Document Kz68VrbN9bpx7LNq2Mp57Lb5X
The Salter Report
* Environmental Authorities Continue to Study Lake Hartwell
BY CHARLES SALTER '
Tbe voviranocsUl nightmare that hit Lake Hartwell
like a holt oat of the hoe ttfoctaaately wool go awajr
with the dawn of a new day.
f -**
In this technological age, we bare grown
. X accastomed to seeing oar problems and HI*
T } nesses solved or cured by computers, brfl-
| liaat minds of scientists and many wonder l^f^Jdnss.
' ~A
Cntaminated fish in tbe Twelve MUe
it*--- T\Credt area of Lake Hartwell and the pee*
i lenee of a Uxie dtenucal In tbe mud on tbe
: {bottom of tbe W,100-acre reservoir are
p. likely to be aroand for a few year&even if ^Hno more of tbe PCB (polychlorinated W-
,,t>'' phenyls) is released into tbe water by an
--
"-'industry.
oinwtdar
Tbe Environmental Protection Agency,
the Georgia Game and Fish Divisioa, state Environmental
Protection Division and Sooth Carolina wildlife authorities
are continuing to check samples of fish taken from a non*
b*r of areas o( Lake Hartwefl.
Biologists warned fishermen oof to eat fish caught in
the Twelve Vile Creek arm of the reservoir. The Army
Corps of Engineers said fish caught throughout tbe lake
shoiHl not be eaten until further notice.
Jack Ravan, regional administrator of the EPA, said
the PCBs are believed to have bees used by an industry in
that area of Lake Hartwell lor three to five years, al
though tbe contamination of fish was not discovered until a
little over a week ago.
Tbe chemicals could possibly remain at dangerous
levels In the mud on the bottom of the lake for three or
more years, Ravan said.
Fish already contaminated can be expected to survive
several more yean in this environment, hot it's a hit de
pressing to realize that fish healthy today are likely to con
sume smaller fish with toxic levels of the PCS in tbe
weeks and months to cone.
Ravan said he didn't ace how In ceeld assure people
about the fish being safe for human comumptien until
checks of fish in the affected area show tbe PCB b no
longer present Five parts per imltiwi b the maximum
health standard set by the u. S. Food and Drug Admints-
uatiwx
Tests on fish bun Tsdve 16k Creek revealed me
tratioBS of PCB ranging from three to U parts per raiBioa.
A Sooth Carolina health department spokesman said
this past week that tbe PCB compounds are suspected hi
cancer of the liver, cancer of tbe gall bladder and tome
related diseases, but conclusive evidence of sack a link
hasn't been determined.
Leon Kirkland, chief of fisheries of the Georgia Game
and Fish Division, said fish checked below the M5 bridge
and below the S. C. 25 spaa did not approach the toxic
levels, but further sampling will continue.
Kirkland suspects the PCB will cause stunting of fish
and mortality of tbe little fry.
"Those contaminated fish would he alive in the lake
two to ten years," Kirkland sahL "Tbe bigger tbe fish, the
more the concentration of the PCB. It will settle out in the
* bottom of the lake and will be around for many years."
Tbe biologist said he would hate to guess whether the
PCB would remain at dangerous levels on the take bottom
as long as mercury in other lakes and rivers. PD "PCB b
relatively insoluble, and that's tbe reason it would be
around lor a long time in the bottom mod," Kirkland said
"I would suspect nobody knows how much it moves in the food chain."
Ia the TWeln Mila Creek arm a< tbe lake, toxic levels
. of tbe PCB acre found ia mate lnrgemocth bom and other
sireahtc predators, adult gizzard shad, channel catlixb and
b number ot paafish.
Kirkland aaid la tome samples of crapple, Ike PCB
Maul was not as high.
. "One walleye bad a bigk eeaceatratioo.' ka said. *Wa
would like to look at all species of fish and conUntK to
lake samples. This is a limited number of samples so far."
Kirkland said examples id PCB concentrations in fish
taken below the 149 bridge iocbode a largemooth bass. 17
parts per nuilkm; a channel catfish, 1J; a bream, 1.0 ppm; and a crappie, j ppm.
Leonard Ledbetter, chief of the Environmental Protec
tion Division of the Georgia Department of Natural Re
sources, pointed rat that PCBs are widespread in the envi-
roomeattoday, hot for a number of years there was ao
knowledge or concern on the port of tbe FDA and other
regulatory agencies that the PCBs would be a potential
problem.
In many cases, tbe PCBs were identified in lab tests as DOT.
Six or seven years ago, a South Georgia farmer was
told that DDT was found in bis cows' milk, and he insisted
be never bad used DDT. Ledbetter said tbe abstain* later
was fossd to be PCBs.
Tbe PCBs have been ased far a mother of yean in tbe manufacture at electrical transformers and capacitors,
but in tbe case of tbe South Georgia farmer tbe PCBs
wen in polyethelene sheeting, Ledbetter said.
Within the past six to eight months, the FDA contacted
suppliers ot PCB and listed the users of the compounds in
the various states. Ledbetter said he has conferred with
two users of PCBs ia Georgia to make sun that none was
being released into the environment
`The real key is to keep it out of the environment end
out of the pathway to man,'' Ledbetter said, pouting out
that when the source of contamination halts its release, the concentration Wwt iWwjbm
Ledbetter said it has been established that fish accu
mulate the PCBs over a period of time.
Theoretically, families at some fishermen could ban
aafmw eaten numerous tones near a period of months
many fish with 1 cmcestratioal at PCBs jot below the
maximum of five ppm allowed
by the FDA, with less
potential harm to their health than persons who ait fish
with 1J-1S ppm or men at tin chemical In only a taw
Tbe U. S. Army Corps of Engineers office in Savannah said fishing activity on Lake Hartwell lias slewed down to practically a standstill* sinct the discovery of toxic levels ot PCBs In lisa ia the Twelve Wile Cheek arm ia Pickens Camaty. South Combos.
MOMS 0 3 0 6 3 7