Document MJ19xyVa1kd1931ENEannwo1x
FILE NAME: Quintec (QUIN) DATE: 1961 DOC#: QUIN007 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: WC Claim - Harding
w
; Ifc< -*'. V.
P
_ / * '. .
#
^
4
I
BEfRE T O ! INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT CCMHS3ICN OF XHE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
CLAIM N, 6 0 S P 1 9 3 -8 5 1
CLI 'FORD P. HATU5TN0, Appjan I.
Y, PLAT ASBESTOS CO,, 'i. T, THOR? A 80NS, INC- MfiTAlCLD INSULATION CO. U IO ., r m CAW, dbb QW NSiriAIOU, DOTTOd ASS j*STOS SUPPtY. COm ARMSTRONG CORK CO. . COAST INSULATING PRODUCTS CORF., 0, K BRAUN & CO.f * OWENS.CORNINO FIBERGLAS CCRP., JCKSW & HOPKINS C O ., J/C, t MARINE ENOlNBEhlHG & SUPPLY CO. , m ib R MAINTENANCE, XNO%i M, R, CASPENTSR, IWCL j WESTERN ASBESTOS CO. , INDSTHJAL UiriEHNITY CO. . CAL1PORNXA CASUALTY WMIMMITY EXCHANGE, STANDARD ACCIDENT U iS, CO, j. TRAVELERS INS. C0.( ARGONAUT IN^. CO , AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS. CO., m * !A CASUALTY fe SURETY C O ., GUARANTEE I N I CO , ZENITH NATIONAL INS., CO,, PA$::PIC EMPLOYEE INS. CO., ASSOCIATED MJWIZTY COR?. fiJid STATE COMPENSATION DURANCE FUND,
Dofniiftonte ,
ORDER APPROVING COMPROMISE AND RELEASE
The p m ie o to the above e n title d action having f ile d a
Coi pporaiee and Release herein, on Aug. Eft MNSlj s e t t lin g the above caj-f f o r $3,300.00, in addition to A l l ourb which ay have been paid
prd W u a ly , and requeatlng th at i t be approved; and th is CoffiroiBslon hattng considered the e n tire record) in clu d in g said;COAproralee and
Be: ia s e , now fin d e that i t should be Approved; and,
GOOD causi: APPEARING THEREFOR;
IT r s CRCEREDthat sa id ComproJiHsa and Release b e , and I t i s
her rty approved, payable no fo llo w s:
By D{CU5TRIAL WEMNITT COMPANY
$ 33 7 .JO
By CALIFORNIA CASUALTY INDEMNITY EXCHANGE By STANDARD ACCIDENT INSURANCE COMPANY
16-66 16.S6
By TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY
Rtf ABOOHAUL INSURANCE COMPANY*
-
50,57 33*?1
y
075
/ ...9....... ...
: *- .
!* * .p 1HT *
c
il*
iV
j ----- a - * - ->- tM rapivit i V # "ififfft'nfWiWWffimrr
^
y r-i t k
^
Ret CtOTORD F. KARUmCt - jim No, 60 SP 193-&54
N^ * * w ,
3y MOERICAH MOTORISTE DTSOKHCE COMPANY
S $4*2&
By AETNA CASUALTY fi SURETY CCAiTMAT sy guarantee in suran ce company
370,01
:
263,54.
BV ZENITH NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY
33,71
By PACIFIC EMPLOYERS IftfURAflCE COMPANY
m .13
By ASSOCIATED INDEMNITY CORPORATION
33*71
By STATS COMPENSATION INSURANCE FUND
I93*t*7 ' .......... i7o?h
IT 1$ FURTHER.ORDERED l i s t SIATE COMPENSATION INSURANCE VjD deduet th e ama o f fSSR.O f i o I t * Bontributiot to b* p a id
d ljfe e tly Et r a l le v a i r $300, t o Sm ith, Farri?)* FewWttt fi C la n c y
e a tto r n e y s 1 t o * j $22,00 to Smith P a r r is h , Pa< k ft C la n cy y
` tran scrip t of the deposition;
Frey, K.D ,
3>J/ Rei UAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION
Al Nltfta t t ? 2 i 1B
F ile d and served on; t J k i j
C LTford f r Hftrdlng, 1^07 Howe A v e ., Sacramento US
? ant Asbestos to ., 1300 * 64th S t , , toteryvllle
y T. Thorp & Sons, I n c ,, 1351 Ocean Ave, Em eryville
M Ptaielad In sulation O?,# Ia o ,, PO. Sox ITS* Torrance
Caw In su la tio n , 3600 - 20-th av a ., Sacramento so
Dutton Aqtoestcs as Supply C o ., 532 NatatA S t , , SP
AjmatxenB Cork C o ., 101 Ogden D riv e . Burlingame
Goaet In su la tin g Products c o r p ., 2684 Lacy s t r e e t , Lo$ Angeles 31
d . F . Braun et C o ., 1000 South Fremont: A V a., Alhambra
Owcna-Corr.ing Fib ergiaa C o rp ,, P ,o , Box dp, Sacramento
aefcaon & Hopkins to -,, Inc,, P ,o , Sox 40, B a x e rsfia ld
Narine Engineering & Supply Co,* 9^1 E aat Second 5t . , Los A n g e l
JU O f Maintenance, In c ., 2500 South A tla n tic Slvd'. , Loi Angeles 22
I L Carpenter, I n ., 907 Fronl S t , Sacramento 7
western Asbestos t o ,, 675 To%m*and 5fc,f s ? 3
in d u s tr ia l Indemnity t o ., 350 sansome S C ,, SP
a U T o m ia Casualty Indemnity Exchange, 550 Kearny S t , , SP
tandanf Accident in e , C o., o to West San B*wno Avs, \San Bruno
raveiers roe. to ,, 550 C a lifo r n ia S t , , SP
rgonaut In s. t o ., 550 C a lifo r n ia S t . , $F
meilcan M otorists In a . to ., bl7 Nontgoaory S t , , SP
etna Casualty k Surety Co., 220 Montgomery S C ,, SP
uaxantva Ina. t o ,,
Kearny 3 t . > 3P
en ith N ational lo a . t o ., 5&2 Market S t . ; $P
acirio Employer Ina. Co.r 244 Pine S t , , SP
.eiiaciefced Indoffinity Corp., 332 Pine S t , , SP
jS tate CcmoenEatiOn In s. Fund * Personal Service
. t^-.,,.
-^r.rr,
rinvma^ .W1rtJi%riririrtir lMr .^ lr
J 4 JpL/UL HfftlP8
4
M W-illT `fcJWh *.i
t ...
br->.VF^-4a^LtP-V.ki-ria^>s^.^.r^V^i^cr^ .. hj A
*
4
*1 Cl if f o r d p, batoujo - C l a i m to . 60 SP 193- 35*
i? 1951
RULat^an servad oit: continued
ami parrtnh, PAducc & claftyr $ o i F in a n c ia l Center B ide,# B&i m & Brophy, 1540 San Pablo Ave., Oakland 3<f wick* D e te r t, Woran ft A rn o ld, 100 Busti 8t*# 8 ? - A lin ?
ome S t ,* SP er K . r
Oakland K e ith
*3-
jf uHUL"*
HU8.BU1I jm 'iuji' m i iy iwwywBwt I i
, w -I P * /
)
Ul.
*
/ .
CtEPCEiD P, KflJUUHO
A, R NELSON. Referee Settcm bcr 21 1951
CUM J *
PIANX ASBESTOS CO-, 7. T, THRP & $tf$, IKC.# et l Claim Ko.. 60 SP 193-85$ In j; Asbestoss
REPORT CF REFEREE CN feDSfc APPROVING COXPROMISE AMP RETEASE
*Ef
Asbestos worker, born February 28, 1696, claim s ftxfoeirtQals &* the re su lt o f in d u stria l exposure in employments Tor TvJriercma employer* going back aom* y e a r*. Ovbrftll in clu din g hi! cmploymantB in th* industry in varloue uts-cf-state lo c a lit ie s he has a h is to ry o f approximately 30 ye&ra ei* in te n o itte n t axpooure tc aabeatca duab.
The record shown th a t a p p lic a n t continued working u n t i l H; y , 1959. ban ha vac a eixed w ith auddAn cavora c h e s t pain* Jto v,.3 h o sp italised on a dla&necia o f coronary occlusion* Cheat X -raya taken a t th a t tim e were in te rp re te d as showing evid ence o f a ibeetoslv*
I t la now proposed to n e ttle the case by tne peyraent o f ^3300. 00, nothing having been paid h eretofore.
Concerning the present cause o f d is a b ility * Dr* Horton Hin&hav, Jr* atotea ao fo llo v a i
"The degree o f a sb asto sU evident on X-ray hare would riot be expected to Lead to heart diueane, and &180 the type of heart d isease produced by lung disease i s quite d iffe r e n t from tHieaai* which ls d i to coronary occlusiony Which t h is patxent apparently has had. Consequently, i*t would bo ny opinion th a t h ie heart disease i s a asperate condition and not d ir e c tly delated to h it asbestosls".
fl
<?n the b asis o f pulmonary fu n ction t e s t s , the doctor
concluded m h is fin a l report th at the p a tie n t's symptom? were to
1 large degree due to h ie heart disease and not to asbestosis*
Indeed, on the t&eLe o f d iffu sio n cap acity test* i t was h is
judgment that the a$be$tosis was so m ild as not to be d isa b lin g
r productive o f any symptoms.
In an e a r lie r report. Dr. Norberc Frsy*. an b e h a lf o f f bo a p p lic a n t, bad concluded that the p a tie n t had a moderate legrea o f pulmonary fib r o s is , which was productive o some hortness o f breath. Hs expressed no opinion concerning the .industrial con trib u tion to the over-* a ll d is a b ility ,
Qi the record, the settlem ent l e ^ a i r and adequate.
U stosiTIO N : Order Approving Ccmpromiae and Release to be paid . 0 said ap p lican t, le s s $30.00 to Herbert Prey H*D? and le e a attorneys* fe e o f ^30 0 .0 0 and reimbursement c o tta o f^ s a .O O to pe paid, to ap plican t** attorneys out o f the smoprit^gyable by State Compensation Insurance Fund.
AKNrmlni
lyiiiiijwgm
I
/J * ( ' * *f*iUtw.inigU* CUAtSlUtt) *ULSA
l louts U-TK..C*JOMt>GJL&I ATJj*TL fitmlTUPUtqtQaCHiSCJ Rflr*"iCQlXWfJ wWiftifcWH
, r --u .i,
I | EXHIBIT
p jc iia jL ^ lhO#JOtm 0
INSURANCE
/
AYFfi.*ot a o ju s t c r j
cON auinriO Acru*ft>C$
t z i * MOAtu c ^ a L C S $ m * T , AirihO M Ia, no,
February 2 ?, 1962
! I
LfWOC IClU SWtP* m cm c u ad O* AOC*R
PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT
JM -Q J> y i* .
nr. wllll*m L. BDgfte*, tfanage)? Insurance Department /rratrd&B. Cork Company lAPcatftar, Pennsylvania,
T*ivl<tFi Policy Ndl
Rt>3-4<awg
Dear S tr:* Please nofo di*j><j*ition mad* o f tbe follow ing *X *ia i
D#e o f Accident: j anuarv 9 . 1935 , oiira*nt; Clif f o r d g. Harding
^ * * ~ -u ^ * * , C l.C .-i A
Locations $acraento, C alifo rn ia Claim Wii b 9527634
D isposition: 50-37 Perm* P a rtia l
fcemarks:
Indicate Uhathor;
Workmen's Cotap, x ____ \uco L ia b ility $ * ! . _
F iD .____ General L ia b ility B*i,
?,D .l
"0
V y truly yonra, MEHNOSt 6 U XW O C* **??, lo s s DSPAATK^r
l
CLIFFO RD P. HAHDSN3 A. . NELSOff, R e fe r e e
September 2X, 1961
V S t>
fL W P ASB2ST05 CO. #
J t VS, TKOJtP ft $QNS4 I N C , et al
C& 41A We. 6 0 3 ? 1 0 3 - 3 5 1*
In ji Aabeatoii
REPORT OP m tV & Z OK ORDER AHROVTHG __________ COMPROMISE jlvd &SLA5$__________
Asbretes worker, born P sorw ry 29, 199$, c la l *
aabcstoqis as the r e s u lt of in d u s tr ia l exposure In eirtpioye>er>Ci to r
. numerous aoiploy*** going back some 15 ycara. O v e r a ll, in clu d in g
h4>s employments in the in du stry in veno u s o u t - o f - S t a le l o c a l l t i * * '
he has a h isto ry o f approxim ately 30 years o f in t e n s itt e n t oxpoaur
tq
(Juftt,
The record shows th a t ap plican t continued *orkin& u n t i l Hay, 1959, when he was seized w ith sudden severe cheat pains, H* bee h o tp lta llttd on & diagnosis o f coronary o cclu sion . Chest X -ray s taken a t t h a t time wore LnUrprec&d as *ho*ing evidence o f a sb e s to s ls .
I t id now proposed to s e t t le the case by erte payment o f $3300. 00, n o t h i n havin g been paid h ereto fore.
CehecftVin# the present cause o f a b i l i t y , P r. RortOn 0. ffiM lu v, J r . v rates as follow s:
"The degree o f asb estoeis evident on X -ra y here would not bo estreated to Jean to h e a rt d ise a se, and m ao the type o f h eart disease produced by lung disease i s q u ite d iffe r e n t from disease which le a d s to epw ncry occlusion, which chi p a tie n t apparently has had. Consequently, i t would be a ? opinion th a t h i t heart dlaereft i s a separate condition and not d ir e c t ly related to his iA V tsto su *,
on the b a sis o f pulmonary fu n ction t e s t s , the doctor concluded in h is f i n s ! reporc that the p a t ie n t ' s symptom* were to a large e g re t \ra to h is hear* dlaaas and not 'to a s b e sto sis. Indeed, on the b a sis o f d iffu s io n cap acity t e s t , it has h is Judgment! that chc aobeatoalo was bo mild so t re bo (Mkiblino o r productive o f any symptoms.
I n an e a r l i e r r e p o , Dr, Norbert F re y , oo b e h a lf o f fch* a p p lic a n t, had concluded th a t 'he p a tie n t had a moderate degree o f pulmonary fl& r o s ls , wniah was productive o f some shortness o f breach, Kb expressed no opinion concerning the in d u stria l contribution to the o v e r-a ll d is a b ilit y .
On the record, the fle*?I4oene i : f a i r and adequate,
DISPOSITION; Order Approving conptQffiise and Release to be paid to said a e p U c a n t, i *=3 $ 3 0 J0 tc Hor'-Jirc Frey, M .D ,. and lea a tto rn e y ' 5s 200. CO and reArth-is-aera!, aoeta o f S3.00 no be paid to a p p lic a n t 's atte m e y a out o f the amount payable by S tate Compensation Insurance Fund.
AKR film
A. E XZL5CX, R eferee
nan
/
j :
, ; ' jj ; ; ` I . "
f : 1 * *
peroni THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT CaPOTIBSON Of THE STATE O f CA-UFORNtA
\
CLIFFt110 P . vi<
HANDIINGC
CLAR wo* tit) SF X9>-83t JOOHPflOfln AND ftgtgftPE
*" -*7*lWNj * riL to OGaS^Bl
1407
lAtftllrinl fcffUfrri CftjniVwH.
RECEIVED
AUG2 3 I9 S IM FILED ^
Soeroowim Qjfieo
No m Avenue ^ . . . ffeevuttnto 21 Californ ia
PLANT asbestos coftpanr Enployor
3 . T* THORP 1 SONS* INC
N-TOCMD INSULATION11? ? , INC*
Employer
PAN Wi*. dba CAN INSULATIfiN
Evploylr
PUTTO AS0E5TOB A SUPPLY CO*
Employer
A?WSTQG CONK CD*
Cmployor
COAST INSULATING PRODUCTS COflP.
Employer
C* F* 5RAUW 4 CD*
*
Employer
Obices CORNING FIBERGLAS COFiP,
Employer
JACES0N t SOPMNS CD, t INC,
Bnplayer
danint engineering a supply sa .
I pwU m t
FLUGS nRitiTCNAn6E * i hc ,
Eralay&r
n* Rr t ARPENTER, lfiZ9
. .EtfpXnyar
WEStEflW asgsstos C.
Employer
.SOD 64*h S tre e t Emeryville, California
.351 Ocean Avenue Emeryville, California
Peat O rn e a Gem 17S Torrance, C alifo rn ia
3600 20th Avanue
5*0r<uft6nt9 3 , C a l i f o r n i e
532 Halme S tre e t
San Francisco 3 , C alifo rn ia
lO H Ogden Drive
flurUnoan, California
204 Leoy S tre e t
Loi Ansale* 31, C alifo rn ia
1000 South Froment Avenue
Amanera* C alifo rn ia
Pcet o r f i c i 89
Sacramento. C a lifo rn ia
Paal O frico Sox 690
Bakersfield, C alifornia
961 East Second S tre e I
Lee ArTOlft C a lifo rn ia
2600 South A tla n tic bgulovard
Loe Anas Ses 22, C a lifo rn ia
907 Front S tr e e t
. .
M Sacramento 7 , C a lifo rn ia
675 Tounaand S tre e t.
Sen P re n d e te 3 , C a lifo rn ia
XWHS1'RIAL JfiOfiflMlTT COPIPANY
Xnuv*nti0 C arrier
W LIFU fflU l CASUALTY INDEMNITY EXCHANGE
Insutanse Carrier
STANDARD ACCIDENT INSURANCE CD riPrY
insure* CairJar
TRAVUERS INSURANCE COMPANY t
Insurance Carrier
ARSON UT INSURANCE QODPANY
Insuranoe Carrier
Af r i c a n pw tork ts MsvftAflGt conPMy
j
IrsHrenoa Carrier
AETNA CASUALTY I SURETY CONPMY t ,
j
Insurance C a rrie r.
GUARANTEE INSURANCE CDNPANY
*
Xnaa?*ri?tf C a rrier *
I T ? NATIONAL INSURANCE COflPAMY
Insurance Carrier
PAOIF a gnPLDYEflS JMSlMAWCl corpahv
Injuratoco Carrier
t
350 Binaori S tre e t Sen Freneieea. C il& rtu m l*
550 Kearny S tre e t San Franoteooi C alifo rn ia
060 u vei Sen ruao Aumui Sen Draco, C a lifo rn ie
550 C a lifo rn ia S tre e t 5n Freneleeo, C a lifo r n ie
550 C a lifo rn ia S tre e t San Francis*, C a lifo rn ia
U 7 ftentgflflBry S tre e t San Franelaco C a lifo rn ia
220 ftontgemery S tre e t San Francisco, C alifo rn ia
590 Kearny s tr e e t
Sen fr a w la c o , ( lirn rn l*
502 JferKel S tr e e t San fra n c is c o , C a lifo rn ia
3730 Piedmont Avenue Oakland XI C a lifo rn ia
jn,m
lu y a
WfF
; 3
. ,
.'
: >
sj
*
'*' r <^m * .
*...,{_ ^
f.
*i
..1^ ..-.pam. .-^ir*ri"a'-- - `Vi | Itrilf**-^
.
9
Sei CLIFFORD . KARPIHa - Clilm No SO BP 103-$5U
iy AKERCAH MOTORISAIS rBSlffi^HCE CfMJftifltf
$ B4.2S
r
By AETNA CAOTAL7T * SURETY COMPAN B/ GUARANTEE' INSURANCE eGMMW
m ei
286.54-
.
By ZENITH NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY By PACIFIC S ifT o m a INSURANCE COMPtfY ny ASSOCIATED INDEMNITY CORPORATION By STATE COMPENSATION INSURANCE POND
33.71 10143
33.71 193A.7B
df"
IT i s m n orde&bd t u t sta te compensation insurance deduct th e mud aC $352,00 from i t f i c o n trib u tio n t o be p aid
o t ly an f o l l o w s * $300,00 t o Sm ith* P a r r is h , Paduek & Claney an attorneys1 few; $22.00 to Smith, Parris/h, .p/ad' ynplc & Clancy transeript of the deposition-, $30*90 tT^ohept Piy# K.D,
u P! R M . ACCIDENT commission
irolm t : ? 2 1 ICG!
F ile d and served on: rjdfatiS
affo rd p . Herding, 1*07 HOwe A v e ., Sacramento 2$ artt Asbeatos Co.t 1300 - 64-th S t , , BneryVillis _L T Thorp & Son?, Inc*, 1351 Ocoan ayd. , E n ery villo MPtalciad in su la tio n co , In c ., P.. Box i? 3 j Torrence Cfatr In su latio n , 3600 - 20th Av, Sacramento 20 ruttOB Abestos & Supply C o ,, 532 m ttsr 3 t * , 3? Armstrong Cork (?oM 1&14 Ogden D riv e . Burlingame C fem In su la tin g Product* COrpf , 20B*I Lacy S t r e e t , Loa Angeles 31 q , p r Braun is C o ., 1000 South Fremont A v e ., Alhambra WCTia-ComiPg F ib e rs!** O o rp ,, P ,o , bo * B9# Sacramento nekaon & U t k in s co..,, I n c .,, P .Q . Bo 490, gator a fie ld Narine Engineering & supply C o ., 9 U East second S t w Loo Angeles ` uop Maintenance, InO,# 25P0 South A ila o tjc BlvdC*., Lea A n g le s 2S , R. Carpenter, X n 6 ,tj?Q 7 Front C t , , Sacramento f restera Asbestos a ., 675 Towneeni 3t* SP 3 in d u strial Indem nity Co., 360 Sam oa S t . , SP ia li f o r n ii Casualty Indemnity Exchange, 550 Kearny S t * , 3? standard Accident In s . C o., 8U0 West San Bruno Ave, , San Bruno `ravoiors In#. Co., 550 C a lifo r n ia S t . , 3? irgonsut Ins*. Co., 550 C a lifo r n ia S t .* SP American N otorit In a . Cb., A17 Montgocer/ S t . , BP totna Casualty k Surety Co./ 220 Montgomery S t , , $P Juarante* In *. C o ,, 550 KcCny St , SF :tn ith N ational In s, Ct>., 582 Market Sfc,, sf 'a e ifie Employer* Ina. Co., 244 Pine S t , , SP \B0O4iated Indennafcy Corp., 332 Pine S t , , SF State Compensation 1rs Fond 1* P erso n al Servie
*E-
;
iv^i pii^iHyiiipitptt
082
/
--
1A 4,L*.
^ g,
M
I
#
4
I
H< CLIFFORD P. HABPXNO Cl^im H>. 60 3P 153-55^
SE? v 1951
Bflinii. and s e r a d owj continued
Soj Jtj fcarrtah, P*dttck & Clancy* 501 ff m u ie la l C e n t ; Bl^K *# Oakland
Jiaj f& & Brophy, 150 San PofcW av#*, Oakland Sec w ick, Deterfc, Hare fc Arnold* 100 Bueb S t ,/ SF * A tin t
Gordon
K e ith
van t*n
n ji^ iaassK -f* w
i
i i
i
I
1
I
083
w gBpwiiiiwwi^^
'iri'^^wvrwp^ ju ii.'it'iggi^ 't v j j j 'i,.
'
A
,-V^.
..... *-
L* jjrag.^K
TfMunnaJri-
#
C lW lR D P, HARDXHO
fi, NELSON, Referee stember 21, i$ 6i
I
va.
PIANI ASBESTOS CO.,
j . t , m a fc ecus, m o.#
et al
Claim No.. 60 SF 193-05** Ir>J: Asbestosis
BEPOF? CF REFEREE CN OFDER. APPROVINO c o x w w B f a i P n n v A & j _________
si* * itti
Asbestos worker, born February 20, 1896, claims aco#6toaia aa the result o f industrial exposure in employments for nvpcrraa employe?* xelug back some 1$ y e a r s . O v e ra ll, meatming his employments in the industry in various cm f-of-Statc lo c a lit ie s , h< hue a history of approximately 30 years o f Intermittent exposure t< asbestos duet,
Tha record shows th a t a p p lic a n t continued working u n t i l
H iy , 1959* when he was n a ile d w ith sudden ever* ch e st p a in s . He
wV..a.M9sr4s4hmyooassbtppaMiki#MteoaMnulizzaaeet*>ad
4thVpoa&npt>ta
t
do xiaagb imbiea
iwnn.imoeiras^meivs
4inomxtVfearcvpMov srrmoeo
itn^JebtatdrIr
y
o as
ccascckhilAuuodfsvl.i1iigonngn,
e
v
cwhoev ea*t idenc
e
of
bastasi^.
I t l a now p ro p o s e d t o n ib b le t h s c a s e b y th e paym ent O f
3 0 0 .0 0 , nothing having been paid heretofore.
Concerning the present causa o f d is a b ilit y , Jhr, Horton C . Hlnshaw, J r . # otateg a* fellow a:
"The degree o f a sb e sto sis evident on X-ray here would rb t be expected to lead to heart disease^ and alBO the type of hfeart disease produced by lung disease IS quite d iffe r e n t from
ctlaM & e v h lo h le a d s t o o o r c o a ry o c o lv v & c n , w h ich t b t a jpafcxent
apparently has had. Consequently, i t would be my opinion that tuo heart disease, la a separate condition and not d ire c tly related to h is asbestoses1*>
ft
on the b asis o f pulmonary function t e s t s , the doctor
uotic]uded in h is fin a l report th at the p a tie n t's symptoms were to
1 large degree due to h is heart disease and not to asbestoses.
Indeed, on the ta&ia of d iffu sio n cap acity t e s t , lb was h is
.udgmenb th at the asbestosis was so mild as not to be d isab lin g
r productive o f any symptoms.
In an e a rlie r report, Dr. Norbert Frey, an behalf o f 'ho a p p lica n t, had concluded that the p atie n t had a moderate logree or pulmonary fib r o s is , which was productive o f some shortness o f breath. He expressed no opinion concerning the ndustrial contribution to the o v e r -n il d is a b ilit y .
Ox the record, the settlem ent le tfa ip and adequate.
JISWSITION? Order Approving compromise and Release to be paid
;o said ap p lican t, le ss $30.60 to Herbert Frey, H .D ., and le a *
ittomeya^ fe e o f $300,00 and relmburBemeni; coots
00 to
>e paid to appUtfan&'a attorneys out o f the moyrfpffisy&bie by
State Compensation Insurance Fund.
AHN:Dftm
) pi ^imiijv^ayagygy
084
/ *
rrr.
)
I.,
*.
|
I
before THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT CO W SSIO * Df TtiS STATS OF CALIFORNIA
CLAIR NO, fiU SF 153*354
Wmw^ **>*,c*rwta.i R Eceiygo
canp^D.PiTSc AND SELESSE
AUG 91961 A . FILED , Zavomnia Qffiet
C tW * m P*
1407 How Avanua . Saccanento 25. C a ll Ternie
V#*
a u G '1 9 ^
PLANT ASBESTOS CQflPjtfy employer
3 . T , THORP i SONESm,pltohyCr HCTALdLAO ZN9UIAT10H CO
' Employttf Ofllf CJ fal. fib* GJW tfiSULAtlO V
CmpJ-*jy**r PUTTO* ASBESTOS k SUPPLY CO
Employer
npnstttlNO CORK CO, employer
COAST IHSULa TINO PflDOUQTS COMP.
Employer
fc
C , F BRAUN 4 CO,
Employer
OliiSNS-jCORNJNG MBEfl&LAS CDRP*
.
E m p lo ye r
JACK I SOPKIWi CD, , IWD, fiw iayor
m n tn . CWBINEERXNB A SUPPLY M * uLur
FLUOR PIATNTWAiJCC, iNO
P , ft. CflftPSNTSft, INC. Employer
WESTER ASBSSfOB CO Employer
300 64th S tre e t Enaryvtll* C a lifo rn ia
351 Ocean Avenue CneryviLi*, ca lifo rn ia
Post o r ris * Box 179 Torrance, C a lifo rn ia
3500 - 20th Avenue a u i i w n t 20, C a lif o r n ie
532 Batons S tr e e t San F ra n cisco 3 , C a lifo rn ia
1814 Ogiea D riv e _ Susllngano, California
2P&U V *cy s t r s t La* Angelea 31 C a lifo r n ia
1000 Sooth Fremcnt Avenue AJhaabri, C aliforn ia
Post OrrtD Bat 99 Sacramento, C aliforn ia
Past OfFtco Boa LSD Bakersfield, C alifo n iia
841 Boat Second s t r e e t Los Angeleo, California
2500 South A t la n t ic B o u la va rP Lee Angeles 22, C a lifo r n ie
BOY F r o n t S t r e e t Soc'amanto 7 , C a lifo rn ia
675 70un**fl8 S tre e t Son FranoitcQ 3 C a lifo rn ia
INDUE RIAL INOE/1NITY COMPANY Tnfcuferea C a r r ie r
CALIF' ROSA CASUALTY M P e ilW W EXCHANGE IftBVren&e Carrier
STANDWO ACCIDENT INSURANCE COnPA^Y Irjauranpi C a rria r
TflAVStlUS INSURANCE rtF AY Ineurenffr C arrier
ARGOH iUT INSURANCE COMPANY Inouranoa Carrier
AdeRiCAN narORisrs w s v m i t e company I * ytfF*ric# C arrier
AETW CASUALTY i SURETY W>PMY insurance C a rrie r.
CUARAJirCE INSURANCE COUP ANY loevw m e Carrier
r m t !E national insurance company Inoyrartee C a rrie r
PACIFIC ERPtOYSRS lUSUftAftCC COWPMY insurance Carrier
350 B*n*em S tr e e t
Sun PaniftD, 6 llffi# n l
550 Kearny S tre e t
Sen Francitcor C a lifo rn ia
&i*9 Uqor San Bruno Avenu*
San Bzxma, C a lifo r n ia
55 C a lifo rn ia S tre e t
San Francleep, C a lifo r n ia
550 C a lifo rn ia S tre e t
Sen Francisco* C a lifo rn ie
e l?
screet
San franc*boo, C a lifo rn ia
220 flontgoioiry s tr e e t
San Francisco, Californ ia
550 K*rny S t r e e t
8n r r a n c ia C n , C a lif o r n i a
582 R U M a t S t r e e t
Sen fra n ctscO y C a lif o r n ia
3730 Piedmont Avenue
OiMlend l l t C a ll T w in*
*1*
"W " P"
0
QS
Vf, * L-*
..^aMuAsf.L
.^ j
^CRE TBE IRDflBIAI, ACCIDENT CGttaSItK OF THE SEKTE OF CALIFORNIA CLAIM HO. CO SP 193-*
c u ford p, bardino, Applicant,
va, P U ASBESTOS CO,, J . T. THORP A SONS. INC M2TALCLAD INSULATION CO ,, IN C ,, nw ,,CAW, db* CW INSULATION, DUTTON ASBESTOS k SUPPLY CO, ARMStRONG CORK
COAST INSULATING PRODUCTS' CRPm . BRAUN & CO, , OWENS- CORNINO m^IGLAS CRP,, A m o * a H0PRIW5 CO* . INC, , MARINS ENGINEERING & SUPPLY 00, * FLUOR MRIHTENfiNCB, INO, . >4. R. CARPENTER, XNCL i VOstfSHN ASBESTOS CO* , iNDUSWflb UHEhMiTY C0,v CALIFORNIA CASUALTY 3N w m EXOfiANOS, STANDARD ACCIDENT BE 00, TRAVELERS INS. CO., AR0NAUT INg, CO , AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS. CO., AETNA CASUALTY & SURETY CO,* GUARANTEE I N I CO. , ZENITH NATIONAL IMS, CO., FAt;:PIO EMPLOYERS INS. CO , ASSOCIATED BOCHMHOT COUP., and STATE COMPENSATION XRgUMWSB FUND,
ORDER APPROVINO Compromise m > r e lea se
SEP ^ j ;$8J. 'k _
The p firtiee to the above e n title d action having f i le d ft
Cortuftmla* end Release herein, on Aug, 9 ,19 6 1? s e t t lin g the above
cm '! f o r $3,300.00, in addition to a l l eutts which mpy have been paid
Pn -flo u aly , and requeatlng that i t be approved; And th is Cowmiailoh
hdvtnsr considered the e n tire record, in clu din g eAldjCemprcfliee and
V
A* jaen, now fin d a that i t should be approved; and, GOOD CAUSE APPEARING THEREFORr
IT IS GRCH >tht e u d Compromise and R elease b e , end I t in
he^Jby approved, payable as fo llo v a :
By DfWSTRIAL INDEMNITY COMPANY
S 3 3 ?.ID
By CALIFORNIA CASUALTY INDEMNITY EXCHANGE
By STANDARD ACCIDENT INSURANCE COMPANY
i 6 -%&
Fy TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY
50.57
By ASfiQNAUT fitSiraUnaS. COMPANY
-
33*71
A
086