Document GKBparRovRn8kb2wBdb59bdKv
MANUFACTURING CHEMISTS ASSOCIATION
1825 CONNECTICUT AVENUE, N W , WASHINGTON, 0 C 20009
TELEPHONE. (202) 328-4200 TELEX. 89617 (MCA WSH)
Calcasieu Parish * Itfuisiss#
TO: Vinyl Chloride Technical Panel Vinyl Chloride Research Coordinators Vinyl Chloride Medical Subcommittee
Gentlemen:
As reported in Section 6.0 of the Record of the University of Louisville Meeting on June 14, 1978, Drs. Tamburro and O'Connell promised to send the Project Manager complete abstracts of all research reviews presented on all component studies. We are pleased to report that they have exceeded their promise by sending us complete transcripts of the actual research reviews covering Dr. Tamburro's "Overview of the University of Louisville Multi-Disciplinary Approach to the Study of Chemical Carcinogenesis" and the reports on the component research projects as well. Included in the enclosed collection of papers are copies of all slides which were presented during the June 14th meeting.
We trust you will find these research summaries helpful and, for the benefit of those of you who were unable to attend, they afford an excellent insight into the overall value of this research program.
Sincerely
JTS:ep Enclosure
J. T. Seawell Project Manager Vinyl Chloride Research
THE WRITER'S DIRECT DIAL NUMBER IS (202) 328-4258
CMA 002339
UNIVERSITY OF LOUISVILLE
Calcasieu Parish, Louisiana
CHEMICAL CARCINOGENESIS MULTI-DISCIPLINARY RESEARCH GROUP
I, OVERVIEW
Slide 1. The University of Louisville has a multi-disciplinary approach to the
study of chemical carcinogenesis, especially, chemical monomers. Vinyl Chloride was one of the first chemical monomers under study; we combined a cancer control program which designed and implemented a prospective medical surveillance system for identifying occupationally related chemical cancer (as shown on the left of the slide) with a clinical research group which worked closely with the medical surveillance program in developing better techniques for detection and prevention, Basic research in the molecular structure and pathogenesis of carcinogens, especially chemical monomers (as shown on the right) made the third link in our multi-disciplinary approach to the study of chemical carcinogenesis.
Slide 1
MULTIDISCIPLINARY APPROACH TO CHEMICAL CARCINOGENESIS
CANCER CONTROL PROGRAM
APPLIED CLINICAL INVESTIGATION
BASIC RESEARCH
INYL CHLORIDE NGIOSARCOMA
MEDICAL SURVEILLANCE SYSTEMS
DETECTION ANI> PREVENTION SYSTEMS
PATHOGENESIS OF
CARCINOGENS
MOLECULAR STRUCTURE VINYL CHL0RI3
1 CMA 002340
SLIDE 2. This simply outlines in more detail the various components of the cancer
control program which include a screening program, a data bank, an epidemio logical study system, educational programs, counseling and rehabilitation programs, and the treatment program.
co: ':0-
o-flor 3-n i.o. 9-4337
Boss v.
^ riot Court
14th Judicial u Louisiana Calcasieu Parish,, Lou
VINYL CHLORIDE ANGIOSARCOMA /.
Slide 2
CANCER CONTROL PROGRAM
:
APPLIED CLINICAL INVESTIGATION BASIC RESEARCH
MEDICAL SURVEILLANCE SYSTEMS 1. SCREENING PROGRAM 2. DATA BANK 3. EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMS *J. COUNSELING & REHABILITATION 5, TREATMENT PROGRAM
,>
DETECTION AND PREVENTION SYSTEMS "
PATHOGENESIS OF THE CARCINOGEN (s)
MOLECULAR STRUCTURE VINYL CHLORIDE
CMA 002341 2
SLIDE 3.
This illustrates the past clinical investigations done in the detection
and prevention systems. They cover a variety of areas such as ffl, looking
at the appearance of normal human bile acids as a means of determining liver function to the identification of potential chemical carcinogens and their
metabolites by new bacterial systems covering the gamut from clinical to
basic research in the area of detection and prevention.
.
C"- '^" 2255-*; pTa--
" *1 , J J B3I
Slide 3 -
VINYL CHLORIDE ANGIOSARCOMA
CANCER CONTROL PROGRAM
MEDICAL SURVEILLANCE SYSTEMS
APPLIED CLINICAL INVESTIGATION
BASIC RESEARCH
DETECTION AND PREVENTION SYSTEMS
1. BILE ACID CLEARANCE 2. BLOOD/TISSUE ENZYMES 3. LEUKOCYTE ADHERENCE INHIBITION A, HISTOCOMPATIBLE (hL~a) IDENTIFICATION 5. URINARY GLYCOSAMINOGLYCANS 6. TISSUE ANTIGENIC SYSTEMS 7. HISTOLOGICAL/ELECTRON MICROSCOPIC
CHARACTERIZATION 8. MULTIVARIANT ANALYSIS FOR END PRODUCTS 9. IDENTIFICATION OF POTENTIAL CHEMICAL
CARCINOGENS
PATHOGENESIS OF CARCINOGENS
MOLECULAR STRUCTURE
VINYL CHLORIDE
cma 002342
3
SLIDE 4. The fourth slide illustrates some basic science research being condu^t^^
in the pathogenesis of carcinogens. In this case, they are numbered from 9 through 1 indicating those areas of research most related to the clinical area such as looking for tissue antigen and antibody detection as a means of screening to the most basic one; that is looking for industrial vinyl monomers by mass spectrometry studies and their metabolites in the carcinogenic`process. These studies are presented in more detail further on. These slides simply illustrate that the inter-disciplinary group is investigating chemical monomers from molecular structure aspects to clinical application.
?-o.
J; 90 - f
Cft^001alu
CMA 002343 4
Slide A P.c
CANCER CONTROL PROGRAM MEDICAL SURVEILLANCE SYSTEMS
APPLIED CLINICAL INVESTIGATION
BASIC RESEARCH
DETECTION AND PREVENTION SYSTEMS
PATHOGENESIS OF CARCINOGENS 9, VINYL CHLORIDE TISSUE ANTIGEN/
ANTIBODY DETECTION 8. HEPATIC FIBROSIS IN CHEMICAL
CARCINOGENESIS `
7. VINYL CHLORIDE CARCINOGENESIS
INDUCTION 6, GLYCOSAMINOGLYCAN IN HEPATIC
ANGIOSARCOMA 5. VINYL CHLORIDE NEOPLASTIC
TRANSFORMATION 4. VINYL CHLORIDE INDUCED METABOLIC
ALTERATION 3. CARCINOGENESIS AND SULFUR AMINO
ACID METABOLISM 2. MUTAGENESIS OF VINYL CHLORIDE
AND METABOLITIES 1, INDUSTRIAL VINYL MONOMER
CARCINOGENESIS
MOLECULAR STRUCTURE VINYL CHLORIDE
5 CMA 002344
ANALYSIS AND SYNTHESIS OF CHEMICALS AND THEIR USE IN BILE ASSAYS FOR THE
IDENTIFICATION OF CARCINOGENIC POTENTIAL
PART A. CHEMICAL SYSTEMS OF DETECTION OF VINYL MONOMER TOXICITY JOHN L. WONG, Ph.D.
SLIDE 1
j_ ^-otective Or^er L-A^
Subject oO -- ^
9Q-iidJ'
Court
Our study is concerned with the chemical systems of detection of the toxicity of vinyl monomers in general and vinyl chloride (VC) in particular. Most vinyl monomers are not mutagenic or carcinogenic per se, but become so after they are metabolically oxidized. They are converted to the epoxides which are highly reactive and can undergo spontaneous rearrangement to the carbonyl compounds. These primary metabolites, i.e. the epoxides and carbonyls, are electrophilic compounds and have a propensity to react with cellular nucleophiles nonenzymatically. Such reactions can be cate gorized into two groups, those reacting in the cytoplasm and those in the nucleus. The trapping of the epoxide and carbonyl compounds In the cyto plasmic environment by sulfhydryl compounds are generally the detoxification reactions. Whereas the primary metabolites reacting with the nucleic acid materials In the nucleus would constitute the putative action and is most likely involved in vinyl carcinogenesis. Basing on this concept, we have made advances in three areas of study: (l) The detoxification of the primary metabolites of VC in a cytoplasmic environment. Here, we have identified key intermediary metabolites and are going to identify all reaction products so that the metabolic fate of the epoxide and carbonyl can be determined as the host factors vary. (2) The putative action of the primary, metabolites . of VC which'involves alteration of the nucleic acid constituents. We have isolated some unusual modified bases and our intention is to relate quanti
tatively these modifications of nucleic acids to bioassay findings. (3)
The mutagenic and carcinogenic potential of industrial vinyl monomers other than vinyl chloride. We have applied controlled chemical oxidation mimicking the metabolic conditions to 1A vinyl monomers which are chosen on the basis of their industrial usage. So far 12 epoxides have been generated for testing. We have seen that this chemical study is beginning to pay off in promoting team work in unraveling the mechanism of how a vinyl monomer is being handled In a cell, which is a critical issue in industrial safety consideration.
CMA 002345 6
" CCrTIDPHTIAI.
Subject to Protective Order in Pose v. "rnoco , Iro . , ITo. 90-4837
14th Judicial District Court Calcasieu Parish,, Louisiana
Slide 1
Chemical Systems of Detection of Vinyl Toxicity
VINYL
metabolic
oxidation EPOXIDE + CARBONYL (3)
------------------------ CYTOPLASM
NUCLEUS
DETOXIFICATION
(1)
T
PUTATIVE ACTION
(2)
7 CMA 002346
SLIDE 2
j, i- - -
Subject tc ?' Ross v. Couoo:
Order in o. 90-4837
14th Judicial District Court
Calcasieu Parish, Louisian*
This slide shows the significant results which we have obtained
pertaining to the detection of vinyl chloride detoxification products.
The chlorooxlrane, COR, compound 1, and its rearrangement product chloro-
acetaldehyde, CAA, compound 2, are the two most commonly hypothesized primary metabolites of vinyl chloride. The central question is how are
they detoxified. Do they yield the same products or different ones? We
have studied their reaction with sulfhydryl compounds 3>4"dichlorobenzene-
thiol and N-acetyI cysteine. The benzenethiol was used by the Stockholm
group in a prJliminary study to detect the formation of CAA and COR from
VC. The cysteine derivative is a cellular sulfhydryl component as v/el1 as
a close analog of glutyathione. In the case of COR and benzenethiol, the
sulfur-conjugation product S-acetaldehyde, compound 3, is formed. However,
CAA and benzenethiol forms the hemi thioacetal compound 4. These two
reactions are distinctly different. The formation of hemithioacetal is
reversible but that of the S-acetaldehyde is not. With N-acetyIcyteine,
both COR and CAA yield the same cyclic condensation product, a dihydro-
thiazenecarboxylic acid, compound 5- This thiazene is a multi-step reaction
product. Its isolation may have solved the mystery of an unknown urinary
metabolite as well as the origin of the identified urinary metabolites:
S-acetic acid, Compound 6, and S-ethylalcohol, Compound 7. In the Dow
paper reporting the fate of
labeled vinyl chloride in rats, there is
also a major metabolite accounting for ^35% of the
label in urine which
has not been identified. We believe that this thiazene compound is a key
intermediary metabolite, that it can undergo further metabolic processing to
yield compounds 6 and J, and may itself be present in the urine. These
results as presented here will enable us to undertake a more comprehensive
detection study of all the vinyl chloride detoxification products in biologi
cal specimens.
00 23 41 8
Ho55 V .
~C- -".2- , '/o. 90-4337
14 Oh Juiloial
7ict Court
Calcasieu Parish., Louiaiana
Slide 2
Detoxification of Vinyl Chloride
PRIMARY METABOLITES INTERMEDIARY metabolites
COR1
Sk
S-ACETALDEHYDE3 THIAZENES5
CAA2
4/
HEMITHIOACETAL4 THIAZENES5
URINARY METABOLITES.
S-ACETIC ACID6 " S-ETHYL ALCOHOL7 CHLOROACETIC ACID8
2 H--CH2Cl 3 RS-CH2CH0 4 RS-CH-CH2Cl
6 RS-CH2C02H 7 RS-CH2CH2OH 8 Cl--CH2C02H
(RS from 3^--dichlorobenzenethiou N-acetylcysteine)
9 CMA 002348
slide 3
The detection study of the putative action of vinyl chloride has been started on the hypothesis that it is due to the modification of the nucleic acid materials by the primary metabolites COR and CAA. Although CAA is long known to react with nucleic acid bases such as cytosine and adenine to form the etheno derivatives, compound 1 and 2, very little Is known about the reaction of CAA on the most, reactive base guanine. By using a battery of modern analytical tools such as HPLC, GC-MS and FT-NMR, we have found that the guanine base in various forms, as the nucleoside, nucleotide and polyguanylic acid, gives rise to two tricyclic ethenoguanines, the linear etheno compound 3 and the angular etheno compound 4, and a third product which is possibly an acetylguanine, compound 5. These products can disrupt nucleic acid structures hence their functions by means of steric and electronic perturbation. It is also worthy of note that their fluorescence properties would allow their direct detection in a cel 1 nucleus. The reaction of COR with the-guanine base is more tricky due to the Instability of COR in aqueous medium. A. multitude of products are formed which we have found to be different from those of the CAA reaction. Using HPLC and NMR techniques, we have tenta tively Identified one major product as compound 6. It is important to note that this is the first indication that COR and CAA show different molecular events in their putative action. The significance of this information In terms of vinyl carcinogenesis will become clearer when we can correlate quantitatively the alterations in nucleic acids brought about by COR and CAA and the bioassay results of these primary metabolites.
CMA 002349
10
CQjriSSlTTIAL
Subject to ?rctactive Ordar in Slide 3
Eos Co-..- ,00
SO-4337
li'-h Juoioial District Court
Calcasieu Parish,, Louisiana
Putative Action of Vinyl Chloride, Reaction with Nucleic Acid Bases
CM ETHENO-C1, etheno-a2 l-etheno-g3, a-ETHENO-G4, acetyl-g5
COR G--7--ACETALDEHYDE6 + ...
11 CMA 002350
'~LTAz
SLIDE A
sS^5g5t^
' ':h% '
imhJmidhi :-^r`;tceifa?t
V, ceii&^f^apfarfih , Lcraf
It is now known that vinyl chloride-mediated mutagenesis in the
Salmonella test requires microsomal activation. In order to extend the
vinyl chloride model to scrutinize the mutagenic and carcinogenic potential
of other industrial vinyl monomers, we have started a methodical screening
system. The conventional Salmonella screening involves treating the vinyl
monomers with the S-9 preparation which contains the mixed function,oxidase
system and a whole variety of other soluble enzymes prior to bacteria
screening. . This is sort of a black box approach, the outcome of which
often is hinged on the history of the S-9 preparation. We have used mild
chemical conditions, a controlled MCPBA oxidation to oxidize ]4 vinyl
compounds to the corresponding epoxides. They are chosen mainly on the basis
of their industrial significance. These epoxides have been identified and
quantitated by means of nuclear magnetic resonance technique so that the
bioassay results can be related to the amounts of epoxides formed. These
epoxides upon heating will rearrange to the carbonyl derivatives which can
be similarly quantitated and tested. We are now vigorously pursuing this
line of vinyl screening study in collaboration with Dr. Streips of the
Microbiology Department. You'll be hearing from him shortly about the
interesting assays which he has carried out on both the vinyl compounds and
their epoxide derivatives.
To summarize, our strategy has been to fully elucidate'the molecular events in the metabolism of vinyl chloride, that is, the detoxification and putative action, and use it as a mode] to screen the mutagenic and carcinogenic potential of other industrial vinyl monomers. This work is part of a group effort. Some of the collaboration results will now be
expounded by Dr. Streips.
Slide 4 Mutagenic and Carcinogenic Potential
. of Vinyl Monomers
VINYL'-Rcp^ EPOXIDE -T* carbonyl
25 (1) nmr quant (1) nmr quant (2) biol screen (2) biol screen
a> oiTos9 nT) Cl U
O O1 %4J 3
H>
^
ta e
W R M
aM -H H%
<3 *5
pe; O
ocf--a0*2
4* "13 2
a,
& > -Q
2 3 & gr
w
^STYRENE, BUTADIENE, ACRYLONITRILE, CROTONONITRILE,
ACRYLATE, ETHYL VINYL ETHER, VINYL ACETATE, VINYL BROMIDE, VINYL FLUORIDE, VINYLIDENE CHLORIDE, VINYLIDENE BROMIDE, TRICHLOROETHYLENE, DICHLORODIFLUOROETHYLENE,1,1"DICHLOROPROPENE
12 CMA 002351
PART B. REACTIVITY OF CHEMICALS AND THEIR METABOLITES IN VARIOUS BACTERIAL ASSAYS - DR. ULDIS N. STREIPS, P'n.D.
With thousands of chemicals being routinely used in manufacturing processes, and new compounds being created daily for specific industrial needs, it is of great importance to assess the relative carcinogenic potential of each of these materials before they are released into the environment in quantity. When considering carcinogenesis assays, the most accurate are animal models. However, these suffer from two problems: first, they are time comsuming; second, they may not reflect the true state in human exposure. Nevertheless, to determine if a chemical is a carcinogen with our present state of knowledge requires animal testing.
There are a variety of rapid screen techniques available for chemicals. All of you are probably familiar with the Ames Salmonella reversion test. This test determines"the mutagenicity of a compound. However, the correlation of mutagenesis and carcinogenesis is only accurate to about 80%. The Ames test in itself makes no prediction on the carcinogenicity of a chemical. Our laboratory also has used extensively the Bacillus repair test. This screening technique measures whether a chemical elicits enough damage to the cellular DNA to require repair for cell survival. Then by measuring the relative killing of a variety of repair-deficient strains, we can determine if the chemical is reactive to the DNA and which type of repair is required to fix this, damage. A good example in Table 1 is chloroacetaldehyde (CAA), the active metabolite from vinyl chloride oxidation. This potent chemical at the concentration indicated causes no inhibition of the wild type, repair-proficient strain (w+), or the strains lacking UV repair (hcr~, uvr~) and DNA polymerase I
G Off? IDSTT TI AI
Subject to Protective r"^sr in
pv>ss v. Car.ooo, Ir.o. ,
"''- 4837
14th Judicial District .curt
Calcasieu Parish,
`S;-
13
CMA 002352
CQH7IDSTTTIAL
'ft
subject to Protective Order in
Eos3 %. Zonop i
\ 90 " 4837
14th JUilc ir 1 ~B istrict Court
Calcasieu Parish,, Louisiana.
TABLE 1
REACTIVITY OF CHEMICALS IN BACTERIAL ASSAYS
CHEMICAL
SALMONELLA REVERSION # REV/PLATE--CONTROL
JAA (0.004M)
""
STYRENE OXIDE (0.01M)
EMS (0.001M)
ms (o.ooim)
265 342 312 355
SOS REPAIR % NONTREATED
15% 100%
80% 1%
SUBTILIS REPAIR ASSAY REC" HCR- UVR- POL mm INHIBITION
0 18 2 2 3
0200 1
1 16 1 1 1
4 21
6
6 10
CMA 002^53 14
(pol A~). However, the strain missing recombination repair (rec~) is tremendously inhibited. This suggests that CAA interacts with DNA and that recombination repair is necessary to rectify this damage. We have done further research with this compound (Table 2).and find that very specific kinds of rec~ strains are inhibited by CAA. This forms the basis for much of our research in the third year on CAA. We will compare strains which are all rec~ but some are killed by CAA (e.g. rec A or rec B) and some are not (rec C and rec H). We will isolate enzymes and structural components from these strains which vary in their response to CAA, then relate these to known mammalian counterparts. These experiments should help to elucidate the mechanism of action of this chemical. Similar studies will be initiated for other vinyl monomers, namely styrene oxide and acrylyl nitrile.
Neither the Salmonella nor the Bacillus reversion tests directly address the carcinogenicity of the compounds tested. We have recently instituted a screen developed by Ronald Yasbin, which may approach, as closely as is possible in a bacterial system, the assay for carcinogenicity. This test will be described in detail in a forthcoming publication (U.N. Streips and R.E. Yasbin, Microbial Testers for Chemical Carcinogenesis, I.C. Felkner (ed). Marcel Dekker, N.Y.). Briefly, most investigators now envision that the carcinogenesis mechanism may be started by error-prone repair, the so-called SOS pathway. This happens when the cell cannot repair by normal means and now induces a repair system which fixes DNA lesions with no consideration for the correct template. As a result, not only has the chemical damaged the DNA of the cell, but the cell in attempting repair has created a mutational site. Therefore, any chemical which induces SOS repair is more than likely a carcinogen. The induction of SOS can be measured in several ways, but the Induction of bacterial viruses is the easiest. Therefore, our test measures the extent of virus
CONPIDZrTx IAL_
Cubjsot to
'?''=!r in
Eos3 v. ^cmVj.
.-0-4837
3 4'--t-. - - -i ............ .. . c; Court
Calcasieu Parish,, .Louisiana
15
CMA 002354
nmi-ffipSUTlAX.. --rr^.^tpct^ve Order in Sttb39V--'0 T"c . HO. 90-4837
TABLE 2
^HSU3-t77h'
^ Judicial
*l=**lvB--trtlct,.Cp1o"ur*t
REPAIR ASSAYS
fl.lM.ieu Perleb. Loulelw*
Strains
REC A
recAl recAl
REC B
recB6 recB3 recB19 recB2 recB2 recB2
-REC C
recC7
REC D
recD27 recD27
REC E
recE61 recE4
REC F
recF7 recF18 recF15 recFIS recF16
Average Inhibition in mm/8 experiments
Of.
13.5 7.5
13.5 9.5
16.5 * 16.5
11,3 16.8
NR
11.5 NR
.
6.7 8.8
6.1 .7.4 ' 7.5 8.42 . 3.1
Strains
REC H , recH342
Average inhibition rrcn/8 experiments
NR
REC
rec-4 rec-13
MTC
ratc-41 (cafr)
UVR
uvr-35 (cafr) her uvr
ml
wt wt wt
15.4 5.4
NR
NR NR NR
NR NR NR
**
.
*100mM chloroacetaldehyde used In all these experiments >
16
CMA 002355
cc J
337
induction in a cell population as a measure of SOS inducifi^^^iftti^3.r.^s^ftiefepuislana virus is induced, the cell dies. Therefore, in Table 1 100% survival is no SOS induction, less than 100% means SOS has been induced.
At the present time several laboratories are assaying various chemicals as well as other materials by the SOS test and correlating this data to known carcinogenicity. At this time the initial preliminary evaluation is that this test may be a very accurate predictor of the carcinogenic potential of a chemical.
In Table 1 I present a comparison of the various systems. I have tested over 60 various substances in the last year by the Salmonella and Bacillus repair tests, but preliminarily only a few so far by SOS. I have chosen these four compounds for this presentation because they illustrate the variance of these microbial tests. All four compounds are mutagenic by the Salmonella test. All but styrene oxide are positive in the Bacillus repair assay, and seem to
\
require recombination repair. Methyl methane sulfonate also is reactive toward the strain lacking polymerase I (pol A). However, the preliminary indication from the SOS repair assay demonstrates significant differences between these compounds. Both CAA and MMS are quite reactive in this assay, but styrene oxide and EMS (ethyl methane sulfonate) are essentially non-reactive. This suggests that neither styrene oxide nor EMS can induce significant levels of SOS repair. It is interesting that recent reports show EMS not to be carcinogenic while MMS is a potent carcinogen (R. Yasbin, personal communication).
It is our intention in the next funding year to finish our studies with CAA, and elucidate the several mechanisms of action of this compound. In addition we will extend our now established research techniques to thoroughly test other vinyl monomers, notably styrene oxide and acryllnitrile. We will also extend our catalogue of compounds assayed by the SOS screen and draw a more reliable conclusion on the applicability of this test for carcinogenesis screening.
17 CMA 002356
coEI52^deT
gcss.y-
Court
'"w*' !Trr&- W-1813"
Calcasieu Yar
THE CHARACTERIZATION OF BIOCHEMICAL ENZYMATIC CHANGES OCCURRING WITH
PROLONGED VINYL CHLORIDE EXPOSURE IN ANIMAL AND MAN J.T. Du, Ph.D., and C.H. Tamburro, M.D.
Conventional clinical biochemical studies have not been shown to be an
effective early indicator of chemical injury to the liver. Little is known
about the earliest cellular enzymatic changes with prolonged exposure to
chemical monomers. An initial vinyl chloride exposure experiment was conducted
to examine sequentially the early enzymatic changes in cellular function of
the liver. Animals were exposed from 10,000 - 20,000 ppm from 14 to 137 hours,
of total exposure being exposed five days a week. Conventional clinical
biochemical studies and subcellular enzyme markers were studied. These
included: (1) microsomal enzymes related to vinyl chloride metabolism:
P450, NADPH-cytochrome C reductase, and mixed function oxidase. Mitochondrial
marker cytochrome C oxidase .and protein metabolism was studied by looking at
in vivo incorporation of tritiated leucine. In addition, glucose-6-phosphatase
and glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase were studied as cytosol markers as
were glutathione content and glutathione reductase in relationship to
detoxification. Overall results are shown in Slide 1 for conventional and
subcellular enzymes.
CMA. 0023s: 18
CONVENTIONAL CLINICAL BIOCHEMICAL STUDIES
Slide 1
I
4. ALK PHOS
5, BILIRUBIN 6, TOTAL PROTEIN
7. ALBUMIN
8. CHOLESTEROL
9, TRIGLYCERIDES
NO CHANGE NO CHANGE NO CHANGE NO CHANGE NO CHANGE NO CHANGE NO CHANGE NO CHANGE NO CHANGE
SUBCELLULAR ENZYME AND METABOLITE STUDIES IN LIVER
1. MICROSOMAL ENZYMES RELATED TO VC METABOLISM:
A. P-450
B. NADPH-CYT C REDUCTASE C. MIXED FUNCTION OXIDASE
NO CHANGE
2. MITOCHONDRIAL MARKER; CYT C OXIDASE
3. IN VIVO INCORPORATION OF ^"LEU
NO CHANGE NO CHANGE
4. GLUTATHIONECONTENT 5. GLUTATHIONE REDUCTASE
6. GLUCOSE-6-P ASE
ELEVATED INCREASED DECREASED
7. GLUCOSE-6-P DEHYDROGENASE
INCREASED
RATS WERE EXPOSED TO 10,000-20,000 PPM VC FOR 14, 28, 42, 71, 84, 103 AND
137 HOURS.
19 CMA 002358
SLIDE 2, 3, 4, 5. This illustrates an early increase in glutathione reductase activity
followed closely by a fall in glucose-6-phosphatase which becomes signifi
cant after 71 hours of total exposure (Slide 3). At 100 hours, a marked
increase in glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (Slide 4) similar to that
seen in metabolic studies by Weber and his group concerning hepatic primary
cell neoplasms was found. As shown in Slide 5, Weber's molecular correla
tion concept of neoplasia shows an impairment of the glucose-6-phosphatase
producing a decrease in gluconeogenesis and an increase in the pentose
phosphate shunt pathways which eventually lead to an increase in purine
ev oC* ^s_|;io'h o
O" Eh li
cvi biosynthesis and nucleic acid synthesis. This, presumably, leads to increased liver cell replication. These biochemical changes in the early
stages of vinyl chloride exposure may well explain the histological
H findings in humans exposed to vinyl chloride which appear to be character
o. ^ o
rt nfHj
istic of vinyl chloride exposure.
These histological findings of focal
o CJ
*OP go H
P
o
,
I
**
3
nodular hyperplasia of
the hepatocytes may well be the histological
reflec
**o"3 >^
*2 <3
w g
SO
tion of a shift in gluconeogenesis and an increase in nucleic acid synthesis,
induced by a mechanism not yet completely understood during the early
phases of vinyl chloride exposure. If one were to carry this to a logical
conclusion one would presume that the hepatocyte would eventually develop
into a malignant cell with continuous regeneration and exposure to carcino
gens. The fact that the primary hepatocyte does not become malignant in
the adult rat, but does become malignant in the newborn rat with similar
vinyl chloride exposure, led us to study the detoxifying capabilities of
the hepatocyte versus the sinusoidal lining cells. During this time,
there were no significant differences in the usual biochemical clinical
studies used for screening early vinyl chloride injury.
f COTTFIPEHTTIAIi
Subject t~ ~ '.tsrtive Order In
.fcoss v. r,-
c.. No. 90-4837
14th Judies.__ j I; riot" Court fel-Caleasien Parish, Louisiana
-Conoco,
02359
EXPOSURE TIME (hours}
SLIDE 2 SHOWS THE GROUP MEANS OF THE SPECIFIC ACTIVITY OF GLUCOSE-6-
PHOSPHATASE WITH RESPECT TO TIME OF EXPOSURE. THE CONFIDENCE 'INTERVALS
FOR GROUP MEAN DIFFERENCES ON THE ACTIVITIES' OF ENZYMES DISCUSSED ARE
BASED ON THE ERROR MEAN SQUARE FROM A TWO FACTOR ANALYSIS OF VARIANCE
WITH INTERACTION. THE TWO MAIN EFFECTS BEING TIME IN HOURS AND EXPOSURE-
NONEXPOSURE, THERE IS NO SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE EXPOSED
AND CONTROL GROUPS FOR THE FIRST THREE TIME POINTS. HOWEVER, THE MEAN
LEVEL OF THE EXPOSED GROUP IS SIGNIFICANTLY LESS THAN THAT OF THE CONTROL
AFTER 71 HOURS OF EXPOSURE.
CJ
Subject to L-r Ross v. Conoco
~r - r,v ".--v in Jo. >0 - 4337
14th Judicial Lictric-; Coart
Calcasieu Parish,, Louisiana
CRIA 002360 21
Slide 3
SLIDE 3 SHOWS THE GROUP MEANS OF THE SPECIFIC ACTIVITY OF GLUTATHIONE
REDUCTASE WITH RESPECT TO TIME OF EXPOSURE. THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT INCREASE THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE EXPERIMENT.
Order
Sub:' -
3, jO - 4337j
R0S5_ V Jii--5-p CG ourt
14th Juuiciai
Calcasieu Parish,, Louisa
CMA 002361 22
SLIDE 4 SHOWS THE GROUP MEANS OF THE SPECIFIC ACTIVITY OF GULCOSE-6-
PHOSPHATE DEHYDROGENASE WITH RESPECT TO TIME OF EXPOSURE. THERE IS A
SIGNIFICANT INCREASE AFTER ABOUT 100 HOURS -OF EXPOSURE. 'cOr-IDEZTTXAl.
------^r"rrrr,-iv3 Order in
Subject to
Eo# go-4837
C2522S^i22^1(rt court
*14tb Judicial ,\v Calcasieu SarisH- Louisa
..
CMA 002362 23
PENTOSE PHOSPHATE PATHWAYS
PURINE B IO S Y N T H E S IS
%
o o to
CTi
weber's molecular correlation concept of neoplasia
I.atp.J
___
I
[gTp
Slide 5
s Hi' `A-U'A SPL 01 \\o. c1 "t\1 1 -JI
A C-T \ ,, ^ \ 1-t V* * V-.' 10
oP oe+ O cnA! p* 1v,1-" q o, P
fl J>V*
p it (O b a
GLYCOLYSIS GLUCONEOGENES1S
PK
<-p[ PEP[
c> [pyruvatT
PEP CKX
1 ^p-exylai8
>
VINYL CHLORIDE OXIDATION AND DETOXIFICATION J.T. Du, Ph.D., and C.H. Tamburro, M.D.
The second phase of study of the biochemical changes associated with vinyl choloride exposure were directed at oxidation and detoxification. SpragueDawley rats were randomly exposed to controls and vinyl chloride exposure at 28,000 ppm, 7 hours per day, five days per week, for a total of 210 hours of exposure, for six weeks duration. Slide 1 shows the vinyl chloride metabolic fate scheme presently under use. Vinyl chloride being metabolized at higher levels by mixed-function oxidase within the liver may be converted to chlorooxirane or the epoxide. This unstable intermediate may then spontaneously revert to form chloroethanol and the chloroethanol may further be metabolized to chloroacetaldehyde. Secondly, the chlorooxirane may be directly detoxified by GSA via the glutathione epoxide S-transferase or further oxidized to chloroacetal dehyde. Chloroacetaldehyde in turn may be shown by glutathione aralykly-Stransferase or further oxidized to chloroacetic acid. Studies by Wong and Streips have already shown that vinyl chloride, chloroethanol and chloroacetic
acid have no mutagenic properties in bacteria. However, the chlorooxirane and the chloroacetaldehyde are both mutagenic. Animal studies demonstrated significant differences in the liver of vinyl chloride exposed animals who showed no physical or clinical abnormalities. These findings are listed in Slide 2. They include an elevation of non-protein sulfhydryl content, (Slide 3) glut athione reductase, (Slide 4) glutathione epoxide-S-transferase (GEST) (Slide 5) and glutathione aralykly-S-transferase (GAST) (Slide 6) concomitant with the increase in glucose-6-phosphate dehydregenase and reduction in P450 content (Slide 7).
A composite of the studies from 14 to 350 hours is shown in Slide 8 which illustrates the earliest increases occurring in glutathione reductase followed later by an increase in glutathione content. It is interesting to note that the Increase in GEST occurred before the increase in GAST around 70 to 80 hours of the total exposure. This implies that the chlorooxirane accumulation is to be
CMA 002364 25
handled by direct detoxification by the glutathione but with prolonged exposure more is converted to the chloroacetaldehyde which then is further detoxified by the GAST. These data are compatible with other findings of increased amounts of chloroacetic acid in the urine of individuals with very high prolonged exposures. This would imply that at initial doses the vinyl chloride is able to be metabolically handled and properly detoxified and that there may be a number of mechanisms by which the active metabolites are handled within the hepatocyte thus, preventing it from inducing DNA injury and subsequently angiosarcoma. Whether these metabolic capabilities are also present in''the sinusoidal lining cells has lead us to our more recent studies.
_--. -- T1 T /1_TJ
m s>t" it1
- Court
v;,, '.jCalcasieM * *
---------
002365 26
Slide 1
I
Cv c)
Cl CH = CH,
ts> Cl CH2CH20H
(chloroethanol)
(chlorooxirane)
DETOXIFICATION WITH GLUTATHIONE
GS CH2CH2OH
t
N-Ac-S-(2-hydroxy
ethyl) cysteine
(chloroacetaldehyde) 4
Cl ch2cooh (CHLOROACETIC ACID)
GS CH2CH0
VINYL CHLORIDE METABOLIC FATE
fGS CH2C00H V
THI0DI6LYC0LIC ACi
13* TO
o ctt- "
fi: o
9b
oI*&Han*-
O
Oci-
0
k *t
*1n j 1 i
p
10tH1r-
*o -1T
IH l* j
LI
1 -j
Vj
tor* CL
CPtPOi*
OO
'OJ
'Of UH> M*
2
002366
Sijae 2
CQi:7H?2j?IAL'
Subject to Protective Order in. Foss v Conoco, lug., Kg, 2Q-47
' 14th Judicial district
. -Calcasieu
jLswtliSjUisia.
RESULTS
In comparison with the.two control groups,, the following
STATISTICALLY SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCES (P < 0.05) WERE FOUND IN
THE LIVER OF THE VINYL CHLORIDE EXPOSED BEFORE ANY SIGN OF PHYSICAL OR CLINICAL ABNORMALITIES WERE SEEN. 1. AN ELEVATION OF NON-PROTEIN SULFHYDRYL CONTENT.
2, AN ELEVATION OF GLUTATHIONE REDUCTASE.
3. AN ELEVATION OF GLUTATHIONE EPOXIDE "S" TRANSFERASE (gEST).
4, AN ELEVATION OF GLUTATHIONE ARALKYL -S- TRANSFERASE (GAST). 5. A REDUCTION OF P-450 CONTENT.
6, AN ELEVATION OF. GLUCOSE-6-PHOSPHATE DEHYDROGENASE
CMa 002367 28
(70) 4 (140) TIME IN WEEKS (HRS) `
61 'NON-PROTEIN SULFHYDRYL GROUP CONTENT IN LIVER
ju. moles per gram
o--
roC/J.p-'Lno^JOO'Oo
a-
B9ZZ00 VWO
-- ro
EH3
oZ
73
~min
^///////////////////////////////^
FTOh
i--]--i
.<
n
*
m X -o
Ym >
73
m X ; TJ
.1 .........
n b=l
^
6 (210)
S lide 3
Wrtrf&T^r'j
nefsEOt^O
3 - '.r-'-rr-r *-n
`yyj;--
. . : --
--__ ~ ----- ^ --r ZJEiqng
Subject
S2Siv' "~Jv'aaf"District Court
5th
-
LIVER GLUTATHIONE REDUCTASE
10O x y moles per minute per ms proto In
o - 10 <0 -s* <n o> *! 00
CD
o
>
I-
< p m
X ro
4
,ec. cD Foss y, Ccno-o,
Cri=r In *n - 4337
14th Judicial listri'-t Court Calcasieu Parish,, Louisiana
LIVER
GLUTATHIONE EPOXIDE -S- TRANSFERASE
100 x p|i per minute per mg protein
o-*rotAcn<j>-jooo-^
tow-*'1
TIME IN WEEK (HRS)
m x TO
-rSKSSW'.
LIVER
GLUTATHIONE ARALKYL - S- TRANSFERASE
10 x jj moles per minute per mg protein to w
(70) 4 (140) TIME IN WEEKS (HRS)
6 (210)
m
32
CMA 002371
co
cu <0 o\
20
18
TIME IN WEEKS (..HRS)
COXFIjDI'TTT AT,
Subject to Fro to SoS3 v. Ccro"t
14th juTi.ir;rv,
Calcasieu Parish,
Grf=r tn
. f--- rO-1837 -"oct Court Louisiana
to
J
4k ai 00
T] I rT
P-450 CONTENT IN LIVER
n molai pr gram
4 o to
ml O)
Jilt Mii 3--
Nto)
fO 4k
to O)
M O
o: O
s
2 o X 3:
>
r*
< n
%
m x 70
33 CMA 002372
0033
IMMUNOPATHOLOGY OF VC-ASSOCIATED LIVER ANGIOSARCOMA AND THE EFFECTS OF INDUSTRIAL CHEMICALS ON ANTIGEN ANTIBODIES
E. Espinosa, M.D.
It has long been known that chemicals can modify antibodies in antigens
of serums, and tissues. The measuring of these changes, hopefully, would lead
to an early detection of the chemical-associated diseases and provide an approach to study the pathogenesis of such disorders. Chemicals or their metabolites can modify antibodies or antigens due to their strong interaction
with proteins affecting the quality and quantity of these proteins. Secondly,
their measurement may lead to early detection and understanding of the patho
genesis of this injury. The first slide summarized briefly our iramunopathologic
observations, in VC-associated angiosarcoma.
COgFIDBIITTAT.
ubject to Protective Cr^r in
P0S3 v. :r:coo.
-o. VO-4337
_.14th Judioinl District Court
Calcasieu Parish. Louisiana
Slide 1
IMMUNOPATHOLOGY OF VC-ASSOCIATED LIVER ANGIOSARCOMA
A. Antigens investigated in liver angiosarcoma: 1. Tumor-associated antigen 2. Antigens shared with tissues: CTA-2, STA-3 3. Antigens shared with bile: BT-1, BT-2, BT-3 4. Antigens with liver specificity
B. Tumor bound IgG
C. Antigens deleted
I 35
0023'74 CFlft.
Firstly, four classes of protein antigens were detected by immunodiffusion and immunofluorescent in the liver tumors: a tumor associated antigen; antigens shared with tissues; antigens shared with bile; and antigens with liver specificity. Studies of the physicochemical properties of these antigens and their presence in circulation have been completed and reported (on some of these antigens, while additional studies are being continued on the other antigens).
We have also reported the presence of IgG binding to liver tumors, indicating that these tumors do produce antigens which stimulate B cell antibodies. Work is still in progress to identify the antigen which stimulates such antibody production.
Our third major finding is related to the deletion of normal antigens in the angiosarcoma tumor. This deletion of normal antigens has recently stimulated similar analysis in chemically induced hepatomas in rats. Similarly to the angiosarcoma-, two tissue antigens were found to be missing in these hepatomas. Studies are now being conducted concerning the properties of these antigens and the significance of their deletion. It may well be that the deletion of certain antigens may be a more sensitive indicator of tumor development.
Table 1 demonstrates the frequency of circulating tissue antigens in various clinical disorders in patients with various liver and non-liver diseases. One finds that circulating tissue antigen-2 (CTA-2) has been found most frequently in acute hepatocellular injury such as in acute viral hepatitis and acute alcoholic hepatitis but to a lesser degree in chronic forms of disease such as cirrhosis and carcinoma and not at all in those with liver angiosarcoma. This data would lend further support to the concept that the presence of tissue bound antigens or their deletion are better markers of tumor development than those in circulation.
CMA 002375
' CIRCULATING TISSUE ANTIGEN
TABLE 1 Frequency of CTA--2 in patients with liver diseases,
other'diseases and healthy subjects
Patients-
No.tested
Acute hepatitis: Infectious Serum Alcoholic
Liver cirrhosis Obstructive jaundice Liver angiosarcoma Pancreatitis Pneumonia Congestive heart failure Myocardial infarction Carcinomas Newborns Healthy controls-
29 9 8
28 5 3 8
22 39 23 35 12 48
No; with CTA-2
23 (79%) 7 (77%) 3 (62%) 8 (28%) 1 (20%) 0 ( 0%) 2 (25%) 2 ( 9%) 8 (20%) 3 (13%) 8 (23%) 0 ( 0%)
0 ( 0%)
CMA 002376 37
A SEARCH FOR EVIDENCE OF A VINYL CHLORIDE-INDUCED TUMOR ANTIGEN H.P. Fortwengler, M.S., and C.H. Tamburro, M.D.
New antigens arise on tumors formed as a response to carcinogens. Their presence on methylcholanthrene-induced sarcomas was discovered by Foley in 1953. This discovery in mice was verified and extended by Prehn and Main in 1957 to conclude that there were antigens peculiar to and specific for tumor tissue. Subsequently, evidence for tumor antigens was found in humans by the Hellstroms, Vankey, Halliday and Malulsh, Thompscn and others. The majority of the evidence suggested that the tumor antigens found were distinctive for each histological type of tumor.
In an effort to capitalize on the well established fact that the body mounts an immune reaction to cancer, Fortwengler's group is endeavoring to find evidence of these specific immune reactions and then utilize them to develop a relatively specific test for possible VC induced tumor development. Lymphocytes (the cells responsible for immunity) from the individual tested are being isolated by density gradient centrifugation. These cells are then grown in the presence of a liver reagent prepared from either a normal individual or an individual who had angiosarcoma. A positive reaction is a three times Increased incorporation of H^-thymidine Into stimulated cultures.
A comparison of the responses between vinyl chloride plant workers and normal non-vinyl chloride workers Indicated that there were many people in the general population having reactivity to tissue antigens Irrespective of whether it was from angle or normal liver. Non-specific reactions of this type may be due to sensitization by "natural" means, injections of human or animal substances, transfusions, et,c. The reactions of lymphocytes to normal and angio liver were quantitated.
A comparison of the responses to angio or normal liver by VC workers according to known VC exposure was made. The VC workers were grouped as either
C0ffPI3)ZK?tat. Subject-to Protective Order In
21 ?-
So. 90. - ; ;7
14th Judicial district Court
.. Calcasieu Pariah, Louisiana
38
CMA 002377
high exposure or low exposure depending on whether they had exposure above the median plant exposure. As can be seen in Figure 1, no statistical differences were noted between the two groups.
On the chance that the non-specific reactions may be obscuring the specific reactions all those VC workers having reactions to both angio liver and normal liver were grouped (see Table 1). Those with reactions to normal liver only were grouped as were those with no reactions. That left only those with reactions to angio liver. As can be seen in Table 1, the only reactions obtained with possible specific tumor reactivity were found in the group of VC workers.
These results, although provocative, must be extended by testing additional VC workers but more importantly by testing a comparison group of individuals having no known VC exposure. Our plans for the future include an expansion of the above data and a slight reorganization of experimental design to ensure maximal statistical strength from the data obtained.
CMA 002378 39
Figure 1
LYMPHOCYTE RESPONSE OF VC WORKERS ACCORDING TO EXPOSURE ;
CONFIDENTIAL
Subject to Protective Order Pars v, Ccr.oro, Inc,., Ho, eo-4837c-
14th Judicial District Court ......Calcasieu Parish,, Louisiana
iilil 'ABOVE MEDIAN' CN=54)
K'- -crna
BELOW MEDIAE;
n) 11
cn ' p'fel
%
jxjivir
'r~~Lr;
ANGIOSARCOMA .ANTIGEN EXTRACT'
LIVER ANTIGEN''extract;
I. #
-i
19 40
ANGIO LIVER
NORMAL AND ANGIO LIVER
( O'ioi^e, ( LYMPHOCYTE REACTIVITY TO TUMOR AMD NORMAL TISSUE PANEL
08^00 vwo
VINYL CHLORIDE WORKERS n ' percentage ' 6 16
18
NON-VINYL CHLORIDE WORKERS n_ percentage
INTERPRETATION OP . RESULTS
0. 0 ;'
Individuals with possible specific anti-tumor reac-*:* tivities.'
fH
8 57
Individuals with nonspecific reactivities masking any possible specific reac tivities.
NORMAL LIVER
5 13
'1 7
Individuals with nonspecific reactivities.
NONREACTIVE
20 53
5 36
Individuals with no tissue reactivities.
TOTAL
38 100
16 100
HLA FREQUENCIES IN VINYL CHLORIDE WORKERS H.P. Fortwengler, M.S., and C.H. Tamburro, M.D.
Mulvihill In the Journal of the National Cancer Institute in 1976 stated
that a challenge to science is to develop a means of screening potential em
ployees for abnormal genotypes that predispose them to. neoplasia after occupa
tional exposure which are harmless to normal genotypes.
An increased incidence of certain HLA types has been shown to be as
sociated with susceptibility to various diseases. HLA-A27 antigen has been
found more often in workers suspected of having the occupational disease asbestosis
than among a control population. HLA tissue typing procedures have been initiated in our laboratory and
we have typed approximately 300 individuals from the Louisville vinyl chloride
polymerization plant. Individuals do not change their genetic complement of HLA
antigens, so the determinations need not be repeated periodically as in various
clinical assays. Tissue typing for 11 HLA-A antigens and 16 HLA-B antigens and
their possible increased association with angiosarcoma or other chemically re
lated diseases is about one-third completed. A comparison between those employees found to have liver disease, labeled
"Pallet Plant", and those without liver disease, labeled "Non-Pallet Plant", may be seen in Tables 1 and 2. Although the number of individuals tested is not as
yet large enough to allow statistical significance to emerge, potential difference
in frequencies may be seen at A9, B15, B27, and B17. As an additional procedural and population check, our compiled data is being
compared with the frequencies obtained by two other large HLA studies. Frequencies of the healthy individuals studied by Scott et al, 1977, and the World Health
Organization compare favorably to the frequencies found in the University of
Louisville study,
*These are individuals who because of their liver disease, were initially reassigned to a shop manufacturing wooden pallets.
COitTIDTHTTIAL Subject to Protective Order in
ss_v. Conoco. Inc.. To. 90-4837 14th Judicial District Court
... Calcasieu Parish,, Louisiana
^
CMA 002381
It has been clearly established that the larger the population studied
the greater the chances of obtaining statistically significant data. The accumu
lation of HLA data on the majority of the VC population plant workers will take
an additional two years as originally anticipated. This is necessary so that
the strongest statistical analysis can be performed upon the completion of all
HLA testing.
Suject'Tr
fV. /",,
* ' c.
14 t >
Ccasieu'r1
c,~i33?
eu -Parish t Co'^t " ^uisiana
CMA 002382 43
HLA - A FREQUENCIES IN VINYL CHLORIDE WORKERS
HLA " A
ANTIGENS
HEALTHY CONTROLS**
who 1975
WORKSHOP
UL/PALLET PLANT***
ul/non-pallet PLANT
A1 34
A2 51
A3 23
A9 16
A10 7
' All . '
" 13
A28 7
A29 ; AW19
9 j^ID*#**
AW30 ^ - ND
AW31
ND
AW32
ND
BLANK'
ND
N TOTAL FREQ,
900 160%
32 49 22 17 -.13 8 11 ' 7 28 5 7 8 ND '
6877 207%
38 58 20 8 12' 8 20 ; -0 ND 8 4 8 16
24 200%
30/ 53 . 18 23 7 10 . 13 7 ND 3 7 7 21'
.243 v' 199%
CURRENTLY TYPING FOR 11 ANTIGENS
SCOTT ET AL,, 1977
COiTFIDEffTI-AT.
DATA COMPILED JUNE/ 1978
Subject to 'Protective Order 'In
NOT DONE
'
- 0S^- v' .Conoco, Inc., Ho. 90-4837
14th Judicial District Court
' Calcasieu Parish,,-.Louisiana
CMA 002383
44
HU - B FREQUENCIES IN VINYL CHLORIDE WORKERS
HLA - B,, antigens*
HEALTHY CONTROLS
1975 who
. WORKSHOP
B5 10 11 .
B7 .
31
23
B8 27 20
B12 B13
30 - 24 3 76
B14
; 5
11
B15
10
.7
B18 B27
..-;T-
8 7
;9
8'
B37 ND**** 5
m 11 12
BW16
. ND.
12 .
BW21 , . '= ND 7
4
BW22 BW35
2
. 5V
5 17.-'
B17 6 . 7
BLANK '
ND
ND
N 900 TOTAL FREQ. 155%
6877 181%
* CURRENTLY TYPING FOR 16 ANTIGENS ** SCOTT ET AL.> 1977 ** DATA COMPILED JUNE., 1978
;WQT M^IDS'TTIAL-
*
'
Fuhject to Frotectiva
in
r ? = g v. Ccr.ooo, Ino. , Wo, OO - 4337
i4th
r;.cj-.-'i.-'!; Court
gliy Parish, Louisiana
ul/pallet PLANT***
ul/non-pallet PLANT
.8 7
22 28
16 .. 22
26 ..
.o
,25. .
7".
-
6
.
12."
.. .12 1
38 12 7
02
0
4-
16 77
. 12 1
17;
0 . ; .7 2 .
774 . :' 4
7 74.
. '6`:.
8 13
22 7 10
* '
. ..
12 14
24 192% .
.243 193%.
v ..
. . -
CMA 002384
EVALUATION OF IMMUNOCOMPETENCE OF HUMANS CHRONICALLY EXPOSED TO VINYL CHLORIDE
H.P. Fortwengler, M.S., and C.H. Tamburro, M.D.
It has been demonstrated that lymphoid cells (T cells) can be cytotoxic to human tumor cells and are often found decreased in cancer patients. Viola, et al, reported the development of neoplasms in rats exposed to vinyl chloride (VC). Creech and others reported the increased incidence of human angiosarcoma in VC production workers. It is the purpose of this study to determine the immuno-
competence of individuals that have undergone prolonged exposure to VC monomer and have developed liver lesions which, in some instances, are thought to presage the development of angiosarcoma.
The scientific literature is replete with demonstrations of lmmunodepression as shown by one or more Immune parameters in cancer patients at various stages of disease. There is very little information in the scientific literature con cerning immunoevaluation prior to diagnosis of frank malignance. We have used im munological assays (see Table 1) that have demonstrated usefulness in indicating
imraunodepression in cancer patients. These tests have been used to evaluate the immunocompetence of Individuals
with possible pre-malignant lesions or other liver disease as demonstrated by biopsy. A comparison of these diseased individuals with normal plant workers demon strated nothing to suggest that the groups were immunologically different. A com parison of those individuals having high VC exposure (defined as those with lifetime exposure above the median) with individuals having low exposure (below the plant median VC exposure) demonstrated a slight pattern of lmmunodepresslon (see Fig. 1) when lymphocytes were stimulated by PHA and Con A. Preliminary evaluation of this data indicated there is no statistical significance between the high and low exposure groups when examined with student's t test. Even-after additional immunological parameters were examined (see Table 2), no statistical differences could be found
between the two groups.
CONFIDEffTIAL
CMa"' 002385
Subset to Protective Order in Boss v. Conoso, Inc.. Ho, 90-4337
14th Judicial District Court V'., Calcasieu Parish,, Louisiana
At this time, our preliminary interpretation of these results, which will soon undergo a more complete data analysis, is that there is no residual immunological depression as a result of chronic .exposure to increased levels of VC as determined by our standard battery of immunological tests.
Further computer analysis of our data in addition to concomitant cor relations with data being received from clinical testing (e.g. immunoglobulin quantitation) will give us more definitive statistical results.
Subject fE-.uoss v. ic -. j'o ,
I'io. of).,;
14th Judicial District Court .Ca.loa.sieu Parish ,, Louisiana
CMA 002386 47
TEST
BATTERY OF IMMUNOCOMFETENCE TESTS IN USE REASON FOR USE
TABLE 1
Absolute Lymphocyte Count SRBC Rosettes, 4C
SRBC Rosettes, 33C
PHA Stimulation
Con A Stimulation
PWM Stimulation
SPL Stimulation
Recall Antigenic Stimulation SLO PPD Candida Varidase
Gives a gross examination of the immune system
Quantitates the total number and percent of T cells. (T cfells can reject tumors and transplants.)
Quantitates the total number and percent of an active subset of T cells
Tests the ability of T cells to respond to a non-specific stimulant
Tests the non-specific function of T cells; overlaps, but not identical to PHA
Tests the non-specific function of T cells; has B cell participation
Tests the non-specific function of T cells; has B and Null cell participation
Determines the ability of sensitized lymphocytes to be activated by rechallenge; everyone should react with at least one of these common antigens
**A
Sublet to Trotwtiw Ora--
Soss v. 0 ona oo <
,c t
"14th Judicial District Court
Calcasieu .Parish ,, ^ Louisian
' COHriBSUTIAL
' Subject to Protective Order1 iri Boss v. Conoco, Inc., No. Sd~4$3tf ' 14th Judicial District Court? (v Calcasieu Parish#,
CMA 002387
48
Figure 1
LYMPHOCYTE RESPONSE OF VC MORES ACCORDING TO EXPOSURE:
300
250 =
200
f
J50 =
100 =
50 f=
fat:-
ofe*
l\V.V
m
1
fl
H S'-
il
*-
-
11
S.v'.v ji: &:::1
*
: PHAi
CON-A
' " COSFIDBflTIAI.
Subject tq Protective O
in.
`n3 T. Ccnoob, Iiio., "b- PO-4837
iv.-i Judicial district Co art
Measles JParlsi* i^slsiasa-
49
I| ABOVE MEDIAN (N=5N) .. BELCW MEDIAN (N=2A)
illi
X ft
. .
fM
fll
PWM
CMA 002388
Table 2 ADDITIONAL IMMGNE PARAMETERS OF VC WORKERS ACCORDING TO EXPOSURE
TEST
Above Median Exposure
SPL Stimulation
Absolute Lymphocyte Count
191 31 <n= 52)
2355 + 132 (n= 52)
SRBC Rosettes, 4C
1508 + 101 (n=* 50)
SRBC Rosettes, 33C 1227 + 80 .. <n-50)
Below Median Esposure
,Statistical Difference Between Groups
186' * 34 (n=24)
2316 + 148 (n- 24)
None None
1524 + 132 (n=**~24)
None
1260 + 123 (n-24)
: .None
Recall Stimulation SLO- -
8+2 (n" 53)
PPD Candida Varidase
29 + 8 (n- 49)
t
11 + 3 (n* 53)
29 + 5 (n- 54)
\
24 + 12 (n= 24)
None
18 +. 6 (n=~23)
None
6+2 <n- 23)
41 + 12 <n-"23)
None. None
oUDject to Protectiyo Order Aao=o. Inc.._ go S0-i
14th Judicial District Cour v., Calcasieu Parish,, Louisians
(-
CMA 002389
50
TISSUE AND URINARY GLYCOSAMINOCLYCANS IN HEPATIC FIBROSIS AND HEPATIC CANCER Charles E. Kupchella, Fh.D.
Because characteristic glycosaminoglycan (GAG) changes have been found in many kinds of tumors and in tissues undergoing fibrogenesis, and because they have been shown to be present in large amounts in blood vessels, and because tissue GAG changes have been shown to be reflected in urinary excretion in certain disease states, we asked the question: "Are there characteristic glycosaminoglycan changes associated with hepatic angiosarcoma and other chemically-induced diseases of the liver and are they reflected in urinary excretion such that they are exploitable in early detection and/or diagnosis?" To date we have found that:
1. Human hepatic angiosarcoma is accompanied by elevated hepatic GAGs. (1)
2. The GAGs in the angiosarcomatous tumors are different from those in fibrotic tissue adjacent to-the tumors. (1)
3. Angiosarcoma and hepatoma patients have characteristic urinary GAG patterns -- patterns not found in workers
__with non-angiosarcomatous liver injury. (2)
4. Heparan sulfate (a type of GAG) is elevated in hepatic tissue undergoing experimentally induced fibrosis and heparan sulfate is elevated in the urine of such animals.(3)
. 5. Yet, uncharacterized, chondroitin sulfates and hyaluronic acid levels -- but not heparin -- are 3-4 fold higher in experimentally transplanted hepatomas than in normal liver and urinary excretion reflects both the tumor GAG composi tion and the size of tumors.
6. Livers of animals bearing metastasizing hepatoma (5123tc) have 50-fold greater concentrations of a non-sulfated, neutral, uronic, acid-positive material than is found in the livers of animals bearing two other, non-metastasizing hepatomas.
Glycosaminoglycans are important in the etiologies of both hepatic fibrosis and hepatic cancer. To date, our work indicates that different GAGs are involved in these processes.. We feel that the roles of the GAGs in the hepatic fibrogenesis and as partial determinants of cancer cell behavior are of such importance that GAG-directed strategies may be evolved for the control of these diseases as well as for their detection and diagnosis. (See Slides
1 and 2).
*der in ?0-4837
51
CMA 002390
REFERENCES 1. Kupchella, C. E. and Tamburro, C. H., Urinary and Tissue
Glycosaminoglycan Patterns in Hepatic Angiosarcoma. In: Detection and Prevention of Cancer, H. E. Nieburgs, Eds., Part 1, Volume 1, Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York. 2. Curran, K. L., Kupchella, C. E., and Tamburro, C, H., Urinary Glycosaminoglycans Patterns in Angiosarcoma of the Liver. Cancer 40:3050-3053, 1977. 3. Kupchella, C. E. , Jarvis, J. 0., Curran, K. L., Greenberg, R. A., and Tamburro, C. H., Changes in Tissue and Urinary Glycosaminoglycans in Chemically-Induced Hepatic Fibrosis in the Rat. (Submitted)
Subject to Protective Order in Ross v. Conoco, Ins., No. 90'4337
14th Judicial District Court .... Calcasieu Parish,, Louisiana
52 CMA 002391
COHFI-INTIAXi
Subject to Pro-:active Order in Foss v. r;vo"C. Ivc . . i'.'q . 90 - 4837
14th Juiiorzl Oitcrict Court Calcasieu Pariah,, Lewleian*
SLIDE 1
Kupchella, et al.
LIST OF STUDIES/EXPERIMENTS COMPLETED TO DATE AND THOSE IN PROGRESS -
1. Evaluate urinary GAG excretion total in 50 human samples -- angiosarcomas, hepatic fibrosis, normal controls, hepatitis, etc.
2. Evaluated human hepatic angiosarcoma, hepatoma cirrhotic liver tissues GAGs (10 cases).
3. Evaluated tissue and urinary GAG patterns in animals undergoing CCl^induced fibrosis (48 animals) at 3, 6, and 9 weeks (histochem/biochem).
4. Repeated if 3 evaluating at 1, 2, and 3 weeks (42 animals) histology/ biochemistry.
5. Evaluating urinary and tissue GAG patterns in animals bearing different behavioral types of transplantable hepatomas (42 animals).
6. Evaluating tissue and urinary GAG patterns in animals following partial hepatectomy,
7. Evaluating diurnal variation in urinary GAG excretion in two angiosarcoma cases (vs. normal).
Compared urinary GAG patterns in workers with known normal and known diseased livers -- 24 workers (complete fractionations using Dowex 1X2 exchange).
8. Compared urinary GAG patterns with other non-invasive tests as to diagnostic value. One hundred-twenty (120) samples (used occasional samples with creatinine determinations).
9. Evaluating the contribution made to urinary GAG excretion by hepatic necrosis (experimentally induced ischemic necrosis in rats).
CMA 002392 53
CMA 0 0 2 3 9 3
NOTE :
These are some preliminary da athered in our transplantable hepatoma studies. These studies are designed to evaluate the relationship between tumor GAG composition and various tumor properties (growth rate, metastatic potential, etc.) and to evaluate urinary GAG excretion as a function of tumor size.
TABLE: URONIC ACID LEVELS BY GAG FRACTION IN MORRIS HEPATOMA TISSUE; LIVER OF TUMOR BEARING ANIMALS; AND, NORMAL LIVER
TUMOR 7777
TUMOR 5123
TUMOR 9618
LIVER 7777
SLIDE 2
LIVER 5123
1 LIVER 9618
NORMAL LIVER
0,03 M NaCl NON-GAG CARBOHYDRATES
176 + 38 176 + 15 524 + 81 664 + 203 6770+1629 455 + 146 950 + 340
0.4 M NaCl HYALURONIC ACID
90 + 10 91 + 12 111 + 9 40 + 8
41+5
49 + 10 25 + 3
1.2 M NaCl CHONDROITIN SULFATE
261 +29 217 + 51 208 + 22 68 + 23
58+5
41 + 10 47 + 7
2.1 M NaCl HEPARIN
31+7
17 + 4
67 + 11 17+3
i
28 + 6
31 + 7
39 + 10
1-T Ti;'f WT___
=m `
`o.GLOj' -a/geoj
U\ japap OATqoaq-Qjj Q1 3-Sofqns
iviitMaaiLiiioD
i tiC. j, o
N. ...jM.l;,
I'ruUcd n U.S-A.
URINARY GLYCOSAMINOGLYCAN PATTERNS IN ANGIOSARCOMA OF THE LIVER
Kevin L. Curran, BA, MS, Charles E. Kupchella, PhD, and Carlo H. Tamrurro, MD
Glycosaminoglycans extracted front 24-hour urine specimens from patients with hepatic angiosarcoma and from normal/controls were separated as cetylpyridinium complexes into "hyaluronic acid," "chondroitin sulfate," and "heparin" fractions, then further separated and characterised by anion-ex change chromatography and hyaluronidase susceptibility. The chromato graphic pattern of the urinary chondroitin sulfate fraction in patients with angiosarcoma of the liver differed from those of controls in that there was a relative increase in the total amount of uronic acid in a hyaluronidase-resistant fraction and a decrease in a fraction susceptible to hyaluronidase digestion. These changes appeared to become more pronounced with advancing disease. Chromatographic patterns and determinations of hyaluronidase susceptibility indicated that the resistant fraction was heparan sulfate and that the susceptible fraction was chondroitin-4-sulfatc and/or chondroitin--sulfate.
Canctr 40:3050-3053, 1977.
HP he emergence of angiosarcoma of the
J- liver and its relationship to vinyl chloride
exposure4,7 has prompted a search for methods
to detect this lesion. Although systematic
screening programs are currently in opera tion, I0," there is still no single chemical in dicator which' is specific for angiosarcoma or for
changes which may precede this disease. The association of elevated tissue glycosami-
noglycans (GAG) with tumors, including angio
sarcoma, has been established.
Glyco-
saminoglycans are also known to be involved in
normal connective tissue synthesis and collagen deposition and are elevated in connective tissue disorders.15 Since angiosarcoma of the liver has
both neoplasia and fibrogenesis in its etiology17 GAG changes could be expected to serve to sig
nal the appearance of early lesions and may be
useful in evaluating advanced lesions.
Galambos* suggested that since the liver con
tributes very little to the overall connective tissue
of the body, hepatic fibrogenesis should not be
expected to result in significant increases in
From the University of Louisville, Cancer Center, and the Price Institute for Surgical Research Health Sciences Cen ter. Louisville, Kentucky 40201.
This work was supported in part by an American Cancer Society Institutional Grant, IN'-I 11, a gram from the 0. F. Goodrich Company, and contract NOI-CN-552I2 with the National Cancer Institute.
Address for reprints: C. E. Kupchella, Cancer Center, University of Louisville, Louisville, KY 40201.
Accepted for publication April 15, 1077.
urinary GAG or collagen degradative or syn thetic products. Preliminary studies in our labo ratory, however, demonstrated an increase in both liver and urinary GAG in patients with angiosarcoma, chronic active hepatitis, and cir rhosis.16 Most of the increase in urinary GAG occurred in the chondroitin sulfate fraction and, in contrast to what was found for normal and other diseases, the urinary chondroitin sulfate fraction was the only uronic acid positive fraction found in the urine of seven of nine cases of vinylehloride-exposure-associated liver injury other than angiosarcoma. This study was undertaken to characterize more completely the urinary "chondroitin sulfate" fraction in hepatic angio sarcoma.
Clinical Summaries
Case 1--(Hepatic Angiosarcoma--advanced)
A 46-year-old white male worked as a chemical helper in a vinyl chloride polymerization plant for thirteen years prior to the diagnosis of angiosarcoma. Twelve years after initial employment, the patient exhibited a persistent elevation of lactic dehy drogenase and underwent angiographic studies which demonstrated multiple areas of scattered tumor stain throughout both lobes of the liver with areas of central translucency consistent with the diagnosis of angio sarcoma of the liver.
Exploratory laparotomy and liver biopsy confirmed this diagnosis, and the patient was treated with adriamycin, cyclophosphamide, and methotrexate; an
COHFIDEHTIAL^
Subject to Prot^;iV";o0r00r-4i337
'o::0 v Onoc-o--,----D---i-s-"t^ru"i^-r1 t
" " --cfcu-i-- Calcasieu Parish,
Louisiana"
3050 55
CMA 002394
MOLARITY NoCI
No. 6
GLYCOSAMi.VOGLVCA.NS l,\ Angiosarcoma
Curran et at.
3051
initial response was associated with a decrease in the alkaline phosphatase activity, improvement in in docyanine green clearance and an increase in radio isotopic uptake in areas of previously defective up take. After completion of the chemotherapy course, hepatic function deteriorated and the patient under went partial hepatic lobe radiation (total dose of
5,000 rads) over a two-month period. Despite radia tion therapy, the clinical course continued to deterio rate with the development of ascites, peripheral edema, increasing jaundice, hypoalbumincmia, and marked elevations of transaminases and alkaline phosphatase activities. This was followed by progres sive hepatic failure, hepatorenal syndrome and he patic coma. Autopsy findings showed extensive in volvement of the liver with angiosarcomatous tissue extending into the diaphragm and metastasis to retro peritoneal and mediastinal lymph nodes, lungs, right adrenal gland and cerebellum. The right lobe of the liver demonstrated near elimination of the angiosar coma, presumably due to the radiation treatment. Urinary GAG assays reported here were made on 24hour urine specimens collected over the two-week period before death (Fig. 1).
NORMAL URINE
_r?r i-sii _1_J^
HEPATIC ANGIOSARCOMA
O *0
o
<
o z c3e
IA
HEPATIC ANGIOSARCOMA--Advanced
_T X
,I--'
V,_, g-
J
--3 -2
-i .z
Case 2 (Hepatic Angiosarcoma--moderately advanced)
A 54-year-old vinyl chloride polymerization worker was first employed as a polymerization vat cleaner 28 years prior to the diagnosis of angiosarcoma. Two years prior to diagnosis, the patient had persistent biochemical liver, abnormalities although he was oth erwise asymptomatic with a normal liver-spleen scan. Angiographic studies showed pciiosis hepatis. A liver biopsy revealed focal sinusoidal dilatation, mild chronic inflammatory reaction with portal fibrosis, Kupffer cell hyperplasia and dysplasia. Subsequent biopsies demonstrated continued sinusoidal dilitation, atypical and dysplastic Kupffer cells with premalignant changes. The peliosis hepatis pattern be came more pronounced and multiple radioisotopic defects were evident on liver scan. A repeat biopsy one year after initial biochemical abnormality demon strated malignant sinusoidal cells. The patient was treated with a combination of adriamycin, cytoxan, and methotrexate with limited clinical and biochemi cal response. Death was preceded by peripheral edema, ascites, progressive hepatic failure, and coma. The GAG analyses reported here were made 10 and 6 months before death (Fig. 1, [middle]).
Materials and Methods
Twenty-four hour urine specimens were col lected from two patients with angiosarcoma of the liver, and from two normal controls.
Urine specimens were stored at --70C until analysis. Cetylpyridinium chloride (Sigma Chemical Company, St. Louis) was added to the entire 24-hour volume to precipitate the GAGs
Fig. 1, Elution Patterns of the Urinary Chondroitin Sul fate Fraction. The glycotaminoglycans (GAC) in a 24-hour urine specimen were precipitated with cetylpyridinium chlo ride (CPC) and separated as 0.4 M NaCl soluble ("hyalu ronic acid"), 1.2 M NaCl soluble ("chondroitin sulfate"), and 2.1 M NaCl soluble ("heparin") fractions. Each fraction was then subjected to anion-exchange chromatography. Shown here are typical 1.2 M (chondroitin sulfate) fraction elution patterns (Advanced = case 1).
according to the method of DiFerrante.* The hyaluronic acid, chondroitin sulfate, and hepa rin fractions were eluted individually according to the method of Schiller el at. ** Cetylpyridinium chloride was removed14 and the GAGs were sub jected to anion-exchange chromatography as de scribed by Schiller et al.'* Glycosaminoglycan fractions were applied to 1.0 X 44 cm AG1-X2 (200-400 mesh, chloride form) columns Bio Rad Laboratories, Richmond, California) and eluted stepwise with 0.0, 0.5, 1.0, 1.25, 1.50, 2.0, and 3.0 M NaCl. At a flow rate of 1.0 ml/min, approximately sixteen 10.3 ml fractions of each molar strength of NaCl were collected and a sample of each fraction was analyzed for uronic acid by the method of Bitter and Muir.1 Stan dards of heparin (Nutritional Riochemical Com pany), chondroitin sulfate (Sigma Chemical Company), and hyaluronic acid (Nutritional Biochemical Company) were also evaluated by ion exchange chromatography.
The uronic-acid-positive fractions within each individual salt fraction were pooled, dialyzed to remove salt, and concentrated. The fractions eluted by 1.25 or 1.50 M NaCl were tested for
_qSS tt , LO * rtecti^rHT- -
jn--dlci , 7 - - ' So.- 9900-.44837 .Calcasieu Parish ^lct curt
Lomslana,
023 9S
3052
Cancer December 1977
Vol. 40
Table 1.
Source
Ratio of Total Uronic Acid Eluted in 1.25 M/1.5 M NaCl
Normal Normal Angiosarcoma, case 2,
pre-chemotherapy1 Angiosarcoma, ease 2,
post-chemotherapy* Angiosarcoma, case 1,
advanced
0.364 0.316
0.843 0.971
5.000
Note: The glycosaminoglyeans (GAG) in a 24-hour urine specimen were precipitated with eetylpyridinium chloride (CPC) and separated as 0.4 M NaCl soluble ("hyaluronic acid"), 1.2 M NaCl soluble ("chondroitin sulfate"), and 2.1 M NaCl soluble ("heparin") fractions. The CPC was removed from the 1.2 M NaCl-CPCsolubilieed fraction and the GAGs further purified by anion-exchange chromatography. The total amount of GAG in the resulting 1.25 M and 1,50 M NaCl columneluted fractions was determined and the ratio of the two fractions was calculated. ('One day prior to begin ning of chemotherapy; 'Two days following chemotherapy initiation.)
acid and heparin fractions revealed no qualita tive differences between controls and angiosar coma patients. The anion exchange column pat terns of the 1.2 M NaCl solubilized GAGs are shown in Fig. 1. Chromatography of the urinary "chondroitin sulfate" fractions of patients with angiosarcoma yielded a comparatively large, uronic-acid positive peak in 1.25 M NaCl. The ratios of the total amount of uronic acid-positive material eluted with 1.25 M NaCl to the total amount eluted with 1.50 M NaCl are given in Table 1.
The susceptibility of the GAGs eluted with 1.25 or 1.50 M NaCl to hyaluronidase degrada tion is given in Table 2. The GAG eluted with 1.25 M NaCl was resistant to hyaluronidase, the enzyme producing only a 43% reduction in tur bidity. The 1.50 M NaCI-eluted GAG fraction was 100% susceptible to hyaluronidase degrada tion.
Discussion and Conclusion
susceptibility to testicular hyaluronidase (Nutri tional Biochemical Company) using a modifica tion of the cetyltrimethylammonium-bromide, turbidimetric assay described by DiFerrante.*
Results
The major GAG fraction observed in all urines--both from normal controls or from pa tients with angiosarcoma--was the fraction so lubilized by 1.2 M NaCl/1% eetylpyridinium chloride (the "chondroitin sulfate" fraction). Anion exchange chromatography of hyaluronic
Table 2. Hyaluronidase Susceptibility
Source
Depolymerizatton %'
Heparin, standard Hyaluronic acid, standard Chondroitin sulfate, standard 1.25 M NaCl cohimn-eluate, pooled
fractions from angiosarcomatous patients 1.50 M NaClcolumn-cluate, pooled fractions from angiosarcomatous patients 1.50 M NaCl column-eluate. normal
5.0 93.1 97.6
43.5
100.0 100.0
1 Gtycosaminoglycans isolated from urine were tested for hyaluronidase susceptibility by measuring changes in turbidity developed with the addition of cetyltrimethylammonium bromide following incubation with hyaluronidase Normal controls exhibited only minor amounts of 1.25 M NaCl column-eluted GAG and consequently do not ap pear in this table.
The chromatographic pattern found here for controls conforms to urinary glycosaminoglycan distributions reported by others.11,11 These pat terns suggest that there was a relative increase in urinary heparan sulfate and a decrease in chondroitin-4- and/or -6-sulfate in patients with hepatic angiosarcoma. This interpretation agrees with the Dowex 1-X2 chromatographic patterns reported by Kao and Leslie11 and by others.1,1*
Heparan sulfate is reported to be partially susceptible to hyaluronidase digestion," and this correlates well with the observed 43% diges tion of the GAG in our 1.25 M NaCl fraction. Since heparan sulfate has been shown to be associated with blood vessels," an increase in the urinary excretion of this GAG is not surpris ing in this vascular lesion. Also, chondroitin-4and -6 sulfates are reportedly eluted from Do wex 1-X2 columns with 1.50 M NaCl1,1* and are susceptible to hyaluronidase" suggesting that our 1.5 M fraction is chordroitin-4- and/or chondroitin-6-suIfate.
Assuming that urinary GAG patterns de scribed here are reflections of hepatic changes, it will be important to determine what processes these changes reflect, i.e., those of neoplastic growth, fibrogenesis, or cell death. In this re gard, it should be noted that 1) the ratio of heparan sulfate to chondroitin sulfate reported here for angiosarcomatous urine is similar to that reported for cirrhotic human liver tissue by Becker,1 and 2) the shift from a hyaluronidase-
............ COUFISEflTIAI."
Subject to Protective Crdsr in .Eosft v. ..7onoco_, Inc.Ho._ 90^4837,
14th Judicial District Court . Calcasieu Parish Louisiana
CMA 002396
No. (i
G;.vcosam;nogly.cans in Angiosarcoma
Curran et at.
3053
susceptible to a hynluroniriase-rcsistant GAG is consistent with the suggestion by Huttercr and Rubin11 that the stabilization of collagen de pends on a shift to a hyaiuronidasc-resistant GAG envelope surrounding the collagen bundle.
Although Huttercr and Rubin attribute this to an augmentation of dermatan sulfate, Becker1 reported that the GAG pattern in human cir
rhosis was characterized by the augmentation of dermatan sulfate and heparan sulfate. If the ob served changes in urinary GAG are reflective of vinyl chloride-cxposure-associatcd fibrosis, the fact that fibrosis is a precursor of angiosarcoma1' indicates that the observations reported here constitute a promising lead in early detection of vinyl-chloride-induced liver disease.
REFERENCES
1. Anghileri, L. J.: Metabolism of acid mucopolysaccha rides in hepatoma and normal liver. Oncology 30:304-317, 1974.
2. Becker, K.: Acid mucopolysaccharides in experimental and human cirrhosis. In Collagen Metabolism in the Liver, H. Popper and K. Becker, Eds. New York, Stratton Inter continental Medical Book Corporation, 1973; pp. 45-52.
3. Bitter, T., and Muir, H.: A modified uronic acid carbazole reaction. Anal. Biochim. 4:330-334. 1962-
4. Creech,,). L., and Johnson, M. N.: Angiosarcoma of the liver in the manufacture of polyvinyl chloride. J. Occupa tional Mid. 16:150-151, 1974.
5. DiFerrante, .V.: The measurement of urinary muco polysaccharides. Anal. Biochim. 21:98-106, 1967.
6. DiFerrante, N.: Turbidimetric measurement of acid mucopolysaccharides and hyaluronidase activity. J, Biol. Chcm. 220:303-306. 1956.
7. Falk, H., Creech, J. L,, Heath, D. W., Johnson, M. N., and Key, M. M.: Hepatic disease among workers at a vinyl chloride polymerization plant. JAMA 230:59-63, 1974.
8. Galambos, J. T.: Connective tissue metabolism and cirrhosis, tn Collagen Metabolism in the Liver, H. Popper and K. Becker, Eds. New York, Stratton Intercontinental Medical Boojt^ Corporation, 1973; pp. 57-61.
9. Gasic, G., and Gasie, T.: Removal of sialic acid from the cell coat in tumor cells and vascular endothelium and its effects in metastasis. Ptoc. Mall. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 48:1172-1177, 1962.
10. Greenberg, R. A., Tamburro, C. H., and Kupchella, C. E.: A prospective medical surveillance program for the detection and prevention of occupationally-related cancer. In Prevention and Detection at Cancer. H. E. Nieburgs,
Editor, Part 1, Volume 2, Marcel Dekker, Inc., NY (In
press).
11. Huttcrer. F., and Rubin, E.: Mucopolysaccharides in
reversible and irreversible experimental hepatic fibrosis. In
Collagen Metabolism in the Liver, H. Popper and K.
Becker, Eds New York, Stratton Intercontinental Medical Book Corporation, 1973; pp. 53-56.
12. Kao, K. Y. T., and Leslie, J. G.: Micro fractionation and determination of urinary glycosaminoglycans. Biochim. Mid. 9:317-326, 1974.
13. Koizumi, T., Nakamura. N., and Abe, H.; Changes in acid mucopolysaccharide in the liver in hepatic fibrosis. Biochim. Biophys. Acla. 148:749-756, 1967,
14. Korn, E. D.: Isolation of heparin from mouse mast cell tumor. J. Biot. Chcm. 234:1325-1329, 1959,
15. Kupchella, C. E-, and Tamburro, C. H,: Urinary and tissue glycosaminoglycan patterns in hepatic angiosarcoma. In Prevention and Detection of Cancer, H. E. Nieburgs, Editor, Part 1, Volume I, Marcel Dekker, Inc., NY (In press).
16. Makk, L., Creech, J. L., Whelan, J. G., and Johnson, M. N.: Liver damage and angiosarcoma in vinyl chloride workers: A systematic detection program. JAMA 230:64-68, 1974.
17. Popper, H., and Thomas, L. B.: Alterations of liver and spleen among workers exposed to vinyl chloride. Ann. PH'Acad. Sci. 246:172-194, 1975.
18. Rich, C., and Myers, W. P. L.: Excretion of acid mucopolysaccharides in the urine of patients with malignant neoplastic diseases. J. Lab. and Cltn. Mid. 54:223-228, 1959.
19. Schiller, S., Slover, G. A., and Dorfman, A.: A method for the separation of acid mucopolysaccharides: Its application to the isolation of heparin from the skin of rats. J. Biol. Chcm. 236:983-987, 1961.
20. Sharon, N.t Complex Carbohydrates: Their Chem istry, Biosynthesis, and Functions. Reading, Massachusetts, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, 1975.
21. Varadi, D. P., Cifoneili. J. A., and Dorfman, A.: The acid mucopolysaccharides in normal urine. Biochim. Biophys. Ada. 141:103-117, 1967,
22. Yamamoto, K., and Terayama, H.: Comparison of cell coat acid mucopolysaccharides of normal liver and vari ous ascites hepatoma cells. Cancir lies. 33:2257-2264, 1973.
"v'"''
SmEsjeet
Order in
o. Jury., o. 90-4S3?
14th Ju'lioiDistrict Court
i!\M .Calcasieu Parish .^.Louisiana .
CMa 002397 58
HEPATIC CELL IDENTIFICATION TECHNIQUE H.P. FORTWENGLER AND C.H. TAMBURRO, M.D.
It became very evident early in our vinyl chloride metabolism studies that in order to be able to determine various cell capabilities of oxidizing and detoxifying one needed both an Iri vivo and in vitro method for determining cell oxidizing and detoxifying capability as well as cell identification. Modification of the technique by Leevy, et al has recently been developed in which the in vitro technique utilizes biopsy tissue for the identification of the various hepatic cell types. This is illustrated in Slide I. A liver biopsy, either human, or animal, is cut in a Y shape in which each of the components of the biopsy can be utilized for different studies; electron microscbpy, light electron microscopy and cell type identification. The tissue for cell type identification Is then incubated in a modified Eagles medium for two hours at 37. By incubating this tissue with various markers, such as tritiated thymidine, iron particles, tritiated hydroxyproline or Factor VIII antibody, one can identify cells as
3 being active in incorporation of HT into DNA, having a phagocytic capability, having collagen forming ability or simply identies of endothelial cells respect fully. This technique has already been put to use in verifying the cell of origin that malignantly transforms into the angiosarcoma. This has been shown to be the endothelial lining cell and not, as some had thought, the Kupffer or macrophagic cell. This now allows us to direct our attention to the variation in metabolic capability between the primary hepatocyte and the endothelial lining cell. We now hope to be able, using this technique for cell identification, to identify early metabolic capability and morphological changes in cells as they are exposed to various chemicals for prolonged periods of time. This will allow us to determine whether or not these metabolic and morphological effects are progressive, at what stage the metabolic changes are morphologically manifested.
59
whether these morphological changes are permanent and irreversible, and whether with discontinuance of exposure, these changes revert to normal or progress on to develop malignantcy. We hope that these new developing techniques may be applicable to human tissue via biopsies techniques and help to identify mor phological changes with greater specificity as "to their etiological cause.
CMA 002399
60
SLIDE I
CUT-
IN VITRO TECHNIQUE FOR HEPATIC CELL IDENTIFICATION
A ELECTRON MICROSCOPY B CELL TYPE IDENTIFICATION C LIGHT MICROSCOPY
liver
BIOPSY
DIVIDED LIVER BIOPSY
F
MARKER
CELL TYPE
^HT/^HU
dna/rna ALL CELLS
LATEX/ carbon/fe
KC
-\
FACTOR VIII FLUORESCENCE
EC
3h proline/
VIT A FLUORESCENCE
FB
Object
Peso 7
---------- `
'-*b
^
Measles
T/nllon ii
^3. -Oj\nj - 4337
ar*-^,, LomaClaonuart
61
CMA 002400
MEDICAL SURVEILLANCE SYSTEM FOR INDUSTRIAL ENVIRONMENTS
The University of Louisville has, through cooperative endeavors with
St. Anthony's Hospital and the B. F. Goodrich Company, (Louisville Plant)
developed a medical industrial surveillance system which is applicable for
industry-wide use. The surveillance system is composed of three levels of
screening programs as shown in Slide 1.
Level I applies to the industrial environment which does not contain
any known or potentially toxic or carcinogenic chemicals. This is alsci
the basis or foundation upon which the more advanced levels of surveillance
are built. Level I data base is composed of an employee work history, a
job exposure history and a medical illness history including illnesses of
the past as well as the present and future.
Level II surveillance is composed of Level I components plus a basic
medical history and physical examination, rank ordering of exposure to any
industrial chemical thought to be potentially carcinogenic or toxic, and
medically and/or Federally required screening tests.
Level III surveillance is designed for an industrial environment
actually utilizing a known carcinogen or toxin. At this level a complete
medical history and physical examination are conducted. Individual job or
person monitoring is done where scientific capability is available; otherwise
rank ordering of exposure to the various chemicals is used for each job
classification. In addition to Federally required tests, specialized screen
ing studies are performed. A triage protocol is shown in Slide 2, which has
been utilized for a combined synthetic rubber and plastic production plant.
Slide 3 illustrates the procedure used for medical evaluation of screening
data on an individual employee basis. Regional standard range is determined
for all laboratory screening tests. Individual tests results outside of the
62
CMA 002401
CD
U CDt
t
ct
SLIDE 1
INDUSTRIAL MEDICAL SURVEILLANCE SYSTEM
THE SCREENING PROGRAM
LEVEL I A. EMPLOYEE WORK HISTORY
B. JOB EXPOSURE HISTORY C. MEDICAL ILLNESS HISTORY
(1) INITIAL (PAST) (2) MORBIDITY (PRESENT) (3) MORTALITY (FUTURE)
- LEVEL 11
A. BASIC MEDICAL HISTORY
B. BASIC PHYSICAL EXAMINATION C. RANK ORDER EXPOSURE - AREA MONITORING D. BASIC MEDICAL SCREENING
LEVEL III A. COMPLETE MEDICAL HISTORY
B, COMPLETE PHYSICAL EXAMINATION C, INDIVIDUAL MONITORING D. SPECIALIZED MEDICAL SCREENING
COH^IPSHTIAXt".......... . fTihicti to pratsotiva Order is poss v. Conaso, Ir.s.. Jo* 90-4837
14th Judicial District Court Calcasieu. Parish*. Louisiana.
63
CMA 002402
---------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------si'imr2--
OUTLINE OF EXISTING PROTOCOL FOR SCREENING
64 CMA 002403
Sub'
FcSfL v 1 ; .
14-3 -
?
Cal*32-' '
SLIDE 3 in
Lo^?^A
PROCEDURE FOR EVALUATION OF MEDICAL SCREENING DATA ON INDIVIDUAL BASIS
1. DETERMINATION OF SCREENING TESTS
2. DETERMINATION OF STANDARD RANGE CSR=90%)
3. INDIVIDUAL RESULTS OUTSIDE SR - REPEAT
4. PERSISTENT ABNORMALITY - DIAGNOSTIC WORKUP
5. R ~ 0 NATURAL VARIATION - NON-DISEASE EX. (A) AGE - ALK PHOS (B) RACE - IGG v(c) GENETIC - INDIRECT BILIRUBIN
6. R - 0 NON-OCCUPATIONAL DISEASE E.G.(A) HEPATITIS (B) DIABETES (c) HYPERLIPIDEMIA (D) OBESITY
7. INVESTIGATIVE DIAGNOSTIC STUDIES E.G.Ca) SPECIAL PROCEDURES (B) HOSPITALIZATION (c) BIOPSY
8. TREATMENT (A) PRIMARY DISEASE (B) OCCUPATIONAL CHANGE
65
CMA 002404
standard range are repeated and individuals with persistent abnormalities undergo diagnostic work-up. There are two major variations in screening tests which may simulate occupationally related disease. These include natural variations, or non-diseases, as exemplified by an elevated alkaline phosphatase associated with age, or elevation of the IgG immunoglobulins associated with race and other areas such as a congenital indirect hyper bilirubinemia which are genetically related. The second category is the non-occupational disease which may simulate occupational injury such as hepatitis, diabetes, hyperlipidemia and obesity. Individuals found to have occupationally-related disease undergo thorough diagnostic studies to determine the etiological cause and are given the appropriate treatment as indicated.
Reasons for surveillance programs are listed in Slide 4. Although the medical surveillance system for industrial environments are designed mainly for the fijth reason, that is, the detection of treatable conditions, the design of this system acutally meets all five reasons for the program} (Slide 4).
BASIC MEDICAL SURVEILLANCE SYSTEM The employee work history is composed of a uniform job classification code for the entire plant or industry, and estimated exposure (Slide 5). to various chemicals. The degree of exposure is ranked in.theorder of 0 to 6. Slide 6 indicates the rating basis for the rank ordering of chemical exposure. These rank orders are used to develop exposure indices such as average, total, or interaction exposure indices. Slide 7 illustrates the selection criteria for the original nineteen chemicals used in our medical surveillance system at the B. F. Goodrich Plant. Similar criteria can be used for chemical toxins or potential carcinogens. Slide 8 is an illustration of a detailed work and exposure history; on the left are listed the years in which the individual was employed, the
CMA 00240S
Subjac-^.?,rotS;: >!o. 90-4837
^oss_v.
_ Tt r'urt SLIDE 4
. Calcasieu
REASONS FOR SCREERING PROGRAMS
PROTECTION FOR ECONOMIC BUSINESS PROTECTION FOR OTHER INDIVIDUALS ALTERNATIVE TO PERSONAL HEALTH SERVICES ACQUISITION OF CLINICAL BASELINE INFORMATION DETECTION OF TREATABLE CONDITIONS
SLIDE 5
EXPOSURE SUMMARY
A, J03 CLASSIFICATION CODE' 3, EMPLOYEE WORK HISTORY C. CHEMICAL EXPOSURES D, EXPOSURE INDICES
1. AVERAGE EXPOSURE 2. ' TOTAL EXPOSURE' 3. INTERACTION EXPOSURE
67
002406
CONFIDENT I AT. "
Subject to Protective Order in MV- Conoco, Inc., g0. 90-4337
14th Judicial District Court Calcasieu Parish, Louisiana sl
RATING BASIS
SLIDE 6
0 - ABSENT FROM ENVIRONMENT 1 - LOWEST EXPOSURE 2 - MINIMAL EXPOSURE TO LOW LEVELS 3 - MODERATE EXPOSURE A - WORKS IN AREA SUBJECT TO OCCASIONAL HIGH
EXCURSIONS 5 - WORKS IN AREAS WHERE LEVEL IS HIGH 6 - INTIMATE CONTACT - SKIN OR HIGH INHALATION
CMJV 002401
68
SLIDE 7 ,, SubJeci^r~:
SELECTION CRITERIA FOR ORIGINAL 19 CHEMICALS
1. IS IT A KNOWN HEPATOTOXIN?
2. IS IT A SUSPECTED CARCINOGEN? 3. HOW TOXIC IS IT? A. DO EMPLOYEES FREQUENTLY COME INTO INTIMATE CONTACT
WITH IT?
5, IS IT FOUND IN THE VINYL CHLORIDE POLYMERIZATION AREA?
002408 69
CONFIDENTIAL
Subject to Tvots<;&iy,e
Bess v. "'mo- r,,
, ],'o.
p
DETAILED WORK AND EXPOSURE HISTORY
flfeOtaaa&iu: Pifl'yi,
WORK HISTORY
EXPOSURE HANK FOR EACH CHEMICAL
YEAR BUILDING
JOB NO. MONTHS VINYL CHLORIDE 2* 3*
22
1944 1945 1945 1946 1947 1948 1948 1949 1949
a
1957
1972 1972 1973 1974 1974
000 000 111 111 111 111
121 121 112
a
576 576
194 194 194 194 .
192 192 253
i
m 235
1a
5^3 li;
000 000 000
TERMINATE!
574 574 574
6 5 7 12 12 8 4 4 8
a
a
12
i
a
5 7
12
8
2 1 1 4* * t i < i * 2 1 1 4tiaaaaiiiiii 5 4 1 1 ' < i i i i 6 4 1 11 1 1 * t i i ( , ,
6 4 3 1...................................................................................................................
5 4 3 1 a i i i i a i * i i i
4 3 1 1iiaaiaitaaai
4 3 1 1iiiaaaaiaaai
2 6 3 2aaiiaiaaiaai
4 31
1
1 21 2 11 2 11 2 11
1 4 4 4
SLIDE 8
* OTHER CHEMICAL
number of months worked at that job in that building. This composes the
work history for the employee. The exposure ranking of each chemical
is shown on the right. Vinyl chloride exposure is illustrated first and
the numbers 2 to 22 are used to indicate the other, chemicals.
A multi-employee continuous work and exposure history form for employees
is illustrated in Slide 9. This demonstrates a simple means of keeping a
work history using a six digit code system for both job classifications and
building codes specific for each industry or company. This would provide
useful prospective as well as retrospective data to document the safety
of the environment or to determine if an occupational Subject to Fro`:'3r.
DATA BANK
r
7
The need for a data information resource to allow prospective investigative epidemiological studies have been well illustrated by the University of Louisville's medical surveillance Data Bank System. The material acquired during a three-four year period is illustrated in Slide 10. Packaged computer programs to analyze this occupational medical surveillance data are presently being shown to be cost effective, time saving, able to guarantee uniformity of data collection, as well as security to the workers as far as personal information is concerned (Slide 11). This data, collected on a prospective basis, provides immediately to industry and others, the best available human epidemiological information for validating preliminary results of other industries or animal data. The use of this information for various types of evaluation are shown in Slide 12.
Illustrations of the effectiveness of the program are demonstrated in Slides 13, 14, and 15. Slide 13 simply lists the number and types of malignancies found in this cohort of chemical workers between 1960 and 1978. At a glance, one has the impression that there is an increasing number of tumors among liver.
71 CMA 002410
SLIDE 9
1 EMPLOYEE WORK AND EXPOSURE HISTORY
YEAR 1945
1950
1957 1965
COMPANY
WORK HISTORY
MILLING, INC.
177* - 268** 177 - 269 178 - 438
PLASTIC INTERNATIONAL
013 - 291 018 - 548 013 - 620
J.K. MANWORK, INC,
100 - 001 100 - 020
G.P. CHEMICAL CO,
001 - Ill
# OF MONTHS
14 26 20
24 12 48
48 48
CURRENT
AREA OR BUILDING CODE ## JOB CLASSIFICATION CODE
Vv:CONFIDENTIAL
Subject to Proteptive Griper in Boss v. Concoo, Inc., Ho. 30-433*
14th Judicial District Court Calcasieu Parish, Louisiana
EXPOSURE DATA FOR EACH CHEMICAL FOR EACH JOB CLASSIFICATION IS KEPT BY THE COMPANY.
0,8 <> 72
SLIDE 10
p. O^ISBUTIAL tc Droiertive Order 1*
^ ^ ' J ______ T- ' . . ;'0 . 90 --'5 - ~ i:l District Court , ^ Calcasieu Parish..*. Louisian^
SOURCE AND USE OF DATA BANKS:
SOURCE: UNIVERSITY OF LOUISVILLE DATA BANK CONTENTS AS OF MARCH 25j
1977
TYPE OF INFORMATION WORK HISTORIES `EXPOSURES INDICES BLOOD CHEMISTRIES LIVER SCANS SPLEEN SCANS CHEST X-RAYS
HISTORY & PHYSICALS (1974) HISTORY & PHYSICALS (1975) HISTORY & PHYSICALS (1976)
BIOPSIES
CcDn
NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES
1672 1672 1347 1222 1217
853 679 875 831
. `EXPOSURE INDICES ARE AVAILABLE FOR 21 CHEMICALS IN
ADDITION TO VINYL CHLORIDE.
CMA 002412 73
SLIDE U
CONFIDENTIAL' .........''
Subject to Protective Order in -^S5 v .;"n_cco, Inc., No. 90-4837
14th Judicial District Court Calcasieu Parish,, Louisian*,
OCCUPATIONAL MEDICAL SURVEILLANCE PACKAGED COMPUTER PROGRAMS
1) WILL SAVE MONEY
2) WILL SAVE TIME 3) WILL GUARANTEE UNIFORM DATA COLLECTION
A) WILL GUARANTEE SECURITY TO THE WORKERS
5) WILL BE AVAILABLE IMMEDIATELY TO MEET THE NEEDS OF
INDUSTRY 6) WILL BE AVAILABLE TO BOTH SMALL INDUSTRIES AS WELL
AS LARGE INDUSTRIES
CMA 002413
74
lung, and possibly, colon.
CO:T?IDZ:iTIAL
Subject to Protective Order i* Boss v. Conoco. Ire., l.'o. 90-43
14th Judicial District Court Calcasieu Parish,, Louisiana
Analysis of exposure work history helped in identifying
correlations between chemicals and cancer. All the cases of angiosarcoma discovered
in this cohort population since the start of the program in 1974 were compared
with matched controls who had begun to work the same year as the angiosarcoma
cases and had worked the same periods of time. Each control and case was then
ranked as to their total exposure to vinyl chloride as show in Slide 14. As
one sees, the angiosarcoma cases are among those with the higest exposure to vinyl
chloride based on their rank ordering. This was significant to a P <.05. In-
contrast, acrylonitrile (Slide 15) exposure ranking of individuals with angio
sarcomas and their match controls shows no such correlation of that chemical to
the cases of angiosarcoma. Of the additional 20 chemicals studied, only three others showed significant correlations, as did vinyl chloride, with angio sarcoma. They were a) the specific catalysts for the vinyl chloride polymerization process, b) hexane,used as a solvent for these catalysts, and c) diethyl maleate, a specialized catalyst used only for a specialized vinyl chloride poly merization process showed such relationships (Slide 16). This data validates the ability of rank ordering of exposure to identify causative relationships and/or the absence of such when used retrospectively. This will be even more effective as it is continued to be used prospectively. Additional studies have been conducted to determine if there exists any relationship between lung cancer and vinyl chloride exposure. As shown in Slide 17 and 18, no correlations were found between vinyl chloride, acrylonitrile, or any of the other 21 chemicals when the cases overall lung cancers were matched against their controls. This data would support the lack of a relationship between these chemical exposures and lung cancer development.
CMA 002414 75
C0l2325E^cl9r in ,. ro 90-4337.
^ ^&&**** -*
rlcasiea *
EVALUATION
SLIDE 12
1, ARE SCREENING PROGRAMS TO DETECT DISEASE LIKELY TO HAVE IMPORTANT EFFECTS ON HEALTH?
2, DOES TREATMENT OF RISK FACTORS INFLUENCE
DEVELOPMENT OF DISEASE?
3, INDIVIDUAL COMPLIANCE IN SCREENING PROGRAMS,
4, DOES THE SCREENING PROGRAM REALLY ALTER OUTCOME OF TARGET DISEASE?
5, ARE THE PRESENT METHODS OF EVALUATIONS MISLEADING
AS TO EFFECTIVENESS OF POSSIBLE SIDE EFFECTS OF SCREENING DISEASE, LABELLING OF INDIVIDUAL AND LONG-TERM THERAPY?
CMA 002415 76
NUMBER AND TYPES OF MALIGNANCY IN CHEMICAL WORKER COHORT-1960-1978
I960 - 64
1965-68
1969-71
1972-74
1975-78
LIVER ^ LUNG
COLON
BRAIN
O
GU
o to it*
<Ti
i^J ibi
CO
&
eiH*
in-;
i J. f .
<o<0+ ! O cOV 0
a oi> ` '
'll
o cl
M 1^
a:u , i-ii
-3
i ^ <U
. o tr
to
crhcp tu-
CA 3
I
H TIA I
VINYL CHLORIDE EXPOSURE RANK
&.! w(+ n **
0> O (fi '-1 ot *to1
^ v*.
<A 3
RANK OF IN D IV ID U A L 'S EXPOSURE
o
N)
ANGIOSARCOMAS 'C=3
AND MATCHED CONTROLS E
]
ACRYLONITRILE EXPOSURE RANK OF INDIVIDUALS WITH ANGIOSARCOMA
Ire#
nH*O-j*
rt D'
&t
C_*.
COD
I II III IV
o to
ANGIOSARCOMAS r. -J
AND MATCHED CONTROLS [
w <t>
|
fI
*
I1 .^J
*"* <3 O
of
cO+
o o El
HJ 1
G;
`rJ
*Ore1
M tj
i0 Ld
Ej
(-3
M
!*=-
V) M U m M Ln
tr*
.D
SLIDE 16
LIST OF SELECTED CHEMICALS FOR EXPOSURE INDICES
CHEMICAL CODE
01 02
COlFIDESTIAL
Subject Hess
to
-b -otectlv-?
I
,vVT;
in
ACRYLIC ACID
l^th Judici^'
> -C37
Calcasieu
-sez-jcc Court
la
ACRYLAMIDES - ACRYLAMIDE, METHYL, N-OCTYL,
nHA
03 ACRYLONITRILE
04 ACETYLENE
05 ACRYLATES -- ETHYL, METHYL, METHYL-METH,
2 ETHYL HEXYL, N"BUTYL
06 BISPHENOL A
07 BUTADIENE
03 CAPRYLYL CHLORIDE
09 CHLORINATED SOLVENTS -- CARBON TETRACHLORIDE
CHLOROFORM, TRICHLOROETHYLENE, EDC 10 CHLORO ETHYL VINYL ETHER
11 DIETHYL MALEATE
12 MECURIC CHLORIDE
13 METHANOL
14 PHENOL
15 TOLUENE
16 VINYL CHLORIDE
17 VINYLIDENE CHLORIDE
13 VINYL ACETATE
19 PVC DUST
20 CATALYSTS
21 STYRENE
22 HEXANE
CMA 002419
80
00
O
002420
VINYL CHLORIDE EXPOSURE RANK OF INDIVIDUALS WITH LUNG CANCER
LUNG CANCERS c=3. AND MATCHED CONTROLS
Eo t*r \r--
"t3 tu fc- ~
VJ "*m*i;*H >' <H** ^ ^ *1 tSo ^o o ^
EL , o
ES5T. go "ois 'pk<.
ifflo 'JJ SsaA 3
ACRYLONITRILE EXPOSURE RANK . OF INDIVIDUALS WITH1LUNG CANCER.
1~J i*M -u ;ui
CO p a;
< *
(D O
c+
pt* o h*
<o r '.-1 tO , ">
c+ o
i-* O
e? !;, H* I J-1 a 1O d J*
tf to o (+
t-*'
Q
O +
o
O
t-i o tO pu
o o U>
g tH
a * C3 Ol
M* 3
X t*ZOo
II III IV
==i LUNG CANCERS <===> AND MATCHED CONTROLS
00
SCREENING TESTS
nOIT?irr.J?IAI
Subject to Protectivs^ Or-:^
Boss v. Cor.oco^j
-'b ^
14th Juuici:Calcasieu Parish* Lstiigia-..-
The use of screening studies to determine the presence of hepatocellular injury have relied mainly on enzymatic studies determined in circulating blood or serum. Slide 19 illustrates the frequency with which the presently avail able clinical biochemical studies correctly indicated the presence of hepatic injury. The best enzymatic biochemical study was the SGPT which correctly correlated with hepatic injury in about 88% of the cases. The use of functional studies such as dye or bile acid clearances which is shown to the far right, demonstrated that using a maximum dose capacity for the liver, one can correctly identify underlying hepatocellular injury in almost 98% of the cases. The major limitation of clearance studies, however, is the lack of specificity as to the cause of the injury.
In addition, our data indicates that clearance studies are able to demonstrate progressive changes much earlier in the developing of hepatocellular injury than enzymatic studies can. This is illustrated in Slide 20 by the demonstration of progressive, increasing changes in dye clearance in the absence of changes in alkaline phosphatase during progressive exposure to the hepatoxic chemicals over many years. More attention to development of more specific and sensitive single screening procedures are needed rather than a "shot gunapproach" of multiple tests.
The medical surveillance system Is a far more cost effective means of deter mining industrial environment safety than any presently useable animal or bacteriological screening procedure. Although bacteriological studies are relatively inexpensive, they only indicate which chemicals may be of potential danger. They do not provide any data as to the degree of exposure or duration of exposure needed to present a significant risk.
Animal studies can provide further information, however, the correlation
CMA 002422 83
COTTFTDEflTIAL',.. '
Subject tolBrotective Order in Boss V. Conoco, Inc-., Mo. 90 - 4837
14th Judicial District .Court Calcasieu Parish,, Louisiana ' .
f
SLIDE'-19
- Frequency of biochemical abnormalities being present and correctly indicating the presencejjsignifleant histological abnormalities (SGPT * alanine aminotransferase; GGT - gamma glutamyl transpeptidase; ALK FHOS - Alkaline Phosphatase; SGOT ** aspartic aminotransferase; ICD = <ni'etrlc dehydrogenase and ICG * indocyanine green clearance)
CMA. 002423
84
FUNCTIONAL vs BIOLOGICAL SCREENING FOR HEPATOCELLULAR INJURY IN AN INDUSTRIAL POPULATION
TEST VALUES
HIGH
NORMAL RANGE
LOW
8
O O fo A k) A
2 A 6 8 10 12 14 1G 18 20 22
TIME IN YEARS
PJ
gS MM Co*
o tr "1 a>
* C3
US t:
.} i o
aO
K);
cOt-
0
t--- J*
'-I
W
fl
i.-)t
1M t< i-n
C(
PI
KOJ
between developing cancers in animals is not necessarily nor consistently
equal to the frequency and occurrence of chemically induced cancers in man.
The cost of studying chemical carcinogens (Slide 21) in the four million
chemical formulations now available, or the 600 new chemicals reportedly
synthesized yearly, or even the 63,000 chemicals estimated to be in common
use, are prohibitive in cost. The minimum estimate of cost to study a
single chemical used at a single dose level, in a single animal specie for
two hundred animals over a two year period, is approximately $40,000. This
cost is a conservative one. If this were applied to all 600 new chemicals
per year the cost would be $24,000,000. If one were to do these studies
solely for the 63,000 chemicals in common use, this would be over
$2,000,000,000. In contrast, a medical surveillance system institution in
a single plant of 1,000 workers costs roughly $45,000. Once developed,
its record maintenance would run about $5,000 per year, or approximately
$5.00 per Individual. Analyses of the data on a semi-annual, or annual basis,
would cost approximately $20,000 for an initial plant and 5-10,000 for each
additional plant. This is a relatively inexpensive and provides a much more
relevent means of determining environmental safety in a prospective manner.
This system can also be utilized to determine and demonstrate whether or not
primary preventative methods are effective in reducing the occurrences of
cancers in those environments where they are shown to be higher than expected.
Such prospective surveillance systems, will provide the means of determining
the need and effectiveness of costly preventive requirements which on theoretical
grounds are thought to be needed but not proven to be useful. Slide 22 shows how Cancer Centers and Health Science Centers may play an external objective
scientific role in assisting corporate medical directors in assessing industrial
environmental safety. The corporate medical director responsible for multiple
plants working with their part-time or full-time plant physicians can work
C05TFIDEI7TTAT.
'bject "to Fr'nt.or''Hvn n.
I4th Judicial District Court Calcasieu Parish,, Louisiana
86
CMA 002425
SLIDE 21
co:;riDrJ?iAL
Subjec .'Ross v.
0r8^r in "o. 90-4837
14tb Judicial riot riot Court
s,. Parish,,. louisiaria
CHEMICAL CARCINOGENS
4,000,000 CHEMICAL FORMULATIONS 600 NEW chemicals/year 63,000 CHEMICALS IN COMMON USE 1 CHEMICAL, 1 DOSE, 1 SPECIES, 200 ANIMALS,
2 YEARS
COST FOR CHEMICAL TESTING
$2,520,000,000 in common use $24,000,000 FOR NEW CHEMICALS
CMA 002426 87
collaboratively with scientific communities on these problems (Line one).
This slide (22) outlines such a working relationship. Various plants dependent
on size and need may have, as shown on Line two, no plant physician or full-time (FT) or part-time (PT) one. Line three illustrates various types of plants.
A single circle indicates a plant manufacturing a single product (i.e., plastics);
multiple circles - multiple products (i.e., plastic and rubbers). The letters
below the circles identify the carcinogenic or toxic environment:
X = no known carcinogen or toxin
iC_OIlFXDf]}JrP J
A = actual carcinogen or toxin P = possible carcinogen or toxin
noss. v. Conoco. T^-, wth
- 1" ~n ";3T
Calcasieu Parish,, Louisian **
Line four identifies the type of medical surveillance program at each plant.
Line five indicates the type of medical screening program being conducted at
each plant and Line six indicates the working team of corporate medical director
and his staff, Medical Center or Cancer Center medical epidemiologist and medical
consultants for prospective ongoing design, review and analysis. The medical surveillance program's screening studies may be carried on
either by local hospitals, or industrial laboratories would supply the test
results and medical information to the regional data banks where medical
epidemiologists and specialists would analyze the data for the industrial
plants in their geographic areas. This information would have the objective scientific status and would prevent claims of biased analysis. If the data were
to show problems developing or existing, industry could then apply proper resources to correct them or determine their validity. If the information showed no
evidence of developing problems, the data would be utilized to support the safety of the work environment. This system has been successfully used for four years now at the B. F. Goodrich Company, Louisville Plant, in cooperation with local medical facilities, the unions and management. Each component collaborated in the
data collection, analysis and validation. Conclusions drawn here have academic,
managerial and labor support of their validity and scientific accuracy.
88 CMA 02427
Line 1,
2.
SLIDE 22
MSP 4, LEVEL
MEDICAL 5. SCREENING
III
II
A
LOCAL HOSPITAL
LOCAL
EXTERNAL
HOSPITAL ' LABORATORY
89
BIOASSAY OF CHEMICAL MONOMERS IN ISOLATED MAMMALIAN LIVER CELLS
Richard C. Feldhoff, Ph.D. Assistant Professor , Department of
Biochemistry, University of Louisville School of Medicine, Louisvil 1e,
KY 1*0232
i*-
COIT?JST!;T?T / t,
Subject to Frot^T^T^: . .
v' f'.woso, J.-'c . , . V- < q ' 7
Siatrict Court . caleasiflu Parish,, Louisiana
The mammalian liver is the principaT organ responsible for the
metabolism and/or detoxification of many drugs, hormones and other organic
metabolites including potential carcinogens. The exposure of the liver to
an hepatotoxin such as ethanol is likely to interfere with its ability to
detoxify potential carcinogens. Many of the metabolic and hepatic effects
of alcohol have been the subject of extensive investigations, however the
concept of the potentiation of carcinogenesis by ethanol is relatively new
and has not been adequately investigated. Indeed, recent animal experiments
suggest that alcohol intake greatly increases the incidence of cancer when
the animals are also exposed to vinyl chloride. In order to better protect
industrial workers and the general public from chemically-induced cancers,
it appears desirable to define pathways for metabolism and detoxification of
chemical monomers by the liver and to assess the role of alcohol consumption
on these pathways.
Studies of chemical monomer metabolism can be facilitated by reducing the complexities associated with whole animal experiments to the leve of individual liver cells. Recently perfusion techniques have been developed which permit the bonds holding liver cells together to be cleaved when the enzyme collagenase is added to the perfusion medium. The perfusion procedure is depicted in Fig. 1. With the proper perfusion equipment, preparations of isolated liver cells can be readily obtained which exhibit very high viability and have been clearly shown by myself and others to retain normal liver specific functions. An example of some data which I obtained utilizing isolated liver cells is shown in Fig. 2. The synthesis and the secretion of albumin and'many other plasma proteins is a specific function of the liver which the isolated cells retain. Additionally, as shown in Fig. 3> the intracellular morphology of the isolated cells when investigated by high re solution electron microscopy is identical to that of the intact tissue.
There are also major technical advantages associated with the use of cell suspensions including 1) the ease of uniform sample collection (media or cells) as a function of time, 2) the ability to assay many different conditions or variables simultaneously and 3) the ability to
C ONFIDENTIAS
SuVe-'t' fn
Order in
v C'c..
, gg- 4
14th JudiCsurfc .... Calcasieu Parish.
90
CMA 002429
Dr, Richard C. Feldhoff
employ radioactive metabolites at a much higher specific activity than is feasible in other in vitro or in vivo systems.
s'v.v-.... corrTs^iAi. Subject to
Boss ?
Fig. 1 Diagram depicting cannulation and perfusion procedures. A, ligature tying portal vein cannula and placed above entry of splenic vein: R, inferior vena -cava and abdominal aorta sectioned after insertion of portal cannula; C, infusion tubing and cannula inserted into rubber tubing insert in inflow line; D, inflow line taped to aluminum blo.k to holtl portal cannula in [dace: E. ligature around celiac axis and superior mesenteric arteries, tied oft after insertion of portal cannula; F. ligature around inferior vena cava above R renal vein, tied off after insertion of vena cava cannula; C, vena cava cannula inserted through right atrium into inferior vena cava, not tied; H, outflow line taped to aluminum block to hold vena cava cannula in place.
- - ROTirellfflTlAir '
_ Subject,
to
c'-W-tive
Orod0er_4iSn-7
Boss v. Ccrcco.j.nc^ i.o. -0 4b-/
judxciil District Court
Calcasieu-Parish,, Louisiana
91 CMA 002430
Dr. Richard C. Feldhoff
HOURS OF IKCU3ATION Fic. 2 Tot.il protein and albumin secretion by isolated hepatocytes. Cells were prepared as described under "Experimental Proce dures*" and pi'i'incubateci Tor 30 min it) Krebs-Henselrit bicarbonate buffer containin'; 7.5 times the normal plasma levels of amino acids. Cells were transferred to 40 volumes of bicarbonate buffer containing normal plasma levels of amino acids and ['Illkuviee jt 10 s*Ci/ml. At each time point, aliquots of the suspension were centrifuged and assayed for incorporation into total secreted protein and albumin as described under "Kepcrimental Procedures."" O -- - O. hcpatocyles from normal rats; O-------O, hepatocytes from hyjiophysectomir.ed
rats.
With respect to chemical monomer metabolism, isolated liver cells can be used to investigate:
1) the uptake, intracellular transport (binding proteins) and metabolism by various cell fractions of radioactive pre cursors (Feldhoff, Tamburro, Du, Wong, (Wittliff - cytosol receptors)).
2) identification and quantitation of metabolites released into the medium (Feldhoff, Wong, (Hoffman - HPLC)).
3) effects of individual metabolites on normal parenchymal cell functions (Feldhoff, Tamburro); mutagenic capacities of newly identified compounds (Streips).
4) potentiation of carcinogenesis by concurrent exposure to hepatotoxins such as ethanol (Feldhoff, Tamburro).
This proposed research program would combine the knowledge and experience of the vinyl chloride study group at the University of Louisville with my own research training such that a model system can be developed where individual steps in the metabolism of potential carcinogens can be routinely investigated following acute and chronic exposure. Initially, due to the lack of continuous human liver cell lines these studies would be performed with Isolated rat liver cells and extended to human liver cells when they become more available.
CMA 002431 92
Fig. 3 Isolated rat hepatocyte. Cell suspensions were perpared by collagenase perfusion
and then incubated for 2 hours at 37 C in Krebs-Henseleit bicarbonate buffer. Utilizing
standard procedures the cells were fixed for I hour at 23 C in 0.1 H cacodylate buffer
pH 7.k containing 2.7% glutaraldehyde. Cell preparations were dried in graded ethanol
solutions, transferred to propylene oxide and embedded in Epon. The sections were stained wi
ification: 7700X. (Feldhoff, R.C. 5 Hi 1lman, B., Unpubbl1i
: '
V ^ < -'";'5:?r'`':'.:yied'-''bbbbSse'revfav1ati
C0?T?ID5}T?IAL' '
Subject to i -Epsg v. C : :
- 24th Jjiihj'i".,
.u ;
In . -J--.2Z7
C$2@&i&ti Parish,, Louisiana
93
CMA 002432
SUMMARY OVERVIEW
THE VALE JOURNAL Of uiOLOCV AND. MEDICINE 51 (Vila), 67-JO
a **G
.sy.tj . -
v,v>^3* ^S*S Slid
aCs Zlsray Detecilor.--7I:e Vinyl Cinoride Model'-2
CARLO H. TAM3URRO University of Louisville School of Medicine, Louisville, Kentucky
Received October 17, 1977
The liver's role in vinyl chloride toxicity and carcinogenicity ii> providing a betterunderstanding ofthe chemical carcinogenesis mechanism. A variety of both malignant and benign hepatic tumors has been demonstrated with prolonged exposure to vinyl chloride. The multisystem involvmcnt of this carcinogen and toxin has provided a model for the study of chemical carcinogenesis common to both man and animal. Clinical studies have shown the usefulness of biochemical, radioisotopic, and radiological studies in the detection of toxic and carcinogenic lesions. Animal studies have demonstrated the biochemical meiab* olism by the liver of vinyl ch!oridc*produced intermediates which are mutagenic in bacterial systems and may be the ultimate carcinogens. Hepatic subcellular enzyme studies prove preliminary evidence of cellular adaptation and increased detoxification. Disruption of this oxidization and detoxification balance may be the key to the malignant transformation of cells. A working hypothesis is presented which may explain the metabolism of vinyl chloride into mutagenic intermediates by the liver ceil and the develop ment of malignant transformation by extra hepatic sinusoidal lining cells, lung cells, and brain tissue.
INTRODUCTION
Currently there is a growing concern that chemical compounds may be respon sible for most human cancer through environmental contact. Although 100,000 to 200,000 new chemicals are introduced into industry each year, little is known about their effects. These compounds are primarily synthetics and thus not natural to the environment. The view that industrial chemicals may be latent carcinogenic hazards has again been brought into sharp focus by the discovery ofvinyl chlorideinduced angiosarcoma. Vinyl chloride (CH2 = CH--Cl monochloroethyene, a gas) is the basic molecule or monomer ofpolyvinyl chloride and its co-polymers and one of the most important organic intermediates in the plastics industry. The resulting plastic resin, polyvinyl chloride, is used in innumerable consumer and industrial products, such as containers, wrapping film, electrical insulation, pipelines, credit cards, etc. Until recently (early 1970's) vinyl chloride was regarded as being rela tively non-toxic [1,2]. Initially this opinion seemed to be supported by the facts that it was used transiently as an anaesthetic and had been used commercially in indus try for many years [3].
The direct information on the toxicity ofvinyl chloride to man was obtained from experiments by research workers on themselves, from the evaluation of its suit-
67
`Portions of this work were supported by a grant'from Manufacturing Chemists Association and by National Cancer Institutes Contract #KOt-CN-55212.
This article is the thirteenth in a series entitled. "Seminars on Liver Disease," that have been presented is part of the Training Program in Liver Disease at the Veterans Administration Hospital, West Haven, Connecticut: Dr. Harold O. Cons. Professor ofMedicine, Yale University School of Medicine, and Directorofthe Training Program in Liver Disease, is guest editor.
Please address reprint requests to: Carlo H. Tamburro, M.D.. ProfessorofMedicine, Chief, Digestive Diseases and Nutrition Division, Director, Vinyl Chloride Project, 511 South Floyd Street. P.O. Box 33260. Louisville, KY 60232
0044-0086/78/5101-C357 501.40
Copyright 1973 by The Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine. Inc. All rights of reproduction in sny form reserved.
94
CMA 002433
6S CARLO H. TAM3URRO
ability as an anaesthetic [4, 5], and from study of the cases of vinyl chloride poison ing contracted curing industrial use [6, 7, 8, 9].
Sporadic studies with vinyl chloride polymerization workers demonstrated vary ing degrees of hepatic biochemical derangements, hematological abnormalities, and skin changes [9j. Acute short term exposures led to disturbances of the central nervous system, cardiac anrythmias, severe irritation of the mucosal membrane of the eyes and the respiratory tract, and in some cases--severe pulmonary edema with obstruction of the liver and kidneys. Chronic inhalation trials in animals ..clearly showed that vinyl chloride was toxic to the iiver and kidneys as well as irrita ting to the mucosal membranes and the lungs. Microscopic examination of liver sections showed degeneration of the central lobules while the damage to the kidneys chiefly involved the tubule and the interstitial lining somewhat like that of carbon tetrachloride damage [10, 11, 12].
BACKGROUND
The literature, however, contained virtually no information on damage to man after chronic exposure until Filatova et al. reported disturbances of the blood vessels and nerves in individuals exposed with 20-300 ppm of vinyl chloride on a continuous basis [13], Cordier et al. [14] and Wilson et al. [15] were the first to re port the hitherto unrecognized disorder termed occupational acroosteolysis (AOL) which included the symptoms oftenderness ofthe fingertips, gradual destruction of bony integrity of the fingers and a Raynaud's-like phenomena.
Studies were initiated in animals to reproduce the acroosteolysis. In 1971, Violi et al. [16] while exposing animals to 3O,C0O ppm to induce acroosteolysis, accidentally discovered cancer. Maltoni et al. [17] while studying various levels of exposure demonstrated that angiosarcoma occured at 250 ppm; the Manufacturing Chemists Association's studies [18] demonstrated these liver cancers even at 50 ppm. At the -same time, Dr. John Creech, at the B.F. Goodrich Chemical Company Plant in Louisville, Kentucky, discovered an hepatic angiosarcoma in one employee. Creech, recalling an earlier hepatic angiosarcoma at the plant, reviewed the medical histories of previous employees. Four additional angiosarcomas were found, further supporting the connection between vinyl chloride exposure and tumor development. Measures to control the levels of vinyl chloride exposure were then instituted following federal regulation.
THE CHEMICAL
Vinyl chloride's chemical structure is a double-bonded, 2-carbon halogenated hydrocarbon which has structural similarities to tri-chloroethylene, an inhalation anaesthetic. As previously noted, vinyl chloride was once considered as an anaesthetic but was discarded because it caused myocardial irritability. Some ofits important physical properties include a low boiling point, a high specific gravity, a low solubility in water, and a half-life in air which ranges from 3-20 hours. Knowledge of these physical properties may be important in determining how this agent produces a cumulative effect in the environment which ultimately leads to cancer formation.
Vinyl chloride is both toxic and carcinogenic, as recognized by the wide variety of assotiated disorders which have been found among vinyl chloride polymeri zation workers and vinyl chloride-exposed animals. A yet incomplete list ofthese
95
7
VINYL CKLCtitUki--CARCINOGENESIS
TABLE I Occupational Vinyl Chloride Exposure Associated Disorders
CONFIDENTIAL"""... w
Sublet to r.otootivo Order in
lss_v.
Lo . 90-4837
14th JuLic:!?.! District Court Calcasieu Parish,,.Louisiana
1. Thronibucylopenia 2. Reiiculucytosis 3. Splenomegaly 4. iiepalic fibrosis 3. Seleru;lcrma-!ike skin changes 6. AcrO'Ostcolysis 7. Raynaud's phenomenon 8. Leukopenia 9. Hepatomegaly 10. Pulmonary functional impairment 11. Angiosarcoma 12. Cardiac arrhythmia 13. Nephroblastomas* 14. Zymbal gland carcinomas* 13. Large cell lung cancer 16. Brain cancer
*!n rats only
6V
associated disorders is shown in Table 1. Animal and epidemiological studies indicate the probability that cancer induction at other sites is also directly attributed to prolonged and excessive vinyl chloride exposure (19J.
In order to develop effective methods of prevention, accurate knowledge of the pathogenesis of this environmental chemical in ultimately producing its most destructive effect--cancer--is needed.
EXPERIMENTAL ANIMAL STUDIES--TUMOR FORMATION
The carcinogenicity of vinyl chloride has been demonstrated in a variety of animals as well as in humans at exposure levels that vary from 50-30,000 ppm. As illustrated in Table 2, a variety of tumor types have been found in rats, mice, and hamsters. An extensive list of benign tumors have also been reported in mice, rats, and hamsters exposed to vinyl chloride. Maltoni's group has now demonstrated primary liver cell cancers in exposed newborn rats.
Direct hepatocellular iryury as well as pulmonary, mucosal and skin injuries have been shown in directly exposed animals. Pretreatment with many agents increases the toxicity ofvinyl chloride; they include phenobarbital, ethanol, polychlorinated biphenyls and pesticides such as hexachlorobenzene [20]. This relationship to vinyl chloride's ability to induce cancer is under study, particularly in view of the industrial environment which allows exposure to many chemicals to occur con currently.
HUMAN STUDIES
s
Epidemiological studies in the human strongly suggest that exposure beyond 10 years is associated with increased cancer mortality, mainly digestive system cancers, primarily hepatic [21,22]. There also appears to be a higher incidence of large cell carcinomas of the lung, brain glioblastoma multiforms, and lymphomas [23,24], although there is some disagreement as to the interpretation ofthis aspect of the epidemiological data.
96
70 carlo i'{. * AiVi^u'k^o
TABLE 2
Carcinog-niciiy of Vinyl Chloride
(Exposure: >0-10,000 ppm)
TumorType
1. Liver--angiosarcoma 2. Liver--hepatocellular carcinoma 3. Lung--adenocarcinoma 4. Lung--large cell carcinoma 3. Mammary adenocarcinoma 6. Zymbal gland tumors 7. Nephroblastoma 5. Osteochondromas 9. Skin epitheliomas 10. Melanomas 11. Glioblastoma multiiorme 12. Lymphoma
Aduit humans, rats, mice and hamsters Newborn rats Rats and mice . Humans* Mice Rats Rats Rats Hamsters Hamsters Humans* Humans*
The multisystem involvement of this carcinogenic and toxic chemical is further illustrated in man. Early physical findings of vinyl chloride-injury include hepato megaly, portal hypertension, possible mild systemic pulmonary hypertension, bilateral midzonal pleural thickening of the lung, and splenomegaly with and without increased portal pressure [25]. These anatomical and physiological findings most frequently occur in the absence of the traditional clinical biochemical derangement of the liver. Screening studies of vinyl chloride workers during the past two and a half years have clearly illustrated the irregular and often delayed appearance ofabnormalities in aspartate and alanine aminotransferases (SGOT and SGPT), alkaline phosphatase as well as other hepatocellular enzymes. Gamma glutamic transpeptidasc (GGTP), believed to be a more sensitive indicator of hepatocellular injury, has proven to have too high a false-positive rate to warrant its use in the screens for hepatocellular injury. Sorbitol dehydrogenase (SDH) studies indicate that this enzyme, which is liver tissue specific, is too insensitive for primary screening but is useful for confirmatory testing.
Anionic dye clearance studies (Indocyanine Green, ICG) have demonstrated the highest specificity and sensitivity of all the primary screening procedures tested when performed at the 5 mg/kg dose level. At the traditional 0.5 mg/kg level, it has the same effectiveness as the aminotransferases and alkaline phosphatase com bined. The frequency of abnormal ICG dye clearances increases with prolonged exposure to vinyl chloride as illustrated in Fig. 1 and correlates well with the - cumulative exposure to vinyl chloride as well as the histological evidence of hepatocellular injury. These functional studies for detecting hepatocellular injury do not, however, identify the cause.
Clinical studies have illustrated the usefulness ofradioisotopic liver-spleen scans as a primary screening procedure for anatomical lesions of the liver and spleen. This procedure has proven to be the single most reliable method oftumor detection. Sixteen of the 19 individuals with anatomical lesions were detected by liver-spleen scan. In contrast, only 32 of 950 normal individuals had scan abnormalities which further diagnostic studies proved incorrect. This method provides an 84% sensitiv ity and 97% specificity, with only a 3% false-positive rate.
97
c3-J
v
'
crv'
7_
C.'
'S^4j
1-3 *4
-'^M6l 'e* 7H -- *>
Wi . . '
W C L.` n MP4 p ;
';04
'"H
52
3 o O
o
J
V)
3) V<j5h45
O >&
V>
s& to
t3o g H
w
Vj*NVL Cii.CiU-3'---mir-ATm*
7i
Diagnostic angiographic studies of these radioisotopic abnormalities in SO individuals have demonstrated 3 major lesions. The first is peiiosis hepatis, illustrated in Fig. 2. These lesions are usually numerous involving the entire liver, and have a diffuse stain throughout the nodules which persists into the late venous phase without central hypovascularity [26].
A second, similar lesion has been discovered in individuals with splenomegaly, and named lienal peiiosis (Fig. 3). These splenic lesions demonstrate a shortened celiac artery to portal vein circulation time, normal portal vein diameters, and increased spleen size. This has been found only in individuals with long-term vinyl chloride exposure.
The final lesion is that of angiosarcoma (Fig. 4). This tumor has characteristic angiographic features of central hypovascularity, midarterial puddling, and a prolonged peripheral tumor stain which continues up to 30-36 seconds after injection. These characteristic findings have allowed differentiation from other primary hepatocellular cancers, benign tumors and benign vascular lesions [26]. These angiographic lesions have been pathologically confirmed with the additional histological finding including peiiosis hepatis, sinusoidal dilatation, and activated ^sinusoidal cells with increased deposits ofcollagen in the sinusoidal space ofDisse. Exploratory wedge biopsies have in addition demonstrated increased subcapsular fibrosis with subcapsular bile duct proliferation plus the often described portal fibrosis [27].
VINYL CPILORIDE METABOLISM AND CARCINOGENESIS
Present biochemical knowledge indicates that vinyl chloride is most likely metabolized by the liver in a three step process [23]. At concentrations less than 50 ppm, vinyl chloride is metabolized by the alcoholic dehydrogenase system into chloroacetaldehyde and monochloroacetic acid.
C1-CH=CHj--*CI-CH2-CKi-OH~ alcohol CI-CHj-CHO---ClCHi-COOH
dehydrogenase
An alternative pathway which appears to become operative at 220 ppm is oxidation by the peroxidase-catalase system.
CI-CH2-CH2-OH- H2O2 -+C1CH2--CH2OOH-
catalase
CICH2-CHO
I I O-S mg/kg
6.0 <no/kg
% 13//w
V.
FIG. 1. Frequency of abnormal indocyanine green dye clearance among vinyl chloride workers utili zing 0.S mg/kg and 3.0 mg/kgdoses.
98
CMA 002437
. *
*
72 CARLO H. TAMRURRO
1
!
j 4
1 !
<
/ / <"
<
--.........
* r----- -
FIG. 2. Hepatic arteriogram: Ve nous phase. Changes of peliosis hepatis are present throughout the left lobe. The multiple nodular stains represent peliosis hepatis lesions (urroivs) ranging from 2-3
1 f,
>
-
& > :i
FIG. 3. Splenic arteriogram: Ve nous phase (15 seconds)- There are 3--4 circular and oval stains (ar rows) in the superior and inferiorlateral portions of the spleen. Nor mal pancreatic stain occurs jsst above the splenic vein.
99
r.nTIFXUKTrTT^X'
Subject to ProteGtivs
' 2^V'
CoMit
0*23
i
1
--
VINYL C>IL0i<ii3--,vii.A\l.J CARCINOGENESIS
73
'4
FIG. 4. Hepatic arteriogram: Venous phase. At approximately 14-15 seconds the peripheral stain is identified (arrows), lasting through the entire phase. Scattered areas of puddling are also present in and around the area of central hypovascularity.
In this case chloroacetaldehyde is again formed. At higher levels oxidation appears to be by the mixed function oxidase system, forming chloroethylene oxide which spontaneously rearranges to form chloroacetaldehyde which then can be further oxidized to form monochloroacetic acid.
CI-CK=CHi oxidase
As illustrated in Table 3, vinyl chloride oxidation intermediates chloroethanol and chloroacetaldehyde, at low doses, are most likely detoxified via the glutathi one-cysteine conjugation system. This system, however, is saturable and at higher levels vinyl chloride is excreted via the lungs [28]. It appears that at higher vinyl chloride levels increased amounts of chloroethanol and chloroacetaldehyde are further oxidized to chloroacetic acid which is excreted in the urine. This is further supported by the absence ofchloroacetic acid in urines ofrats exposed to low, short term levels ofvinyl chloride but found in urine ofrats exposed to 5,000 ppm for an extended time and reponed in workers exposed to levels greater than 250 ppm for a prolonged time [29, 30].
Elmore et al., utilizing a modified Ames system and pure synthesized vinyl chloride intermediates, has demonstrated that vinyl chloride, chloroethanol, and
100
002439
74
Cl CH - CHj (VC)
Liver MFO
Cl CH-CHj
\l 0
(Chlorooxirane)
. CARLO K. TAM3UARO TABLE 3
Proposed Metabolic Fate of Vinyl Chloride
detoxification with glutathione
Cl CHi CHi OH (Chloroethanol)
| +GSH Cl CHj CHO-----------(Chloroacetaldehyde)
GS CHi CHO
Cl CHi COOH (Chloroacetic acid)
GS CHiCOOH
Thiodigiycolic acid
chJoroacetic acid are not mutagenic in bacteriological systems [31]. This may indicate that the vinyl chloride monomer is neither hepatotoxic nor carcinogenic until it has been metabolized to its intermediate forms by the liver and/or other tissues.
Alternatively, chloroethanol--the most transportable of the vinyl chloride metabolites--may be transferred or diffused to adjacent cells, such as the sinusoi dal lining cells, where it could be converted to chloroacetaldehyde but less likely to be detoxified or further oxidized. Since vinyl chloride appears to bind the serum albumin, it may, itself be transported to and oxidized by extra-hepatic cells which are unable to fully oxidize or completely detoxify its metabolites, and thereby lead to molecular DNA injury and cancer formation at distant tissue sites.
These quandaries led to further study of the hepatochemical changes in rats undergoing progressively increased exposure to vinyl chloride. Subcellular en zymes and metabolites were studied in animals exposed to from 10-20,000 ppm vinyl chloride, ranging from 14-137 hours. Microsomal enzymes, including P-450, NADPH cytochrome c reductase, and mixed function oxidases were studied. Determinations of cytochrome c oxidase as the mitochondrial, tritiated-leucine incorporation as the protein synthesis and glucose-6-phosphatase as the carbo hydrate metabolism markers were also done. Glutathione and glutathione reduc- tase as oxidative and detoxification markers were determined in addition to the conventional clinical biochemical studies which included the aspartate (SGOT) and alanine aminotransferase (SGPT), alkaline phosphatase, bilirubin, lactic acid dehydrogenase (LDH), total protein, albumin, cholesterol, and triglycerides.
During the entire 137 hours of exposure there were no significant changes in the mitochondrial and the microsomal enzymes, the tritiated-leucine incorporation, or in the glutathione content. There was however, after 71 hours, a rise in the gluta thione reductase and a concomitant fall in glucose-6-phosphate. This occurred without any histologically discernible changes in the hepatocytes by light micro scopy nor any significant changes in the conventional clinical biochemical studies.
' V COffFIDTSITTTAT.
Suhipn+
..
Bo
101
CMA 002440
VINYt, CHLORIDE--ELATED CARCINOGENESIS
75
The discovery of a decreased g!ucosc-5-phosphatase after "simulated" chronic exposure led to the study of enzymes in the pentose phosphate shunt pathway. Weber and Lea [32] had found similar changes for primary hepatocellular neo plasms, demonstrating that in a rapidly developing primary hepatocellular tumor, there is decreased giuconeogenesis with a reduction in the g!ucose-6-phosphatase,
followed by an increase in glucose-6vh.ospr.ate dehydrogenase and transaldolase. These biochemical changes were also followed by an increase in purine biosynthe sis (increased phosphoribosyipyrophosphate aminotransferase (PRPP) and in creases in the production of ATP and GTP leading to increased nucleic acid synthesis.
Vinyl chloride-exposed animals showed no significant changes in the glucose-6phospnatase dehydrogenase activity during the initial S4 hours of exposure. However, after 103 hours, there was significant increase in glucose-6-phosphatase dehydrogenase. Studies of PRP?, at least up to 137 hours, have as yet shown no significant changes. Studies are now underway using animals exposed to 130 to 250 hours to determine if the biochemistry in vinyl chloride injury is similar to that in primary hepatocellular tumors.
This, however, does not explain why the hepatocyte, which is the primary cell for oxidizing and detoxifying vinyl chloride, is not the primary target for cancer trans formation. How do the hepatocytic biochemical changes, seen in the early phase of high vinyl chloride exposure, relate to the later morphological changes that occur in the adjacent sinusoidal cells?
MORPHOLOGICAL FINDINGS
Electron microscopic examination of liver sections of mice exposed from 1 to 6 months to 2,500-6,000 ppm vinyl chloride, for 5 hours/day, 5 days/week--a level known to induce angiosarcoma [33]--have demonstrated hepatocellular changes as early as one month. These changes included hypertrophy of the smooth endo plasmic reticulum (believed to reflect vinyl chloride metabolism) and, plasma membrane loss of microvilli with invaginations--possibly reflecting the movement of injurious metabolites across the membrane and out of the cell, allowing the metabolites to be picked up by the sinusoidal cells [34].
The sinusoidal cell reactions were multicellular. Increasing numbers and sizes of lipocytes were seen with little fibrosis. Macrophages were seen filled with phago somes, sometimes containing long needle-like crystals. Although there were many mononuclear cells present, the main abnormalities were seen in the endothelial lining cells. In the early stages they are larger and thicker--possibly swollen. Later, they became bulky and in places, multi-layered containing increased organelles, especially mitochondria and endoplasmic reticulum. Later disruptions in the sinu soidal walls seen were consistent with beginning peiiosis hepatis. The lining cells, probably the precursors of angiosarcoma, often resembled fibroblasts. However, their endoplasmic reticulum did not contain any collagen components. These observations by Schaffner et al. [34] give support to the suggestion that metabolites of vinyl chloride produced in the hepatocytes may be transported through the plasma membrane and enter sinusoidal lining cells, eventually leading to angio sarcoma. Attempts at screening for vinyl chloride hepatic injury might be better aimed at the endothelial cells and the hepatic sinusoidal circulation rather than the
hepatocytes. Our work in humans has identified similar findings. One major difference at
102
*'0 ;t$
i4th judicial District
'iff.
.:.j =--A
CMA 002441
76 CAaLL) H* *i Ai'-i.iURJlO
present is an increased collagen deposition, characteristic of human vinyl chloride injury and likely species specific. Light microscopic studies utilizing special stains on hepatic tissue from individuals with extensive exposure to vinyl chloride but without clinical biochemical hepatic abnormalities have shown distinctive midzonal increased deposition Of collagen in the space of Disse [35]. Routine light microscopic studies using hematoxylin and cosin failed to easily demonstrate this midzonai increased collagen. The increased deposition along the hepatic cell surface is associated with larger sinusoidal space and activation of the sinusoidal lining cells illustrated by increased nuclear size and cytoplasmic content. The in creased collagen deposition, when studied electron microscopically, demonstrates compression of the hepatocytes by the collagen bundles which initially give the ap pearance of rntra-hepatocelluiar collagen bundles as illustrated in Fig. 5. The strands of collagen appear to compress the hepatocytes causing cords of hepato cytes to be broken and to coalesce with adjoining sinusoids eventually leading to peliosis hepatis-like lesions.
These observations led us to the study ofthe proteroglycan role in collagenformation in vinyl chloride-exposed workers. It had been suggested in the literature that glycosaminoglycans in blood and/or urine might be useful as means ofearly cancer detection since a number of studies had demonstrated the production of sulfated glycosaminoglycans with malignant states. Pathologists have often used this feature as a diagnostic aid in characterizing malignant vascular tumors of the skin
V (imrFlPSflT I Ali
?05 V, ConogQ,
1.
"ih Judicial. District Court
, Calcasieu Parish.* Louisiana-
FIG. 5, Electron microscopy showing collagen (CB) bundles (arrows) isvaginating into the hepatocyte. giving the appearance of inter-hepalocytic collagen. N nucleus; S sinusoidal space: IM " invagination into the cell membrane (small arrows).
103
tdeit t iaT
Subject to Protecti7fj Oi-''
BoS3 V. C 07.0CO, _lno., he. 90
14th Juiici-ii r-Irjt'r-'ot
,
., tCalnasycu Parish,, Louisiana
CMA 002442
t*.
Pe- o 3a ,
_>C Cl V
*-3 ^ * c H-t ^ o
E-t
& w n M
+u>
icc `
;
^ rH
o * ~J S
I** :
f=i
O o
Coi; V*i2].
-o<)Dj
*r.
ul > -5
3
c3o PS
VtSYk* C*xLGHiD*.--v4.4-A i ^ A^CINOGUNHSIS
77
[36]. Others have noted a strong positive Aldan blue glycosaminoglycan staining reaction in hitman angiosarcoma tissue (37J. This suggested that quantitative and qualitative determinations of glycosaminoglycan production in individuals with neoplasm, either by serum or urine, might be used to identify those at high risk or as an early indicator of neoplastic formation. The feasibility of glycosaminoglycan "spot test" for vinyl chloride production workers made this an attractive possibil ity for mass screening.
Urinary giycosaminogiyeans, measured as uronic acid. Were studied in individu als with alcoholic cirrhosis, viral hepatitis, secondary liver metastasis, hepatic angiosarcoma and normal controls.
The percentage of total glycosaminoglycans that was dialyzable and the percent age ofunfractionated total that appeared in the hyaluronic acid, chondroitin sulfate, or in the heparin fractions was similar for all groups. However the distribution of positive fractions varied with the different groups studied.
Seven of the nine vinyl chloride-exposed individuals, other than those with angiosarcoma, had glycosaminoglycan positive chondroitin sulfate fractions with negative hyaluronic acid and heparin fractions whereas this occurred in only 3 of the 32 urines from other hepatic diseases [33].
In addition, study of the total tissue glycosaminoglycan levels in angiosarcoma tumors and fibrotic tissue adjacent to the tumor demonstrated that tumor tissue itself had higher levels of hyaluronic acid and heparin fractions as compared to the non-tumor adjacent tissue which had higher levels of chondroitin sulfate fractions. A similar relationship was found in cirrhotic liver tissue and normal controls. This data conforms to reports by others that both hepatic connective tissue disorder [39,40,41,42,43] and hepatic cancer [44] result in increased hepatic glycosamino glycan levels. It may be significant that the angiosarcoma patient has half the urinary glycosaminoglycan excretion of patients with liver metastasis and that analysis ofangiosarcoma tumor tissue exhibits halfthe glycosaminoglycan content reported by Kojima et al. [44] for hepatocellular carcinoma. The increases in liver and urinary glycosaminoglycans may well reflect the importance ofthese substan ces in the process of fiorogenesis and tumor growth. Although no significant differences were found in total glycosaminoglycans ofvinyl chloride-exposed indi viduals with associated liver injury, there was a significant difference in the excre tion patterns of these individuals. Seventy-eight percent of them had positive chondroitin sulfate fractions in contrast to only nine percent of the non-exposed liver injury cases. Thus the change in the glycosaminoglycan excretion pattern in individuals with pre-cancerous injuries may be of significant prognostic and
diagnostic importance [45]. The urinary glycosaminoglycan excretion patterns in an angiosarcoma patient 3
months to 2 weeks prior to death demonstrated an increase in the urinary chondroi tin sulfate fraction with a change in its composition as the disease progressed. During this time, the chondroitin sulfate composition showed a continuous increase in the ratio of the 1.25 M NaCl to the 1.5 M NaCl fractions. This was due to an increase in die 1.25 M eluate and a decrease in the 1.5 M eluate fraction and was 2.3 times greater than the controls. In the most advanced stage ofthe angiosarcoma the ratio increased to 13.7 times greater [46].
These very preliminary studies would suggest that alterations in the ratios of these fractions' compositions rnay be useful in evaluating the severity and subsequent progression ofdisease. Early lesions may produce small changes in the ratio which would become more pronounced as the disease worsened. The
104
002443
76 CARLO H. TAM BURRO
determination ofthis ratio might also be useful in identifying those individuals with significant injury or continuing progression of disease despite changes in the environment. Finally therapeutic measures for intervention might be better evalu ated for their effectiveness in arresting cancer development as reflected by the glycosaminoglycan changes which in turn reflect changes in collagen formation.
SUMMARY AND HYPOTHESIS
Vinyl chloride appears to enter the body through the respiratory tract, the skin, or by swallowing; it is absorbed and transported to the liver by the systemic and portal circulatory systems. In the liver, the primary site of metabolism, it is oxidized by various enzyme systems: alcohol dehydrogenase at lower exposure levels; the peroxidase-catalase system at intermediate levels; and mixed function oxidases at higher levels. At the higher levels, the mixed function oxidase system transforms vinyl chloride to chlorooxiranes which are then spontaneously trans formed into choroethanol and chloroacetaldehyde.
These two intermediate metabolites, chloroethanol and chloroacetaldehyde, are detoxified by conjugation with glutathione and cysieine-SH groups and are excreted in the urine. At even higher doses increasing amounts ofthe chloroacetal dehyde are further oxidized to chloroacetic acid and excreted as an end product in the urine. However, when chloroacetaldehyde and/or the chlorooxiranes exceed the detoxification threshold of the hepatocyte, this leads to hepatocellular toxicity and/or stimulation ofthe sinusoidal cells. This acute event in tum acts as a stimulat ing mechanism for increased collagen deposition in the space of Disse and sinusoidal areas as shown by electron and light microscopy studies. The increase in the collagen depostion in sinusoidal spaces then leads to disruption of hepatic cell surface function, disruption of the hepatic cords, coalition ofthe sinusoidal spaces and eventual peliosis hepatis. These lesions alternately lead to sufficient vascular dysfunction to add further to the biochemical manifestation of hepatic cellular injury.
Since it is highly unlikely that the unstable chlorooxiranes are able to be trans ported to adjacent cells and that the chloroacetaldehyde would most likely be conjugated or detoxified within the hepatocyte, an intermediate form, such as chloroethanol, which is transportable from the hepatocyte, may then move on to the adjacent sinusoidal lining cells, or possibly even further to other extrahepatic tissue. At these extrahepatic sites, an intermediate, such as chloroethanol, may then be converted to chloroacetaldehyde. The extrahepatic tissue sites are most likely unable to further convert the chloroacetaldehyde to chloroacetic acid nor to detoxify it sufficiently, if at all, by their own detoxification systems. This would allow a longer contact period with the cell's DNA. In addition many of the extra- hepatic cells normally are regenerating at faster rates than hepatocytes, thus increasing the possibility of DNA derangement and ultimate carcinogenesis.
Alternatively, vinyl chloride itself may be taken up by extrahepatic tissue, oxidized but incompletely detoxified, allowing the cell itselfto become susceptible to direct DNA injury. In this or similar manner, chemical metabolites may induce injury to the DNA in rapidly replicating cells at sites beyond the liver, thus accounting for other cancers developing with vinyl chloride.
The recent work by Maltoni's group, showing that exposure ofnewborn rats to the same dose of vinyl chloride as adult rats, results in primary hepatocellular carcinoma (40-45%) rather than in angiosarcoma (8-12%), lends further support to
`" " CONFIDENTIAL
Subject to Protective Order in
Boss v. Conoco . Inc. , I!o. 90-4337
14th Judicial District Court , -Calcasieu Parish---Louisiana-------
105
CMA 002444
VINYL
^/xaC'NOGaNcSIS
79
Ihe cor.cep; that the hepatocyte's ability to resist cancer transformation is dependent upon its ability to detoxify the mutagenic/carcinogenic metabolite of vinyl chloride.
This review of our present knowledge of vinyl chloride injury and cancer formation in man is, at best, a very rough hypothetical outline. With continued investigation and study it will ailow us to more accurately and completely fill in the missing pieces ofthis fascinating puzzie, thus leading us to a better understanding of the pathogenesis of chemically induced cancer in the biologically complex human system.
REFERENCES
1. Elkins 113: The Chemistry of industrial Toxicology. Second Edition. New York, New York. John Wiley & Sons Inc, 1950
2. Oettcl H: In Ullmann's Enzyklopadie derTechniehcn Chemie. Third Edition. 5:489. Munchen-Berlin, Urban and Schwarzenbcrg, 1954.
3. Kunststofikomission des Bundcsgesundhensautes (Plastics Committee of the Federal German Ministry of Health), Bundesgcnundhcrlsblatt. 8:369, 1975
4. von Ottingcn WF: The Haiogcnated Aliphatic, Oleflnic, Cyclic. Aromatic, and Aliphatic-Aromatic Hydrocarbons Including the Haiogcnated Insecticides, Their Toxicity end Potential Dangers. (PHS Publication No. 414). Wash ington, D.C., Government Printing Office, 1955
5. Osier RH.CaiT CT, Krantz JC, elal; Anesthesia XXVII. Narcosis with vinyl chloride. 8:359-61,1947 6. Schottek W: The toxicity of vinyl chloride. Chcm Techn 21:708-711, 1969 7. Gauvain S: Vinyl chloride. Proc Roy Soc Med, 69:275-310, 1975 8. Braun P, Druckman E, Eds: Public-health rounds at Ihe Harvard School of Public Health. Vinyl chloride: Can the
worker be protected? New Eng J Med 294:653-657, 1976 9. SelikofTU, Hammond EC, Eds: Toxicity of vinyl chloride--polyvinyl chloride. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:1-337,1975 10. Irish OD: In Aliphatic haiogcnated hydrocarbons. Industrial Hygiene and Toxicology. Second Edition. Edited by
FA Patty. New York, Interscience Publishers, 1963, 2:1241-1332
11. Mastromatteo E, Fisher M, Christie H, ct al; Acute inhalation toxicity of vinyl chloride to laboratory animals. Atr.sr Ind Hyg Assoc J 21:394-398, 1960
12.- Lester D, Greenberg LA, Adams WR: Effects of single and repeated exposures of humans and rats to vinyl chloride. Amer Ind Hyg Assoc J 24:265-275, 1963
13. Filatova VS, Balakhonova I, Gronsberg ES: Hygienic characteristics of vinyl chloride production. GigTr Prof Zabol 2:6, 1958
hi14. Cordicr JM. Fievez C. Fever, et al: Acroosteolysc ct lesions cutanees associees chez deux ouvriers, aflceles
au nettoyage d'autoclaves. Med Trav 4:14-19, 1966 15. Wilson RH. McCormick WF, Tatum CF. et al: Occupational acroosteolysis: Report of31 cases. JAMA 201:577-
581, 1967 16. Violi PL. Bigotti A, Caputo A: Oncogenic response of rat skin, lungs, and bones to vinyl chloride. Cancer Res
31:516-522, 1971 17. Maltoni C, Lefemine GL: Carcinogenicity bioassays ofvinyl chloride I. Research plan and early results. Environ
Res 7:387-405, 1974 18. Keplinger ML, Goode JW, Gordon DE, et al: Interim results of exposure of rats, hamsters, and mice to vinyl
chloride. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:219-224, 1975 19. Nicholson WJ, Hammond EC, Scidman H. et al: Mortality experience of a cohort of vinyl chloride--polyvinyl
chloride workers. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:223-230, 1975 20. Star Series: Scientific and technical assessment report on vinyl chloride and polyvinyl chloride. EPA 600/6-75-
004:48, 1975 21. Tabershaw 1R, Gaffey WR: Mortality study of workers in the manufacture ofvinyl chloride and polymers ofvinyl
chloride. J Occup Med 16:509-518, 1974 22. Tabershaw-Cooper Associates Inc: Supplementary epidemiological study of vinyl chloride workers 1. Manuf
Chem Assoc 5:1-30, 1975 23. Duck BW, Taylor KJW. Williams DMJ: Mortality study of workers in a polyvinyl chloride production plant.
Lancet ii: 1197-99. 1975 24. Waxweiller RJ, Stringer W, WagonerJK, et al: Neoplastic risk amongworkers exposed to vinyl chloride. Arm NY
Acad Sci 271:40-8, 1976
P
E
ke-
1-3
*3 I--I Eh
o +>e0t
M
PI
w fa
+foka->t
O +O>
o k.
: +uta->*>s
* w
106 CMA 244S
GGfc
I
80 CARLO H. TAM3URRO
25. Tamburro, CH: Unpublished results 26. Whelan JG. Creech JL, Tamburro CH: Angiographic and radionuclide characteristics of hepatic angiosarcoma
found in vinyl chloride workers. Radiology 118:349-357, 1976 27. Popper H, Thomas LB: Alterations of liver and spleen among workers exposed to vinyl chloride. Ann NY Acad
Sci 246:172-193, 1973 28. Hefner RE Jr., Watanabc PG, Gchring PJ: Preliminary studies of the fate of inhaled vinyl chloride monomer in
rats. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:135-148, 1975 29. Watanabc PG, McGowan GR, Gchring PJ: Fate of '`C- vinyl chloride after single oral adminstraiion in rats.
Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 36:339-352, 1976 30. McGowan GR, Watanabc PG. Gehring PJ: Vinyl chloride urinary metabolites: Isolation and identification.
Personal Communication, 1977 31. Elmore JD. Wong JL, Laumbach AD, et al: Vinyl chloride mutagenicity via the metabolites chlorooxirane and
chloracetaldehydc monomer hydrate. Biochim Biophys Acta 442:405-419,1976 32. Weber G, Lea MA: The molecular correlation concept. In Methods in Cancer Research. Edited by NH Busch.
NY, Academic Press Inc, 2:523-578, 1967 33. MaltoniC, Lefemine G: Carcinogenicity bioassays of vinyl chloride: current results. Ann NY Acad Sci 246:195-
219, 1975 34. SchaffnerF, Popper H, ScIikofTU.etal: Initial features ofvinyl chloride hepatic injury. Gastroenterology it:(No.
5) A35/928, 1976 35. Schrodt R, Tamburro CH: Unpublished data 36. Girard D, Johnston WC, Grahm JH: Cutaneous angiosarcoma. Cancer 25:868-83, 1970 37. Barr R, Bower M: "Letters" JAMA 231 (9):9I4, 1975 38. Curran KL, Kupcheila CE, Tamburro CH: Urinary glycosamlnoglyean patterns in angiosarcoma of the liver.
Cancer 40:3050-53, 1977 39. Galambos JT, Shapira R: Natural history of hepatitis: IV gtycosaminoglycuronans and collagen in the hepatic
connective tissue. J Clin Invcs 52 (11):2952--62, 1973 40. Koizumi T, Nakamura N. Abe H: Changes in acid mucopolysaccharide in the liver in hepatic fibrosis. Biochim
Biophys Acta 148:749-56, 1967 41. Kojima J: Studies on the metabolism of hepatic connective tissue in fibrosis of the liver. Med J Osaka Univ
16:419-29, 1964 42. Rubin E: Autoradiographic characterization of sulfatcd acid mucopolysaccharides in experimental cirrhosis. 5
Histochem Cytochem 14:688-89, 1966 43. Patrick RS, Kennedy JS: The synthesis of the sulfatcd mucopolysaccharides at sites ofhepatic fibrosis is induced
by carbon tetrachloride, amyloidosis, and the implantation of catgut. J Pathol Bacteriol 88:549-55, 1964 44. Kojima J, Kanatani M, Ohmori K: The glycosaminoglycans in human hepatic cancer. Cancer Res 35 (3):542-57.
1975 45. Kupcheila CE, Tamburro CH: Urinary glycosaminoglycan excretion patterns in chemically induced liver injury
and cancer. Clin Res 25:329, 1977 46. Kupcheila CE, Tamburro CH: Urinary and tissue glycosaminoglycan patterns in hepatic angiosarcoma. In Pro
ceedings ofthe III International Symposium on Detection and Prevention ofCancer. Edited by HE Niebcrgs. NY, Marcel Dekker Inc, 1977
Carlo H. Tamburro, M.D. Cancer Center and Digestive Diseases and Nutrition Division
Department ofMedicine University ofLouisville School ofMedicine
Louisville, Kentucky 40201
-r.:,,;vV!T-C01TpII)ENTIAxI +
Subject to Protective Crier in
Bo83 V. Conoco^Irc.^ Ifo. ?0-43.>7 14tb Judicial District Court C&lcaslen Parish,, Louisiana
107
00^446