Document LzYe4QgdxMKjnEpwBGadMgk5
FILE NAME Household Contact HC
DATE 1989 DOC HC025
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Journal Article - Domestic Asbestos Exposure Lung Fibre Burden and Pleural Mesothelioma in a Housewife
British Journal of Industrial Medicine 354
355
Domestic asbestos exposure lung fibre burden and pleural mesothelioma in a housewife
M HUNCHAREK JV CAPOTORTO J MUSCAT From the Boston University School of Medicine Boston Massachusetts Staten Island Hospital Staten Island New York and Memorial Kettering Cancer Center New York USA
Although the risk of mesothelioma associated with serous fluid Biopsy showed a malignant neoplasm
occupational exposure to asbestos is well documen- consistent with malignant mesothelioma of the
ted the risk posed by environmental and domestic biphasic subtype
"
exposure is uncertain Epidemiological analyses of
In March 1983 a chest tube was placed and tetra-
this problem is complicated by the lack of reliable cycline was instilled which satisfactorily controlled the
estimates of the mesothelioma dose response effusion She received no chemotherapy or any specific
relation.We report here on a diffuse pleural meso- treatment for the disease One month before death
thelioma in the wife of a shipyard machinist with June 1983 her clinical state deteriorated with gradual
quantitative evidence of substantial lung asbestos fibre weight loss decreased appetite and increasing weak-
burden from domestic contact Although previous ness The patient died from her malignant meso-
reports have documented an increased risk of asbestos thelioma in early July 1983
related diseases among household contacts of asbestos
Necropsy showed a malignant mesothelioma affect-
industry workers to our knowledge this is the first to ing the right chest with extension to the mediastinum
provide data on actual lung fibre burden This report pericardium and left chest No evidence of metastatic
suggests that such household contamination can result disease or other primary tumour was found
in bystander exposure levels similar to those found
The occupational history showed no direct
in the industrial setting
occupational exposure to asbestos An extensive
interview with the patient's husband established that
Case report
he was employed for 34 years 1935-69 as a machinist
in a shipyard where he dismantled boilers and other
A 76 year old woman smoker born in 1906 was well until the spring of 1982 when she developed right sided chest pain In late November 1982 she was
shipyard machinery throughout his employment He
stated that his workclothes became covered with
dust and that his wife regularly laundered these
admitted to another hospital with rapid heart beat and complained of episodes of severe epigastric pain
radiating to her chest Physical examinatioant this time showeda right sided pleural effusion Cope needle
biopsy of the right parietal pleura showed atypical mesothelial proliferation and pleural fibrosis Pleural cytology was benign She was discharged in early December 1982. She had had a cholecystectomy in
clothes at home
Before beginning employment as a machinist he
had worked as a merchant marine 1931
-
a2rigger's
helper on bridge construction 1932-4 and on bridge ,
construction assembling cranes for a construction
company No exposure to asbestos was known to :
occur during this period 1931-4 He retired from his job as a shipyard machinist in 1969 and no other
1979 and a history of diverticulosis and congestive
heart failure
occupational history was given This patient married her husband in 1931 at the age
In January 1983 she was admitted to hospital
of 25 after which she never worked outside the home
*
complaining of pleuritic chest pain and shortness of breath Chest x ray examination showed pronounced accumulation of the pleural effusion The patient subsequently underwent needle biopsy of the right parietal pleura followed by removal of 1000 cc of
Accepted 23 May 1988
Her occupational history before 1931 was not given Her only documented exposure to asbestos was by secondary exposure through laundering her husband's
asbestos contaminated workclothes At necropsy the
patient's left lung was removed for asbestos fibre
analysis by an expert pathologist The report of this
analysis was reviewed and the results are summarised :
in the table
354
Fee ae} ym
wan
omestic asbestos exposure lung fibre burden and pleural mesothelioma in a housewife
355
ng asbestosfibre content
re type
Noof fibres
wet lung tissue
ysotile
172 10
osite and crocidolite 59 ^ 10
molite actinolite
nd anthophyllite anthophyllite
10
No of fibresig dry lung tissue
2.5 10 0.8 ^ 10
2 10
scussion
nce the initial report of family contact asbestos sociated mesothelioma by Newhouse and Thompn in 1965 additional evidence has accumulated
licating that indirect exposure to asbestos in the
me may be a serious health hazard In most
stances asbestos fibres are carried home on worker's
thing and liberated on removal and during preparan for laundering
interestingly only one study has attempted to antify the actual exposure to asbestos fibres in the mes of asbestos workers Nicholson et al found that
exposure in the home can be substantial as reflected
by the lung fibre burden outlined in the table Such
exposures should therefore not be assumed to be
light exposures
This case report therefore provides evidence that
family members exposed to asbestos fibres brought industry
home on the workclothes of asbestos industry workers may accumulate lung fibre burdens similar to those seen in the occupationally exposed individuals and this
contamination may constitute a significarinstk of
mesothelioma
This case was obtained from the files of the Canadian Tumor Reference Center with which MH was previously affiliated We thank the Reference Center
for help with this report
Requests for reprints to Michael Huncharek MPH Box 487 Boston University School of Medicine 80 East Concord Street Boston Mass 02118
rysotile asbestos concentrations in the air of the
mes of 13 asbestos mine and mill employees ranged
m 50 to over 2000 mSamples from three
ghing homes of miners ranged from 32 to
AB
Unfortunately few quantitative data are
ilable regarding actual respired dose of asbestos
res by household contacts in such settings
As seen in the table the lung asbestos fibre content
this woman was similar to that seen in cases of
sothelioma associated with occupational exposure asbestos Since lung fibre concentrations exceeding
villion fibres per gram of dried tissue are associated
h an increased risk of malignant mesothelioma it
bears that such household contact as described
ove may represent a considerable risk of meso-
lioma
. Currently the nature of the dose response relation
asbestos related mesothelioma is uncertain Part of
3 uncertainty arises from the lack of accurate
posure data and information on fibre type The data vided here indicate that secondary asbestos
References
1 Selikoff IJ Lee DH Asbestos and disease New York Academic
.
Press 1978
2 Huncharek M. The epidemiology of pleural mesothelioma
current concepts and controversies Cuncer Invest in press
3 Peto J Seidman H Selikoff IJ Mesothelioma mortality in asbestos
workers implication for models of carcinogenesis and risk
assessment Br J Cancer 124
35
4 Newhouse ML Thompson H. Mesothelioma of pleura and peritoneum following exposure to asbestos in the London area
Br J Ind Med 261
9
5 Li FP Lokich J Lapey J Neptune WB Wilkins E. Familial
mesothelioma after intense asbestos exposure at home JAMA
1978
6 Vianna NJ Polan AK occupational exposure to asbestos
and malignant mesothelioma in females Lancet 521
2
7 Anderson HA Lilis R Daum SM Fishbein AS Selikoff IJ
Household contact asbestos neoplastic risk Ann NY Acad Sci
311
23
8 Nicholson WJ Rohl AN Weismann I Selikoff IJ Environmental
asbestos concentrations in the United States ARC Sci Publ
823
7
9 Mowe G Glyseth B Hartveit F Skaug V. Fiber concentration in lung tissue of patients with malignant mesothelioma a case
control study Cancer 1985 1089 93