Document JNaQ6K8RZbaOeEGBvKm46g6Xv

December 5 1974 M r. F . F . Roasch CTFA SobcemmlUe M illin g on Asbestos in Tale The mealing was held at B rio tn H tfy ers , Hillside on December 4, 1974. Those In attendance Included: D r. Joseph Simka M r. H arold Stanley M r. George Sandtend M r. George Cohort M r. A llan Harvey D r. Robert Rolls D r. George Lee O r. John Travors (C o lg a te ) (P fizer) fjJrlstQ -tyers, Chairm an) (B ristol-M yers) (V anderbilt) (JJ) (J6J) (Avon) JSJ pushed for th e commlite to submit the attached methods for consideration by the FD A . T h is was opposed b y most members (Avon and V an d erb ilt remained n e u tra l) on the grounds that tha w ork hod been performed by only Avon and JSJ. R eportedly, Mennen and Chesebrough-Ponds havo DTA equipm ent but they have not started to examine tha samples. Colgate am i P fize r have D TA equipm ent ordered but as yat do not even know th e dote o f d e liv e ry . t told tha group o f our DTA w o rk at Debell end Richardson w here w * had 3 samples exam ined. F o r c u r inform ation these were Identified as: A #466 Tele- B . $4665 T a le; C . fS09 T a lc . Debet I and Richardson had reported sample nA & ( 60) to contain chrysolite because H had a paak at 8SO degrees C . D r. Hollo felt that thte was not proof o f the presence of chrysolite because there must be two peaks (another at 630 degrees C ) . # e have agreed to subm it another three blind samples to Pebelt S Richardson for additional DTA w o rk. We w ill receive these from Rolls (JfiJ), It was reported b y JSJ and also b y Avon that the FDA has never Identified cbrysatlle In any l i . S . cosmetic ta lc . PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT WCD-321 continued WCD000139 tabbies' December 5, 1974 .j Mr, F . F. Reesch CTFA Subcommittee Meeting on Asber in Talc \. ' Fftzer feels that DTA is being pu -bed by JfiJ because the FDA has similar equipment but they do not have an electron microscope, i foal that Pfizer is correct in this Attitude but two different types of personnel a re involved, tt.iafces much greater skill to operate tha electron microscope than it does to operate the OTA. .7 VJl'j, '.fe *Af,, Reporte+y, the FDA hss commissioned the Franklin Institute* Philadelphia start a research study of asbestos und talc. V 'lP ' m. f h a nftxt meeting to be held at Bristoi-Myors* has been tentatively set for Tuesday February 4* 1975. Irs the meantime, Mr. Sondiand will try to set up ah informations! typo meeting with Borman Estrin ,A . (GTFAi, I RRJi/m w ftsy R. Krammes , ;*S\. i-r. .. <; K,: b \ f-fc ' '. Mk . ' :-''= : - - , ' T . Ly *.% . * * WCD000140