Document MJGZZ8RwbXeRygx3J8peNRyB7

FILE NAME: Insulators Workers' Comp Claims (IWC) DATE: 1963 DOC#: IWC075 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: Claimant - Brokenshire, Leonard C. WORKERS* COMPENSATION APPEALS B<UBD I I STATE OF CALIFORNIA 8078G3 LEONARD CHARLES BBOKENSHTHE APPLICANT VS ASiSTRONG- CONTRACTING AND SJPPLT COMPAN , T AL CASE NP. 63 L.A. 250-245 CERTIFICATION FOR EVIDENCE DEFENDANT (S| I DO 'HEREBY CERTIFY that the attached are full, \ . true and correct copies of the documents- in the file in the above-entitled causQ. This certification is for evidence only and is not 'to be used for filing with the County Clerk under Labor Code Section 5806 ' Attest' ny hand and the Seal of the Worker's Compensation Appeals Board of the State of California.. Dated At: Los Angeles, Ca. : September 5, 1978 \ PSE3IE 3 T0N"7TO5g >1* frfltt/na r i ?. . ^v '/Sc*7*-.8i 4fc6SL Juk 10 s 23 H *S7 i*'. E A . C I F ^ <=X f P E S w L S s T I T Y ' G R O U P __ cns^erT s/lfiPiSS^ -- r . o i n o iN O tM H rfY e o w fA w y t t x a * M i n e w D iM N rry s o m m w v MOM I M W W T tK N C IM IO IM OO M M ITV M M M N V *oo wikOHioc e u L s v A . woo a m o k w -CO. c a w i p o m m i a *oas* Jtane 19,. 1967 Workmen's Compensation Appeals Board *ft07 State Bulldine 107 S* Broadway Los Angeles, Calif* Gentlemen: Pile No.: Assured * Claimant t Accident: Comm No. $ 01 PEC 62**0^3 Thorpe Insulation Leonard Brokenshire 12-55 - 63 LA 250-2lt5 We respectfully request that the above captioned case be ^dismissed for lack of coverage as alleged, per our letter I August ljp^96Vr-lack of prosecution and De Minimis. Very truly yours, JJT/jg . cc: Stearns 4fc Gross Attorneys At Lav 9200 Colima Rd Whittier, Calif. *ni* -- r/ ulMTl *SSVB 0? i.S5STSUt ACOStHT. .CS EUS WBNG^N, KSNpIGiiV^OaCWiU A TTO N V * AT LAW IST, ?*&' *000* coR^f; ist W*r POUPTt rntcrr ANTA AMA. CAUPOAMIA S 70I T tA -- 4 l . 13t a e w u r n rrw avknuc POMONA. CAUPOPM IA I T f < 7 * ~ a 3tA M IN L r A erar to. Los Angeles , Jone 19 1967 Workmen1s compensation Appeals Board . 107 South Broadway Los Angeles California R2t LSOHARD BROXESSHIRS V VARIOUS EMPLOYERS 69 LA 250 245 Gentlemens- ' There has been no action on this matter for over a year, we believe a notice o intent to dismiss should issue and If valid objection Is raised thereto, that this case be restored to calendar or a full one day hearing. Yours very truly, W3XSGASD, KSNSIG & STOCCSLL BYt ' JOSEPH BILCHA2C JB/mjc cos Aetna Casualty and Surety Company - F (S) 33CC 1036193 McLaughlin, Ivans, oalbey and cumming -Steams, cross and Moore . . Zonni, Ginocchio and Taylor Fireman'3 Fund American Insurance Company G9JU.08 1 2 3 4r 9 6 r 8 9 10 11 12 15 14 18 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 LEONARD WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD STATE OF CALIFORNIA CASE NO 63 LA 250245 LOS 4W5S ES e r a s WOKK,;.v! j i^'C'SAuCN AiVfcAl* SiiArtO CHARLESBROESNSEEZRE* ) FILED * `lSw}Jr Applicant, ) VS* . ) ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY COMPANY, ) a corporation; at al,,, Defendants MINUTES OF FURTHER HEARING AND ORDER TAKING OFF CALE2 THIS CAUSE came on for hearing- at 9:00 a.m., March 29, 1966, Ln Department 5 Workmen's Compensation Appeal* Board, Loa Angeles, Jalifornia, before the Honorable ROBERT W DUBEAU, Referee. PRESENT: G. C. Faurot, Reporter vuotisi Leonard Charles Brokenahire, applicant Steams & Gross, by* Richard Gross, attorneys for -applicant APR 4 1966. S. C Schweitzer, Representative for Thorpe Insulation; * Fireman's Fund Insurance Company McConnell & Cramoline, hy J. f . Hclzer, attorneys for Marine Engineering it Supply Co.; Pacific Employers Insurant Zonni, Ginocchio it Taylor, by Wm'. Blanchard, attorneys for Accurate Insulation Co.; Casualty Insurance Co. of Californ- Weingand, Kendig & Stockwell, by Rosa C. Irwin, attorneys for Mudet Cork. Corp. j Fiberglass Engineering it Supply Comoany: Armstrong Contracting & Supply Co.; The Aetna Casualty and Surety Company. George R. Haswell, by Charles P. Carlstroem, attorneys for Riley Stoker Corp.; Liberty Mutual Insurance Company McLaughlin, Evans, Dalbey it Cumming, by John F. McLaughlin, attorneys for Armstrong Contracting fc Supply Co.; The Travelers Insurance Company F. W. Harrington, Representative, for Accurate Insulation Co.; Mission Insurance Company, a corporation, successor to ' Enterprise Insurance Company, a corporation 1 2 3 4> 9 6 7 8 9 10 n 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 Phil Collins, Representative for Plant Insulation Company; Pacific Indemnity Company, a corporation 50 WITNESSES NO EXHIBITS i DISPOSITION: . ` . ' Li order that additional parties may he Joined, GOOD CAUSE APPEARING THEREFOR: IT IS ORDERED that this matter be TAKEN OFF CALENDAR subject to being- reset upon request of any of the parties. Service of this Order is waived WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD 807867 ^ D IV IS IO N OF INDUSTRIAL. ACCIDENTS WORKMEN COMPENSATION APPcrZ.iS BOARO STATI OS CAUPORNIA 8078G8 IZONARD CHARLES HRCKZNSHIRE. vs^ Applicant ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY J & B B a C COMPANY, a corporation* et al and OWENS-CORNING FIBERGLASS COMPANY; COAST INSULATING PRODUCTS COMPANY; INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY COMPANY, a corporation; NATIONAL AUTOMOBILE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, a corporation . H tfm d sn ti C auN *+ 63IA 250 2^5 O rder Joining P art^*8 D efendant Good Cause Appearing: rr IS ORDERED T H A T - OWENS-CORNING FIBERGLASS COMPANY; COAST INSULATING PRODUCTS COMPANY; INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY COMPANY, a corporation; ' NATIONAL AUTOMOBILE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, a corporation parties * joined u defendant bercia. Rttm , VORXMENt COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD Dated at: Loa Angeles, California September 22, 1967 SERVED BY MAIL ON PERSONS S H O W ON THE OFFICIAL ADDRESS .RECORD . ' ------ ------- 3 "B 9/22/67 --- Copy of notice of hearing, application and. Joinder of 2/9/66 served all newly Joined parties and their attorney and Reece insulation co cao;ni) STATE O F C A U FO H N tA I 20NHD CHARTES ERCEOERSHZRS' A p p lica n t_ n. ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPET COMPANY, & corporation; at al D e fe n d a n t__8 Case No* 63LA 250 245 SUPPLSOENTAL Notice of Time aadr Place of F urther Hearing On the Petition of The Travelers Insurance Company for contribute under Labor code, Section 5500*5. NOTICE TO ALL PARTIES You are hereby notified th at further hearing will be held in the above-entitled action at 4107 LOS ANGELES STATE OFFICE BUILDING, 107 SOUTH BROADVAY ' LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA October $ , 1967 9s00 .M. all day WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD D ntd tu Lot Aagcin, Ciliform . NOTE: CONTINUANCES AND FURTHER HEARINGS ARE N O T FAVORED. SERVED BY MAIL ON PERSONS SHOWN ON THE OFFICIAL ADDRESS RECOJU3 Dau: Bjrs /. ______ 9 A 3 /6 7 d k / ~ v t m e n t o f in d u s t r ia l . R ELA T ^'.S - D(VISION o r INDUSTRIAL ACCIBCMTS WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS STATXOF CAUEORNIA BOARD O iU i.O S 12NARD CSARIZS BK0KESSH25Z,. A p p lica ti m Ar m s t r o n g c o n t r a c t i n g & s o f f i t CORPORATION; TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY, . 'D cfendanti C a s e No. 63 LA 230-245 SUBPENA. DUCES TECUM PIEAS2TBE SUES SEE TOESISU'S CC-2PEKi,ATIOlf appeals BCAEDucissa IS 037 AIL HECCEDS TOO STUB IE ANSWER TO THIS SUBPOSOl , The People of tie State of California Send Greetings to; p a c if ic m p s H S lT y com p. __________ 320G Wllshlre Blvd,. Los Angelas Califs T E COMMAND YOU, to tppcer bcfu* .tdu m of th t WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA *_________ 107 South Broadway, io Anaales, California . (xui 15 WJI A l ORISC DATE) ^ ----1-------------------- ,, Spebr 27th ,, 67 ,, 9 :00 A.., tad bring with yon and prodoc the foflowia, dmcribed doormenr, pip, book and w w tjc ANT AND a i l .COPIES OF WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION INSURANCE POLICIES AND/OR d a l e s RELAXING TO MARINE ENGINEERING & SUPPLY COMPANY BETWEEN ' JANUART 1 , 1947 AND- DECEMBER 31 1962.CC S S a g B a a B M W l ! w y w -- For fiflur to attend aad to pradoee a id documents yen may bo deemed guilty of a contempt and fiebk to pay to the pwtie* aggrieved tU damages nueaiatd thereby aad forfeit oao hundred doilan in TKe rubpena is an ad at the requestof the person making the declaration an the reverse hereof. srp 1 g KV7 . VUAKMEN'5 COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD , I <v-- r / *,<* '*- , r By.----------- 1-- - r - rt Ajrir r u t te n a tr, ) U n APPLICABLE ONLY IF INITIALED BY REFEREE OR ASSISTANT SECRETAftV , ,, Yon bpena by mailing the records dcKribed to tia V orkaea'a Gampetuarion Appeals Board **-' ..... . California, w ithin Etc {J ) days of the data of service of this mbpena, attaching the copy of tf nihnnm ap mifV inv fJva oL* k^ * * * V OC C -v L WORKMEN'S' COMPENSATION APPFALS BOARD Ot 2 STATE OP CALIFORNIA 5 . CASE NO. 63 L.A. 250-2*5 4 8 LEONARD CHARLES BROXSNSHXRE, ,rr.o / JL i 6 Applicant, ' 7 to. 8 ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY ' COMPANY, at al, . 9 Defendants. 10 ORDER TOR APPORTIONMENT AND CONTRIBUTION U IX 3 ORDERED t&at defendants hereinafter named pursuant t 12 Stipulation filed herein on January 12, 1968 pey to the TRAVELERS IS INSURANCE COMPANT the following auma ea their proportionate a h a of 14 all liability for this Injury for relabursesent for permanent disa 15 bility, temporary disability, and medical expense heretofore paid by 16 17 18 19 . 80 21 22 23 24 TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANYi , PACIFIC EMPLOYERS' INSURANCE COMPANY PLANT RUBBER * ASBESTOS COMPANT LIBERTY. MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANT PIREMAN'S PUND INSURANCE COMPANT INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY COMPANY NATIONAL AUTOMOBILE AND CASUALTY IN SURANCE COMPANY CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANT OP CALIFORNIA * MISSION INSURANCE COMPANY AETNA CASUALTY 6s SURETY COMPANT .16* .19* .008 .058 ' .052 .019 .109 .024 .2*5 2339.46 2767.*! 11*.12 827.37 7*1.78 271.03 155*.89 350.00 3*9*.93 DATED AX'LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA, this'22nd day of January, *968. 29 26 (SEAL) 27 WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS SOAP 28 SERVED B Y MAIL ON ALL. PASTIES LISTED ON THE OFFICIAL ADDRESS RECORD 29 Dates 1-22-68 tt|dpb . By: D.P.Brennan -- ' 30 CMtM Merooemi 3&2W "*** 08 AAV SL CUMMIfM imaoo x MttiHvrr n r iuAwfii M4AM PAaCMVAMAX Rtv.ciVcu *T McLaughxjn, Evanv D a u e y e Cummxnc ATTO*NCY* AT t*AW > , IT1THMT1I HMMLAM&AVCNUC WlTt?10 , w'v! i swing qaupqania M e u ; <99> M ltn m a t t e r u 136. X Varfanea'j Gwnprtuxooa Appeals Boerd 207 South. Brosdeay loo Angelos, California IIWSWWS WCAB BkNa BaxtefDhtc G cntiaem TJTFTf ORCKBHSBJBjE. 61 Ml 250 245, ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) Yaar rarn d ra is m p atlu lfr iatited to tee fattowte; Axadxd plate find dnljKxcautd Coapnmiie itKetexteterjear approval. Atgaae b hereby m d e lor farther h a s te ; to panto <waenuaaaan of ' ta d pwentxaoo U rebuttal evidence. Flea* enter ear appesnsee a atteroeyt ter - Platt setcuefartxtela tea* arcnow ones in aatot. AtttrtirH far S ite; herein arc STimATIOK WITH REQUEST FOR AWARD A i m jRoaaDiNes under labor cods dated. January 10 1963 COpttt tOi Brobeek.Phleger & Harrlooa very m u y youn*. Pacifie Employers Insurance Co, liberty Mutual insurance Co MeLAUGHLIN, EVANS, DALBEY fc CUMM1NG Flreaan's Toad Insurance CO.-L.A. Weingand, Kendig & Stocfcwell *v ' {_ Industrial Indesaity Co.-UA. juy cwoniag Notloool Autotaobile & Casualty Ins,Co. Mission Insurance^Cotnpany Casualty las. Co. of Calif. Travelers Insurance Co. - 'S (X a ^3 0= *vl X MCLAUGHLIN, EVANS, SALBET & CUMMING CJ z 1717 North Highland Avenue- Suit* 710 Loa Angolas, California. 90028 3 Hollywood 6-854L 4 Attorneys for Defendant* f3 S 8 7 S* 8 BEFORE T H E WORKMEN.1S COMPENSATIO APPEALS B0A20 ' 1 ' 9 O T THE STATE OT CALIFORNIA 10 11 LEONARD CHA2LES BROKENSHXRE, 12 A p p lican t , 13 V. 14 ARMSTRONG CONTRACTOR? AND SUPPLY COMPANY, at al, IS Defendants; 18 CASE HO. 63 LA 250 245 STTPOZATION WITH REQUEST FOR. AWARD AFTER SUPPLEMEHTHY PROCEEDINGS UNDER LABOR C O S SECTION 5500.5 17 Tha parties to this agreement, eater lata the following 18 tlpulation* and request tha Workmen's Compensation Appeals Board. 19 Issue its Findings and Award, without further proceeding*. 20 t 21 LEONARD CHARLES BROKERSHIRE. Applicant herein, while employed 22 by various employers, -j In 1941 to a February 8, 23 1963,-developed ashesteals. 24 n _ ' _ . ` 25 Tha Applicant elected to proceed for benefits against ARMSTRONG 26 CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY COMPANY, Insured during period of sxposursi 27 at various tines by AETNA CASUALTY AND SURETY COMPANY sad TRAVELERS 28 INSURANCE COMPANY. ' 29 hi SO That the Workmen'* Compensation Appeal* Board (then Industrial 31 Accident Commission) issued, its Findings end Award on November 6, 196: 32 herein, the Applicant wee awarded permanent disability of 62% which, j 07874 s *c th* rat o $52.50- per week, equaled $O',020.00; temporary 2 disability far tfc* period beginning February 9, 1963 through: June 9, $ 1963 t t tii* race o 970*00, <ad farther medical. treatment far fti balene o Applicant's life - | S - . ' ! 5 Thee pursuant to said Findings and. Award, TRA9ZI2RS pK ^raaffT ' 7 CCWPAHr has paid 914,265.00 consisting of 913,020.00 far permanent I - 8 disability indemni ty 9360.00 temporary disability indemnity, 9 9285.00 aedieal expense. 10 ? 21 Zha Applicane was esployed b y tfa* fallowing a t various -*-- 22 between. 1941 and February 8, 1963 boa workman's compensation 13 Insurance carries during said period of exposure is also daslgnatad: 14 Plane Rubber & Asbestos Works Permissibly self-insured. 15 Riley Stoker Corporation. 16 liberty Mutual Insurance Company 17 Marina Engineering & Supply Paelfie Employers Insurance ' Company - Compa n y . 18 19 Thorpe Insulation Company aka Pacific Employers Insurance Plane Insulation. Company 20 Company and Fireman's Fund Insurance Company 21 Fiberglass Eng1nae,-lwg & 22 Supply Company Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. 23 Owens-Corning Fiberglass Company 24 Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. 25 Reece Insulation Company 26 Industrial Indemnity Company and Rational Automobile & Casualty Inauranea Company 27 John Manvilla Sales Corp. Travelers Insurance Company 28 Mundet Cork Corporation Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. 29 Accurate Insulation. Company, casualty insurance Company of Inc. California and Mission 30 Insurance Company 31 Coast Insulation Company, Inc. Pacific Employers Insurance Company 32 -2- Armstrong Corporation Travelers Insurance Company' & Aetna Casualty & Surety* Co. 807875 VT a For their respective, employers,, the insurance carriers' 2 percentage o liability is as follows t 3 Pacific Employers Insuraaca Company .164- $ 2339.48 4 Plant Robber & Asbestos Company .194- 2767.41 5 Liberty Mutual Insurance Company .008 114.12 ff Fireman's Fund Insurance Company .058 827.37 7 Industrial Indemnity Company .052 741.78 2 National Automobile and Casualty Insurance Company 9 Casualty Insurance Company of 10 California ' . ,0< lf .109 271.03 1554.89 IX Mission Insurance Company .024 350.00 12 Aetna Casualty 4 Surety Company 13 Tbs Travelers Insurance 14 Company .245 .118 3494.93 1683.27 Iff Iff 17 vxr 18 That a Findings and Award b e issued assessing liability in 19 tfae percentages set forth in paragraph VI and that, the 20 monetary amounts designated in said paragraph be ordered paid 21 forthwith to the Travelers Insurance Company. 22 DAZES this / d ? day of*S > s^ e % 196J. ; ^ lv 23 PLANT RUBBER & ASBESTOS WORKS aka * FXBREBCAKD CORPORATION - ' 24 By : l C d w * ' 25 PACIFIC SURANCE COMPANT By : V 26 L LIBERT? MUTBAll INSURANCE /COMPANY \ .' 27 rBy: j .C.- } s > 28 .FIRMAN'S FQND'INSURANCE COMPANY 'Bv: VS&1*-- - 29 AETNA .CASUALTY & ffURETY C0KEAN3L_. 30 Bv: ^ ---- t v / 31 BIDUSTRIAx" TOE&1NITY COMPANY Bv: 4 A + U J - tP. ? A 3 Y -- 32 3- X Z 3 4 5 6 7 a . 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 1T la 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 NATIONAL AUTOMOBILE AMD. CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY,-" ... . . Bvr / ' ./ .Y. ^ / < y / ->rf ' - ` -4 0787G 807877 1 WORKMEN S' COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD STATE OF CALIFORNIA 3 CASE NO. 63 LA Z5Q-35 4 5 taQWATO CHARLES BROKENSHIRE, C Applicant, MINUTES r OF 8 ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPL . COMPANY, a- corporation; PLANT . ? INSULATION COMPANY-; MARINE ENG2BESOTG AND SUPPLY-COMPANY; FIBERGLASS ____ . io ENGINEERING AND SUPPLY COMPANY-} REECE INSULATION COMPANY; THORPE INSULATION u COMPANY;MUDET CORK CORPORATION; ACCURATE INSULATION COMPANY; AETNA FURTHER BEARING AND ORDER TAKING OFF CALENDAR 13 CASUALTY ft SURETY COMPANY, corporation; THE TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY, a 13 corporation; FIREMAN'S FUND INSURANCE COMPANY, a corporation; CASUALTY 14 INSURANCE COMPANY CF CALIFORNIA, a corporation; MISSION INSURANCE IS COMPANY, Successor in Interest to Brted i t Los Ang*H*. Enterprise Inaurane Company, a , Catifemie 18 corporation; PACIFIC XNDEMNixi COMPANY, a corporation; PLANT -RUBBER ft ASBESTOS ; wrijiw IT WORKS V PACIFIC INDEMNITY COMPANY, a corporation; RILEY STOKER CORPORATION; I fit 18 U B S OE Y MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, a corporation; PACSTIC EMPLOYERS INSURANCE < in -Mtfuttf tm ts 19 COMPANY, a corporation; OWENS-CORKING FIBERGLASS COMPANY; COAST INSULATING '.FFTA'-J SC4W ` or,-** ? .urMC . 20 PRODUCTS COMPANY} INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY CCMPANY, a corporation; NATIONAL 10 1^7 ' L ' ZL AUTOMOBILE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, a corporation; FIBREBOARD PAPER 23 PRODUCTS CORPORATION, a corporation, Defendants. 23 24 THIS CAUSE came on. for trial October 9, 1967 at 9tOO a^s.- 29 in Department 5 of the Workmen's Compensation Appeals Board, . 28 Los Angeles, California, before the Honorable ROBERT V , DUBEAU, 27 Referee. 28 . Beth Irene Marriott, Official Reporter 29 APPEARANCES: 30 Leonard Charles Brofcenshlre, applicant Tam imm e >}A><1 -1 - 4>** 8 6 r 8 9 10 1 13 13 14 18 18 IT 18 19 20 21 22 25 24 28 28 27 28 29 30 NttMnftAo4 MWtifl I m}Mat ' (Df cc cc -si cc APPEARANCES: (contined) HAroId P. Shoop, representative for Firm a n 's Fund, Ihsuranei Company McConnell & Cranoline, toy H. F. Hblrer, attorneys for P&elft Enployars Insurance Company Brotoeck, Phleger & Harrison, toy Attorney Sclaroni, attorneys for Plant Rubber k Asbestos Works and Fltoreboard Paper Products Corporation Charles P. Carlstroem, toy Wllltanr N. Roberson, attorneys fox Riley Stoker Corporation and Liberty Mutual Insurance Company F V. Harrington, representative for Mission Insurance Compa a corporation, Successor In Interest to Qrserprise Insurance Company, a corporation Zonnl, Oinocchlo k Taylor, toy William Blanchard, attorneys f Casualty Insurance Company of California and Accurate insulation Company Weingand, Kendig k Stockwell, toy E- H. Kendig, attorneys for Aetna Casualty k Surety Company Clapton k Penny, by Robert R. Wills, attorneys for Industrie. Indemnity Company McLaughlin, Evans, Oalbey k Gumming, toy Ray B. Cumming and Barry F, Evans, attorneys for Armstrong Contracting and Supply Company and Ebe Travelers Insurance Company Albert A. Atkinson, representative for National Automobile and Casualty Insurance Company WITNESSESr None EXHIBITSt NONE DISPOSITION: Pending the probable resolution of all Issues b y stipulation, and GOOD CAUSE APPEARING THEREFOR: . IT IS ORDERED the above-entitled case be, and the same hereby is, taken off calendar, subject to toeing reset upon written reques of any party hereto. Service of this Order is waived. ------- s REFEREE WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD 2-  Cfl< / ^ ^ ^ 09 o DEPARTMENT O F INDUSTRIAL. RELATIONS M 09 WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARD CO rATCOFCAUTORNIA __ . ? H B d<01P2C 62V 0"+. ANSWER rf PACIFIC n m a n m w Tin. .BKMBP ESOSSSSHEffl______________ -- ---- ' iw n 63LA 2TO ?Ur_______ a t^ t a .t.j 12- y gaoigs nrsnu n o i r c o m p a r t .p a c i f i c nrpB-nrnr compaitt -ZftL m s s , M S A M ratBSj cdr.Twr .^20Q tfTTB-nig a n m IQg ASSETJg, gir. uoittr fa-Mif 4 wmmu . UaU h y far t o w .NriadxrfdhaUW . formanonl dbsU R f IT Iff RrtTHK AUfiMDr . 1. M andant fio** paid dTmfelltty'Indemnity In dm tomi amaant of * RUHR -- dm tom of L i Affrantivn datone end arimr LACK OF NOT ICS ' pL_JURISDICTION STATOTB n? r.nrmfTnw.^ M andant do net worn dm right to r a te additem i te n in nrrnadanca idi dm proinant of law mid dm tuiaa of noetica i! other tutmb develop. fwfcnnuj AS defenda n t medical reports how# fc fled_________ AddWoool reparti wilt ba filed before ***** * fra*triai wontedj _ _ ru a BlAWtrfatitiuiRaMwmrri<sM<MnStCv)i.aei ovai " IATO AWIrfiI.ll .Coitemi* PACIFJC TTOffCTTTT CCOOMHIB m , tasto ' ''TPMHiITTL COLLINS 1 3200 WIISHIRS BITO- tos inrx.T.v.s (iwwa m* m i n a i m a s irrtu a ) 1 331-3211 e x t blW nanna un in (DA Ib t a m r t a the application^ v tm ak e allegation *<i are raise the sues which a n checked below. Should o th er b u m oocoow known to be proper and. n tseaw y derelep later we tocrare the rig h t to n u n m k additional awe i s v ~ r i wi t h the provision* o f law and. the rale o f the Commiariao. . S Employment (2 a t the time of injury N IS- N ata n and extentof disability S Occupation of employee * 2 LiabiGtr for medical treatm ent S Injury ariringoutaf aadorcnrrrng i s the count of employment Q Statute olimitation Q Inaurancccoverage (Employer hat b ets . notified appear and defend) a ------------------- :-------- Q ---------------------------- Q y.rAW reporte have been erred at luted in covering letter. DieehtSty indem nity baa b e ta peid a t fellow: Ttm poory? N il Permanent: Beginning _au_ fn wear! Tewln/ftmy * *" -- *`dwdtwg........ -- }T o rJ y------ _ _ ( t . ....,, a week {Total $ %------ ____a week 'W w believe T^'ar the presentation of o u r evidence w ill require a minimum of. P*imirrA m r n W ofw itm M et, i f e e eflsM e . Pacific Loyers urance Company Byt Robert S. Guthrie, Authorized Reprsentt 4050 Vilshlre Blvd., Los Angeles, Calif. (Tele; 381-2611) . ^ . . .,90005 Norm ACOFTef this Aonse dull bessvideeiU sdnss* p stis, or aefciaam iy* sadsaoouoBf schism e and tie pens a n e i oust beaade heme. .. . sc: STEARNS and OIOSS, Attorneys at Law Byt Richard T. Gross, Attorney 9200 Colima Rd., Whittier, California. aSD/ah -  :.y 807881 SEPAREMENT CP' LNOTSTRXAC. RELATIONS VOSEKEN' Z COOEENSATXCN A P P E A U BOARQ . BEATS. O P CAEBCHNIA ESDNAHS CHASSES BRQK5X3HXRS AppIAaanft- n. - ARMSTRONG CSNTRACTZNCr ART SSPFtE COMPANY t corporation; t al . Dfendant* Caae Ko. $3C1 290 24$ sonos, or t u b a nd PZACS or FURTHES HSARZKS m M n . arma W w<m"t' u---m----s"i' **r r wu*t nm* " FEBS 1936 B O U C S TO ASC PARTIES . y o u .i r * hereby notifiad that fMrtftar haarlng *111 te bald la tha above-antitled action at AlffT SOS ANGELES STATE OFFICE SOTLBZNa, 10T SOQTB BROADWAY SOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA tore* 29, 1966 9*40 A.M. ail day Sated att LOS ANGELES . . f Q 9 1365 ' VQRKMEN'S CCMPSiSATION APPEALS BOARD XOTS: CQNTONUANCZS ANS FOHTHER HEARINGS ARE KOT PAVORSD. Sa* attaehed jolndar for serviea. .1AR 22 1SSS {Signatr of"perao r serving notice) X '- Cc o . -sT CO ' CO rc t. BEFORE THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFOR z CASE NO. 63 L.A. 250-245 s LEONARD CHARLES BROKENSHIRE, ) 4 . . Applicant 8 rs ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUFFL ) CONFANE x. corporation; PLANT r INSULATION COMPANY; MARINE ENGIN- ) MINUTES OF FURTHER HEARING ERRINO AND SUPPLE COMPANE; FIBER- AND 8 QLASS ENGINEERING AND SUPPLE COM- ) ORDER JOINING PARTE DEFENDANT PANE; REECE INSULATION COMPANE; AND 9 THORPE INSULATION COMPANE; MUDET ) ORDER TAXING OFF CALENDAR CORE CORPORATION;' ACCURATE IN 10 SULATION COMPANY; AETNA CASU- } ALTE fc SURETY COMPANE a corpora 11 tion; THE TRAVELERS INSURANCE ) COMPANE, a corporation; FIREMAN* S 12 FUND INSURANCE COMPANY, a corpora-) tlon; CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY DATED AT tOS ANGELS CXUFOSNM IS OF CALIFORNIA a corporation; ) MISSION INSURANCE COMPANY, Suc 14 cessor in Interest to Enterprise ) JULI 51364 Insurance Company, a corporation; 18 PACIFIC INDEMNITY COMPANY, :. ) a 'corporation, 18 C*.BA. INS..JkiT-- 1NSA__ in.a ___ SUF__ Defendants. ir 18 THIS CAUSE can on for hearing on July 13, 1964, at 9:00 a.m 19 In Department 13 of the Industrial Accident Commission Los Angel 20 California, before the Honorable CHARLES GLASMAN, Referee. 21 Gladys M. Behilag. Reporter 22 PRESENT; . 23 Leonard. Charles Brokenshlre, Applicant 24 S t e a m s 4s Gross, by Richard Gross, Attorneys for applicant 28 Welngand, Nandig 4s Stockwell, by Ross C. 29 Irwin, Attorneys for Armstrong Con- tractlag and Supply Company; Aetna Casu 27 alty it Surety Company; Mudet Cork Cor poration; Fiberglass Engineering and 28 Supply Company Zonni, Ginocchio 4 Taylor, by Ben ?. 29 Taylor, Attorneys for Accurate Insula tion Company and Casualty Insurance 30 Company of California ' 0 pp test. Bk. #33 -1 - ,<w >r ce O si ca co CO 1 ' s 4 8 e 7 a 9 10 11 12 13 14 18 16 ir 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 28 26 27 28 29 30 S C R E THE. INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION 0? THE STATE OP CALTF0R1 T CASE NO. 53 LJl. 250-24 ECNARD CHARLES BROKENSHXHE, J Applicant, i rs ' RMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY OMPANY, a corporation; PLANT NSULATION COMPANY; MARINE ENGIN- ) BRING AND SUPPLY COMPANY; FIBER- LASS ENGINEERING AND SUPPLY COM- ) ANY; REECE INSULATION COMPANY; HCRPE INSULATION COMPANY; KUDET ) ORE CORPORATION; ACCURATE IN- . ULATION COMPANY; AETNA CASU- ) LTY I SURETY COMPANY, a corpora- ion; THE TRAVELERS INSURANCE ) CMPANY, a. corporation; FIREMAN'S UNS INSURANCE COMPANY, a corpora-) ion; CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY ip CALIFORNIA, & corporation; SSSION INSURANCE COMPANY, Sue- essor in Interest to Enterprise insurance Company, a corporation; ACXFIC INDEMNITY COMPANY,T 'corporation. MINUTES OP FURTHER HEARING AND ORDER JOINING PARTY DEPENDANT AND ORDER TAKING OFF CALENDAR DATS AT tOS ANGELE CjUPORNIA vmus JUL1512S4 R ____ c.------ b a _ tN$.--WdL_. INSA. in.a. .SUN. Dependants. *wrra CAUSE cams on for hearing on July 13, 1964, at 9&00 a.a. n Department 13 of the Industrial Accident Commission, Los Angele: California, before the Honorable CHARLES GLASMAN, Referee. . Gladys M. Behllng, Reporter Leonard Charles Brolcenahire, Applicant . Stearns It Gross, by Richard Gross, Attorneys for applicant tfeingand, Kendig Is Stoelcvell, by Ross C. Irwin, Attorneys for Armstrong Con tracting and Supply Company; Aetna Casu alty it Surety Company; Mudet Corle Cor poration; Fiberglass Engineering and Supply Company Zonnl, Ginocchio Is Taylor, by Ben P. Taylor, Attorneys for Accurate.Insula tion Company and Casualty Insurance Company of California pp test. : #33 -1 - BEFORE THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION OF THE STATE O F CALZFORN! *** CASE NO, 63 I A 250 245 LEONARD CHARTES BROKENSHIEE, Applicant, ; V*, ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUFFIT COM?ANT, a corporation, et si. Defendants. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BT MAIL OF PETITION FOR SUPPLEMENTART PROCEEDINGS TO ESTABLISH APPORTIONMENT OF LIABILITY AND RIGHT OF CONTRIBUTION PURSUANT TO LABOR CODE SECTION 5500.5 : > 8 *.4* c . . 7mt*. r IT i< STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) it. COUNT! OF LOS ANGELES) t\ 3 c i3! i 1 rATHi-KHW DAWSON, being first duly sworn says: char affiant is a citizen of the United States and. a raaidanc o f the county aforaaaid; that affiant la over tha ege of eighteen yaara and ia not a party to tha within above-entitled action; chat affiant's buainasa addresa ia 6725 Sunaat Boulevard, Lot Angelas 28, California; that o n January 6, 1966 affiant served copies of petition for Supplementary Proceedings to Establish Apportionment of Liability and Right of Contribution Pursuant to Labor Code Section 5500.5 on the parties- listed below, by placing said copies ia a sealed envelope with postage thereon fully prepaid, in the United States post office mail box at 6725 Sunsat Boulevard, Los Angeles 28, California, addressed as follows: Pleat Rubber & Asbestos Works 537 Bracnan SC. San Francisco, California Pacific Indemnity Company 3200 Wilshire Boulevard Loa Angeles, California Riley Stoker Corporation 9 Neponsae Street Worcester, Massachusetts Liberty Mutual Insurance Company 6006 Wilshire Boulevard Los Angeles, California ikCtE JAS i 9S{ U U .SS3if 1 Merlo* Engineering and Suppl/ Co. 941 Ease 2nd Screen Z los Angele*, California 90012 17 18 19 20 21 ZZ 23 24 25 28 27 28 29 30 31 32 -2 - I V8808 ; 7 JQH* T.MUUMMU *Am* * CVAMA I wM, t u t * e*tacv * *+r %. CUMM4M . M M U x tNMcrr i > * \ >SyUS7?.iw COlOS*^ McU u o h u k . Evans. Da i i c t & Cum m ins *TTONCV*'T lXw r M N tr t aogucvAS LO*AMgftlt,CAMroani M C M January 5, 1966 . WUVI I1` 0 5- n'iu r... _E:CflSir__ cAic h:._ ____________ .<F3L Indus trial Accident Commission. ' 107 South Broadway . Los Angeles 12r California Sa: Casa No. 63 LA 250 245 Laonard Charlas Brokanahire vs, Armstrong Contracting & Supply company, se al. Gantleaan: Consistane with tha Petition of Travelers Insurance Company for supplementary proceedings, we are requesting chat Che following employers and carriers be joined as party defendants: o p it* Q U EliBSJtubber 4 Asbestos Works, 537 Brennan St., San Francisco, CAlirornia and its I n s u r a n c e c o m p a n y - Paetfla TndepMey ffa. 3200 Wilshlre Blvd , Los Angeles, California. S i i t i Stoker Corporation, 9 Nepoqset St., Worcester, Massachu setts , and its insurance companyfl/Llbertv Mutual Insurance Co. 6006 Wilshire Blvd , Los Angeles, Caliti '.'JL'.'t @ Marine Engineering and Supply Co., 941 E. 2nd Sc., Los Angeles, ' Calif. 90012. The carries for this particular employer is * to date unknown. We ere serving e copy of this letter upon the persons listed Jabove as well as serving them with a copy of the Petition for Supplementary Proceedings and tha documents attached thereto. We ask chat this matter be restored to calendar f n r a one-full day hearing. Tours very truly, M cLa u g h l i n , e v a n s , d a lb e t & comm u t o BPEikd By: cc: Stearns, Gross & Moore ec: Weingand, Kendig & Stockwell cc; Zonal, Ginocchio & Taylor uni. usua'- / Harold Shoop, Representing Thorp' Insulation Company and. Fireman.' s Fund Xnsuranc Company McLaughlin, Evans, Dalbey & Cumming, by John McLaughlin, Attorneys for Armstrong Contract ing and Supply Company and The Travelers In surance Company . Harold Bennett, Representing Accurate Insula tion Company and Mission Insurance Company, suecessor in interest to Enterprise Insur ance Company* No appearances by or for Plant Insulation Com pany; Marine Engineering and Supply. Company and Reece Insulation Company . COCO CAUSE APPEARING THEREFOR, . 13? IS ORDERED That Pacific Indemnity Company, a corpora tion, be, and It hereby is, Joined as a party defendant. DISPOSITION: TO permit further investigation on Issues of coverage : end employment, end, GOOD CAUSE APPEARING THEREFOR, I]| xs ORDERED That the above-entitled matter be taken off calendar subject to being reset upon request of any of the parties. Service of this Order has been waived by the parties. thereto except Pacific Indemnity Company. Copy of this Order to be served on Pacific Indemnity Company. Referee INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION -2 - '' ' 1- ! ' S jiij 807888 JL BOTORE THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION OP THE STATE OP CALIFQR 2 CASE NO. 63 L.A. 250-2*5 S LEONARD CHARLES BRGKENSHIEB, 4 Applicant, 9 ' 6 ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPL COM?ANI, a corporation; PLANT T INSULATION COMPANT; MARINE ENGIN- ) E E U N G AND SUPPL? CCMPAN?; FIBER. a GLASS ENGINEERING AND SUPPLT COX- ) PAN?; REECE INSULATION COMPANT; 9 THORPE INSULATION COMPAN?) MUDET ) CORK CORPORATION; ACCURATE IN 10 SULATION COMPAN?; AETNA CASO- ) 11 ALT? 4 SURET? COMPANY, a c o m o r a -- tlon; TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY,) xs a corporation; FIREMAN'S FUND INSURANCE COMPANY, a. corporation; ) CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY OP 13 CALIFORNIA, a corporation; ) MISSION INSURANCE COMPANY, Sue14 cesser In Interest to Enterprise ) 15 Insurance Company, a corporation, le Dfendante. MINUTES OP FURTHER HEARING MunWeTuALT9A4cPoSoAefbffgcMolmAme/ssi JUN2S a w g r V/JU.1AM KAPLA A*r. saxr.-ur 17 THIS CAUSE cane on for hearing on JUne 23, 196*, at 9:00 a.o. 16 la Department 13 of the Industrial Accident Commission, Los 19 Angeles, California, before the Honorable CHARLES GLASMAN, Referee. 20 Gladys M. Behllng,. Reporter 21 PRESENT: 22 Leonard. Charles Brokenshire, Applicant 23 S t e a m s 4 Gross, by Richard Gross, Attorneys for applicant 24 Weingand, Kendlg 4 Stockwell, by Ross Ireln, 25 Attorneys for Armstrong Contracting and Supply Company; Aetna Casualty & Surety 26 Company; Mudet Cork Corporation; Fiberglass Engineering and Supply Company 27 Zonni, Glnocchio 4 Taylor, by Marco J . Zonni, 28 aAntdtorCnaesyusalftoyrIAncscuurraantcee ICnomspualantyioofn CCoamlpiafnoyrnia 29 0 pp test. Bk. #29 30 -1 - 9m 07889 I ! Harold Shoop, Representing Thorpe Insulation Company and Fireman's Fund Insurance Company McLaughlin, Evans, Dalbey 4 Cunmdng, by Cohn McLaughlin, Attorneys for Armstrong Contract ing and Supply Company and Travelers Insur-anee Company Hhrold Bennett, Representing Accurate Insulation Company and Mission Insurance Company, successor 1b interest to Enterprise Insurance Company . appearance* by o r for Flant Insulation Company; Marine &igineering end Supply Company and Reece Insulation Company . . r r IS STIPULATED That Aetna Casualty 4 Surety Company was the workmen's compensation: insurance carrier for Fiber-glass Sigineering and Supply Company from January 1, 1953, to September 1, 1955. VS IS FURTHER STIPULATED That Aetna Casualty 4 Surety Company was the workmen1s compensation insurance carrier for toidet Corle Corporation from December 31, 1956, through Decern- 3 1 , 1 9 5 9 , and that the applicant was a l l o y e d b y Mudet Cork Corporation from March 195T through February 19 5 9 . IT. IS FURTHER STIPULATED That Casualty Insurance Company of California was the workmen* s compensation insurance car rier for Accurate Insulation Company from April 1 , 19 5 9 , through February 1, 1961, and that the applicant was employed by Accurate Insulation Company during this same period. XT IS FURTHER SUPtJLAIH) That Mission Insurance Company, successor in interest to Enterprise Insurance Company, was the workmen's compensation insurance carrier for Accurate Insula tion Company from February 1, 196I, through March 25, 1961, and that the applicant was employed by Accurate Insulation Company during said period. -2 - 807890 I T I S FURTHER STIPULATED That Ptreaan's Fund Insurance Company was the workmen's compensation Insurance carrier for Thorp InsuJatlon Company- from October 1, 1956, through. Octo ber x, 1957- DISPOSITION:. At the request o f the parties the matter sow stands ad journed until 9:00 a .a. on July 13, 1964, in accordance with the Notice of Further Hearing- dated May 27, 1964. -3 - I 03 o v2 OS INDUSTRIAL. ACCIDENT COMMISSION cc TA TS O F CALIFORNIA ZSOB&SD CHARLES BB08X3I3HXBS ' Ffc. ApplienU._ : abmstromg co v ra a c tsro aso supfme CCMPjUZZ, a oorpora.tionj et al O tfn iitn tJi scrynatBStic. Notice of Time and. Place of Further Hearing OS DEFEBDAHT OEAVEIEES 32IS F s s m o v for sopplehshtahz PROCEED DGS 10 gflmflT.Tgg APPORTIOKKOEX OP LULBIUTI usd lasa o? coKiaiaraos FCHSOAET TO LABOR COOS a serio 5500.5 NOTICE TO ALL PARTIES T o a hertby norifitd tht fa r hearing willbe heU jn th ibore-enricled 4107 LOS ANGELES STATE OFFICE BUILDING, or s c o r a LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA OTTO 2 3 . 1961^ 9*00 A J . -1 /2 DAT ad. JTJLZ 13 A Ut* 1961^9*00 U I .> TVO DAZS D o t i u i LOS ANGELES CifK W, LLIAM , INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION Nora CONTINUANCES AND FURTHER HEARINGS AXE NOT FAVORED, t u i a AMO ABDUS 0* TUONI V t D OAR 5-27-61* Leonard C. Brolceashlra, 11*717 Liabacher ATO.Borvalk.Cal. Staaraa k Oreas,9200 Colina Hd. Whittier, Cal. A n a t r o a g Coa tracting k Sappi7 Co .1*31*0 District Blvd.LA9005S Plaat Insulation Co.271*1 3 Zatas Avs.IA Fiberglass Sag.* Supply Co.5933 Talegraph Ed.LA Ihorpe Insulation Co.271*1 S. Zatas At o .LA Hodst Corle Corp.6116 Valicar Ava. Maywood, Cal. Aeeurate Insulation Co.8823 Mattier St. LA90003 Fireaaa* Fuad las.Cd.Boz 2323,1a AttiH. sboop Casualty Las.Co.of Cal.810 S. Spring St.LA Blsaioa Insurance Co.successor to Enterprise Iaa.Co.300 S.Eobart Aetna Cas.& Surety Co.2l*0l* Wilshire Blvd.LA Travelers las. Co.3600 Wilshire Bird.LA Weiagaad,Eeadig k Stockvell,611 S.CataliaaLA McLaughlin,Evan a ,Dalbey k dimming, 6331 Hollywood Blvd.LA.90028 Blvd. >9 <OW, (SIT, M tl ^goodman (rMATUMor SfSOII IUVWI MOTTCO) 00 o si oo eo ro HEPCRSr THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION OP THE STATE OP CALIPC CASE NO* 63 L .A . 2 5 0 -2 4 5 8 9 10 u 12 IS 14 IS 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 29 24 28 28 27 28 29 30 s& r -a IK LEONARD CHARLES BROKEMSHIHE, } Applicant, j. 7*. j ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND ) SUPPLE COMPANT, a corporation: PLANT INSULATION COMPANY; ) MARINE ENQIKE&RINQ AND i SUPPLE CCMPANT; ' j FIBERGLASS ENGINEERING AND SUPPLE COMPANY; j REECE INSULATION COMPANY; THORPE INSULATION COMPANY; } KUDET CORK CORPORATION; ACCURATE INSULATION COMPANY; j AETNA CASUALTY It SURETY COMPANY; t- corporation; ) TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY, t corporation; ) FOREMAN'S FUND INSURANCE COMPANY t corporation; CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY OP CALIFORNIA, a corporation; j ENTERPRISE INSURANCE COMPANY, t corporation, j -- Defendant, ] GOOD CAUSE APPEARING THEREPOR: ORDER JOINING PARTIES DEPENDANT .- . \ ' . IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT Plant Insulation Company, Marine engineering and Supply Company, Fiberglass Engineering and Supply ompany, Reece insulation Company, Thorpe Insulation Conany, Mud orle Corporation, Accurate Insulation Company, Fireman'a Fund nsurance Company, a corporation. Casualty Insurance Company of allfomla, a corporation, and Enterprise Insurance company, a orporation, be Joined as parties defendant in the above entitled ause. '' B;MP HIED AT LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA _- 7 , 1964 ' I ts Referee ) INDUSTRIAL ACdDENT'COMMISSIC - ' . 1 . . * CoO -vi 05 CD . - w 1 BtiOli THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION O F THE STATE OF CALIFOBNIi 2 CASE NO. 63 LA. 250 245 \ 3 4 LEONARD CHARLES BSOKENSHXRE, ) 9 Applicane, v. 7 ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPL CCKHANY, a corporation, a t al. l \ -V PETITION FOR SUPPLEMENTAL!" X PROCEEDINGS TO ESTABLISH APPORTIONMENT OP LIABILITY 1 AND RIGHT OF CONTRIBUTION PURSUANT TO LABOR CODE SECTION 5500.5 9 D efendants. 10 11 tta Travelers Insuranca Company, a corporation, in support 12 os said Petition, alleges and avers as follows: 13 r . liM ' Sii! <;5l 14 ,5 alleging 10 asbestos 18 Application was filed in the above matter on March 15, 196.' Injury on February 8, 1963 by reason of exposure to resulting Is the occupational disease of asbestesis. ' n At a hearing upon this application before the Industrial 19 Accident Commission at Los Angeles, Californie on July 30, 1963, 20 said application was amended to allege a period of injury commencing, 21 in 1941 and ending on February 8, 1963. . ' 22 III 23 At e further hearing before the Industrial Accident 24 Conanission on July 30, 1963, the applicant elected under Labor Code 29 Section 5500.5 to proceed against the last employer, Armstrong 20 Contracting end Supply Company, and its Insurance Carrier, your 27 Petitioner, with respect to its period of coverage from April 2, 1951 - 28 co January, 1963. 29 17 30 The Industrial Accident Commission issued Its Minutes of 31 Further Hearing and Award on November 6, 1963, a copy of which is 32 attached hereto and marked Petitioners Exhibit !,A". Tour Petitioner MCLAUOHUN * JGZ~ ft** (31-.. / i' i-- * i 607894 t /' MttlAUUtlLIN O VAN AtVOMMCVA AT LAW 1 has complied and is still complying with the terms of that Award. 2 T 3 Based upon the medical evidence filed in the above matter, 4 copies o which are attached hereCo, your Petitioner contends chat 5 applicant's injury consists of the industrial disease known as 6 asbestosis which is due and eausad by applicant's erposura to 7 asbestos during his period of employment from 5 * to February 8 8 1963. ^ 9 vr 10 Z o v r Petitioner further allega, that applicant vas employed 11 and exposed to asbestos during that period of by various 12 employers who were insured for workmen's compensation insurance lby 13 various insurance carriers as see forth in Exhibit "B" attached j l . u hereto. 3!" ' , m - i" ! | I 17 Sj 18 That pursuant to Labor Code Section 5500.5, your Petitioner is entitled to e determinacin by the Industrial Accident Coanission with regard to an apportionment of its liability as wall as to a 19! right of contribution with respect to payments which it has made 20 i under the terms of the Commission's Decision of November 6 , 1963. 21 WHEBEF0SS, it is requested thee a hearing be scheduled in 22| the above matter for the purpose of datarmining the above issues. 23j Dated: April g f r . 1964. . 24 23 26 Respectfully submitted, KcLACGHLXN, EVANS, DALBEY & GUMMING 27 5yJ- f i b r i & t y T O M, A * Attorneys for* Petitioner 28}) . 29 301 311 32 2- S6U 4.08; 7 - 32L2XSL SCHEDULE OF EMPLOYMENT PERIOD OF EMPLOYMENT cn t t INSURANCE CA3RI } Slant Insulation. Co. 2741 S. Tates Avenue Los Angeles, Calif. 1 Marine Engineering and Company address (unknown) Supply . . L94L Co April, 1950. / April 1950 to December, 1952 Fiberglass Engineering and. Supply Company 5933 Telegraph Road Los Angelas, Calif. December, 1952 to August, 1955 Reece Insulation Company address (unknown) Plant Insulation Co.-- Thorpe Insulation Company 2741 S. Tates Avenue . Los Angeles, Calif. August 1955 to . JI7 , 1956 July, 1956 to Mrfreh, 1957 Mudat Cork Corporation 6116 Walker Avenue Maywood, California . ' Htrch, 1957 to October, 1959 - Accurate Insulation Co 8823 Ksetiar Street Los Angeles 3, Calif October, 1959 to April, 1961 Armstrong Contracting and Supply Corporation 434c District Boulevard Los Angeles 58, Calif. April, 1961 to February, 1963 . , unknown. . unknown Aetna Casualty and Surtey Company unknown Fireman's Fund Insurance Company Aetna Casualty and Surety Company Casualty Insurance Company of Califor and Enterprise Ins Company Travelers Insuranc ' Company and Aetna Casualty and Surat Company EXHIBIT B - ' ' J * /. 00 a -v] oc t statxor CAnrcsm c: I co tn m ro r z . ----------- B arir F. Szans_______________ oam. o 3 l-l****^-- - ....-- AC<-rrr-oy n-F 4 3 l d t aitUi mi Amt militi d -- m__1 W _ 6 :or S m w l m K n t a i T Procegcitn^s ro Ssrahlf', Apportionoant o Liabiliftr and H ic h t o r C o n trib u c i n P u rsu an c co 1 Labor-Coda Sactton j5QQ.,., -...... , , m itm m it 8 limtktt _hia_ ikMUHr 9 mrndrn 10 bis ftftrm imi bd*ftmd m t w m m m . 11 12 13 m m *#* d 14 *r* pril 9.*7 .a J . t j S w L IX .9 U L A ^ 15 (SUU ____ Xtrntr P*UU U m i Itr m ii Ctm if m i Suu 16 Airmum o r s o m a 17 iTMAn.-uaJkC.cf. STATEor CAUTOBOA cacniicA T x o r s a v ia Y MAJA-- U U k C C f . (2) 18 coamror 19 TSTrSTmSiS^S!!nSS^SlT3mTn>TSr5mm 20 m i mw Wh i t j tii* emmtj tftrmmi; dm tfim t i tmr Ut tir* / tttkitm jm n m i It mt t ?mw ** <A* miiiit ttm t m ittti <riimi tim tfm it 21 mmfm m a tan mtmtr ti tki Sm t Str (/ C A M t mmuti i l Uit mmt, m i mt *ptttr Aik mi tim A -- 22 23 rt- 24 *****----1*25 -- rt i ... i i 26 mrimti t t imiti tuift a* ____________. ______ _ ..... -- i tt i tolm, tr p/mmjttrtte m timttj, A n m /WjrpufV.k li*Utiui Smmfttt i/b aal tw -- 2? tiittm ti mItOtrnt 28 29 30 tifim ii >pav 31 T.i-- . W --J -- . -*' 32 ----- ------- -- J9--- . af iturtij tt Itm i'iottrr Publici/i**4/*rand C*uAtf m m /C4f0rmm f*STSUAV/dlssi*/Knn u* ftmfom mitn Saaius mtU ra^7ic*cr(At / /' ' Oo . ; O - . -j ` ,, . 02 CO -a I BEFORE THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION 0? THE STATE OF CALIFO 2 ' CASE NO. 63 E- A. 250-245 3 4 LEONARD CHARLES SROKENSHXRE, . . . . ) MINUTES OF FURTHER HEARING 9 Applicant, 6 rs. ) AND j r y ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY 8 COMPANY, a corporation; . AETNA CASUALTY k SURETY COMPANY, ) 9 a corporation; TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY, ) 10 a. corporation, ) 11 Defendants. 12 ' AWARD SARD XT COS ANGELS nuo; vs. NOV 61963 / S__JL.im_ C _ W A __ 1 .Z Z Wi.a--- s jr---- 13 THIS CAUSE came on for bearing this 4th day of November, 19 14 nine a.s u , in Department 7 of the Industrial Accident Commission IS Los Angeles, California, before Honorable RICHARD BARRY, Referee. IS H* A. MeNeal, Court Reporter. 17 IS PRESENT; ' ` 19 Leonard Charles Brokenshlre, applicant. 20 Stearns k Gross, by Richard' Gross, attorneys for applicant. 21 Joseph Bilchale, representative for Travelers. . 22 Velngand, Kendlg, Stocksell k Callanan, by E. Kendlg, . attorneys for Aetna. 23 24 WITNESSES; 28 (None) 26 27 EXHIBIT S ; 28 Applicant's 1 - Reports attached to and listed In transmita 29 letters of 4/22/63 and 4/3/63. Defendants' A - Report, 10/30/63, EDGAR F. MAUER, M.D.j report, IO/I0/ 63, HURLEY L. MOTLEY, M.D.j report, 4/8/63, EDGAR ?. MAUER, M.D.j report, 4/4/63, CHESTER ?. BONOF?, M.D.j * report, 3/13/63, JOSEPH SCHMERLER, M.D. 3pp ' ' ' - i : * , 00 O co CO ' Oo L rr IS STIFCLATSD B? AND BETWEEN TKg-PABTTVg AKE FBESB 2 1. That Leonard Charles Brokenshlre, b o m July g, 1907, wa 3 employed by Armstrong Contracting and Supply Company, a corporat 4 as an asbestos working foreman at Los Angeles, California, uric 9 period bat began la 1941 and continued to and Including - 6 February 8, 1963. T 2. That said employer's insurance carrier faming the perlo a that began April 3 1981, and ended December 31, 1962, was 9 Travelers Insurance Company, a corporation, and that the carrier 10 faring the period that began January 1, 1963, to and including IX February 8, 1963 the last date of appUeent's employment, was 12 Aetna Casualty and Surety Company, a corporation. 13 3. That spplloant's employment during the period of covers 14 by Travelers Insurance Company and Aetna Casualty and Surety . 19 Company contributed to applicant's ssbestosls, which constitutes 16 an injury which arose out of and occurred In the course of his 17 said employment. IS 4. That applicant's earning capacity at the time his said 19 injury culminated In disability was in excess of the maximum. 20 5. That all medical treatment has been furnished. 21 6 . That said Injury resulted In temporary disability that 22 began February 3 , 1963, and ended June 9, 1963, entitling the 23 applicant to payments at the rate of $70.00 per week during said 24 period, less the sum of $250.00 that has already been paid. 29 7. That applicant's condition is now permanent and station? 26 8. That applicant has permanent disability as the result oi 27 said Injury that is equal to 62$ of total, which Is equal to 248 28 weeks of permanent disability indemnity at the rate of $52.50 pej 29 week, or a total sum of $13,020.00, payments to begin June 17, IS 30 9. That applicant Is In need of further medical treatment 2- OC \ O -vi oo / CD CD 1 2 3 V 5 6 7 81 10 11 12 13 14 10 16 17 18 19 80 81 22 23 84 28 26 27 28 89 30 99mm 999 mm t-*9mm l a entitled to have- It furnished, to him by the defendant: Insurai e a r n e r s for the balance of his life. ' 10. "m a t the payments and the further treatment will be furnished by travelers Insurance Company, Aetna Casualty and Surety Company agreeing to reimburse travelers Insurance Company in. such amounts as they agree to adjust between themselves. 11. that travelers Insurance Company and Aetna Casualty ant Surety Company reserve their right to proceed against defendant employers and insuranca carriers who are not present In order te assert their contribution rights based on the allegation that applicant's ezppsure extended over a period of time not covered by the Insurance coverage of either of the present defendant insurance carriers, and that this aspect of the.case is to be considered as taken off calendar at'this time to await the fllir of adequate allegations and the joinder of all necessary parties defendant. ' . jL2. Shat an Award may be made a part of the Klautes and bt filed as such without the necessity of any further compliance wl the provisions of Labor Code Section 5313* DISPOSITION; Submitted. ' AWARD AWARD is made in favor of Leonard Charles Brokenshlre again Travelers Insurance Company, a corporation, (Aetna Casualty and -3- .. I `'S 00 o .cc o o 1 Surety Company* a corporation* to reimburse a portion thereof to 2 Travelers Insurance Company In. accordance with the understanding J set forth hereinbefore} In the sua of $13*020.00, together with 4 interest as provided by lair, payable to applicant at the rats of s $52.50 per wash beginning on June 17* 1963*- Plus temporary 9 disability Indemnity for the period. February 9, 1363 and ending r June 9, 1963, at the rate o f $70.00 per weelc, defendants being a entitled to- credit for all sitae heretofore paid on account o f 9 temporary disability Indemnity* plus further medical treatment 10 for the balance of his life* less the sum of $500.00 to be paid 11 directly to applicant's attorneys as the reasonable value of the 12 services. 15 u Iff 16 / -- ..... . 1 RljPbHkbl----------- 17 rmCSTBIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 Peetoa* sr-ar 807901 / CASS NO. 3 L. A. 250-245 LEONARD CHAHLES 3R0KENSHIRE AIMSTRONO. CONTRACTOR AND SUEBL* COMPANY, a. corporation; AETNA CASUALTY fe SDBETY COMPANY. & corporation; TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY, a corporation. REFEREE; HEARING: DICTATED; RICHARD BARRY. NOV. 4, 1963. NOV. 4, 1963. ALT,TOED INJURY; Beginning in. 1941 and andlru Peb. 8, 1963. - S t e r n a A Cross, by Richard Gross, attorneys for applicant. - Joseph BUehalc, representative for Travelers. - Velngand, Kendlg, Stockvell At Callaoan, by E. Sendlg, attorneys for Aetna. . REFEREE'S MEMORANDUM ON TOOTHER HEARING The applicant has proceeded against the last employer who had two Insurance carriers. The parties were able to eater Into stipulations that permitted an Award, all as reflected in the Minutes. The stipulated rating was substantially based on Dr. Mauer's descrip tion of the restrictions that applicant apparently has. It was recognized that applicant has a progressive disease and. that his permanent disability may Increase la the future. However, It is permanent In the sense that It la Irreversible. The Insurance carriers who have liability by reason of the stipulation will pro ceed against other defendants la a supplemental pro ceedings in order to assert their rights of contribu tion. DISPOSITION: Submitted. RB/taMc RICHARD BARRY REFEREE 807902 CASS NO. 63 l>- A. 250-2^5 LEONARD CHARLES BRQKENSHXRE v s. ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY CO. AETNA CASUALTY AND SURETY COMPANY, a corporation; TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY, a corporation. REFEREE: RICHARD BARRY. HEARING: JULY 30, 1963- DICTATEDr JULY 30, 1963- ALLEGED XNJURYr . Beginning in 1941 and ending _ February 8, 1963. - Stearns & Gross, by Richard Gross, attorneys tor applicant. - Veir.gand, Kendig, Stockwcll it Callanan. by E. Kandig, attorneys tor Aetna Casualty and. Surety. HEFEFW-'S MEMORANDUM ON HEARING In his application as amended at the time or this hearing, the applicant alleges Injury to his lungs by reason of exposure to asbestos during a period that began in-1941 and ended 2/8/63 The applicant elected, to proceed against the last employer, Armstrong Contracting and Supply Company. However, the case could not go forward because Aetna Casualty and Surety Company did not have all of the coverage of the last employer. They admitted coverage beginning in January of 1963. Their Information Is that travelers Insurance Company had coverage from April 2, 1961, which is the beginning date of applicant's employment with the said last employer, end up until the time Aetna's coverage began. Travelers Insurance Company was, therefore, Joined as a party defendant. NO other insurance carriers, were Joined because tne informa tion with respect to the prior employers as set forth in applicant's attorneys' letter of 1/25/63 is quite sparse-. Apparently Tiberglaa Engineering and Supply Company was absorbed by Owens-Coming Fiberglass, and their carrier was the defendant Aetna. Aetna also insured Mudet Cork Corporation. Apparently Casualty Insurance Company of California and Enterprise Insurance Company were the carriers for Accurate Insula tion Company. None of the prior employers were Joined at this time. They will be joined at a later date If liability Is established against the last employer, whose insurance carrier, as a matter of aseerting . their rights to contribution, can then proceed against the other em ployers and their carriers. Dr. sohmerler in a First Report Of Injury diagnosed a chronic emphysema and fibrosis. Apparently he has been tne attending physician. His bill In the sum of $159.50 will be paid by Aetna. Applicant's Dr. Hoffmann indicated a diagnosis of possible asbestosia. Defendant Aetna's Dr. Mauer diagnosed pulmonary fibrosis that is probably secon dary to industrial exposure to asbestos. He recommends further tests, including respiratory function tests, and Aetna will see that they are made. Meanwhile, Aetna will also make a monetary advance to applicant. His claimed period of temporary disability began 2/8/63 and ended 0/IO/0; He is now working as an estimator for an asbestos firm. A copy of this memorandum, together with a copy of the application and a copy of applicant's attorneys' letter of 4/25/63, will be served on Travelers Insurance Company so that they will be better advised. DISPOSITION: Continued, to be reset for one full day (not before two months from this date.) RB/MMc FILED. SERVED. V <*"'* ' EE__ ^ EPA 6.7______E R A TM IMS INSA LM. Cl___ SUIF____ ( ^ .jt RICHARD BARRY REFEREE -i QO- ` . O -si I ca . o - GJ KURT O. HOFFMANN, M.D, rruenuczn muibm. oxtut u m ia - is ia s sruessA its* soaa HomtMjb BAurasM* nmwnT M4I*- f t*e April 17.1963 Stearns &. Groas Attornevs at Law 9200 Colima Ed.Whittier./Calif. Ear Leonard Charlas Brokenshire. Oaar Sir, - On tha 11,20-1962 Mr L.C. Brokanablra cam the first time to my office complaining about pain in his chest especially on hi left side. After examining the Pat. tha diagnosis was: U.R.I.,ch: julaonazy fibrosis, poss. asbestosis. B.P.was 120/32. Because of his oain on the left side, EK0 was taken,Findings:Normal. Chest* Xrar taken 11-29-62 in Studebaker Hospital, 13100 Studebaker Rd.i Norwalk showed the following impression: The changes are those ol extreme chronic pulmonary disease manifested b y fibrosis and emph sema. The possibility of an occupational process must be seriousl considered. The second and last time 1 saw Pat. in my office on the 11, of December 1962. He had slighly improved.He was told changing oi his job would be advisable to furthermore improve his condition. Tours very truly *w*r. 807904 0 J O a s m X ICMMDtlXK. M. O . F.&C.J. uiycu*o*c*fc.ecxTCT t**W N (WOK *VNW M in n n etu raw TOMrVn H a n * k , 1963 10 SDK H HIT COacSHSr Bat laanard Brukanahlrt Kr. Loonard Brolcanshix v u xtalaad T as on Babroaiy 2% 1963 ad on. Mnrch **-, 1963. Ha nxffar* fro* aaxfcad t i A n i M ad poaaibla ohrssis aabastosia of tba long. Battant 1* djrajnaac on. *alk1 ng a a nodazata paca, and aarttaly djrapaaae vhan alldsg { U t o r oliabing staiz*. Hovarar, ba la coafortabla sitting, standing1or waUd s g lovljr. . Mr. Bzokanahira la Jafinitaly partilly dlsablad, and la unabla to parfois bia prariooa dntias, vtaich ineludad cllabiag laddart vfaila baariljr vigfatad. Hhabilitt!on o t H diffarant occupation la Josi m /tg ___U.3.C. CJIkOiO* M m u T e n r ua**T0irr ~r totmwii nsnur1a7. rokaunrrosiM POIKQHARI FtmCTIC2I STUDIES BBOSE2I5HZEE( Leonard: 0 5000 October 16, 1963 Dr* Edgar 7. Hsu* The total vital capacity supine was decreased in. a narked decree* The *<-'* vital capacity Tor .three seconds was decreased la a narked, decree a slightly less than the. total'vital capacity observed standing* The "*i breathing capacity wee decreased la a narked degree* The Berime! breathing capacity was increased. from 73*3 to 112*7 -liters per ainntc after one broachodilator treats* with, lauprel indicating the presence of a aodernta degree of bronchospasm. The shape of the spirogram tracing reveals a very alight prolongation of the rapid forced, exhalation without evidence of air trapping* Inspiratory tine on the 53irogram is prolonged indicating loss of lung elasticity, the vit Lty for 0,5 seconds teas 1494 si. 155*! of the observed total vital capaci 1 The tinea vital capacity for 1.0 seconds was 2475 al* (92.5 of the total vital capacity), aorsal. The residual air m s aaasured both by open circuit and. the helium closed circuit methods and found to be decreased slightly. The total lung capacity was decreased is & narked decree. The rgsidual air occupies 34*9$ of total lung capacity and represents a slight aodereya increase in this ratio above the normal predicted value* The ventiiati fact ir .-as decreased is a moderate to marked degree* The ventilation factor is the iviirace of the timed vital, capacity for three seconds, the ^ 1 brewthin cape st ir and the residual percent of the total lung capacity, all expreeeea on the m s .s of the normal predicted, value* The alveolar nitrogen wus 1.1$ after breathing oxygen for 5 minutes, normal* The nitrogen washout curve was obtains with ^ggntlauous recordings of each breath on oxygen breathing on the nitrogen a total time of 4*5 minutes was required to. reduce the end tidal nitr L>. The shape of the nitrogen washout curve Is smooth and uniform. The 'nitrogen washout is to an end tidal of 1 or less within 5 oinutes and forced exhalation the alveolar should not exceed 1*5$. The nitrogen was this case with the nitrogen meter indicates normal air distribution in t arterial blood oxygon saturation at rest was 91.9$ on air breathing (a ato marked decrease), and 90.0$ with step-up exercise (a marked decreas lse saturation was repeated walking on the treadmill in a steady state lea per hour fisc with a 2$ grade on air breathing and found to be 90 as with, the stop*up exareisa)* With intermittent positive pressure on compressed air only at rest the saturation was 96.2$ (normal). Tit-, exorcise was repeated at 1.5 miles per hour CSt with a 2$ grade cn 32*752 oxygen breathing (increasing the inspired pOo from 116.9 on air treetain, to 231.2 am. Hg.) and with this level of oxygen breathing the saturation was 96.2$ (normal 97$ or more). After breathing 100$ oxygen the saturation of the arterial blood was 99.7$, the COg content 46.6 vols. percent and the pH 7.45* T: COg content on air breathing was decreased slightly both at rest and with exer- d s o . The arterial blood pH was normal at rest and increased slightly with exa else. The hemoglobin was 14*59 grans basod on oxygen capacity measurement and further checked with the Ceckman DU Spectrophotometer cyanmethemoglobin method. The hematocrit was 40.4$ ' . 80790G I IO WEOK ir Mir COHCSHS OoB CO o vl KURT a . HOFFM ANN, M .O. m u m i n aiULCma l u i r n o , m i * m i o a M n 0*0 m m uf. aujraiiH iA UDMMIfr M4I4- April 17.1963 Steams & Cross Attorneys at Law 9200 Colima Hd. Whittier. /Calif. Re: Leonard Charles Brokenshire. Dear Six, On the 11. 20-1962 Mr. L.C. Brokenshire ease the first tine to my off1ee eemplaininy about pain is bis ehast specially on bis left side. After examining the Pat. the diagnosis was: tr.S.I, ,ehro oulmonary fibrosis, poss. asbestosis. B.P.was 120/32, Because of his oain on the left side, EKG was taken.Findings:normal. ChestIray taken 11-29-62 in Studebaker Hospital',. 13100 Studebaker 2d.in Norwalk showed the following impression: The changes are those of extreme chronic pulmonary disease manifested by, fibrosis and emphy sema. The possibility of an occupational process must be seriously considered. The second and last time I saw Pat. in my office on the 11. of December 1962. He had slighly improved.He was told changing of his Job would be advisable to furthermore imorovs his condition. , lours very truly 807908 X f It 11 11 I I r tOVlSVASO L i t I O A * R . M A U E t, M .O. A .W .O tL S S t-T. C A l i r o t N t * . October 1563 Aetna Casualty t Surety Company 2404 Wilshire Blvd. Lot Angeles 3 California. Attn Ray Skooey Rei Leonard Brokonshire . _ vot Aawtrong Construction Co* ' Sentlsaen . Pulmonary function- studies or* dan* by Or. Motley on October 16, 1903. These studies reveal abnormal findings characteristic of pulmonary fibrosis. The figure* reveal a moderate reduction in pulmonary func tion. tt is obvious that this raduoad function is dua to the patholo gical change* noted by examination and particularly by tha x-ray. That* have been regarded a* due to tha Inhalation of aabaato fiber*. On the basis of that* studies, it is ay belief that Hr. Broksnthir* could be oployad at an occupation which did not involve a degree of exertion which would causa shortness of breath. In other words, a sedentary job which involves an ordinary amount of walking about an efflea or even about an open site on level ground would not cause any difficulty. Any exertion, such as climbing ladders or climbing stairs, might product dvtnnsa and discomfort although this would not increase the severity of the dlsesse at this tins. Any work pro- . scrlptlon should also Insure the avoidance of insulating materials particularly asbestos and fine dusts. This Implies that his condi tion has not changed sine* the last sxaminatlon, April 14r 1963. Asbtstotis 1* s progressiva disease. It is likely that tha degree of puloonarv fibrosis will progress in tha coming years. The lesions is permanent, It is in ill likelihood progreesive, but at this time it is not totally disabling as lndlcstsd above. Should any question arise following the receipt of this report, please do call upon me. Yours sincerely, EFM/hj Edgar F. Hauer, M. 0, 00 o *vl CO o 5060 pulmonary ventilation measurements at rest reveal a normal <<*! ventilation, a normal oxygen uptake and a slight decrease la the percent of oxygen exartcted from the inspired air breathed. The E-2 whan calculated on th basis of the resting oxygen uptake was +0.2? of his nnr-ai predicted value. Vi step-up exercise the minute ventilation was within the normal range, the oxygen uptake was decreased In a moderate to marked degree and the percent of oxygen extracted from the inspired air breathed decreased in a moderate degree. Dyspa tine was net prolonged after on minuta of step-up exercise. Direct tension measurements o f arterial blood at rest reveal a pCO- at 36.6 m . Hg. (normal 10) and a p02 of 80.5 mm. Hg. {normal 95). The effective tidal air at rest based os the expired pCO* and the arterial pCOo was 66.15 (normal 7 5* or more). With treadmill exorcise in a steady state at 1.5 h i c wi6S a ^ srade^the arterial pCOg was 35.5 am- Kg. and the arterial 77*4-1 = 3 Hg.. The effective tidal air with the treadmill exardse was 72.6 bnseff^a the expired pCOj and the arterial pC02, normal 75? or b t i . The carbon tone:dtta diffusing capacity Beasuramont at rest was 5.58 and with step-up exercis< lo.31 (CO uptake, cc. per minute per mm. Kg. alveolar pCO). Our normal Tali is-varjr from 8 to 20 at rest and from 20 to 50 with atep-up exercise. The Tuldwwa. test was obtained with direct recording of the brachial artery pulse pressure, and. this test was essentially normal. The average blood pressure as *5? brachial artery rest supine was es follows; syttjdbLe 132, diastolic 62- and mean 80 os* Hg.. I:, summary the pulmonary function studies reveal the absence of emphysema as s significant factor in this case. There is a marked reduction in the total lua^gHpacity indicating a restrictive condition of the chest and lungs, asst characteristic of fibrosis- The spirogram reveals no significant obstructive factor for the rapid forced exhalation. A moderate degree of broncho spasm was M wb2?? tadica*0,i * T the increase in. the maximal breathing capacir art!rJ r ? Tjochodilator treatment with Isuprel. There is significant hypoxia ' ?r2 j S L otb **_?*?* aa{* with 1X01*0130. The resting hypoxia was corrected with i n ^ a i t t o n t positive pressure breathing on compressed air only indicating the prestnee of poorly ventilated, areas. However, it can be noted that the arterit P02 by direct tension measurement is higher proportionately ttwin the arterial blood oxygen saturation based on Tan Slyic measurements of oxygen content and oxyaaa/oapaoity. This would indicate the perlusslon of some blood through nonventiMted areas, a characteristie finding in fibrosis. Also it can bo noted thatWfren on z. high level of oxygen breathing (32.75? oxygen), there was a sligi decrease with exercise. The carbon dioxide la being blown off adequately. The decrease in the exercise oxygen uptako in this ease indicates the presence of increased pulmonary vascular resistance and the inability to increase the pointer ary blood flow corresponding to the degree of exorcise given* This again is a fairly coecon finding in restrictive conditions of the chest and lungs as best demonstrated in this case by the decrease in the total lung capacity. These studios would be consistent with hypoxia resulting from the fibrosis which also creases pulmonary vascular resistance and the inability to expand the pulmon ary vascular bed in the nrfraal manner corresponding to the d i d exercise given, p e s e findings would indicate the presence of a severe degree of pulmonary function impairment. auyff surley Kotley, Director TJSP? 807910 CABDIO-SESPIBATOar LABORATORI, U.S.C. SCHOOL OF MEDICINE And the Hospital of the Good Samaritan. 1212 Sbatto St Los Angeles 17, Calif* PULMONARY FUNCTION STtJDIES nr, I d g a r ?. auer name rnamaag. c. NO.__sogo bsa. 2.h dais m- LONG VOLUME MEASUREMENTSr (BTPS) t (Predicted] (Observed) {% Normal) 1 SPIROGRAM RECORDINGSt ' T H A I CAPACITI, Supine, ml.... . ..... JZ2L Standing, ml*.... A725 TIMED T H A L CAPACITY, Standing. 3 see. al. -221. * Standing..'.. A725 MAXIMAL SHEATHING CAPACITT, Lanini Before Brooehodllator Standing 147.0 -2677 28102721 2931 73.3 <6-7 57,$ 62.0 After Bronehodilator.Iautgel 117.0 112.7 76.7 2. 8ESIDUAL AIE, SOPIRE MEASUREMENTS Test of Iatrapuifloneiy Mixing....... Air N* " l.l after 5 aia. Residual Air, ml....................IT7S Total Lung Capacity (TLC.} al* . (Residual f Vital). .............. ioo Residuai Air % of TLC.............. 2* -1437 -UL Jiu9. 21.2, -liti. .171.0] 3. VENTILATION FACTOR. ..... . 100 ' ARTERIAL BLOOD MEASUREMENTS: '""'EST . (Predicted ^ S f a o i P ETER E I:---- ObservedJ (Predicted Observed 1. OXIGEN CONTENT, VQL.J....... 19.0 2. aXIGEN SATURATION, . ...... 3. C02 CONTENT, 70L. %........ _2 43.5 4. pH, GLASS ELECTRODE...... . 7.40-15 18.26 01. Q -6.8 --7*44.. 20.0 18-31 J&L <W.O 43.5 -4fe*Q_ 7.40-45____ 2142. 5. HEMOGLOBIN, Ga............. 14.5 14.59 -liSP , 6. HEMATOCRIT, %.............. 45.0 4P,4 -42.1 iL-22 2. VENTILATION, L/min./aq.M/BSA." : (STP.)........... 2.6-3.3 3. OXIGEN UPTAKE,ml./min./sq.m./ BSA.. (STP.)............ 120--115 4. OXIGEN ft EXTRACTED FROM INSPIRED AIR BREATHED.... 1-- 5 13.5 -LJ. -127 3.57 20-30 8-10.5 500-600 21.0 -2*14-- AOS -4.47 EXERCISE. ONE MINUTE STEP TO TEST (__21 ) Steps on Stool 8 in. High. D_u_r_a_t_i_o_n of DvT.o.n_e_s 42 sec. (Normal 90 sec. or less). BTPS. (Body Temperature-,--B-a-rometric pressure,Saturated), ST?.(Standard Temp.Pre T T i V ftft ) i t a t u Casualty t Surety Company April i f 1 3 W -2-- Da: Hr. Leonard Broksnsbire BISTORT (COKmUCT) - his return to dusty occupation. Prior to Hovmafeer 1962 ha was tar* of sbortssss of breath "running op and down laddars" par* haps for tho last S v years. Ha also aotad this on stairs. Ha doss not cough. His kiss do not avail. Ha has a aaasa of eon*' stricdcB arotatd ths lower chast - notad aainly la bad If ha erics la his garden this saasa of eoartrieeiaa Is noted "that sight." Ha has never coughed up blood. 8s uses one pillow at night. Bo stopped smoking six or saves years ago because of distaste. Ha was nee instructed to do ao. PAST BISTORT - Ba was b o n in Arisooa. Bo eaaa to Long Beach <t tho ago of nine and than to San Diego whore ho lived until ba bad finished ths ninth grads. Than ha want to work at Whiting Mead is tha Sash and Doer Departaont. Hast ha was in pipe lina constriction for Richfield for a abort time, and later worked as a casual, laborer. In 1927 ba started working with insulation for a aarina engineer. Ha did this for two or throe years and then worked in the oil fields again. Beginning in 1937 ha began to work steadily la tho insulation field. Ha was laid off during th* war bur has been at this trade steadily sines 19U1. Ha has worked with various forma of asbestos and with styrofeaa. Re garding tho latter, ho was recently informed that tbare la a gas released when this sateriaL la cut. This gas. ba says, la a' reaction product of the bubbling process which ferns it. PAST TT.TJIESS - Patient states hs baa always been healthy. Ba tails his doctor that he is tired and can't seen to breathe well. Ho took s o m pills that made bin dizzy, so ho stopped taking then. Tastarday ba started on what sounds lika IPPB therapy. HARITA1 HISTORI.- He has been Banded for 21 years. His wife has been ill for a long tine. Hs has one son, age id, living and well. T608 ) . \ ii : Aetna Casualty (. Survey Ce^any April S, 1963 ! fAMILT* 8XST0CT - . Rat Leonard Brofcsnshira . HI* aether died. off cancar at apa 61. ' - H I father <liad at apa 3* - "old apa* - Two brochar and oca aiatar ara liria* and all.. So fully history of tabarcaloai*, hypertension, or disbates.. SrSTEMS Central Hervoos Systan - 8 ayseepa. Eyaa - Titian, is pood. Ha w a s plsasas for reading. E a , Koaa, aad Threat - Infrequent colds So history of asthma. Cardie-Respiratory -- Sea above. So history of aathaa, bronchitis, or poanaonia. . Sastro-Inteatinal - Occasionally ha feels on the verge of"sea sickness", but ha pitas no specific symptom. So constipa tion, rectal bleediap, or eelana. Genito-Oriaary - So dysnria, nocturia, blood or stones. PHYSICAL EXAHTKATIOK - Hr. Brokaasbi is a well developed, veil nourished white nan~in no pais or distreas. His color is good, and ha does not cough. Ha is conforcabls is the supine position. Haight 73 1/2" with shoes Haight 203 1/2 lbs. with indoor clothing Blood, pressure 1SQ/90 . SKJLC AMD SCALP - Negative. S H a ANft r i O T T k s h b rahes - cuar. - The ouails am~gound. regular, equal, react to light and acc o m odation. MOSS - Hot obstructed. THRTaT - Clear. HECK - He thyroid vnlargvoant or adenopathy. THORAX - Syamtrical. The axpansicn is fairly good. Heart - The heart does sot appear to ha anlarpad. The tones a m of good quality, regular in rata and rhythm. Thera a m no thrills or s m m . 8Tfi08 t / i1 A*t=m G fm X tr * Surety C o tta r April 8* 1983 . - a - 8*: Leonard Brokenahire PHYSICAL EXAHTNATTOK (C0HT1W1EC) - ' " " * " " * *>* ere n r a o t . Braatb e m it as* somwhac * m a t are hand. Thar la ae wheezing. AM0jg8 - Moderately obese. Vo h h o r tenderness. EXTSEMITIgS - Vo clubbing. Vo defcmity or Unitarian of notion. There is so dang of tha lower estzeniti*. LABORATORY - toinaXyaio - Tha urine is yellow and lightly cloudy Spacific S w H q r 1.017 (it 7.5 Attuarin negative Sugar negetir .Hicrosecpie - Sox* rod call, occasional bit oall, fen epithelial call, to cants. Blood Count - Hencglobin m , 2 grans or 91% Baaatocrit 6% hits count 8300 Differential! Neutrophils Sb%, tar^hoeytas 35%, Kanoeytas 5% Sadinastasioo rrta 28 tm /l hour. Than tra nocnal ealaas, excepting for the elewntien of tba sediaastatien rata. Tha electrocardiogram is within aotnal Units. ' & m *t -ray sewed bilateral iaflaaastioa, net prooouncad in tha bases, with eld pleural reaction. A eopy of Dr. Beaoff's report la enclosed. . PXAQW8IS - Pulnmery fibrosis, probably secondary to industrial aaposura to esbastea. 00MHS8T - According to the history glean by Hr. Brofcenshire ha has had slid *y*ptoos of shortness of breath for approximately five years prior-to the acute onset of shortness of breath, which occurred in Novasbar 1962. Is view of the worie history of handling insulating materials since 19<U, it is necessary to 807914 i AprijL. g , 1963 oow mt (co H T n ro sa ) - . enusldsr hi pulmonary lasioos as dun to occupations! ai^osura.. 1 would b* M C M M I 7 , tbarcfaro, to datsrniao hot tho prods* a*trtt* of axpcours to sohstsneas adrorsoly affacting tho lung had boa*. A* you knew,. eartaia typa* of asbastos do produca chronic pulmonary lasioa knows a asbottosis. h*. 8rofc*nshir* do** not oath or r d s * spot*, thorofOt, it 1* sat posslblo to soarch for asbestos fibres is his broschlal saaradcos. < 1 quantitative assay of his pulmonary- disability and dttsriaatleB of ioeondiry cardiac isrolvoaast ooold b* asdo by performing rocpirctoty function studios at tho Pulmonary Function Laboratory odor tho diroctics of Dr. Hotlay at the Bospitsl of tho Good. Saasrltsn. At tho prssost t i n it is certain that tfcora should bo no furthor axpasur* to subotaseos eapablo of earning pulmonary fibrosis. At tho prosant t i n so tho basis of information aaoilabla tho pulmonary lasions found hara aust bo regarded as occapotional. Thank you. for tho pririlaga of attaining this oaa. Tours sincerely EFH/eg*. and. Edgar F. Msaar, a.D. 807915 I C f 6H C TC * O N O rf M. O. (0 w u w * **VhCv* nns word Srokatiahi? O*- Edgar T. Mattar A pril 4. 1961 =SS~S= . b. riIhtY^ r b. * ^ l i s t s S i * * r S T fr; r s * * * H^Ma^arSSrS" SpSSSSSSS^ * S 3S 3 S f e IM PRESSIO N ; U o w p ia tira i th ick aning. 2. ^ a i e faJUaaatorr proct.. larotriac " t * lua* Th possibility that tu r*J?*M *u *** a i ** P"otoconia can* ooC b* tclvdid, T b M k to l yo fo r th x ,U r ta c , <t th is u u , I * C P B .-b r , Stktiit e*"'-- V-3- 6` M* C'C y' **0 K,*SC ------- _ J * 13 8 35 M,j 5"..C4; *? 05 O ni ( . ' - S T i s m . CASaiir & s e e t ? es., 2<> wuanira bit<u , i .a . 5* DOOOR'SJW REPORT of wo c njury x m >T&TE.<Vr1 IriTMal> ^ tSTAILCCMPB35AnON;ip2ANCLFOHI>' , `-- '^',*witai<uair*a*uarii^' A tA lamdtaMr flot fa t a n te ai n o n findirl t e OMtoa ( Utar W flta u * h s a m t B. 1 t a H& SiF r a d a t. Fubm.n'filaactpaccirich dDtrine*iim*iOEaoar. (t.cbor Code, Sacdom (407*4413.) r il qiiwciaaj fa ily. ' I, [ M P I O TM iiTMtron C a i i t n i - * Co. ......... . i 2. Addnat & .VVQ_.31-<ttggt. 3 l T d .. In* A f f a la . 2 a JL . _ IV Surm. S S S f l ^ r s - l i S a r a , -------S a n a t s a g f l B --------------------------------------------------------------:-------- axM iw 4. EMPtOT** f f l S t T i S r ` Lantw.nl 3m>lcaMh-t-a \\ (f ^ 1 U K U tm Tttr17 Tnlhae-nb'p. tTanmtV. g a i . V ' ' * n .-- .in. A s b a a to a votst t -- i f v ra . c . V*l* f H u i nf p u t (nr mmiairina ?(?*! (f(*t TTnnr 10. N om schar docteci ha tnaad BB pfaf fortU> ^ r r W * -- f r 1T*"~ "**t--''* ',i*W l " t cd eaaa od iaiatr ar iUaav . . . . . Battant voxkad for n a n y jraaxs. l a eonatruntion eoapaay * b a n d i t n y aabaatoa - l . N A tn tK ANO EXTENT OF Q4JOH.T OR DISEA2Z Chronio cspboraaoa b m a l a of lunga -*u- I I . X -ayn #7 ta n akaat F sdiap: ---- ?*>* Bt+1___________ ChroBlo oaphysam & filtroaia of luogs U. TnumtaB Gooarnl hyglana, IfB txaataa&ta 11. C ad af e u t _____ Of'V- en________ If hncpitilfiad, Bty___________ N u a aad iddrot of t"" piwl ............... U . Fuidm cmuBxac irriiaJ* ""* 17. tn iw i nd p n M A diabclitjr (an RaguJat g-r.tfc ... - Modi#d "** U . D a c n t u y ptratM B t diniiliqr or dgw taM st a p a e n d <-- --* , , 1 w t -'i 1 b n e - n i *.i An _______________________ f - . l l orV t r a m oit l f ___________________________________________ 17. I{ dmch cosuad, p r t daca 20. itEXAJUCS ar UbwwH7 oo>tterpmtaaa*% ______________________________________________________ /]______ w. i ^ - o t c r r oN B xa i x a c r n o N A i m a s e m a s ikouio u abvs cjx cvxjta ncu t u a h& n ia u to contscu* o u i, s M ts a u , co ratO G u a d ba uino n u b x . r o o ro u m o N . u x m nototib that w s oe a o * ts i a m a . / * `MS.',U ~ )- ./ $70h S. CUric .cv.. 3l l f l o v e - t.i m. "<W .7;u,w Ut* rtv*rt* tid* if mort tp*** rtquirtd ' ' M l MMO 4 *** 007917 INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION TATS O F CALIFORNIA 1E0NABD CHARLES B80KSS3X2& GuriV<L_63_U_2_2*5 A jp lien t-- 12KSTB0N5 CONTRACTO AND SOPHEX COUPANT; t al Dtfnemim. Notice o T i m e aadPlaceof Fortier Hearing .sc NOTICE TO ALL PARTIES Youait herebynotified dut further b o asr willbMd dit abore-earidrd scon t 4107- LOS ANGELES STATE OFFICE BUILDING. 107 SOUTH BROADWAY LOS ANGELES. CALIFORNIA NOVEMBER 4,1963 D n d ws LOS ANGELES 9:00 i.K. ALE DAT ' INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION NOTE c o n t in u a n c e s a n d f u r t h e r h e a r in g s a u n o t fa v o r ed . x u a am is s u s o r h u o n s u r t d . d a is O c t o b e r 2 , 1 9 6 3 L e o n a r d C .H ro Icen* h i r e , 1 4 7 1 7 L l e b a o h e r At . , N o rw a lk - S te a rn s A G ro a t, 9200 C o lis a B d .. W h ittie r A rm s tro n g C o n tr a c tin g A S u p p ly C o ., 4 3 4 0 D i s t r i c t S lT d ., LA 9 0 0 5 8 A e tn a C a a .A S u r e t y C o ., 2 4 0 4 W l ls h lr e B lv d , LA 9 0 0 5 4 T r t T e l e r s I n s . C o ., 3 6 0 0 W i l s h l r e B l v d ., LA 9 0 0 0 5 W e in g a n d ,E e n d lg ,S to o k w e ll A Ca l l e n a n , 6 1 1 S . C a t a l i n a , LA 9 0 0 0 5 fesH iOOL dev. i~et> K. Stern teeewamw ranean iu>m m tw i  rajno 1 BEFORE m s INDUSTRIAL. ACCIDENT COMMISSION" 0? THE STATE OF CALEFOR 2 CASS NO- 63 L. A- 250-245 3 4 LEONARD CHARLES BRQK2NSHXEE, MINUTES OF HEARING 5 Applicant, 6 VS. ^ AND ORDER JOINING r ) PARTY DEPENDANT" ARMSTRONG CONTRACTING AND SUPPLY COMPANY; ) 8 AETNA CASUALTY AND SURETY COMPANY, a corporation; ) 9 TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY, a corporation, IO ) ***!or CIAJ8P-.** AUGI 1963 jjr- 11 Domandante. ). WJU.IAM 13 TRIS CAUSE cam* on for hearing this 30th dar f July, 1963, 13 nino a.n., la Dopartnant 7 of tha Industrial Accident Commission z 14 Loa Angelas, California, bafore Honorable RICHARD BARRY, Referee. 18 K- A. McNeal, Court Reporter. 1 ir PRESENT; 18 Leonard Charles Brokenshire, applicant. ' 19 Stearns 4 Gross, by Richard Gross, attorneys for applicant. 20 Welngand, Kendlg, Stoctarell 4 Callanan, by E. Kendlg, 21 attorneys for Aetna Casualty and Surety Co. 22 23 WITNESSES: 24 (None) 28 2 EXHIBITS: 27 (None) 3pp SERVED 7/30/63 MMo: " - Travelers Ins. Co., 3600 Wllshlre Blvd., LA 5. - Steams 4 Gross, 9200 Colima Rd., Whittier. - L. C. Brokenshire, 14717 Llebacher Ave., Norwalk. - Armstrong Contracting 4 Supply, 4340 District Blvd., LA 58. - Welngand, Kendlg, Stockwell 4 Callanan, 6ll S. Catalina, LA 5. - Aetna Casualty 4 Surety Co., 2404 Wllshlre Blvd., LA 54. X'SVTJ' Cs G / < G >- G / I 1 POOD CAPSZ APPEAflINO THSHEFORs < . 2 XS ORDERED that the application b amended to allege a 5 period of continuing trauma. that began In 1941 and ended on 41 Pebruary 8, 1963. 5 Iff IS ORDERED that TRAVELERS INSURANCE COKEANT, A COBPQRATK a be, and It hereby la. Joined aa a party defendant as. Insurance T carrier for Armstrong contracting and Supply Company the 6 period of applicant's employment with that company that began on 9 April 2, 1961, up until the time coverage began by Aetna Casualtj 10 and Surety Company. . 12. 12 VS IS STIPULATED B Y AETNA CASUALTY AND SORETT COMPANY: 19 1. That It was the insurance carrier for Armstrong 14 Contracting and Supply Company for the period that began 10 January 1, 1963,- and. continued through the last date of applicant la employment. 17 2. That It (alone or posalbly In conjunction with Travelers ia Insurance Company) will make a monetary advance to applicant and 19 will pay the medical expense Incurred In the sum of $159*50 for 20 the bill of Dr. Schmerler. 21 22 DISPOSITION: ' 23 Continued, to be reset for one full day (not before two 24 months from this date.) 20 28 27 28 29 30 I ;MO r?G08 INDUSTRIA"'ACCIDENT COMMISSION c TATK O F CAUPCHMIA cc i -------------- ----- ;----- ty f w n rwtaras BSOKOSHXBX Nonex o f h e a r i n g AppiiIccGnt- U V ' G u *N o,.k3 L ?$o-as AWSTCH3 CCBCTACTIEff ATO 3T7IX COWiBT ^yw>A ciSSiLTt iSD SBEBET COMMIX O'rftnitntX- Mg jUcSktt apffmii Accsotf ctNtittoa TTtn jul9 1963 -*/l^ William karlan am. tffittIM f rs^TL. b - ~ (or b a a a f " 4107 LOS ANGELES STATE OFFICE BUHDINQ, 107 SOOTH BROADWAY LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA J E T 30^X 943 9*00 AJC. d 4 .* 4 J * A m f A t *1 tppfiaona io * I "* * *7 Wm T_W^__*_1 _i_pn_i_l m I I .1 t --- r*-- al * S a of O Bffloi MO jwcM w M" 1 -f-e ,mt--im*--mmm-tm--mtfc,Wm** fUMk p __ I. LOS ANGELES, CAUfOUNIA tM k % in d u s t r ia l a c c id e n t c o m m issio n . m i i a Xaplta A f4i\m la rrn ifa r m w iaMd, . , C tE fon, wb i p ttt* M m H t laidncA follow, n v ie N m w m A M m w o Pw m SotM L#onar4 C**rl.. K S i sssu ,, |_ | Tjfln , a tb U nitai S ac m til oc id <*T. Lo* A u|i*. "* " 1W17 *" Calli g * ? i j*0***" * C t li * K ^ iS iS : cmr* (MUTVM * F**" a*1 w ** . ,< i u n or ouirotNSA / 'DWIRIAt ACCXDENT COKMKSOr' \ j -- APPLICATION m i aama oum tu. an sxx carati P lu s psnrqb ira u m m akjbbsb) CASE NO. Oo o -v2 ZD te te GTLA 250245 330HA2D CHABSZS BRflKSHSHlUH l!717 Clbacfaer _________ H orvaU c. C a llio m . AmSTBOKS I5SPLATI0H CO. Smm{mbd^ V-. 5 2 0 -0 f-3 0 2 2 ta*Q P i a t r l c t a ? * - i -SQ? ABC8ly 58. Callfi.w.4. i3B ti asrajurcg cctg jg r 2>0fVUafalr 3ouI>vard MMMMtMin MNH CO* tgll, C*Uf<WEl* XSOHABD CHABL23 3BQggHgHlMB 7 /9 /0 7 W T------- ^''1. -fa.~~>bWCBi^ A" 1f ^ mfc.Asinata Worittr Pai-- - la* m T.i.. ___ ______ CtlUacBM b r . miiMM Al M ^ W P t j nITOlatlOB Co, , hAw iw in N iaiiifraiMttowNd^ittifacDiMafA..^itT-.l.Tt.nT-n -Looa A a b a rto z h a . 'A ia lffettd vith 4 Mttkr **m .iBtmi - rw ilri. a .-gf hm ai y 8. S - 4. V < J.i a m . g A . r f i A . . 199.00 . *. V a mt&al tnmi^t mi-li ^ vwt M IM IW a Nrkofambdd -TO d np^Tv'i m n a a a t 4u> oi jwr. ===- 1^3 **** tcm\*mnrmrr r % . i S ? to *****mt m n t m w w n. n m *m iu t ***r u --; P g - g l * Vnftmanm________________ Pr. Joaopfa J, SehwTlar. urld hT pollent t.^ -- t - `- ,- r - j ....... i t r i t i , r .. * T o p o o i r < S M S r r _ J L . k. h u u d h O f f i t y ^ J L . *** nM* t U d g iria e v e w ^J E*--* t M T d l c a l - 1 1 . -~< n u g ro e rta niM am <L M *fio c tWm. ~|-- -- 4.. Nnutbv di wt*Mwii ruiiMMi J - >?,' <% ***. Whlttlar m tV O V 2 day Dog<i. w n lttla r. .OHora.-- Harefa 8f 6 SlEAHffS A ro. G fiS S ^ l^ '"* * -'' BTl L . ti- .'* * ' / -- -- >_ J u *JL &> . 9299 C o lia a W .. t r a l t t l a r , Cal if o r n ia .ttMiin Kiim >rruNim w NtMHtnw1,0M*M.*M.I##T-.M-.fN.MMITTIUiNtm *W*UkT^MHMIM>IMTtTMNlIUtTtflVmUtUNWfiiti,ilfNin|liwl **'*****,uM It m il(ilMMltMtu' I*t*U*H*I*!NitMfMilmUiIU1fNNNiMmfm* ri <mn m MMMI mim