Document JJRN3VLaDgoxY9YQgozZD62N6
Supplement II Presentation of Dr. James T. Trainor J. T. Trainor Testing Co. LLC BMC/SAE J2430 Dynamometer Test Program (Standardized Effectiveness Test for Aftermarket Brake Friction Products) Presented June 4, 2000, at the FMSI Annual Meeting Key Largo, Florida
FMSI--0505
FMSI 01201
T
J
VII
MO J S I| iSs| i Is Sfg3lu.
sg
O
o
VH4I
a 2x
S3
S
z t vi
44"
2 a e X
Sf!
zIII u-i
ft
u
O
SXLI
t
3
o
! 4 > faOt ua
S VI
>o
e
2ft
g
& o
ft
S2
<*
IkI
O a4
B ui
4 F zu H
i N 2 "
XXLLI 3
vi 3
O
> HU<
2: 4
I
VII O
VfI zI
> VzHIII
oI
Z 4X o z z2
gt
hS
oI
Ko-
ui mml 4 5v
O XULI
aHOj
ui ft
O
o
S oo
a aa
XzI
S"
Sg u= 3n Bao
OHVI
>4
o
USIiuOoSoI-
H o
I FH 4 P
> 2 ssS
*BJ
ZIZ-l
*
SXo
sv>i Sui auV)
l4<M
95 2< o
2 ft
HVI **
<
S ui
sa 5i
s
52 VI VI Ji zO h4
ft ui
=u xa "O> aft vI-i Sui 3 Q _vi
Oz HoOw vi 2 a
gSg
UVVVU)III
4
Xo
Ik
MX
vfti
4
oUI
Ul
ik
v4i
UXLJ
oo> oH
VI
OX
<u
;a !
5?
2g ag aa Ok
SI *-O
EH
4
H
ft
O
4
ft
Q
g
O z. ft
aUI a
aUI
zu
g* EH "
I-
IU- 9z
a3
!
s<
v9mi aaa
a4 oui
o
*
X
>
g
9 a
4
U x
S: aa
N
J
FMSI 01202
T
BMC/SAE J2430 DYNAMOMETER TEST PROGRAM
REVIEW & UPDATE FOR FMSI
JUNE 4, 2000 OCEAN REEF CLUB--KEY LARGO, FL.
OUTLINE OF TOPICS
I) WHY A STANDARDIZED EFFECTIVENESS TEST FOR AFTERMARKET BRAKE FRICTION PRODUCTS?
II) KEY PROJECT OBJECTIVES
III) BACKGROUND-KEY EVENTS (1987-1999)
IV) SAE J2430 RECOMMENDED PRACTICE
V) J2430 VALIDATION TESTING
VI) J2430 APPLICATION TO AFTERMARKET PRODUCTS
VII) ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA MEANING? WHAT THEY DO NOT MEAN?
VIII) CURRENT ACTIVITIES AND DIRECTION
IX) SUMMARY
J.T.TRAMOR TESTING CO. LLC RIVENDELL OR.
SHELTON, CT. 0S4S4
-I
IU
o 0
H
S
o H
o 2o oZ a
SIU 2
O PC
o S
0
Sz a
<iu 0fc
Z0
U
> J<
3
O
0z
h
i > z
0u
0 IU
gz0
2-N 303 4ZU
is|
o 1 *0
S3
gx 1
z<
<u
IE1I < s
h
u.
O
s9a u=z 0zu
<
J & >tc. 2*1 5 g<D igg & x z <(/)
s23
u JL < *
t
z
2
iu
a
< 2 HPCI u<.
o h
fac
0
1 PC h)
p
< U
0 t s
OHI
oz
g
0|U
z
2
CL m
IU m
O
o
< IU
3 N
Et Uhi. O tjz 0 0ss3
< PC au
inu J?
mi
o
"25
z
o o
_a Wr*
8 g
822 9IzU 0ao
*
(0
53
j2
< " fc
i0S|
II HI U |1
si;
to* *
** **
g H| i-
70 0
<Z ZHU
3 <o
V0uMIil
2K
*
PC a
cpfc
t> 3
o
Z
J
3
o503
< a Is
Hz
hi
Z<
a
0
<
gZ
iu
3 O
*
*
0
J
THANK YOU
FMSI 01204
"TT
EHICLE CORRELATION
J
>i
Ss sco
X
<
az
s
<0
uCAi
HI
zIU
l>pUIIIbUIkI
HIU x
hIU
xsX<-
XIU
Z
2
cza o P
g
2
Ik 5*
<
X z
PIk
IU
"a
o
po
5 u.
Z oZ
s
(A
oH
ciua
H HZI
H
2* *o
<
<a iozu
<s
OXIIaXUk iu a
s
z
oo
2p a 2< *<
5
a to
Sx
X
<s
aIIH<Uk:
Z< >X s
IU Oo>
CA 3 O z
* *
aH IZU Xiu o> 0
>1 <I-
HI
<
3Ik
*
(0
uj
oO3Ha
*
Si (A SS
*
<0 E
Z Si OX
OX
**
*
(A O
&
a
S o 3
3
3
<
uIU hu
x
x< IU
8
^>"
3
X
Sh
*
2
X yj
82
a ca
g2 i3k
uS IA
A 3 52 a2 >*
SS XUXj OXHI
Xo
ss
oIU
11-1
p
sg CJi"uA Iosk
X
O
" a
<
J
<
Is H HI Si
3K
Ns?S ss iau oz
<CA :
*
*
&
IS
2Z Bg B
=x5 - ik -*
N
FMSI 01205
T
J
IU CO
oz
0 IU
H
z<
< 1s
i
zo . S a co
iio
IU
IU O J Uzo
<3
o6
zoS lit j
CO Z2 IxU fat
J
< hCO
2S ss
<< H iu Z IU " <*2
111 Ik
2Qz
HZ
OuU
LU 0C K.
OO go CM 8
< O
po>
J as <
co ft z
S?EO
^ CO O -J
z<
0 H
zoo
CO u!jg
1 S UI <
5 * iu
CO " as
5 o
^ry Xw3 CO > o
Z IU
JOo
<a CcOo
a*x
s<
!iJ
o
o
41
o
o
ni * *
**
CM CO
T
FMSI 01206
J
IU
X h*
8
IU
sJ FMSI 01207
T
BMC FRICTION MATERIAL COMMITTEE POSITION PAPER
X
J
iis 3 > s J
I 2 S 3 J
z
< UJ
K LU
S
O
UOi
o o o
ui
UI J
<9 z
u UI <
311 o
I
>oX
"<o
OXO
< UI X
h
H UI UI
UI " CO Z
*
it 9
5
< X
<
* III
k o
z
SO J J
UI uj < X
Sttsfid o
S
o
5
<
h
-i J
552
UJI
o
ar<
8tfE_>
less
S j5jj ui S>
ui 5 * 5
o?h
0=0
<
III
Z
g
z
p
*
k
co
CO
5co
c>o
Zg
< X k
>z
lb
CO
CO
X CO
5 0
z
UI
z
III >
k0
k CO
uibi
IUbI
k
Oz
kcUoI
o Q
a
ui
8 ..
CO *
UI ui 5:
3 3 ZZ
X
UI -* 1c1o1
UI
a ucaoi
k
1? Z P
5 Z ui
k u"i
go
2$ 2x
2
eudi
zf<uli
od k
S3 x<
tx
0
*5
a
o
ui 8z
Qd
ui 6<
XZ
Hoz >-O
g
uoi o<
*
5oZ<
FUI "2j
**
<
Oib
ib o ?S CO
5Z
sg
5 J ui
fc a o
fs
OzUXkUC=X<OII OM2OC3aujXgO. ffkkXauC--UQSiOiI cino Zm5T kx 3
Mi Ag B
CgO os O>.
0 XL H UI = o x si
Z Jfl
CO
TM
H--i
E<
2g3
UUhI
X i
Sn Z< oU
N co
k g` .
3
1 u K *g
35
6|
s 0SifcS
k3 &
[U fc!
1 I^ s$-j
0
&
o
k t* 2
5&
Q3
&5K
* Ui ^
5
! 15
FMSI 01208
J
VII) WHAT DOES MEETING ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA MEAN?
HI o
uIII
2
H(AI -I
8$gU< 2
Z
e
I
-j oz
Iok
HI op
Li
i.o
<
o Hi us 8 <S <
z* oS uz zw
HI >
oa oH
z Ik>
a 0iu gK.
>z I=k aH
igg
6Sl"aUt Batl s
s11
1u5
ilHMI
UHi
m
8**ss pg
5 (0 -I 5Z=
iS< com
z 5 d z_
i s s* z 2
S <
S<
2 Z
*o
f t
_
hIH-eI
^
z1
O^ as
O tm
hi Js
ags 21 >h sO
g28oaS
5 a "
*sa
<ao
Ho"I
uW*
o
u
1<00
Hp2 53
III
z111
>
>w S
z Z HI Ik
IUk iig <J
Ba
>= g >; <0 gu j2j a oa "> g" !|3 boz oz
300
22is
HI
. S5 5 IHI i*s i J s2 ** **
pig 2 J HI
5323 >J
Ik HI
o z
z O
WHI S<i 3O
J< zI Co S >
Si
2
5f >us
2t: *
" < zU i
= 0.0
5sS
iiS 0E
1< * g
HI <0
HI o
Z <
>
"
o
ozs
< O Ik
2i
CM CO
FMSI 01209 TT
BMC OBJECTIVE
MATERIAL EFFECTIVENESS,
J
IaU
21
za
-- DC
U&J 1
S id IU ^
>i O *5
UI
u X h g
S
h u Hi a zm
o
a
a HI U
U O z <
a fc; a
iil aIs
IU o 3Z
a
it
< HI
O
a
z" _l a<
a
22 * g 2 ui
aa
Z < fISc
O a *a a H
221*
i>1
9O >a
Oaui ao-- 8
Qa a
a
Ao 1u11 ta aui aa aa is
&
aazHaa
1 oo
sJ<
s
<
2hO
E o giat
0 1
fr w o7 *111 is ^S
al >- u.
< UJ
si
o o <0
IU 5
z o p o iEb o
oIb aIU a
oH M >
t a
IU
a< s
a < u
2
s H So g= a
lg
ho gaj Sa>
fig
agE|
gi *S
a
<
iu
S
a iu
28 Z o iii a
S*
%a aa ao
2 52 a
H wz o
z
86
aP
hi u
oz
*
2
a
2 a
a oib
a a<
aa a<
<2 <a
Ul X H
O Xu
H
FMSI 01210
tr
p
s siuHhn
t1H1c1
SSIII 85S
0 1< z a
oz<aluUe
Oitkc
mu o
Si
UI S si
!*
l!
zu o
ID
>
o
a
>
Co
(i0^^s0
> 3 Ik
SOQ
SHS
OMZ <
oo
o a t* 2
E8
W Ik
"g
HU i
"I
<
s5
0z
oa<
UI
6
P uuZUeiI
ik ik
g
sui
u
S5 2
Si dg;
o is &z
I *Safe N I
auft
32
*
ao< *9
H og
sZUI a. at
if
Jj I
i"
oIU p
s tk o
gs
s* ui
Ct 8
oik t<
azui
aH J
|| s2*ut*ooaaooo<*4
PoUI
K UI
ui H H <UH0I
sUI M u
UI
s mi
|Sp z
ot0Sa
w 3 a
o
8 = aa tt
<o
FMSI 01211
TT
J
FMSI 01212
Ill) KEY EVENTS 1987--19a5
SAE PUBLISHES J1652-SINGLE APPLICATION DISC BRAKE TEST BMC/FMC FUNDING FOR REAR DRUM BRAKE PROCEDURE
2
HI) KEY EVENTS 1996-1999
u
3 Q
a(9
Z
<
IU
oIoU
-I < oo
S PC Bl
a zo
P
N
3
s 0*1 2
2 5 2-1 HI
~2 I5U f11B M2
g 3 2 5; I 2
g Silogsg
O g HI H HI O
gt Pojjj^
O 5 O Z S HI M
PJ HI .* 3 < ,2<2pw|SgeSaS*H!I
38 - 2
S"oSzuo^boioPZh
y iu -i iu o o s gSaugig
imm
hg^gao!:
Urns
< hi a
*s
hi O
go
9Z
hu 1 a
0 : **
o
2
HI
3 a
PC
g
HI
*
inI OK
Pn
2z
HO
(A PC HI II.
Eg
mul Of
= HI
HI = > HI
O 2
za
UJ jji
2jS<<
s o*6Z=i j2EM*I*U
_ <<IUo IOo IKaU gnH 2S* *
VI
FMSI 01213
TT
J2430 PROCEDURE SYNOPSIS
POST TEST COOLING CURVES
19 |sm
y ff f r
888
8-
" ip *
* | * Hi
1 Ml | 1 1 I 1 Mi
> FMSI 01214
SAE J2430 RECOMMENDED PRACTICE
S. DESIGNED FOR EFFECTIVENESS & FADE EVALUATION ** NOT INTENDED TO ASSESS WEAR, NOISE, ROTOR WEAR OR EXTENDED LIGHT DUTY VEHICLE SERVICE.
J
AZ
zO
oP
H <
<o
8
o3
z o
N
o H < a
-1
*"SOHI o <X
15ni
> I!
< so
5s
J <
sO M^ HI
il01
H
<
SS1
X o
5ox
OHI Xoe
M1
A
A1
u x
<s oe oi
H
rNAt
ss
<
oAAn
H3 03< 7u <in > aoi XA I! 3a 4 001
O a<Noae
IH0KA1-
Z
o
2P
* 3
An 31 >* 1a wX
H"
&
za
in O
a
^A
<
Z
2> o a a
A *
"u WA iJ > 25
ar<t **
a3 &
a<
< 01 XX X
zo
oa01 A
a 3
X O
Z
3
AX
oA
o 1-
5 a O 01 O z xX A
X Oa 01j
Q oi X
3 OX1i X H XD A01 z 3
X<k-
3 O
3A *
oo So o aoi 5o
oo
ooei a<
Xoi 0<1
i
i< 3*
a! "
s u >
M
S:
in
3N" (AI ((<AA <s XU O2S H Mi oe b uu x 55
O I88
<< M&A AI> <a z o:
FMS1 01215
T
FMS101216
J
FMSI 01217
FIGURE5
---------------
FORD EXPLORER FRONT BRAKE J2430 AVERAGE SPECIFIC TORQUE
LNKAVG. 0.263 GTL 0.261
J ou>'
C>
II
J1
ci u
s
J
W ^ OJ 1- o
OO o o o
dMAU'N "IH3A
FMSI 01218
J CO ho
8
o
p o
5
LU
*a:
J <s Q LU
<
O
a. a< o
CO * CM
IU
O<
S
10 8 I
(0 <0
Z IU
>
is F
o IU
ssO= UHs
Ik
iIuk
8
33
0
3*
1 biu s
b
35
z
8s
5Ss 2 o 86 O
h* U I
S
(0
Zo
<0
o r
(0 & (0
O ft HO 10 I10 10 0 I (0
uz zu
>U
F&
28
(0 CO
IU
Iz-
J
3 b O
Das
H
2u iiu
u
< zo
H * o
Ik IU Ik Ik
t < IU Ik 5afl Ss3i-
3z
(0 IU
Q
*iu
b b 0
1 < o oft K O z <ik oa
iSau 3":
(0 *
3 0
*
--
:=
:=
>
>
CM
FMSI 01219
TT
J2430 DYNO TEST SETUP PARAMETERS
1998 FORD EXPLORER 4 DOOR
J
i
E5
i Hi li li
CO
3
4iii iliill ssssss ill h ?!
J
ai FMSI 01220
T
J.T.T. 1/11AO
5J5PS8
5
3(0
FMSI 01221
FMSI 01222
FMSI 01223
FMSI 01224
V) J2430 VALIDATION TESTING
1997 HONDA CIVIC; 1997 CARAVAN; 1997 GRAND PRIX; 1998 EXPLORER; 1998 F250.
J
0
J< 0 0
o
z
o uXi z
z
o 0
Z
o
s 0111 H
a i ui
0 0 z
sJ
?!
z
Ui
ui
Jj0
ui s 0
N0 IK<I-I
0
0 III
s0
SIS0 <A 0 2 IISsJ
2o
it
s
3
IU
0
H
0
0 a
0
jU
ui
o flf o
(0 " X
5 H111 *
0iii h
UI
gp O
ui
;
0
z
Oz
Z<
fZc
*
0 o
0
H
<
z
a
s*
fc
< I!
E U N N
oK- :*
*
#
" (A
s5 0z
g3 J ui J 5 Si f
K III 3
sN* 550 s<e
0
0 0
ofl
*"
UI * *
H T- DC
<0j H2 E" S
U3 00
UI E <
&: a M
3a 3
a
a o
0-I
5 HUI o
oS*i
2 -
0z
*= 0s UI 3 O tH 0C Z<
0
IHU 0
J 0 a2
OQ Zt 0O 3*
os
X*
0" a 0 ui SI z a3 32S B J1
0
FMSI 01225
x