Document GzrVQVGV37E5DdY8k4NpmmMOx

January 1J, I9I+I DHMB55eoar,prsSvtaoPahrntrhamd,titeluMiUnpctanksioDsvSf.reitrnIrsnekieetdyrtustrial Hygiene Dear Mr. Drinker: . bpwwo1aef7hhpitiinheccthghrh,eIIcthssrhIuaiatagtivagcmleIeaistnlwstteiolornateinndtebdineilongeyanneygyctoaoerufburiatrliehitchlIleieaartnonetalgmtwenrIieraottdohcvteuooagacfuioeillvidnDc,neregwwiBctaeiiaimmnsctlhyhkibyos,nesmusraeobtpluuf'nstd basis for my criticism. As you will note, I have not minced words in dealing with Belknap, and I have not felt it necessary to be cautious because I am quite sure of my ground. I do not accuse Belknap of intellectual dishonesty in presenting these data, but I do think he has been uthnenseecedsastaarialyt cthaeremleesest.ingH, obtuotnIlysudbidseIqucernittliycize talked with Belknap and pointed out to him with reasonable care, the basis of my criticism. Moreover, on several occasions, we have had the opportunity of checking certain analytical results of his on patients, and his results have been excessively high in practically every instance. He has adequate reason, thereforec to suspect these results, and to publish them in this form represents, In my opinion, something of the in accuracy of approach that often characterizes good clinicians when they say that the results poubrtpaionseeds.areUngfooordtuennaotueglyh finorthcilsiniincsatlanacned, dtihaegnostic results are not good enough and they are not presented for purely clinical consideration. Without doubt they will produce a good many ' medico-legal difficulties. This is particularly Moinm,,uCnofmomrtiuttneeateofstihneceABmeelrkincaapn PisubalicmeHmebearlthofAtshseoAc9i0a-,0tISiAoH<1nQ,3ndtIJ0 of which I am Chairman, and we are working out a ItfJLldSOH 1YH3N39 0 ' 3N'D1G3W JO 393T IO D -2 nnorsscjeuaooftlripasttdatotrhiritragfhitytyshhinfaitukststhnfioethktcuhreitwnaisiodstsiainthroudootinaftumota,lidnecoddaanbnirinedusecwnlepwfiehopseqhisrclruiinhmcnihtveeihhsotwatiscessB.eadlebraleekriOtnaoeenbsnavowwpainpt,ohetreuaaobXtmssduleyhuIptlactvIeioihnedtaugvdtobiebsyetoen nyitnhoouat rtthbeetJhoekeunirtoanhwraet,lir,csolftmeoooer isIlcornriftegeivecioliesrwmseuItosdroetrbwuydtihsilprtaleetbrctshettooanmftostahrtdheweuihswsoeexhwatiecirniehnllt are, perhaps, more pointed than mine. Sincerely yours, RAK:is Robert . Kehoe, M.D. Kr 0015268 February 6,191+1 MThreaJHouerlennalLoawf sIonndustrial Hygiene and TB55ooxsStiochnoaltotugMycakssS. treet Dear Mrs. Lawson: rbaiodatmehydeftpevspfatlacrhyunocrenihrbtbautrtahgeoomvbdemelabmerreabIiyrtondeytuhocemmDsfratiaytretmpi.itlmahcoeenBoitaidsyhdnkemo,litkunddssnags.sisnaecpodfofuuIuffsitrtlshhstahiepiIinosseouanhprlrlappnaeyvonocaotseotspftieemsetorr.ttrmheh,w,aeeesodnaaeTutnbrrhtslediDdee.olisrautImb.tstIeseiBtsvvtehsvceeeeoeserrledrsikrvetmnyinimooeacaendbssiprse'iomstssft, hrodeafecscetohbnueetneltynd, itIdshhteoivzwieosnlnopeuheondmfboemerthteuiotnnhdofa,detertoiootfhmrhaeittngothDiovrnp.arroeiBonceulilykssinoamonpnoe.dhaityfsOipncemattahiodoeifnss lathanasIttrrhpeeasrpaisogrnauspnihbcoleonfvsinhtacitseedmreIenpnltyth.coisnIcrteerginsainrdqgumsiitenetchepoodhsse,sibhInlaesthe mnTo3sthntoihease.ttatshtetuhhpo,meeaud,dehhbonoselituwtfrhsebheeIa.jvesneedecarxT,ttl'hdphyieiaeassstrtiaaiseIIq,.nnrtuarcbieleAytcyleoetch?nivticicfuhdauallaiencsllnhealtgyms,rw,.ebstothhietunheTohlceddhineeIsddpisstrtauhrotteoheaov;uenidwpbclypeuloiertbnhoeclswnisotsertniihiettvguehsIitedptceeesmtueoicovctfthnhiidneat.oeanthcee mwpaihmoheeortiyhcntahgonadIctrsheseeo.mnftouspTmebrhloeeevcreiepdscd;oaautrlaatlryrneada,yirneeatahnddede;errqctiohsuoneaneyotcoefluuasdrtsoeieoafnnedidsxnecfimRiteneesielassyclievhtiaeesldedelycinofprgnvioc,damtaruIrinayrthebeiltmmeha t are at variance with established physiological facts. rmvSaaiitrkghtenueiarfsoilcmltyahenacnbuenrciieoovffnefretushadseiliostenaoc,rmciaetahpltattactenoIrmcMse,tmrh.eiaonnnftkdDp,trhtoihencienkosetnniursnepigmedederiogirofiuhnorttgrwsthcteiheslnehasrititotiyvity wuDaaaaoiaictnnpnnhnottfirtocdsdmtaiahnemtlnttcpauhudakhainedrcotnreireehcitcieburnondseedus,tspgetre,roabauwe.tltocauaqsecteihyensSttttumehediuatwootctenosohawccffnenthotolimmmyap,rtlntuohierotleembeodsriirtnnosuuethfahfvctgotttoieerehotedgnrehnrrtfrmseghoedcesm.smeyleeteeydiIoncttaoaosEhfhfttrdnoewaexodmkasmspmimmueileenibeMclatcrephhyititarehbhoaSt.lneoadlsiutshocoDdsoscoeeuehflsfrodnfiitpianeowdungcsatoltpnrkrieoidmcaadeigemnnoattmemrdofhb.oeplaeoeeranfrlilnrymeittmtnhadtogaomawnewcewtdsattoeeiiewitluotvrhrBifhlliimnreetdotaoehsdlmilmrgi,nJtksenobo,oanmialeulttaoeiMosmtrpoohvbnr'bndeysia.aslrking mwBIsmhoeaoulptukltodelnsdrasbpieogb'sflreaepaasntotoilasgyilbntyiaeitofpliinicpec,arvaleenwcmtiiattehhitttehaerotmebdsMIesnpoi.rnecf.gcidPIitnfseaoftniooIrtrIhamnatalmhflaloyeltrw,imoadrngIoeand.rteafg,ie,nsifndoowrritihtittnhhisaDtthIre. iltnoedtttiehcearteoddne.lmetyiIotcnrwitoaisfcinsthmoet,winIotredcnRed"reegtfdareoirntrsoilsny"gbefhratoovomebMjnetrhoc.etiDoosbnrejianenbtckelteneiorc'nes , but rather to indicate extensive rather than minor ienxapcocsuurraec. iesAvinerythelarmgeeaseurreromrenwt oourldIbneterrepqreutiaretidontoof mdponryeoldwtehutaeiycoenuto,trhinbeceurr.itetirscaIuitlshetesexrpoilnartodinoicIfnfatehtdneiiddscabnatenyoyttthhoaesaftmaanIynacodloobyljtlneiecocaattgilougnodesao.ttoautthoef Sincerely yours, RAK;ls Robert A. Kshoe, M.D. KF 0015270