute
nnuummbbeerrooffDDececaattuurr eemmppllooyyeeeess ((bbuuttnnooktp~erncetn-tw.wiisse)) hhaavvee ppa~ritciicpipaattedd dduurriinngg eeaacchh yyeea~r,,
for his longitudinal assessmentthereweremore Antwerp (57 percent) thanDecatur(43
for this lon~din~ ~ssment th~ we~ more An~e~ (57 ~rcent) ~an Decatur (43
~perecnentt)) eemmppllooyyeeeess.. AAnnttwweer~p eemmppllooyyeeeess hhaavvee hhaadd lloowweerr sseer~umm PPFFOOSS lleevveell bbyy
aapppprrooxxiimmaatteellyy
00..55
ppppmm
((OOllsseenn
~ett a~l
11999988;;
OOllsseenn
eett
a~ l
11999999a;;
1199999%b;;
220~01la3;;
2001;
2~ib;
220~011c)).. T~heer~e wweer~e iinnssuuffffiicciieenntt nnuumm ber~s ooff ffeermuallee eemmppllooyyeeeess ffoorr nmyy m meagnainnignf~ull
Tongitudinal analysis. Given the variability inherent in the analytical method (Hansen et
lon~mdinM ~ysis. Given ~e v~ability inhe~nt in ~e ~ic~ me~ ~sen et
212001) and the different laboratories used, serum PFOS and PFOA levels may have
~ 2~1) ~d ~ ~ff~nt labo~tofies ~ se~m PFOS ~d PFOA l~vgls may have
ssyysstteemmaattiicc em~oorriinnccoor~poor~atteedd iinn eeaacchh m me~asuu~rm emeenntt t~haat wwee wweer~e uunnaabbllee ttoo a~ssseessss ~as
blood samples were analyzed only at the ime of the surveillnce program. This
blo~ s~ples we~ m~yzed only at ~e time of ~e su~eillmce p~. ~is
(
systematic eror may have masked associations with lipidorhepatic clinical chemistries,
sys~mafic e~or may have m~ked ~s~iafions with lipid or hepatic clinical che~s~es,
although the rangeofPFOS and PFOA measured was relatively consistent throughout the
akhough ~e range of PFOS ~d PFOA me~md w~ ~lafively consistent ~mu~out ~e
ssttuuddyy ttiimmee ~pedrioodd.. BBe~caauussee 33MM hha~s aannnnoouunncceedd aapphahs~ee-~ouutt ooff tthhee ppr~odduuccttiioonn ooff
perfluorooctanyl chemistry-elsted materials, we doubt that there willbe manymore.
pe~uo~tanyl h~mis~-related mater,s, we doubt ~at ~e~ will ~ many more
subjects inthefuturethacan be included in this longitudinal assessment.Also,the
subj~ in ~e ~m~ ~at cm ~ inclu~d in ~s Ion~m~n~ ~sessment. ~so, ~
findings from this assessment would suggest that serum PEOS levels have either.
fin~n~ f~m ~is ~ssmen~ would suggest that ~mm PFOS levels have eider
remained constantordeclined slightly over time among these 175 employees. On the
~m~ned constmt or ~lined slimily over time ~ong these 175 employees. On ~e
otherhand.serum PFOA levels appearedto trend upwaonravdersag,e, by approximately
o~er h~d. ~m PFOA levels appemd to trend upw~, on average, by epp~ximately
0.510 10 ppm for these employees. Another limitasion i the fac ha the serum PFOS
0.5 to 1.0 ppm for ~ese ~mp[oye~s. Ano~er li~tafion is ~e f~t that ~e se~m PFOS
amndd
PPFFOOAA
lleevveellss
mmeeas~uur~edd
iinn
these
these
employees
employees
were
we~
lower
lower
than
~
those
those
tha
that
cause
cause
effets
effec~
in
in
laboratory animals.
la~to~ ~imals.
11779999..00001166
IM_MN02482178
3M MN02482178
P33aMMgeCCo7omm5p0paa6nn5yy
Page 17 ~f63
(i
IInnssumummarym,aalaloonngrgiittuuyddiin,naall aannaallyyssiiss oovveraeassirixxyyeeaarrttiimmeeppeerriioodd ooff 117755 AAnnttwweerrpp
aanndd DDeeccaattuurr mmaallee eemmppllooyyeeeess ddiidd nnoott sshhooww ssiiggnniiffiiccaanntt cchhaannggeess,, ccoonnssiisstteenntt wwiitthh
ttooxxiiccoollooggiiccaall ddaataa,, ooff lliippiiddoorr eheppiatcic cclliinniiccaall cchheemmisisttrryy vvaalluueess aassssoocciiaatteedd wwiitthh eeitthheerr
PFOS or PFOA. The PFOS and PFOA serum levels measured in these employees were
PFOS or PFOA. The PFOS and PFOA serum levels measured in these employees were
lToowweerr tthhaann tthhoossee tthhaat ccaauussee eeffffeeccttss iinn llaabboorraattoorryy aanniimmaallss..
11779999..00001177
IM_MN02482179
3M MN02482179
,
RREEFFEERREENNCCEESS
MP3aMgeCCo1om8mp0pa0an6ny3y
Page lg of 63
3i3tMsMsaCCloso.mmppSatan.nyyPa((u22l0000(00V))I..N)SS:II3DDMSSCIIonnmiittpiiaaallnaayss,ssee(ssussnmmpeuenbntltirrseehppeoordrttr::ePPpoeerrrtff.lluuoorrooooccttaannee ssuullffoonniicc aacciidd aanndd M`itMsiinsnannleetasap.pooSlliti.ssP((aMMuNNl)-()~:UUrNin)vi:ve3reMsrsiittCyyooomffpMMaininnynn,ees(souolntapa,u, b((uluinnspphuuebdbllriiesshpheoedrdt)rr,eeppoorrtt)).. AP`eAnrndfdleeurrossrooonnoDDcJtJa,,nMMoauutlIevvaaannnada DPDeEErf((l11u9o99r9o77oa)c).t.anAAennsaaulllyyfttioicncaaaltleRReienppoHorurttmffaoornr tthSheeerDDueetmteebrrymmiLinnCaat/tiiMooSnn.ooffIthaca NNPYe:YrAf:lAduvdoarvoanonccceteaddnoBBiaiotoeaannaanalldyytPtiiceearalflluSSoeerrrovvoiicceeetassnIIennsccu;;lAfAouunggauutsesttin1199H997u7.m. an Serum by LC/MS. Ithaca
APAennrddfeelrurssooornnooDDcJtIa,,nMMoauutlelvaavnnadaDnPDeEaErf((l11u99o9r97o76ob)c).t.anAAennsaualllyyfttoiinccaaailleRRieenppoHorurstmffaoonrr ttShheeerDDueemtteebrrymmiLinnaMattSiioo.nn ooffIthaca NPNYe~r:'f:AlAudodvrvaoanoncccteeaddnoBBaiiotoeaannaanaldlyytPtiicecaralflluSSoeerrrovvoiicceeetassnIIennsccu;;lfSSoeenppatteteemmibbneeHrr u11m9999a77n.. Serum by LC/MS. Ithaca
BBLuiutdteeennrhhoPof.fffO.JllLLs,,eCnCoGossWtta.aGT,,hEEollcmcooommrbdbeeCPC.,,TFFoaasrrirrcaairrtDDy,,ofHHaaanmsmenonnKsKi,,ueImIwwanpaieiHrHf,l,ulJouurnnoggocRRt,a,nKKoaeetnnenne(dAeyPdGFGy,O,) in
:
LccyyienndooemmrooPllg.guOusslsmmeononnGkkWeeyy,ssTaahffotemrr f22o66rdwwePeee.kkTssooofxfoiocriratayl oddofossaiimnnggm.. o((ununinuppmuubblpliiessrhhfeleuddorrreoeppoooerrtta))noate (APFO) in
HHquaaannnstsieetnnatKKiIvJ,e, CCchlleaemrmaecitnaerILi.AAz,a,tEEilolllneefofsfsooornngMMaEnE,i,cJJfolhuonorsoohcnhJJneIHm-iIOOsca((l2o2s0000i1nn1).)b.ioCClooomgmpicopauolnudmn-adtsr-pisecpceeisc.fiificEc,n,viron
qSScuciianTTteeictcahhtnnivooell
3576-770. characterization
35:766-770.
oF organic
fluorochermeals in biological
matrices.
Environ
{
HHpeaaruuflgguhhooormomctBBa,,noSSippcyydadeceivvdool(lddPF0OOA((1)199,992p2)e).r.lTuTohhreeocmmteeaccnhheasananliispsmhmonuuinncddeearrclliyydiinn(ggPFtthhOeeShhAyy)ppooalnliidppecemlmoiifccibeefifffceeccatctioodff. pBeirofcluhoermoiectaaneotiBciaocpihdys(iPcFaOAAc)t,ape11rf2l8u:o6r5o-c7t2a.nesulphonie acid (PFOSA) and elofibric acid.
Biochemica et Biophysica Acta 1128:65-72.
clIkyketeddoaachTTr..oFFmuuekkPuu-dd4aa5KK0a,,nMMdoporeiilrIIo,,xEEinnsooommmeotoportMoMlo.i,fKKerooamtmiaoaini TTi,n, SSrauutgglaaivTTer((bt19y988p77e))r..flIIunnodrdiuurccatttiioeondn ooff eocodcycstttoa)anncNehesesruouwlmlffYooeonnriPikcc-:4aaS5icp0dird.ia.nngIIdnenr::peVPPreoeerrrxliii.asrvgooo,mssrpmaeepepss3r0iionn4l-iBBf3ei0or8ali.otigoyon.aainnlnddrMaoMetdleiigdvcieicrnyinebe.y.p((eIrH-f~lDuoFFraaihhnmratiiedaannddi HH SSiieess,,
eds) New York:Springer Verlag, pp 304-308.
JPJPoeoerhhrffnnllssuuoooonnrrooJJoo'DDcc,t,taaWWnnoooloaatlttteeeerraaJJnn'TIdd',, PPCCeeoocrllffaall.iuuizzooyyrrooOGooEFce,t,t,aaRRnneeeetssthuhuwlwliffoliollnnl aaPPttAAee,,iiNnnNeHHelulsusmmoonananRnRMMSS.ee.rruuQQmmuuaUaUnnsistiifinnfiiggccaaIIotoiinnoo--nnPPaooaififrr `EESxxptterrcaatccrttoiiomonentaarnnyddwiHHtiihgghhAuPPteeorrmffoaortrmemadannSccaeemLLpiliqqeuuiPiddreCCphahrrraootmmiaoatnt.ooggSrrtaa.ppPhhayyu--lTT,hhMeeNrrmm:oo3sspMprraEayynvMMaLasassbs, 1996.
Stt~ctrometry with Automated Sample Preparation. St. Paul, I~-N:3M Env Lab, 1996.
LaLinitatttleeylisliiRRsoCCf..rPPeeepnneddaeetrreggdaasmstet aJJ,,suNNraawetasarrdaaajjtaeann. RRSt((a22t000M000e))d.. MM1o9o:d1de7ol9lii3nn-gg18ec1oo9vv.aarriiaannccee ssrtruuecttuurree iinn tthhee
analysis of' repeated measures data. Stat Meal 19:1793-1819.
LLCiaitcr~eyellllNRRCCCS..AMMSilillIliinkkseteinntuGGtAe~,n,c.SS.tt.rroo1uu9pp96WW, W6W3,3, WWpoplo.flfiinnggeerr RRDD.. SSAASS SSyysstteemm ffoorr MMiixxeedd MMoodedlesl.s.
Cary NC:SAS Institute Inc., 199(5, 633 pp.
OcOllilssneeicnnalGGcWWh.e.mBiBsuutrrrrriiiesssJJ,'MMh,e, mMMataaonldoenglJyJH'dla-.In,ZedZoobhlbeoorllmLLenRRe((s11i99n998r8)e).l.atAAinonneeoppisiddeeermmuiimoolllooeggviiecclsiinnovvfeesstitgiagtiaotniooofnf cppCeleoirrnmffilplcuuaaoolnrrcoyohoo(eccumttanainpnseeutrbsisleuuislls,ffhoohennedaamttreeeaptiioonnrlDomm)ga.aylleeanfflduuoohrrooorccmhheoemmnieicscaailnl pprerrooladdtuuiocctntiiotoonnseeemmrpuplmlooyyleeeeveses.l.sSSottf.. PPaauull::33MM
Company (unpublished report).
11779999..00001188
33MM_MMNNo022448822118800
P33aMMgeCCoo9mm0pp1aa6nn5yy
Page 19 of 63
(
aOOlnlsdseehnnepGGaWWti,c, BBaunurdrrriilssipJJiMMd.c,lMMinaiancndadleelclhJJeHHm,i,sZZtoorbbyeeltlesLLtsRRi((n11f99l999u98o)ar.)o.chSSeeemrriuucmamlpppeerrroffldluuuocortrcioooocnctteaamnnpeelssouuylleffeoonsna.attee:
JaJ'nOOdEEhMMep44a11t(i(c99))a:7n79d999-l-i5p80i06d6..clinical chemistry tests in fluorochemical production employees.
MOOlalssneednnelGGWWJ,H, (LL1oo9gg9a9a5nn).PPWWF,,luSSoiirmmoppcsshooennmiCCcAaAl,, eHHxaapnnossseeunnreKKJaJ,s,sBBeuusrnsrm'iiessnJIt'MMo,,fBBDueurcrllaeetwwurMMcMhM,e,miSScccahhluuammpnpederfrttilJImCC,, MppllaaannnttdecermlaJpp'FllIooyy(1eee9es9s..9bSS)t.t.. FPPalauuuoll:r:3o3McMheCCmooimmcpapalanenxyyp((ouusnnupprueubballsiisssehhseesddmrreeepnpotortro)tf)..Decatur chemical and film
OhOellpssaeetnnicGGeWWn,z,yBBmuuernsr'i,isscJIhMoMl,,eBsBtuurrrollleewwanMMdMMl,i,poMMparanondtdeeeilnlsJJ'HiHn ((a22m000m000o))n.. iPPullmaasspmemraaflccuhhooorlloeeocccyytssaitonockkaiintnenn aanndd pphrreoopddauutciccttiieoonnnzywwmoorerkkse,errcssh..oDDlerrsuuteggrCoClhhaeenmmdTTloipoxoxipiccrooollte22in33s(44-i)n6:60a03m3--m662o20n0.i.um perfluorooctanoate
OOslelssreeunnm GOpeWWr,f,luBBouurrfolloeecwwtaMMnsMMu,l,foBBnuaarrtrdess(JJPMMF,O,SMM)aanandndedellpeJJr'HHif((u22o00r00o11o)ca.t).aAnAcoraoctsreoss-(ssP-esFceOtcAtii)oonnianallealaanntaaillyoynssisstoooff ccsfleleiirmnnuaiircclaaaellpec~cmhhrpfeellmmuoioiyssrectoreyoy,c,pttatahhrnyiysrcruoiolipfidaodhnnhtoaostrremomfo(PontnFheeeO,,2Shh0)ee0mma0anatdAtoonpllteoowrgglefyyruaaponnraoddnoduucDrrtiieanncnaaaollyytasstuieirss(fPrrleeFussOuoulrlAttossc)ffhirernomomrimeclmmaaaltailolmeeneaadtnniocddal fsseuumrrvvaeeliielllleaamnnccpeeloppyrroeoeggrrpaaammr.t.icSSipCt:aPPnatasuullof((MtVhNNe))2::0330MM0 CCAoonmmtwppaearnnpyya((nuudnnDppuuebbcllaiistsuhhreeddflurreeopprooordcr)th)..emical medical
JOOKll.sseeMnnaGnGdWWe.l, SSJccHhhim(m2ii0cc0kl1dlbee)rr.MMNDNe.s.cTTriiieeprrt~einnvsse JJsMMu.m, mLLaoorggayaonnfPPsW We.r, uBBumurrrfrilissuoJJrMMo.c,hBBeumutirlcleaewlw lMMevMMe.l,sLLauumnnoddnbbgeerrgg `JepKemrmo,ppgMllrooayaymnee.edeeSppltaa.rJrtHtPiiacc(uii2plp0:aa03nntV1tss1bo)oC.ffottDmhhpeeesayycneeraiyaprrt(i22uv00ne00pu0s0ubAAlmninmstthwwaeeredyrrrppoefffpllosuve)oor.ruromocchhfeelmumoiicrcoaalclhmmeemeddiiicccaaalil lsseuuvrrevvleesiilalllmaannoccneeg
program. St. Paul:3M Company (unpublished report).
TOO2ll0ss0ee1nn)GG.WW.D,esLLcoorggiaapnntiPPveWW,s,uSSmiimmmapprssyoonnofsCCeAA,r,uBBmuurrruniossrJJoMMch,,eBBruuirrcllaeewlw llMVevMhe-,~ls, LLauumnnoddnbbgeerreggmpJJKlK,o,yMMeaeannddeell JJIH-I "`pP(pa'a2aur-rlt0:ti0ic31cicipM)pa.annCDttsoseomtospcfhratihepnetyiyyv(eeeuaansrrup22um00b0m0li00asrDDhyeeedcocafratetsupueorrrrutffml)lu.voofrlrouocochrhoeecmmhiicecamallicmmaeleddileiccvaaelllsssuuarrmvveeoiinlllglaanencmceeppplorroyoggerreaamm.. SStt
Paul:3M Company (unpublished report).
PaPsstautsdotiooeosrrToTfPP.a.mLLme~oeenKKiPPu.,mPPepererririlfM~luLAo~,r.,oGGoiciltllalineeossaPPtYel-((i11n99d88u77c).e).d hBBeiipooaccthheoemmmieicgcaaalllayannaddnmdmoproeprrhpoohxliooslgoomi~ecc.aall
proliferation. Exp Mol Pathol 47:98-109. studies of ammonium perfluorooctanoate-induced
proliferation. Exp Mol Pathol 47:98-109.
hepatomegaly
and
peroxisome
`SSSeeaaabcc-aactthrAAoMMni.c. TTdhiheootmmafrfyoortrddoxPPiJcL,itHHyaoanfnpssoeetnnaKKsJsJ,i, uCCmlleeprmeaeernnflLLvAAr,o,eCCtaaassneeesMMuTlT,f,oBBniuuctteaencnhidohfoiffJYLrfLat(2s2.000T01o18xa)i).c.ol SSSccuiib((-scsuhubrbommniiittcteedddie22t00a0r01yi3at)o)..xicity, of potassium peffluorooctanesulfonic acid in rats. Toxicol
S{SoeevaaicccaaitrtyAAsMMt.u.diTTehhso0offnoorrpddefPPJlJ.'u,oHHraoanonscsieeannnKKsJsJu,',lOOflolssneeannteGpGoWWt,a,sCCsaiassueemsMMaTlT.t. BBinuutcteyennnhohomofofffJlJgLLu..s SSmuuobbncckhheroryonsin.cic: TTtoooxxxiiiccciootyll sSStccuiid((iessusubbommniipttteeed~d..u2o200ro001o1bcb)t).a.nesulfonate potassium salt in cynomolgus monkeys.
SSPeoorhhfllleeunnoiiruuosscAcAtKKa.n,eEEsxruikklssfssooonnne AAsMMc,i, HiHooaggspsiotrrtoeomnmtCCi,n,dKKuiciemmrlolaafnnddpMMer,,oDDxiecsPPoiimeearrlrreefaJJyWWa(c(11i99d9933B))-..oxidaton
PaaPnhnedadrfrloomuttaohhcreeoorrolsacccTtttoaiirnvvieiitciisoeeulsslfk7ko2nnn9ooi0wcw-nn9a5ctt.iood
beis
be
affected a potent
affected
by peroxisome proliferators inducer of peroxisornal fatty
by pcroxisome proliferators
in mouse liver. acid B-oxidation
in mouse liver.
Pharmacol Toxicoi 72:90-93.
11779999..00001199
IM_MNo2482181
3M MN02482181
vos. I)F{).~ roa I)F(')A TorTOF noAge iI]MI Ase AIc(,hol scheYes Ilaselh]e Years Viked Worked Comes ('igaretles Goes Cl~oleslerol noI 1DL
Tweides "rriglycerides Mme AIk Phos aor( ~( ;'1" astAS'I" arAIJI" Talis 'r.lal Ifiliruhi. Dealiobn I)ired lliliruhi.
HIANEog1. pClisc CSheatrotne!rAisnaanld CyliMniecs CsnheomcioefDAisnotnswnofdSeDeerrcnapPHMOaSl,ePEFOlA,oTOyF, we l ~lllO~ll)lli~ O)ara~terislk-s and (:linical Ol~inislries of Ant~rp ~lld D~calur Male We Figted iTr ona Med Sovionc Exam ween 19475 0d 3060 Who I~ailicipat~ in Two or More Medical Surveilla.c~ ~x;ll,i,ations I]ctween 1994195
outs ew xm 191J4! 1905
I g97
2111XI
AMeps SS)0_ DeMcae(aNoA)) MAawnwpN=SSS)D| DMeeeni=SSO MAamnen (0S0O MDarenurN=7S9D) Mean was ae am we x us te ue wm wh aw I.g7
SI ) I.gt~
. .~(~a_!_u,r.!N =J!)~.
Mean
2.62=
1.7g
. A.~!W~.!rD.(_I~.-~_.55.) ......l_)~.:~_!~ir (N = .'i_:'i)
Mean
SI)
Me;In
SD
1.42
1.2fi
I.R5
I.M
^nlwer|~ (N=IOO)
Mean
SI)
I. 16
1.07
I')ecatur (N = 75) ..
Mea.
SI)
1.67~'
1.39
Was atm ase we Wr aa wr as 1.08
1.53
1.9~~
1.0fl
1.54
1.61
1.41
1.17
1.43
1.21
1.83"
!.53
Bem at am a an ae an a ad am 1.4~t,
1.77
3.(~'
1.77
I.gX
1.4X
2.17
1.76
1.74
1.24
2.3-I~'
1.72
Woe a wow ew om ww 0 3(,
{,.(,
43'~
32
6.8
4.1'i
7.3
.18
7,8
47~
7.0
Mw wr ow om ow mr a ow am me a 2~.~
2.4
~8.0'~
232
2.4
29. I'=
4..3
24.7
2.1~
2').0'l
4. I
Wow mw er ww ww wwe I. I'~
I. I
0.3
0.9'l
I.(1
O. I
O. I
I. I'l
1.0
(I. I
0.2
10 87 we ww sa we el oe mr ks I I J)
S.7
211.4~
7.1
7.0
5.2
I(|,0'1
6. I
9. I
ft. I
20.Y
8.5
47 ww 4 WB ww 217 sw" ne on ~4'~ 11 Wwe wm I I I nw we ow 72 woos ae ow 37 xn won 2~ Ww ne ox 44 0% 04 0s 02 (I.Q 0204 02 aw (I.2
7 43 13 7) I ~ 2~ I I I 7
0.4 0.4
I0~'
219 43 2~~ 103~ 47 31= 49
03 0.2
I
13 122 27 24 ] I
0.2 0.(H
sa 5 om us 202 wow 49" ms lOg ws 68 ona 23 xe 26 won 30 ow od 0.8I' of om 0. l)'
7 45 I i 53 15 I I
6 12 0.4
0.(!7
sow sow soon 5 woos om oa mw 214 a ws on uw 43 Wem om ow ws 181'~ EE g7'l
wom sow wow 33" w cs ow 1m 26 wos nou wou 32 wo ew wm ow ow 0.6 a 0M of wes 01 om (}. 1
10 35 I0 112 20 27
8 15 0.2
0.04
5 220 53'~ 131 5g 25 24 23
1.0')
0. I~
8 41 12 gO 14 19
7 I 1 (I.3
11.05
5 213 44 17g~" 74" 2() 25 32a
().~
0, I
II 411 I0 115 2 I 18
7 14 0.2 0.(}6
APCUS Mpedl pom a. p < .fl.S
h. p < .01
r. i) <
dpedl comomarsoci mycsoflemaceingsh.
_ozsez182 3M_M N02482182
11779999..00002200
Take. CosScio pis of Mem ndSand rifSeu OS, FOR. TO. ton vi Tabh." 2. ('nl~.~-.";cctional A,alysb; o1 Mean lind Standard I.)c.vhaion olScrunl I'FOS, I'I"OA, 1"( )F. Demi Tarts nde (ticsTee Sgro of ArteMorl ies 41) I)nlographk: ('h;traclerislJc.~ still ('li,fical { 'ht~lllisll'ies o1" Three Suhcro,lXS of Antwerp Male I]nlldO~ecs (A, I| mid (")
Pipl Tw BtMe Sora Eoin eee 195 208 Who I)illlicipated ill Two or Mol'C Medical .~l.lrveill;lllCe EX~lltlill;lliOlIS nelwel~n 1995 ;,rid
ws em ww 19o5
1997
21}0tl
AWE) NONE) AMZ) _CONEML_ AMZ) heey cove _A_.(_.N.~. 21_) .... !_l (N = 45) ........A,(.N_~.2_I)_.
C (N = 34)
A(N=21)
II (N=451
(? (N = 34)
Mew | Men Sb Men Sh Mew SO Men SD Mas SD Mem 5D Mean
Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD
os wom am am 26 mn wm i aw ma ow on 1.32
11.93
1.53. 11.87 1.211
1.31 11.87I' 0.7 I
mon ew le a7 am ea a en mw eo 2.2R
11.61
2.(16a 1.04 1. I 7
1.37 1.38 0.94
or Am Am dee am ee om as ss ww 1.59
I1.91
2.41= 0.81 I.Sg
1.51 1.52
11.89
a Woeoow 7 aw sw 7 ow oe oe 7 ow oa 5
7
38=
6
42"
7
32~
7
wi meow aw moa ow mow ww omy wow ou 2.8
2.O
24.3
3.4 25.5"
2.7 23.9
2.4
dy 03 ae es a2 2 er ex ra won ue 1.2
(1.7
1.7"
t.3
1.2
I.I
0.8
11.6
Conti 474 8s 7s 1 6 8 4 8 ss 7
6
8
4
8
5
8
BaiecYan 99 43 He @ ow ar 31 40 09 a me wn 40 4.3
5.3
4.9
9.9
4.3 I 1.6
6.3
5.3
4.9
WCohees w Wa mw me ww Mm Be ar Ww me 226' S$ nom om os 0 om om % wom ou ow on 51
Tipe 85 0 momo Ns @ wa mes aso 9s ws os 115 Mme ew on ow @ we om os om ow us on 67 aan FE EE 25 I x os 0% nm owm 0s ow 1 om sox 9 oa 211 wx e+ wom ow ow ow on oom won wow 7 31 Tllibe 003 0x 00 ox wor oe do mm ar we wm 11.8 Diatiiotin 02 an 02 ow 01 ois 02 am or om or ow oom O. I
511 9
69 19 I(1
5 12
11.3 0.1i5
187 dR 1(14 69 22 26 30
0.8 11.2.
34 II 41 12 II "
7 13 11.4 ll.01l
~29 56 123 55 23 , 22 22
1.0 O.l
46
233='
12
52
65
154
17
(~1
13
3If
5
25
II
25
11,3
1,0
0.03 (I. I
38
196
I I
52
95
105
14
58
25
19
9
23
13
21
1}.3 11.9
0.06 O. I
31 13 55 12 11 6 7 0.3 0.()6
aw_wozee218s 3M_MN02482183
11779999..00002211
veo MDW AmoMga"niWblCiel.aMaCciuwoB terrsne:SedcNtiaaTSonnDeosd!ltAecAMrdooiaNrCemfhSv eMmeMSiEedsaiahen)aseaSode STrCMhaevdweeNoecSnon I=ErvxaoSme i)sinDaotfoiDofinm eSsActMrtoewnMM ePaenRlOeS1SE) 29,Dn5s4PpsFiOnyABMc,ia0eNwsT0n(O04E,,e1)S1oDd C)sMCeawd)onSeOoSN I'F(IS
Table 3. ('ross-,~ol:liOllal A,ialysi,~ of Mean ;llid SI;itRl:lrd I)eviation of Scrum I'1~O,";, Pf;OA, TOF, I )en~q~raphic Characlcrislics and Clinical Clmmistries of Three SubgroLil)S of Decatur Male E,nl)h)yees (A, B and
Who I'articipaled in Two or Mol~ Medical ~urvoillance Examinalions Between 1994 and
1994
:, 1997
2(100
__ A_ (_N. ~_~(.1) ........B_(N = 2111 _
A .(N =.201 _
C (N = 35)
A (N = 20)
P, (N = 20)
Mean SI)
Mean SD
Mean SD
Mean SD
Mean SD Mean SD
2.07 I .(,7
3. I 3= 1.76
1.93
I.'/6
1.811
1.59
1.78
2.14 1.84
I.O3
c (N = 35)
Mean SD 1.51 0.98
won mA LM Le WB le M20 ede PFOA
1.50 {I.~7
2.30= I. 14
1.41
I. 16
1.41 : 1.20
1.46 1.34 2.60~ 2.112 1.60 1,14
Tor 0s ee 4m am um aw mo 26 2m 2m im am aw TOF
2.37 1.54
3.64~ !.79
2.22
1.78
~.14
1.78
2.16 2.16 2.9R
1.76 2.(1~
1.32
ne @ 1 Ms ow 7 oe aw 1 ows ows Age
42
7
44
S
45
7
42
8
48
7
511
5
45
8
wa Wa ow WW a me 4s me a Wan ma as BMI
28.2 4.0
27.7
~.3
28.3
4. I
29,6
4.5
28.9
4. I 28.7
3.3 29.3
4.5
mika 01 01 we ee ar me a2 a0 a ez oa wm me I)rinks/day
O. I (I.~
0.4
0.8
(1.1
ILl
ILl
0.2
O.11
ILl
11.2
0.3
(I. I
0.2
Cowes 60 W040 su 3m ws 40 Cigarelle~day 6
13
14
15
,I
10
5
I I
3
8
I11
15
aves 90 6. MA S2 We xe m2 We be 86 23 52 we mo Baseline Years 19.6 K6 Vocs Wo~ed
21.3
5.2
19.(;
g.6
2(|.2
10.()
19.6
8.6 21.3
5.2 211.2
IO.O
Qoesewt 3% WW % mw me wm ow wom a Cholesterol
235" 34
21H
36
223
3 I
208
37
228
39
199I'
33
212
4 I
ou wow wow uw 9 em woos HDL
47~
16
Tks 0 8m Ws Wns mow mm wo % ws om T~glycCride~ 180
8~
39
9
229
145
45
I I
IB8
115
41
9
178 " 112
47
12
.':18=
6
45
9
193
124 187
76
165
128
Mite mm wm ow ow om wm ow wm mom now ow AIk Plltls
98
29
1117
24
85
22
87
Ig
711
27
1~2
17
72
211
ar a x = om o o% ow ow wm wou on ow ow (;GT
41
25
52
22
35
36
31
20
29
16
34
2.t
27
17
st 2s 0m 6 x a om x om x om 4 3 1 AST
32
15
29
6
25
6
27
8
~Z6
8
25
4
25
7
nr sm 0 om wos x 6% wo uo ow ALT
52
Todliiakn 06 02 05 02 oe 02 0s a2 0s 2 01 or on 02 Total Ililirubia 0.6
c7iWannt 0m7 it00e5 r 02 0Mne Wo01man0k0 70m1 Mm6m"oi 0m a1 oor a1 om Direct Igillrubin (I.2=
33 0.2 (~.115
47
11
30
15
34 - 16
0.5
0.2
(I,fi
0.2
11,6
0.i
IL2
0.~
0. I
0,04
O. 1
11.05
30 0.8 O. 1
18
32
0.2 0.7
0.08 0. I
11
33
0.2~ 0.8
0.04 (I. 1
14 0.~ 0.06
amw o2eez184 3M_M N02482184
11779999..00002222
Tae 4 in Cen sine, Sd rs 5, -Yl sd95% Conre Lins 'l'abl~ 4. Mixed M~dl Co~fl'icicnl I.'.'Slhnal~s, ~landard Errors {SF.), P-Valu~ and 9.5% Confidence Limi|s TorTein Pac Dkmp ofCoatCage ong EOSmd mrs wih I'rOnl "l'csting Polcntial Determinants of Chol.qterol* Change Including PFOS and the [ntcr'-,ction with
mt oom of oto an elkEmp biumher of Years o1" Observation o[ Antwerp and Decatur Male Emp|oyccs
Pod
--C ----on 9955%f % Coi nfidd enceLe Liimmitin tss _c_e_
...a..s..............e.e...CK_o_c(.~fl'fliccieiilt en_____ SS!E~.
J as om Inteacep!
4.868
O. 12'7
ros uo os PFOS
O.(llO
VonOharviin oi ous Years Obwerv:,tion
0.(1009
0.005
PROS Vemone tos oz PFOS x Years Obs
- O.~H
0.1~)2
re aun os Age
O.(fi7
O.$)3
a oa ours BMI
0.(~6
().(~13
Dray one onz Dfink~day
0.014
0.012
Chetty oom oon Cigaretle~day
- 0.~9
0.(~ I
<ape.l~i-vwaltele. <~.0001 18 ".84 n.83 o.0 ! o.07 =n.27 @.41
lLoowweerr
wan4.618 om- 0.005 om - 0.008 oa- 0.0O4 aon0.002 "omes - 0.0005 "oon- 0.01 ! oon- 0.003
UpUpj2e1~rr
,.
ss5.118
ams0.025
aoe|1.010
oan0.003
aos0.013
ous0.013
ans0.038
aon0.001
Lo~caatti~iomn*
000.3(1344
0o.0m37
3.366
[-- ao ous Lm ~l~ Peri~)tl**
0.(164
0.028
.02
Bute vers oom aos Baseline Years
- 0.~
0,003
.20
TU
initirierismre sesseese rr--------------
tg *natural log "Ehsreyp)n *Antw~ vs Decatur
** 1994195 vs 1997
0- 0..003099
0O.. 110088
oo an 0.009
0.119
oom oon - 0.009
0.002
i----------eeSt--
swmczizes 3M_MN02482185
11779999..00002233
prCoemndy
"'rTaahbloleem 55..TMeMisniixneegddPMMeontd~eilellsCCDooeefefficeiiec,rIiEmeslnihonftnaCelehe,s,eSSnsalant.tndedasarnrdCFEhroraorrnss ((ISSnEE)c},,hPPi-n-VgVaaPlulFesOs Aanndadd9955h%%eCCoInnotfneifridadceetnnicco~en wLLiiilm,nhiitlss from Testing Numbeorf Yeof aOfscrrvatsion of Antwesrndp DecaturMaleEmployees I)olential D~terminanls of Cholesterol' Change Including PFOA and the Inlet'action with
Nnmber of Years of Ohsm'valion of Antwerp and Decatur Male Employees
95% ConfidenceLimits
95% Confidence Limila
merce InlorcepI
oo Cutien LS ............... .L.',..m.I_".fci__i_e!~I...... SI~.
am om ~1.812
O. 127
pie Lower Upper p-v:due Soon asa S061 < .{X}O!
Lower 4.561
Upper 5.063
Pron om om os oon oost PFOA Years Oscrvtion 0005. oms un "oom ou Years Ohserv~ilion
().O32 ILIX|5
0.0{F)
:
O.(X)5
.0~R~8 .24
0.013 - 0.004
0.0.5 I 0.014
PROAs Yet 0005 oo PFOA x Year~ Ohs
- 0.005
0.~12
0s.005
00- 0.009
--00.00e022
Ase
Age
Ba BM!
ves oon on 0002 oon O.008 on oon ou 000004 oon O.(l~i7
0.003 0.003
.007 .049
0.002 0.00004
0.013 0.013
Dinkekey ou oon Drinkshlay Cigmetesisy ~oo0r oon CilPtrelles/d:ty
0.014 - 0.01) I
0.012 0.(X| I
0 -o010 oor .263 -0003 oon .32
- 0.010 - 0.003
0.037 0.001
Locaicat oon [rd l..,Ocalion*
O.(H !
(I.037
n oan ons .27
- 0.032
O. 114
Boy ero oes oon Entry Period**
0.068
0.027
o oars om .01
0.015
O. 122
Basen Years 0001 oom Baseline Years Worked _ Worked
- 0.004
O.LR)3
as 000 oor .15
- 0.009
0.001
"*A*"nnAanaitntututorwrwaaulelerlslporovggv,psvseDD1ee5cc9aa7ttuurr
*'1994/95 vs 1997
_mozsc2188 3M_M N02482186
11779999..00002244
"Tle SA. MidModeCoffe time, Sand Ss (SE, Vals nd 95%ConfiLeicnes 'r-hie 5A. Mixed Model Coefficient F.stimates, Standard Errors {Sff-), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits To TestaPon Decminans of Ces Chnge locoPRO andteTrion I'ronl Testing Polcnlial Determinants of Cholesterol~ Change Including PFOA and the lnteraclion ih Number of YeasofOvation of Awe Mal Enpoyet with Number of Yca,~ of Observation of Antwerp Male Employees
rene
ere Coeamno lnterccpI Pron am PFOA Yorsomeran ous Yearn Ohscrvation OA Yamow oun PFOA x Ycm~ Obs
C,~fl~cicn! 4.7 l0 0.029 O.(g)5
- 0.(~13
neAge oarBM[ Dinky D~nk~y Gpsrtiny Ciga~tle~day BayPaes ~lry Peri~al** Buel Yeas B~elin Years Woh Work~
wn0.~ ow0.~g om0.022 own O.{XX)7 om0.0~9 oom - 0.(~2
wpa SF. oi <oor 0.149 wore o 0,012 oom PF 0.(~6 oun 0.{~)3 oun on 0.~3 ows u 0.{~5 oon 0.013 oun OAX~2 ous o 0:038
ao7r a 0.~
p-value < '.~l
.01 .36
.20 .~8 .14 .09
.70 .(H .67
ovCmdemctms 93% Confidence Limits
Lowe upp Lower
Upper
an S005 4.414
ao ass 0.~
0.053
om oor - 0.~ oom oan - 0.~9 ao o0te 0.~3, oom oo - 0.~3 ome oon - 0.~
0.017
0.~2 0.016 0.019
oom aor - 0.~3
0.~
oor wis 0.~
0.1'53
-000 oan - 0.Ol0
0.007
re "~nnaatluurmalllloogg.
-
**19~/95 vs 1997
woes 3M_MN02482187
11779999..00002255
"ble 1. Mixed ide Coeticen Fics, Sandiors (SE, P-Vlu nd95% Confidence Limi rd Table 5B. Mixed Model Coefficient Estimates, St=mdard Errors (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits roTeng Pct DermatofChurChange ncocding PROA aodthe traction wih fro,n Testing Polential Determinants of Cholesterol~ Change Including PFOA and the Interaction with NanberofYearsofOirvaion of Aner Sub A (1995, 199 nd 2000) ieEmployees Nt,mber of Years of Observation o1' Anlwerp Subgrm,p A ( 1995, 1997 and 2000) Male Employees 98% Confgece imis____ 95'$ Confidence Limits
j Company Page 26 of 63
= lniercepl pron
PFOA
Yeu Observation
Years Observation
PROAXYewsObs
PFOA x Yenrs Obs
ae Age i
Dinky Ddnks/,t~,y r-- Cigarettes/day Bseie Yeas Baseline Yeat~ Worked Worked
Coen C~efficient som5.059 oon0.044 00370.037 001) - 0.013 oo- 0.0007 am0.~4 ase - 0.(116 aos (1.003 ons 0.015
SESE
oan0.414
oon ().t)2t)
outs0.015
00s0.005
oo0.012
oon0.012
ao 0.019
i
ows (1.(XI5
aoe 0.016
pe p-value <ooor < .0001 on.03 .02 @.02 5s.95 n.77 ".41 st.5 i 3.36
Lows Lower a 4. ! 94 oom0.004 oon 0.007 00- 0.023 om - 0.025 oo - 0.020 -o0ss - 0.054 0007 - 0.007 oom - 0.018
Oper Upper sons 5.925 wos0.084 oor 0.067 002 - 0.002 ous 0.024 as 0.028 oom 0.023 0013 0.0 ! 3
000 0.047
tut og ~natural log
aw mozeez168 3M_MN02482188
11779999..00002266
ae
"Tlieo5,TesMtiinngedPMoodeell CDoeeftiecriemoniftCnehoa,ineSetaronsd ons (SF, P-Values and 95% Confidence ini Table 5(:. Mixed Mudl Cocfl'icicnt I~timales, Slandard EiTors (S]~), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limils l Change includingPROA and he licracion with I'rom Tcsling Polenlial Dclerminanls of Choleslerol~' Change Including PFOA and the lnleraclion wilh Numberof Year ofOvation ofAntwerp Subon B (199 0d2000) Mis pipes Number of Years of Observation of Antwerp Subgroup B (1995 and 2000) Male Employees oveComnenciins 95% Conlidcnc~ Limits
i CooficSeE n phe Low Ue (2~fl~cienl
SI.."
p-value
Lower
Upper
= ass 024 <oo0 a6 300 Interccpl
4.838
0.244
< 0.001
4.34fi
5.330
pron ors oor = -oois ous PFOA
" ' 0.018
0.017
.30
- O.0 i 6
0.052
YeasOberon 0005 ous 5 -oon oon Years Obscrvalion
(1.005
0,008
.55
- 0.0 ! 1
0.021
POA Yeon 0002 oom 0009 000s PFOA x Ye,'~rs Obs
- 0.002
0.004
.58
- 0,009
0.005
ae anos ams " 000s oars Ag
0.(XH
0.{X)5
.40
- 0.006
0.015
ma oon om n oom oon BM!
0.014
O./X)9
.13
- 0.004
0.03 I
Dinky oon oon as ous oor Drinks/day
0.O I 7
0.022
.45
- 0.028
0.061
re-- our oo " 000s oun Ciga~elle~dqy
11.002
0.003
.44
- 0.004
0.009
T BaselinB e Years rmammarms----ome-----------------oon--------oo-- n -- Ba~eliue Years Worked
- 0.11001
0,006
.99
- 0.011
0.01 I
raul 'natural log
aw moz4e2188 3M_MN02482189
11779999..00002277
"Tle SO. Misc Mode Coxicicn mse,Stand Fron (5,P-Vlos1d 95% Confidence Lis Ts Table 5D. Mixed Model Coefficieni Hstimates, Standard ~rrors (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limils om Teng Peat DekergatsofCholestrold Carpe Including PFOA edhe nein wih from Tesling Potential Delerminaals .f Cholesterolu Change Including PFOA and Ih Interaction with NaifYous ofOtervoaf AiwoenSuro C (191d2000) Mil Employes Number of Years ofObservali.n of Anlwe~p Subgroup C (1997 and 2000) Male Employees
95%Contre imi 95% Confidence Limits
oo comdew Se phe lee Ue C~x.'fficient
SH
p-wdue
Lower
Upper
Inert sm oan <a ass S100 lnlercepl roa * oan ww P ons om PFOA YonObernion -0010 om ~0s6s oom Ycam Obscrv-tion PoAxvamow 000 om o -oms ouss PPOA x Years Obs a aos om a ome ou Ag~ ma own oon o ais om BMI
4.528 0.004 - 0.010 O.OI0 0.016 0.009
0.28 I 0.062 0.026 0.022 0.006 0.012
< .0001
.95
.70
65 .01
.43
3.955 - 0.125
- 0.065
- 0.035
0.004
- 0.015
5.100 0.132 0.044 0.055
0.028 0.033
Drikatey oom am Fl om aio Drinks/d-y pssst "ooo oun = ow 00s Cigareltes/day
0,033 - 0.0001
0.032 0.003
31
-0.033
0.100
.97
- 0.007
0.006
w Bact Yous e ows .I om oon Baseline Yea~s ~~ Work
- 0.005
0.008
.49
- 0.021
0.011
murs log | ~natural log
w_wozue2190 3M_MN02482190
1177999..00002288
Tale. Mine ode Cocticen sic, Stand Eon (5, -Vlos nd 35% Confidence Limi Table 5E. Mixed Model Coefficienl Estimates, Slandard Errors (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits fmTsingPotcnil Determinants of ChkcterlChangs ocing PFOA and the ication wih from Testing Polcnlial Determinants of Cholesterol~ Change Including PFOA and the ]nteraclion wilh Numbeorf YeuofObservationofDecaturMak Employees Number of Years of Observation of Decatur Male Employees
osobCmfemelimts 95% Confidence Limits
i ern CofEiY dew 0S2E6 Intercqa von 006 one PFOA
Coefl~cien! 5.220 0.016
S ft, 0.206 0.016
puke p-value <o01 ,~ .0001 Mo.34
lewLower 50 4.810 oon- 0.017
Upper Upper sao .5.630 oon 0.048
YanObservaion +0002 Years Obscrv,qion
- 0.002
POA YenObs 0003 PFOA x Y~ms Obe
- 0.003
re oo Age ma oom BM! Drinks oss Drinks/day Cpmeetiy oom Cigarettes/day Buy Peis ov Entry Period** Busco Yeas 002 Baseline Years BE rstes Worked
0.002 0.003 - 0.088 - 0.002 0.047 - 0.002
om mn -oon ours (I.(X)8 oon 2 0000 oon 0.003 ous x er oo 0.005 oom ss -o0ns oon 0.004 ous on ois -oois 0.035 aon 1s oom oo (1.001 os u oon ois 0.040 --o--o ----------@ --------0--010--------0--006---- ().1)04
.77
- 0.017
0.01:3
.22
- 0.009
.0.002
.70
- 0.008
0.012
.55
- 0.006
0.011
.01
- 0.158
- 0.018
. [ 5
- 0.004
0.0007
.24
- 0.032
O. 125
.62
- 0.010
0.006
ott og ~natural log "1953s 1997 *'1994/9.5 vs 1997
aw_o2ez191 3M_MN02482191
11779999..00002299
Tae. Table 6.
from
Mido PMot iCotint cs, SdEenSE F-A35%Cconfs Mixed Model Coefficie,! I~slimales, Standard Errors (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Krof Go olAhyreo s eitio aTn OkFEwdos os T~tiag Potential Detem)inanls of Cholesterol* Change Including TOF and the lnleraction
LiteLimits
with
isos . Company
P~g 30 of 63
Number of Years of Oh~rvalion or Anlwerp and Decalur Male Employees
ec
J as am Inlercepl
CodfceSmH Ct~l'ficien!
SI~.
4.828
0.127
or om om TOF
0.02 I
Voronin 004 aos Year~ ObservaliOll
O.O(H
O.IX)5
pe p-value
om< .l~01 =on.37
---- 955%%CCoonfindenfceLiLiimmdiitssence
ewe Lower
asm4.577 ao0.006 ows- 0.t~)5
Ups
som5.079 aos0.035 aone0.014
"TTOOFF xx YYeeaarrssObs. * -000,00033
00.000011
3:
.007
-000.00055.
000.0000033.
~~ aon ous o oon ours Age
0.007
0.003
.0 I
0.002
0.013
a ao aos o oor oon BMI
0.006
0.003
.05
- 0.0001
0.013
Donny oon aon = oz ans Drinks/day
0.012
0.0 i 2
.32
- 0.012
0.036
Comets om aor n om oon Cigarettes/day
- 0.001
O.(,q) I
.37
- 0.003
0.00!
Loaion aoe - 2 ons2 ans Location*
0.042
0.037
.26
- 0.032
0.115
[-- oss ou aon an Enlry Peri(~l**
0.063
0.027
.02
0.010
0.|!7
Bates ome aos on oz BWaosrekle iende Yeae ts e-s01}--04------------0.--003--------------.17---------------0.0-- 09 ------------0.0--02------
iArrrceoDe)s annaattuurraull lloogg .
*Antwerp vs Decatur *'1994/95 vs 1997
swmcziez 3M_M N02482192
11779999..00003300
TTaubblreeo66mAAT,e. tiMisnixgeeddPoMMeooncdtakillCCDooe~stfeltircmiieinnntansI~tsitiomtfaCeteh,s.oSStta,an,elddaa"rdCBhEarrnrrogsres ((nSSIE~).),,dPP--VVaiTalluOueesFsnaaannndddgt99e55%%nCCoenoofnifciddoeennnccweeiLLthimiists
fi'om
Testing
NumobfYeearr ofObcrvation Potential Det,~rminants of Cholesterol~ Number of Years of Observation
of Aner Mole Employes Change Including TOP and the
of Antwerp Male Employees
Interaction
with
95%Confidence Limits
95% Confidence Limits
eo Cofelew Coefficienl
Spe SI~.
p-value
lows Lower
Umer Upper
ree Intercept 108
TOF
am oso <o001 aan sons 4.'/21 oon oon 2 -0004 oo 0.017
0.150 0.011
< .O001 .12
4.424 - 0.004
.5.018 0.038
Yours Observion 004 rd Years Obscrvalion
O.t104
O.lXI7
5 -000 oon .55
- 0.009
0.017
TOFxYewsObs -00008 oo TOF x Years Obs
- 0.0008
0.002
TM -oc0s oo .70
- 0.005
0.003
ABa 00000 00000s6 aoa -o00002z ooootm6 BMI Dinkatay oo ois " -o06 ots Drinks/day Cigetesiny 0000s. oon -0003 000s Cigarettes/day
O.(X)9 0.009 0.019 0.0008
0.003
.0 i
0.006
.12
0.013
.14
0.002
'.
.69
0.002 - 0.002 - 0.006 - 0.003
0.016 0.020 0.045 0.005
Bey Periods Entry Period** Belin Years Baseline Years Woded Worked "natura log ~naluml log "IUDvs 1997 **1~4/95 vs 1997
oon 0.070 "ooo - O,O(k)g
oo o -0006 ous 0.038 oon0 5s 0009 0008 O.{X)4
.07
- 0.006
O. 145
.85
- 0.009
0.008
_o2ee2193 3M_MN02482193
11779999..00003311
bl 1. Mined Mil Coin art,Sand rors (SE), P-Vls1nd 95%Confidence Livi Table 6B. Mixed Model Cocfficien! l~limates, Slandard Errors (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits rom Teng Pena DekrmofiCvalnsrsl Chinge IcTiOFnsndghe ection with from 'l~sting Po!ential De.tcrminanls of Cholesterol~ Change Including TOF a~i the Interaction with Norra YousofOierovfDaeis oMinse Eploycs Number of Ye=n~ of Observation of Deca!ur Male Employe~a 95%Conitece Lin. 95% Confidence Limils
Fn Company
Page 32 of 63
-- co .......................
nerIntercept onTOP YanObvsion Years Observalion TORxYenob ]'OF x Years Obs aeAge BatBMI Drntasy Drinks/day Cmte Cigamues/day Buti Yeas Bl~eline Yem's J Worked rag Jnatural log per *'!994/95 vs 1997
Coelfiew _.(.'.~Im'__fi_c_e_!~!
sau5.214 "oom0.014 0002 - 0.002 0m - 0.002 oon0.002 oun0.002 00m - 0.090 oo- 0.002 om- 0.002
SSEE
om0.202
oon0.01 !
ooos0.008
oo0.0(12
oms0.005
wos0.004
:
oms0.035
oan0.001
oom0.004
pee p-value
aon < .000 I .19 .'/9 a.22 .69 ss.55 az.012 0.16 ! ".60
aanLloowweer
4.gl I
om - 0.007 oom-0.018 ome 0.006 os - 0.008 ms -0.006 -oi0 -0.160 ou- 0.004 000 -0.010
UppUer pper
sss5.616 oouosn0.013 omni0.001 oon0.012 oan0,01 l -aomsoe - 0.020 aos0.006
w_wozue2108 3M_M N02482194
11779999..00003322
PaeCs omey .i CUliillliny
Page 33 of 63
Table 7. Mined Mase Coli: Emacs, Standard Fors (SE) P-Yaloesad 95% Confidene Lins Tal)lc 7. Mixed ldodcl Cocl'ficicn117.sli,ilales, Standard Errors (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits fromTingPotential Detrminantosf DL"ChangeInding PROSadthe neracion wilh from Testing Potential Determinants of HDL# Change Including PFOS and the Interaction with anesofYeas ofObservation of Antwerp snd DeMacleEmoploryes Number of Yc;u,'s of Obscrvatitm of Anlwerp and Dccntur Male Employees
95%Confidence Limits
95% Confidence Limits
Costin (?oefficienl
siSI~
patie
Lower
UUppppeerr
[)-viihie
Ttereep an oa <oon 39% aos lntercepl pros "ooo ooo a -o0 oor PFOS
4.212 " - 0.010
0.144
< .O001 .24
3.930 - 0.026
4.495
Year Otservaion 0002
woos
a
~0008
oz
Year~ Olisel'Vlil iilli
0.(1()2
.71
0.012
PROS AYews Obs 0001
oz
2
-000s
0002
o 0.005
0.00_.2
ree 001 00s 2 -00n oon Age
II.(~
.22
- 0.002.
0.0! !
EY on oom <oo01 os 0010 BM! Drinkany ost oon <on oom oo Ddnk~day
- 0.017 0.~
0.013
< o00OI <
- 0.025 0.037
0.010 0.090
Lr--" Cigarelte~day
ot - O.{g~
oon0.~ I
ows .0005
-00m - 0.007
-0002
- 0.002
Locaion
EePros Efllry Perilldi* Bsc Yous webes Baseline Ycar~
Wo~ed
ne*nAaantttumwuelrlIyoo~gva Decatur 99495 v3 *Antweq) vs 1991
** t9~95 vs 1997
0006
ous 0.025 0007 - 0.~7
aon .89
[ La 0.032
.44
oon o 0.~3
.O3
"oom- 0.079 oss - 0.038 -oon3 - 0.013
oot 0.091 oss O.Og8
~00005
- 0.0005
_Mo24g2195 3M_MN02482195
11779999..00003333
TTaublbetfe8r8.oo,mmMMTTiiexsxseeitddiNnnMgMgoooPPmddoeeeteerlnCCioteiofalflYilDDe'cfeaieicrttioseeenrrnomtmtfiiEEnnOsaastn,itltmtcssactoo,effr"s,HHvSSDDtLaoaaLnnfd'dtCAaCahnrihnadtanwoEEngegrrenrreooprIssncc((llSSuEiEdD))nie,,ncggPPaP--tPVuFVFaraOlOluMAoAeassakananndnEdddmthhp99ee55l%%oIInenCtCceaoroscnantfcfitdiidooeennrncwwcieeiLtthLhiimnists Number of Years of Ohservalilln of Aniwe,'p and Decatur Male Employees
Comper Company Pats Page 34 of 63
= Inlercepl
Ce Coen 12ocl'ficient__ 216 4.216
sn pve _.qF. ......~p-value
ous <oo01 (). 1,15
~,0001
95% Confidence Limits 95% Confidence Limits
Lover Up Lower
Upl~r
39 aso 3.929
4,.503
Poa PITOA
"oom " - (1.006
aontl.(ll I
0 ..'i6
-o0m - 0.027
ons
0.0
Years Oerviion 000s aos Years Ollsl~rvllliun POA Yeon 0002 on Pl'q~li~. i ~Ciil-,,,l Ohg
11.011.5 - 0.002
I}.lltl$ I1.1102
3{35
~- o0.s0u0s5
oon 0.014
" -000 0002 .40
- 0.006
0.002
re oon oon EY 00m oo Age
0.004
0.003
.28
- 0.003
0.010
aBM1
Drinking Drinks/day
Cigreteiay Cigarelies/day Locaioat Localim~* EyProds Enlry Period**
WBBaaesseeelliindnee
Years
Years
WorEed
"nao. ~natural lug *Antvery vs Deca *Antwerp ~sDe~alur "198495 v8 1991 *'1994/95 vs 1997
~o0 ooo <oo01 - 0.017 [rs oun pr 0.tgl2
0.(104 0.013
< .0001 < .(RIO I
"0004 . - 0.1}(H
oun oo 11.1101
~
.00(14
oo aon ss O.i~g
0.043
.g5
oom oom 5 0.02~
0.032
.53
000o 7 ous T o - 0.007
0.003
.04
oom - 0.024 ook 0.036
"010 - 0.010 ons 0.088
~oom
oom
- 0.007
-
00% 009 - 0.076 000 oom - 0.042
0.093 0.082
--o00n .01133 T -000.0000044
_Mo24s2196 3M_M N02482196
11779999..00003344
eoemasn
"TTaabbllee r99..omMMTieixssetcidnMgMa~cPleeo!leCCnoaocelffifDcicieieeenntrtEEmsstiliin~mnaaattleoesfss,,HSSDalanLnddaCarhrddaEEnrrgreoorssI((nSSEEc)),,lPPu--TVVdOaaliuleanssnsgdannddth99e55I%%nCtCoenosfntifiiddneennwccieethLLiimmiitlss
from
`Niamber ofYeas of Otevain of Aver and Dect Male Esplayees Tesling Potential Determinants of HDL~ Change Including TOF and the Interaction Number of Years of Ohservation of Anlwerp and Decatur Male Employees
with
ooo MCoudemclmis 95% Confidence Limits
Coen SE Coel'licienl
__SL;
phe p-value
lLoowwer
UmUpeperr
Intercept
aan
ous
<ooor
3s
aso
Intercept
4.217
0.14.S
< .0001
3.931
4.502
Tor.
TOP
0006 oo; " "00m 0010 "- 0.006
0.(xi8
:
.44
- 0.023
0.0 i 0
YearsObscrvion
Years Ohservalion
TOPxYeurObs
TOP x Yem's Obs
AeAge aaBMI
0004 0.004 -usom - 0.(R)(F)
004 0.004 "oon - 0.O 17
[ 0.(XI5 oonO.(N)I
oon O.(XL3 ooo 0.0(H
a
.47
El
as.2.5 <oo0r
< .000 I
oor - 0.007 "oom- 0.004 oom - 0.003 -- o0.m02s5
oo 0.014 0002 0.002 0010 0.010 "- 00.00100
Dinkainy 00a on pr [rd 008 Drinks/day
0.063
0.01 ~
< .0001
0.037
0.089
Cetestiay oom oor Cigarelles/day
- 0.004
0.001
005 -0007 .0005
- 0,007
0002 - 0.002
Locaions 07 oo Localion*
0.007
0.043
- -oom 002 .88
- 0.078
0.0'92
BatyPros oon oon oo os l~nlry Period** Baseline Vu on oun on -oon ~00001 Baseline Years 0 Woe Worked
0.021 - 0.(RI7
0.032 0.003
.50
- 0.041
0.084
- 0.013
- 0.0004
"~*nAnanatiuavraenlrllpoovggsDecatur "199455 ve 1997 *Antwerp vs Dc~:atur
3!.
**1994/95 vs 1997
_ozse2197 3M_MN02482197
11779999..00003355
iceompsar Page 36 of 63
"TTaabbfrill~oeemm1I00T3..e~sMsMiilinnnixgge~dPNPMooMotlcuocdndtelieilamalColCDDfoeoYeeselcfaefrtrirmcisicinnntoaf!nOIl~bsctsloioimcfmlr"aTaFvilrt~etiegisg,,loynySnSccoactea~fnnnaddddAeaan~"rtsCdw~hEEeaarrrnsrnpooggrassced((IISnSnDIcE~eel).luc,cadPPit-in-nuVVggraalPiPluueFRsesOOslaSSanEnadnmdnpdd9l55ott%h%yeeeCeCInonsinoteefnrrifaiaddcceetinniooccnneewwL~iiLm tihhisls Numl~r of Years of Observation of AnI~=? and ~atur Male Employees
9955%% CConofnifiddeennccee LLiimmiittss
ree lnlerccp! pros PFOS
Cen SE Cocfficicn! 210 ons 2.730 ons aon O.1|25
0.335 0.(|2(!
pe <o.o00o0n1
<
2
low Lower 20682.068 "ons -0.015
Ups Upper am 3.392 oss 0.065
Yours Years
Oervaion Obsc~alion
- 00..0(0~4
ons 0.O 13
PROS Yan
0006
ous
PFOS x Years Obs
0.~6
n "om oa .73
- 0.029
0.02 I
2.22
--o00.00044
ois 0.015
AAgee
oon0.(~3
oo0.~)8
@.~7
~- o0.o0n111
ois 0.01g
MBMiI
000.0(~6
oo0.~9
<oo01
ous
<
0.048
oss 0.083
Drinksay ons am = 0094 os D~nk~day Cipmetesiny oan oon oo 000s oon Cigar~lle~day Locatont oz 009. 01 020 ~ati=~n* Bay rots ans om -00ss 02 FJ~I~ I~riod~* Bsc Years 00s oon = -oo10 oa Baseline Ymtrs J Worked
- 0.029 0.011 0.052 0.089 0.(~15
0,033 0.~)3 0.0~D 0.073 0.~7
.37 .0002 .~0
,50
- 0.094 0.005
- 0.143
- 0.055
- 0.010
0.035 0.017 0.247 0.234 0.019
~"*"4nAAs1antanu9ttrrww9aalec4prl~o5y.gvvv5ssDD1ee9cc9aa1ttuurr
** 1994/95 vs 19~
_mozse2198 3M_MN02482198
11779999..00003366
_--Intercept
PFOA
I Lulill)a|iy rage 37 of 63
T Se L 'Fahle I I, Mixed Model Coefficiem [Lslimales, Standard Errors (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits LL fn)m Te.~ling Polential Determinants ofT,'iglyceride~ Change Including PFOA and the Interaction with
blumbcr 0f Years of Observation of Antwerp and Decatur Male Employees
-- 95% Confidence Limits
eileen Coefficient
t,;E
p-value
Lower
Upper
TT. 2..539 wm mw. 0.094
0,332 0.025
<!.0001 .0002
1.883 0.045
3.196 0.144
Years Ob~rvalion
O.IX)7
0.012
.57
- 0.017
0.03 I
ramon mm PPOA x Years Obs
- 0.008
0.005
.12
- 0.018
0.002
- me cms on wm - Age
BBMMII
0.006
00.006666.
,0.007
:
000.00099 !
.42
<<..00000011
- 0.009
000.04499.
0.021
00.008833
-- ww. Drinks/day
- 0.027
0.032
.40
- 0.090
0.037
oP Cigarelles~day
0.011
0.003
"
.0002
O.005
0.017
_------m am - Location*
0.072
0.0{)6
.46
- 0.118
0.262
mS Entry I~i-iod* *
0.1198 .
O.070
.17
- 0,041
0,236
mma mm Baseline Years
0,003
0.007
167
- 0.011
0.017
Worke ed c--------------------------------------------
ah "naturallog
';4'|tJ94)tJ.s vs I~J'/
3M_MN02482199
11779999..00003377
Tle 11A. Mixed Model Coefiin titsSida iors (SE), P-Vsnad95l%Coonficdensce Limits 'l'ahle 11A. Mixed Model Ceefficien! IL~!imales,!Slandard Errors (SE), P-Value~ and 95% Confidence Limits fro Towing Pte DetermofiTniagnetr!s ChangeInccing PFOAand he Inicrscion with fi-om Testing Potential Determinanls ofTriglyceride' Change Including PFOA and the Interaction with Numbeorf Yeof aOhirrvalson of Antwer Mle Employes Number of Ye.'u~ of Obse,'valion of Antwerp Male Employees 95%Confidence Limits 95% Confidence Limits
ras
p--ren lnlcrcept
ProPFOA Yen Oeovtion Years Olk~rvali,m PROArYenObs PFOA x Y~ars Obs neAge aBMI Drinkstny Drinks/day Cipmecsny Cigarel~es/day
Cafe Sw Coefficient 067 om 3.(167
"oo ow 0.089 -00402140 oooatns 0.024
Sl! 0.394 0.030 0.Ill 5
oniz{L012 ms O.I)39 om - 0.026 oon 1~.01R
oom 0.1)09 oo0.014 ous0.033 oatsO.OOS
pwp-value <a<..000 I os.005 ans.12 .22 wn.007 ".44 oon .0004
owLower 226 2.286 oon 0.028 0006 - 0.006 00s - 0.023 0007 - 0.00"7 oon0.011 om - 0.092 oun 0.008
UweUpper 3s 3.g4g 0149 0.149 0053 0.053 000s 0.004 oom 0.030 006s 0.068 oot 0.040 ous 0.028
Boy Perit oor 0100 Entry Period** Pascoe Yeas omy oon Baseline Years Nowe 7". Worked stun log 'natural log 2195408v 1997 *1994/95 vs 1997
O.013 0.003
0.100 0.011
0 -o2n ois - 0.212
0.186
6 Oo~o0"19 002 .76
- 0.019
0,026
:
M_No24E2200 3M_MN02482200
11779999..00003388
"TTaohlbrceomI11I1lT.ls. iMMniigxxeePddoMMc(oo~dleellDCCeooteesfrffmiiciiincnaantltslF[tosftiimmTaaleeys.s,,rSStteannd"daasrCddhaBFmnr'gooer.sq (n(S5cE1l))o,,ciPPn--gVVPaalFluoOessAaanandndd99t55e%%CICononenfrfaiicddteeinnoccneewiLLtiihmmiitss `Numberof Year ofObservation of Atver Subgsoup A (1995, 19aod920070) Make Employees from Testing Polenlial Delerminanls of'l'riglyclidej Change Including PFOA and the Int~raclion wilh
Number of Years of Observalioq of Anlwcrp Subgroup A (I 995, 1997 and 2000) Male Employees
95% Confidence Limits
95% Confidence Limits
ad Page 39 of 63
tree Intercq)l pron PFOA YeusOmervion Years Observulion PROAx YeusOls PFOA x Yca,'s Obs AeAge a
BMI
Drinkadey Ddnkdday
Cgmetesiny
Cigareltes/day
WBBaaesseellbiinneeeYYeeaoarrss Worked
Coden ator
3.104
om
O. 182
0167 0.167 0061 - 0.061 "0007 - 0.007 oom0.039 oom - 0.082 000s0.008 00%0.036
SBSI~. 1063I .{X)3 oust 0.051 [ 0.037 oon0.011 oon0.031 omo 0.030 00st0.051 oo2 0.012 oonO.PAI
pee _p-value on .009 or~001
pr< .0001 <r < .0001 .83
x.20 ".12 =.52 ".40
lLoowweer oss0
0.880
ooo.
0.079
oo0.091 -00m - 0.084 006 - 0.069 "oom - 0.O21 "os - 0.186 oon - 0.017 | oon - 0.049
Upe Upper E5.328 02s 0.286
oan0.241 "oo - 0.039 o0s6 0.056
00 O. 100 oom 0.023 oon
0.O33
ono 0.120
nalmal lloogg
_o2se2201 3M_MN02482201
11779999..00003399
"Tle 11C. Mined Mode oer Fnac, Smid ros (SE). P-Vnd i95%lConfoidensce Lit "l'ablc I I C. Mixed Madel Cocl'ficicnt I'.'stimaLes, Standard F.rro,~ (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits ro Tesin Pain Decrinas of Higheen:Chane cainPFOAand he krncion wilh I'rom Tcsling Potential D~terminanls of Tdglyeeride" Change Including PFOA and the Interaction with Noerof Yeh ofOsrvationof Aster Sgro, 159 snd2000MuleEyes Nomher o[ Years of Observ:dion of Antwerp Subgroup B 11995 and 2000) Male Employees
sto
nee oo Intercepl Fron PFOA [ER Year~ Observation POA Yerobs PFOA x Yeln's Obs neAge maBM ! Denke DHnk~y Cipuetcusy Cigm~ttc~d~y Bate ves Ba~li~ Years J Worked aug #natural log
Gemew fficion! ams2.77.5 oon0,097 ----0.005 oun 0,0008 oars0.019 I0.~2 ome0.038 ry0.022 oom - 0.~2
spe S E osm0.523 omI).038
,,
vonI).01 ~ oun 0.009 oan0.01 I oa0.019 oso 0.050 oon0.1X)7 oo0.012
loe smCasenuetmine is lEy_alue ooo mm amo ,~ .(KX)I oo om .02 " om won .~11 oon oo .93 ator oon . I0 wPn"yn o0oo0ooomm2 oooooomnns .45
95% Confidence Limils
L~wer
Upper
1.720
3.830
0.019
O. 17/4
- 0.033
0.042
- 0.017
0.018
- 0.004
0.04 I
0.003
0.08 I
- 0.062 O.00g
0.138 0.036
- 0.026
0.021
w_woze2202 3M_MN02482202
1177999..00004400
AComny M Compaay . Fenn Page 41 of 63
TTaabbflflieei'oom1ImIDTNTD.ue.esrMlMiiiinenixgxreePPoddfoeMlMeYnneeoatadiealrelsloDDCCfeoOoteebeflmsftieic~riicvecnJaaltnlritIEsoLmoniosftfnoiTfimTeriaAisntgtel,lswya,eecSSertrntrpaaindnseddS~aaurrbCCddghhraEaaonnnouoggprreesCIo((nS(SccEE1l)u9l),,9du7iPPang--gnVVdPPaa2FllFu0OuOe0ssAA0na)aandMnnddda99ltt55hhe%%eeEImICCnpnotolaennorfcafyiticedditeeeioonnsnncceevwiLLitliihhmititss Number of Years of Observalinn of Anlwerp Subgroup C (1997 and 2000) Male Employees
9955%% CCoonnffiiddeennccee LLiimmiittss
so Ie Intercepl pron
PFOA
Coffeen SG Coefficient aus 0104 3.285
0.744
[= oo 0.032
O. 149
phe p-value 001.0001 5 83
loLowwesr 11.776690 0am - 0,280
Ue Upper sor 4.80 I ou 0,344
Yeus Observation Years Observation PROACYemOm PFOA x Yea~s Obs TMAge.
aBMI Drinkatey
Drinks/day
Ciguencsiy Cigarelles/day
-0072
- 0.072
000 0.020 ~ovos - o.tX~5
0057 0.057 00s - 0.025 oo0.019
oa 0.063 ost 0.05 woe o.OI 6
oo0.030
ost 0.08 I ous 0.t)08
x om ooss 26
- 0.203
0.0.58
En -o087 ois .70
- 0.087
0.128
nn oss ons 77
- 0.038
0,028
= -0008 om .08
- 0.006
O. 120
a6 0195 ous 76
O. 195
0.145
os 0002 [3 .032
0.002
0.036
WBBoaasdseeleliidnnee YYeeaarrss
oom 0.010
oot0.02 I -- 5655 SE
003 - 0.034
00 0.053
Worked
"nauni ~natufal lloogg
_Mo24e2203 3M_MN02482203
11779999..00004411
Tle 1, Med Mod Coitns, SmsGE.P-Vd5i% Ciodsec is Table I IlL Mixed M=glel Coefficieqt F.sfimales, Standard Errors (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits Toso Pacm Doa o Ther nnd Cha e hc Fe RaO to ih front 'l'esling Potential Determinanls of "l'riglycerid~ Change Including PI~)A and the Intcraclion with of Se el ores Number of Years of Ohservation of Decatur Male Employees
Fas M Company
Page 42 of 63
-- J Inlercepl
2m aser oo Co{?nutefificcimefnl __ oSis ~,
2.581
0..%7
<app-vaalluee
< .000 I
9955%%CCoonfindenfceLiLiimmdiittsse_n__c_e_
woower L~)wcr
1.450
sz UpUppeperr 3.712
PFPOFOAA.
OAsYam Years Ohservation
PFOA x Years Obs
00.005s4
---- - 0.028 um0.~2
000.14~66.
wz0.022 ous0.1~8
224
-- 000.03377
oun ans .20
- 0.071
= oot aon .85
- 0.014
o02e14s5
0.015 0.017
Ase
a ours wr, om oso aon BMI Dray om am ass ass Drinks/day Pr oons I " ao aon Cigarettes/day [-- om om o aos am Entry Pe,iod** Bete ves aon ont " aon oo ed Baseline Years
Worked
ration #natural log eon *'!994/95 vs 1997
-00.0.0~088
0.073 - 0.038
0.~5 0.274 0.~9
Oo.Oo1n3
0.o!2 ~
0.0~)
-~.
0.~
O. 109
0.011
9.9s5
< .~1 .70 .I 6 .01 .44
-- 000.02288
0.050 - 0.235 - 0.002
0.058 -0,013
00.002266
0.096 0.1.58 0.012 0.491 0.030
scan 3M_MN02482204
11779999..00004422
PCiunasn Page 43 of 63
"l'aTfuhrlloeem112T2..esMMtiiixnneegddPMMeoonddaeell CCDooeefefffnicinineinsnl aEFn.ssatoismftaTtresisl,SyStctaaennrdddaaerr'ddECEhrxaToonrsgse((SSIEEc)).i,dPPi--nVVagalTluuOeessRaaannnddd99:5t5h%%e ICCnootnenfrfiaidcdeteinnoccneewLLiim hiists from Testing NumobfYeearrs ofObucvof Aantwierop anndDecatur Male Employes Polenlial Determinants of Tdglyceride~ Change Including TOP and the Interaction with
Numl~r of Years of Ohscrvalion of Antwerp and Decatur Male Employees
95% Confidence Limits
95% Confidence Limits
= Intercept Tor
TOP
E--
iCucflicicnl 2002 2.612
"ous 0.053
suSV
~
oa0.334
aon 0.020
pase p-value <o001
< .0001
~AX)8
Lover Lower
1953 1.953 oo0.014
Upper
Upper
am 3.272 00m 0,093
YearsObservation ~00005.
ons
Yeur~ Obscrvalion
- 0.0005
0.013
= oom [3 .97
- 0,027
0.026
TOFxYesObs -00005
0004
TOF x Years Obs
- 0.0005
0.004
a -ooos 0007 .91
- 0,008
0,007
Ase 0004 aor El ~oi0 oo 0.(~H
0,007
.57
- 0.010
0.019
0 00s 0009 <.o001 oo oom 0.066
0.009
< .0001
0.049
0.084
Drinkadey oom [3 Drinks/day
- 0.03 i
0.032
Er oom .34
- 0.095
0.033
Cigmetesiny wont oa 002 000s oon Cigarelles/day Locuiont oom om as om 026 ~tion* Ey cits ooms om 2 ass 02% EnlW I~riod Basel Years 0004 0007 8 0010 oom B~line Yea~ 2 Worked
O.011 0.074 0.085 0.004
0.003 0.098 0.(171 0,007
.0002 .45 .23 .58
0.005 - 0A 19 - 0.055 - 0.010
0.017 0.266 0.226 0.018
ae+Ansnalttuwraaelrllpooggv,s Decale 19945 v3 1997 *Antwerp vs ~catur
**1994195 vs
_Mo2462205 3M_MN02482205
11779999..00004433
le 12. itd ecso soSnbBr 5, abs nd 5% Cotes iis "rahlc 12A. Mixed M(~I Coefficimll Estimates, Standard Brrom (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limils on king Pac] TeChg Pea TOF ste ih fi'om 'l'csling Polcqdnl Determinants af Triglycerid~ Change Including TOP and the Interaction with nes ooo sn pe Wis Number of Yeqrs of Observation fiw Antwerp Male Employ~s [-- 95% Confidence Limils
Co
re Intercept rorTOF YasOvrion Years Observation TOF Yano TOF x Years Obs -Age aBMI Dinter Drinks/day Cimetsey Cigareltes/tlay Byres Entry Period** baton Baseline Years
Coomcem Coefficient
sus3.078 oss " 0.053 00160.016 0000 - 0.0007 oun0.009 ose0.042 om- 0.032 oars0.018 ats - 0.045 on0.007
SB~;1~.
as0.395 aon0.028 an0.017 aos0.0[~6 ao0.009 aoO.014 oon0.034 ones0.{X)5 on0.101 oon0.011
puke pvalu
om< .00O I -.0~ xs.35 .90 =.32 oom0.004 .34 as.0005 .66 Ls.56
low Lower
202.294 oz - 0.002 oars- 0.018 oz - 0.012 own - 0.009 anne0.014 wom- 0.099 I0.008 ois- 0.245 ome - 0.016
UpUpeperr
21623,862 -0.107 oo0.049 oom0.010 -0.028 om0.071 oiss0.~35 ao0.029 oss0.155 oom0.029
EWH oAedeeersnereesemmeser :m eataersmme mmniS reriiiPA n emperet mere
for #*nnaattumc'ialllologg.
'
**1994P-~5 vs 1997
cain 3M_MN02482206
11779999..00004444
"Tl'aabbllreo11m22B.Te. sMMtiiinnxgeePddoMMonodtdesell CCDooeeeffficfkicincul iEseotinfmTtarsteg,sh,cSSettaannndddeaa"rrddChEEearrrnoogrress ((cSSEE)),,lPP--VVaaaTlluuOeeFssdyande9955%% ICConnocfnaifcidideoennnccweeiLLihimmititss
from
Testing
NuYmeasbof Otecrvarton or Desatar MaleEmployees Potential Determinants of Triglyceridee Change Including TOP and Number of Years, of Ohservation fi~r Decalur Male Employees
the
Interaction
with
HY Company
I'agc 45 0f63
omcodecclmis 95% Confidence Limits
ners Inlercepl Tor
TOF
Coen Coefficient 200 2.644 oa0.031
s0SE ser 0.563 [ 0.030
pe p-value <oo0n < .0001 .29
leer Lower on1.521 os - 0.028
per Up.per ans 3.766 oom 0.090
Year Otvervation 0435 om ow om own Years Observation TORxYamon 0u04 00s s oom oois TOF x Years Obs Ase 0002 oo om ons Age Ba ou oz <tr 0050 0010 BM! Drinslday 0000 0099 7% oz 0166 Drinks~day r-- 000s oon 0003 oon CigarItem/day
- 0.035 0.004
- 0.002 0.073
- 0.030 0.005
(I.022
0.005
:
0.014
0.012
0.099
0.004
. ! 2~ .45 .90 < .0001 .76 .20
- 0.079 - 0.007 - 0.029
0.050 - 0.227 - 0.003
0.009 0.015 0.025 0.010 0. ! 66 0.019_
Ear Periods oars om Entry Period** Basco Yeux am aon Ba~:liae Ycah~. Woke Worked "anus og enatural log "15a 1997 **1994195 vs 1997
0.275 (I.O~F~)
O. I 11 0.01 I
on ooss oa .01
0.055
0.494
" --- 03 oso .44
- 0.013
0.030
aM No24E2207 3M_MN02482207
11779999..00004455
"Tl 13. MixedModel Coffin mats, Sandu iors(SE).P-Vlues nd 95% Confidence Limits Table 13. Mixed Model Cocfficien! Estimales, Standard Errors (SE], P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits from Tesing Peis Decinoaf ArlkatlisnePhosphate! Che lingPROS nd he nation wih from Testing Polential Determinants of Alkaline Phosphatase~ Change Including PFOS and the Interaction with
Numberof YeasofObcrvation ofAntwerpsnd DecMaaeEimpluoyres Numl~r of Years of Observation of Antwerp and Decatur Male Employees
ard 1 Company
~ge 46 of 63
95%Confidence Limits
95% Confidence Limits
sneer rs ]nlerccpl pros
PFOS
Yeas Observation Years Observation
fee Coefficient am3.789 om 0.002 -0051 - 11.051
SESE aim 0.176 oun O.(R~) ouO.(RJ6
phe p-value <tr < .0001 n.87 <0 < .O00l
lows Lower saz 3.442 oon- 0.017 0002 - 0.062
Ue Upper wa4.137 ono 0.020 000 - 0.(140
PROS YearsOt PFOS x Years Obs areAg aBMI Driokttey Drinks/day ra Cigarelles/day Locaiont Location* Baty Periods Entry Period** Basco Yeas Baseline Ycnrs Worked Worked igyeerides" Triglyeerides~
oo 0.002 ous0.005 ~0007 - 0.0007 -o00 - 0.001 oo0.003 -020 - 0.242 oom0.098 0006 - 0,006 oi 0.113
oon 0.002 ows0.004 oa0.004 oo0.014 oan0.O01 ao0,049 om0.037 oan0.004 om 0.024 :,
a.47 x.20 -.88 ".94 on.03 <0 < .0001 Ir.008 0. I0
<0 < .0001
0003 - 0.003 0003 - 0.003 -000 - 0.009 00% - 0.030 [ 0.0004 0x8 - 0.338 ons 0.025 oon- 0.013
00670.067
0006 0.006 oon 0.012 oom O.OOg ou 0.02g 0006 0:006 01s - O. 145 om0.171 Ir 0.001
06 0.160
'a*nAaotuttrvaelrlopoggve Decatur "IOS vs 1991 *Antwerp vs Decatur
**!994195 ~s 1997
aM No24E2208 3M_MN02482208
11779999..00004466
Ia
-,
mpnny
Frais P,,gu ~,7 of 63
froT"mTaaTbleleest11i44n..g MMPiioxxeenddtMMao(DdKeeleltlCeCoroemfil'nificeciseennotf IB~AtslkliiamslaietnesesP,,hSSotstaapnnhddasatrradds,erE'rCorohsrasn((SgSEIe~).,),nPPc--VdVaialnlutgmessaPanRnOdd9A95a5%%ndCCtohoennIfifdnteirnadcceeLtLinoiimnciwtesisth
f,'om
Testing
"NumberofYeasofOsrvation of Awe ndDecatur Mal Employees. Potential Determinants of Alkaline Phosphatase~ Change Including PFOA and the Number of Years of Ohservalion of Antwerp and Decatur Male Bmployees
Interaction
with
95%ConfidenceLimits
95% Confidence Limits
si
oe Cole Sp ewe e UUppeperr Lower
Inercep Intercept EN PFOA
YearsObcrvsion
Yea,~ Obserwlion
POA Yeas Obs PFOA x Years Obs Ase
Age
BMBMI Drinkakiy
Drinks/day
r------ (2igarelles/day
25 3.785 000s 0.005
0.47 - 0.(H7
0001 - 0.001 000s 0.005
-00009
- 0.0009
0002 - 0.002 oon 0.003
01m O. 176 oo(I,(} 12
ool0.006
oo0.002 oo0.0114
0004 0.004 ons 0,015 ooo0.001
<oo01 < .0001 ".69 <o001
< .0001
@.62 w.19 a.85 .89 o.03
2431 3.437 en - 0.019
-ooss
- 0.058
-o00s
- 0.005
0002 - 0.002
-0010
- 0.010
"00st
- 0.031
00004
0.0004
am 4.133 oom 0.028
ose - 0.036 oo 0.003 oon 0.013 ooo 0.008 oom 0.027
0006
0.006
Locaiont Location*
BaErntyryPPeerriioodd*s* BBaWsoacsrlekileinndee YeuYears
Worked
020 - 0.243
0100 0. 100 00s - 0.006
oon, 0.049
:
ose 0.036
oot 0.004
<o001
< .0001
on.007 3.09
"om - 0.340
oo0.028 -ooue
- 0.014
"- 0o.1r4e7
om 0.172 0001
0.001
Tigeeided ona oo <oon1 oss oi Triglyce,'ides#
0. I ! 4
0.024
< .0001
0.066
0.161
~"nnaaAttaunrnatl ltlooggaw. Deecrsipr 4*A1ntw9er9p vv4ssD919e9c57atur
**1994D5 vs 1997
aM_No24E2208
3M_MN02482209
11779999..00004477
iss
"Table 15. Mixed oseCost stoic,Standan)Eres (5).-Valossnd 5%Confidence Limits Tahlc 15. Mixed Mod~l Coeffi,'icnl I.~:~lil)lalcs, Sl~,ndard Errors (SE), P-Vp,tues and 95% Confidence IJmits om Testing Ronit Deer ofAlkaliPhosphCtosane InclocingTOP ad he Iscron ith from "l'~sling Potential Determinants of Alkaline Phosphutas~I Ch:mge Including TOV and the Inler~tion with
NabofeYearrsofOecrvofiAwoen snd DecMalaeEtmpluoyres Number 0f Years nr Oh.~rvalion of Antwerp and Decatur Male }]mpIo~ees
_ Co
trent ]nlcrccpl TorTOF Yon Oberon Years Observation TOFx Yaron TOF x Yca~ Obs ae
Age
wi
Drikoay D~nkdday
Coote
amy 3.78') "oom - t).(~ 0049
- 0.~9
-000006
- 0.~6
ous
0.~5
oon
oo - 0.~2
SL omO. 177 oun O.(~F) owe O.(~ [ 0.~ 17 oonm0y4 0.(~ ons 0.015
pe <oo0 < .0001 .~) <0 < .~ I Ea.97 =.19 ".9 i
LoLSCodmelinis 95% (2onfidenc~ Limits
over Upper Lower
Upl~.r
a wm 3.441
4.138
-oom ours - 0.019
0.018
0000 007 - 0.0~0
- 0.037
0003 0003 - 0.003 0003 oor - 0.003
0.003 0.012
00 ons - 0.0lO
0008
oon ous - 0.031
0.028
Ciguetediay
0003
Cigare~ledday
0.(~3
Locaions
ozs
Bay Pees 0100 ~try Period**
().1~
001
0.(~ I
ons ao0.036
.03
<o001 oon
.~7
os 0.0004 "03- 0.342 ous 0.028
oo 0.00~ ues - 0.148 om 0.172
BWaosrekliende Yeas 0006
ou
WoAcd
a0 oon - 0.013
0o00!
Tigers" ons om <a ous we T~glycerides=
0.1 ! 5
0.024
< .~ I
0.068
0.1152
nS"anAatlnaunreatrl plloovggsDecsor "E100 ve 1997 *Antwerp vs Decatur
**10A/95 vs 1997
w_o24Ez210 3M_MN02482210
11779999..00004488
uy
"Tale 16. Mined Model CaelTiin Fstimais Standard ror SE), P-Valucssnd 95% Confidence Limits "l'ahle 16. Mixed Model Coel'ficie.~t I~tim,',es, Standard Errors (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits fio Testing Poesia Deterninais of GGT hang IncludingPROSand he erin with from Testing Potential Determinunts ofGGT~ Change Including PFO$ and the Interaction with Nunberof Yeas of Oervaon of Anwenrd DeMcleaEmpuloyres Number of Years of Observation of Antwerp and Decatur Male Employees
trp Inlcrcept rosPFOS
YousOtvervion Years Observation PROSxYemOb PFOS x Yea~ Obs IAgc aBMI Driokiay DHnkgday Clguretesiay
Ciga~lle~day
Coffe C~mfficienl Ls1.883 oo - (}.004
0475 - 0.075 0004 0.~ oom - 0.~13 000s 0.~5 oon 0.~2 00009 - 0.~9
suSE am 0.3"/3 oom0.020 oo0.012 oom0,~ woos 0.(~)8 0 O.(~J oo0.03 I ous0,~3
pose p-value "oon < .0001 ",84 <a< .0001 2.42 74 .59 ".18 mn.77
OS ConfienceLimits 95% Confidence Limits
Lover pe Lower
Uplx~r
Lu 260 1.146
2.620
03 00s - 0.043
0,035
oom oust - 0.098
- 0.05 i
-o00s oon - 0.005
0.012
0019 oon - 0.019
0.013
03 oo - 0.013
0.024
00 oi - 0.020
0.104
0007
dons
- 0.007
Locaion 00% oi % 00% ono ~alion* Eny Pairs ass om <0 om osi2 ~nlry Period** Dascine Yeas os oo -0007 os Ba~linc Y~m~ Weed Work~ Tapeeroe" ozs) [a <0 ois2 03% T6glyce6des~
- 0.096 0.358 0.~8
0.251
0~1 04 (},078 0.~7
0.050
.36 < .000 !
.30
< .0001
- 0.030 0.204
- 0.007
0.152
O. I I0 0.5 ! 2 0.024
0.350
't"nAautnui,n~vleolovgga Decatur *"AHin0twRAerRpSvvsaD1e9c9a7tur
**1r~4195 vs 199"/
aw_o2eez211 3M_MN02482211
11779999..00004499
able 17. Mined ModelCocfficica imtcs, apd rors SE, P-Valucs nd 95% ConfidenceLimits l'ahle 17. Mixed Mt~ll Coefficient I:.stimales, Sland-rd Errors (SE), ['-Values and 95% Confidence Limits fonTsing Poenial DeterofmGGiT*nCheansge Iclding PFOA adhe nection wth from Testing Potential Determinants of GGT~ Change Including PFOA and the Interaction with Nomerof Years ofOscrvoafAinwoernp snd esMlseEmoployrees Number of Years of Ohscrvalion of Anlwcrp and Dccatur Male Employees 958Conune Limits 95% Confid,~nce Limits
aeons Page 50 of 63
............ me
ern Intercept Pron PFOA Yea Oberon Years Observalion PROAxYeunObs PFOA x Years Ohs AwAge aBMI
Collen Coefficient
176I .a76 "own - 0.0(F,t 00m - 0.077 0005 0.005 0002 - 0.002 oo 0.fl04
S0 SI~. om 0.374 ous 0.025 nz 0.1112 ous 0.005 ous 0,008 oun 0.009
pee p-value Zon < .(K)O 1 no.72 <0 < .0001 .29 a6.76 -.64
ewer Lower LsI. 138 ooss - 0.058 0100 - 0.100 oom - 0.004 -oos - 0.018 -oou - 0.014
Upa Upper 260 2.613 000 0.040 00s - 0.054 oo 0.014 oo 0.013 oon 0.023
Drinking oon ou a -o0i9 0105 Etrink~Jday Cipuretesny ~00007 000 = aon oos Cigarctte,~day Lociont 009 0108 EY 031 ous Location* En perodss 038s om <o001 ozs oso Entry ['eri~l** Busine Yeu ao 00s 0 0007 oo Baseline Yeut~ Worked Worked
0.043 - 0.0007 - 0.097
0.355 0.008
0.031
0.003
0.104 0.077
(}.008
.17 .82 .35 < .0001
.30
- 0.019 - 0.007 - 0.301
0.203 - 0.007
0.105 0.005 0.108 0.507 0.024
Theater! 026 ost <0 ois 0356 Triglycerides~
0.256
0.05 !
< .0O01
0.156
0.356
nul og #natural log "AlvesDeca *Antwerp vs D~catur "Hio5uns va 1997 **1994P)5 vs 1997
aw mozeez212 3M_MN02482212
11779999..00005500
AciSgs M C'amp~ny
Page 51 of 63
'l'ahle Ig. Mixed Model Coefficient I,'-stimatcs, Standard Errors (SI~.), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits
om Tsing ei Deans GTCoane oo TO se rion fi'am Testing Potential Determinanls of GGT~ Change Including TOF and the Interaction with Narheof YoofOruvaison of Awe sod DoMilcEmpluoyes Number of Years of Ob.~ervalian of Anlwerp and Decatur Male Employees
958 Cones Limits 95% Confidence Limits
c [-- om um moaonw pCuokem LoLvi er 2U0p08p lnlercep! or own TM " om oon TOF
Coefficient 1.870 0.002
SE 0.374 0.020
p-value < .0O01
.93
Lower I. 132 - 0.037
Upper 2.608 0.04 !
Yess Obervion ~~ -00m oun <omn ion ~oos4 Years Observation ToPvanOn ont ow x os oon TOF x Years O|xs
- (i.079 0.004
0.013 0.003
< .0001 .25
- 0.104 - 0.003
- 0.054 0.011
ne om TM as oon oon Age
- 0.003
1).008
.75
- 0.018
0.013
a ows own = oon oa BMI
0.005
0.009
.57
- 0.013
0.024
Drnktny 000 om n oon oor Drinks/day
0.043
0.031
.17
- 0.019
0.104
Cpe ose oon n our ous Cigarette,/day
- 0.0009
0.003
.77
- 0.007
0.005
Lacan ous ator oa on Location*
- 0.088
0.104
.40
- 0.294
0.117
By oes os wm <om oa os Enh'y Period**
0.352
t}.078
< .0001
0.200
0.505
Bacto vous ous aces at our oa Baseline Years Voted Worked
0.008
0.008
.31
- 0.007
0.024
Tighe! wan aso <a wo I Tdglyccrid~s~
0.249
0.050
< .0001
0.149
0:348
troy ~natural lag "Haver Dec *Antwerp vs Decatur is **1994/95 vs 1997
awmozsszzns 3M_MN02482213
7197999..00005511
sl 1. MedMod Coun tines, Sard irs(55. Vil95% Cuties : Lins Table 19. Mixed M~el Coefficicn! Eslimates, ~t.',ndard Errors (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits
Ting Po Ds ofAST Chg le PRO a co i from Tesling Potential Delerminanls of AS'I~ Change Including PFOS and the Interaction with Nantes Yous of rerio oer Des MlEpos Number of Years of Ohservalion of Antwerp and Decatur Male Employees 95% CondLeivis 95% Confidence Limits
PR Company
Pag~ 52 of 63,
--_-- oo ecem ...................t_:_oel'ficienl
rt 10m lntercepl
3.080
ros aoe PFOS
0.010
VernObrien 0009 Years Observation
- 0.009
Pros veusons 1007 PFOS x Years Ohs
0.(~07
re os Age
- 0,008
wa aon BMI
0.004
Orta amo Drinks/day
0.030
Cptesisy om Cigarcllcdd~y
- 0.003
Lain on Lncatimt*
O. 102
ny es oom Entry Period**
0.039
Bute Yen aes Baseline Years Ve Worked
0,005
erst TM Triglycerides~
0.063
SS EE
oonO, 198 oonO.t) l I aor0.007 os0.003 on0.004 oms0.005 aoe0.018 oz0.0{)2 ass0,053 oon0.039 aon0,004 I0.029
pe p-value
com <~ .0001 ,39 w.19 .79 os.05 a.47 u. I I @.07 -.06 .32 2.22 .03
lLoowweerr
2a2.689 oon- 0.013 "oo- 0.024 aos - 0.005 oot- 0.016 "oan - 0.007 "oom- 0.007 ome - 0.006 oe - 0.206 ous- 0.038 ous - 0.003 os0.005
UUppppeerr
san3.47 I oon0.032 ous0.005 ax0.006 "oow0s - 0.00005 ao0.014 one0.066 oom 0.0002 sors0.003 ae0.116 oo0.012 amO. 121
rant Inalural log Cheaecm ~'Antwerp vs Decatur sw **19~4/95 vs 1997
swmczizzis 3M_MN02482214
11779999..00005522
"TTaobbleefr2200o..mMMTiienxeeiddnMMoPedelenl CCioDsefcfDfiticctiieeennttrE[":mistniime~uo,slfcn,sA,StS$T1tsapnddCaahrraddnigEeorrroIrnsscl((SScEEi)n),,gPVP-FVaOalAulaenswudandtdee9955sI%%teCCscootnifniodnetnwcidtehLLiimnitss from NanherofYea af Otcrvof Aantwierop and DecMalaeEtmpluoyeres Testing Poteatial Detemfina.t~ ofA~ Chm~ h)cluding P~O~ ~nd th~ lntcJ'~ction wilh
Numl~r of Y~a~ of Ob~crvalion of Anlw~ and D~a~ur Male ~ploye~s
aeM Cunan
958% Confidence Limit
95% Confidence Limits
JE Inereps
Intercept
proPFOA
YYeeaa~r;s~ Orton Obscrvalio. PROAXYemOb
P~A x Yeat~ Obs
I
Age
MiBMI
Drinkadey Dfink~day
Cigmtestiny Ciga,~tlcgday
Locaiont ~alion* Ey Protos Enl,T Pcrital**
BBWaoasr~eklliienndee
Years
Years
Work~
( ],~i'ficicnl
0s3.053 om 0,027
- 0O0.(g0)88
0002 - 0.~2 "oom - ().~)7 0004
0.(~
os0.030 0003 - 0.~3 0097 - 0.097 oon 0.04,1 00040.~
SES I '.' 019 (I. 109 ois0.015
o0.o1~r7 0003
0.[~3
0004
0.(~
000s 0.~5 oo0.018 oo0.1~}2 os 0.053 ono 0.039 oo0.~
pale p-value <0 < .O(R) I
.06
x.28 a.41 0.08 .39 0.10 o.07 o.07 2.26 z.27
Lower Lower 2662.661 "00m - 0.002
oon - O.O22 0008 - 0.008 -oms - 0.015 Es - 0.006 006 - 0.006 -0006
- 0.006
0201 - 0.201 oon - 0.032 -0003
o 0.003
UUmpl~rer aus 3.445 0056
0.056
00.000066 00.000033 oon
0.0008
oots
0.015
oss
0.066
00002
0.0002
00s 0.008 ono 0.120 oon 0.012
Tigres" oust Tfiglyceridcs'
0.054
oo0.030
o -0004 on .07
- 0.004
0.113
"~"nAnanaltuawranelrllpooggvs Decatur 419945 ve 1997 *Antwerp vs I)calur
**199419.5 vs 1997
_ozsez215 3M_MN02482215
11779999..00005533
le 21.nMeiniednModP el Cot c seS tsASSTi nCher.si 5T- OF 5 dh orCcointienc ii Table 21. Mixed Model Coefficient I:.stimates, Standard Errors (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits from Testing Potential Determimmts of AS'I~ Change Including TOF and the Interaction with NNuumlmmroboffYYeeeararrss ooff OObhsseerrvvaattiinonnooff AAnnttwweerrpp aunndd D DeceaturcMMaalale9EEt mmplpuoloyyereeess
Con 9955f %% Coi nfidd enceLe Liimmitin tss ce
--i
meen Intercept
TorTOF [I Years Observalion ToFxvamon TOF x Y~,~ Obs aAge aBMI Dray Drinks/day psy Cigarette 'dday Losin Location* ry ers Entry Period** foBaseline Yeats es Worked
CoCoceffficieint clens S,',;$E
sas wo, 3.058
O. 198
:
oor oTMm - 0.0(19 ows om - 0.006 Cams om - 0.008 oom ours 0.004 oom oars 0.029 03 Pr - 0.003 os ass - 0.095 aon am 0.039" aoos ao 0.005
0.1108 0.002 0.004 0.005 0.018 0.002 0.053 0.039 0.004
TrTirgilgylyccecrriiddeess't
000.50588
000.02299
pr tnatural log "hs bc *Antwerp vs Decatur Aston *'1994/95 vs 1997
pwp-vealeue
com < .l~O I
-a.24 .79
.06
".40 " 12 ".07 =.08 .31 x.24
0.055
lLoowweerr
2066 2.666
aos - 0.005 EE- 0.024 ams - 0.005 ome - 0.016 ams - 0.006 oun - 0.007 os - 0.006 "oi- 0.199 amr - 0.037 "aos - 0.003
0.00.000000033
UpUpppeerr
2a3.449
oot0.04 aos0.006 oom0.004 aos 0.0002 oors0.015 ooss0.065 oom 0.0002 ao0.010 ans0.115 aor:0.012
o0.l11e6
sumczizzie 3M_MN02482216
11779999..00005544
Tale "l'ablc 22r22.o.MmMiTxiexseteiddngMMoP(soue.llelelnCCooeelfDificceiietnnte! HErsmlshineanotfea,sAn, LSStatTasnnddCaahrrddanFEeroroIJs.n'scl((cSSiEEn))g,, PPP--RVVaOalSlouaeesnss.dannhdde9955I%%nCaCocnotfniifodidneenwncceiesLiLmimitisls from Numerof Yearsof Ghcrvainof Testing Potenlial Delerminanls of AL'I'~ Aniwerpsnd Decatur MeleEmployes Change Including PffO$ and the lnlcraction with
Nmnber of Yea~s of Observation of Antwerp and Decatur Male ~nployees
95%ContgenceLimi
95% Confidence Limits
J _ Comew Si puke .........................!~ ~.~!'fi__c_J~LLl............ .'51.~........ .~
Inerep 2501 om <o001 Intercept
2.501
0.273
p-w,luc
.~ .0001
Lower Lower 15611.961
Upter
Upper
ou
3.041
pros + ono 006 st 0021 oon PFOS
" 0.010
O.O 16
.54
- 0.021
0.041
YeanObservation 0095 oot Yems Observalion
- t}.t}95
0.010
OSs YemObs 00000 004 PFOS x Years Ohs
- 0.00003
11.004
ne 00000 00s Age
0.0009
11.006
<a
"ous
< .000 I
-000s
.99
- 0.008
5
-oon2
- 0.012
ons
- 0.075
os 000 0.010
a 000 oo w 000 os BMI
0.010
0.007
.17
- 0.004
0.024
Dinky Drinks/day
002 - 0.012
ous 0.025
0062 oo .63
- 0.062
0.038
Ciguetesiny -0008 [= Cigarelleshlay
- 0.008
0.002
on -o0iz .130 I
-0.012
-0003
- 0.003
Locuions 008 on L~alioll*
- 0.088
0.073
.23
03 - 0.233
00.005566
Bay Peas om = <o00t 022 ous Entry Pcniod** Base Years oon 00s - ooo oo Baseline Years Worked Worked
0.329 O.001
0.054 (I.005
< .000I .84
0.222 - 0.010
0.436 0.012
Tigris" 0159 ooi0 Triglycerid~s~
0.159
0.1140
conn 09 os .0001
0.079
0.238
phd
A#*anaaAturnal otlovggvsDeecray "109vs419S97 *Antwerp vs Decatur
** 1994195 vs 1997
aw mozeez21 3M_MN02482217
11779999..00005555
Pcs i'ag~ 56 of 63
"Tole{r223o3.. TMMeiisxstecidnMMgPo,~tdlecelCCoocffDfficeiicenn!r~Essmtlilii~nl:sn|oelcfsnsA,,tLSSttsTaapnddCaahrraddrrEgoerrroI~s(n(SScEE,),lPPP--uVVFaaOdllAuoeaissnnnadnhddge9955e%%CaCotnofniifinddeennwcciteehLLiinmiti[ss
fron~
amber ofYears ofObservationof l'cslinB Polcnliul Dclcrminanls of AL.T= Number of Years of Ob~crv.'=tion of
Aiwerp andDecaturMaleEmployes ChunBc lncludinB P~'OA and the lnterac|ion
^mweq~ and Decatur Male Employees
wi~h
oskC9o5%nCfonifideencre cLimeitls imis
--nee [ntercepl pron
PFOA
o Coffeen Sh ................( h~cl'ficicm __ 2a am 2.4?9
SI~. 0.272
ams ama 0.015
O.020
phe p-value <o001 < .0001 a".46
lew~wcr 1901.942 ~oos - 0.025
Umer Upper an 3.016 as
Yeas Oration -0.107 uo <ao0r pr 0081 Years Observation
- 0.107
0.(110
< .~1
- 0.126
- 0.087
PROACYeisOb 0005
oon
P~A x Yea~ Obs
(1.~15
0.(~
ree
~00001
os
Age
- (l.l~l
-0003 ons .19
- 0.003
0.013
5 -onut oon -0.01 l
0.011
oa
oon
a
Drinkadey 000m os D~nk~duy
- 0.(~)
0.025
5 om 02s - 0.003
0.025
-ooss 000 .72
- 0.058
0.040
CiCgiagratreelsletgidaayy
-- 00.0(~071
02 0.(~)2
0 002 oom .~I
- 0.012
- 0.003
Location "00m om ~ation*
- 0.079
0.072
om 064 .28
- 0.222
O.Od4
ry Piss om 53 co ons [= ~nt=y Pcri=al** Base Years 000s 000s "000 oon B~eline Years Worked Worked
0.330 0.~
0.053 0.~5
. < .~I .89
0.225 - 0.010
0.434 0.0| I
Tigers" ost ont Tdglycerides~
0.151
0.~ I
000s oon om .~3
0.071
0.231
Ansar log, #nalural log "Aatvervps Decatur *Antwerp vs l)catur 19945 ve 1997 ** 1994/95 vs 1997
_ozsez218 3M_MN02482218
11779999..00005566
ad
"ible
Table
22f44.o. m
MMTieinxueeiddngMMoodPdeaellcCCiaoseffffDicieitiecnnmt iFsn.saitinmmsatosefs,ASSLtaaTngdaCarhrdiCEninrs'oorescS(lSFuE)i),n,PgPT--VVOaalFluuaeesnsdnanhdde99I55%%nCsCotnofnoifniddeetnncchee
Limits
Limils
from
NoYee ar ofr Oservf aion of Testing Potential Delerminants of ALT~ Number of Years of Ohservati(m of
Anwerp Change
Antwerp
3x) DecMilaeEmtpluoyeres Including TOF and the lnleraction
and D~atur Male Employees
with
958Contgnce Limits
95% Confidence Limits
e[=e Coof2i47e6n lnlercepl or 0am TOF YearsOtseraion 0.102 Years Olmervalion TORK Years oo TOF x Years Ohs ne ~oo00s Age 0 oon BMI Deikatey 003 Drinks/day Cipuetesiny 00s Cigarettes/day Locaions oom Location* Ey Periods os Entry Period** Basco Yeas ooms Baseline Years Worked Worked -- ous Triglycerides~
Ctx:fficie.I 2.476 0.020
- 0.102
0.002
- 0.(1005
O.O 11 - 0.013
- 0.008 - 0.073 0.325
0.0008
O. 148
Si SI'.'
:
om0.273
ons; 0.016
:
vont0.01 I
oom0.003
000O.(X~6
oom0.007
oms 0.025 oon 0.0O2 oor0.073 o0s3 {}.0.53
os 0.005
00.00400
pe p-value Soo < .(~JOl a.2 I <a< .0OOl 0.50 @.03 a 1 I @.62 oon.oo I 2.32 <0 < .0001 ".88
00s.0003
Lover 19%1,936 -oon -0.011 om -0.123 0008 -0.004 oon-0.01 i 000 - 0.003 -0062 - 0.062 ~oon - 0.012 oan - 0.217 om0.220 pr- 0.010
009 0.069
Upper Upl~r . 201s 3.015 00st0.051 oom - 0.082 000s 0.008 oo 0.010 os 0.026 oom 0.037 om - 0.{)03 oon 0.072 on 0.430 oono,011 ozs 0.228
"asta og ~natu~al log "AntvwsDeecratpur *Antwerp vs Decatur "Emns vs 1997 *'!994/95 vs 1997
aM mozeez210 3M_MN02482219
11779999..00005577
Table 25. Mined Model Celio LiSnandicsors S,E, P-Vlues nd 9%Confidence Limits lkble 25. Mixed Model Coefficicnl I?.slimates, Slandard Erro,'~ (SP.), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits frTsing Penis DermofaTotn ibn ChangeIningPROSand he Iersction wih from Testing Polentia112~terminams of Total Bilirubin~ Change Including PriOR and the Interaction with
NumobfYeearsofObcrofvAwaertpanid Deocatnur Male Employes Number of Years of Observation of Anlwerp and Decatur Male Bmployees 95%Confidence Limi 95% Confidence Limits
rn
eros
YenOvervion
PROS x YeusObs a I
Diinkalday
Cparecstny Locaion EvyPeres BWaosrckiendeYeas
Ctame Coefficient
aos - 0.018 0433 0.033 0002 - 0.002 oon0.011 000 - 0.003 one 0.016 - 000.00088 os
0.315
"oi oon - (1.002
sSeE om
oo0.014 on 0.(~119 ou0.004 ons 0.(~5 oun 0.007 ome 0.024 .
oo0.002 0os6I).064
oms 0.005
:
pnee p-value 2
.22
wos ".94 .02 o.67 0.50 <om < .0001 <a< .0001
".(~4
ler Lower osm -0.811 006 - 0.046 ous0.0148 0007 - 0.007 oon0.001 -o016 - 0.016 000 - 0.030 oon - 0.012 0o6i 0.189 oon-0.01!
upe Upper oi 0.142 oon0.011 ous 0.052 000 0.007 oo 0.020 on 0.010 one:0.062 0004 - 0.004 out0.44 l om - 0.022 our 0.007
Tighoerides" oom
ou
- 0.088
0.037
0161 oats .02
-0.161
- 0.015
otal log anatural log "Ane va Desaar *Antwerp vs Decatur SAS va 1997 **1994195 vs 1997
M_No24E2220 3M_MN02482220
11779999..00005588
Company
Farr Page 59 of 63
"ibolmeT26e.MinidPoMoodDe eCoterfimciieomfnTntoes, Standard Coors (SE, -Vaocs wd95% Confidence iis "l'abl 26. Mixed Model Coefficient F~timates, Standard En-ors (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits t rb Chang niin PPO sndih Ison wih from 'r.~ting Potenlial Determinants of Total Bilirubin# Change including PFOA and Ihc Interaction with
Numberof Yea ofOsrvaion of Amwer sndDecor Mile Bplcyecs Number of Years of Observation of Antwerp and Decatur Male PmpIoyecs
95%Consens Limits 95% Confidence Limits
_nee J ois ovman pune Loomver oUpipeer Intercept Pron oan oor 1 oo oon PFOA
............. Coefficilll -0.315
- 0.030
Yon Obsrvion 0428 oom oot oo Years Obscrvalion
0.028
POAXYomOM 0005 oo " oo oon PFOA x Yem~ Obs
0.005
Sit 0.242 0.019 0.009 0.004
_p-valve .19 .16 .003 .18
Low~l- O.'793
0.001 - 0,002
Upr~r o.1d2 o.0~7 0.046 0.013
AAsgee
maBM1 Drinking Drinks/day Cipreetiny Cigmetl "s/day Locaion Location* Bot Pies Entry Pc,'iod** [re Baseline Years Vokes Worked genie Triglycerides~
a010
0.010
00m - 0.003 oon0.014 oom- 0.008 oan0.318 ouone -0.124 oo- 0.082
os 0.005 ::
oom0.007 om0.023 om0.002 I0.064 oot0.(H6 oms0.005 oun0.037
.o04
at.61 55.55 <aont.0001 . <aont.0001 on.007 a.'71 .O3
00007
0.0007
-0016 - 0.016 oom- 0.032 oor- 0.013 ss0.193 oats-0.215 ~o0u- 0.011 "oss -0.156
000
0.020
aon0.010 oo 0.060 00m - 0.004 oss 0.444 oom - 0.034 oom0.007 oo
"oat log #natural log "Aner vi ecsar *Anlwerp vs Decatur io5ims a 197 **1994195 vs 1997
aM ezeezz21 3M_MN02482221
11779999..00005599
, Compaay
bTlree2T7.sMinigPdoMoedle DCeocsriasnoafeTto,e StandardFos (5), Valu sd 95%Cofdece Lit fran] "i'ahle 2'7. Mixed Model Cocfficicm ILstimat,~, Standard Errors (SE), P-Value~ and 95% Confidence Limits Bibi Crargs ching TOFand he Incrscion wih froan Tesling P(aenlial ]:leterminm}ts uJ" Total Bilirubin~ Change Including TOF and the Interaction wilh
"Numberof Year of Onc of Aner snd Decor Mile poy Number of Yea~ of Oh~rwdion of Antwerp and Decatur Male Employees
95% Conitene Limi 95% Confidence Limits
cme wm pose Lover topes ................... Coefficient
ere oe ne "ome oie Inte~cpl
- 0.31 g
,~1,~ 0.242
p-~alue :. 19
Lower - 0.796
Upper 0.160
Tor +000 oon " 000 oom TOP
" ~ 0.02(}
0.014
.16
- 0.~9
Yon Oberon 0429 woo os oom oot Y~ OI)s~rvalion
0.029
0.010
.(~)5
0.~9
0.~9
TORxYemon 0m oom 2 ous oo TOF x Years Obs
0.~3
0.~3
.3~
- 0.~3
0.~
Dnoreitnks oooomn oooummns 5a oo~ooo0rtn6 ooonamen D~nk~day Cipmctcslny om on <aont oor oom ~igarcttc~day Locaiant oie oot pr om oan ~ation~ BeaytriYeeass owomm ooomts "" o~ooamn0 oooomm B~linc Ycm~ Vokes Worked Tigre Er oan " "ose oon T~glyccridcs~
0.016 - 0.(H)8
0,316
- 0.~2 - 0.085
0.023 0.(~2 0.(~
0.(~5 0.037
< .~ I < .~ I
.68 ,02
- 0,012 0.190
- 0.011 - 0.15g
- 0.~ 0.442
0.~7 - 0.012
"naan log )natural log "AnvveDeecar *Antweq~ vs Decatur "isis a 991 **1994195 vs 1997
aMnezeezzz2 3M_MN02482222
7197999..00006600
re
"Table28. Mined Model Coffin: stmt, Sandu iors(SE, P-Valus nd35%Confidence Limits Table 28. Mixed Model Coefficient Estimates, Standard E=TOrS (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits fomTeunPte Detrminouof Direct Bilin' Chang IncluingPROS nd he nracton with from Testing Potential Delerminanls of Direct Bilirubine Change Including PFOS and the Interaction with
Number Years ofOtsvatin of Aver sd Deca ii Employes Nnmber of Years of Observation of Antwerp and D~catur Male Employees
osmCodmcotimis 95% Confidence Limits
[-- Co1%en2S0E 0 lntercepl ros "oon oon PFO~ YeasObservation -097 oom Years Obscl'ValJell PneOieSxYersO 0ro0u0yr6 oo00oo0ns PFOS x Yea~ Obs
Coefficient - I.'156 - 0.013
- 0.097
-o.oo6
0.007 - 0.003
SE 0.204 0.013
0,009
o.,~
0.004 0.006
Drikuisy Ddnkgday -- Cigaretlegday Locaions
~ation*
Baty Perot
~try
BWBouarssekcleiindee Yeus
Worked
ooO.O l B ~ooms - 0.0005 ous 0.076 09 0.353 ~o0n - 0,001
oom0.020
oe 0.002
:
oon 0.053
ous 0.038 :
ous 0.004
pee p-value oo < .0001 .29 <0 < .0001 a.is .06 st.58 .37 .79 as,15 <or . < .0001 n.74
ewer Lower 210 - 2.160 00m - 0.039 116 - O. 116 001 - 0.014 ous - 0.00O3 -oais - 0.015 om - 0.022 000s - 0.004 00s - 0.028 om0.277 00- 0.009
Ue Upper ass - 1.355 oor 0.012 oom - 0.079 oon0.003 oois 0.015 oun0:0O8
ous0.058 oom0.003 om 0. ! 80 am0.428 ous0.006
Tiled! T~glycerides=
00- O.09fl
oun0.033
os "iss .006
- O, 155
-om6 - 0.026
tout og natursl log *Anivevps Decor *Antweq~ vs Decalur "SIBBRS vs 1991 *'1994/95 vs 1997
amozeez220 3M_MN02482223
11779999..00006611
ue 2. Mix Mode Calitics,Sadr vs (SE, Pa 12495l %Confe idece Lis Table 29. Mixed Modal Co~fficic.t l~timalca, Slandard Errors (SF_,), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits onTain Potcota ekminas of Dk Dri Cars Incug PFOA rdhe rschon ih from Tesling Polenlia] Dclerminanls of Direct Bilimbin~ Change Including PFOA and the Interaction with
Nome of Yea ofOlocraionof AverandDectHolsEmpcyes Number of Years of Observation of Anlwerp and Decatur Male Employees
cumsew __. - _ ere us Intercep! ron "oo PFOA YonOtscoion "0035 Yeal~ Observalion POA Vemobs 004 PFOA x Yem~ Obs I I Age a oan BMI Drnksay oon Drinks/day
Coel'ficien! - 1.753 - 0.0 ! 2 ' - 0.095 - 0.004
0.006 - O.OO3
0,014
[r-- Cigarettes/day Locsin Locatioot* EarPro Entry Perind** Buse Youn Baseline Years Vries Worked Tighe Triglycerides#
0000s - 0.0005 aoe0,083 ous0.345 oon - 0.0008 oom- 0.089
seSE om0.207 oon?0.017 on0.009 IO.(XH I0.{XH oes0.006 ooo 0.020 om0.002 oe0,053 oom0.038 oa0.(304
om0.033
puke p-value <so01 < .0eel a!.47 coon | < .0001 a.27 n. I I P.66 0.50 0.80 n.12 <a< .0001 =n.83 wn.OO9
95% Confidence Limits
Loner upp Lower
Upper
"2161 Ee -2.161 outs om - 0.045
- 1.345 0.02 I
om oom -0.113
- O.O77
-o0n2 oun -0.012 0001 oon - 0.001
0.014
oie oo - 0.014
-oms 00s) - 0.026
0.053
ou oo - 0.004
0.003
om oun - 0.022
0.188
om oo 0.271
0.420
ous oun - 0.008
0.OO7
oss -0.155
om - 0.023
Huta |ttntural log "AvnsDecyatur *Anlwerp va Decatur ime ** 1994P)5 vs. 1997
w_woze2226 3M_MN02482224
11779999..00006622
~..A Company
tS Page 63 of 63
ile30. Mod Mot Cocina, Stn Eres5, P-as 45% CotoLins Table 30. Mixed Model Coefficient Estimates, Standard Errars (SE), P-Values and 95% Confidence Limits
ffrroommTTestsitinngg PPooitceanttiiaall DDre,tetrmeinranm[sioonffDaDirinrceetcstBiBliilirroubbiinn# CChhaannggee IInncclluuddiinnggTTOOFffaannddtthheeInIntteerraaccttiioonn wwiitthh
Ronit Yeuof Ova of Aw Doct i Els Numb~r of Yeara of Observation of Antwerp and Decatur Male Employ~s
ost Contrctimi 95% Confidence Limits
cen = rae Love . Coefficint
SE
p-value
Lower
Upper
[I Cire os wor aise 120 Intercept
- 1.748
0.205
< .000!
- 2.154
- 1.343
or ous - "oon ours TOP
" - 0.O13
0.013
.33
- 0.038
0.013
VousOrsion 003 oa0 <a "ons ours Yearn Observation
- 0.093
0.010
< .0001
-0.113
- 0.073
LR os a "oon aon TOF x Years Ohm ne oom oom BN Er aoe Age
- 0.(}04 0.007
0.003
0.004
-0.011
0.002
.08
- 0.0008
0.014
ma ows oo = amis aoe BMI
- 0.003
0.006
.57
-0.015
0.008
Dry aon au om 00st DdnkrJday
0.017
0.020
.39
- 0.022
0.057
CiCgaigraert,~iteless//ddaayy
Losin Localion* Ey eae Entry Pedod** Bucivan Baseline Years oes Worked
TiTirgihgylyeceerriiddeess~'
0- .00.0000044.
a0.074 00.349 om- 0.001
00m - 0.087
10)0.00022
ass0.053 ons0.038 aon0.004
om0.033
.8a4
<Pa M< .0001 n.77
00
-000.00044
ost - 0.031 az0.274 aoe - 0.00g
-"00.115522
00.000033
am0.179 aass0.424
00m - 0.022
Airvre rDeec ; ~anatatuurraalllloogg
*Antwerp vs Decatur **1994D5 vs 1997
czas 3M_MN02482225
11779999..00006633