Document KRkd1gn5eKjOeV361MaLYqZMo
FILE NAME Insurance Industry INS
DATE 1964 DOC INS083
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Medical Journal Article - Asbestos Exposure and Neoplasia
JAMA April 6 1964
Asbestos Exposure and Neoplasia
Irving J. Selikoff MD Jacob Churg MD and E. Cuyler Hammond DSc New York
Building trades insulation workers have relatively light intermittent exposure to asbestos Of 632 insulation workers who
exposure smoking habits and personal history on the size of series and on inadequate histological
verification in some cases
entered the trade before 1943 and were
Within the last few years a number of additional
traced through 1962 forty died of
problems connected with asbestos exposure have
cancer of the lung or pleura whereas only
appeared making clarification and resolution of the
6.6 such deaths were expected Three of the pleural tumors were mesotheliomas there was also one peritoneal mesothelio-
foregoing
siderable
increased
statistical uncertainty a matter of con-
concern First there has been greatly
use of the various types of asbestos a
ma Four niesotheliomas in a total of 255
fold increase in world utilization of this group
deaths is an exceedingly high incidence for
such a rare tumor In addition an unex-
pectedly large number of men died of cancer of the stomach colon or rectum 29 compared with 9.4 expected Other cancers were not increased 20.5 were expected
21 occurred Twelve men died of asbestosis
of minerals from 500,000 tons to 2,500,000 tons per year in the last 30 years as well as a greatly increased number and variety of industrial applications of asbestos over 3,000 such uses now recorded Second suspicion has been growing that malignancy associated with asbestos exposure may include neoplasms other than carcinoma of the
LTHOUGH PULMONARY CARCINOMA had been observed in the earliest studies of asbes-
lung Thus a significant relationship has been claimed between diffuse mesothelioma of the pleura and peritoneum and asbestos exposure
tosis association between the two conditions was
This communication is concerned with investi-
first suggested by Lynch and Smith in 1935. Ad-
ditional reports of such association followed Per-
haps the most striking data was presented in the annual report of the Chief Inspector of Factories
gations undertaken to study the following factors 1 the incidence of deaths due to pulmonary carcinoma among a group of workers exposed to as-
bestos under United States industrial conditions
of Great Britain for 1955. Every death with asbestosis in the files of the Factory Department
in the past several decades 2 whether or not
such individuals would also be found to have an
from the first recognition of asbestosis as a disease
increased risk of other neoplasms and 3 whether
entity was studied Altogether 365 such deaths were recorded 1924-1955 Sixty or 17.8 were found to be accompanied by cancer of the lung or
such risks would be present in an industry other than the producing or products industries with which most reports in the past
pleura Doll after reviewing the problem and add-
have been concerned but which would not nec-
ing data of his own concluded that lung cancer was a specific industrial hazard of heavily exposed
asbestos workers
Nevertheless some investigators have held that while these observations might be suggestive they did not establish an increased incidence of carci-
essarily represent the most important areas of asbestos exposure at this time Further it was hoped that study of an industry with asbestos exposure of limited extent and intensity would throw some light on the potential problems associated with
minimal exposure to asbestos
noma of the lung in pulmonary asbestosis and
Paner further that the association The factor of selection was tial weakness in evaluating
was unproved
considered a potenreports of autopsy
Materials and Methods
Our investigations have been concerned with 1,522 members of the Asbestos Workers Union in
series It was noted that complicated and unusual cases would be more likely to come to autopsy thus raising the apparent frequency of associated
the New York metropolitan area members of New York Local 12 and Newark NJ Local 32 of the
International Association of Heat and Frost Insu-
lung neoplasms Further it was argued that au-
lators and Asbestos Workers As the full title im-
topsy statistics which dealt with particular groups of those who died do not reflect total populations
of asbestos workers Additional reservations were
plies these men are insulation workers Although the union is considered one of the building
unions its members do insulation work in a va-
based on the frequent absence of data regarding
riety of industries including shipbuilding Called
From the Division of Thoracic Ducase Department of Medicine and the Department of Pathology Mount Sinai Hospital
Read before a joint meeting of the sections on radiology and diseases
laggers in Great Britain they are often designated pipe coverers insulators or asbestos
of the chest and the American College of Chest Physicians at the 112th Annual Meeting of the American Medical Association Atlantic City NJ June 17 1963
workers in this country The union is one of the oldest in the country
NOTICE Thik metarial may be protected by copyright ket TKR 17 U.B Code
AAA COURT REPORTING
142
per DEPOSITION -, EXHIBIT SS
#5! Vol 189 No 1
ASBESTOS EXPOSURE ET AL
23
** The New York local as the Salamander Associa-
tion of Boiler and Pipe Felters was the first union of insulation workers in the United States It amal-
gamated with other locals as the current Asbestos
Workers Union in 1912. The stability of this union has been reflected in the stability of its membership rolls Once a pipecoverer always a pipecoverer has been of epidemiological importance to us and has made this group of men particularly suitable for the study of term effects of asbestos inhalation Unlike unskilled workers exposed to asbestos inhalation in poorly paid industries
there is little labor turnover among insulation workers Accurate employment records are main-
tained by the union which has also been concerned with health problems in the industry
The trade was badly hit during the depression some men had to drop out and very few were added during the 1930's By the end of 1942 the union rolls consisted mainly of men with considerable experience plus a few who joined in 1940
1941 and 1942. Between 1946 and 1962 union
membership increased substantially Source of From union records a list was
prepared of every individual who was a member
of either of the metropolitan locals on Dec 31 1942 or who joined between that date and Dec 31 1962. No one was omitted whatever his subse-
quent work history The 1942 list included 632 men 890 men joined after 1942
Personal data were obtained from union records
and the work history of each man was detailed including withdrawal from employment war_ser- war_service other employment retirement illness These
data gave the baseline for calculation of the onset
and duration of exposure For members who had died records of the Health and Welfare Fund pro-
vided date and place of death Copies of death
certificates were obtained on all but one of them
Autopsy protocols histological specimens and hos-
pital records were obtained and reviewed in those
deaths approximately one half in which the terminal illness had occurred in a hospital
Statistical Previous studies have suggested that neoplasia associated with asbestosis sel-
dom occurs until 20 years after first exposure to as-
bestos dust Therefore we decided to limit the
present analysis to men with such an exposure
history Our complete records cover all members
of the union including active and retired mem-
bers both dead and alive during the year
period from Jan 1 1943 through Dec 31 1962
However with few exceptions the only men with
a history of 20 years or longer since first exposure
to asbestos were the 632 men on the union rolls as
of Jan 1 1943. The exceptions were a few men
who joined the union after Jan 1 1943 but who had been employed previously as asbestos workers
elsewhere , 1963
Of these 632 men 255 died before Jan
Table Years of Experience of 632 Asbestos Workers Exposed to Asbestos Dust 20 Years or Longer
-
Age
35-39
40-44
2
oe.
45-445-499
ne
50-54
=...
55-59
we
60-64
65-69 70.74
ss
.
i
ae
75-79
84
Lo.
85-
sae
19431947
85.0
| 230
339 391.5 382.0
221.0 1390
830 315
5
35
Years
1948-
1952
~
~
1953
1957
185.0
70
486.5
2915
324.0
530
364.0
390.0
308.C 316
341.5
344
181.0
2860
115.5
1370
70
705
185
38
2.0
----
sy
19581962
11.0 700 314.5 502 5 268.5 255.0 280.0 1975 75.0 23.5 135
Totals
16
|.
1,912.0
2,478.0
2,336.5
2,011.0
Of these 632 men 339 had been exposed to asbestos dust prior to 1924. In other words as of Jan 1 1943 20 years or longer had elapsed since these 339 men were first exposed The remaining 293 men reached the exposure point at some time after Jan 1 1943 and before the end of 1962. The 339 men who were first exposed prior to 1924 were counted in each of the 20 years or up to the time of death of those who died The 293 who were first exposed in 1924 or later were counted only after they reached the sinceexposure point those who died being dropped at the time of death When the statistics were completed we found that we had records covering a total of 8,737.5 years of experience of men
with a history of 20 years or longer since first
exposure to asbestos dust
Of the 8,737.5 years 1912.0 were in the five-
year period 1943-1947 2,478.0 were in the period 1948-1952 2,336.5 were in the period 1953-1957 and 2,011.0 were in the period 1958-1962 Table 1
shows the age distribution of the years in
each of these year periods Table 2 shows 1 the average specific death rates of all US white males during each of these periods and 2 the average specific death rates from cancer of the lung pleura mediastinum and trachea among US white males during each period as reported by
the US National Office of Vital Statistics
The years were then multiplied by the corresponding reported US death rates to ascertain the expected number of deaths under the null hypothesis that the death rates of asbestos workers
do not differ from death rates of all US white
males both age and date being taken into consid-
eration The results are summarized in Table 3
Results
Total During the first five years 19431947 only 28 deaths occurred among the asbestos workers whereas 39.7 deaths would have occurred had their specific death rates been the same as for all US white males during those years Ta-
ble 3 In other words at the start of the study
the asbestos workers had below average death
rates This is by no means surprising Indeed such
143
24
ASBESTOS EXPOSURE ET AL
JAMA April 6 1964
Table Total Deaths and Deaths From Cancer of the Lung Bronchus Pleura Mediastinum and Trachea per.10,000 White Males per Year
1943-1947
Total
Lung Cancert
36
oe
55
1
1948-1952
Total 30
Lung Cancert
48
1
1953-1957
1958-1962
Total
26
Lung Cancert *~~ Total
25
Lung Cancert
1
43
I
42
}
133 196 295 435 634 977 1,453
2,422
4
124
5
189
7
281
7
417
166
605
166
915
166
1,353
3
2.162
5
115
6
116
7
8
178
10
178
1
10
276 272
11
416
17
418
21
11
586
16
607
21
878 ne
B
1,346
12
7
2,017
9
866 ce
1.363
2.148
Ca
35 11
Death rates as reported annually by the US National Office of Vital Statistics A year average is given here for each period Average
for 1958-1962 is a projection of 1958-1960 since 1961-1962 rates are not yet available Death rates include cancer of the fung bronchus pleura mediastinum and trachea assigned to international list code No. 47b prior
to 1949 and to No. 160-164 thereafter
&.
rides r
Peed .
SS
ena)
en
SNe .
is almost always found in the first few years of a
prospective epidemiological study of this type The explanation is almost certainly as follows The 632 men in this analysis were actively employed as asbestos workers in 1942. Since disability from illness or other causes precludes employment in a trade of this type these men were presumably well or at least not disabled at the start of the study pe-
riod Almost any group so selected as to exclude
the ill and disabled has a lower death rate during the ensuing few years than does the general population since ill and disabled persons have extremely high death rates A selective effect of this type gradually wears off with time and largely disap
pears within five to ten years from the time of in-
itial selection
During the second year period 1948-1952 the death rate of the asbestos workers was slightly higher than the death rate of all US white males ie 54 observed deaths compared with 50.8 expected deaths In later periods the death rate of the asbestos workers was proportionately higher For the period 1953-1957 there were 85 observed deaths compared with 56.6 expected deaths and for the period 1958-1962 there were 88 observed deaths compared with only 54.4 expected deaths
Table Observed and Expected Number of Deaths Among 632 Asbestos Workers Exposed to Asbestos Dust 20 Years or Longer
Cause of Death
1943
1943 1947
Total all causes .
asbestos
Observed asbestos workers
Expected US white males
28 39.7
Total cancer all sites 2... Observed asbestos workers Expected US white males
13 5.7
Cancer of lung and pleura
.
Observed asbestos workers
Expected US white males
568 0.8
Cancer of stomach rectum
colon
workers
and
)
Observed asbestos workers Expected US white males .
2.0
Cancer of all other sites com-
bined
:
workers
Observed asbestos workers
Expected US white males
AsbestosIS
'
ie
crane
Observed asbestos workers
3 2.9
Years
1948-
1948- 1953 1952 1957
54
85
50 17
56 26
8.1
8
14
13.0 13
2.0
4 2.5
7 26
5
4.28.45.0 4.28.45.0
6
4.28.45.0 4.28.45.0
1958 Total 1958 19431962 1962
88
255
54 39
203.5 95
9.7 18
36.5 45
24
66
14 2.3
29 94
7
4.28.45.0 4.28.45.0
21
20.5 12
Cancer of the Lung Pleura and Trachea each of the four year periods far more deaths from cancer of the lung and pleura occurred among the asbestos workers than would have oc-
curred had their death rates from these diseases
been the same as for all US white males Table 3 Altogether 45 of the 632 asbestos workers died of
cancer of these sites whereas only 6.6 such deaths would be expected from general US experience Of these 45 deaths 42 were recorded as due to
bronchogenic carcinoma and 3 to neoplasms of the pleura The pleural neoplasms were all recorded
as mesotheliomas
Thus it was found that the death rate from can-
cer of the bronchus and pleura was 6.8 times as high among these asbestos workers as in the general US white male population both age and date being taken into consideration
It may be asked whether the high rate of lung
cancer among these asbestos workers could pos-
sibly be attributed to an unusually large proportion
of cigarette smokers among them We cannot answer this question directly since we have not yet
been able to ascertain the smoking habits of the men who died However the following pieces of evidence indicate that unusual smoking habits cannot account for the high death rate from lung can-
cer among these workers
We have interviewed 320 of the 377 surviving members of the 1942 group Table 4 gives a summary of the smoking habits in this group compared
with a sample of men drawn from the general population of 1,121 counties in 25 states The un-
ion sample is somewhat inadequate since it does
not include the men who died and does not in-
clude all of the present living members of the
union Nevertheless it shows that a substantial
proportion of asbestos workers never smoked ciga-
rettes regularly Certainly the 632 men in our analysis of death rates were not all heavy cigarette
smokers
In the general male population cancer death rates are about ten times as high among cigarette smokers as among nonsmokers and the
ead
Nene 144 thes
". Vol188No I
ASBESTOS EXPOSURE ET AL
25
FE
-|
Table Smoking Habits of 320 Abestos Workers Exposed to Asbestos Dust 20 Years or Longer
Compared With Sample of Men From the General Population
ee
Smoked
. Never Smoked
Pipe Cigar
Regularly
Asbestos
Regularly
Never Cigarettes
ee ee ne
a
History of
Cigarette Smoking
oars
Asbestos Workers
General Population
Asbestos Workers
ce
ce
Bc
Age 9.3 Ro
1049 50-59
% 4.6
6.1
General Population
Population
7.5 __
9.9
:
Asbestos Workers
85.1
79.6
General Population
737
-
70.2
____
60-69
70+
__ 20.3
25.5
23.6
37.1
30.1 11.8
16.2 23.9
69.7
62.7
60.2
390
Sample of men from general population as reported by Hammond and Garfinkel
death rate from lung cancer increases greatly with
posure to asbestos by insulation workers as stud-
the amount of cigarette smoking However a large
ied here results in a marked increase in the inci-
proportion of all men in the United States have a history of regular cigarette smoking From data in
dence of cancer of the lung approximately six to seven times the expected incidence Altogether
a prospective study on smoking it may be esti-
45 17.6 of 255 men with more than 20 years
mated that if all men smoked a pack or more of
elapsed since the onset of exposure died of cancer
cigarettes a day ie if all the nonsmokers cigar
of the lung or pleura
smokers pipe smokers and light cigarette smokers had instead been heavy cigarette smokers the cancer death rate would be approximately
These data do not give the incidence of cancer of the lung in asbestosis They relate to the specific conditions of our investigation to a group of
3.4 times as high as it is at this time
men with only intermittent exposure to materials
From this we may conclude that even if all our
containing limited amounts often % to 20 of
e asbestos workers had smoked a pack or more of
asbestos under working conditions varying from
cigarettes a day and indeed from our sample we
very dusty as in extracting old insulation in closed
ww know they did not and if exposure to asbestos quarters to those with little dust exposure as in
were of no significance then their lung cancer
building construction in open air Moreover they
death rate would have been about 3.4 times as
relate to the relatively recent past in a trade with
high as the rate in the general US male popula-
the shorter work week of the strong building trades
tion Clearly the smoking habits of the asbestos
unions in an era when industry has been aware
workers cannot account for the fact that their lung-
of potential asbestos hazard and the working popu-
cancer death rate was 6.8 times as high as that of
lation has had some consciousness of potential
white males in the general population
risk associated with dust exposure These data
Gastrointestinal Cancer to our surprise
would not necessarily apply to asbestos exposure
the death rate from cancer of the stomach and the
in other industries such as the factory production
death rate from cancer of the colon and rectum
of asbestos products the asbestos textile industry
were higher among the asbestos workers than
etc where conditions of employment might be
would be expected from the rates reported for the
quite different Our results do not contradict the
US white male population calculated in the same
even higher incidence of lung cancer suggested in
way as for lung cancer Twelve deaths from gastric
other studies ; they are merely a shade less strik-
cancer occurred among the asbestos workers as compared with only 4.3 expected Seventeen deaths from cancer of the colon and rectum occurred
among the asbestos workers as compared with 5.2
expected Cancer of All Other Sites combined death
rate from cancer of all sites other than lung and pleura and stomach colon and rectum was not increased Twenty such deaths occurred among asbestos workers as compared with 20.5 expected
AsbestosOifs the 255 deaths 12 were due to
asbestosis pulmonary insufficiency cor pulmonale The lapsed time from first asbestos exposure to death from asbestosis averaged 45.8 years with
ing
Diffuse Pleural and Peritoneal Malignancy Mesothelioma the incidence of diffuse pleural mesothelioma is complicated by the insecurity of its histological verification While some pathologists will so categorize a high proportion of diffuse pleural tumors in the experience of others it is a very rare tumor and may be mimicked by anaplastic peripheral carcinoma of the lung and diffuse fibrosarcoma of the pleura It is difficult to evaluate completely the published reports of diffuse pleural mesothelioma in asbestosis in the absence of complete details of each case
a range of 32 to 59 years
To the present time there has been no informa-
Comment
tion concerning the incidence of diffuse pleural mesothelioma in asbestosis since the published
Carcinoma of the Lung results with regard
cases are reported without reference to a total pop-
to carcinoma of the lung are clear Industrial ex-
ulation in which they occur Nevertheless the
145
"
26
ASBESTOS EXPOSURE ET AL
JAMA April 6 1964
growing number of reports of individual cases
suggests that these tumors are perhaps becoming relatively frequent complications of asbestos ex-
posure
Our observations in this series are similarly suggestive In three of the 255 deaths among the men
who had worked for 20 years or more the exam-
ining pathologist considered the death due to diffuse pleural mesothelioma and in the two cases in which we have been able to review the histological material the histological appearance was that often so categorized and asbestos bodies were pres-
ent This incidence of more than % of deaths
from pleural mesothelioma is strikingly high for a tumor which is generally considered to be extremely rare In one case in our series pathological examination suggested diffuse peritoneal mesothelioma This single experience is too fragmentary for
evaluation
Gastrointestinal Carcinoma instances of
gastrointestinal carcinoma in the presence of asbestosis have been known but there have been no data to indicate that these were more than coincidental findings Among the asbestos workers studied here cancer of the stomach colon and
rectum was three times as frequent as expected These data suggest that there may perhaps be an etiological relationship between industrial asbestos exposure and carcinoma of the gastrointestinal
tract
Environmental Asbestos Exposure recent
demonstration
by
South
African *
and
British
British
in-
vestigators of pleural and peritoneal neoplasms
among individuals who had chance environmental
exposure to asbestos many years before raises the
very important question of possible widespread
carcinogenic air pollution The possibility of environmental exposure has long been known Soon
after the initial clarification of asbestosis as a clinic
"
entity Haddow demonstrated asbestos bodies in
a man not employed in the industry but living next
door to an asbestos factory This finding was later mirrored in the finding of chronic beryllium dis-
ease among residents of a community near a beryllium factory What is new however is an appre-
ciation of the potential
Thomson and associates
extent of the problem
*
have reported the fre-
quent findings of asbestos bodies in the lungs of urban dwellers Among 6,312 individuals rayed
in an area about an asbestos mine in Finland
13
Kiviluoto found 499 cases of pleural calcification
of the type characteristically seen among asbestos
workers without obvious cause In a comparable
area without any asbestos mine no cases were
found among 7,101 persons rayed It should be
noted that these were not people who worked in
the none but rather were farmers
housewives and others who lived in the general
location In one subject who came to autopsy
polarized microscopy demonstrated asbestos
fibers in the lung Similarly the lung of a cow graz-
ing near the mine also showed the presence of
asbestos
A particular variety of environmental exposure
may be of even greater concern Asbestos exposure
in industry will not be limited to the particular craft that utilizes the material The floating fibers do not respect job classifications Thus for example insulation workers undoubtedly share their exposure with their workmates in other trades
intimate contact with asbestos is possible for electricians plumbers metal workers steamfit-
ters laborers carpenters boiler makers and foremen perhaps even the supervising architect should
be included
1E 100th St New York 10029 Dr. Selikoff
This study was supported by the Health Research Councal of the City of New York
Cooperating in this investigation were the executive officers of the International Association of Heat and Frost Insulators and Asbestos Workers Washington DC and the officers and membership of the New York and Newark NJ
locals of this Union
References
1. Lynch K.M. and Smith W Pulmonary Asbestosis Carcinoma of Lung in Silicosis Amer J Cancer 56-64 May 1935
2. Annual Report of Chief Inspector of Factories for Year 1955 London Her Majesty's Stationery Office 1956 cmnd 8 P 206
3. Doll R Mortality From Lung Cancer in Asbestos Workers Brit J Industr Med 81-86 1955
4. Bohlig H. and Jacob C Neue Gesichtspunkte ^...ber den Lungenkrebs der Asbestarbeiter Deutsch Med Wschr 231-233 Feb 17 1956
5. Braun D.C. and Truan T.D Epidemiological Study of Lung Cancer in Asbestos Miners AMA Arch Industr
Health 634-653 June 1958
6. Wagner J.C Sleggs C.A. and Marchand P Diffuse Pleural Mesothelioma and Asbestos Exposure in North Western Cape Province Brit J Industr Med 260-271
1960
7. Hammond E C. and Garfinkel .: Smoking Habits of
Men and Women J Nat Cancer Inst 419
44A2ug 1961
8. Hammond E.C. and Horn D Smoking and Death Rates Report on Forty Months of Follow of 187 783 Men I. Total Mortality II Death Rates by Cause JAMA 1159-1172 March 8 1294-1308 March 15
1958
9. McCaughey WT.E. Wade O.L and Elmes P.C Exposure to Asbestos Dust and Diffuse Pleural Mesothelio
mas Brit Med J 1397 Nov 24 1962
10. Haddow A.C. in Report of Annual Meeting of British Medical Association Manchester 1929 Lancet 230-231 Aug 3 1929
11. Chesner C Chronic Pulmonary Granulomatosis in Residents of Community Near Berylium Plant Threc Autopsied Cases Ann Intern Med 1028-1048 June 1950
12. Thomson J.G. Kaschula R.O.C and MacDonald R.R Asbestos as Modern Urban Hazard S Afr Med J 77-81 Jan 19 1963
13. Kiviluoto R Pleural Calcification as Roentgenologic
Sign of Occupational Endemic Anthophyllite tosis Acta Radiol Suppl 194 pp 1-67 1960
146
VOL 188 NO 1
Annual Convention
WEDK
BRARY
San Francisco Calif # WEDK
APR APR
BRARY
BRARY
June 21-25 1964 |
Advance Registrations and Housing Form p 283
ORIGINAL CONTRIBUTIONS
DIAGNOSIS OF BONE METASTASIS BY PHOTOSCANNING
M. Sklarua MD and
D. Charkes MD Plutadelphia
RETURN OF RENAL FUNCTION AFTER URETERAL Alexander Brunschwig MD H. R. K. Barber MD and Steart Roberts MD New York
OCCLUSION
EVALUATION OF PATIENTS WITH BASE
J 5. McDonal~-kD. Laughin 45 and G. Bedell MD Jowa City luma
IMBALANCE
CIGARETTE SMOKING CHRONIC BRONCHITIS
IS Mirebell MD T.
Vincem MD
F. MD an Gd . F. FilFlilleey y MD DenDevnveerr
VEIN SURGERY
K. Lofgren MD Rochester Mian
AND
EMPHYSEMA
ASBESTOS EXPOSURE AND NEOPLASIA
1. J. Solikoff MD Jacufa i burg MD and
2. Hammond Ps New York
,
WORK PHYSIOLOGY IN HEALTH
E. aongaoanga UD , Los AngAngelees les
AND
DISEASE
NORTH AMERICAN LOXOSCELISM
C. J. Dillaka MD G. 3. Jansen 3D
M
and C. R. Hayden MD L^/rdeRock Ark
Honeycu11 MD
.
SYMPOSIUM ON STEATORRHEA
LABORATORY AIDS IN DIAGNOSIS OF STEATORRHEA M. Et Kalser MD PhD Coral Cablen Fla
METHODS OF SMALL BOWEL H. J. Balt MD Ann Arbor Mich
BIOPSY
GLUTEN DIET FOR NONTROPICAL SPRUE
Kurtz J. MD 1. M. Ruffin MD 5. M.
{
W Bath MD and W. M.
MD L. Borland Jr. Roofsil MD Durham NC
INTERPRETATION OF INTESTINAL MUCOSAL BIOPSIES Margot Shiner MRCS LRCP DCH London
SPECIAL COMMUNICATION
THE ANESTHETIST AS A PHYSICIAN K. Brecher MD H. H. Bendizen MD Phillips Hallowell MD Henning Pontoppidan MD and D. P. Todd MD Boston
CLINICAL SCIENCE
EPSILON AMINOCAPROIC COAGULATION AND FIBRINOLYSIS
3. H. Lewis MD and A.
Dovle MD Pitisburgh
SPECIAL CONTRIBUTION
A TALE OF TWO LANTERNS F Ebaugh MD Denver
NEGATIVE RESULTS
1
INTRAVENOUS METHO^ ARBAMOL
69
W. Shaftan MD and
5
Horace Herbsman MD Brooklyn NY
EDITORIALS
9
APRIL 4 IS MISSING
2
THE MOST POTENT DIURETIC
R
12
pH and CO2 IN RESPIRATORY FAILURE
70
LORD LISTER 1827-1912
72
17
CLINICAL NOTES
22
PHEOCHROMOCYTOMA WITHOUT
HYPERTENSION
74
27
M. Kahn MD and
D. ^ Mullon MD Tucson Ariz
33
SERUM POTASSIUM AND
'
URETERAL PERISTALSIS
76
William Samuellas MD and
H. H. LeVeen MD Brooklyn NY
CONGENITAL PERICARDIAL DEFECT
78
37
F. D. Fisher MD and
J. .. Ehrenhaft MD Towa City Iowa
40
FLUORESCEIN STAINING OF THE CORNEA
81
\ C. Holland MD Greenville SC
42 LABIAL MUCOUS SALIVARY
GLANDS IN CYSTIC FIBROSIS
83
L. H. Meskin DDS Belly Bernard MD
45
and W. J. Warwick MD Miancapolis
CONTENTS CONTINUED
Adv Page 5
49
56
Sg.
Als 64
Als ABV3317 Als Poth iss.
ABV3317 ABV3317
as jaar