Document KRxYRqE8rogVbvwbY7apebyNr
FILE NAME: Metalclad (METC) DATE: 1961 DOC#: METC003 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: WC Claim - Harding
| d .t ,>rirt-hatih i.-^'r ,i .b trw v .fly , i ^Ttm-fate-fii-f.ni ^ . ,,...',,
0
BEFORE THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT CCMCSSICN OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA CLAIM NO, 60 SF 193-854
CLIFFORD P. HARDJUO,
Applicant,
vo,
PLAl }T ASBESTOS CO., J . T. THORP A SONS, INC METALCLAP INSULATION CO., PNC,, CRN CAW, dba CAW INSULATION, DUTTON ASB SSTOS A SUPPLY CO., ARMSTRONG CORK CO, , COAST INSULATING PRODUCTS CORP., C, P. BRAUN & CO., OWENS-CORNING HTBErGLAS CORE., JACKSON & HOPKINS CO., NCi. , MARINE ENGINEERING & SUPPLY CO. , PLUbR MAINTENANCE, INC,, M, R, CARPENTER, % , NESTERN ASBESTOS CO. , INDUSTRIAL INliaNITY CO. CALIFORNIA CASUALTY MtyMNITY EXCHANGE, STANDARD ACCEDENT INS, CO. , TRAVELERS INS. CO,, ARGONAUT m g , CO , AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS. CO., AETNA CASUALTY & SURETY CO., GUARANTEE i n s . co , ze n it h national i n s ., co ' F a b r i c employers i n s . CO,, associated MtjNMNITY CORP., and STATE COMPENSATION INSURANCE FUND,
Defendants ,
ORDER APPROVING COMPROMISE AND RELEASE
The p a r t i e s to the above e n t i t l e d ac tio n having f i l e d a
Cot pre m ie s and R e le a s e h e r e i n , on Aug, 59, 196 1, s e t t l i n g t h e above
ca: ? f o r $ 3,300.00, in a d d i t i o n t o a l l sumo which may h av e been p a i d
prt tlo u s ly , and req u eatln g t h a t i t be approved; and th i s Commission
hat tng considered the e n t i r e re c o rd , in c lu d in g said ; Compromise anti
Re tao e, now f i n d s t h a t i t s h o u l d be ap prov ed ; and,
_
GOOD CAUSE APPEARING THEREFOR;
IT I S CPEERSD t h a t s a i d Compromise and R e l e a s e b e , and i t IB he shy approved, payable as fo llo w s:
By INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY COMPANY
$ 337,10
By CALIFORNIA CASUALTY INDEMNITY EXCHANGE By STANDARD ACCIDENT INSURANCE COMPANY
16-86 16.86
By TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY
50.57
B y ARGQKAUI INSURANCE COMPANY'
-
3 3 .7 1
75
)
'
ji
f
, Wi., . ., w.ffcfc..*--A w u <1.
;
t
^
J r -r
^
^
Re: CLIFFORD P. HARDINO - CI mm No. 60 SF 193-&54
3y MffiRICAN MOTORISTS INSURANCE COMPANY
$ 84,25
By AETNA CASUALTY k SURETY COMPANY By Guarantee insurance c o m p a n y
370.81 286.54
By ZENITH NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY
33.71
By PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INSURANCE COMPANY
101.13
By ASSOCIATED INDEMNITY CORPORATION
33.71
B\r STATE COMPENSATION INSURANCE FUND J
1934.73 $*--3303i v7c S_
IT IS FURTHER.ORDERED t h a t STATE COMPENSATION INSURANCE FUND d e d u c t t h e sum o f $ 3 5 2 .0 0 f r o I t # c o n t r i b u t i o n t o b# p a i d
d i r e c t l y as fo llo w s: *$300.00 to S m ith , P a r r is h , Faduclc & Clancy #a an a t t o r n e y # ' f e e ; $22.00 t o Smith, P a r r i s h , Paguplc k C lancy
t o t tra n sc rip t of the deposition; $30.00
y i F r e y , M.D.
0YUR e f
U A L ACCIDENT COMMISSION
-APN; Im f `r ."3 t i if.r>t
_Filed and served on; n d k u J
C l i f f o r d , H ard in g , 1^07 Howe A v e ., Sacramento 25
P l a n t A sb esto s Oo., 1300 - 6 4 th S t , , E e r y v i l l e
J - T. Thorp k Sons, I n c . , 1351 Ocean Ave., E m e r y v i ll e MAt8l l a d I n s u l a t i o n Co., I n c ., P 0. Box 173, T o r r a n c e Caw I n s u l a t i o n , 3600 - 20t h A vo., Sacramento 20
a i t t o n A sb e sto s k S upply C o ., 532 Natoroa S t . , SP
Ajptstrong c o rk C o ., l o i n Ogden D r iv e , Burlingame
q o a s t I n s u l a t i n g P ro d u cts C o rp ., 2684 Lacy s t r e e t , U>a Angele# 31
q. F. Braun 4 Co., 1000 South Fremont AVe., Alhambra Owens-Coming F i b e r g l a s C o r p ., P .0 . Box 89, Sacramento
Jackson k Hopkins Co-,, Inc-,, P.O. Box 490, B a k e r s f ie l d
N a rin e E n g i n e e r i n g 8c S upply C o ., 9^1 E a s t Second S t . , Lo# A ngeles
F l u o r M a in ten an ce, I n c ., 2500 South A t l a n t i c Blvd'., 7 R- C a r p e n te r , I n o . , 007 F r o n t S t , , Sacramento 7 V estcrn A sbestos Co., 675 Townsend S t . , sf 3
Lo# A n g e le s 22
i n d u s t r i a l In dem nity Co., 350 Sansorae S t . , SF
C a l i f o r n i a C asu alty Indem nity Exchange, 550 Kearny S t , , SF
. ta n d a r d A c c id e n t i n e . Co., 640 West San B runo Avs. San BB rr u n o r a v c i c r s In s . Co., 550 C a l i f o r n i a S t , , SF
tr y o n a u t In s . Co., 550 C a l i f o r n i a S t . , S?
American M o t o r i s t s I n s . Co., 417 Montgomery S t , , SP
Aetna C a s u a lt y k S u r e t y Co., 220 Montgomery S t , , SP G u a r a n te e I n s . C o,, 55 Kearny S t . , SF
E e m t h N a t i o n a l In s . Cb., 582 Market S t . , ` sf
P a c i f i c Employers Ina. Co. f 244 P in e S t . , SP
A s s o c i a t e d In d em nity C o r p . , 332 Pine S t , , SF
S ta te Compensation Ins. rund - Personal Service
*wwuui#*.ll m u L IJ M P '<
/
)
f
i I
Ri CLIFFORD P. HAHDrNQ - c la im to . 60 8P 193- 65L
S L.' 1 L 1S61 . i__ _________________
P.13 rat. and served on: c o n ti n u e d
Smj p a r r l o h , Paduck & claney, J o i F i n a n c i a l C e n te r B l d g . , Oakland
Hai ia & Brophy, 1540 San Pablo Ave., Oakland
Sec ;wick, D e t e r t , Moran & Arnold, 100 Bush 8t . , SP - A ttn : Gordon K eith
muI er> k P l l i p p l , 315 Montgomery S t . , SP J . ' a t r i c k Goodwin, Ll S u t t e r S t ., SP
I
i
i
i I
I
a
)
CiifpRD P. BARDINCl A. H. NELSON, R e f e r e e September 2 l ' 1961
va.
PLANT ASBESTOS CO-,
J . T, THORP 4 SONS, IN C .,
et al
claim No.. 60 SP 193-854 in j; Asbestosis
REPORT CF REFEREE CN ORDER APPROVING _________ CPXPKOMISF. ANn RPTFAKF
16 *#!
,, l
. A sbestos worker, born February 28, 1896, claim s
a ? t ^lc r c s u *t o f i n d u s t r i a l e x p o su re In employments Tor r ^ i , , f m pl? y 8 r 9 Sl n S b a c k some 15 y e a r s . O v e r a ll , I n c lu d in g h W w f - 0ymento In th e lp d u e try in v a rio u s c u t- o f - S ta te l o c a l i t i e s ,
t* a s b e B t o ^ d u s t f a p p ro x ln la te ly 3 y arfl o f I n t e r m i t t e n t e x p o su re
y,. in c o
record shove th a t a p p lic a n t continued working u n ti l
Vv!n ^he waB s e l z e d
audden s e v e r e c h e s t p a i n s . He
w..s h o s p i t a l i s e d on a d i a g n o s i s o f c o r o n a r y o c c l u s i o n . C h eat
a ib e e to s is 6" a t t h a t tiroe were i n t e r Pr e te d a show ing e v id e n c e o f
i mon on v f v / 10? P f P "ed " t t l e t h e c a s e by t h e payment o r S300.00, nothing having been paid heretofore.
_
. Concerning the present oauae of d is a b ility , Dr, Horton
C Hinanaw, J r , , e t a t g ao f o l l o w s :
"The degree of a s b e s to s is evident
a p p a re n tly has had. Consequently, i t would be my opinion t h a t
rf h e a rt d ise a se is a separate condition and not d ir e c tly
re la te d to h 1$ a s b e s to s is " .
}
n , ^ . 00
b asis o f pulmonary function t e s t s , th e doctor
Uoncluded in h i s f i n a l re p o rt t h a t th e p a t i e n t 's symptoms were to
J >a r e d e g r e e due t o h i s h e a r t d i s e a s e and n o t t o a s b e s t o s i s
.ndeed, on th e b a s is of d if fu s io n c a p a c ity t e s t , i t was h i s '
.udgment t h a t t h e a s b e s t o s i s was so m ild as n o t t o be d i s a b l i n g
" r p ro d u c tiv e o f any symptoms.
`" E
^
*n / "h e a r l i e r r e p o r t Dr., N o r b e r t F rey , an b e h a l f o f
J.He a p p l i c a n t , liad c o n c l u d e d t h a t t h e p a t i e n t had a m o d erate
i e g r a s o f pulmonary f i b r o s i s , which was p r o d u c tiv e o f some
i h o r t n c s s o f b r e a t h . He e x p r e s s e d no o p in io n c o n c e r n i n g t h e
ndustrial contribution to the o v er-ail d isab ility .
*
Ch t h e r e c o r d , t h e s e t t l e m e n t l a r a i r and a d e q u a t e .
JISBOSITION: O rd er A pproving Compromis# and R e le a s e t o be p a id
to said a p p lic a n t, le s s $30.00 to N orbert Frey, H.D., and le a s t t t o r n e y a f e e o f $ 3 0 0 .0 0 and reim b urem en t c o a t s o f ^ 2 2 00 t o
je p a id to a p p l i c a n t ' a a tto r n e y s out o f th e am curft^S yabie t,y
s t a t e Compensation In surance Fund.
r
>
AEN.-mlm
i" ^ w . n 1 'i f ui p ( p i m i j n . n M ^ w i .w p y
0
*
/
H$W y Q lt CUA*34U*5 'ULSA
r. louts
^r.-CAOO
LT* ViCil 5
SAX T5AWO5C0 Nfw CilXi^S H'Uk)u>wiJ
EXHIBIT
-_moo.:.
11
A i u e ^ a i s s p i k i r ^ A J 2; x a p j d e n s ^ r i ^ i L c -/
.NCO^OiAfSO
jjo ^
rtLPKfct
INSURANCE
/
,Uuo
AYCRAOE a d j u s t e r s
consulting actuaries
Ttt^rt^I0^!
3 3 NORTH UABLES STREET, BALTIMORE IS. n o.
c a r s AOotOs -ALEXIUrf-
February 27, 1962
: PLAINTIFF'S * EXHIBIT
! n to D
n r . W i l l i a m L. Haghe, t i a im g e r Insurance Department A rmstrong, Cork Company L ^ n cafiter, P en n sy lv a n ia .
Dear S ir:
T r a v i l f l r i P o l i c y No. Rl^ - 4 4 9 0 4 5 9
P l e a s e n o t e < J l p o * it i on Dnd< o f th e f o l l o w i n g c l ^ i n ; Date o f A ccident: J a n u a ry 9 , 1955
c l a i m a n t : C l i f f o r d p. H a r d i n g
Location: Sacramento, C a lifo rn ia C laim Ho. : B 9527634
D i s p o s iti o n : SO.57 Perm- P a r t i a l
R erarks :
a .C s A
In d icate Whethur:
W orkmen's Cop. x W to L i a b i l i t y B . I . __________
P, C .___________ G e n e ra l L i a b i l i t y B . I . _ _____
P . D , _______
g
Very t r u l y y o u rs , AUGX4NDER 6 ALEXANDER HC. LOSS DSPARTXSN
t
CLIFFORD P. HARDrNO A. H. KELSON, R e fe re September 21, 1961
PLANT ASBESTOS CO. , J. T. TKORP * SONS, IN C .
e t 4l
C l* ln No. 60 SP 103-359 I n J i A sbeacoji*
REPORT OF REFEREE ON ORDER APPROVING ________COMPROMISE AND REL8A3S________
/U beitos worker, born February ?9, 1896, lilts a o e j t o i $ th e r e s u l t of I n d u s t r i a l exposure In employments f o r numerous em ployers going back some 15 y e a r s . O v e ra ll, i n c l u d i n g h is employments m the in d u s try in various o u t- o f - S t a te l o c a l i t i e s , he has a h i s t o r y o f ap p ro x im ately 30 y ears of i n t e r m i t t e n t exposure to aebeetos duos.
w in.cn
r0 ? o r ^ shows th a t ap plicant continued working u n t i l
Jiay, 1959, when he was s e i z e d w ith sudden s e v e r e c h e a t p a in s . He
bas h o s p l t a l l n d on a d ia g n o s is o f so ro tu ry o c c lu s io n . Chest
X -rays takon a t t h a t time wore i n t e r p r e t e d as showing evidence of asbestosis.
.
I1
proposed to s e ttle the case by the payment of
00, nothin h a v in g been paid h e re to f o r e .
,,
. Concerning the p re s e n t cause of d i s a b i l i t y , Dr. RortOn
C. Kinshaw, d r . , s t a t e s as f o llo w s :
* u
"Tha degree o f a s b e s to s i s ev id e n t on X-ray here would
no t bo ex pected t o lead to h e a r t d is e a s e , and a ls o th e type of
h e a r t d i s e a s e p ro d u c e d by I udg d i s e a s e I s q u i t e d i f f e r e n t from
disease which le a d s to coronary occlusion, which chi* p a tie n t
a p p a r e n t l y has had. C onsequently, i t would be 1- o p in io n t h a t
h is h eart d isease l r 4 separate condition and not d irc c tlv
r e l a t e d t o h is a s b a s t o a i i '.
'
9f
b asis f Pulmonary function te s ts , the doctor
c o n clu de d in h i s f i n a l rc p o r c t h a t th p a t i e n t ' s symptom* were to
? >a r 8 / d e g re e due to h i s h e a r s dl =Bas< and n o t t o a s b e s t o s i s . In d eed , on the b a s i s o f d i f f u s i o n c a p a c i ty t e s t , i i has h i s
Sucgmcnv th a t th 5 a a b e a tc a ia no mild . n o t to bo d i s a b l i n g
o r produotiv* of any symptoms.
a
I n an e a r l i e r r* p o r c , Dr, N o rb e rt F re y , on b e h a l f o f th_ appl c a n t , had concluded t h a t he p a t i e n t had t moderate d eg ree o f p u lm onary f i b r o s i s , which was p r o d u c t iv e o f soree
b r e a Sh - **
no o p in io n c oncerning the
in d u s tria l co n trib u tio n to the o v e r-a ll d is a b ility .
On t h e ro c o r d , the s e t t l e o e n t i s f a i r and a d e q u a te .
DISPOSITION; O r d e r Approving Comp r e e l s * ar.d R elease t o be paid to said a c p U c a rt, loss $30.30 tc Norbrt Frey. h.D and leas a tto rn e y * ' Sea o f * 3 0 0 .0 0 end .-Bim.cscn.cnt M t , o f ' 122.00
be p a id t o a p p l i c a n t ' s i i t c m c y s out o f the mount p a y a b le by
State Compensation Insurance
^
/iKN :nln
H. NELSON, R eferee
1
: '
ati-YArv
;
;
;;
;
,,
;
" .*-****, Vv^rrTy]'v'**'~*,~~`~*'~ ^
. Cl M ^
BFQHE THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION DF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
C L I F F Y P.
CLAPI NO. 60 SF 193*B5L
Muiirloi
deceived
compromise and release
AUG 2 a 1961 r f y
FILED .
Sa=rom.nro Office
:
F LEO
1407 Houe Avenue Sacramento 2$, Californie
PLANT ASBESTOS COUPANT
Employer
3* T. THORP t SONS, INC Employ.
METALCl AO INSULATION CO.,
Employer OAR CW. dba CAU INSULATION
Employ Pl/TTOI ASBESTOS t SUPPLY CO.
Employer ARMSTRONG CORK CO.
mployor
COAST INSULATING PAOOCTS CORP.
Employer
C. F . BRAUN 1 CO.
*
Employer
OUENS-tCORNING FIBERGLAS CORP.
-
Employer
JACKSON k HOPKINS CO. , INC.
finplayer MARINI: ENGINEERING SUPPLY CO.
Ew.uUwr
a u o R maintenance, in c .
Employer fl. R. CARPENTER, IlVT
Employer WESTERN ASBESTOS CO,
Employer
64 t h S t r e e t Emoryvillo, California
Ocean Avenue Emeryville, California r r i e e Box 17B
Torrance, C alifornia 3600 - 20t h Avenue
Saoramonto 20. C alifo rn ia 532 atoca S tr e e t
Sen Francisco 3, C alifornia
1011* Ogden D rive
Burllngaraa, C alifornia
266li Looy S t r e e t
L
Loi Angeles I I , C alifo rn ia
1000 South Fremont Avenue
Alhambra, C alifornia P o e t O f f i c e B o x B9
l H P W W . H ai
Sacramento. C alifo rn ia P a s t O f r i c a Box A90
Bakersfield, California 9A1 E a s t Second S t r e e t
L os A n g u la , C a lifo rn ia
2500 South A tla n tic fioulovard
Lo A ngeles 22, C a l i f o r n i a 007 F ront S t r e e t
Sacramanto 7, C alifo rn ia 675 Tounaand S t r e e t
San fra n c le c o 3, C a lifo rn ia
INDUS' 'RIAL IfllOEMNlTY COMPANY
350 Sinuoma S t r e e t
im upinco Carrier
Sr> F r i n c i e e o . C a l i r e r n i a
CALIFORNIA CASUALTY INDEMNITY EXCHANGE 550 Kearny S t r e e t
Insurance Carrier
San Franaieco, C alifornia
standAro accident I nsurance c o n p m r
SAO West San Bruno Bvmu
Imuranca CaVriar
San Bruno, C a lif o r n ia
TRAVELERS INSURANCE COUPANT
550 C a l i f o r n i a S t r e e t
Inouraneo Carrier ARGONAUT INSURANCE COMPANY
San F ra n c isc o , C a lifo rn ia
550 C a lif o r n ia S t r e e t
I
Insurance Carrier
San Frencieeo, C a lifo rn ia
AMERICAN MOTORISTS INSURANCE COMPANY
$17 Montgomery S t r e e t
r
Irsuranca Carrier
San F rancisco, C a lifo rn ia
AETNA CASUALTY i SURETY CDMPANY (
220 Montgoraary s t r e e t
Insurance C a rrie r."
San Francisco, C alifornia
GUARANTEE INSURANCE COMPANY
550 Kearny S t r e e t
Irm.-flnc, Carrier
:
3on fra n c isc o , C a lifo rn ia
ZENIT NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY
582 Market S t r e e t
..
Inauranc Carrier
San f r a n c is c o , C a lifo rn ia
p a c i f i c employers insurance company
3730 Piedmont Avenue
I nsurance Carrier
Oakland 1 1 . C alifo rn ia
-1-
SL
3
)
i I
rWI i m
. I, . A -- .-a ?=3<ra- -U2f-nmimnr ----- j
*
- . . 1 !
'
Re: CLIFFORD P. HARDmo - Claim No 60 SF 193-854
ay AMERICAN MOTORISTS INSURANCE COMPANY By AETNA CASUALTY 4: SURETY COMPANY By GUARANTEE INSURANCE COMPANY 'ey ZENITH NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY By PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INSURANCE COMPANY By ASSOCIATED INDEMNITY CORPORATION By STATE COMPENSATION INSURANCE FUND
$ 84,28 370.01 206.5433.71 101.13 33,71
193*1.72
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED lb fit STATE COMPENSATION INSURANCE puy D d e d u c t t h e sura o f $ 3 5 2 .0 0 from l t B c o n t r i b u t i o n t o be p a i d
d i r e c t l y an f o l lo w ! . $ 3 0 0 .0 0 t o S m ith . P a r r i s h , Paduck fc C lancy
as an a tt o r n e y ' fe n ; $22.00 t o Sm ith, P a r r is h , Padjiclt it Clancy
fo tr a n s c r ip t of th e d e p o sitio n ; $30,
P rey , m.D.
ATN; mlm f-rr, - y If.Rt
M j/ Ref (RIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION
^ F iie d and served on:
C l i f f o r d ? , H ard in g , m o 7 HOwe A v e ., Sacram ento 2 5
P f a n t A sbestos Co., 1300 - 6 4 th S t , , E m e ry v ille
, P rF & ? on-s> l u c . , 1351 Ocean A ve., E m e r y v ille
M P t a lc l a d I n s u l a t i o n Co , I n c ., P.O. Box 173, T o r r a n c e Caw I n s u l a t i o n , 3600 2 0 t h A v e., S acram ento 20 E titto n A s b e s to s & S u p p ly C o . , 532 Natoma s t , , sp
Ar m s tr o n g Cork co., 1314 Ogden D r i v e . B urlingam e
Cjoast I n s u l a t i n g P ro d u c ts C o r p ,, 2604 Lacy S t r e e t , Loa A ngeles 31 q . P . Braun Sc C o . , 1000 S o u th Frem ont A v e ., Alhambra O wens-Coming F l b e r g l a s C o r p . , P.O. Box B9 , S acram ento
Jackson k Hopkins to..,, Inc.,, P.O. Box 490, B a k e rs f ie ld
M arine E n g i n e e r i n g it S upply CO., 941 Eant Second S t , , Los A ngeles
F lu o r M aintenance, Inc., 2500 South A tla n t ic Blvdl, 7 - R. C a r p e n t e r , I n c . 907 F r o n t S t , , Sacramento 7 w estern A sbestos to ., 675 Townsend S t . , S? 3
Los A ngeles 22
j n d u a t r i a l In d e m n ity Co., 35O Sansome S t . , SP
C a l i f o r n i a C a s u a lt y Indem nity Exchange, 550 Kearny S t . , SF
S ta n d a r d A c c id e n t I n s . Co., 84o West San Bruno Ave. , San B m n o T r a v e l e r s I n s . Co., 550 C a l i f o r n i a S t . , S ?
A rgo n au t Ins-, t o . , 550 C a l i f o r n i a S c . , SP
American M o t o r i a t s I n a . to ., 17 Montgomery S t . , SF
Aetna C a s u a l t y k S u r e t y t o . , 220 Montgomery S t . , SF G u aran tee I n s . C o,, 550 Kearny SC. , 2 P Z e n it h N a t i o n a l i n s . t o . , 582 M arket S t , , ' sf
Pa c i f i c Employers In a. Co., 244 P in e S t . , SP
Aeeoolated Indemnity C o rp ., 332 Pine S t , , S?
S ta te Compensation Ins Fund - P ersonal S ervice
-2 -
/
)
-r
i 7 - - . . , c--
,V|,, V/jl^
hU im titt,
Ri CLIFFORD ?. HARHOIO - Claim No. 60 SP 193-05^
s l - ]9si
EJJLafl-and se rv e d on: c o n tin u e d
5" , ft P4 r r l uh *
* Clancy, 501 F in a n c ia l C enter B ldg.
2 " t r o p h y , 1540 San P a tio Ave., Oakland
Sec .Vick, D e t e r t , Moran fc Arnold, 100 Bush S t . , SP - Artn-
KUl .en k F i l l p p i , J . 'a tr ic k ooodwin
5 t SF
Oakland Gordon Keith
1
i
i
I
" --" ~ T ~~TT~~T~~i-- [ip~TfrTnfTjTiiij,ii iw m ii
/
)
rfrn* i ~ CLIFFORD P,
HARDINQ
H. NELSON, R eferee September 21, 196a
J I*.
X
VS.
PLANT ASBESTOS CO,,
J . T. THORP i SCN8, IN C .,
et al
Claim No.. 60 SR 193-354 InJ: Asbestosis
REPORT CF REFEREE CN ORDER APPROVING
_ ,
COXPRQMISE AND RFIFAftF_______
St?
l _ . A sbestos worker, born February 28 1896 claim mneijnneetrooSuioi1!e!map?lotyielcrs r ge os iunlgt boaf c ki n sdoumset r1i 5a l y eeaxrpso.^s u r eO vIne r aeml lp' llnoyc ml uefnltisn f o r
to asbestos dS^t, f approxlI,lately 3 years of in term itten t exposure
h s v la n o T^ i L r e i!01'11 howo t h 4 t a p p l i c a n t c o n t i n u e d working u n t i l
w is'h^soltaii'red
Bud<Jen a *v ftri
pal " a - Ke
X+ravs ta k e n ^ e ^ h * - +?1 Bn08lB. 0 f COronary o c c lu s io n , c h e s t
subM toflis?
th 6 t tin,e wer* in te rp re te d as showing evidence of
ii jLj o0o0. oOoO, ^n oTt h^ in^g OKh a.PvfinCgP0ib*e'e1n t0p aDi d" tfhcel0r e t o f o cr ae e. e * /
pay* ment o f
ua ,, b n c e m l n g t h e p r e s e n t c a u s e o f d i s a b i l i t y . Dr Horton
Hlnahaw, J r . , s t a te s as fo llo w s:
Y`
M nsn
u. .
The d e g re e o f a s b e s t o s i s e v i d e n t on X -ray h e r e would
nbt be expected to lead to h e a rt d is e a se , and al80 the tvoe of
dU1i oH* s,bd lS" hh iioShH
Pl eraoddsu c $t;od
bcYo r olunna8rryydooi scceccallvvsaeexx ooinns .,
qwwu
hhi ttieec
k h
d
ftihhf<fie<s r
e p
n a
V ti
fro en
i t
n
i p a r e n t l y h a s had C o n s e q u e n tl y , i t would be my o p in i o n t h a t
Is heart disease
It H I t . A -
1
J
_,, .
l a t e d Y o h i es a ^ b e 3s t o s i ^ a.rat0 c o n < ,itio n and n o i d ^ c t l y
n 1 . . 011 J ^ e b a s *a f pulm o n ary f u n c t i o n t e s t s t h e d o c t o r lh5 ` the P a t e n t ' a s y ^ t o ^ w e r e to
' arSe degree due to h is h e a rt disease and n o t to asbestnsi
ndeeB, on th e b a s i s o f d i f f u s i o n c a p a c i t y t e s t i t was h ? l
'rf fpmrr oZdWu c thi vKet o^ f anays bsey8mt optsoims s.was ,0 mil d as n o t t o b e ^uiisslubolni nn gs
n e a r l i e r re p o rt, Dr. N orbert Frey an b eh alf n f ` rhe a p p lic a n t, had concluded tfiat th e p a t i e n t ha " moderate
h n r t n p ! E f i 0 " 8.1? f l 0 s i s ' which was p r o d u c t i v e o f some
h o r t n e s s o f b r e a t h . Ffc e x p r e s s e d no o p i n i o n c o n c e r n i n g t h e
industrial contribution to the o v er-ail d isab ility
6
Ch t h e r e c o r d , t h e s e t t l e m e n t i s f a i r and a d e q u a te .
>ISPSITICN: O rder Approving Compromiae' and R e le a se t o be p a id
o s a i d a p p l i c a n t , l e s s S30.O t o N o r b e r t P r * y . m/D , nd l e a s
t e r f e C , ? f i3 0 0 ' 00 and re im b u re e m e n t e & t . o& m 7oo "
be pa!d to a p p li c a n t's a tto rn e y s out o f th e amourft^rfdyable by
S tate Compensation Insurance Fund.
" X # * * 0- xe oy
AHN :mlm
.. .......................................
t
/
1 ; . : i ; ;! ' i* L
r
: *
^ ;
BEFORt THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT COMMISSION OP THE STATE OP CALIFORNIA
CLAIM NO. 60 SF 1 9 3 - EISA
J"<fartel,eM,i Camini,,
! COMPROMISE AND RELEASE
RECEIVED Aug 2 ai9 6 i r j ^
,, FILED r . So^omonlp Office
CLIFFC RO P . HARDING Empio y V y * inaisi*!.
' f M-EO ,
1407 Hsu* Avenue Sacramento 23, C a lifo rn ia
auG T 9 ' 96'
PLANT ASBESTOS COMPANY Employor
3 . T. THORP t SONS, INC. Emoloyn
ftETALlLAO INSULATION CO., INC.
J
' Employer
oan cAy, obit c au insulation
I
Efn^l oyor
DUTTOj ASBESTOS i SUPPLY CO.
'
Employer
ARMSTRONG CORX CO.
Cmp1 Dyer
COAST INSULATING PRODUCTS CDflP,
Employer
C. F . BRAUN 4 CO.
"
Employer OUENS^CORNING PISERGLAS CORP.
Employer
JACKS! N t HOPKINS CO, , INC.
Emplaysr MARINI : ENGINEERING S SUPPLY CO.
D w ibw i FLUOR MAINTENANCE, INC.
Enj.|ika^r n. R. CARPENTER, INC.
,,
w Employer
WESTERN ASBESTOS CO,
Employer
1300 - 64th S t r e e t
_
Emeryville, C elirernla
"i 3 5 l Ocean Avenue Emeryville, C alifornia
P o s t o r n e e Box 178
Torrance, C alifornia 3600 - 2 0 th Avenue
Sacramento 20, California 532 Netom* S t r u c t
San F ra n c isc o 3, C a lifo rn ia 18X4 Ogden D rive
Burlingamo, C alifornia 2504 Lacy s t r e e t
Loa Angelas 31, C a l i f o r n i a
1000 South Frem cnt Avenue Alhambra, C a lifo rn ia
Poet O rn ea Box 69
Sacramento, C a lifo rn ia P a s t o r r i c e Box t>90
Bakersfield, California
941 E ast Second S t r e e t
LOS A n g e l o , California
2500 South A tla n tic Boulevard
Lo Angales 22, C a l i f o r n i a 907 Front S tr e e t
___ Sacramento 7 , C a lif o r n ia 675 TOunaand S t r e e t
Son F re n c iic o 3 , C a lifo rn ia
IN0US"RIAL INDEMNITY COMPANY
Inauve*> C a r r i e r CALIFORNIA CASUALTY INDEMNITY EXCHANGE
Insurance Carrier STANDARD ACCIDENT INSURANCE COMPANY
Insurance Carriar TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY
Inouranee Carrier ARGONAUT INSURANCE COMPANY
Insurance Carrier
AMEAIAN MOTORISTS INSURANCE COMPANY
^eurancs Carrier
AETNA CASUALTY t SURETY COMPANY ,
insurance C a r r i e r . "
GUARANTEE INSURANCE COMPANY
u
Insurance C a r r i e r :
ZENIT" NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY
Inouranee Carrier PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INSURANCE COMPANY
Insurance C a r r i e r
350 Sansoma S t r e e t
Sn F r a n c t e c o , C a l i f o r n i a 550 Kearny S t r e e t
San F ra n c le c o , C a lifo rn ia B40 Ust San Bruno Avr>ui
Sen Bruno, C a li f o r n i a 550 C a li f o r n i a S t r e e t
San F rancisco, C a lifo rn ia 550 C alifo rn ia S tr e e t
San F rancisco, C a lifo rn ia 417 Montgomery S t r e e t
San F rancisco, C a lifo rn ia 220 Montgomary S t r e e t
San F rancisco, C a lifo rn ia 350 Kaarny s t r e e t
Ban r r n n c l e u , C a l i f o r n i a 582 Rafkat S t r e e t
San f r a n c i s c o , C a l i f o r n i a
3730 Piedmont Avenue
Oakland 1 1 , C a lifo rn ia
-i-
NL
Ma
-- i 4 ^ h a i'.''.iftiil i.Hi i ,i k ^ iiM l. f'r i a k
a .......
^ _ .-
I
B E 'ORE THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT CCMSSICN OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA CLAIM NO. 60 SP 193-854
CLI 'FORD P. HARDIN0,
Applicali t,
ORDER APPROVING OOMPROMISE AND RELEASE
PLANT ASBESTOS CO., J . T. THORP & SONS,
INCh METALCLAD INSULATION CO, , INC,.
L.CAW, dba a w INSULATION, DUTTON
ASBESTOS Sr SUPPLY CO, ARMSTRONG CORK
CO. L COAST INSULATING PRODUCTS CORE,,
C, P . BRAUN SC O ., OWENS-CORNING
.
FIBERGLAS CORP., JACKSON fc HOPKINS CO..
INCj. , MARINE ENGINEERING & SUPPL CO. ,
KLUDR MAINTENANCE, INC,, N. R. CARPENTER, INC., WESTERN ASBESTOS CO. , INDUSTRIAL
INDEMNITY CO,., CALIFORNIA CASUALTY
WtpSWITY EXCKANOS, STANDARD ACCIDENT
IN^. 00. , TRAVELERS INS. CO., ARGONAUT
Big, CO , AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS. CO.
ABBIA CASUALTY ic SURETY CO,, GUARANTEE I N I CO. , ZENITH NATIONAL INS. CO
PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INS. CO , ASSOCIATED
BOOJIMNITY CORP., and STATE COMPENSATION INSURANCE FUND,
Daf a n d a n ti .
The p a r t i e s to the above e n t i t l e d a c tio n having f i l e d a
Compromise and R e le a se h e re in , on Aug, 29,1961, s e t t l i n g th e above
ca '
$3,300,00, i n a d d it io n t o a l l sums which may have been p a id
P ri flously, and rc q u e a tln g th a t i t bo approved; and t h i s Commission
hai- tng considered the e n ti r e record, in c lu d in g said;Compromise and
Rs iaae , now f i n d s t h a t i t sh o u ld be ap prov ed ; and,
..
GOOD CAUSE APPEARING THEREFOR;
IT I S CHEERED t h a t s a i d Compromise and R e l e a s e b e , and I t in he; Jby approved, p ay ab le a 3 follow s:
By INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY COMPANY
$ 337.10
By CALIFORNIA CASUALTY INDEMNITY EXCHANGE
16.86
By STANDARD ACCIDENT INSURANCE COMPANY
16.86
By TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY
50.57
B y ARGONAUT. INSURANCE COMPANY'
-
3 3 .T l