Document KRJXyXYyzNB2VoyYDMngY0dw0

PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATIONP. 0. Box 8361 Engineering, Manufacturing, and Technology Services So. Chas., WV 25303 Central Engineering BUSINESS CONFIDENTIAL June 15, 1987 TO: L. E. Calvert S. W. Clark G. B. Elder R. H. Engle S. S. Murphree COPY TO: E. M. Bartrug, Jr. D. J. Dickson P. D. Franson G. E. Garrett T. E. Martin 3. A. Reynolds J. E. Sanders FROM: C. C. Neely SUBJECT: Background Data Next Task Group Meeting July 23. 1987 As mentioned In my May 18, 1987 transmittal to you, one of the agenda Items for our July 23 meeting will be action plan development for asbestos-containing materials other than gaskets and packing that are used In the C&P work place. The attached listing published by the Alternative Materials Institute will hopefully provide a fairly complete listing by categories of the various products that we must consider In our action plan development. This will supplement the article entitled "Alternatives to Asbestos" that Larry recently submitted to us. As discussed with some of you, I have arranged to have Kart Schmidt from the Cleveland GRAFOIt" factory participate In our meeting and lead a discussion of the various GRAF0IL~ gasket products and their limitations. Karl Is an Application Representative and should be able to help us factually address questions regarding the trade-offs associated with their various gasket products as a function of service conditions. By copy of this memorandum, Messrs. Bartrug, Dickson, Garrett and Martin are requested to send a representative or representatives to this meeting to participate In the GRAFOIL" gasket style trade-off discus sions. The action plans that I hope will result from the discussions led by Karl Schmidt are ones relating to the use of GRAFOIL"* gaskets In: UCC 0012746 Memo -2- June 15, 1987 pumps and other commonly used machinery Items; and control systems equipment. As requested earlier, please transmit meeting agenda Items to me by Monday, July 6. Many thanks. CCN:aa Attachments 49171 . Neely UCC 0012747 APPENDIX I Mtfll _____ALTERNATIVE MATERIAI5 INSTITUTE AMERICAN SUPPLIERS OF NON-ASBESTOS PRODUCTS December 17, 1986 BOTE The attached list of questions and products was prepared by ICF, the contractor doing EPAfs economic analysis related to the asbestos rulemaking. AMI is providing this list as a service to its members, but in doing so, AMI does not suggest that all of the information requested should be shared among the members of the Institute, Some of ICF's questions relate to product prices, costs, market shares and the like. Although the information is needed by EPA, such data should not be shared among the members for antitrust reasons. We are currently developing mechanisms by which members may provide this information to EPA without sharing it with one another. AMI018LQP 60S Fourteenth Street, NW. Suite 900. Washington. DC 20005 . Telephone 202 737-1419 UCC 0012748 , . g . (l le a questions asked fo r drum brake lin in g s . e h ic le s answer v e -road pleas f f , o s) and th re e severe braking ca te g o rie a ra ilro a d c a rs , Foe th e fo u r p rim a ry usea o f brake b lo c k # i tru c k a and uck r ) t ts g je inin g. m . (e and t ra f in g c g a ir lo g m 2 o 2 Sa-S sS s U M m Qt no IH *m> A3 u fL W n Omx C 0 O* -A4--(1 0 a hC 4-2 2 o* c c9u ^ O ? O Wir -X*h Uhd w g ? o JC M x * o M -*H O O ftu " % u < *>l --*30 --Pc "O HoOc 3 0 0 UV It -- 5 Mw H <W 0 CO' *5 0 0 ?m 9 m X 9 g a 9 JW 52 iOu v t0> 0 v `rCoi ** w two? Oa Jcoo I? --06 0* *0< H30 * -. E a * x W a % 2 t .* a, V --0>1 o * a O C J V6i 0 O Cw w %O4 pHO ^ a w 5? V > -- 2 50 o0 Mo -* 3 pH y * 0 a O' pH U 3ffi -2H 0--V 000 X X 0 m 8v * 0 --U U *H x9m x H3 W M O H o Or 9 xau 3 s. U 0 s 503 ?--0 w *. TJ o O C 0 c*n -<0M* --*O0* tw u O< O *> *O*~i Qi 0W 0u 0 B w 0a u 0a J0J -0w i-0> 0 S ^ 0s x *HI 2m 1s 2* 00 00 my *oH 4J +> ? 1-4 E c S'? 0- 0 0-4 00 MO iVt V0 %i 0<ii o 0W O 00 0 O H it U ->< nOu 0 U a-< 0 3oU 0 0 1* jj 8 0 0 0< .*4 >i Vc h* -oC U Vo00 --0 0 10-i 0-i 0 V J0 a 8" 0 Eu 0o om o ii -0&kI-iI --%oC4 w0ek0> 0&oC 00 H 21 *3 4i >1 O *co w* *I*M4 C X A -o t) a >- %d . ^ 9n XA0l jj E O p*H|*HH c*! c E ImO ^c 00 +> it >. X ou it *-n a^ m 9 -4*J 4J O_ #M -* O' w it ~4 O 0 0b 0 X 9 0 0 > C E 0 U -- 3--0 3s,? e u m m >4 0 W> -- 0> 0 JD u ?O xX o 0X 00 --0 030 0tu 41 8 2 w a 41 9 41 H 4> B X 9 r* y 4J OO r> 9 b 0 Or fk 0 --00 4O> 5 o0 -24 .2 v00 0 O0 -- Jr * S a5 *2o 4 -*0c^04p b0 --M> b fX W 0V ?** 9c bb 00 o-- <*4 Xa --0>3 --CO0-OCr 0e --o0 0 - w N 0 --U -24 <-- v0 w O' 0 ftsJ -- E -- 0 TJ O a. 0 uO N^ o rXH O0 -- 3-- C f. H O 3 y* E00 25 0 0 0H 3b w C rH _ ^ b. Ob pH 0 -- t2 = L> p V. --* 0t3> 0 --Ct> OS 0 0 0 0 0c OB'-- -- --0 0 .00> E 0 ac 0 0 0O < NO. --' -- O 3 ----y a 0 0 50 0 --co C 0 * --0 O' 010 *0 0CVOC --C --0 822--EI 0 c --C B> E, O O t0n -- <z i iu <w g SVi MI m n ox u m aw aM m2 2 m m < U s. V * -} M J5 i 0p0i m 2 < Serai-w etalllea HAO (non-asbeatoa o rg a n ic ) com bination o f K e v la rR, fib e rg la s s , and/or m ineral fib e r fttake block8 UCC 0012749 la anyone producing or im porting asbestos rollboard? o Xl t XI | b 3 >< C -4 C -4 ttt ~fb4t X3ftI c 3 \\ 0X W3 sr.3(T ft XI ft x> ft si3 ft Q. ' ft XI b f1t E xl 0 e b ft ft *-4 g 0 ?40 O ft ft b ftS c CL x o o ft 0 O ft *4 ft 04 O ft *4 *V Xl O b >i x> ua o > 0 TJ ft b ft >. xl ba o 0a <XI 4 ft It S.& to to V ft ft g> ft C -4 ft ft c C - i xi "Ei4 aO ? .0 *4 0 t t> x-fIti uoft 3 I* OVHMO xftl w jf XI w je a c o *t o ft 0 Is* H x 3 iu xflt ft O Jt bb XI ft Jt ft ft Xl ft eft ec 4O*4 0 ^4 ft XI xl * ft ft b 0 0 -- IS U ft X. <-4 E b ft ft 0 ft Jt M ft ft b & ft ft ft ft xi x> O xl lb 0 0 X 0 x> X * 0 Xi ^ft Cft fEt ug u ft Q. ft xfbt fet Eb b E ft a 44 ^ *i u ft -4 3b c -- ft U to o ^ 0 n b >. ? S0 ft ft c X O ft > XI --4 ft XI 00 > Xi ftl 0 <0 0x4 o o C *M r1 5o (I H VI M ft ft w >ft b Ml O x) H <M f>t b bft *fCt ~O ft b O XI lb a w 3 C- 0 hi -J <-- *o O bJ5 - fl IU 81 O ft O *-4 ft ft b ft ft xl U (b O0 H fftt b ft xOi ft C ft C O -H x> -< ft C XI w- -- C -4 ft ft b4 b aft- - cc ft b4 O C C -4 ft 4 XI -( C O' ft ft C b XI fUt xC4 C_ ft ft -x to 0 5 ?S o c c * a r b P +i x Xi c 0 ft XjjI m bx a X> 00 3 4J3 --. hi xi 3x o^ C Cb W 0 -4 ft +o* 0 XI XI ft b a ba o ft ba * X3I ft ft xi O x0 0 Xi Xi 3 0 Xi Ua 0 0 b sr*1n X> x> (S ft ft ft ft C xl ft ft <D5 b xl XI ft x i ft ft ft C 41 ft <o ft V V Jt ft ft ft o 4) 0 -4) c xi ft E O X *-4 0 ft b *b XI u a fiti a ft! *< X) Xi 0 xi 0 0 0XX Mc <w oo x3! x4 (b Xi X C H b < O O 3 44 b4 b c 6. i- O 0 3 -< ft -4 ft ft O V SMU M XI > XI 3 X3 0 *00 0 0 Xi H 00 O 0 u 0 0X Xi X4 00 m C Ho 3W a 4^* OS 0 Cue 0 0*>^ E Sib b K V0 O *4 ^ _oe *8 c * VQ * ft-i Q O Xi 0 Ecc --' c -- O b b*-- cr 4^ ub b Z " *4 *1 ^0 W C to 0 0> H --C 8 5* Kb Ob b \0 40 0C0 o o #H -- 0 8Xi 0 00 -- e -- 9* ^ 0X W oS22 <0-b-b --X -- 4. W .IU c ob a c zs V E t bEft Eft to U) 0 "*- 1c 0 a 0 "O -- 4*. C ft 0to u X O' ft 3* w 1 b r ib r fr a x paper (5S0 & 570) Kaowool R ollboard Ceramic paper R ollboard UCC 0012750 A r* th e re o th e r fib e r s th a t can be used in re p la c e ment products fo r asbestos te x tile s o th e r than fib e rg la ss, ceram ic/refractory s ilic a , carbon/ g ra p h ite , aram id, and RBI? V O ii b 43 f b F a4 2 O ^ xi S S DC 8tt m - W 4 i) lJ Xi xi -4 0 XI -4 4 H 0 W *4 4 64 & %Zo -- m it -4 a o Iu 0 xui au xai a n0 C-H J V -O0r-i.>ObfHi NScb F 4 o bE b b 9 a p* *o I 6C a i F 0 x*>l m *sO4 s v x*l >. u Or ** ^3 L> x> XI H 00 u5 4 o -4 -C -< ZE m - sV 3 3 b xi C X* -4 xl xl xi a xi e m * 3b3 5 a3a 3 0. b XI a-- a xi XaI fb Z5 3 --C o C CW 4 4> B4 H IM 4 o B 2 B 4 >t C F M ft 0 F a4 8 F M Oi N 4 BH 4 lU H4 tf <*4 M 44 4H > eo K If o* r-1 W o| O O F& 4 V 0 Cc 44 X jj 4 (V 44 HNu 0 0 9 3 0V M4 W w n? 9 4* i9f 0 U X 4 0 X g --* 3 u 9 u4 B SF ^ V0i W 4 C. B* 4 O xi O o 9 0 *- *8 . S3 O a v *o UM 4H 40 4 F8 MO<M IM IM 04 ^U H CH 4 4 4 0 e- m E M X u w 44 g CO Cw r a0 I W *H z s fc. ac b xi E <-i ti xl E u -i >. aa <H ha H t) I CT> --< *1 bC *i a cr O' b b H O W baalOf O' X tcoc *+ x b> oa *a. b xc* a3-u4o30o sca a K b aaa ba - HU X 3 w pt O 0 b 41 -aOsH. oxcasi Ub -4 e a-a4 >&p>H, SI et o W -H 4 >H W 00 ac O &> a F -4 0 O ^ *4H 4 3 44 40 MO O p3 rlb e tq L a a s Ceram ic/Refractory s ilic a C arbon/graphite Aramlds ^batoE ta x tlla a UCC 0012751 QUESTIONS 1 r# -04 \ jJ a #-i mo X) +> * AJ f*- a a O' 0c a o a> a o a A a Xe oa 4D Va a > <*4 aj a a a u a o o a c 4J a A> o wa a aa 04 0 a w w a A IM u a o o > a y aj a M o a u Al M WH m a a a a 0 4 > w i-t a .c a a a aK H A> y g a a lu o aa aj *j a > -4 a A> a AJ a a wo a 2 AJ a JS 8 a tj a m 0 uu <0 8 2 0 <M 2 A H 2 \W Q a A* O' o a 9 % a *2 o a* A# m a a o +i 1 a A/ aa T"l ^ *4 O' p4 m A* a 9 A* 2 *4 co Al w a Si o o p4 **4 AJ dD c& *o **4 a o \ -04 A4 a A * aa 9a c u aa * sAJ JS M fw r- A ax a* o u A> Irf a u 8 O -rs 0. O aM y A> H a> 9 a A a hi tt A* aE AJ m A# 9 j* ahi 6 AJ a x5 i a > o X A y SA a 3A c w 0 D C IM <M * 0 t fw c& ao o u ^4 *s. -M 0u< a a y ar4 0 a a a a m *> a M 0H a1 0 oo cn H a | OV Ai 3 V 9* Li M 1 -e 4 Li s* a O a 0 a m* a. aN 4 a A> w 09 k 90 0 M w Ot O & 4*4 CL A> D At M Ai c a CL c -i-i c u 30o o V o CJ a > o 44 a % v a H o 9 a *m a c A* a a A> a ^4 A> A> a c aJ fv. 0 0 m a 4> 0 9 < a 9 a 0H aC *04 a m c aj a AJ w aa s m 0 c a hi a 44 A> f hi 0 M <M At oc IM #4 * a P* a M a W 0 mi 0 M A> i1 9 M aM EaUa E 0 S. a n +J a a0 u Al a f* m a jj 0# hi 0 aa aM u s & TJ O' a m4 a aM a u a a*04 c Ma o. a ov A> Va Li O' <0 r^ M aa i o o tft 'I *04 0 ^4 a 9 Oa M W9 O0 T-l 0 aa uE a 9 IM +> 0a a 0 M C a Al a a m A* 44 a i I TJ i c at 9a cr * a w CL w A> 4^ fs -t*. C Li O e 6 ahi hi C I 2 M >4 5:2 oa a A4 9 o 4J a o M aa ohi a a a a> a M 2 0 r* a u V *8 tt a C p- E a *> m 0 c i a c TJ ot L> ul u w *04 s Li a a NM 9 0 a 2 A* M M 0 AJ a0 0 i> a a 4- w TJ a a oM O N < M O %4 O* 44 P aa uM aM O 00 M a C a hi cL a Ou a 2 Al a 41 VM a a o X0 (4 a*4 a a Ai a 4J a a ^4 H1 -4 Ai T3 a aAP a w 0 -^4 e E 4 Ca a Al a *04 U aa O' a U H #4 u m o* a > TJ *o 9 a i c o e w a m9 AJ 0 0 aM Mo 0 w O' ao fW U IM a AJ CL c M A ua W T' E o hi A> Q. C 6 a y aM a a o* -o M a o ohi O M 0 41 D* At a 4J c a 4 e 41 AJ a w* 'O TJ a p 4J *0 E a 5 a Al a a & hi 5 as ^a4 xa 2 p< 9 | oo *o cs r4 o a 9 n 2 * 0 H X as M 1-4 E H a a At 3 a 9. A* a ft 0 M 0 -4 o 9 m a Ai a <c A* T5 3C Al a m 4J 3 0 m 0*4 4ft <N n t O m a 44 0 I0M ft Mc aa a N r* a c r* Al *4 n N0 0 >4 a Mi a Al a a hi a 2u 2 0 u0 cu o M 2 D 0 0u a b r4 M 0 v4 A* L4 Al 0 c L> O a -4 > 5u 0. a CU X aa> O N *o cN JS >4 H i Si 04 i*> 3 0 SUBSTITUTES KNOW BY ICF ASBESTOS PRODUCTS UCC 0012752 o 0 Cl XI c u 0 s ft* 9 x< H W9 w E 0 0 Cl 9 if X X >i 0 * U 0 X 0 * X4 39 XX ^4 X o N 00 41 X X* 9 Mi X 0 '* 0 3 A1 0 f 9M -b c bo 0> ri XI 0 mc co o - sO x0l 55 xci 0 x> a U \< X 3 0 ^4 X 0 9 u 9 -4 -4 0 x* ^a X 3 ~*44 0a Xl N O 00 3 lb XI 9 X0 X O9 X u w9 0X o -x*l 14 O 9 9 X 3 b xl *M X 44 0 x> 0 bi XX 0 X 00 fr o c n s 4# U O a N 9 XI o < 9 30 X Mi o b xi X X r- c 0 O' X * 3 0 X2 . b N X0 xo O0o fV C 25 S5 Xl a a l X V * 8 c X 44 0 O <* 2D O0 *H4 41 m4 <M 9V 9 WX * *5 9 o 44 0 1 w lou b bl X f8ixSe 0 V0 O b 55 ab. 0e XI 09 44 3O 9 0 0 <* V V XI X 9 9 we W Xxi x*1l dDi D = xe M B0 XI XI 9 b> X 44 Mi * 0 0 O X 0 X S 8. 9X 0 9X 0 a X0 0-4 xl xl XX 44 H 4 w < 3 O 5 55 XcI 8 0 E o0 o s-- b Cl 0 Ct b b. ~* T> 00 0O xl b 0O 0no *0o ~ci -b E M 0 O' 4n1 9c -cb b xl 0 b 0 b tQ Q A 5 a e > x a o r >h --Cl 0>. *<* O Ob o0 0 o 88 o0 0" E bu o u UCC 0012753 0 p4 w 44 t> 9 5 xl X c* Roof C o a tin g * t Cewenta C allulose Fibers Polyethylene Fibers C lay, Talc What percentage o f the ro o f c o a tin g s or cement market is asbestos-free? Are there o th e r s u b s titu te s being used? e 1 i UCC 0012754 in-Roofing (s p e c ia lty ) Adhesives, Sealants C o a tin g s P olyolefins Acamid C ellulose Fumed S ilic a Clay, T a lc , Limestone What o th e r s u b s titu te fib e r s t f i l l e r s are being used in sp e cia lty form ulations? What are th e d iffe re n c e s between s ilic a fib e r s , fumed s ilic a , and sodium s ilic a te s ? Document #30390