Document M4ZowQV1BqgavvOYKbRyREJQx
Fifth. Report of the Lead and Calcium Studies0
192? - 1328*
Massachusetts General Hospital*
The last report of the activity of our laboratory in
studying lead and calcium metabolism was issued in October, 1327*
Since then our laboratory has continued to study factors which
might influence lead and calcium metabolism* Those associated
with me in the work were Dr* William Salter, Dr* Ray Farquharson
of Montreal, Miss Dorothy Tibbetts, and Miss Elsie Rossmeisl*
The result of the work of the previous years was confirmed and,
briefly, this may be summarized as follows:
Calcium salts may be pulled from the bones by various
methods: First of all by a diet low in calcium; second, by means
of the active principle of the parathyroid glands which act spsfeifi-
v
cally in increasing the calcium excretion; and third by the thyroid
gland, which has an enormous influence on -calcium excretion, a fact
not before appreciated* These facts are incorporated in our pre-
vious reports*
VMOtOlM CilWAH
In the last year wb^studied^these'factors far more'carefully
in order to determine whether the other normal salts in the body
were influenced in the same way that calcium was* This v;as a very
difficult and complicated problem in metabolism but the results indi
cate that the effect of these various procedures; upon other normal
inorganic salts is negligible compared to the action upon calcium
excretion. In other words, the chief effect is in pulling calcium
from the bones and the other inorganic salts in the tissues are
relatively spared from strain, -Another important problem lay in the effect of diet alone
and re, therefore, studied with great care the effect upon, inorganic salt excretion of varying the acidity and alkalinity of the diets, Worl: of this type is laborious but important, and little of it has previously been done. Our studies indicate that the salts in the diet have a definite influence o.n the calcium excretion. 5hue, a man could be on a potentially acid diet-, talcing large quantities of moat and the acid vegetable rice, and he would excrete more calcium than if he were taking an alkaline diet with large quantities cf vegetables and fruits. Our studies also prove that this effect of varying diets was dependant upon their potential acidity alone and, therefore, the action of these diets is similar to the added acid 'which v:e had previously used to increase calcium excretion.
This work on calcium is also referable to the excretion of' lead because we have conclusively shown, previously, that lead ex cretion ana calcium excretion run. parallels This work explains why our early studies on diet alone caused so definite an increase of le^^jjg.py-ctfpn,, . for _the diets we had previously used were potentially very acid ohes, as well as being low in calcium. It is also importssgt4-^ tPeaHaber that the average American eats a potentially acid diet and one which is relatively low in calcium, which fact should be taken into account in the prevention, of lead intoxication.
It may be of interest to show the practical results of our investigations, and to summarize here our present treatment of lead intoxication, \7e find this very satisfactory and we are told by men of great experience that our present method allows people to go bach to work in weeks rather than the months which were pre
3
viously required for their rehabilitation after evidence of severe
intoxication.
When a patient enters the hospital with severe lead colic
he is given a diet at first which is high in calcium in order to
prevent the-further liberation of lead from the bones* At the same
time he is given sterile calcium chloride intravenously (a slow in
fection of 15 c.c. of a 5fo solution). This usually stops the lead
colic within a very few minutes so that the patients who have been in
intense pain usually go. promptly to sleep. If the colic returns in
the matter of a few hours calcium chloride is again given. In the
meantime the patient is given a large dose of epsom salts. On this
treatment the lead colic usually completely and permanently disappears
within a very few hours and continued pain means that some other
abnormal condition is present. After the patient has had three or
four days of freedom from symptoms he is given an acid diet low in
<SS- J . . ' *
^
^,
calcium content and maintained on this-for a period of about a month.
At the same time he is given large,.,id^sfsv.iq|`;i{a salt which produces acid
in the body, usually ammonium chloride. This treatment causes a
liberation of calcium and lead from the bones without reprecipitating
manifestations of lead intoxications. At'the end of this treatment
the patient is again given large quantities of calcium in his diet in
order that the depleted store of calcium may be replaced. The readily
available storehouse of lead in the body is thus partially removed,
which largely eliminates the possibility of a late manifestation of
poisoning from lead stored in the bones. This treatment, which is
quite simple and which can easily be carried out at home, has had an
extremely beneficial effect on practically all cases of lead poisoning.
4
The patient can get bach to work relatively quickly and the unpleasant neurosis so often seen with chronic lead poisoning is now extremely rare in our cases.
The lead treatment of cancer. Another intensive activity of our laboratory was the study of the. effect of lead on cancer, a treatment which was originally suggested by Professor Blair Bell of Liverpool. We treated a group of patients suffering from inoperable cancer by the intravenous injection of colloidal lead phosphate. We used our usual method of carefully controlling the diet, etc., so that we v/ere able to study the excretion of lead in these patients and to determine the effect of diet and treatment upon the distribution and ex cretion of lead. One might, naturally, exert a very distinct influence upon the efficacy of this method of treatment for if one could keep the lead in circulation it, naturally, would have a greater effect on the patient. The results of the treatment, however, clinically have been nyy, \^s^.tlii#fiaO'6H^4"'and we have given up using lead as a treat ment of canoe2J.H However, we did learn from these patients the method of excretion*of lead when it is given intravenously and this work will undoubtedly be of value to other investigators who are continuing the search for a satisfactory lead compound for the treatment of cancer. This study was largely supported by a grant from the Cancer Commission of Harvard but in small part the expenditures also came from the Lead Fund.
The third activity of our laboratory was to study the value of our methods of treatment upon other types of.disease. It, naturally, occurred to us that where abnormal bone deposits occur we might be able to eliminate them by our method of treatment. Such conditions occur in arthritis and in otosclerosis, the common type of inherited
deafness. We have, therefore, attempted to use this treatment in twenty patients suffering with otosclerosis. It is too early to he sure whether these patients are definitely benefitted hut there is some evidence that it has been of help in a few of the early cases. We now know that the lack of better results is undoubtedly due to the store of readily available calcium which we previously dis covered and which is first mobilized before further stores of calcium are affected. The work on these cases of otosclerosis was not supported at all by the Lead Fund for we derived our funds from other sources but the idea developed from our studies on lead poisoning.
v.a --33m TO
J ~t