Document Lgq7BDzMzrG6q13bLN741xEQ

PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT BE 005127 MAINTENANCE FACILITIES BROWNSVILLE PLANT November, 1975 MAINTENANCE FACILITIES TEAM J. David McMahon 005128 MAIN'l.VV.U facilities survey results BROWNSVILLE PLANT The METT Facilities Project Team conducted a Maintenance Facilities Survey of the Brownsville Plant in conjunction with the MOT Maintenance Survey. It was generally found that many improvements had been made in the^shops since the last' survey. The Central Shops are well equipped, have improved lighting throughout, and are constructed with adequate height and material handling capability! The Field Shops for maintenance crews with plantwide responsi bilities are scattered in the plant and their quality range from more than adequate for those in the Old Machine Shop to inadequate for the 930 Field Shop. The three zone shops are very beneficial to the maintenance effort due to their location, size, equipment, and ease of control. In continuing the improvement program for the maintenance shops, it is recommended that: (1) Better utilization of the Old Hachine Shop should be investi gated. This is a very sturdy building with more than adequate space, height, and materials handling capabilities than the present shops require. Consideration should be given to moving the Welding/Sheet Metal Shop to this location and constructing smaller shops for the present tenants in location better suited to their needs. Another possibility would be to buiId a faci1ity with 8^ to feet ceiling height to house many of the shops that require low ceilings (process mechanics, carpenter, insulation, glass fitters, etc.). (2) A general improvement program for personnel facilities should be developed. In numerous shops it was found that the personnel ate at their work benches. This can become an extremely critical problem at some shops such as the Glass Fitters. The guardhouse lunch room and cafeteria are too small or too distant to handle the plant needs. More shop lunchrooms should be considered or possibly an extra shift should be considered DE 0Q5129 \ for the cafeteria. Host shops lacked enough lockers for their personal effects (slicker suits, coveralls, lunches, etc.). Host restrooms were clean and well ventilated but lacked a sufficient number of toilets, urinals, and lavatories. The plant should also start making plans for the installation of female personnel facilities in the maintenance shops. Many of the Kanawha Valley and Gulf Coast plants are already seeing an influx of female maintenance employees in both central shop and field maintenance capacities:.' .(3) The plant should continue with its present plans for the Fire Station/Safety Equipment Shop and the Mezzanine Feasibility Study for the warehouse. The proposed Fire Station/Safety Equipment Shop would place emphasis on the plant's commitment to individual safety in the plant and would help to insure that adequate and timely safety in spections are made. The warehouse has adequate height to allow a mezzanine and the economic justification of this possibility needs to be investigated. (A) Portable buildings should be considered to reduce the Maintenance Department's office space problems. The use of portable buildings could reduce some of the crowded office space conditions that exist in the machine shop and 930 field shop. This would also allow the, centralization of the planning group and RM-1 Group. (5) A "house cleaning" program needs to be implemented to improve the storage and safety in the shops. Although it is wise for the shops to maintain a limited amount of spare parts in the shops, this practice is being exceeded. Some shops were found to have so much being kept that the shop personnel really didn't know what they had, work space was being lost, and hazards existed from having to crawl over equipment or tools to retrieve items on shelves. DE 00S13Q 11 MAINTENAN CE FAC ILI TIES DROWNSVILLE PLANT In November, 1975, a survey of the Brownsville Plant's maintenance facilities was made by the METT-Faci1ities Project Team in conjunction with the Maintenance Operations Team Maintenance Survey. The attached is a compilation of information regarding these facilities. Included are: 1.' Maintenance Facilities - Brownsville Plant............................... Page 1 (A short summary of features, strong and weak points and opinions as to the adequacy of present facilities.) 2. Major Maintenance Shops - Brownsville Plant............ ................ Page 3 (Charts showing use, size, conditions and features of the larger maintenance buildings and shops.) 3. Maintenance Facilities Description................................................... Page 7 (A report provided by maintenance personnel giving a description of maintenance shops, storage areas, office and other facilities.) k. Maintenance Shop Details............................................................. .....Page 2k (Charts showing heating, ventilation, lighting, insulation, utilities and material handLing equipment of each shop.) 5. Maintenance Survey Questionnaire-Summary.................................... Page 29 (Facilities section of an eleven-part questionnaire completed by maintenance supervisors and engineers.) 6. Maintenance Facilities Location Plan--.........................................Page 35 Brownsvi He Plant DE 005131 1 11 maintenance facilities BROWNSVILLE PLANT It was generally found that the Maintenance Shops arc progressing toward improved, more efficient, less hazardous work places. Although Shop Personnel are pleased with the changes that have been made in the last two years, there is still room for improvement. Most shops were foun*d.ito be adequate in work area and equipment but were lacking in the areas of storage space and personnel facilities. CENTRAL SHOPS The Central Shops are well equipped but the Machine Shop equipment is in need of repair. The improvements that have been made in the Process Mechanics Shop are very beneficial for the plant and the personnel who workin the shop. The recent painting of the Central Shops has improved the lighting throughout. The shops are adequate in height and material handling capability with the possible exception of the Welding/Sheet Metal Shop. The installation of small, specialty shops (corrosion lab, T&l, blacklight room, safety) have disrupted the layout of the shops. This has resulted in crowded conditions in the specialty shops and major shops. FIELD SHOPS Most of the Field Shops were found to be adequate in size, equipment height, and matdHal handling needs except for the 930 Field Shop. Although the 930 Shop is used by approximately k5 personnel who work throughout the plant, the present facilities lack adequate office space for the foremen, utilities to meet their needs, materials handling equipment, and covered work area. The Old Machine Shop (Building 161) is an excellent building that is being under-utilized. The Insulation Shop personnel do most of their work in the Recovery/Reaction Area of the plant (90% according to the foreman) and are located in the opposite end of the plant. DE 005132 -1 2- Field Shops (Cont'd) The Glass Fitters Shop is located in the Southeast corner of the building and the fiber-glass is drifting toalj of the other.shops due _o__the prevailing wind. The black-light .-coni in the building is actively used for 30 to 45 days every 18 months for the "thaw" and essentially idle the rest of the time. The riggers' chokers and equipment is also stored in the Old Machine Shop. One end of the Quonset Hut serves as the Plant Garage and this shop has adequate work and storage space, equipment, and wash facilities. The Sand blast Yard Is ' i n a good location with adequate equipment and outside work area. The Paint Storage Building is well ventilated and the shop building provides very adequate restrooms, lunch room, and Shop Office. ZONE SHOPS The three Zone Shops (Reaction, Recovery, and Oxygen/Energy) are all well located in relation to the units that the zone personnel service. All are well equipped with tools and the satellite stores provide much needed assistance. The Recovery Zone Shop would be rated the best of the Zone Shops. Tlie Recovery and Reaction Foremen's Offices are not located at the shops but' within the unit boundary. This facilitates their control of their personnel working in the shop and the unit. Unlike the other zone shops, the Oxygen/ Energy Shop does not have a lunch room. The personnel are supposed to eat at the Guardhouse lunch room but~^ost eat in the shop. &E 0QS133 D E 005134 TO a 14- o0) o a. c o. TuO *w-- TO *U` cc oto oo c >* o -- "TOO U 3t. AJ oTO 2 OOC WTO. "O o o "O Coo5 (oA in m *Cj wO JT3O TO W W E TO < TO 0 in 1 < 1 D u > --c o---- --Uo. --^TO --TO in in *- O TO C *-> _Q TO in in E TO < oTO w i < i cn ic u u--O0.--^T--O----u--T--O TO TO U O in TO *-* o ETO TTOO U C, < TO C o TO U TO in U 3 TO OC0 --UU <OO ----K 1 CD oI > --oo il ----3TO ----uTO Good F lo o r - C oncrete W all - B ric k Cei 1 irrg -A c o u s ti ca 1 MAJOR MAINTENANCE SHOPS - BROWNSVILLE PLANT 28 53^1 V TO <Ot --C >TO- \D CM un CM CM TO N Lu t/> O' to O O O IA N *>-- o o O ooo Oo o o CM vD >3 nD CM o vO PA CM \D NO f^. CM CO M3 *-- - r* CM *w >--P>* V-' a : o. >. at m iT_O m C UJ LTO. UTO * EE TOX IA O O *o a_ O in O ec *j ec o. N 4-* 4>i u o 1 (/) Q. C TO _ o o> Li. TO o. o U. > TO C i- a. to -- a TO t >. o 1 TO -- c t/t X O) 4-> V> id TO TO L. O TO TOl -M o I*. -- o *- o C U- U- -- TO C a. O a c o E O # w-- *- a cm to in o TO_J U 3 o3 K in 4-> 5 w C 4- To -- * o> u U /) \ u TO <C M- TO TO C 4J TO in TO o to u at --m ot c X TO C in TO O) 3 at iff o TO McM in u O -- TO U TO a> o m -- u> D o mmm NJ a ai C TO TO CD X a. a -- o U 4J 3 cd O 1ii11 i o /t I BCR T r a in in g pa vO VO M3 VO vO f -3- - 'MV. MAJOR MAINTENANCE SHOPS - BROWNSVILLE PLANT ( C o n t'd ) 01 d _Eo 23 ^0 0C.l C o CD U' CCl *CU Cl O id o m vo (A (A o (0*A-* *WC-l w00L1. O X<<(A> -<iioCf-.l C t- *- t_0> WO oo OI 1 cn 1c L. m. o---- o---- --li- ^CO oo LA CO -- c >* ^c0 ro *- 0a. --c u3 xE -- to 25a:> LQa>.. ooc NO O -X --. -o u m --u* O5 3 T3 O Cro wj) TiCn)l TCll m 3 <0 OC --o l. O m <D O3' --C **o1 w D -o Q. -- 0 Cl LTV CM cn UIt -3* CM C oi oo X "D OOO 01 4~ X Cl 0) L- (A -*- u o -X o c uO -M 4W) U O <uo XI I t v) *-> O < Cl c i- I 01 -- oO ---- x</> --~- --u. 3id oo u -- 0C1l OC 0c1i m O 4J t cn i C7> C --uoO. ---I-<S-0--~o-w- 01 cd TIC V <"> 01 *- N Ia mb in O' in o CM o CO IN o o CO oCA o CM in CM O o <n PoN n* o <T\ o vO ^LbA cn id in. CM __ o -3* O CMoOB CA o CO -3* mt o c D --O O3 -i,. (A O. o X in CLD. 4- C. 01 o Q- O X CL o. cn o0 X . in in CD O 01 o> MB c c L. MB MB li Xo -o m- O 01 CD D X IS UJ 111 s li 0) in O CL u0-) o MB --o CX a CD cn >i. cd cn o *N 01 X X c cn O -M cn 0) c 0u X 01 u 4M c (A E3 4OJ 4CJD 0) e u (A L c cn a o> 01 O in lO_ C -- CL 01 MB 44 a. 0) 3 C L. u O* 0) CD _ U1 O O li. 1 11 (A Cl M- 4M MB M o CD U. MB V c c ion Ib V a. i 0) o MB Mb Mb o 0) o c CD c 0) L* c MB CD X LA CM -C3M* 01 cn UCD CD ID vO -T MAJOR MAINTENANCE SHOPS - BROWNSVILLE PLANT ( C o n t'd ) DE 005136 in ft) "0 L. 3O --5 o --C "oft) ft) V) <0 N W ft) --3w co o fl) </> ft) -o w 3O -- 5 O c *-- ft) o ft) in f0 _N 4-J 3 kft_) to o <D L. ft) ft) 63 u- ft) zoa. oc tufot) -- cft) co CJ 5 u3 L. CJ in oOC -o o o o ft) ft) ft) W ft) 4^ O d (/> L - P Aft ic c *Po <C9 PO h- t 1 o> L. 1 --c o -- *-- o---- -- to ft) u- i o cs O ^ (A "O o o o in 4O-> tn tn O ft) ft) 4-i -o <m in m > ft) < u^ O in u c < *OO L uO u1 t o cn oc U|-- O---- 0---- -- (0 ft) u. ^ o -o o o o MB ft) ^ 4ft-)* C0) fftt)) CO *U w. O CO L0*0 > CU- <M1 > 1 o 3> oc l- 1 -- O---- 0---- -- ro ft) u. 3: o L. <0 u. in 0 V> Aft O ft) .O m in * ft) < Cft) jQm u e < j>p4) e pO L| ) O 3) P> C U1-- O---- o---m ft): u- ^ o Vu). ft) (0 <Q --c >>- r-. cm CM Nft) La. o Oo ooo o m<tn ooo O' CO (oO CM O) c *o --o 3 CO o u c >" 4-* V) 10 CO *co (0 l/> <T\ O-3O" ocl ^ /> oo. ft) C IO o is) *0 * ft) Dm > o U1 ft) CO ce w oa -C <o -o ft) lZ o (cOn II t CoL c CO ofct) N co +J o to ft) ce II 5 f be 005137 MAINTENANCE FACILITIES DESCRIPTION MAINTENANCE AREA BUILDING NO: 163 BUILDING NAME: Riggers Loft 1. CONSTRUCTION: 2. AGE: . 3. GENERAL CONDITION: A. . EXPANDABLE: 5. MAINTENANCE FUNCTION: Permanent - Cement floor; Asbestos wall and cei 1 ing 26 Years Good Yes FUNCTION FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL Boilermaker Shop (Now used by Construction) 5000 6. PERSONNEL FACILITIES: Lunch Room: Rest Room: Lockers: Female Facilities: None 1 toilet; 1 lavoratory None Not required pE 005138 -7- "i I ME NANCE AREA BUILDING NO: 164 BUILDING NAME: Old Machine Shop 1. CONSTRUCTION: 2. AGE: 3. GENERAL CONDITION: 4. EXPANDABLE: 5. MAINTENANCE FUNCTION: Permanent - Cement floor; Asbestos wall and cei ling 25 Years Good Yes: East, North and South FUNCTION FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL Zone Shop (Oxygen/Energy) Glass/Tubing fitters Riggers Loft Insulation Shop Black Room s Field Hechanics Main Aisle (Shared by all shops) Personnel Facilities 1320 770 1210 660 660 1760 220 6600 7 13 11 31 6. PERSONNEL FACILITIES: Lunch Room: Rest Room: Lockers: Female Facilities: Howe- 2 toilets; 2 urinals; 2 lavoratories; 220 Sq. Ft. 20 lockers: 1 assigned per man Not Required -8DE 005139 MAINTENANCE area BUILDIMG NO: 16k (Gont'd) BUILDING NAME: Old Machine Sli-. ZONE SHOP- 73 OXYGEN/ENERGY FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) MO. OF PERSONNEL Shop Office Work Area -Inside Storage 220 880 220 1320 I 6 7 7b PERSONNEL: 7c INADEQUACIES: 1 - Foreman 4 - Pipe Fitters 2 - Riggers 7 - Total Storage area in need of housecleaning. Potential hazard from having to crawl over equipment on floo to reach items on storage shelves. GLASS/TUBING 8a FITTERS SHOP FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL Shop Office Work Area Storage Inside no kBk 176 770 1 12 13 8b PERSONNEL: 8c INADEQUACIES: 1 - Foreman 12 - Glass Fitters 13 " Total Due to prevailing wind through shop, fiber glass from this shop drifts down to the insulators and zone shops at the other end of the building. 005140 BUILDING NO: 16A (Cont'd) maintenance area BUILDING NAME: Old Machine Shop 9a INSULATION SHOP FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Fc.) NO. OF PERSONNEL Office (Shared) Work Area Outside Storage 1 10 550 1000 1660 1 10 11 9b PERSONNEL: l - Foreman 10 - Insulators 11 - Total 9c INADEQUACIES: Vacuum barrel for insulation bond saw should be located on outside of building in water tight enclosure. 90 percent of work in Recovery/ Reaction area but shop is located at opposite end of plant. -10- j i l DE 005141 MAINTENANCE AULA BUILDING NO: 166 BUILDING NAME: BtR Training R<>, Mil 1. CONSTRUCTION: AGE: ). GENERAL CONDITION: >!. EXPANDABLE: 5. MAINTENANCE FUNCTION: Permanent - Tile floor; Brick wail; Acoustical ceiling 26 Years Good Yes: East, South, or West side FUNCTION Training Area Dry Room FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) 53^0 2800 8U*0 NO. OF PERSONNEL N/A 6. PERSONNEL FACILITIES: Lunch Room: Rest Room: Lockers: Female FaciIities Personnel eat in training room 2 toilets; 2 urinals; 2 lavoratories 120 Sq. Ft. None___________ Required but not separate 7. PERSONNEL: N/A DE 005142 -11- maintenance area BUILDING NO: A2A BUILDING NAME: Central Shops 1. CONSTRUCTION: 2. AGE: 3. GENERAL CONDITION: A. EXPANDABLE: 5. MAINTENANCE FUNCTION: Permanent - Concrete floor; Corrugated asbestos wal 1 and ceiling 20 Years Good Yes FUNCTION FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL Machine Shop Welding Shop Electric Shop Process Mechanics Shops Carpenter Shop Safety Equipment Service Center Personnel Facilities 3080 2520 900 770 1500 970 10A0 10,780 1A 15 8 11 13 2 63 PERSONNEL FACILITIES: Lunch Room: *' Rest Room: - None - Personnel eat at cafeteria or work --bencbes__.___ _____ _ Machine Shop: 5 toilets; 2 urinals; 2 lavoratories; 600 Sq. Ft. Electrical/Instrument Shop: 1 toilet; 3 urinals; 1 lavoratory; 200 Sq. Ft. Welding Shop: 3 toilets; 1 urinal; 1 lavoratory; 2A0 Sq. Ft. DE 005143 .".AINTENANCE area BUILDING NO: 424 (Cont'd) BUILDING NAME: Central Shop 6. PERSONNEL FACILITIES: (Cont'd) Lockers: None Female Facilities: Not required 7a MACHINE SHOP Office Work Area 7b PERSONNEL: 7c INADEQUACIES: FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL 80 3000 3080 2 12 111 1 - Fo reman I - Working Foreman 6 - Inside Machinists 6 - Field Machinists 14 - Total Heat circulation poor Work benches with storage space poor Lockers for machinists' slicker suits lacking Noise and smoke problems from Welding Shop Shop office too small for 2 foremen Floor space lost due to specialty shops - metalurgical lab, valve shop, etc. 8a WELDING SHOP Shop Office Work Area 8b PERSONNEL: FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) 120 2400 2520 NO. OF PERSONNEL l 14 15 1 - Foreman 14 - Welders and Fabricators 15 Total DE 005144 maintenance area BUILDING NO: klk (Cont`d) BUILDING NAME: Central Shops 8c INADEQUACIES: 8d DEFICIENCY: C People eat on fabrication tables or floor Need lockers for personnel----------------- Need improved ventilation to remove smoke Need another overhead crane Need sheet metal roll, shear and saw 9a ELECTRICAL SHOP FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL Shop Office Work Area (H1 height) Storage Inside HO 660 100 900 1 7 8 PERSONNEL: 1 - Foreman 7 - Electricians 8 - Total 9c INADEQUACIES: Housekeeping a problem due to limited size Work bench areas lacking Motors larger than 50HP are worked on in Machine Shop where they have the needed Iift capacity Wooden step ladders stored outside in the open where they get wet--electricians working on hot lines might get shocked "* Pipe cutter and threading machine in poor locations due to limited space PROCESS 10a MECHANICS SHOP FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL Office Instrument Shop Electronics Shop 150 A50 170 770 1 9 1 11 DE 005145 maintenance area BUILDING NO: 424 (Cont'd) BUILDING NAME: Central Shops 10b PERSONNEL: 1 - Foreman 10 - Instrument Mechanics 11 - Total 11 a CARPENTER SHOP Office Work Area lib PERSONNEL: 11c INADEQUACIES: FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL 100 1400 1500 1 12 13 1 - Foreman 3 " Carpenters 1 - Painter 1 - Sheet Metal Worker 7 - Helpers 13 ~ Total Radial and band saws are too close to each other No phone for the foreman--he must use weld shop office :AFETY EQUIPMENT SERVICE CENTER FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL Work Area Fire Station Foam Trailer Storage 252 525 192 969 2 2 12b PERSONNEL: 2 - Fire Station Attendants DE 005146 -15- MAINTENANCE AREA BUILDING NO: klk (Cont'd) BUILDING NAME: Central Shops 12c INADEQUACIES: Ventilation and insulation poor Rest rooms and water fountain 150 feet away-- 200 feet allowable maximum Need plant air Facilities for cleaning safety equipment is lacking Storage space cramped -16- Wi'i >.u DE 005147 MAINTENANCE AREA BUl'LDING NO: 1*25 BUI LDING NAME: Maintenance Office 1. CONSTRUCTION: 2. AGE: 3. GENERAL CONDITION: i*. EXPANDABLE: 5. MAINTENANCE FUNCTION: Permanent - Concrete; Tile floor; Asbestos & Shee t-rock 27 Years; Addition is one year old Excel lent Yes: on South side FUNCTION FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL Technical Staff Offices 3180 25 6. PERSONNEL FACILITIES: Lunch Room: Rest Room: Lockers: Female Faci1ities: None - Personnel eat in cafeteria or lunch room 2 toilets; 2 urinals; 2 1avoratories; 100 Sq. Ft. None 2 toilets; 2 lavoratories; 100 Sq. Ft. DE 005148 -17- MAINTENANCE AREA BUILDING NO: *)6l BUILDING NAME: Garage 1. CONSTRUCTION: 2. AGE: 3. GENERAL CONDITION: 1). EXPANDABLE: 5. MAINTENANCE FUNCTION: Permanent - Concrete floor; Steel wall and ceiling (Quonset Hut) Good No FUNCTION FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL Shop Office Work Area (25* height) Inside Storage Outside Storage Personnel Facilities 6. PERSONNEL FACILITIES: Lunch Room: Rest Room: Locke rs: Female Facilities: 36 212it 300 12,000 30 1M80 None 1 toilet; 1 lavoratory; 30 Sq. Ft. None Not required 1 3 7. PERSONNEL: 1 - Foreman 2 - Mechanics 1 - Helper 1) - Shop Personnel 3 " Drivers 1 - Utility (Dumpster) 8 - Rigger/Cr. Operators 12 - Field Personnel -18- DE 005149 MAINTENANCE AREA BUILDING NO: 461 (Cont'd) BUILDING NAME: Garage 8. INADEQUACIES: Rigging equipment is stored in Old Machine Shop instead of quonset hut. DE OOSiso -19- MAINTENANCE AREA BUILDING NO: J89 BUILDING NAME: Sandblast Yard 1. CONSTRUCTION: 2. AGE: 3. GENERAL CONDITION: k. EXPANDABLE: 5. MAINTENANCE FUNCTION: Permanent - Concrete floor; Transite wall Corrugated steel ceiling 27 Years Good Yes FUNCTION FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL Office Work Area (Covered) (10' height) Work Area (Outside) Storage Personnel Faci1ities 168 1200 28,120 512 30,000 1 6 7 6. PERSONNEL FACILITIES: Lunch Room: Rest Room: Lockers: Female Facilities: Seating for 280 Sq. Ft. people; 2 toilets; 2 urinals; 2 lavoratories; 32 Sq. Ft. 8 available; 1 assigned per person 32 Sq. Ft. Not required 7. PERSONNEL: 1 - Foreman 6 - Painters 7 - Total -20- DE 005151 maintenance area BUI.LDING NO: BUILDING NAME: Recovery Zone Shop (S-3 Field Shop) 1. CONSTRUCTION: 2. AGE: 3. GENERAL CONDITION: A. EXPANDABLE: 5. MAINTENANCE FUNCTION: Permanent - Concrete floor; Corrugated asbestos walI and ceiling Year Good Yes; to the South rfrWest FUNCTION ' FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL Office (Portable Building) Work Area Personnel Faci1ities 200 1500 300 2000 A 8 12 6. PERSONNEL FACILITIES: Lunch Room: Rest Room: Lockers: Female Faci1ities: Seating capacity for 10 people; 300 Sq. Ft. Personnel use area rest room in unit Assigned per man Not required 7. PERSONNEL: 1 - Foreman 1 - Working Foreman 2 - Planners 8 - Craftsmen 12 - Total DE 005152 -21- MAINTENANCE AREA BUILDING NO: BUILDING NAME: 930 Field Shop 1. CONSTRUCTION: 2. AGE: 3- GENERAL CONDITION: k. EXPANDABLE: 5. MAINTENANCE FUNCTION: Permanent - Wooden floor; Corrugated steel wall and ceiling 2 Years Good FUNCTION FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL Offices Work Area (Covered) Work Area (Outside) 340 600 30,000 30,940 6 24 30 6. PERSONNEL FACILITIES: Lunch Room: Rest Room: Lockers: Female Facilities: None - Personnel eat in main cafeteria Hone - Personnel use central shop rest room across the street 25 available Not required 7. PERSONNEL: ' k - Foremen 1 - Scheduler 1 - Mat'1 Expediter 2k - Craftsmen 30 - Total 22pE 005153 I I J BUILDING NO: MAINTENANCE AREA BUILDING NAME: Reaction Zone Shop 1. CONSTRUCTION: .2 AGE: 3. GENERAL-CONDITION: A. EXPANDABLE: 5. MAINTENANCE FUNCTION: Permanent - Cement floor; Corrugated asbestos walis and celling Fair Yes: ail except North FUNCTION FLOOR SPACE (Sq.Ft.) NO. OF PERSONNEL Work Area Personnel Facilities 700 300 1000 6 6 S. PERSONNEL FACILITIES: Lunch Room: Rest Room: Lockers: Female Fact Titles: Seating capacity for 8 people; 300 Sq. Ft. Portable unit; also Reaction II Control building 10 lockers Not required 7. PERSONNEL: - 1 - Foreman (office In unit) 3 " Pipefitters 3 - Riggers 7 - Total 8. INADEQUACIES: No heat In shop - open sides DE 005154 -23- L MAINTENANCE SHOP DETAILS DE 005155 do -- m a. cs w *o to- --I oyv ^ o< > "O OlC o < m c i> m w E-i -->. C(i IS Sw c ** cr> !>*--> >*m --' U o X -- O. I/) o < o - ^ > (S\ - CD s, 19 O < 1. O ^ WU > -- -y cn -* o < *--< C D m w6;>n c rt) C I) * V-V.VA (L *J(/)OL. k--. --> 3t o o z 5.8' kJ C <-> C <-> u in o m m c1 IuQ uI. &o --c Ou. XV> w rCa u<9 cu U -i U w u. VI u. um o u. o C u. z -- O V) ** to o co U vm *0 m-y c in 1 *o0 w1 ao. C u. x -- v 5 .S -- 03 h- 1) <9 X O.X uw x > I til o 5 V z E * o *> c -- <-> -- c I/IUI9 ** c o^ JS oe o Jo -24- CD X \g~>- (A k Ol D^ --** c c a J--C--U.USJ X0 mo * e u> o X n tn tt D > C *--0 --CD O* IoS I: </> V) oc co jE ^ u* -- X3 VI ^c O--' <os wOu eI<k9 l- D *- w W-- OVe --vcV 5 ui u> is o V* V-- --c UJ =3 E S 8 o ee T> . --w oo oc1) ucV MAINTENANCE SHOP DETAILS (C o n t'd ) DE 005156 XU, -- CL n 3> a: - 4I- co OCI . 2Zi --^* Wft) <> -- _ IA w0 L0 . <0 OIQ > k. O O 3 ZO wO 0 --ft) J0 SO 5 8 wN --Oc) cPi *IJ*-*--Cft) c L3 V0_) O**a E^- > 0 l m flJC -- ft)J-*CT>ft) L. * ft) -- o W ft) >.C O A 4-k.O~UX*-'*- -- 1/lQU L<OOM- w W^ u > --<*- 0cEOc) *u* _ o_** 3 - J 6n w 4- .* 3 c C ft) 3 10 (A-- k. u LA --a. C-- --u. >W ---- > k. -- ft) to v --<L. ccn 0*-0* cft0) L03.I/310 L>.I -* --.* > >-- cC) u mw i CCU^O>0k.-- U0>xoc< -- U -- u X W W o- aou.<oototo- o c(0 z -> K ** zo ta o u u. 0V rO*. ko. IAi aI 3U.O -- U. Z IkOiA o u <a0 o * > A* li_ u. >* o V3. Lr<A4 LiA < <- --- U0 SflJ Z Q.Z W0 X > I UJ --K aO z -c 111 V) cc --^ u<-0 s. ft) 0 xkfEt-) tO9o u u. V) LA ft) la r*. Bk. rtu-..aio -- U. x a O to 0 *-* u. u u. to LA 0 IA LA uo r-< ai --3 Uu.. Ox It. O tO 0 J3 "O O --0 V-- oa 0 -25- MAINTENANCE SHOP DETAILS (C ont'd) DE 005157 Mo o* X ui l0 --c --0. U. 3 l M18 Vw k. Jt} <u 8- 3 3<ouu V 2(i iA > --< 0c Mnj cv (VA>tm C j--Ci---c3D f-->c* coOM^e- <9 --m - --fl -u Oo --^ *U1 X>M0 OCl--A (^0WU.<0(AV1 -- 8V- <> 3_---><J/> oN0 --w 0C8 08 4M) 2t) >.-7* < C <8 V) 8. o M .CM -- 3 _g *<9i N*> CIP 1I)9 -C bV ko- cv--\* l_aoU ilk i--AM v19t--- o c --CuO^/-.3IP 3w v vCj> . J 0) C < w C 08 V MO w _6 j--<c- -->.cv * < C <9 c -- M 08 U &^>9>(/V8--/0WO0O<VUO>XUOs(L0kt-A- OV a.-- o *o KO x x; UJ V) e-- X<9 8ob -26- AV. V-- UJ MAINTENANCE SHOP DETAILS (C ont d)' DE 005158 l Oc Hco Hoc- OOO c cc si T O* C CO < C V VO _ -- -- c o-a* e < c w cn k v v -- v > ^ trv -- ** u u X -- -- a. v% o < o z -- uo ^u v VO ^ ^V V 5-3- -< OC I<9 tcl V/> * --U-- c n *nc* --JeC uvMmv )c>n* gwoNm> -- l- -- U X 4- -- &. O U.< o t/> -- 27- -28_____________ _______________ ) I DB0Sls9 :i MAINTENANCE SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE SUHHARV ll. Maintenance Facilities a) Do the'naintenance people in your area have adequate personnel facilities in? n ' Offices? PERSONNEL YES NO. 2 NO NO. 2 DID NOT ANSWER NO. * i UCC Brown t Root 8 ' 57.2 : 5 55.6 5 35.7 4 44.4 1 7.1 0 0.0 TOTAL RESPONSE 13 56.5 9 39.1 1 4.4 i a Lunch Roods? PERSONNEL YES NO. NO NO. 2 DID NOT ANSWER NO. 2 UCC Brown t Root TOTAL RESPONSE 9 ` . 64.3 5 55.6 14 60.9 4 28.5 3 33.3 7 30.4 1 7.2 1 11.1 7 8.7 n Locker Roods? PERSONNEL YES NO. 2 UCC Brown S Root TOTAL ntSPONSE 6 42.8 4 44.4 10 43.5 NO NO. 2 6 42.8 5 55.6 11 47.8 DID NOT ANSWER NO. 2 2 14.4 0 0.0 2 8.7 b) In your area are the following aspects of the facilities located, designed, and/or equipped to handle work efficiently? n Heating? PERSONNEL YES NO. 2 NO NO. X DID NOT ANSWER NO X UCC 11 78.5 2 14.3 1 7.2 Brown S Root TOTAL RESPONSE 1' i \ CO e-4 7 77.8 2 22.2 0 0.0 78.3 .4 17.4 1 4.3 / RAH-058 Bonner tc Moore Associates, Inc. -29- 005160 n Ventilation? PERSONNEL UCC Brown & Root TOTAL RESPONSE YES NO. X 12 85.7 7 77.8 IS 82.6 NO NO. *A 2 14.3 2 22.2 4 17.4 010 NOT ANSWER NO. i 0 0.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 n Lighting? PERSONNEL UCC Brown t Root TOTAL RESPONSE YES NO. X 13 92.8 7 77.8 20 87.0 NO NO. X 0 0.0 2 22.2 2 8.7 DID NOT ANSWER NO. V 1 7.2 0 0.0 1 4.3 n Insulation? PERSONNEL UCC Brown & Root TOTAL RESPONSE YES NO. Z 9 68.3 5 55.6 14 60.9 NO NO. Z 3 21.4 3 33.3 6 26.1 DIO NOT ANSWER NO. .X 2 14.3 1 11.1 3 13.0 n Material Handling Equipment? PERSONNEL UCC Brown & Root TOTAL RESPONSE YES NO. Z 8 57.2 6 66.7 14 60.9 NO NO. X 4 28.5 3 33.3 7 ' 30.4 DID NOT ANSWER NO. Z 2 14.3 0 0.0 2 8.7 I RAH-058 Bonner a Moore Associates, Inc. WTTRX1 00S161 o utilities ? PERSONNEL UCC Brown l Root TOTAL RESPONSE YES NO. * 10 71.4 5 55.6 15 65.3 NO NO. X 0 0.0 3 33.3 3 13.0 DID NOT ANSWER J NO. ! ; 4 28.6 1 li.: : 5 21.7 j ' o Shop Equipment? ' PERSONNEL UCC Brown & Root TOTAL RESPONSE YES NO. X 8 57.2 5 55.6 13 56.5 NO NO. X 4 28.5 3 33.3 7 30.4 010 NOT ANSWER NO. m 2 14.3 1 11.1 3 13.1 n Storage Area? PERSONNEL UCC Brown & Root TOTAL RESPONSE YES NO. X 6 42.8 3 33.3 9 39.1 NO NO. X 6 42.8 5 55.6 11 47.8 DID NOT ANSWER NO. X 2 14.3 1 11.1 3 13.1 a Transportation Support? PERSONNEL YES NO. X UCC Brown & Root TOTAL RESPONSE 7 50.0 4 44.4 11 47.8 NO. NO. X ' 6 42.8 4 44.4 10 43.5 OID NOT ANSWER NO. V 1 7.2 1 11.1 2 8.7 RAH-058 Bonner fc Moore Associate*, Inc. DE 005162 -31-