Document MGYw56a3Q90EE9DwxNJa2DgJz
FILE NAME Cape Asbestos CAPE
DATE 1949 Dec DOC CAPE004
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Journal Article H. Wyers - Asbestosis Postgraduate Medical Journal
a December 1949
WYERS
nevertheless that a considerable number of men
who develop complicated pneumoconiosis when
aged 30 to 40 are a very bad risk Tuberculosis 4 was present 36 per cent of all pneumoconiotic 1 deaths in 16 per cent of all deaths due to simple
4 pneumoconiosis and in 39 per cent of all deaths due to complicated pneumoconiosis The figure
36 cent of the extent of complicating tuberculosis in coal miners pneumoconiosis is higher
Asbestosis
than the figure given by Gooding and others but it is considerably lower than the figure for other industries especially for slate mining in
North Wales where tuberculosis is present in 75
per cent of pneumoconiotic deaths Finally one is impressed by the apparently in-
creased susceptibility of coal miners with simple
pneumoconiosis to pneumonia and acute respira-
tory infection
BIBLIOGRAPHY
BALGAIRIES E. DECLERCQ G. JARY J. and NADIRAS P.
1948 Revue Medicale Miniere 2 12 CUMMINS LYLE and SLADDEN A. F. 1930 J. of Path
and Bact 33-
CAMAZIAN FILS PIERRE 1947 ' Recherches Sur Les
Pneumokonioses Dans Les Charbonnages
DAVIES
I.
and
MANN
K.
1948
'
Proceedings
of the
Ninth
International Congress on Industrial Medicine In the
press FLETCHER C. M. 1948 Brit Med J. 1 1015 1005
GOODING C. G. 1946 Lancet 2 891
SMITH GORDON Personal communication GOUGH J. JAMES W. R. L. and WENTWORTH J. E.
1949 A Comparison of the Radiological and Pathological Changes in Coal Workers Pneumoconiosis Journal of the Faculty of Radiologists I 1 GREGORY J. C. 1831 Edin Med and Surg Journal 36 389
GRENFELL D. R. Personal communication
HART P. D'ARCY and ASLETT E. A. 1942 Special Report
Series M.R.C. No. 243 B
JENKINS
T.
H.
1948
'
Mining
Aspects of Pneumo-
coniosis in South Wales Paper read before the South Wales
Institute of Engineers
KEATING N. Personal communication
LECLERCQ J. BALGAIRIES E.
BONTE G.
DECLERCQ G. 1948 Revue Medicale Miniere 4 23
and
MCCANN HURTADO KALTREIDER and FRAY 1937
Journ Clin Invest 16 23
MEIKLEJOHN A. 1949 Lancet 2 360 Contribution of the Employment History to Clinical Diagnosis
ROGERS ENID 1944 Paper read before the Tuberculosis
Association
RUBIN ELI H. 1947 ' Diseases of the Chest W. B. Saunders
and Co.
TATTERSALL N. 1926 J. of Indus Hygiene 8 466
THOMAS R. W. Personal communication
ASBESTOSIS
By H. WYERS M.A. M.D. D.I.H.
Although certain difficulties remain to be explained the theory that silica is a causative agent in pulmonary fibrosis is widely accepted When however the fibrogenic potentialities of silicates
are considered these difficulties are very greatly
increased Olivine for example has been shown
it provoke only a foreign body reaction and has been suggested for foundry work whereas asbestos is notorious Studies in mineralogical
composition of atmospheric dusts and ashed lung tissue are progressing and to the data found theories of solubility and crystal form are being applied If the solubility is high as in the case of silicic acid gels and sols the material is eliminated too fast to produce fibrosis A low solubility such ds in mixtures of quartz and aluminium equally retards fibrosis King 1938 There appears also to be an optimum size of particle with a surface area which will release silica in sufficient quantity for a sufficient length of time
In animal experiments this was found be about 0.1 micron Tebbens et al 1945 In the
case of asbestos fibres it has been shown that
whereas there is an excess of chrysotile over horn-
blende varieties in dusts ashed lung tissues con-
tain only hornblende Sundius 1938 Kuhn 1941 It is concluded that it is the chrysotile in solution which is the fibrosing agent Gardner
a 1938 demonstrated by animal experiments that
longer fibres produced fibrotic reaction which
did not occur with shorter fibres and concluded
that asbestosis is at any rate in part a mechanic-
ally conditioned complex of lung changes In support of this mechanical theory Johnstone 1948 records the clinical observation that workers at the Thetford Mills exposed to high concentrations of extremely fine asbestos dust did not suffer
from asbestosis
Structurally silica shows continuous threedimensional arrangements of SiO tetrahedra and
to these may be related such a surface as to pro-
duce the characteristic biological effects Those silicates therefore which most nearly resemble quartz in having a dimensional network of oxygen tetrahedra likely theoretically to produce similar biological phenomena These
a
eeprelaten
a
an cate
pont
Ser. citar pek paouins
are) ae tee
mow
gt
Soefot
ir
menag wt eo
a re
ae
ee emwre ty
aA:
iedtes ee
pare en en ee
Cte eeae oe Neee
lo Ranebomn
oe
pn Senal SeOe
nto
oe
omne
o
a
e oeile.
e
ae he
nt
+
theas gO Fae
Be hae wes.
3he
Ae BhanRGA,IE,
real IR
5
ud
mpenrena raed Tre
ee
ee
ar
A
rep oewheae aa ae Ta a
ne
Fay
Loan
:
aus
7. ane
ne
holy
2
.
8
ue
:
ye
632
POSTGRADUATE MEDICAL JOURNAL
December 1949
7
diminishing are grouped in
Nagoelschmidt 1949
order of similarity by as alkali feldspars sheet
structures such as micas and kaolin double and
single chain structures like amphiboles and pyroxenes and finally the orthosilicates such as olivine Animal experiments tend to confirm this but it is pointed out that the type of binding of the oxygen tetrahedra is of biological importance and aluminium silicates such as sericite
and kaolin are not likely to present a major
silicosis hazard
h,
~ mattresses
|
Asbestos enters into the com
position of lagging material for steam pipes jointing for steam pipes panelling of rooms tiles the lining of chemical pans the coating of bulk-
heads of ships and marine piers and perhaps most
significantly into the brake linings and clutch rings rings
of motor cars
The properties which commend asbestos to
modern industrialists are its resistance to heat
acids electricity and sea water and its fibrous
structure which enables it to be spun Unline
The diagnosis of pathological states of the lungs
due to dusts also presents many clinical and
radiological difficulties A high incidence of pul-
monary disease among those exposed to pure silica is presumptive evidence of an etiological re-
lationship but the
coniosis is difficult
rare case of to establish
talc pneumo-
High atomic
weights and consequent opacity produce shadows on the ray film from inhaled dusts
which are not necessarily pathological as for
example in the siderosis of arc welders Doig and
McLaughlin 1936
Asbestos its History Uses and Mineralogy
vegetable fibre it can be split in a longitudinal direction to microscopic size without discovering
an ultimate element and without loss of ide discovering
The shortest fibre recorded is Grand (4
chrysotile and is of the order of 0.00075 mm length whilst the longest is exhibited in the Maritzburg Museum and is 43 in in length This latter fibre came from Umsinga Natal and is also probably chrysotile The best length of fibre for spinning is 1in 3.75 cm
The asbestiform minerals form a group of
silicates which differ widely in chemical composition but resemble each other in being fibrous and in their resistance to heat acids and sea
Whatever doubts there may be as to the fibro-
genic potentialities of many silicates the processing of asbestos unquestionably exposes the worker to the risk of lung disease It has been
used on a small scale since very early times being
known to the Greeks as 4 do^ rossignifying un-
quenchable Used as a substantive ,,do^ ectoswas unslaked lime whilst the masculine gender
^ do^ e toswas used to denote asbestos The
word ... > which,,in modern English
speech signifies the disease asbestosis to the Greeks a plastering or stuccoing This last word _ was originally suggested by Cooke 1924 when he
also drew attention to a passage in Herodotus
describing a cremation cloth made of asbestos The Romans knew it under the name of amianthus
a word of Greek origin signifying absence of miasma or pollution They obtained it from the Italian Alps and the Ural It seemed appropriate that the Vestal Virgins guardians of the Sacred Fire symbol of the deepest emotions and instincts in Roman family life the last rite of paganism to be extinguished should have used asbestos lamp wicks Another fibrous mineral resembling
Italian amianthus was spun and woven into a
cloth in Siberia during the 13th century A factory for the manufacture of asbestos articles was opened in Russia in 1760. The discovery of asbestos in 1876 contributed greatly to modern
industrial expansion Today asbestos is used for a wide variety of
purposes Textiles enter into the manufacture of
fighting suits safety curtains and boiler
water Legally asbestos means any fibrous
silicate mineral and any admixture containing any
'
such mineral whether crude crushed or opened
Asbestos Industry Regulations 1931 eralogists classify them as follows
Min-
1. Serpentine Group 2H 3MgO 2SiO Characterized by a high percentage of magnesia and water generally white in colour naturally lubricant and therefore suitable for stuffing boxes
and glands Examples chrysotile picrolite 2. Rhombic Amphiboles MgFe SiO Soda
confers a brown colour when present Like the
third group the members of this division contain
high percentages of ferric oxide and have a low
. water content The texture harsh elastic-
enclosing a maximum amount of air in a minimum
of incombustible matter They are particularly
. efficient as heat insulators Examples antho-
phyllite amosite
Amphiboles
re
a
3. Monoclinic Amphiboles Tremolite CaO
3MgO 4SiO2 Actinolite CaO MgFe 4SiO2 Crocidolite NaFe SiO3 Fe SiO3 -
The presence of soda in this group confers a
lavender blue colour Hall 1918 The ferric
oxide content of crocidolite encourages slag forma-
tion when it is employed as a wrapping for electrodes The countries of origin are chiefly
Canada white chrysotile South Africa blue crocidolite and the brown amosite Australia and
the U.S.S.R. It is found in the banded iron-
stones the deposits being classed as cross fibre slip fibre and mass fibre according to the direction of cleavage relative to the orientation of the vein
633
.
ae
aar e or
.
aot
ae ns
.
:
ae
FIG Asbestosis bodies in a section of fibrotic lung Photomicrograph x 400
From the case shown in Fig 4
Chemical analysis explains some of the varying properties of the three groups
i Canadian
Canadian
Chrysotile Crocidolite Crocidolite ~
Chrysotile
-
cent = Per cent
Vumina core
+1
50
+ ric Oxide j 2 . 35
gnesia ow.)
+0
2
italis
img
8
ter
1+
+
aa
100
100
Amosite
Per cent
+7
37 6
I
3
IOO
- anufacture
The mineral is obtained by open mining akin quarrying Outside the mine adit the crude . bestos is reduced in size and pieces of iron are tached manually ' cobbing ) or by mechanical eans It is then transported to the factory in lined sacks where it is crushed in a large
o n lge runner or a small pan mill foreign matter
emoved and the fibres opened in a Crighton achine The ancient process of carding follows
by which the fibres are made to lie parallel in a continuous $ sliver Essentially this machine con-
sists of toothed drums and condenser rollers The
derivation
of the
word
'
card
from
the
Latin
carduus a teasel or thistle doubtless indicates the
means by which this operation was carried out on other fibres in primitive times Slivers are twisted
frames together to form strong yarn on spinning material by ring or flyer as in other textiles The
is then plaited into rope or it may be woven into
cloth on the conventional power loom To the
medical observer perhaps the loom as a special
significance for the weaver's beam has given its name to living tissues Occupying a horizontal
position in modern looms its historical position
was vertical The Greeks called it lor^sas they
did a ship's set upright
cloth itself
mast
The and
or indeed anything which was word came to be applied to the eventually to the histological
structure of living organisms
History of Asbestosis
In 1906 the Departmental Committee on Compensation for Industrial Diseases 1907 heard
evidence from various authorities arising out of
"
en
pe
ennt dAa
tnig) ns
eagrenma mak. Ryeor Pa al Pike
Lo
OW
ee
ee. bite
of
2 aeeae
Fe csaie
magepeors
we
=
fa
ae OMEoD
alie
om
eo niete
eont
haterNe
oon
ee
hatae osc
PaticemnGeant, CORE
ie e
To Pte:
SY SE PEO
SH OW
as.
oJ ae
2
~e
+o
at
4
Sia re
a
DR OR
vay
>Leo
snojuesur ue yim xedsied ut pasojoua Aq7e103
Suroq oa soueay Suruurds Aro30jsuo ut ! uOTNUOTIE
jeoads paarsoe1 sey uonsneyxe ysnq
pauruexa
Jesajeur yeorgojoyyed =yonur puy AZojorper jo
opeul Uaaq sey o8 ) syadxjao sjaued Aq Ajyenuue
urese pue Ayentur pouruexo Ayjeotpaur useq aaey
syueunsedsep Ajsnp 0} syursjuo ye 161 aourg
astasip
ayy Suyjorucs ul eAnoaya AyperuaS uaaq sey
uone|sidaT
3Jso joNUOD 9Y3 YM paryy oy} pue
uoHesuadu0s Jo preMe ay2 YIM puooas ay}
preg
[esIpayy B JO suoNoUN} pue uoONMINsUCd ay}
WA WYeap isiy oy,
(16s1)uonensay Aagsnpuy
Soyoqsy ey} pue (161) awayog (sisoisaqsy)
Auysnpuy soysaqsy ayy
(161a) wayog (syuaut
-a8uvsry ]eorpayAl) sisoysaqsy puke sisootic ay
posvadde svaX Surmoyjoy ayy uy
(of61)aatg pue
JOY IMarITAI Jo yroday ay3 07 Burpeay Aammbur ayy
paieudisaid yorym pur sisoaqy Areuowynd pure
Sojsaqse usemjeq diysuonejr jeooambaun ue
Yst[qeisa 0} poulaas yorym
saAamoy (gz61)aseo
SJaplag sem ay (Fz61)yoog Aq pue (F161) ayeg
Aq Alqeiou
paysodasaq 01 panhunuod sisojsaqse
JO Sasey
uonBayTIaDyo Ayarys sanynoyip
03 Surmo ajnpayog paryy, ay3 zapun saseasip jo sy]
9Y} UT WOISN]IU! $y PusUNUOdar JOU pynos Aay? yay
AaTUUWIOD) ay}
suonedndsuorey199 07 sytoads pur
Aiqua yeorur e& sem sismpyd ploiqy wy} Burseize
381.44
OJfo ade 9y3 ynoge punos parp pey soyeur
4OmsMty JO autY Jey pajeis pey
FEpase Jayzom
Wool pies Be
uRWTSIU,
sistyypdromgy yeordAy ,
Jo oo6r ur jendsoyy ssorg Surreys 9y} ur parp
pty OYM Iayx10M soysaqse UL JO asked ay} payodax
Aesinyy, andeyuojy, Armbua yyy yy
9061oy
uonesuadwi0D suaUyI0A\ ayy Jo ajnpayog pay,
a4) UT sasvasip JRLYSNpUT UIE}I90 JO WOISNpUT oy}
*AABD Ssaosqr UB
Spuno.ins BulouToIgd snoweEnbs ve afod Jamo] au) 1y
einatdpauayoryy pure stsojsaqse jo svare yeuos{jod
yoefq-aniq Surmoys Bun] jo uonoas rg
savad
aay
qdapSuruuidg
Sf au ajeway eqyn
z OL
OFG1 40QNEIIICT
ecember 1949
WYERS Asbestosis
evice which permits easy access to bobbins andling has been reduced to a minimum and od housekeeping kept on a high standard With ry few exceptions cases certified by the Board asbestosis have industrial histories extending to
eriods prior to 1931
athology
;
Whereas the heavier and smaller particles of
lica find their way to the alveoli and thence to the
mphatic channels the lighter and larger particles
asbestos block up the finer bronchioles Chains
etrmine silicate tetrahedra with intervening cations
etermine the fibrous structure of asbestos and
ese chains in frayed bundles interlock and are rested Hence silicosis is a fibrosis of the lymph odes and asbestosis a fibrous cuffing of the
ronchioles Dangerous fibres measure about 20
icrons and a noxious concentration is said to
ccur when the dust count exceeds five million
articles per cubic foot of air Page 1937 There is no local necrosis or leucocytic reaction
> the trapped fibre such as would occur if a rotoplasmic poison like colloidal silica hydroxide were liberated It seems significant that if the
brous character of chrysotile asbestos is absent s in its chemical equivalent serpentine the dust
; inert Instead the lining epithelial cells are esquammated as a result of friction and make ttempts to engulf fibres which proving too long re sometimes observed projecting from these
dust' cells Asbestosis giant cells are also seen
lue to small aggregations of dust cells They are igmented stippled and multinuclear Fibro-
plasts appear around bronchioles and alveoli in
nterlobular septa and in the subpleural connective issue Asbestosis bodies and pigment are also
present Finally there is an invasion by collagenous
fibres to form the characteristic reticular pattern
around the distal arborizations of the bronchial
tree The alveoli capillaries and venules are
crushed by the fibrosis
Asbestosis bodies can be demonstrated in the
lun pleura and sputum The length of time tak for them to develop is unknown They
car : be found in the mineral itself It has been
sho + by staining reactions with sodium nitropru le and ammonium sulphide and by dissoly phuric the outer portion with concentrated sulphuric acid that they consist of a central fibre of
dsats Fig ) with an containing segined covering which is thought to have been deposited by a colloidal reaction between the fibre and he blood proteins Gloyne 1929 Their
presence is held to be evidence of exposure to
asbestos and not of the disease itself
Dense sessile adhesions of the pleura are
common and the interlobar fissure obliterated
The pleura has a ground glass appearance with
yellow horn plaques 2 or 3 in in diameter
besides patches of recent pleurisy The cut surface
of the lung exhibits the typical black polygonal areas roughly lobular in distribution in to gonal in 3 mm to 6 mm in diameter on a red background of bronchopneumonia The areas
tend to confluence at the bases and exhibit the
'
pleural
drift
common
to
the
pneumoconioses
Confluence is becoming rarer as the dust cloud
becomes less concentrated Fig 2 Compensa-
tory emphysema on the other hand seems to be occurring more frequently as cases live longer It occurs chiefly along the margins of the lungs
sometimes giving rise to bullae but not so commonly as in silicosis One case in the present
series of 115 fatal cases died of a spontaneous
pneumothorax consequent on rupture of such a bulla The right heart is generally enlarged and there are the usual signs of back pressure in the
liver
Clinical Syndrome
In the writer's series the average exposure for
males was 16.2 years for females 7.3 years and for all cases 10.4 years The duration of the disease
was 6.4 years for both sexes The mean age at death was 46.5 years in the case of men 37.5 years in the case of women and 40.8 years for all
\
FigFig 3.-J.N. male aet 45.
Sectional dept 18 years
Fingers
ray of lung showing fine mottling Fingers show
gross clubbing Advanced asbestosis
re
aeNY
eeele
'
14) Taye
Se
a =
a
eae
Paae
Manes
eamesa wesdbnte
van nine?
a
moro
ae .
ae
oan
eeenige
ie
ee nage
Sink
Lt are
ae
af an Wo
ae
ae
e
FR
we
Ce
^ OSTGRADUATEMEDICAL JOURNAL
cases
Burton
Dyspnoea is a universal complaint;
Wood regarded asbestosis as a mono-
symptomatic disease Dry cough is noticeable on
rising in the morning and during changes of
temperature A paroxysm usually terminates with
the production of some thick mucoid sputum very
rarely flecked with blood and in the later stages
containing nummules of pus An increase in the
quantity of sputum indicates a complicating factor
Anorexia loss of weight fatigue and chest pains
are occasional symptoms
The cardiovascular signs of the disease are im-
portant because once established they are per-
manent whereas adventitious sounds in the chest
tend to be evanescent An earthy cyanosis has
been described Of 53 consecutive cases of
asbestosis examined by the writer 29 showed clubbing of the fingers the toes being similarly affected in eight of the cases an incidence of
54.7 per cent In the same series the second
pulmonic sound was found to be accentuated in
33 patients that is to say 62.2 per cent of the cases These signs appeared separately together and quite often not at all even in advanced disease The liver was never palpable in an ambulatory patient nor was there oedema of the dependent
parts
The chest is flattened bilaterally The respiratory excursion rarely exceeds 1 in 2.5 cm
Percussion often reveals a sensation of resistance
to the finger ( felting ) which may be general or localized Probably this is a reflection of the dense character of the fibrotic lung or of the pleural plaques which are often seen post mortem resonance is occasionally noted Dry crackling sounds can generally be heard along the emphysematous margins but often become generalized or disappear altogether in the same
individual An odd sonorous rhonchus may be heard There is deficient air entry at the bases
and expiration over the anterior aspect of the chest
is harsh
Radiological Appearances
Whereas the roentgenogram may show considerable involvement in silicosis with few if any symptoms the reverse is apt to be found in
'
asbestosis Sayers 1938 This is the opinion of all with experience of the disease The typical appearance of the lung fields is a diffuse haze or
point mottling in the lower halves or twothirds Fig 3 Emphysema may be seen in the
upper zones and of later years a granular pattern in the lower zones somewhat resembling cotton wool which has been teased out Fig 4 The domes of the diaphragm are flattened and may show coarse striae running up into the lower lung
fields The vertical diameter of the chest is
FIG 4.-T. aet 45. Sectional dept 18 years Asbestosis bodies shown in Fig 1. ray of lung shows coarse fibrosis and emphysema Gross
clubbing of fingers fibrosis Eventually died with tuber-
culous infection
diminished The phrenic sulcus is frequently blunted A shaggy left cardiac border is
often seen in advanced cases and sometimes the
entire silhouette and diaphragmatic cupolae are
blurred
Complications
Bronchiectasis has been stated to occur fre-
quently Only three undoubted cases occurred in
the present series and one of these was a con-
genital condition affecting the apex
Pregnancy was associated with the deaths of
two women suffering from asbestosis The disease
does not seem to be adversely affected by pregnancy but the strain of labour may tip the balance
in favour of right heart failure
i
Bronchopneumonia is almost invariably found
complication post mortem The next commonest
is tuberculosis with a much lower incidence than
in silicosis and affecting a lower age group In 115 fatal cases 15 men and 21 women 31.3 per cent in all showed also pulmonary tuberculosis
The mean age at death was 34.9 years after an
average exposure to asbestos of 7.6 years Taking the remaining cases alone the age at death was
43.6 years after an exposure of 11.5 years
December 1949
-
WYERS Asbestosis
An excess mortality from cancer of the lung in cases of asbestosis was recorded by Merewether
1947 Of 6,884 cases of silicosis 1.32 per cent were found to be complicated by pulmonary cancer
whereas the incidence was 13.2 per cent in 235
cases of asbestosis Wedler 1943 collected 92
mortem reports of asbestosis cases from lifferent parts of the world and found an in-
cidence of 16 per cent pulmonary cancers The development of the lesion corresponded with the engths and intensity of the exposure 12 to 42 years Boemke 1947 called attention to the association of asbestosis with pulmonary cancer he latter almost always taking the form of carcinoma of the pavement epithelium He thought t possible that in addition to chemical processes he purely mechanical effects of the asbestos needles may also be responsible for the develop-
ment of carcinoma
In the present series of 115 deaths from
isbestosis 1 males and six females had pulmonary
cancer whilst cancer of other organs was present
n three males and four females pancreas colon stomach ovary The proportion of pulmonary ancers in the series was therefore 14.8 per cent
Squamous cancers were present in nine cases oat ell in five columnar cell in one endothelioma of he pleura in one and the histology unknown in
one Two of the cases were brothers The mean
ige at death was 52 years the mean exposure to
asbestos dust 17.3 years and they died a mean period of 6.6 years after leaving the industry
Fig 2
Medical Aspects of Asbestosis
It is difficult to assess the effects of such
factors as personal habits and the preference of families and those of defective physique for certain
occupations Meiklejohn 1929 has pointed out the possible effects in the past on the spread of Tuberculosis among Sheffield knife grinders by the
habit of spitting into the water trough through which the abrasive wheel passed Stewart 1929 has indicated that the high incidence of tubercuosis among boot operatives is due to the attraction of disabled persons and their families to a light jocupation Similarly the family histories of those
ing of asbestosis and tubercle frequently dis-
ose the presence of tuberculosis in those of the
me household who have never been exposed to
sbestos
employment survival showed a sex Suferentiation the mean period for men in this
series was 2.3 years and for women 9.8 years
oubt many women ceased work to marry
No and
symptoms of asbestosis did not appear until some
time later
Of the 115 deaths only two had commenced
work subsequent to the 1931 Regulations a man after ten years exposure and a woman who also had tuberculosis after two years exposure Three other men have also developed the disease after
exposures of five four and four years respectively the last one having been certified in 1946
The writer has 28 cases under observation at
present business
The men are occupied as follows executive storekeeper painter and
window cleaner lagger in other employ cleaning brasses ventilation engineer in charge of sports and social sections laboratory handyman retired ,.
small printing press operator foreman in charge of stores foreman in charge of rubber department
light carpenter tally clerk week relief handyman in canteen at home recovering from
tuberculosis and one relief gateman The women
are occupied as follows light housework in charge of works solarium canteen work repairing overalls in works laundry three doing light house-
work and two doing sewing duties and mending
duties at home
The reduction in the intensity of the dust cloud
seems to be producing a more chronic type of disease Merewether's investigation of 1929 indicated a period of seven years exposure for the disease to develop whereas this series which commenced in 1931 indicates that an exposure of
ten years is necessary
Through the kindness of Dr. Roodhouse Gloyne the writer had access to the late Dr. Burton Wood's notes on 89 cases of asbestosis
which he had collected up to 1931. Of these cases
17 showed clubbing of the fingers i.e. 19.1 per cent a much lower figure than the incidence of 54.7 per cent in this series Radiologically the fine mottling is giving place to a coarser shadowing
which seems to be due to compensatory
emphysema At post mortem confluence of the characteristic lesion is becoming rarer and cancer
incidence is rising
Other Silicates
Of the other silicates talc is the only one con-
cerning which there is definite evidence of a harmful effect on the lungs although there is some
clinical and radiological evidence of pulmonary fibrosis due to mica McLaughlin et al 1949
reported the
confirmed at
this country
first case of talc pneumoconiosis
post mortem to have occurred in
The radiographs showed nodular
shadows which on the left side were fluffy
Histologically the lung showed greyish nodules of
loosely woven fibrous tissue in association with bronchioles There were also curious bodies
closely resembling asbestosis bodies Mineralogical investigation proved that the condition was not
in fact asbestosis but duteo talca hydrated
at
he gate
tenaAEs
ane
sap
e rten,
=
rte
neceae
C
ye
ne
nti poe
lie
ee
Sn
ee
-{. eaehg ee = I pr
Tete eeey _~ e ae e tar
Re
Toete ee oe Te Ps
oo
He
aongeas ew
Be
TPG,
panean Ey
SS,
S2 e,
.
Wa
:
ie. et
638 oa
|P.OSTGRADUATE at
Mg.Si magnesium silicate
in certain instances
Talc may
of tremolite and it arise as an alteration product
both
may replace anthophyllite in
cases inheriting an imperfectlyimperfectly fibrous form
Norwegian and Canadian tales are platy but
contain a proportion of fibres The
respiratory
MEDICAL JOURNAL
.
December 1949
a passages appearedappeared to have acted as filter
the fibres to get into the lungs whilst
allowing
plates
The
authors
concluded
that
rejecting
talc
the
coniosis may be ascribed primarily to theppnheyusimcoa-l
form acicular crystals of the mineral but that
asbestos is more actively fibrogenic
BIBLIOGRAPHY
ASBESTOS INDUSTRY H.M. Stationery Office
ASBESTOSIS
SCHEME
1931
. ASBSEtSatTiOonSery IOfNfiDcUe STRY REGULATIONS 1931 H.M.
BOEMKE F. 1947 Med Monatsschr 1 2-6
BOEMKE F. 1947 Chem Zentr 1 835 COOKE W. E. 1924 Brit Med J. 147
DEPARTMENTAL COMMITTEE ON
C Fd OR INDUSTRIAL DISEASES 1907
COMPENSATION
Minutes
3496 p 127 H.M. Stationery Office
of Evidence
DOIG A. T. and MCLAUGHLIN A. I. G.
771
1936 Lancet 1
FAHR T. 61 1914 Woch
, 625
Asbestosis
Pneumoconiosis
Pneumoconiosis Munch Med
GARDNER L. U. 1938 J. Amer Med Ass 111 1
GLOYNE S. R. 1929 Tubercle 10 404
HALL A. L. Asbestos in the Union of S.
Survey Memoir No. 12 1918
AfricAa frica
GeoloGeologgicail cal
JOHHNygSiTenOeNp E 36R.9T. 1948 Occupational Medicine and Industrial
KING E. J. and ROMAN W. 1938 Biochem
KUHN J. 1941 Arch f Gewerbepath und
J. 32 2283
Gewerbehyg 10 473
MCLAUGHLIN A.A. I. G. ROGERS E. and DUNHAM
1949 Talc Pneumoconiosis Brit J. Industr Med 6
MEIKLEJOHN A. 1929 M.D. Thesis Glasgow
MEREWETHER
Inspector
E.
R.
A.
1947
Annual
Report
of the
of Factories H.M. Stationery Office
Chi
Stationery MEREWETHER E.
Effects of Asbestos
NAGOELSCHMIDT PAGE R. T. and BLOOMFIELD Repts 52 1713-
R. A. and Dust on the
G. 1949
PRICE C. W. 1930 Lungs H.M. Research 2 170
Remetien Remetien Office
J. J. 1937 U.S. Pub Health
SAYp ER6S0 R. R. and LANZA A. J. 1938 Silicosis and Asbestos v
SEILER 1928 Brit Med J. 11 982
SUNDIUS J. SILICOSIS AND ASBESTOSIS
MENTS
SCHEME
1931
MEDICAL H.M.
ARRANGE
Stationery Office
STEWART A. et al 1929 Brit Med J. 1 926
SUNDIUS
SUNDIUS NN.. aand nd BYBYGGDEN DENA. A. 1938J. InIndd HyHgyg ToxTox 20
TEBBENS D. D. SCHULZ R. Z. and
7. Ind Hyg Tox 27 199
DRINKER P. 1945 1945
WEDLER Lungenkrebs Med
H. W. 1943 Asbestose und
Woch
Aug. Aug.
No.
6 69 No.
31/32
575-6
Dent
THE ROYAL MEDICAL FOUNDATION
of Epsom College
We appeal to all members of the medical
In every profession some must fall
profession who do not already already do so to subscribe
wayside by the
; others must
to the above Royal Medical
days Our object is to help the families
inevitably fall upon evil
of those less fortunate brethren To that
a 50 ordinary pensions to medical men or their their widows
end the Foundation in 1948 has provided
b 45 Foundation Scholarships for boys
educated c 13 Scholarships for girls
clothed and maintained entirely free of
cost
_
_
tee
see
d Education of 28 boys at reduced fees
oe
vee
ve
we
te
vee
vee
we
vee
:
tee
e 140 pensions and annuities of varying amounts vee te wee
we
.
f Grants towards education of 56 boys and girls
g Grants to medical men widows and spinsters
tee
we
tee
on
tee
oon
This is an expenditure of 18,103 in the
year
oe
tae
wee
Foundation
:
s 8,7028,702
570
1,968
3,023
1,843
see
497
remain Without sufficient help from them
even our existing benefactions would have to be
ing applicants men widows and children of
dation to make
school age
curtailed Owing to lack of funds many deserv
educational grants grants for those who
most welcome
cannot obtain Scholarships
unassisted The Sherman Bigg Fund enables Donations to augment augment the
the
Foun-
income of this Fund will be
We therefore beg you earnestly to send either
may if you wish stipulate the particular
a subscription or a donation to this Foundation Foundation
form of benefaction on which it is to be
during 1949. When doing so you
expended Subscriptions and donations may be sent to
by whom full information will
any of us or preferably to the Secretary the
request gladly be sent on
Secretary's Office Epsom College Surrey
JOHN SELL COTMAN Treasurer HAROLD SPITTA Chairman
ERNEST GOODHART Chairman
|
me
er
a
Ae
BPE