Document Exo0jxNDrmaM1LV26B1LdEVen
Vol. 6, 1051-1056,
December 1997
Cancer Epidemiology,
Biornarkers
& Prevention
1051
Decrease in Bladder Cell Micronucleus
Prevalence after Intervention
Lower the Concentration
of Arsenic in Drinking Water'
to
Lee E. Moore, Allan H. Smith,2
Claudia Hopenhayn-Rich,
Mary Lou Biggs,
David A. Kalman, and Martyn T. Smith
School of Public Hea1th University of California at Berkeley, Berkeley, California
94720 [L a M., A. H. S., C. H-R., M. L B., M. T. S.]; and School of Public Health and
Community Medicine, University ofWashington,
Seattle Washington, 93195 [D. A. 1(1
Abstract
Epidemiological
studies performed in Taiwan, Argentina,
and Chile suggest that ingestion of arsenic (As) may cause
bladder cancer. Because of these findings, we previously
investigated
the relationship
between As ingestion and
genetic damage to the urothelium in two cross-sectional
biomarker studies, one in Nevada and one in Chile. In both
studies, we found that increased levels of micronucleated
cells (MNCs) in exfoliated bladder cells were assodated with
elevated concentrations
of As in drinldng water, suggesting
that As induces genetic damage to bladder cells. To further
investigate this relationship,
we conducted an intervention
study in a subset of highly exposed men (n = 34) from the
cross-sectional
study in Chile. Subjects whose usual source
of water contained about 600 gag/liter As were supplied with
water lower in As (45 gwJliter) for 8 weeks, allowing ample
opportunity
for renewal and exfoliation of bladder epithelial
celis. Mean urinary As levels decreased during the
intervention
from 742 to 225 pg/liter. Bladder MNC
prevalence also decreased from 2.63 MNCs/1000 cells
preintervention
to 1.79 MNCs/1000 cells postintervention
(P < 0.05). When the analysis was limited to individuals
previously having subcytotoxic
urinary As levels (<700 zg/
liter), the change between pre- and postintervention
MNC
was more pronounced: the level decreased from 3.54 to 1.47
MNCS/1000 cells, respectively (P = 0.002). Among smokers,
MNC prevalences
decreased from 4.45 MNCs/1000
cells
preintervention
to 1.44 MNCs/1000 cells postintervention
(P = 0.002). Among nonsmokers,
the decrease was much
smaller: 2.04 MNCS/1000 cells preintervention
to 1.90
MNCs/1000 cells postintervention
(P 0.25), suggesting that
smoker's bladder cells could be more susceptible to
genotoxic damage caused by As. The reduction in bladder
MNC prevalence with reduction in As intake provides
further evidence that As is genotoxic to bladder cells.
Received 4/28/97; revised 8/1 3/97; accepted 8/29/97.
The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of
page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked advertisement
in
accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
I This work was supported by National Institute of Environmental
Health Sciences,
NIH, Grants P30ES01896
and P42ES04705.
L E M. was a Trainee of the Health
Effects Component of the University of California Toxic Substances Program.
2 To whom requests for reprints should be addressed, at School of Public Health,
University ofCalifomia
at Berkeley, 140 Warren Hall 7360, Berkeley, CA 94720.
Phone: (510) 843-1736; Fax: (510) 843-5539.
Introduction
The exfoliated cell MN3 assay is a useful method for measuring
and quantifying recent DNA damage that results from environ-
mental exposure (1). The use of such a biomarker of genetic
damage as an outcome in an epidemiobogical
study not only
shortens the length of time between exposure and effect but is
also a unique opportunity
to measure the effects of exposure
reduction using each person as his or her own control. To date,
very few intervention studies using biomarkers have been con-
ducted. Moreover, to our knowledge, cytogenetic intervention
studies have never been used to evaluate the relationship be-
tween an environmental
exposure and a genotoxic effect in
humans. Examples of exposures that have been examined using
the MN assay and the intervention
study design include che-
mopreventative
agents such as antioxidants
(i.e. , vitamin A and
f3-carotene) retinyb palmitate (2, 3), a-tocopherol
(4), antischis-
tosomal drugs (5, 6), and genotoxic agents, such as radiation (7,
8) and formaldehyde
(9, 10).
MNs are extranuclear bodies in the cytoplasm of a cell that
form when acentric fragments or whole chromosomes
are left
behind the main nucleus at tebophase. They provide a quanti-
fiabbe yet nonspecific measurement
of recent DNA injury that
results from genotoxic exposure. An increase in the prevalence
of MN in a population of cells indicates that chromosome
damage has occurred as a result of an exposure that caused
either a clastogenic or an aneupboidogenic
effect.
Environmental
exposure to In-As, a known human carcin-
ogen, primarily occurs from contaminated
drinking water
sources (1 1). In-As is a known cause of lung cancer, via
inhalation, and skin cancer, via ingestion. Its ingestion is also
thought to cause more fatal internal cancers, including those of
the bladder, kidney, and lung (12-16).
Exfoliated urothelial cells are epithelial cells that are
sboughed from the surface of the genitourinary
tract, with a
turnover time of about 3 weeks. Because exfoliated epithebiab
cells are derived from basal cells, recent genetic damage to the
basal layer of the bladder is thought to be reflected by the
presence of MNs in these cells. Arsenic (As) has been shown to
have both clastogenic and aneupboidogenic
properties in vitro
(17-20) and in vivo (8, 21).
Previously,
we investigated
the relationship
between
chronic ingestion of In-As and the prevalence
of exfoliated
MNCs of the bladder in two cross-sectional
biomarker studies.
The first, performed in a small county in Nevada, detected an
exposure-dependent
increase in bladder MNC frequencies with
urinary As levels, suggesting that chronic ingestion of In-As
may have a genotoxic effect on the bladder epithelium (22). A
larger cross-sectional
biomarker study conducted in Chile also
3 The abbreviations used are: MN, micronucleus;
In-As, inorganic As; MNC,
nucleated cell; MMA. methylarsonate;
DMA, dimethylarsinate;
Tot-As,
MMA, and DMA; FISH, fluorescence
in situ hybridization;
PR, prevalence
microIn-As, ratio.
1052 As Intervention
and Bladder Cell MNs
revealed a higher prevalence of bladder MNCs in a high- versus
low-exposure
group. When the study population was divided
into quintiles by urinary As levels, an exposure-dependent
increase was seen at urinary As levels between 54 and 729
pg/liter, and the MNC prevalence doubled at levels as low as
54-137 ,g/liter. At higher urinary As levels (between 729 and
1894 ,.gIliter), the prevalence of bladder MNCs returned to
baseline levels, possibly due to cytostasis or cytotoxicity.
To confirm whether As ingestion was responsible for the
increased prevalence of MN that we found in our previous cross-
sectional studies, we conducted a prospective short-term interven-
tion study involving 39 men from our Chilean study, who regularly
drank water with 600 pg/liter In-As. We supplied them with water
that was lower in As (about 45 gfliter) for 8 weeks, allowing
ample opportunity for renewal and exfoliation ofbladder epithelial
cells. To determine whether a change in As exposure results in a
change in the prevalence of exfoliated bladder MNCs, we used a
fluorescent version of the MN assay (23, 24) to compare MNC
levels before and after intervention.
Patients and Methods
Study Subjects. Participants in the intervention study were a
subset of a high-exposure
group from a large cross-sectional
bi-
omarker study that was performed previously in the area (21).
Briefly, the cross-sectional
biomarker study compared residents of
San Pedro in northern Chile (population, 1600) to those of the
neighboring town of Toconao (population, 360), which had water
with low bevels of As (about 15 p.g/liter), with respect to MNC
prevalences in exfoliated bladder cells, urinary As levels, and
questionnaire
data. Prospective
participants
were contacted
through public announcements,
meetings, and door-to-door con-
tact. Local recmiters interviewed them to ascertain age, duration of
residence, smoking status, and interest in participation. Recruit-
ment was limited to those who were at least 18 years of age and
had lived in the town for at least 3 months. All study subjects were
interviewed by trained interviewers, regarding demographic char-
acteristics, smoking and drinking habits, and medical, occupa-
tional, and residential histories. Urine and exfoliated bladder cells
were collected. We included only male participants in the study
because cells found in male urine are almost exclusively transi-
tional bladder cells (25, 26). Although females exfoliate a similar
number of transitional cells as males, they also exfoliate squamous
cells from the bladder trigone, vulva, and lower genital tract
(25-27). Because transitional cells derive from the target tissue of
As-induced cancers, without the ability to differentiate squamous
cells from transitional cells, any association between chronic in-
gestion of In-As and bladder MNCs in women would be diluted,
biasing the results toward no effect.
Intervention.
The intervention included 34 men, who were all
participants
in a previous cross-sectional
study that had been
conducted in the area (21). Immediately
after the cross-see-
tional study was conducted, those who agreed to participate in
the intervention phase of the study were provided with bow-As
water (45 pg/liter) for a 2-month period. The water, originating
from the town of Calama, located 100 km from San Pedro, was
delivered biweekly, directly to participants'
homes, in 60-liter
tanks. Each family was instructed to use only the low-As water
for all drinking and food preparation
purposes. During the
2-month period, local study personnel contacted families to
ensure that they were not running low on supplied water.
Data Collection.
Following a 2-month intervention
period,
urine samples were collected from all participants for exposure
assessment and to obtain exfoliated bladder cells for the MN
assay. Participants were also administered
a questionnaire
by
oral interview. Data that were collected postintervention
compared to corresponding
data that were collected
vention during the previously described cross-sectional
were preinter-
study.
Exposure Assessment
and As Speciation.
To collect exfoli-
ated bladder cells, participants
were supplied with preceded
polypropylene
bottles and instructions for urine collection, both
pre- and postintervention.
In addition to dichotomous
exposure
status, which was determined by pre- or postintervention
status,
the combination ofln-As and the metabolites MMA and DMA,
referred to as Tot-As, was used to assess exposure. This meas-
ure is considered
to be the best biomarker
of recent In-As
exposure. Urinary concentrations
were also adjusted for creat-
mine; however, in the MN analyses, only unadjusted values
were used because they more closely reflect the As concentra-
tions to which the urotheliab cells were actually exposed (28).
The first morning urine void was collected from each subject
and was analyzed for In-As, MMA, and DMA. Urine samples
were analyzed for As content by hydride generation atomic
absorption spectroscopy,
based on Andreae's method (29, 30).
In-As, MMA, and DMA were converted to their respective
arsines by treatment with sodium borohydride
under acidic
conditions and were collected by sparging and cryogenic trap-
ping. Following the collection of vapors, the trap was allowed
to warm, and the arsine species were sequentially
volatilized
and detected by atomic absorption spectroscopy
using a micro-
burner combustion cell. Detection limits for In-As, MMA, and
DMA were 0.5, 1.0, and 2.0 .tgfliter, respectively.
MN Assay. To obtain bladder cell samples, each subject was
asked to provide a total of four urine samples, two nonmorning
samples on 2 consecutive days. Only the second and third urine
voids of the day were used for cell isolation. The first morning
urine void was not used for exfoliated cell collection because
exfoliated bladder cells tend to degrade from overnight expo-
sure to urine. Instead, this sample was used for exposure as-
sessment purposes, as described above. Bladder cells were
isolated and stored as described previously.
Cells were permeabilized,
the MN assay was performed, and
slides were scored as described elsewhere (23, 24). A fluorescent
version of the MN assay, which uses FISH with a biotin-babeled
a-satellite probe for all human centromeres (Oncor), was used. In
certain urine voids from some participants, cell pellets were heav-
ily contaminated
with crystals or a sand-like sedimentation
that
obscured cells on the slide. In such situations, we used 0.9% NaCl
washes and a Percoll gradient to separate the bladder cells from
crystals without jeopardizing cell recovery.
Slides were coded and scored blindly in sets, each con-
taming the same participant's
slides, both pre- and postinter-
vention. Only cells that were not smeared, clumped, or over-
lapped and that contained intact nuclei were included in the
analysis, thus excluding cells that were undergoing abnormal
cell division and degenerative
processes, such as karyorrhexis,
karyolysis, nuclear fragmentation,
and pyknosis. The preva-
bence of MNCs was calculated, based only on the number of
normal, intact exfoliated cells, using established scoring crite-
ria. All questionable MNs were cross-checked
by two observers
and discussed until a consensus was reached. We also assessed
the percentage
of abnormal cells per person by scoring the
number of cells with the degenerative
processes of karyolysis
and karyhorrhexis
in two sets of 100 cells each. If the two
values differed by > 15%, a third set of 100 cells was scored
and incorporated
into the analysis.
Compliance.
To ensure compliance with the intervention proto-
col, attempts were made to collect urine samples from participants
at two intervals during the intervention period. The first compli-
Cancer Epidemiologj,
Biornarkers
& Prevention
1053
ance sample was collected about 2-3 weeks after the change in water supply, and the second was collected after an additional 2-3 weeks. Twenty-five subjects participated on the first collection visit, and 24 subjects participated on the second.
Statistical
Analyses.
To obtain group values, the MNC preva-
lence for each individual was first calculated, and then all preva-
lences were averaged for the group. The MNC PR of the group
was calculated by dividing the MNC prevalence postintervention
by that preintervention.
To quantify the magnitude of change, we
also calculated the average change in MNC prevalence by sub-
tracting the preintervention
prevalence from the postintervention
prevalence and then averaging this difference for the group. Be-
cause the changes in bladder cell MNs were not normally distrib-
uted, statistical significance ofMNC prevalence between interven-
tion groups was assessed by the Wilcoxon sign-rank test. It was
hypothesized a priori that a decrease in As exposure would be
associated with a decrease in the prevalence of MNC, so one-tailed
tests were used. Urinary As levels, the number of cells scored, and
the percentage of abnormal cells scored/person
were compared
using Student t tests. All analyses were performed first for the
group as a whole and then stratified by age, years of residence,
ethnicity, and smoking.
We also divided the preintervention
group by urinary
Tot-As levels because our previous cross-sectional
study re-
vealed an unusual dose-response
relationship
when the group
was divided into quintiles (Qb-Q5) by urinary As levels (Ql,
<53.8 pg/liter; Q2, 53.9-137.3
.tg/liter; Q3, 137.4-414.6
pg/biter; Q4, 414.7-728.9
j.g/liter; and Q5, >728.9 pg/liter).
An exposure-dependent
increase was seen between Tot-As and
MNC prevalence when Qi (1.61 MNCs/l000
cells) was com-
pared to Q2, Q3, and Q4 (3.39, 3.69, and 4.77 MNCs/l000
cells, respectively).
In Q5, MNC prevalences returned to base-
line levels (1.52 MNCS/1000 cells), probably due to the cyto-
static or cytotoxic effects of As at such high levels. Because
dividing cells are needed to produce MN after a genotoxic
insult, both cytostasis and cytotoxicity
could inhibit their ex-
pression. To preclude the possibility that individuals exposed to
very high doses of As (urinary Tot-As > 700 g#{241}iter) might
mask a reduction in MNs that could only be seen in those within
the genotoxic or subcytotoxic
range (Q2-Q4), we divided the
group into two groups, those with Tot-As over 700 gIliter
preintervention
(cytotoxic range) and those with Tot-As levels
below 700 pg/liter preintervention
(genotoxic range), and we
analyzed each group separately.
Results
Thirty-nine
men participated
in the intervention
study. Five
subjects did not exfoliate urothebial cells, either before or after
intervention,
leaving 34 males to be included in the analyses.
General characteristics
of the study population are presented in
Table 1 . The average age, length of residence, years of educa-
tion, and ethnicity distributions
were similar to those of the
high-exposure
group of our previous cross-sectional
study (21).
Twenty-four
% were current smokers, most of whom smoked
five or fewer cigarettes per day (88%).
For the group as a whole, preintervention
As concentra-
tions in participants'
drinking water were approximately
600
pg/liter, whereas the As concentration
in the water delivered to
participants'
homes during the intervention
period averaged
about 45 gIliter. The corresponding
average urinary Tot-As
concentration
decreased from 742 (preintervention)
to 225
(postintervention)
pgIliter, with a mean decrease of 510 pg/
liter. For the subset of subjects from which compliance samples
were collected, the average Tot-As was 779 gIliter before
Table I Descriptive
characteristics
of intervention
(n 34 men)
Characteristic
Mean (range)
Age (yr) Years of residence Years of education Ethnicity
Atacameflo European Aymara Other Nonsmokers Smokers (cigarettes/day) <1 1-2 2-5 >5
42 (20-74) 19 (0.4-61)
7 (0-16)
study participants
Frequency (%)
27 (79%) 2(6%) 2(6%) 3 (9%)
26 (76%) 8 (24%) 3(38%) 1(12%) 3 (38%) 1 (12%)
intervention,
252 and 196 gIbiter during intervention,
and 213
pg/biter at the conclusion of the intervention
phase. Details
concerning
the changes in methylation
patterns during inter-
vention are given in a separate paper (31).
For the MN assay, a total of 36,890 and 37,910 cells were
scored in the pre- and postintervention
samples, respectively.
The prevalence
of MNCs/1000
cells decreased from 2.63
MNCS/1000
cells preintervention
to 1.79 MNCS/1000
cells
postintervention
(PR = 0.7, P < 0.05; Fig. lA). There was an
average decrease of 0.84 MNCs/1000
cells, with 18 of the 34
participants
(53%) experiencing
a decrease (average de-
crease = 3.16 MNCS/1000
cells), 1 1 (32%) showing an in-
crease (average increase
2.57 MNCs/l000
cells), and 5
showing the same prevalence of MNCs. The five individuals
whose MNC prevalences stayed the same had no MNCs, either
pre- or postintervention.
The results of the analyses for the group of individuals
with urinary Tot-As concentrations
within a subcytotoxic
range
before intervention
(<700 gIbiter) are shown in Fig. lB. The
average concentration
of Tot-As before and after intervention
decreased from 421 to 189 pgIliter, with an average decrease in
Tot-As of 232 pgIbiter. The prevalence of MNCs/l000
cells
decreased from 3.54 to 1.47 MNCs/l000
cells (PR = 0.4, P =
0.002), with an average decrease in MNCs of 2.07 MNCs/l000
cells. Thirteen of the 18 individuals (72%) had bladder MNC
prevalences
fall an average of 3. 1 MNCs/l000
cells, three
(17%) had prevalences increase an average of 1.03 MNCs/l000
cells, and two (1 1%) showed the same prevalences.
The results of the same analyses for individuals who began
the intervention within a cytotoxic range of As exposure (>700
gIliter) are presented in Fig. lC. The average concentration
of
Tot-As, before and after intervention,
decreased from 1 103 to
265 pgIliter, with an average decrease of 838 pgfliter. The
prevalence of MNCs/1000
cells increased from 1.60 to 2.14
MNCs/l000
cells (PR = 1.3, P = 0.25), with a mean increase
of 0.54 MNCs/l000
cells. In 5 of 16 (31%) participants, MNC
prevalences
decreased an average of 3.3 MNCs/1000
cells,
eight (51%) increased an average of 3.2 MNCs/l000
cells, and
three (19%) did not change.
Stratified comparisons
of the MNC prevalences by several
variables, pre- and postintervention,
are presented in Table 2.
Among smokers and nonsmokers,
the average changes in
Tot-As were similar: -452 and -527 pgIliter, respectively.
However, in smokers, the bladder MNC prevabences fell from
4.54 MNCs/l000
cells preintervention
to 1.44 MNCs/l000
cells postintervention
(PR = 0.3, P = 0.002) but did not change
significantly
in nonsmokers.
Six of the eight smokers (75%)
1054 As Intervention
and Bladder CeH MNs
ABC
14
-I 12
LU
C) 10
0
0 0
8
C) 6 z
4
2
-1-2.63
:. a
!
PRE Intervention
-t1.79
T
POST Status (N = 34)
14
-I 12 LU
C) 10
0 0 08
C) 6
z 4
2
-3.54
-
-5-1.47
PRE Infervenflon
POST Status (N = 18)
14
1 12 LU
C) 10
0
0 0
8
6
C)
z 4
2
--1.60
-2.14
I
PRE Intervention
POST Status (N = 16)
Fig. I. Prevalence of MNCS/I000
cells before and after intervention.
with urinary As > 700 g#{241}iter preintervention.
A, all individuals;
B, individuals
with urinary As < 700 pg/liter preintervention;
C, individuals
had MNC prevalences fall an average of4.47 MNCs/l000
cells,
and two (25%) had MNC prevalences
increase an average of
1.00 MNCs/l000
cells. No such decrease was seen among
nonsmokers.
The average change in MNCs/l000
cells was also
greater among smokers than nonsmokers:
-3.1 versus -0.14.
In the comparison
by ethnicity, the group was divided into
Atacame#{241}os and all others combined because 79% of the pop-
ulation were of Atacameflo
origin. The average change in
MNCs/1000 cells was greater in the non-Atacameflo
group than
it was in the Atacameflo
group, but, after stratification
by
ethnicity and smoking status, the apparent decrease was pri-
many due to smoking. After stratification
by age and length of
residence, the average change in MNCs/l000
cells appeared to
be greatest in the oldest group (>50) and in those who had lived
in the high-exposure
town for <5 years.
There was no evidence of an association
between the
percentage of abnormal cells, the number of cells scored per
person, and the change in MNC prevalence.
Discussion
The results of this intervention
study provide further cvi-
dence that As in drinking water is responsible
for the
increased bladder MNC prevalence
that was found in our
previous cross-sectional
studies. Bladder cells turn over
within 1-3 weeks, and MNCs do not accumulate
over time.
Therefore,
a prospective
intervention
study design can be
used to provide experimental
causal evidence for the asso-
ciations that are found in cross-sectional
studies. Because
each individual serves as his or her own control, problems
due to confounding
are largely eliminated.
Causal inference
in biomarker
studies is thus greatly strengthened
by con-
ducting intervention
trials.
The results of this study demonstrate
that MNC preva-
lences decreased when the As concentration
in drinking water
was lowered. Urinary As bevels dropped from 742 to 225
pg/liter As, indicating that urinary levels were still higher than
those that would be expected from sole consumption
of water
with 40-50 ,gIliter As. In unexposed populations, background
levels of urinary As generally range from 4.4 to 57.2 pgIbiter
(32). Some reasons for the elevated levels include: participants
drank fluids or ate food prepared outside their homes; they
consumed food grown in the area and with the usual farming
water source (San Pedro River, containing 170 .tgIliter As; and
compliance was incomplete, although most study subjects re-
ported using only the provided water at home at the time of the
last interview (3 1). The higher bevel could also partly be attrib-
uted to As stores in internal tissues from previous exposure. For
the group as a whole, the bladder MNC prevalence fell from
2.63 to 1.79 MNCs/l000
cells. A larger reduction was seen
when individuals who may have been experiencing
cytotoxic
effects of As were removed from the analysis, from 3.43 to 1.47
MNCs/1000
cells. An increase was seen when MNC preva-
lences from individuals within the cytotoxic range ofurmnary As
preintervention
were compared, adding further weight to the
hypothesis that individuals who are exposed to high bevels of
As may not be able to express As-induced damage in the form
of MNs. We attempted to use the percentage of abnormal cells
as a measure of cytotoxicity to the bladder epithebium but did
not find that an increase in this measurement
correlated with a
decrease in the MNC prevalence.
To date, a relationship
be-
tween an exposure and abnormal cell prevalence
has been
demonstrated
in buccal cells but not in bladder cells (8, 21, 33),
suggesting that this method is not a sensitive indicator of cell
death in a bladder cell sample. We also used hematuria as an
indicator of cytotoxicity
and cellular damage to the bladder
mucosa, but no relationship was seen with As exposure. Here,
hematuria was only seen in 1 of 34 males preintervention
and
0 of 34 males postintervention,
suggesting that As exposure
does not cause bleeding from inadequate epitheial lining.
It is noteworthy that postintervention
MNC prevalences
were lower than those that would be expected from our previ-
ous cross-sectional
study, in which MNC prevalences for quin-
tiles Ql-Q5 were 1.61, 3.39, 3.69, 4.77, and 1.52 MNCs/1000
cells, respectively
(Qi, <53.8 pgfliter; Q2, 53.9-137.3
pg/
biter; Q3, 137.4-414.6
pg/liter; Q4, 414.7-728.9
p.glbiter; and
Q5, >728.9 gI1iter). According to our previous results, the
expected postintervention
MNC prevalence at a urinary Tot-As
concentration
of 225 gIliter (Q3) would be about 2-fold
higher, approximately
3.7 rather than the observed 1.79 MNCS/
1000 cells (Fig. 1A). Similarly, in Fig. 1, B and C, the expected
Cancer Epidemiology,
Biornarkers
& Prevention
1055
Fa C t or
None
Smoking No
Yes
Ethnicity Atacame#{241}o
Other
Age (yr) <30
30-50
>50
Years of residence <5
5-15
>15
Table 2 Prevalenc e of MN Cs/l000 cells, pre- an d postintervention,
wi th all ethnicities
Intervention status
Urinary Tot-As n
(gfliter)
Average change in Tot-As
MNCS/1000 cells
Pre 34 Post
742 225
-517 2.63 1.79
Pre 26 Post Pre 8 Post
765 237 668 217
-527 2.04 1.90
-452 4.54 1.44
Pre 27 Post Pre 7 Post
808 248 486 171
-560 2.14 1.85
-315 4.50 1.56
Pre 7 Post Pre 16 Post Pre 1 1 Post
582 279 939 266 557 154
-303 3.63 2.33
-672 1.77 1.96
-404 3.24 1.19
Pre 4 Post Pre 12 Post Pre 18 Post
661 143 863 206 679 270
-518 3.63 0.80
-657 2.70 1.80
-409 2.36 1.99
c ombined and by various factors
Average change in MNCS/1000 cells
PR
-0.84 0.68
-0.14 0.93 -3.10 0.32
-0.30 0.86 -2.94 0.22
- 1.30 0.19
-2.05
0.64 1.11 0.37
-2.83 0.22 -0.89 0.67 -0.36 0.84
#{176}
(one-tailed) <0.05
0.25 0.002
0.15 0.03
0.11 0.45 0.03
0.04 0.15 0.30
MNC prevalence postintervention
(Tot-As levels, 189 and 265
gfliter) should have been greater, about 3.7 MNCS/1000 cells
rather than the observed 1.47 and 2.14 MNCs/l000
cells, re-
spectiveby. It is possible that individuals previously exposed to
higher bevels of As may be more efficient at detoxifying As by
some unknown mechanism as part of an adaptive response to
exposure. The major route for In-As detoxification
involves
methylation
of As by methyltransferase,
followed by elimina-
tion via urinary excretion (31, 34, 35). Two methylation steps
take place producing MMA and DMA, both considered to be
less toxic than In-As. Pre- and postintervention,
In-As and its
methybated metabolites were measured in the urine in the fob-
lowing approximate
proportions:
In-As, 19.3%; MMA, 16.7%;
DMA, 64.0%; and In-As, 17.7%, MMA, PMA; 14.3%, and
68.3%, respectively.
If highly exposed individuals
had in-
creased methylation capacity, one would expect the proportion
of methylated As species to increase when exposure dropped.
However, after intervention,
the percentage of In-As did not
decrease significantly,
(from 19.3 to 17.7%; P = 0.54), sug-
gesting that increased methylation capacity was not responsible
for the lower MNC prevalences
measured. A decrease was
seen, however, in the MMA:DMA
ratio postintervention
(0.28
and 0.22, respectively;
P = 0.005, paired t test), which could
mean that participants were more efficient methylators at the
second methylation step as a consequence of their previous high
exposure.
With respect to the different subgroups, other factors were
also associated with a greater change in MNC prevalence after
intervention,
including smoking (Table 2). MNC prevabences
decreased substantially
among smokers, but there was little
change among nonsmokers.
It is possible that the increased
MNC prevalence found in smokers is due to chance because of
the small number of very light smokers (88% smoked <5
cigarettes per day). Alternatively,
it is also possible that bladder
cells of smokers may be more susceptible to genotoxic damage
caused by As, due to competition between As and the chemicals
that are found in cigarette smoke for substrates that are involved
in As detoxification,
such as glutathione
or the methyltrans-
ferases (15, 36, 37). Ifso, one would expect to see a relationship
between MNC prevalence and methybation capacity, which was
not observed in this study. It has also been proposed that As
inhibits DNA repair enzymes, which would be necessary to
repair genetic damage caused by tobacco carcinogens
(38).
Cells treated with As in vitro have shown enhanced sensitivity
to X-ray-mediated
death and retarded repair of X-ray-induced
single-strand
breaks of DNA (39). Li and Rossman (38) have
shown that arsenite inhibits DNA ligase II, which is required in
DNA excision repair. Arsenic is highly reactive with closely
spaced vicinal dithiol groups in proteins (40, 41). The number
of proteins containing vicinal dithiobs is relatively small, but
this feature is common among DNA-binding
proteins, tran-
scription factors, and DNA repair proteins.
In our previous cross-sectional
study, we were able to
determine that chromosome
breakage was the major cause of
MN formation in As-exposed
bladder cells. We used a flu-
orescent version of the exfoliated bladder cell MN assay,
using FISH with a centromeric
probe to identify the presence
(MN+) or absence (MN-) of whole chromosomes
within
MN, thereby determining
the mechanism
of As-induced
genotoxicity
in vivo. Here, preintervention
samples had ab-
most three times as many unscorable
MNs as postinterven-
tion, making it impossible
to compare the mechanism
of
genotoxic damage between groups. This disproportionality
of unscorable cells in the highly exposed groups was seen to
some extent in studies of both radiation and As-exposed
individuals
when interphase
cytogenetics
with centromeric
probes were used. In these studies, it was inferred that probe
penetration
to the nucleus may have been impeded by thick-
ening of the cell membrane,
as a protective
response to a
genotoxic or cytotoxic exposure. For this reason, we chose
not to present the centromeric
probe data.
In summary, we have shown genetic damage in the form of
1056 As Intervention
and Bladder Cell MNs
bladder cell MNs to decrease after changing from a high to a lower concentration of As in drinking water, from 2.63 and 1.79 MNCS/ 1000 cells, respectively. The greatest change was seen when only individuals at a subcytotoxic urinary As level (<700 .tg/liter) were included in the analysis, from 3.54 and 1.47 MNCs/1000 cells. The prevalence of MNCs from very highly exposed individuals (unnary Tot-As > 700 g/1iter) did not decrease, possibly due to the fact that their cells were experiencing cytotoxicity or cytostasis. Both factors would make cells less likely to express the genetic damage that they have incurred in the form of MNs. In addition, MNC prevalences decreased only in smokers, suggesting that their bladder cells could be more susceptible to genotoxic damage caused by As, supporting the suggestion of synergy between smoking and As exposure.
References
1. Stich, H. F., and Rosin, M. P. Micronuclei
in exfoliated human cells as an
internal dosimeter for exposures to carcinogens. In: Stich H. F. (ed). Carcinogens
and Mutagens in the Environment,
Vol. 2, Naturally Occurring Compounds:
Endogenous
Formation and Modulation.
pp. 17-25 Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press,
1983.
2. Stich, j3-carotene in Asian
H. F., Rosin, M. P., and Wallejera, M. 0. Reduction with vitamin
administration
of proportion of micronucleated
buccal mucosal
betel nut and tobacco chewers. Lancet, 1: 1204-1206,
1984.
A and cells
3. Stich, H. F., Rosin, M. P., Hornby, A. P., Mathew, B., Sankaranarayanan,
R.,
and Nair, M. K. Remission of oral leukoplakias
and micronuclei
in tobacco/betel
quid chewers treated with a-carotene and with a-carotene plus vitamin A. Int. J.
Cancer, 42: 195-199, 1988.
4. Benner, S. E., Wargovich,
M. J., Lippman. S. M., Fisher, R., Velasco, M.,
Winn, R. J., and Hong. W. K. Reduction in oral mucosa micronuclei frequency
following a-tocopherol
treatment of oral leukoplakia.
Cancer Epidemiol.
Bi-
omark. Prey., 3: 73-76, 1994.
5. Rosin, Egyptians 539-543,
M., and Anwar, W. Chromosomal
damage in urothelial cells from
with chronic Schistomsoma
haematobium
infections. Int. J. Cancer, 50:
1992.
6. Rosin, Involvement development 283-292,
M. P., Saad el Din Zaki, S., Ward, A. J., and Anwar, W. A.
of inflammatory
reactions and elevated cell proliferation
in the
of bladder cancer in schistosorniasis
patients. Mutat. Res., 305:
1994.
7. Stich, H. F., San, R. H. C., and Rosin, M. P. Adaptation ofthe DNA-repair
micronucleus
tests to human cell suspensions
and exfoliated cells. Ann.
Acad. Sci., 407: 93-105, 1983.
and N. Y.
8. Moore, L. E., Warner, M. L., Smith, A. H., Kalman, D., and Smith, M. T. Use
of the fluorescent micronucleus
assay to detect the genotoxic effects of radiation
and arsenic exposure in exfoliated human epithelial cells. Environ. Mol. Muta-
gen., 27: 176-184, 1996.
9. Suruda, A., Schulte, P., Boeniger,
Steenland, K., Stewart, P., Herrick, R.,
genetic effects of formaldehyde
exposure
Epidemiol. Biomark. Prey., 2: 453-460,
M., Hayes, Douthit, D.,
in students 1993.
R. B., Livingston, and Fingerhut, M. of mortuary science.
G. K., A. Cyto-
Cancer
10. Titenko-Holland,
N., Levine, A. J., Smith, M. T., Quintana, J. E., Boeniger,
M., Hayes, R., Suruda, A., and Schulte, P. Quantification
of epithelial cell
micronuclei
by fluorescence
in situ hybridization
(FISH) in mortuary science
students exposed to formaldehyde.
Mutat. Res., 371: 237-248, 1996.
1 1 . IARC. IARC monographs
on the evaluation of the
chemicals to humans: some metals and metallic compounds.
39-141, 1980.
carcinogenic IARC Sci.
risk of PubI., 23:
12. Chen, C., and Wang, C. Ecological
water and age-adjusted
mortality from
5470-5475, 1990.
correlation malignant
between arsenic level in well neoplasms. Cancer Res., 50:
13. Chen, C. J., Kuo, T. L., and Wu, M. M. Arsenic 414-415, 1988.
and cancers.
Lancet i:
14. Wu, M. M., Kuo, T. L., Hwang, Y. H., and Chen, C. J. Dose-response
relation
between arsenic concentration
in well water and mortality from cancers and
vascular diseases. Am. J. Epidemiol..
130: 1 123-1 132, 1989.
15. Hopenhayn-Rich,
C., Biggs, M. L., Smith, A. H., Kalman, D. A., and Moore,
L. E. Methylation
study in a population environmentally
exposed to high arsenic
drinking water. Environ. Health Perspect. 104: 620-628,
1996.
16. Bates, M. N., Smith, A. H., and Hopenhayn-Rich,
C. Arsenic ingestion
internal cancers: a review. Am. J. Epidemiol.,
135: 462-476,
1992.
and
17. Eastmond, D. A., and Tucker, agents using cytokinesis-blocked antibody. Environ. Mol. Mutagen.,
J. D. Identification human lymphocytes 13: 34-43, 1989.
of aneuploidy-inducing and an antikinetochore
18. Eastmond, D. A., Rupa, D. S., Chen, H. W., and Hasegawa, L. Muliticolor
fluorescence
in situ hybridization
with centromeric
DNA probes as a new
approach to distinguish
chromosome
breakage from aneuploidy
in interphase
cells and rnicronuclei.
In: Vig, BK. (ed). Chromosome
Segregation
and
Aneuploidy,
NATO Advanced Science Institutes Series, pp. 377-390. Berlin:
Spinger-Verlag,
1993.
19. Wiencke, J. K., and Yager, J. W. Specificity of arsenite
cytogenetic
damage induced by the DNA crosslinking
agent
Environ. Mol. Mutagen., 19: 195-200, 1992.
in potentiating diepoxybutane.
20. Vega. L., Gonseban, M. E., and sodium arsenite on human lymphocytes detected. Mutat. Res. 334: 365-373,
Ostrosky-Wegman,
P. Aneugenic
in vitro: an individual susceptibility
1995.
effect of effect
21. Moore, L. E., Smith A. H., Hopenhayn-Rich,
C., Biggs, M.
D. A., and Smith, M. T. Micronuclei in exfoliated bladder cells among
chronically exposed to arsenic in drinking water. Cancer Epidemiol.
Prey., 6: 31-36, 1997.
L., Kalman, individuals Biomark.
22. Warner, M. L., Moore, L. E., Smith, M. T.,
Smith, A. H. Increased micronuclei in exfoliated
chronically
ingest arsenic-contaminated
water
Biomark. Prey., 3: 583-590, 1994.
Kalman, D. A., Fanning, E., and bladder cells of individuals who in Nevada. Cancer Epidemiol.
23. Moore, L. E., Titenko-Holland,
N., Quintana, P. J., and
biomarkers of genetic damage in humans: use of fluorescence
tion to detect aneuploidy and micronuclei in exfoliated cells.
Health, 40: 349-357, 1993.
Smith, M. T. Novel in situ hybridiza-
J. Toxicol. Environ.
24. Titenko-Holland,
N., Moore, L. E., and Smith, M. T. Measurement
characterization
of micronuclei in exfoliated human cells by fluorescence
hybridization
with a centromeric
probe. Mutat. Res., 312: 39-50, 1994.
and in situ
25. Schulte, recognizing 1963.
J., King, abnormal
C., MacDonald, epithelial cells
D., and Jassie, M. A simple in urinary sediment. J. Urol.,
technique for 89: 615-625,
26. Tyler, D. Stratified squamous epithelium in the vesicle trigone and urethra: findings correlated with the menstrual cycle and age. Am. J. Anat., 111: 3 19-325, 1962.
27. Hofseth, L. J., Dunn, B. P., and urothelial cells of catheterized patients Res., 352: 65-72, 1996.
Rosin, M. P. Micronucleus
frequencies in
with chronic bladder inflammation.
Mutat.
28. Biggs, M. T., and a biomarker 1997.
M. L., Kalman, D. A., Moore, L. E., Hopenhayn-Rich,
C., Smith
Smith, A. H. Relationship
of urinary arsenic to intake estimates and
of effect, bladder cell micronuclei.
Mutat. Res., 386: 185-195,
29. Crecelius, E. A. Modification
of the arsenic speciation
generation. Anal. Chem. 50: 826-827,
1978.
technique
using hyride
30. Kalman, D. A. Quantitation
of arsenic species in urine for exposure
ment studies. J. Res. Nail. Bureau Stand., 93: 315-317, 1988.
assess-
31. Hopenhayn-Rich,
C., Biggs, M. L., Kalman, D. A., Moore, L. E., and Smith,
A. H. Arsenic methylation patterns before and after changing from high to lower
concentrations
of arsenic in drinking water. Environ. Health Perspect.,
104:
1200-1207.
1996.
32. Hopenhayn-Rich,
C., Smith, A. H., and Goeden, H. M. Human studies do not
support the rnethylation threshold hypothesis for the toxicity of inorganic arsenic.
Environ. Res.. 60: 161-177, 1993.
33. Tolbert, P. E., Shy, C. M., and Allen, J. W. Micronuclei and other nuclear
anomalies in buccal smears: methods development.
Mutat. Res., 271: 69-77, 1992.
34. U. S. Environmental
Protection Agency. Special
ganic Arsenic: Skin Cancer, Nutritional Essentiality.
3-87/013. 1988.
Report on Ingested InorU. S. EPA PubI. No. 625/
35. Vabter, M. Species differences
in the metabolism
Appl. Org. Chem., 8: 175-182, 1994.
of arsenic compounds.
36. Georis, B., Cardenas, A., Buchet, J. P., and Lauwerys, R. Inorganic
methylation
by rat tissue slices. Toxicology,
63: 73-84, 1990.
arsenic
37. Thompson, D. J. A chemical hypothesis Chem. Biol. Interact., 88: 89-1 14, 1993.
for arsenic methylation
in mammals.
38. Li, J. H., and Rossman T. G. Inhibition a possible mechanism of its comutagenesis.
of DNA ligase activity by arsenite: Mol. Toxicol., 2: 1-9, 1989.
39. Snyder, R. D., and Lachman, P. J. Thiol involvement
DNA repair by metals in mammalian
cells. Mol. Toxicol.,
in the inhibition of 2: 117-128, 1989.
40. Joshi, S., and Hughes, J. B. Inhibition of coupling factor B activity by
cadmium ion, arsenite-2,3-dimercaptopropanol,
and phenylarsine
oxide, and pref-
erential reactivation
by dithiols. J. Biol. Chem., 256: 1 1 1 12-111 16, 1981.
41. Knowles, F. C., and Benson, Biorned. Sci., 8: 178, 1983.
A. A. The biochemistry
of arsenic. Trends