Document KRn8XB8O9G1dX7Z3emKVLEo36
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBU
TJ-J
A/C Pipe Producers Association Executive Committee International Affairs Committee
F. W&&A________
\/J. F. Welch, Vice President
FCM
^^^JbiemQl Correspondence
SUBJECT
PAC-01-82, Municipal Market Program, Trade Releases REF: JFW correspondence, AACPP Trade Releases, April 27, 1982 ACTION REQUIRED: Review for information
As mentioned in the above reference, the Journalbf American Water Works Association published the AACPP trade release on the statements of Drs. Murray and Browne (Advisory #3) regarding the lack of association between asbestos fibers and gastrointestinal cancer. The total circulation of the Journal is over 60,000 including 32,500 water utility managers, engineers and consulting engineers, 11,000 principals of engineering consulting firms, 13,600 water utility superintendents and 8,700 key municipal personnel including city managers, mayors and water utility officials.
AACPP will continue to make trade releases for each new A/C Advisory. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call.
JFW/ajb
cc: A. Kahn, Esq.
copies to:
Executive Committee
International Affairs Committee
L. Ambler J. Cran L. Taylor
E. van der Rest R. Dorner L. Giannitrapani N. Officer P. Hart A. Saoulis R. Jalan V. Pattabhi H. Hudson C. Barton S. Al-Tarkait M. Delcourt J. Cuvelier B. Giboin G. Zaviezo
F.02EI20801 Chrono
CAPCO JEN 0033345
i
(Cnnlinved from page 53) facility near the southern boundary of the - p!,-.nt grounds in Barnwell County, S.C.
Evidence points away Irom link between'
asbestos ingestion and cancer .-
'*
b
Two British scientists, Robert Murray
and Kevin Browne, have concluded that
"evidence from animal experiments, oc
cupational exposure, and epidemiology is
beginning to point strongly away from
any association" between asbestos fibers
and an excess mortality from gastroin
testinal tumors.*
Murray and Browne rely on two major
recent animal experiments. They point to
a study conducted by the Institute of
Occupational Medicine in Edinburgh,
Scotland, that "confirmed the absence of
asbestos-related gut tumors in a large-
scale study of rats monitored for their
whole life span"2 and to studies currently
. being conducted with laboratory animals
by the US National Institute of Environ
mental Health Sciences (NIEHS). With
respect to these latter studies, the US
Environmental Protection Agency
(USEPA) has stated, "The initial results
did not detect any adverse effects on the
test animals from asbestos in the diet."
Regarding the observance of excess
gastrointestinal cancers in some occupa
tional groups heavily exposed to airborne
asbestos, Murray and Browne state. ", . .among the less heavily exposed, no excess has been found." They mention the suggestion of Turner-Warwick and
Parkes that, "except for the lung, asbestos might act not as a local carcinogen but systemically via the immune system."3 They also refer to a study by Goldsmith, which provides evidence that "the in creases in background rates at different sites appear to be an example of cancer promotion following impairment of de fense mechanisms rather than site
specificity."* The authors also cite the Connecticut
study, conducted by Meigs et al, in which cancer incidence data collected over a 35year period indicated "no increases in incidence either of all cancers or of the individual sites considered."5
Murray and Browne take issue with the conclusions of a California study by Kanarek,5 noting two major problems of interpretation with the conclusions of this study. "Firstly, as these workers point out, certain cancers, including stomach, lung, and colon, show an as sociation with social class, and consider able social class differences appear in their figures... [TheyJ correct for this by correcting for three different levels of education and. income. But unless these are perfectly correlated with the factors responsible for the large differences in
COMPUTERIZE YOUR
UTILITY BILLING
Each billing period only the meter readings and receipts need to be entered.
Calculation and printing of the bill is done by the computer
Reports are provided to assist in the ' management of receipts and consumption
All of this and more are accomplished on your micro-computer.
For more information write to: Banyon Data Systems 7373 W. 147th Street
Apple Valley, MN 55124
If you do have a computer please let us know what kind.
54 NEWS
Reader Inquiry Service No. 105
cancer rates between social classes, the-^Q? residual variation may well cause a spurious correlation to appear between " geographical feature and cancer rate for some organs. Secondly, the computer has 'V' made possible the large-scale dredging of population data forpositive associations,.- -i-'; and probabilities obtained in this way- Sr:, should not be taken at face value."
References
1. Murray.R. 6 Browne, K. Response to As-
bestos in Water, The Lancet (Aug. 22..- tt;
1981).
2. Bolton. R.E.; Davis. J.M.G.; & Lamb, D.The -'S
Pathological Effects of Prolonged Asbestos i-^3
Ingestion in Rats. Environ. lies, fin press).:,iS
3. Turner-Warwick. M. & Parkes. W.R. Cir-
culating Rheumatoid and AntinuclearFac-'.-fST
tors in Asbestos Workers. British Med.-C^
Jour. (1970).
' ".".-ni'-Sg
4. Goldsmith. J.P. Asbestos as a Promoting.-"/!5
Agent for Non-Pulmonary Cancer: The' i'S.
Epidemiological Evidence from Eight Co-
horts. Proc. First Symp. on Epidemiol, in
A Occupational Health (Helsinki, 1981)/.
' Scandinavian Jour, of Work Environment
Health (in press).
-/si
5. MeiCS. J.W. ET At_ Asbestos-Cement Pipe --/?
and Cancer in Connecticut: 1955-1974.
Environ. Health. 42:187 (1980).
.
6. Conforti.P.M. ETAl-Asbestos in Drinking -
Water and Cancer in the San Francisco Bay . \\
Area: 1969-1974 Incidence. Jour. Chronic --/?
Disease. 34:211 (1981).
Hi
Business news
. ...-SS-Il ..(jsj
Raymond International Inc. announced ;
that one of its subsidiaries is the project .-'A:
manager of a joint venture partnership 'V5
that was awarded a $30 million contract * \i
to manufacture and install concrete
foundation piles for water reservoirs in vp!
Iraq for the municipality of Baghdad. g
The joint venture between Raymond -w
International (UK) and the State Con- -
trading Company for Piles and Founda- \V
tions, an Iraqi government company,
received the award from the State Con-
trading Company for Water and Sewer [?.
Projects, another government company. ~
The piles will be supports for three water -
'reservoirs with 8 ha (20 acres) of water A
surface. The project is expected to be -'ij
completed in 1983.
d
Hydranautics Water Systems has been
awarded the contract for a reverse osmo-
sis (RO) water treatment plant with an
ultimate capacity of 11.4 ML/d (3.0 mgd)
for the Englewood (Fla.) Water District.
The first 1.9 ML/d (0.5-mgd) train is
scheduled to go onstream by September
1982.
Englewood, a community on the Gulf of
Mexico, had to develop a new ivellfield to
meet growing water demands. Because
the source aquifer is brackish. RO was
selected over other desalinat ion processes
to provide potable water because of its
lower operating costs and successful field
experience in Florida.
Q
/ - -. -! V-
-:
j j
~
JOURNAL AVVWA *
CAPCO JEN 0033346